Has anyone successfully used a "WD My Book for Mac" via NAS (plugged into USB port on router) as a Time Machine back-up drive?

Has anyone successfully used a "WD My Book for Mac" via NAS (plugged into USB port on router) as a Time Machine back-up drive? Apple support tech tried to tell me it wasn't possible and that the only NAS Time Machine could back up to is the Time Capsule, but I'm not buying it. I know it's doable, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which External HDDs will work and which ones won't.  If not My Book for Mac, is there an External HDD that will work? (Running OS X 10.9.1 - Mavericks, btw...)

Given the nature of backups, my recommendation has always been to use a strategy that is unequivocally supported by Apple. As you already determined Apple Support unequivocally informed you that your proposal will not work, unless your router is an Apple AirPort Extreme or Time Capsule.
The exhaustive list of devices supported by Time Machine amounts to the following:
AirPort Time Capsule's built-in hard disk (any model)
External USB hard disk drive connected to a Time Capsule (any model)
External USB hard disk drive connected to an AirPort Extreme (current model only)
A hard disk drive directly connected to your Mac
That is all.
Use whatever backup device you want, but you should be aware that this site is full of reports of misery from hapless individuals who had been using NAS devices for Time Machine backups, only to find that they were incomplete, corrupted, or useless when they were required. Apple won't care if you lose your data while using a Time Machine configuration specifically excluded from their technical support documents.

Similar Messages

  • Has anyone successfully used the ZTE Open C with an AT&T microcell?

    I have a ZTE Open C and have had no issues with initial setup w/AT&T. However, like most newer phones the voice signal reception is very weak.
    I've had an AT&T Microcell before, but I don't have one now. For those that are unaware, the microcell allows 3G phones to connect via a 3G signal, but the call is routed through a home broadband internet connection.
    Has anyone successfully used a ZTE Open C w/Firefox OS AND used an AT&T microcell? If yes, did you need to do anything special on the phone or with Firefox OS.

    I don't use a ZTE Open C, however, I do have a ZTE Open (Original) on AT&T and so I'll see if I can help ;D
    I know someone who has a Microcell, and I have used it myself a few times. However, the microcell only works if you have entered in your phone number into settings of the Microcell.
    Check the Microcell settings.
    Check the data connection settings on your FxOS device
    Make sure your Microcell is properly connected to WiFi
    and check the AT&T support page for more info
    For a while, it actually hasn't actually worked for me. I apologize if this doesn't solve your problem :D

  • Has anyone successfully used the Intuit Quicken compatible with Lion upgrade for investment tracking?

    Has anyone successfully used the Intuit Quicken compatible with Lion upgrade for investment tracking?

    Although I gave up investment tracking for personal reasons (I had used Quicken Deluxe 2002 for many years for that reason), my understanding is that the new Quicken 2007 for Lion/Mt. Lion is completely the same feature wise as Quicken 2007 for PPC.  It will run on Snow Leopard, too.
    For $15, why not download it and just try it and LET US KNOW!

  • Has anyone successfully used Oracle EM as a Monitoring Solution??

    Hi All,
    This might be a wrong place to post ;) but anyways. My question is can we use Oracle EM as a Monitoring Solution? If so has anyone successfully used it?
    I have used Oracle EM over the years for mostly managing Databases. Eventually with the Middleware Support I have tried to use it to monitor Middleware Servers, earlier OC4J and recently WebLogic Servers. I however find that most people when talk about EM they think of it as a Business Transaction Monitoring Solution. (Lets keep BTM out for a while I know about that plugin but it is another full set of questions)
    Mostly I get questions as to can we "drill down the transactions" and see who initiated it and "what is being processed at this moment". Here transaction means Business Transaction as opposed "this thread is executing this particular piece of code". People want to know this piece of code is being executed "for Purchase Order XYZ" as opposed to just knowing that purchase order is being processed. If you know what i mean.
    No doubt OEM is great tool for an Admin but does it really sell itself as a monitoring solution? I have not seen a successful implementation so far with OEM being a central monitoring solution. If anyone has any experiences to share it would be great.

    I tried to look at that option. It is available only for the Database. I was looking something more towards say the web Services hosted or the Web Applications hosted on Weblogic instances. Can we find say the Web Service call which had the Purchase Order XYZ in its request, etc.

  • Has anyone successfully set up scan to smb to mac os 10.7.x from a Konica Minolta bizhub

    Has anyone successfully set up scan to smb to mac os 10.7.x from a Konica Minolta bizhub. I'm using 10.7.3 on MacBook Pro. Don't care what model bizhub is being used as I have access to many. I've seen the posts for FTP workarounds but want to use SMB if that is an option. Any suggestions? Thank you!

    petermtnbk wrote:
    I've read other discussions that have suggested changing the format of the username and password when having login problems. I'm not familiar with NT-Status Codes. Could changing the format of the username make any difference? Something like... "workgroup/username" or "username@domain" or "domain/username" or some other combination of workgroup, domain, username, computername.
    The issue has nothing to do with the format of the user authentication. What you are reading is about the Lion Mac connecting to a Windows computer that is part of domain or workgroup. The method changed slightly compared to Snow Leopard.
    KM does support FTP so that is still an option, but I would ideally would like to set up SMB scanning. I'm not sure if KM is going to support AFP anytime soon.
    With the lack of SMB support and KM offering no alternative at this stage then I suggest you look at using FTP. While Lion removed the option to enable FTP via the Sharing pane in System Preferences, it can still be enabled via Terminal using the following command
    sudo -s launchctl load -w /System/Library/LaunchDaemons/ftp.plist
    You will be prompted to authenticate using your Mac's admin account & password. Once this is done, you can then configure the address on the copier to push scan using FTP. The keys are;
    The host name requires just the IP address. No leading slashes like SMB
    The path will be the folder that you want to scan to, also entered without a leading slash. For example, Desktop
    The user name will be the short name of the account who's folder you want to scan to.
    The only other option may be WebDAV if the KM supports it. We have this with our imageRUNNER ADVANCE and with a document scanned to a shared folder in the copier hard drive, we can then connect to that folder by using Finder's > Go > Connect to Server facility. You then just enter
    http://ipaddress/share
    which connects you to the shared folder and lets you see the document you scanned. You also have the facility to set subfolders for security of users documents.

  • The disk drive in my iMac 8,1 has stopped working, so I now use an LG 8x Slim Portable that works.  However, every time I use the LG drive, I lose contact with my Time Machine back-up drive that has to be deleted and reinstalled.  Help!

    The disk drive in my iMac 8,1 has stopped working, so I now use an LG 8x Slim Portable that works.  However, every time I use the LG drive, I lose contact with my Time Machine back-up drive that has to be deleted and reinstalled.  Help!

    It's not Logic that can't find them, it's your Komplete apps, though if you did exaclty as you say I can see no reason why they can't.
    Do you know where the apps installed them in the first place? I chose a non-standard locarion for mine, but I'm sure it installs sounds to your documents folder/native instruments/name of app.
    Go into the prefs of each app and choose the library location button on the library tab and point it to the relevant folder in documents/native instruments and see if that works
    jake

  • Both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?, both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?, both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?

    both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?, both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?, both my USB ports are suddenly dead... has anyone had the same prob? what can I do?

    Reset your computer's SMC:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3964
    May I ask what purpose you think it serves to repeat your message six times? Once is quite enough.

  • Just got Prosoft drive genius 3 software, and it's telling me that the external hard drive that i am using for my time machine back up drive needs to be defragmented.  is it wise to do this or should i not??

    just got Prosoft drive genius 3 software, and it's telling me that the external hard drive that i am using for my time machine back up drive needs to be defragmented.  is it wise to do this or should i not??

    Let's hope a couple things: that you have bootable clones of your drives also; that the backup drive for TimeMachine has over 3x capacity of the data you plan and are storing. I would also switch TM backup drives so you have a 2nd.
    Fragmented free space affecting performance happens when the drive is too full which may mean there isn't enough free space for a full backup set.
    1.5TB for backing up 500GB, while WD Green 3TB is $140 and WD Black 1.5TB is, about the same price.
    I'd be worried about the integrity and directory, and whether you can afford to lose that drive. Defragging is also a very slow operation. the ideal: to just clone a drive, or start over with another drive and wait. cloning TM volumes has not been done or has it? SuperDuper hoped to but I don't think they or Bombich's CCC made it there.
    Trouble with highly fragged is when free space gets to 20% normally, 1/3 or so though for TM volumes, and finding where and a chunk of space for the file being written. Does TM use large spare image files of like 2GB?
    Best would be to ask in the TimeMachine section Snow Leopard
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/mac_os/mac_os_x_v10.6_snow_leopard?view= discussions#/?tagSet=1009
    where there are some good FAQ and tutorials, and people that know the ins-and-outs and shortcomings.

  • How do I retrieve my iphoto library from the Time Machine back-up drive, when the original iphoto library was on a separate external hard drive that has crashed?

    I recently backed up my iMAC and Simpletech external hard-drive to a 1 TB WD Passport  external hard drive, using Time Machine's back-up utility.  Today, I tried to access my iphoto library from the back-up drive, but received a message saying "the iPhoto library is a Time Machine back up, and so cannot be used as the main library.  Relaunch iPHoto with options key held down to choose another library."  Since my Simpletech died on me, what other iPhoto library is it expecting me to access?  I know approximately 169 GB were backed up, and my iPhoto library is roughly 54 GB. 
    Angie in Charlotte

    Thanks.  I will try going through TM.  Since my Simpletech is on the way out, I'll be plugging in a new external hard drive (other than the back-up drive) and trying to restore the library to the new drive.  Any advice or warning if this is NOT the right thing to do?
    Meanwhile, that is a great tip to do an alternate back-up using a different means.  It's been tough to figure out how to "preserve access" to digital images and files for posterity, knowing the hardware will always fail/obsolesce sooner or later, and that "clouds" are only as good as their consistent and reliable accessibility.  Upping the odds with redundancy will help dull the edge of my "access anxiety", though logically, it can never relieve it.  Will look into
    Carbon Copy Cloner.

  • Can I use Airport Express to connect to a printer, Time Machine Back up drive, second b/u drive, and scanner through a USB hub? if so, how?

    I have an Airport Express that connects to my printer. I'd like to add a scanner, and two back up drives (one for use with Time Capsule, another specifically for photographs backed up from Adobe Lightroom.
    The printer connects to the Airport Express through a USB hub and is recognized.  I cannot get the scanner nor either of the back up drives to be recognized.  Is there a way to do it or will I need to rely on a USB hub wired to the USB port of the MacBookPro?  If it is possible, can you walk me through the set up for each? 
    Thanks,
    Doug Earle

    I'd like to add a scanner, and two back up drives (one for use with Time Capsule, another specifically for photographs backed up from Adobe Lightroom.
    Unfortunately, the USB port on the AirPort Express will only work with a compatible printer.
    It will not work with a scanner, copier, or hard drive.
    It should be possible to do what you want by connecting a powered USB hub to your Mac and then connecting the devices to the powered hub.
    The setup for the scanner and hard drive would be covered by the manfacturers documentation, so providing specific advice for those types of products would be outside the realm of this support area.
    But, if you can provide model numbers, it is always possible that another user who is using those products might see this post.

  • My wife has old macbook osx and cannot transfer photos from her iPhone 5 when plugged into usb port

    my wife has old macbook osx and cannot transfer photos from her iPhone 5 when plugged into usb port

    She needs to upgrade to OS X 10.6.8 buy purchasing here http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC573/mac-os-x-106-snow-leopard and then running software update when the installation is complete.

  • Has anyone successfully used the Zoom R16 with Audition?

    I’ve tried just about everything, but can’t seem to get Audition to run with the Zoom R16.  As noted in a recent post, I updated both the Zoom R16 firmware and widows driver, but that doesn’t seem to make the 2 work harmoniously. 
    Has anyone had success getting the 2 to work together?  If so, what’s the trick?!
    Thanks in advance
    C

    CharlestonPro wrote:
    As noted in a recent post, I updated both the Zoom R16 firmware and widows driver, but that doesn’t seem to make the 2 work harmoniously.
    I'm intrigued - what is actually disharmonious?

  • Has anyone successfully used new custom templates with bookings?

    I have been trying to use an alternate list template for bookings as a fallback for the standard list I have which is outputting json.
    I saw recently in the september release that custom templates are out (thank goodness).
    I have tried:
    {module_booking,a template="fallback_list.tpl"}
    {module, booking,a template="fallback_list.tpl"}
    This is from http://helpx.adobe.com/business-catalyst/partner/using-custom-templates-modules.html it looks wrong to me.
    Then I tried renaming it to html cause I read http://forums.adobe.com/docs/DOC-2573
    Then I tried relocating it, removing the underscore, adding commas, removing commas, single quotes and double quotes.
    But they all return No events found.
    {module_booking,a, }
    Returns the expected amount of bookings.
    Any thoughts?

    Hi,
    Thanks Mario.  http://npaqueensland.businesscatalyst.com/events
    The events done with backbone and JSON are working, above those there is a bar of filters (not yet hooked up properly), and directly above those filters is the part I am having an issue with.
    Thanks,
    Allan.

  • Has anyone successfully config'd a 2wire 2700 for Back to My Mac?

    I have read documentation. I have searched this forum. I have searched the net. I have yet to find any mention of successfully configuring a 2wire 2700 to work with Back to My Mac, though Apple lists it as compatible and tested.
    Please, anyone who has accomplished this, post how you made it work for the rest of us.

    well here is their official reply to my enquires:
    " Thank you for contacting TELUS. My name is XXXX and I will be addressing your inquiry today. I apologize for the confusion with my previous reply. This section did not go into the email that I replied to: TCP/UDP 443 (ssl)
    Customers will not be able to accept inbound ssl connections on this port. "
    Hence I could not get BtMM to work after 4 frustrating days of trying. Hence my call to TELUS.
    Shaw has confirmed they DON'T block INBOUND on port 443.
    And I confirmed this last night with a person who uses BtMM with a Shaw Cable Modem and Wireless router ( but not a 2Wire one).
    I will be going to Shaw unless someone on these boards provides confirmation that they are successfully using TELUS and BtMM!
    PS the fellow that successfully used 2wire and BtMM was with Qwest. And he was using a 2Wire 2700 and opened up the two ports 443 and 4500 for incoming traffic.

  • Has anyone successfully captured a Training or Assessment for IBM iSeries Apps

    I just got CP5. I am working on a project where I need to create training and assessment simulation for an IBM iSeries application. ISeries applications must be run in a mainframe emulator and are text command in tensive. CP4 did not capture text entries or command entries, I guess becuse the fields are not GUI text boxes. I had to do text entries manually. Has this changed in CP5? Has anyone successfull done a capture of an iSeries app using the IBM emulator?

    I just got CP5. I am working on a project where I need to create training and assessment simulation for an IBM iSeries application. ISeries applications must be run in a mainframe emulator and are text command in tensive. CP4 did not capture text entries or command entries, I guess becuse the fields are not GUI text boxes. I had to do text entries manually. Has this changed in CP5? Has anyone successfull done a capture of an iSeries app using the IBM emulator?

Maybe you are looking for

  • ITunes no longer able to sync with Outlook

    Hello, This is my first ever post on any forum so please go easy on me. I have an iPhone 4s, and iPad1 and run Windows7. I recently tried using iCloud but didn't like the Outlook calendar (appearance or speed) so wanted to go back to just syncing via

  • Problem opening Premiere Pro project after upgrades to 4.1.0 and Shockwave

    I cannot open my project. During this project which has many CS4 AfterEffect pieces and with the Premiere Pro 4.1.0 upgrade and with the installation of the Shockware and updating the Flash Player to 10.0., I am no longer able to open my project!! I

  • Dreamweaver CS4 dead slow on windows 7 after inserting some png images, I can't scroll. Why?

    I am using Dreamweaver CS4 on windows 7, I put some png images in table and one 900px width image on background, now I cannot scroll the page, I can work smoothly on code view, but really dead slow in design view, Why? I am using Toshoba Tecra laptop

  • Sapinst not started in EP 6.0 on Unix

    Dears, I need to apply Java patch on EP 6.0 which is on Oracle with HP-UNIX. I have set DISPLAY variable by: setenv DISPLAY 192.163.193.155:0.0 My environmental variables: HOME=/home/epdadm PATH=/oracle/EPD/920_64/bin:.:/home/epdadm:/usr/sap/EPD/SYS/

  • Dropping Wireless after installing Windows XP. Help!

    I just installed Parallels and Windows XP Professional, and now my wireless goes in and out. Usually just disconnecting completely from my home network. I think I have seen this problem before. I could not locate it in a search though. Please help wi