New 2.4GHz MBP in "lid closed mode" wakes up automatically

Hi,
I got one of the new 2.4Ghz MBPs, had a first gen 2.16Ghz MBP before. I have external mouse, keyboard and display attached and use it with the lid closed. When I sent my older MBP to sleep it would take a few seconds before the display went dark. Then I turned of the power outlet and the MBP kept sleeping.
With the new MBP I have to power off during the time the display is still on or otherwise the MBP will immediately wake up as soon as I turn off power. Then it will take a few seconds for it to "realize" that I did not intend to wake it (i.e. the lid is still closed, no external display, no power supply) and will finally go to sleep.
2 Questions:
- Is it bad (for the display or the MBP) to power off at the time the Cinema Display is still active?
- Can I somehow regain the sleep behaviour of my old MBP?
Thanks a lot!
Björn

Try resetting your SMC.
Resetting the System Management Controller >>
Also, try trashing these 3 .plist preferences and reboot. Reset your Energy Saver preferences.
HD > Library > Preferences > SystemConfiguration > com.apple.AutoWake.plist & com.apple.PowerManagement.plist
User > Library > Preferences > com.apple.systemuiserver.plist
BTW...do you notice much difference in performance between your old MBP and the new one?
-Bmer
Mac Owners Support Group
Join Us @ MacOSG.com
iTunes: MacOSG Podcast
 An Apple User Group 

Similar Messages

  • MBP in lid closed mode, will the display get to hot?

    i run my MBP in lid closed mode all of the time, as i have a Cinema Display hooked up. i'm not too worried about the MBP overheating, but i was wondering about the display getting extra hot from the MBP when it's closed. i do have a radtech microfibre cloth on top of the keys as protection...
    should i be concerned?
    17" MacBook Pro   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

    I'm interested in this issue too, as I intend to get an MBP but use it with an external screen and keyboard most of the time.
    I'd also like to know about ventilation - where does the cooling air come from and go to? What parts need to be kept clear, and which bits can I have up against or close to a bookshelf or hutch or whatever?
    Thanks in advance.
    PS, I think the glossy screens look fantastic, but also think I'll go for matte since they are more practical.
    G3 B&W   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

  • Computer freezes in lid-closed mode when connected to external display

    I have a Sylvania SC190 CRT display connected to my Powerbook via a VGA to DVI adapter. Every time I put the computer in lid-closed mode and try to run it off of just the SC190, after a few minutes it freezes up and I have to hard restart it(hold power button down).
    Now, a few days ago, my powerbook stopped recognizing the display as an SC190, and just recognized it as a VGA Display. Don't know if this is relevant, as I have never used lid-closed mode before.
    Does anyone know what the problem is, and/or what I can do about it?
    Thank you.
    PowerBook 15" G4 1.67 GHz   Mac OS X (10.4.8)   512MB, 80GB, SD-DL

    I have the exact same problem.
    Here's my story:
    To give you some backgroud, my setup involves having the macbook on a mstand hooked up to an external monitor. I run a usb hub from my macbook, this is where my mouse transceiver is plugged in. I use am Apple wireless bluetooth keyboard (latest slim model)
    I recently purchased the 13.3' inch 2.26 MBP as I gave my older 2.0 uMB to a family member. The computer is in the stock configuration with no hardware upgrades.
    I have noticed weird behaviour when waking the computer from sleep when the lid is closed. When i wake the computer up (by tuning on bt keyboard), the keyboard light blinks like there is not bt connection and the computer will wake in an inactive state. The led light will be on, but when i flip the screen up....nothing. Screen is dark, keyboard pressing does not illicit any responses. I have to do a hard reboot by holding down the power button to restart the computer. Unfortunately any previous data or work is lost.
    I work in IT so I completed troubleshooting and also things outlined on forums in google. Reset PRAM, reset SMC and also reinstalled OSX. Still I get the same result. Fearing I purchased a defective unit, I called Apple and they told me i could exchange the computer so I dropped by the apple store and exchanged it quite easily.
    I've spent hours restoring from time machine and I am experiencing the same issue on my new laptop. I'm now assuming its not hardware but more firmware related as I had to do a bluetooth firmaware upgrade when I bought the computer when I checked for software updates.
    Is anyone else having any wake issues with their new MBPs? And what should I do next? Should I exchange for a 3rd unit? Thanks for you help everyone.

  • Lid closed mode--ntsc and pal

    I used to be able to put my MBP's display onto a TV using lid-closed mode and the Apple DVI-video adapter. I was changing my TV's resolution to something slightly higher, clicked the wrong setting (set the display mode to PAL), and now whenever I use lid-closed mode (or when I use boot camp to boot into windows XP) my TV (NTSC) does not work. It only does this in lid closed mode, and I've reset the PRAM to try to fix it. I can't see the TV display in PAL mode, so I can't change it back to NTSC. Please help!!! Should I reset my PMU or use some EFI command?
    15" MBP   Mac OS X (10.4.7)   using composite video on dvi-tv adapter (ntsc)

    I recommend running both the MBP (lid open) and the TV at the same time in screen spanning mode (not mirror mode). In this way, you should have complete control over the TV's Display Preferences settings from the screen on the MBP. Make sure you have the "Show displays in menu bar" check box clicked in Display Preferences. You should be able to restore the old settings you were using for your TV with this technique.
    Once you get your old settings restored, you can go back to using just the TV with the MBP lid closed again.

  • Resuming sleep from lid-closed mode?

    Sorry if this has already been answered, but searching through the manual and 34 pages of previous posts didn't turn up anything.
    When I get to work, I connect my MBP (in sleep mode) to my external monitor and then to my usb keyboard/mouse, which triggers the computer to wake up and go into lid-closed mode. I work all day with the lid closed.
    The problem is that when I'm ready to leave at the end of the day, I cannot just disconnect everything and resume sleep mode for the transport home.
    If I go to Apple/Sleep, it'll go to sleep for 1-2 sec, then re-enter lid-closed mode. If I unplug everything, then the computer stays in lid-closed mode and won't go to sleep. The only way to get it back into sleep mode is to disconnect everything and open up the lid, wait for the display to come on, then close it again. Time consuming measures like this clash severely with my impatience at getting out of the office.
    Any tips on how to re-sleep from lid-closed mode without having to open the lid? Thanks in advance.

    My impatience was my own undoing. Upon further testing, once the magsafe is disconnected, the laptop begins the routine to go to sleep. I'm a very happy camper now...don't have to open the laptop at all, and I get to reduce the rate of dimming of my laptop screen.

  • Bezel separating? / lid closed mode

    I've been operating my MacBook in lid closed mode for a week now. This morning I noticed that the plastic bezel on the left side and at the bottom of the display are starting to display small gaps with the LCD. Is this something I should be concerned with? Thanks.
    MacBook   Mac OS X (10.4.7)  

    This is my question too, so to save a new thread I'll chime in here.
    When I used an ibook, extensive googling yielded the concensus that the ibook should definitely not be run with the lid closed as the machine is ventilated through (or partly through?) the keyboard. In contrast it was said that lid closed mode was fine for the powerbook which was ventilated through the case somewhere.
    As far as I can tell the ibook and macbook have pretty similar cases, including what I assume is a vent at the back. (Actually on the ibook it looks more obviously like a vent, as it has a grill.) I don't have access to a powerbook to compare.
    So I guess that still leaves me asking whether it can be confirmed that the macbook is definitely safe running with lid closed (which is how I've been using it). Is the rear vent on the macbook more efficient than on the ibook? Or is the thing on the back of the ibook not actually a vent at all? ???
    Can anyone shed any light?

  • Simulate lid closed mode

    Do you know if is possible to use a software utility to simulate the lid closed mode for use with external display?
    I would like to use my macbook pro only with external display without close the lid, is possible?
    Thanks

    I have two suggestions:
    - If you close the lid and then wake up the Mac with a USB device like a mouse or a USB flash memory drive or some other USB device, then only the external screen will be active. Once the external screen comes on, you can open the lid and the internal screen will remain off. You have to have the MBP power adapter plugged in for this to work.
    - You can also use a small magnet to simulate a closed lid. Just place the magnet on the right edge of the plam rest over the area that is above the security port on the right side. This will make the MBP think the lid is closed.

  • Will Logitech Wireless keyboard/mouse work in lid closed mode?

    I know you are supposed to plug in a USB keyboard and mouse to get the MacBook to work in lid closed mode.
    Is it a strict requirement to be USB wired? Or will the Logitech wireless desktop be sufficient (with radio dongle plugged into USB)?
    Thanks.
    iMac Core Duo 2.0 Ghz   Mac OS X (10.4.7)  

    I honestly do not have a lot of confidence in this working.
    Unless you can find someone who's done it or somehow get an answer from Logitech (good luck with that one) I don't know how you're gonna find out, short of buying the combo and returning it if it doesn't work.
    Applecare is willing to help things work properly when they should, but something like this isn't gonna get you any response or help over the phone other then a reference back to these forums or to Logitech/google.
    Hope you find an answer, but all i know is that if it says USB...then there must be a reason. Doesn't mean nothing else will work though, but might not be the easiest thing to get an "in advance" response on.

  • MacBook Pro, Lid-Closed Mode

    Hello, I'm considering getting an Apple Cinema Display to use with my MacBook Pro. I understand that most modern MacBooks, including the Pro are lid-closed mode compatible.
    A) I understand that one must have the display, keyboard, and mouse to use the notebook in lid-closed mode. Is it true that the Apple Wireless mice and keyboards are compliant as well? If I've read this article correctly, then yes:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1308?viewlocale=en_US
    B) The screen doesn't turn on, back inside the notebook does it? That would be a redundant use of power.
    C) Is lid-closed mode harmful to the longevity or otherwise well-being of my MacBook Pro?

    Is it true that the Apple Wireless mice and keyboards are compliant as well?
    Yes.
    Is lid-closed mode harmful to the longevity or otherwise well-being of my MacBook Pro?
    No.
    (34225)

  • Problem with lid closed mode

    So as far as i know, to get the computer to run in lid closed mode you press f7 until you get video mirroring, the second mode i believe, close the display, then wake the computer with the external mouse or keyboard. I've done this, but almost as soon as i wake the computer, it goes back to sleep again.
    How do i fix this??
    Is it a problem for I'm using a windows keyboard, but i wouldn't think that could be it.

    Also, if you haven't already done this, make sure that Bluetooth is enabled and that you "Allow Bluetooth devices to wake this computer" (Systpref/Bluetooth/Settings)

  • Thunderbolt display problems using MBP with lid closed

    I am experiencing a very reproducible problem since purchasing aThunderbolt display to use with a recent (1 month old) Macbook Pro 13"2.7GHz i7.
    I use my MBP with lid closed with myThunderbolt display. If Ithen allow the MBP to sleep and power down, on restarting it the WiFi hasstopped working- the menu bar says I am connected by WiFi but Safari will notconnect to the internet and Time Machine cannot connect to the Airport/TimeCapsule to backup. Nothing I do will fix it (shutting down all programs, turingWiFi off then on) and so I have to shutdown/reboot BUT THEN the MBP freezesduring shutdown (waiting 15, 20, 30 minutes!) and I have to hold down the powerbutton (hard reboot). Once I reboot everything works fine UNTIL I take a breakand the computer goes to sleep again.
    Doesn't seem to be a problem with the MBP lid open, but I needto test this a bit more to be sure...
    On top of this the Bluetooth trackpad now keeps going on andoff; connected, not connected despite being near or the computer. Veryirritating at best, unusable at worst. This only started to be a major problem(every 10-15 minutes or so) when I started to use the Thunderbolt display.
    These problems seems to be in some ways similar to anotherthread:
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/16205098#16205098
    ("Major problemswith Thunderbolt display & MBAir")
    I have applied the recent Thunderbolt Firmware update, and SMC& PRAM/NVRAM resets. Interestingly these seemed to work initially but thenafter a prolonged power-down period the problem has recurred. Back to square 1.
    Any ideas out there?

    Just to be clear, have you installed everything that you find on this page?
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4644
    I just talked to Apple Care about Thunderbolt issues in general and even though I already had the Thunderbolt Software Update installed, he had me reinstall it.  If you go to this page:
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/16889000#16889000
    you can read in detail about the issues I was having which have for the most part been remedied (for now at least!)
    The Thunderbolt cable definitely transfers heat for some reason even when there isn't a high CPU utilization.  The process 'kernel_task' seems to be where the API for thunderbolt is running.  But for some reason, the behavior of CPU Utilization to Fan Speed is amplified when connected to the TBD.
    Apple Care is researching it.

  • Computer does not put itself to sleep when used in lid-closed mode

    Hi. I'm having a small problem when using my macbook pro with the LED display, lid closed and with external keyboard and mouse. If I leave the computer unattended, the display goes to sleep at the time specified in system settings under energy saver. The computer, however, does not go to sleep - the white power indicator remains solid and noises for new email etc can still be heard.
    I should probably just try to remember to put it to sleep manually but I keep forgetting. Does anybody know what settings I need to adjust?

    I tried cycling the old battery many times, and the computer would still shut down unexpectedly instead of going to sleep when it ran out of power. I got a free replacement from the supplier [http://myworld.ebay.com/cbkusaelectronics>, but I have cycled this new battery twice now, and it still does not go to sleep when it runs out of power. The capacity of the battery is fine (4.9 Ah), and the timing calibration seems fine as well. I have two older batteries from NewerTech and they allow sleep every time, so I think my computer is fine. Can anyone enlighten me about the cause of this problem? Does my battery lack some 'sleep battery' cell in it for use after the other 4 cells discharge? Or does my battery lack a chip that communicates with the computer? Is there any hope of getting this battery to support sleep when discharged?
    Has anyone else seen this problem consistently in a brand of battery? Does anyone have a recommendation for a cheaper battery that does not exhibit this problem? I have been happy with NewerTech, but they cost over $130.
    (I only paid $44 plus $10 shipping, so I probably got what I paid for. It is maybe still worth it to have a high capacity battery for such a low cost, but I can't rely upon it in those last few minutes or I may lose work.)

  • Lid Closed Mode on an 867?

    I am surethis has been covered in these forums somewhere, but I must be using the wrong search terms, b/c I can't seem to find a conclusive answer. So here it goes:
    Can I run my 12" aluminum 867MHz Powerbook with the lid closed while attached to an external display? Or is that an option only on the newer (newest) PBs? I know iBooks need the keyboard clear to help dissapate heat. Is that an issue with my PB as well?
    Thanks!

    Hi,
    I've been using my 867 Mhz PowerBook with the lid closed and connected to an external display, keyboard, and mouse ever since I bought it in March, 2003. I've had no heat-related problems at all. However, whenever I have a chance, I prop up the back end of the PowerBook on somethat that will raise the rear of the machine off the table about an inch or so to allow for better air circulation underneath it, where it seems to get the hottest. I didn't do this as a response to any problem, but when I realized how warm the underside of the machine gets, I figured it was a prudent thing to do.
    Ken

  • New HDD keeps spinning with lid closed

    I have replaced the original 160GB HDD in a Macbook late 2008, OS-10.6.8, with a WD Black Scorpio 750GB.
    The thing is that when I close the lid, the screen gets black but the disk keeps spinning.
    If I set it to sleep in the Apple menu, then the drive get silent. … Worrisome?

    My iBook G4 went back to Apple just an hours ago. A lot of issues developed, which I suspect is a bad logic board, but who knows:
    * Intermittent problems like yours where it can't sleep with the lid closed
    * Waking up to either the black screen of death or else the screen freezes (and the cursor disappears) within a few seconds after waking up (the panic log suggested an AirPort issue, but who knows?)
    * The combo drive will not play or rip some CDs (although if I make a copy of the CD on another computer, it plays fine)
    * Yesterday in the middle of writing an e-mail, the screen went dark with a series of vertical white lines
    The last issue convinced me it was a logic board problem and had to go back.
    I'm typing this on my previous iBook (G3, 800 MHz) that had some issues with the battery and AC adapter failing and did have the closed lid/sleep/wake cycle issue that you have but it works fine now and never had a documented logic board problem. I'm surprised the bugs haven't gotten worked out of the iBook after all these years. Very disappointing!

  • 10.4.3 update destroys portrait lid closed mode with cinema display

    The 10.4.3 update destroys the ability to use an external cinema display in closed lid mode. In particular using the rotate by 90 degrees option. Once set the external display goes nuts and can not be set back to landscape -- even in open lid mode. Zapping the PRam is not sufficient to reset the display.
    Anyone solve this problem?

    I'm interested in this issue too, as I intend to get an MBP but use it with an external screen and keyboard most of the time.
    I'd also like to know about ventilation - where does the cooling air come from and go to? What parts need to be kept clear, and which bits can I have up against or close to a bookshelf or hutch or whatever?
    Thanks in advance.
    PS, I think the glossy screens look fantastic, but also think I'll go for matte since they are more practical.
    G3 B&W   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

Maybe you are looking for