Sony Z1 Compact... why is the camera so poor? Comparison shots within.

The Good...
I picked up a Sony Z1 Compact the other day, and am so far absolutely in love woth it. The speed and responsiveness are fantastic, the build quality rivals that of the iPhone, and the size is just perfection.
The Bad...
But... I am VERY dissappointed with the camera and its poor performance. 80% of the photos I take with my phone are while on a night out with friends, usually in bars or other more dimly lit places than broad daylight. In Auto mode, photos taken in the average pub lightning are unuseable,m and look so artifical as to completely destroy any detail in the faces of the people I snap. I have also experimented with manual settings, but still the quakity is just plain poor. In fact, mny Samsung Galaxy S III blows it out of the water in this regard, images in similar conditions are much superior.
The Ugly...
So why is this camera, a camera that uses what is theoretically a high-quality imaging unit used by point and shoot cameras, so bad in everything except broad daylight?
The answer according to not only my observations, but the observations of many professional websites who reviewed the Z1 series, is seems to be that Sony are purposefully and inexplicably messing with the final images by forcing huge amounts of processing on them. This takes a natural image, messes with the colours and tone, and then proceeds to crush any detail.
Here are some samples of what I mean, taken with Superior Auto:
Sample 1: Z1 Compact
A close-up portrait shot...
Look at how artificial that image looks... it's like someone applied a strange kind of gaussian blur tool in photoshop.
Sample 2 - Z1 Compact
A group photo...
Here again, in what was one of the better photos that I took, we see the find detail is very poor.. at full size it looks horrible pixellated, and the colours severely washed out. The blacks are also severely crushed.
Sample 3 - Z1 Compact
Here is a shot that should in theory be detailed and natural looking. A guy near a wall in better light, with the camera held perfectly still.
Again, a horrible image... bad detail, visible artifacting, washed out colours.
Sample 4 - Z1 Compact
In addition, using the flash causes severe light pollution on the final image, so much so that the bottom half of the photo I take has a very noticeable purpley bluish haze on it.
Look at the level of bleed entering the scene from the flash below the lens. And look at the dreadful overall image quality... the detail is simply shockingly bad. Like a camera phone from years ago.
Samsung Galaxy S III Comparisons...
And here we have some comparison photos with a Samsung SIII, also taken in a dimply lit pub:
Sample 1 - Samsung Galaxy S III
Look at the difference... detail is preserved, the image appears natural, and colour tones are reasonably natural. It's a great shot.
Sample 2 - Samsung Galaxy S III
Again, here we see that the photo is much cleaner... flash lights up the subjkects as well as can be expected considering the size and power, and the colours and detail are preserved, including in the surrounding environment where the coloured lights at the top are also visible.
Sample 3 . Samsung Galaxy S III
And finally, a close-up portrai-style shot...
Again, not the easiest of conditions for a phont, but overall detail is good, the face is clearly visible, and the photo looks clean and detailed as you could hope for in the circumstances.
WINNER: SAMSUNG GALAXY S III
Conclusion...
Sorry Sony, but this level of imaging is just not acceptable on a premium device with such a high spec sensor in it. I have had better results fron devices that are 2-3 years old. Oh yes, and that's including the video camera mode which has no 24p or 60p options... come on Sony, there is a Snapdragon 800 SOC in this phone, use it.
 I really hope you are going to take a serious look at this and fix it.

Wow thanks guys... it seems a LOT of people have noticed this issue. I also saw one guy with exactly the same problem as me with the flash http://www.android-hilfe.de/7156334-post40.html
The question is: how on earth did none of the Sony designers see this issue? It seems to me that someone must have seen it, but too late in the design process, so they just kept it like this and are going to pretend ignorance.
I just did the same test as inside-handy.de where I cover the flash completely and then take a picture, and the light bleeds very badly into the lens, so I guess my phone is badly affected.
I do not expect such a badly designed camera and flash system on such a premium device, and we cannot be expected to live with such a fatal flaw in a phone which is marketed as a pure camera phone. 
EDIT - It seems the press are now aware and will be following this up... hopefully Sony will make a response soon when they see the overwhelming evidence http://www.inside-handy.de/news/30330-led-erzeugt-farbiges-leuchten-auf-bildern-sony-xperia-z1-compa...

Similar Messages

  • Why is the camera so poor?

    I am really disappointed with the poor quality of photo's - yes I know all about the wise crack comments about the iPad not being a camera BUT the adverts would lead you to believe the camera is wonderful and it most definitely is not.

    No arguement.  Its fine for facetime, and facebook, and casual photos, but not really good for serious photos.  Light is quality in the digital world, and you will find that outdoor daylight pictures aren't bad, but they are certainly not good.
    If you are a serious photo person, use your existing camera, and import the photos.
    Safe bet that the next pad, whenever it comes, will have an upgraded camera.  I upgraded from a pad 1 to a pad 2, and a mediocre camera was a huge improvement from no camera, but there is another step ahead.

  • Why is the camera such poor quality to take still pictures.

    I have been trying other a
    Apps to see if the quality of the still shots can get better.
    No such luck. It just looks like a grainy picture.
    Is there anything that can make this take good still pictures?
    Especially for the price you pay for one of these things?

    Yes I must admit the camera on the Iphone is very good.
    Yes the Ipad is well bait big to hold in the palm of your hand so to speak.
    But it would be nice to be able to take a quick snap if a picture becomes apparent.
    It would have been nice to have the Iphone camera in the Ipad2.
    Oh well just have to be disappointed about this feature.
    Question to any one. Is there an app that allows you to take a picture from a movie you made on the Ipad2 at all?
    As the camera picture is clear enough for me when I pause it.
    Thanks

  • Why is the camera icon grayed out in the text message screen so that I cannot text a picture on my iPhone 5?

    Why is the camera icon grayed out in the text message screen so that I cannot text a picture on my iPhone 5? I have an unlocked TMobile phone. My husband has the same phone, plan, and set up; his picture messages work fine.

    Check this it maybe the problem
    Settings > Messages > MMS Messaging > is it on?
    Hope that helps

  • Why is the camera icon now next to my lock button

    Why is the camera icon now next to my lock button on my iphone?

    I was just looking for an answer to this, thinking the new update was buggy since clicking the camera icon didn't work anymore.  I didn't see the SLIDE option.  Thanks!  

  • Why is the camera so blurry

    ever since i downloaded the new os x the camera has been very blurry

    Nang123 wrote: why is the camera so blurry
    Because something is wrong.  You need to troubleshoot to find what to fix,
    If you have checked that the camera lens cover is not smudged, restart Mac and check again.
    If the problem continues, check more than one other Apple camera app in more than one  user account per http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2090.
    If the problem is exactly the same in all apps and user accounts, reinstall OS X 10.9
    Message was edited by: EZ Jim
    Mac OSX 10.9

  • Why does the camera shutter stay closed?

    Why does the camera shutter stay stuck?  The camera won't operate.  I've rebooted several times, I've changed settings several times, I've held by finger over each camera as demostrated on a youtube video.  Nothing has corrected the problem.

    That happens sometimes.  See this ongoing discussion.  An appointment at the Genous Bar of an Apple store is probably in order:
    Camera shutter issue: Apple Support Communities

  • Why is the search so poor?

    Why is the search so poor? The first page had nothing useful when I typed:
    owner change in finder
    Google would do much better.
    Xserve   Other OS  

    No - I just expected it to be as good as most other searches, ie first return full hits and then partial hits as per Google and many others. I don't want to restrict it to a phrase but I expect the phrase hits to come first followed by hits for all words and then hits for less words - it is 5 years out of date.

  • Why does the Utilities Folder not Show up within the Applications folder on my Dock

    Why does the Utilities Folder not Show up within the Applications folder on my Dock, but is showing within the finder view? Thanks!
    Lynn Kenneth Pecknold

    Thanks, I have reminders on my iphone, which has all the icloud stuff

  • Why is the Camera app so slow when switching modes?

    When I switch modes between still-photo and video (or back) in the Camera application, there is a 2-3 second pause while the "iris" appears and disappears. Ok, that's not very long, but when you are in a rush to capture "that moment" it can be all the difference between "great" and "rats!".
    I get that an app can take a few seconds to load, but switching camera modes should be nearly instantaneous, shouldnt it? Do other people see the same delay, or is it just me? Are there any known tweaks to improve this delay?
    On an iPhone 4 with latest iOS.
    --Tim

    I don't know why Apple doesn't fix this problem or even acknowledge it. I have had this problem since 1.1.2. Upgrading through 1.1.3, 1.1.4 and on the 2.1 has not helped. My SMS loading time varies between 3 and 10 seconds. I maintain all my SMS messages deleted (which I should not have to do). Due to lack of support from Apple I purchased a Nokia phone for my son. At least basic phone features work like they should.

  • Why is the Camera's aspect ratio different between Still to Video

    Can you tell me why the Camera's aspect ratio is different when taking Stills versus the Video?
    I would like to capture the stills in 16x9 as the video does. Why is this not something that could be chosen in options?
    Thanks

    Still looking for an answer as to why the Still pics are 4x3 and the video 16x9. 
    I would like to take pics in 16x9, like the video. Is this an option that's coming in the next iOS, does anybody know

  • Why has the camera roll be deleted in iOS 8?

    The complete overview on all photos was quite good until iOS 7. now in iOS 8 it is much more uncomfortable to scroll through all photos. Apple, please bring back the camera roll like it has been since the first iPhone.

    One of the worst changes Apple has ever done -- Jobs would never have allowed it.
    The lack of a camera roll is a headache. I don't want photos that I've deliberately left on my camera roll for any number of reasons mixed in with the thousands of other photos from my computer and the Cloud. I keep all of these photos separate and in their respective places -- camera, Cloud, computer -- for a reason. I shouldn't have to browse through thousands of cloud and computer photos mixed in with camera roll-only photos to find a camera roll photo that's not "recently added". Why is Apple micromanaging where we keep our photos and thus making it more difficult for us to access photos when and where we want? Terrible design and very very bad end user experience.

  • Why is the camera on L540 black & white in Windows 8.1?

    When I use the Windows 8.1 Camera app, I get a black and white picture. There's no setting where I can select colour or black/white. If I go to the control panel and select "View scanners and cameras", the integrated camera is not listed there at all.
    In the Device Manager, the camera is listed as Integrated Camera and has device status "Working properly". The driver provider is Vimicro and the driver version is 5.13.514.3.
    How can I get the camera working properly as a colour camera?

    Recieved my machine today to discover that I am having the same issue! I hope this is malfunctioning software. 

  • Why is the camera roll album gone iOS 8

    Updated to iOS 8 and the camera roll album is now gone, and all you have is recently added photos and an album for deleted photos which I think completely defeats the purpose of deleting photos. To see the rest of your photos, you have to go to memories or collections or something like that and have to scroll through  extremely messy date stamped albums then click on them and it takes you to a map that takes forever to load then you have to zoom in to find the picture you want. This is probably the dumbest thing I have ever seen come from Apple so far. Bring back the old camera roll album and don't force us to use photo stream or iCloud sharing photos or whatever it may be. I want the ability to simply see all of my pictures in one place and scroll through them and if I want them on my Mac I will plug up my phone and sync it. Until then, I'm going to try to go back to ios7. Also after the update my not abused iPhone 5 with 32gig memory is much slower, the apps fade in and out much less smoothly, added more apps from apple that I don't want nor can I delete, and made it ignorantly hard to go through your photos. Very disappointed

    agreed, I will not buy the new iPhone if this is how the photos and camera are going to be handled. You would think one of the highest grossing and most intelligent electronics company would have seen how terrible of an idea this was during their many months of development. Hopefully this will be seen along with others who feel the same and apple can give us the camera roll album back, thats seriously all I want in my pictures. I don't want to know when I took it, or where, or have pictures organized by these criterion, or several albums to hold other useless stuff and copies, we just need the camera roll.

  • Why is the camera stuck

    when I go on the camera, it is stuck I am not able to take pictures :(

    Try closing the Camera app:
    1. Double-click the Home button to reveal the Task Bar
    2. Hold down the Camera app for a second or two until you see the minus sign
    3. Tap the minus sign to close app
    4. Tap area above Task Bar to return to Home screen
    If the above doesn't solve the problem, do a reset:
    Hold the Sleep and Home button down for about 10 seconds until you see the Apple logo. Ignore the red slider

Maybe you are looking for

  • Mov file in Keynote doesn't work in 4.0

    I've been a presenting a Keynote file that includes many imbedded animations (mov or mpeg files) I did not create. I just upgraded to Keynote 4, and now one of the slides has stopped working. This shows Lake Chad slowly drying up (from Gore's present

  • No "Administration" Option in the BPM Worklist App

    I'm working on an environment w/ the BPM Worklist App, and I notice there is no "Administration" option for the weblogic user (which is apparently the admin) when I login to the app.  Assuming he doesn't have the appropriate credentials - any idea wh

  • Scrollbar does not work in PDF documents

    When FF opens an PDF document the scrollbar does not work. If it is a one page document I can use Page up/Page down to toggle between top and bottom of page. If it is a multiple page document I can use PageUp/Page down and the arrow keys.

  • Installation DVD for ECC 5.0

    Hi Experts, I downloaded the DVDs from SAPnet and I am using as a Master DVD the one with the Number:51033746_15. During the installation I choose: My SAP 2004 and UniCode. But the DVD seems to be wrong. Could you please let me know the correct DVDs

  • [SOLVED] troubleshooting midnight commander

    Hello, I am trying to have .doc files opened in word (through wine) when I hit ENTER on the file in midnight commander (mc). However, when I hit ENTER, the screen briefly flashes, then nothing happens. Somewhere I read that if you hit M-! then you ca