Average of Averages before aggregation

HI,
I have an issue calculating the averages of a score in the query, we are on BI 7.
Here is the example
Emp ID............Q1 Score.....Q2 Score..... Average of Q1&Q2
12345............. 66.67 .........100...............83.34
24689............. 66.67..........75................ 70.83
98765............. 33.33........... - .............33.33 (As there is no value uner Q2score the average is done by 1 insted of 2)
Total.............166.67........ 175............. 187.5
Average....... 166.67/3 .... 175/2 ........... 187.5/3
55.56 .........87.5 ................ 62.49 (This value is derived from Average of Q1&Q2)
when i try to get the value 62.49 directly with out displaying Employe id's (by putting employee id under structure under Row)
This is how the query calculatin with employee under structure
Emp ID............Q1 Score.....Q2 Score..... Average of Q1&Q2
EMPID .............55.56 .........87.5 ............ (55.56 +87.5)/2 = 71.53
i am getting different value which is the average of (55.56 +87.5)/2 = 71.53 which is not the correct value
I have used exception aggretion and still not able to find correctanswer.
Can any one please let me know if there is any workaroud
Thanks,
Kumar.

Hi Kumar:
Please refer to the documentation below.
Section on "Formula Collision", Slides 37 and 38 of the document "BW OLAP Aggregation".
http://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/scn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/d61b1e95-0501-0010-dfbe-a03970712ef1?QuickLink=index&overridelayout=true
Pages 7 and 8 of the document "Selection/Formula Properties: Enhancements"
http://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/scn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/c08b9190-0201-0010-5d8e-f9cee963f0da?QuickLink=index&overridelayout=true
Regards,
Francisco Milán.

Similar Messages

Warning "Time of Calculation 'Before Aggregation' is obsolete" in BI 7.0

Hi Friends,
We have recently upgraded our BW system from BW 3.1 to BI 7.0. While executing one of the query in BI 7.0 i am getting the Warning Message "Time of Calculation 'Before Aggregation' is obsolete". I can run the query by ignoring the message and get the results. But I am not getting the correct result for some of the calculated key figures which has setting for Time of calculation as "Before Aggregation".
After doing some research i found that before aggregation is not allowed in BI 7.0. We are using queries created in 3.x environment. There is some work around which talks about creating new calculated key figure with after aggregation setting and all. But in my case it not feasible as there are so many queries based on those calculated key figures.
Does any one had the similar situation? Is there any other way to correct this problem?
I would appreciate your help in this regards.
Thanks,
Manmit

Hi
Try SAP notes 935903.
Symptom
Calculated Key Figures "Existance Indicator" with aggregation behaviour "Before Aggregation" will get now with NW 2004s warning popup "Time of calculation 'Before Aggregation' is obsolete" during execution.
this may be helpful.
Also Check the below thread
/message/2986338#2986338 [original link is broken]
Regards
Shilpa
Edited by: Shilpa Vinayak on Oct 10, 2008 4:23 AM

Calculated key figures from multicubes before aggregation

Hi,
I am calculating a total using a calculated key figure
that has one key figure from a multicube and two other key figures from another multicube.
Also I factor the total using a variable with a replacement path on the dummy attribute (Constant) to "force" the calculation at the material level.
Cost = Cost(CUBE1) / Quantity(CUBE1) * Quantity(Cube2) * ZVRMATER1
Problem:
If I split the calculation this works before aggregation at the material level. Also this works fine using calculations that use key figures that must be calculated before aggregation if they all are from the same cube at the time. The required formula above will not work (zero divide) since during selection the OLAP processor retrieves in phases and with value 0 from the key figure of CUBE2.
Any suggestion on how to solve this without new back-end development?
Thanks.

Hi,
I am calculating a total using a calculated key figure
that has one key figure from a multicube and two other key figures from another multicube.
Also I factor the total using a variable with a replacement path on the dummy attribute (Constant) to "force" the calculation at the material level.
Cost = Cost(CUBE1) / Quantity(CUBE1) * Quantity(Cube2) * ZVRMATER1
Problem:
If I split the calculation this works before aggregation at the material level. Also this works fine using calculations that use key figures that must be calculated before aggregation if they all are from the same cube at the time. The required formula above will not work (zero divide) since during selection the OLAP processor retrieves in phases and with value 0 from the key figure of CUBE2.
Any suggestion on how to solve this without new back-end development?
Thanks.

Calculated key figures before aggregation

Hi,
I'm having trouble creating a new calculated key figure. Here's the situation.
I have two key figures: stock, value A. Now I want to create a new calculated key figure (in 3.x) using both key figures. The calculation would look something like: "stock * (value A == 0)". Now I want this key figure to work before aggregation. When creating this calculated key figure however I am unable to set the aggregation setting to before aggregation. Now, with any other key figure besides stock, this is no problem. Something like "profit * value A == 0)" works fine and I can set the aggregation setting to before aggregation. I suspect the reason I can't use stock in a calculated key figure set the calculate before aggregation is because of the exception aggregation of the stock key figure. It's set to last value in exception aggregation.
Does anyone know how to solve this problem? Thanks in advance.
Alex

Hi Alex,
please read this:
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw2004s/helpdata/en/75/21054da1392649948e5b94e4fc4bce/frameset.htm
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw2004s/helpdata/en/80/1a62f8e07211d2acb80000e829fbfe/frameset.htm
The reason that somtimes the propertie is available or not depends on the key figure type - e.g. if it is complex or not. I think that here is a lot of info available in the forum.
Regards,
Adem

How to calculate key figure before aggregation for complex formular?

Hi, buddies
Here's the simplified senario:
I have a cube, in which the characteristics are 'Calendar Day' and 'Hour' (values are 01~24), and the key figures are stored by day and by hour.
What I need is very simple, a query to display calculated key figures only by Calendar Day. I don't need Hour information.
So I create a query: column charact is Calendar Day, rows are several calculated key figures.
Now the problem is that:
if I don't put 'Hour' as row in the query, I'll get WRONG result. But if I put 'Hour' as row in the query, I'll get CORRECT result, but all the 'Hour' details will display, which should be hided.
I know the reason is that:
the calculated key figure that I create should be calucated before aggregation, not after. But since the formular is pretty complex, I can't change the 'Time of Aggregation Calculation' in key figure's property. (It's greyed out.) So I have to put 'Hour' as row in the query to force calcuation 'before aggregation' in query and set the property 'Calculate Result As...' as 'Summary'.
My question is:
whether there's any other way to force calcuation 'before aggregation', so I don't have to put 'Hour' in the query.
If no, is there a simple way to hide the 'Hour' details and only display summary result ON THE QUERY LEVEL? (
I can hide detail lines by using web template, or maybe using VB in excel. But I can't use either of them. I want to hide the details on the QUERY LEVEL. So I can use the query directly in any other reporting tools, like Visual Composer.)
Any idea?
Wei

Hi, Sudeepta
Thanks for your reply.
I did try to set 'No display' for 'Hour'. The result is that the Characteristics 'Hour' doesn't appear on the query result, but the detailed line of key figures still display on the result. It looks like the followings: (I put summaries on the top/right)
Date 1/1 1/2 Overall result
KPI1 10 11 22 (sum line)
KPI2 20 21 41 (sum line)
KPI1 12 13 25 (detailed line)
KPI2 13 13 26 (detailed line)
KPI1 11 12 23 (detailed line)
KPI2 12 12 24 (detailed line)
I want to suppress all the detailed lines and leave sum lines on the result.

Bex Issue : before aggregation

Hi,
I have a problem in Bex that I thought to solve with the "before aggregration" option in Bex Analyzer but this doesn't seem to be possible.
My query looks initially like this for 1 shipment 1344601 that is linked to 2 deliveries
Shipment Delivery Del.Quantity Counter Del.Quantity/Count
1344601   81209721 41.160 KG     2      20.580 KG
1344601   81209722 14.840 KG     1      14.840 KG
Resultrow .............56.000 KG     3       35.420 KG
This 35.420 KG is the right total delivery quantity for shipment 1344601. Note that counter is calculated via a formula with before aggregation. Also the Del. Quantity is included in a formula with before calculation.
When I now remove the drilldown on the delivery my result is wrong :
Shipment      Del.Quantity Counter Del.Quantity/Count
1344601       56.000 KG    3       18.666.67 KG
Resultrw     56.000 KG    3       18.666.67 KG
The system is dividing 56.000 KG by 3 which leads to an incorrect result of 18.666.67 KG.
==> My problem is that I can't put the Del.Quantity/Count on calculation before aggregation, although Del.Quantity and Counter that are used in the calculation have both calculation before aggregation.
Via a little trick (include the calculation in a new calculated keyfigure where I multiply it by 1) I could put it on calculation before aggregation but then the query execution fails.
Does anyone know a solution for this behaviour as I think lots of you might have faced similar situations and I would like to avoid to solve this in data staging as this doesn't seem unsolvable in Bex to me...
Message was edited by: Wim

Hi,
As per the my knowledge, we can use the properties of Before Aggregation in Bex Analyser.
for ex. when u excute your query, by default the result of the calculated key figure is generated after aggregation. But we can change this property to before aggregation by going to context menu of the calculated key figure for the analyer.
But it is considered as a bad practice in SAP.
If you want to use this option in query designer it not available,
because when we use calculated key figure in formulas it calculate as after aggregation. If you want to change it, we can change at analyser level.
Hope u understood.
Regards,
Vamsi
Assign points if useful.

Calculation Before Aggregation obsolete in NW2004s

We are upgrading our sandbox from BW 3.5 to NW2004s and several of our queries use the obsolete Time of Calculation 'Before Aggregation' technique. I searched and found a thread Time of Calculation "Before Aggregation" obsolete in NW2004s in which Klaus Werner recommended the use of exception aggregation in place of the calculation before aggregation method.
We do not yet have our BI Java up and running and I do not yet have access to the Query Designer 7.0, just the Query Designer 3.5 under NW2004s. I have not been able to create the solution proposed by Klaus Werner and I think his solution is only possible using Query Designer 7.0. Is this right or am I missing something and should be able to modify my Query Designer 3.5 queries to utilize the exception aggregation solution as proposed by Werner.
An example of our CKF which currently uses the calculation before aggregation technique is
CKF1 is defined as ((KFa >0) AND (KFa < 1000) * KFb + 0)
and we want that resolved at the document level (before multiple documents are summed) to determine if KFa is in this range for a single document. For every document in which KFa is in the above range, we want to sum together KFb. When I input my formula into CKF1 I am not given a choice where I see any exception aggregation options using Query Designer 3.5 under NW2004s. Am I just missing something or do I need to wait until I have Query Designer 7.0 to change my method of calculation this?
Thanks for your help,
Jeri

Hi Jeri,
Could you tell me where you found the document of Klaus Werner?
Answer:
I found it in the other thread.
Thanks,
Eelco
Message was edited by:
Eelco de Vries

Warning Time calculation "Before Aggregation" is obsolete

Hi,
Recently in our project we have upgraded BW 3.0B to BI7.
After upgrade to BI7, when we run some of the reports we are getting a warning message as below -
Warning Time calculation "Before Aggregation" is obsolete.
Pls refer to the attachment.
Any of our satyam colleagues encounter this warning, if so what was the solution you applied.
Note : I found some notes in Forum like saying use ' Exception Aggregation' for the Before Aggregation.. etc etc., but my problem is in our project thre are many CKFs are there which are using 'Before Aggregation'.
Please let me know if you have any other alternatives.
Thanks !!!!!!!!!

Hi,
Try SAP notes 935903.
Symptom
Calculated Key Figures "Existance Indicator" with aggregation behaviour "Before Aggregation" will get now with NW 2004s warning popup "Time of calculation 'Before Aggregation' is obsolete" during execution.
this may be helpful.
thanks,
JituK

Before Aggregation in NW2004s(BI7)

Hi Bex Gurus,
We have upgraded our BI System to NW2004s and Bex version is still 3.5.
Now we are also planning to migrate Bex to new version(NW2004s ).
We have used "Before Aggregation" in some of the calculated KFs in the queries. "Before Aggregation" is obsolete in NW2004s. So, I want to know whether these calculated KFs will give the same result when we migrate our front end to NW2004s.
Please provide your experience.
Regards
MB

Peter,
Thank you for your reply.
Is there a automatic way to do what you mentioned in below sentance?.
" Using the new front end tools you can apply exception aggregation to all calculated key figures including those with formulas in them"
Our scenario is,
We have a many CKFs with "Before Aggregation" setting in BW 3.5 version.
Example : CKF1 with "Before Aggregation" setting. This works irrespective of the drill down ( i.e Palnt, country or region) in BW 3.5. But, when I migrate the query to NW2004s, CKF1 is not giving the expected result when we drill down on Palnt, country or region.
So, Do I need to create three new CKFs (on Plant, Country and Region) using exception aggregation and use corresponding CKF based on drill down to get correct result in NW2004s?.
Appreciate your help.
Regards,
Madhukar

Time of calculation before aggregation is obsolete

Hi Gurus,
I have this message when i try to ejecute my query, can anyone help me to resolve this problem, i have the SAP 7.0 EHP 1, and i just have the upgrade from SAP 3.5.
I have a lot of CKF's in my queries and all of those use BEFORE AGGREGATION option, when i put in the propietries of my CKF the option after aggregation and then i check my query i have a message "time of calculation before aggregation is obsolete", and then when i put the option before aggregation in my CKF i have the message "CALLATE = 0 is not allowed".
I hope that someone have the same issue and can help me with this.
note: i'm using the BEX 3.5 and the BW 7.01 because the client wants that.
tnks
regards
Odiseo
Edited by: Odiseo BW on Oct 18, 2010 7:46 PM

hmmm... how about checking the differences between 3.X & 7.X???
before aggregation is no longer possible in 7.X, hence the error messages

Before aggregation with boolean operators

Hi gurus,
does someone know if there is a way to force a bex formula, defined by a boolean operator, to be executed in "before aggregation" mode?
For example, let A and B two propositions, and KF1 and . We define the following formula key figure
(A) * KF1 + (B) * KF2
where (A) = 1 if A is true and (A) = 0 if A is false.
My question is: is there a way to force this formula to act before aggregation.
Thank you very much
Matteo

I cannot do that, because you can set "before aggregation" property only for KF that are built on basis KF. But I have to built my formula using boolean operators that are not basis KF.
That's why i cannote use "before aggregation" in the properties of my KF.
thank you
matteo

Before Aggregation in Bex

Hi,
My query is at a Calmonth level but I have to do the calculations at the Calday level.
OverTime = Actual Hours - Planned Hours
I have Cal Day in my MultiProvider. How can I use Before Aggregation in the query so that I can achieve the calculations at a day level.
Thanks
Deepthi.

Hi Deepthi,
Use Exception aggreation for the key figure calculating OverTime.
with reference characteristic as 0CALDAY.
If you are in BEx 3.x, you may creat a new calculated key figure , with the original key figure and in the properties of this calculated key figure, you can exception aggregate using enhanced properties...displayed with a button below...
In BEx 7.x.. you can create a new selection and in aggregation tab in the selection properties mentione the exception aggregation as Sum with reference characteristic as 0CALDAY.
Hope this helps,
Best regards,
Sunmit.

Warning before aggregation is osbsolete

Hi guru's
I'm migrating our BW system and in some queries we have the message Warning calculation before aggregation is obsolete.
We still use BW 3.x analyzer.
when i execute queries the message is only a warning and i can see result in my reports.
i need to check the data but do you know if the message is a warning because this functionnality does not existe in BI 7 analyzer tool and if i use Bex 3.x will the data be correct ?
Thanks
Cyril

Good day Cyril,
When you migrate a query which has CKF with 'Before Aggregation', you will be requested to change it to 'after aggregation'. After turning on the option for 'After Aggregation query behaves same as what it used to do in BEx 3.5 with option 'B4 Ag'gregation'. Results are same.
The use of BEFORE aggregation was removed as this can cause a drain on the system resources and therefore cause performance problems. For this reason it was made obsolete with the 7.x system. The OLAP processor handles data differently in the 7.x systems so removing the before aggregation option should not cause too many problems for customers migrating over.
With this in mind, however, there are differences to BEFORE and AFTER aggregation. It may not affect the calculations you are using in your queries but you must be aware that some calculations are carried out at different times and this can cause hiccups. Most note-worthy would be when formulae are used and when replacement path variables are needed. In some cases, the necessary calculations may not be carried out and the figures may not be available which would not have been an issue in the 3.x system using before aggregation.
Check out SAP Note 1151957 which is excellent for understanding how the OLAP processor carries out calculations. It also details the differences between BEFORE and AFTER aggregation and should be very helpful for you going forward - particularly if you use formulae or replacement path functions.
Be aware that there are differences and there may be queries where you get a red X instead of a value. In most cases, this means rewriting a formula so that the processor can now accomodate the aggregation you need to achieve.
Hope this helps, Cyril.
Regards,
Karen

Before aggregation in NW2004s

Hi All,
We moved to NW2004S but we are still using BEx3.5
I have created a simple calculated kf(say Amt) at ODS level (Amt = qty*price).
The Amt numbers are coming incorrectly.I have used Before aggregation and it throws me an error " Before aggregation is not allowed for Amt".
Can some one please explain how can i achieve this.?
Thanks in advance.
Regards,
Raj

refer:
Before Aggregation in NW2004s(BI7)
/message/3943188#3943188 [original link is broken]

Calculation before aggregation

Hello BW Guru's
What does this calculation before aggregation mean ?
In which situation we use the above setting ?
when we can use this option in Modelling and when we can use this option in reporting ?
I am zero with this.. please explain me with a real time example.
Full points will be assured for the best answer
many thanks in advance,
NIru.

Hi,
An aggregate is a materialized, aggregated view of the data in an InfoCube. In an aggregate, the dataset of an InfoCube is saved redundantly and persistently in a consolidated form into the database.
How to create Aggregate for the cube.(for the example shown below)
step1
go to rsa1 transaction code , right click on the cube --->maintain aggregates ---create by your self
Step2
in the dimension Drag Region give the name of the aggregate .
after dragging in the aggregation selection type you will find * . that means it is assigned for all characteristics value.
or
right click on the * and select fixed value as NY( this will give aggregation values only for NY)
but in the example i have take * it is for all characteristic value ( means for all values NY and CA)
Step3
Now place the curser on the sigma symbol and activate the aggregate.
Step4
Now load the data to the cube , befor loading the data to the cube it a good practice of switching of the aggregate and switch on after loading.
this option can be obtain at top menu aggregate---> switch on of for queries that means the aggregates are available for the reporting to view.
by doing this this will increase the load performance and also the execution of the query will be fast
Step6
now open the report and execute
The scenario below shows you how to count the results of a calculated key figure in the BEx Query Designer.
You have loaded the following data into your InfoCube:
Before Aggregation
Region/     Customer /Sales Volume USD
NY /     A     /400
NY/     B     /200
NY/     C     /50
CA/     A     /800
CA/     C     /300
After Aggregation
Region/                SalesVolumeUSD
NY/                        650
CA/                       1100
Overall result                 1750
hope this is clear
Santosh
Edited by: Santhosh Nagaraj on Oct 29, 2009 3:35 AM

Average of Averages before aggregation

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for