Differences between SOAP Adapter and WS Adapter
Hi Experts,
In order to consume a service in SAP ECC by SAP PI 7.1, I´m using a service based on RFC. I tryed sucessfully to do that using SOAP Adapter and WS Adapter.
What are the differences between using a receiver communication channel with SOAP adapter or WS adapter? Which is the better way ?
Tks in advance.
Hi,
Please go through the below URLs for a discussion of SOAP and WS adapters:
The difference between SOAP adapter and WS adapter in PI 7.1
WS adapter vs. SOAP adapter
Regards,
Rajeev Gupta
Edited by: RAJEEV GUPTA on Jan 9, 2009 3:41 PM
Similar Messages
-
What is the Difference between AQ adpater and JMS adapter??
What is the Difference between AQ adpater and JMS adapter in BPEL11g??
In what scenarios we go for AQ and for what scenarios we go for JMS adapter???Go for AQ when using Oracle Advanced Queueing (the database stuff).
Use JMS when using JMS (in memory of file queues)
hth,
Peter Paul -
Differences between SOAP-ENV and soapenv
Hi all,
I am trying to find out why some SOAP request (inbound web services) in siebel work and do not work when the namespace prefix is SOAP-ENV and soapenv,
For example XML Spy generates "</SOAP-ENV:Envelope>" where as soapUI generates "<soapenv:Envelope>" and some difference in the name spaces.
Intrestingly other scenarios like invoking inbound web services with WS-Security and with out security had worked fine when tested from XML Spy.
Why is siebel not accepting the xml from XML Spy for Siebel Authentication scenario?
Thank youHi, just to let you all know, and please correct me if I am wrong, I have found this on the internet:
http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/ws-axis-user/200308.mbox/%3C00fd01c35ba6$ed85e620$6f01a8c0@TPX21%3E
Although, the SOAP spec uses the namespace prefixes of SOAP-ENV and
SOAP-ENC, these prefixes aren't required. You can use any string you like as
a namespace prefix, just as long as it maps to the appropriate namespace
name. The reason why the spec bothers with telling us the notational
conventions is that prefix names (e.g., SOAP-ENV) aren't normative, and the
spec just happens to be using this set of naming conventions. So the prefix
name doesn't matter. Only the actual referenced namespace name (e.g.,
http://schema.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/) matters.
I confirmed this information from an expert from Fusion Middleware and he says that the name-prefix could be anything as long as it is mapped in the namespace (URL from the SOAP XML). -
The difference between SOAP adapter and WS adapter in PI 7.1
Hello all,
can anybody explain what is the main difference between SOAP adapter and WS adapter in PI 7.1?
I have checked this [link|http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nwpi71/helpdata/en/0d/5ab43b274a960de10000000a114084/frameset.htm]
but was not able to find the real difference.
Or better, what can I do with WS adapter I can't do with SOAP adapter? What are their advantages/disadvantages?
Thank you all, Igor.In addition to RM, ws adapter also support other ws standard like SAML which is not available in SOAP adatper. Beside:
if your sender or receiver is SAP system, you can also monitor the message in the sender/receiver in addition to the PI box. This is a very good thing, because sometime the MONI in PI shows nothing wrong, but the MONI in your receiver will show you error message that's only related to the receiver system.
However, if you define ws sender CC, and your ws client doesn't support RM, you will have issue sending ws request.
And ws CC will generate ws runtime in PI box, if your configuration is wrong (like user name and password not correct), even if you correct it, the ws runtime sometime won't be regenated based on the correction. In this case you need to delete the ws CC/agreement, and re-create it with all correct information.
Beside make sure your basis team configured the PI system properly regarding ws. If not, you will have lot of pain to figure the problem which was my case.
Jayson -
Difference between webservices model and adaptive webservices model
hi
Can any one explain me regarding Difference between webservices model and adaptive webservices model.
ThanksHi,
In old WS Model, ithere was no concept of logical destinations.
There if you are using a WSDL located on a server and if the location of the WSDL
changes, your application won't run. The deployed application using the WS Model will have trouble finding
the WSDL. As a result you'll have to again import the
model. Moreover old WS Model does not have re-import functionality.
But incase of AWS Model, you can desine logical destinations and even if the location of the WSDL changes, all you have to do is change the new url in the Visual Admin and not import the model again.
You can visit the following link for more details:
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/b04308ed-62d5-2910-b3a6-c26771b1c78e
Regards,
Nidhi -
Difference between OA Adapter and DB Adapter
Hi All,
i am very new to SOA, Let me know the difference between OA Adapter and DB Adapter.
thanks
HariThe EBS (OA) Adapter is mainly a sort of wrapper around DB and AQ adapter supporting the different interfaces of EBS including Business Events(AQ).
The adapter introspects the Integration Repository. And it sets the responsiblity/application context for you when connecting. The ebs-user and responsibility are set in the wsdl. Using the database adapter you should take care of that yourself.
Honestly, if you're basically using custom-plsql api's or the pl/sql api's of ebs (eg. TCA) then you're perfectly fine with the DB-adapter. The only thing is that you should set the responsiblity in the pl/sql yourself (for example in the intialization block of the pl/sql package).
Regards,
Martien -
Difference between AQ Adapter and JMS Adapter
Hi All,
i am very new to SOA. let me know the difference between AQ Adapter and JMS Adapter.
thanks
HariPlease go thru the bellow link
http://www.mscd.edu/~ittsdba/oradoc817/ois.817/a83729/adois07.htm#408020
Krishna -
Difference between XI adapter and HTTP adapter
Hi,
I am not very clear on the exact difference between XI adapter and HTTP adapter.
I want to know, when should we use XI adapter and when to use HTTP adapter.
Regards,
SantoshHi,
We use HTTP Adapter in case of the Application is trying to post the HTTP Request message to XI and able to receive the HTTP Message from XI also.
While using the HTTP as Sender , HTTP Sits on ABAP Stack and can able to communicate with the Integration Server Directly, No need of any Adapter here, it is adapterless communication
In Case of Client Proxies
Source application can directly interact with the XI by executing the report in SAP R/3 & will be able to send the XML data to IS,
So no need of the XI Adapter in this case to post xml to XI.
In Case of Server Proxies
Now XI has to post the xml data to the Target Application, here some thing shld be there to establish the medium with the Target System. So we use XI adapter here.
In the receiver case, we need XI Adaper to communicate XI integration Server with the Local Integration Engine( Which we made in SAP R/3's Business system as local IE) to post the data
Basically XI adapter will be used in normal scenarios also to communicate Adapter Engine with Integration Server internally while delivering the msg.
Check this Msg Flow how the XI Adapter is used in Normal Scenarios
Understanding message flow in XI
REgards
Seshagiri -
Difference between File adapter and FTP adapter
hi,
I would like to know what is the difference between File adapter and FTP adapter
thanks
YatanBoth file and ftp adapters are non-concurrent jca adaps, however we go for file adapters mostly when you have files on your local environment and do not need to wait for someone to FTP the files on a timely basis. In case of FTP Adapter, we would need an FTP Server, a remote location with access where in files pitch in for polling.
Also, File adapter is dependent on the local folder and OS, however FTP adapter is dependent on the local as well as the remote file system/OS/folder permissions/user access. -
Difference between WCF-NetTCP and TCP/IP adapter
What is the difference between WCF-NetTCP and TCP/IP adapter ?
Are both work in the same way or there is any similarity in their working ?
PrakashHi Ashwin,
Yes,I am referring to Codeplex based community adapterhttp://tcpipbz2010.codeplex.com/ for TCP/IP
adapter.
As from your reply ,both adapters can perform the same task .Right ?
Actually I am using socket programming to connect TCP/IP adapter.
Can I do this with WCF-NetTCP adapter ?
Prakash -
How can find the difference between iphone 5 Real Genuine adapter and fake adapter
Can anyone please tell me, How Can Find Difference between iphone 5 Real Genuine adapter and fake adapter....
That's about the only way. Many of the fakes are indistinguishable from genuine without taking them apart. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wi-b9k-0KfE Note that BOTH of the adapters in this video are fake. Yet the one on the left looks identical to the "real thing".
-
Difference Between SOAP And HTTP Adapters
Hi,
Any body give me some information Abt Differences between SOAP And HTTP Adapters i know both are in use of Webservises. Any one come with more specific differences like in what case we go for SOAP And in what case we go for HTTP. thanks in advance.
Thanks
kiran.BHi,
In addition to the above
The SOAP Adapter enables u to exchange SOAP messages between the remote clients or web servers and the integration server
The HTTP Adapter is used to receive the arbitrary XML in the body of an HTTP-Post request.The HTTP adapter uses HTTP version 1.0 and does not support returning fault messages to the sender.
The HTTP adapter is used by the external systems to connect to the integration engine using the native HTTP interface.The plain HTTP adapter is a part of integration engine.
Regards,
Gunasree. -
Diff between Seeburger Adapter and File Adapter
Hi All,
My company needs to interact with some banks and the banks are particular that they want SFTP, which is not supported by File Adapter, so we have decided to go with Seeburger adapter.
Now what are the differences between File adapter and seeburger adapter?
I believe that Seeburger adapter does not support File Content Conversion, Archiving etc.
Could you all pls put some light on the diff between file adapter and seeburger adapter when it comes to dealing with files?
XierHi
You are aware with working of File Adapter.
The most direct way of using the Seeburger adaptors is to configure the BIC as a module. There is a software component from seeburger called bicmapper which will allow you to
1. Define or import the inbound message metadefinition in various formats ( edifact, xml,...)
2. Using a mapping create an xml variant as the output metadefinition or edifact in the other direction.
3. Create a one to one mapping between input en output.
4. Export the metadata in xsd or sda format for import in XI
5. Generate an SDA which can be deployed in XI and used as a module.
Have a look here,
http://www.seeburger.com/fileadmin/com/pdf/SAP_Exchange_Infrastructure_Integratio_Strategy.pdf
Some Seeburger related information
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/servlet/prt/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/e2aeb02c-0601-0010-d680-c9be61ffa390
Go through this threads:
http://www.seeburger.com/fileadmin/com/pdf/SAP_Exchange_Infrastructure_Integratio_Strategy.pdf
Need Material on Seeburger Adapters.
Seeburger Adapter
Installing seeburger adapter
http://www.seeburger.com/xi-adapters/
Thanks -
Difference​s btw stb and digital adapter
can someone clarify what are the main differences between a stb and a digital adapter besides size and price.
i know you cant receive any hd signal right? DCT-700 Standard Definition Digital Adapter
(Dimensions: Width: 5.50” (13.97 cm), Depth: 6.60” (16.76 cm), Height: 1.75” (4.45 cm), Weight: ~0.85 lbs (~0.39 kg))
Features:
Can decode and play all Standard Definition (SD) channels
Has Coax Out (Screw in) and Composite Out (Yellow, White, Red) to TV
Is much smaller than our other Set Top Boxes (STBs)
Restrictions:
No High Definition (HD) content support
No data features whatsoever (No Program Guide, VOD, Widgets, Games or IPTV)
Cannot participate as a video client in a Multi-Room Digital Video Recorder setup (MR-DVR)
Cannot view photos or stream music or videos from Home Media on the customer’s PC
There are no buttons or displays, just a Power light – it requires the Verizon remote to operate
QIP-2500 Standard Definition Digital Set Top Box
(Dimensions: Width: 14.72” (37.4 cm), Depth: 10.00” (25.4 cm), Height: 2.75” (6.9 cm), Weight: ~5.5 lbs (~2.50 kg))
Features:
Can decode and play all SD channels
Has Coax Out, Composite Out, and S-Video Out (Round plug with 4 pins in it)
Has full data features – IMG, PPV, VOD, Games, Widgets and IPTV all work fine
Can participate as a video client in a MR-DVR setup (SD recordings only)
Supports Digital Optical Audio and Digital SPDIF (also known as Coax Digital) Audio
Restrictions:
No HD content support
Cannot view photos or stream music or videos from Home Media on the customer’s PC
Also there are DVR and HD stbs etc -- if you want any info on them just let me know. That is just the comparison of the digital adapter and standard stb.
Message Edited by DzWR on 04-17-2009 03:04 PM -
Soap Sender and RFC Adapter receiver getting APPLICATION_ERROR
Hi, all,
I have a webservice soap sender and RFC Adapter receiver scenario, it works fine with RFC "RFC_SYSTEM_INFO", When i tried the RFC "RFC_READ_TABLE", getting the following error message, <SAP:Code area="RFC_ADAPTER">APPLICATION_ERROR</SAP:Code> in
SXI_MONITOR, in webservice client, i am getting error message like this:
<faultcode>SOAP:Server</faultcode>
<faultstring>Server Error</faultstring>
<detail>
<rfc:ZZTEST_RFC_READ_TABLE.Exception xmlns:rfc="urn:sap-com:document:sap:rfc:functions">
<Name>TABLE_NOT_AVAILABLE</Name>
<Text>QUERY_TABLE not active in Dictionary</Text>
</rfc:ZZTEST_RFC_READ_TABLE.Exception>
Thanks a lot!Hi
Its not compulsory but its good to wrap it as Z object.
Well if you are facing problem with SOAP data. Then try to do one thing. Check with the data you received from SOAP message. If this works
Then try to check in mapping is it passing the data correctly or not. With this check with the user authorization PIAPPLUSER. if its having less authorizations to execute this BAPI in ECC
Thanks
Gaurav
Maybe you are looking for
-
How can I migrate everything from one account to another on same computer?
How can I migrate everything from one account to another on same computer?
-
My iPod is "Stuck" on one screen! How Do I Fix It?
My iPod Nano is stuck on the Screen it looks like when you reset it! I plugged it into my computer to sync it with music and when I took it out, the music was there but it wouldn't play. I tried hitting the fast forward button but then it reset and i
-
Replace characters in chat text
I was written a small applescript to replace some characters in chat message. Here is my code. property searchList : {"live"} property replaceList : {"love"} to switchText of t from s to r set text item delimiters to s set t to t's text items
-
SQL Server Best Practices Architecture UCS and FAS3270
Hey thereWe are moving from EMC SAN and physical servers to NetApp fas3270 and virtual environment on Cisco UCS B200 M3.Traditionally - Best Practices for SQL Server Datbases are to separate the following files on spearate LUN's and/or VolumesDatabas
-
The "Complete Percentage" box doesn't work
Can anyone tell me why the b0x remains "0% Complete" even though the form is filled out correctly?