Same code gives different results in Matlab Script in Labview and Matlab

I am implemeting a Matlab code into a LabVIEW application using Matlab script. When I import the exactly same code to the Matlab Script in LabVIEW it gives a different result than it is in Matlab. This code is a simulation code including first kind bessel functions. Using LabVIEW 7.1 and Matlab R14 service pack 3.

Labview 8.5
Matlab R2009b
Attached are the graphs produced by matlab script in labview and in matlab.
The minimum of graph produced by matlab code is below 1 and that in labview is above 1.
Thanks a lot for your reply.
Sorry, I haven't quantified the "sometimes" yet.
Attachments:
matlabsResult.jpg ‏29 KB
LV.png ‏84 KB

Similar Messages

Same C++ code gives different result in MacOSX and Ubuntu

Hi
I have a C++ program which starts by reading an external file, but changing the name of the file give me different results.
I selected just the important part and made a simple file with the reading part of my program and can be downloaded here
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/664351/files.zip
It just reads the external file and does the output of some values.
It has two external file examples. If one uses "x.txt" everything works fine, but if we use "dados.txt", which is a copy of "x.txt", the last value in the output is wrong.
The stranger is that if i use these same files in ubuntu everything works just fine!
I tried in a MacBook, a MacBook Pro and an iMac (all of them with macosx 10.6) and i always got the error, but not on ubuntu!
Does anyone has a clue about what is happening here?
Cheers,
Marcelo

marcelobarbosa wrote:
Does anyone has a clue about what is happening here?
Change OutFile from a 20 byte character array to a string. GCC isn't able to tell what type that is and is picking int or something, corrupting your memory.

Different output of DST function in labview and matlab

I am passing a 1D array of size 1550 as input to DST function. I have also calculated DST of same array in matlab using 'dst' function. I got approximately same answer till 1399th element but after that answers of two varies abruptly. I tried hard but I am unable to find the solution. I am attaching the data file in which it can be clearly seen that at 1530th element there is a difference of sign also.
Attachments:
data file1.txt ‏37 KB

Out of curiosity, have you tried another software, like Octave? When you have two software that is different, which one is incorrect?
Also, have you tried to use the DST function in LabVIEW directly?
Another think to keep in mind... When you try to run a sequence for so long, small round-off errors could be cummulative and show later on the analysis. Also, it depends on how you load the data into each software. Hopefully when moving the platforms, the string conversion would not truncate the number. The best is not using string, but some kind of binary format...
These are some ideas to check...
Barp - Control and Simulation Group - LabVIEW R&D - National Instruments

Do IMAQ Cast Image or IMAQ Linear averages give different results when using different computers that are running under Windows XP ?

Hello
I'm currently developping an image processing algorithm using Labview 7.1 and the associated IMAQ Vision tools. After several tests, I found a weird result. Indeed, I put the labview algorithm - including the IMAQ VI on the library to get sure that I use all the time the same VI - on my memory stick and used it on two different computers. I tested the same picture (still in my memory stick) and had two very different results.
After several hours trying to understand why, I found that there were a difference between the results given by both computers at the very begining of the algorithm. Indeed, I used a JPEG file.
To open it, I first create an Image with IMAQ Create (U8). Then, I open it.
Then in my first sub-VI, I use IMAQ Cast Image to be sure that the picture is a U8 grayscale picture.
Right after that, I use the IMAQ Linear Averages. The results of this VI are different on the two computers.
I tried several time on the same picture : one computer always give me the same result but the two computers give me a different result. So there is no random variable on the results.
So my question is : Do IMAQ Cast Image or IMAQ Linear averages give different results when using different computers that are running under Windows XP ?
My bet is on IMAQ Cast Image but I'm not quite sure and I do not undestand why. The labview and IMAQ are the same on both computers.
The difference between the two computer are above :
Computer 1 :
Pentium(R) 4 CPU 3.20GHz with a RAM of 1Go. The processor is an Intel(R).
The OS is windows XP Pro 2002
Computer 2 :
Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz with a RAM of 512Mo. The processor is an Intel(R).
The OS is windows XP Pro 2002.
If anybody can help me on this problem, it would be really helpful.
Regards
Florence P.

Hi,
Indeed it's a strange behaviour, could you send me your VI and your JPEG file, (or another file that reproduces) so that I could check this inthere ?
I'll then try to find out what's happening.
Regards
Richard Keromen
National Instruments France
#adMrkt{text-align: center;font-size:11px; font-weight: bold;} #adMrkt a {text-decoration: none;} #adMrkt a:hover{font-size: 9px;} #adMrkt a span{display: none;} #adMrkt a:hover span{display: block;}
>> Découvrez, en vidéo, les innovations technologiques réalisées en éco-conception

Same query giving different results

Hi
I m surprised to see the behaviour of oracle. I have two different sessions for same scheema on same server. In both sessions same query returns different results. The query involves some calculations like sum and divisions on number field.
I have imported this data from another server using export / import utility available with 9i server. Before export every thing was going fine. Is there some problem with this utility.
I m using Developer 6i as the front end for my client server application. The behaviour of my application is very surprizing as once it shows the correct data and if I close the screen and reopen, it shows wrong data.
I m really stucked with the abnormal behaviour. Please tell me the possiblities and corrective action for these conditions.
Regards
Asad.

There is nothing uncommitted in both the sessions. But still different results are returned.
I m sending u the exact query and result returned in both sessions.
Session 1:
SQL> rollback;
Rollback complete.
SQL> SELECT CC.CREDIT_HRS,GP.GRADE_PTS
2 FROM GRADE G, COURSE_CODE CC, GRADE_POLICY GP
3 WHERE G.COURSE_CDE=CC.COURSE_CDE
4 AND G.SELECTION_ID=45 AND G.GRADE_TYP=GP.GRADE_TYP
5 AND G.TERM_PROG_ID=17 AND GP.TERM_ID=14
6 /
CREDIT_HRS GRADE_PTS
3 4
4 3.33
4 3.33
3 4
3 4
3 4
3 4
7 rows selected.
SQL>
SESSION 2:
SQL> rollback;
Rollback complete.
SQL> SELECT CC.CREDIT_HRS,GP.GRADE_PTS
2 FROM GRADE G, COURSE_CODE CC, GRADE_POLICY GP
3 WHERE G.COURSE_CDE=CC.COURSE_CDE
4 AND G.SELECTION_ID=45 AND G.GRADE_TYP=GP.GRADE_TYP
5 AND G.TERM_PROG_ID=17 AND GP.TERM_ID=14
6 /
CREDIT_HRS GRADE_PTS
3 4
4 3.33
3 4
3 4
3 4
3 4
6 rows selected.
SQL>
U can see in session 1, seven rows are returned while in session 2 six rows are returned. I have issued a rollback before query to be sure that data in both sessions is same.

The same code behaving different in two files.

The same code behaving different in two files.
in pro*c file it is returning rows
in sql file it is not returning any rows.
please suggest me.
regards,
prasad.

please find the code.
sql_stmt := 'SELECT rNum, dpcCode, sID, hDate, fBlock, '||
'lBlock, recQty, fID, fName, ' ||
'tSeqNo, sType, tDate, fStatCode, pDate, recCount, r ' ||
'FROM (SELECT rownum rNum, DPC_CODE_ORIG dpcCode, ' ||
'SENSOR_ID sID, ' ||
'to_char(HEADER_DATE, ''YYYYMMDDHH24MISS'') hDate, ' ||
'FIRST_BLOCK_NUMBER fBlock, ' ||
'LAST_BLOCK_NUMBER lBlock, ' ||
'RECORD_QUANTITY recQty, ' ||
'FILE_ID fID, ' ||
'substr(FILE_NAME,1,30) fName, ' ||
'TRACE_SEQUENCE_NO tSeqNo, ' ||
'SENSOR_TYPE sType, ' ||
'to_char(TRAILER_DATE, ''YYYYMMDDHH24MISS'') tdate, ' ||
'NVL(FILE_STATUS_CODE, ''NL'') fStatCode, ' ||
'to_char(PROCESSED_DATE, ''YYYYMMDDHH24MISS'') pDate, '||
'NVL(RECIRCULATE_COUNT,0) recCount, ' ||
'ROW_NUMBER() ' ||
'OVER(ORDER BY TRAILER_DATE DESC, LAST_BLOCK_NUMBER DESC) r ' ||
'FROM logfc10t ' ||
'WHERE DPC_CODE_ORIG = :IN_DPC_CODE ' ||
'AND SENSOR_ID = :IN_SENSOR_ID ' ||
'AND (((TRAILER_DATE <= TO_DATE(:IN_TRAILER_DATE, ''YYYYMMDDHH24MISS''))' ||
' AND (LAST_BLOCK_NUMBER < :IN_BLOCK_NUMBER)) ' ||
' OR (TRAILER_DATE < TO_DATE(:IN_TRAILER_DATE, ''YYYYMMDDHH24MISS'')))) ' ||
'WHERE r = 1 ';

Using Matlab script in Labview

Hello,
I am trying to use matlab script in labview to post process the sampled signals from DAQ(attached is the vi I tried)
After every 10 seconds I want to the send the sampled voltage data to matlab scritp block which does 1) detection of peaks using peakdetection function and plots the obtained peaks on the sampled signal 2) calculates standard of 10 secs data and plots on chart.
But I am confused of 1) how to call the peakdetection function inside the matlabscript block
2) How to send the 10secs data of voltage and time values to the matlab script block
3) How to plot the signal and detected peaks on the same plot (which can be done in matlab using holdon as shown in the atached vi).
Can someone suggest for implementing these .
Thanks.
Solved!
Go to Solution.
Attachments:
Labview&Matlab.vi ‏55 KB

Thanks GabeG,
Now, Labview&Matlab_TestNoAq.vi is woking Good and for the second one Labview&Matlab_TestAq.vi it is showing error as shown in the attached image when these ines of code are present in the matlab scrtip
subplot(2,1,1),plot(maxtab(:,1),maxtab(:,2),'*r');
SDN=std(maxtab(:,1));
and SDN output of the Matlab script
but when I removed these it is working fine(but not showing the detected peaks).
Can you suggest me a solution for the above and also can I know the best method to add one more channel that samples another device signal which has to be processed in this same way(Signals sampled from 2 devices have to be porcessed in this same way).
Thanks.
Attachments:
Script_Error.JPG ‏133 KB

Matlab script in Labview

Hi there,
I want to integrate my Matlab script in Labview,
the input variable should be a Matrix like
the following A = [ 0 256 ; 1 256 ;1.5 100 ; 1.55 110; 1.59 55; 1.6 56 ; 9 256; 14 256 ;15 100 ]
How do I do this in Labview, I tried an array but
no succes...
Bye for now

hi chris .. thanks for the reply ...
here's the results from 'ver
MATLAB Version 7.0.1.24704 (R14) Service Pack 1
MATLAB License Number: 227039
Operating System: Microsoft Windows XP Version 5.1 (Build 2600: Service Pack 2)
Java VM Version: Java 1.4.2_04 with Sun Microsystems Inc. Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM
MATLAB
Version 7.0.1      (R14SP1)
Simulink
Version 6.1        (R14SP1)
Aerospace
Blockset
Version 1.6.1      (R14SP1)
Bioinformatics
Toolbox
Version 1.1.1      (R14SP1)
CDMA Reference
Blockset
Version 1.1        (R14SP1)
Communications
Blockset
Version 3.0.1      (R14SP1)
Communications
Toolbox
Version 3.0.1      (R14SP1)
Control System
Toolbox
Version 6.1        (R14SP1)
Curve Fitting
Toolbox
Version 1.1.2      (R14SP1)
Data Acquisition
Toolbox
Version 2.5.1      (R14SP1)
Database
Toolbox
Version 3.0.1      (R14SP1)
Datafeed
Toolbox
Version 1.6        (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for Infineon C166 Microcontrollers    Version 1.1.1      (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for Motorola
HC12
Version 1.1.1      (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for Motorola
MPC555
Version 2.0.1      (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for OSEK
VDX
Version 1.1.1      (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for TI C2000
DSP(tm)
Version 1.1.1      (R14SP1)
Embedded Target for TI C6000
DSP(tm)
Version 2.2.1      (R14SP1)
Excel
Link
Version 2.2.1      (R14SP1)
Extended Symbolic
Math
Version 3.1.1      (R14SP1)
Filter Design HDL
Coder
Version 1.1        (R14SP1)
Filter Design
Toolbox
Version 3.1        (R14SP1)
Financial Derivatives
Toolbox
Version 3.0.1      (R14SP1)
Financial Time Series
Toolbox
Version 2.1.1      (R14SP1)
Financial
Toolbox
Version 2.4.2      (R14SP1)
Fixed-Income
Toolbox
Version 1.1        (R14SP1)
Fixed-Point
Toolbox
Version 1.1        (R14SP1)
Fuzzy Logic
Toolbox
Version 2.2        (R14SP1)

Interface LabVIEW and matlab

Hello, I want to interface LabVIEW with MATLAB using TCP/IP for data transfer. Can anyone, please give me a step-by-step instruction to how to do this? Or else can you point out where I can get them? Thanks.
Solved!
Go to Solution.

Hi Sanchu,
As TCP/IP is such a generic protocol then you should be able to fairly easily build TCP/IP interfaces for both your LabVIEW and Matlab code and transfer data using ASCII, or variants etc depending on what sort of data you are trying to transfer. I'm not too familiar with Matlab, but on the LabVIEW end there are some very good TCP/IP server and client examples that ship with LabVIEW.
Another option that you may want to consider, and the reason I'm answering this is that I've recently done a project whereby we took some legacy Matlab code which we wanted to transpose into LabVIEW so that we could then fully automate a test system we have using TestStand. Much of it we were able to derive LabVIEW equivalent functions, but for some functions where LabVIEW didn't appear to have a suitable equivalent, or where it was simply more efficient, we simply copy and pasted the Matlab code into either in the first instance MathScript nodes (not dependant on Matlab) or Matlab script nodes (which will hopefully return to at a future date to fully transpose over to LabVIEW so that we are no longer dependant on a Matlab licence).
In both instances the relative ease of doing this was very impressive, and we were able to wrap huge amounts of Matlab code within LabVIEW with very few issues. As an idea, have you considered wrapping your Matlab functionality in this way and then keeping all the TCP/IP client and server comms within LabVIEW?
N.B. if you haven't found it search the palette for 'Matlab Script'
Best of luck,
David
David Clark
CLA | CTA
CLA Design Ltd
Hampshire, England

Matlab 'place' command gives different result in Mathscript/Labview

Hello,
I am trying to implement a order reduced observer in Labview. First I used Labview blocks for programming but it happens that I get different results when I am using Matlab. For that reason I used Mathscript to make a simple 'place' command to check it. The result in Labview and Mathscript is the same, but not in Matlab...
This is the instruction in Matlab:
A22=[0.9024 0 0;0 0.8607 0; 0 0 0];
A12=[0 0 0 ;0 0 0.0548;0.0417 0 0;0 -0.0417 0];
K=place(A22',A12',[0.32 0.31 0.3]);
Ko=K'
Ko =
   0 0 13.9664 0
   0 0 0 -13.2062
   0 -5.4745 0 0
And I have attached the VI where I do the test with Labview blocks and Mathscript. As you can see the result is not even close to be similar. Why is this produced? How can I fix it?
Thank you a lot in advance!
Attachments:
pruebararamathscript.vi ‏39 KB

Hi,
Indeed there are a lot of gains that places the poles on the desired locations. BUT, seeing as the Varga's SEAP algorithm is implemented, the G matrix is selected through a uniform white noise generator and the desired characteristics are verified (controllability). This does not unsure optimization regarding stability margins or disturbance rejection (sensitivity minimization regarding perturbations an matrix A or B).
As an example, the system presented in this thread, the algorithm implemented in CD Pole Placement.vi computes an observer gain that determine a 7,4455 value for closed loop infinity norm. The place algorithm in Matlab computes an observer gain that determine a 2,8230 value for closed loop infinity norm, so better noise rejection or robustness.
cosmin

Same exact Code but different results

I am trying to fill a Listbox in a single Dialog based program using names
from a file. I started by using an example program from the MSDN - Modeless.
A simple Dialog based program using a modeless dialog to add strings to a
Listbox in the main dialog. I inserted into the sample program the following
code, which works perfectly:
#include <Fstream>
BOOL CLeasesDlg:nInitDialog()
char* names;
CListBox* pList = (CListBox*) GetDlgItem(IDC_LIST);
infile.open("Leases",ios::in, filebuf:penprot);
while( (infile.getline(names,25,'\n')) != NULL)
pList->AddString(names);
infile.close();
Sunce the sample program was just a stepping stone I created my own Dialog
based program using the AppWizard. I inserted the above code. I now receive
an "unhandled exception" error every time during the "getline" execution. I
have been trying for the last several days to track down the problem but can
not.
Some of what I learned:
First-chance exception in Leases.exe (MSVCIRTD.DLL): 0xC0000005: Access
Violation.
so I wrote code to establish access permissions:
int test = 0;
// Check for existence
if( test = ((_access( "Leases", 0 )) != -1) )
// Check for read permission
if(test = ((_access( "Leases", 4 )) != -1) )
I stepped thru both with no problem. The file exist and is readable but can
not retreive the first name.
In the disassembly window it stops on this line:
strgetl.cpp --------------------------------------------------------------
102A75CD 88 08 mov byte ptr [eax],cl
I do not understand how the code can work in the sample program and not work
in the one I created. I looked back at another program I wrote several years
ago and I used the exact same code with no problem. I would think that my
compiler was corrupted but it compiles the modeless sample program.
I am totally baffled .... PLEASE ... PLEASE help!
I would be greatly appreciative

Hey Randy,
This forum is reserved for Measurement Studio questions. I recommend checking with Microsofts forums because the people there will have more experience doing what you are looking for.
Regards,
jigg
CTA, CLA
teststandhelp.com
~Will work for kudos and/or BBQ~

P/L A/c for a single day gives different results for different users

Hi!
     We have SAP B1 8.81 (PL 09) in our office. P/L Account for a particular date gives different value for a single account (Other Income Account) for one user and a consistent value for all other users. The user in question is a super user and does not seem to pick a specific entry posted in the Other Income Account for that day thus giving erroneous result. I have checked the Trial Balance for that day and it gives proper result. Only the P/L account gives erroneous data. Could anyone help with the reason for this.
Thanks
Sreekumar

Hi Jitin,
          Thanks for your reply.
          I tried the way you mentioned. However, the result is the same.
          The entry that I'm talking about is an automatic journal entry posted through the Outgoing Payment option.
          To make it more clear, an outgoing payment to a vendor was posted on 05/19/11 for 1,42,178.32. The check was drawn only for 71,089.16 which was the correct amount and the remaining amount (71,089.16) got posted in the Other Income account. The P/L account for this date is not picking the amount of 71,089.16 in the Other Income Account.
Thanks & Regards
Sreekumar
Edited by: Sreekumar on Jan 31, 2012 5:58 PM

Why not exists and minus give different result

HI,
I am writing thes query by using two different operators they should give me the same output but they dont. Please can anybody explain why they give different output.
query 1
SQL> SELECT COUNT(*) FROM
2 (select orig_idx
3 from rel15_au_poi a
4 MINUS
5 SELECT ORIG_IDX
6 FROM REL14_1_AU_POI_INTERM B) ;
COUNT(*)
244312
query 2
SQL> select count(*)
2 from rel15_au_poi a
3 where not exists
4 (select null from rel14_1_au_poi_interm b where a.orig_idx=b.ORIG_IDX) ;
COUNT(*)
245341
best Regards,

Because you have duplicates in rel15_au_poi which are counted with exists and removed with minus.
http://download.oracle.com/docs/cd/B19306_01/server.102/b14200/queries004.htm#sthref3147
MINUS Example
The following statement combines results with the MINUS operator, which returns only unique rows returned by the first query but not by the second:
SELECT product_id FROM inventories
MINUS
SELECT product_id FROM order_items;

Same Query returning different result (Different execution plan)

Hi all,
To day i have discovered a strange thing: a query that return a different result when using a different execution plan.
The query :
SELECT *
FROM schema.table@database a
WHERE     column1 IN ('3')
       AND column2 = '101'
       AND EXISTS
              (SELECT null
                 FROM schema.table2 c
                WHERE a.column3 = SUBSTR (c.column1, 2, 12));where schema.table@database is a remote table.
when executed with the hint /*+ ordered use_nl(a c) */ these query return no result and its execution plan is :
Rows     Row Source Operation
      0 NESTED LOOPS (cr=31 r=0 w=0 time=4894659 us)
   4323   SORT UNIQUE (cr=31 r=0 w=0 time=50835 us)
   4336    TABLE ACCESS FULL TABLE2 (cr=31 r=0 w=0 time=7607 us)
      0   REMOTE (cr=0 r=0 w=0 time=130536 us)When i changed the execution plan with the hint /*+ use_hash(c a) */
Rows     Row Source Operation
   3702 HASH JOIN SEMI (cr=35 r=0 w=0 time=497839 us)
22556   REMOTE (cr=0 r=0 w=0 time=401176 us)
   4336   TABLE ACCESS FULL TABLE2 (cr=35 r=0 w=0 time=7709 us)It seem that when the execution plan have changed the remote query return no result.
It'is a bug or i have missed somthing ?
PS: The two table are no subject to insert or update statement.
Oracle version : 9.2.0.2.0
System version : HP-UX v1
Thanks.

H.Mahmoud wrote:
Oracle version : 9.2.0.2.0
System version : HP-UX v1Hard to say. You're using a very old and deprecated version of the database, and one that was known to contain bugs.
9.2.0.7 was really the lowest version of 9i that was considered to be 'stable', but even so, it's old and lacking in many ways.
Consider upgrading to the latest database version at your earliest opportunity. (or at least apply patches up to the latest 9i version before querying if there is bugs in your really low buggy version)

Disk Utility Gives Differing Results...........

I used disk utility (Leopard, not from start up disk) to repair permissions and to verify the hard drive. Permissions repair worked fine (but v slowly), but verifying the disk brought up an error saying that the disk needed to be repaired. I therefore ran disk utility from the disk (ie holding c at startup etc....).
Running disk utility eventually resulted in green text saying that no repair of the disk was necessary.
I restarted, re-ran disk utility in Leopard and it still says the disk needs to be repaired. Onyx also says the disk needs to be repaired. I have run the extended hardware test, which said there are no problems.
Can anyone shed any light on why I am getting these different results and if I need to be worried???
Many thanks in advance!

There are a few important points to verify to ensure an external drive is bootable. Attach the external drive while started up normally. Run Disk Utility. Select the external drive in the left sidebar and look at the info at the bottom of the window. To be able to install Leopard on it, the Partition Map Scheme must be GUID Partition Table.
If it is GUID Partition Table, you can start up from the Mac OS X installation disk and select it as the target for installation. If the drive is not empty, the data already on it will not be affected, but you should probably back it up if it is valuable. After the installation, start up from the external drive and run Software Update to get all the updates. You will have to run Software Update a few times to get all the inter-dependent updates.
If it is not GUID Partition Table, you will need to re-partition it and change it to GUID Partition Table using Disk Utility's Partition tab. In this case, the drive will be erased.
Once you have done the installation and all the updates, you can run Disk Utility while started up from the external drive and select the internal drive for the Repair routine. Since the Repair process should be identical, hopefully the results will be consistent.

Same code gives different results in Matlab Script in Labview and Matlab

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for