Yet another Logic Vs.Pro Tools question. Please help!!

Hi guys! I just arrive to the world of mac a few days ago, and I couldn't be happier. Now it's time to purchase new audio gear, and I am torn between Logic Studio/Apogee interface, or the Digi 003. I've been a Sonar user for the past couple of years, and before that I was on Cubase.
I love Sonar, but I'm sick of PC's(hence the switch). I need something with good compositional/midi tools, but I also need powerful audio editing. One thing I love about Sonar is the ability to use non-destructive editing in the arrange window. Can the new logic do this? Currently I am leaning towards logic...but I still haven't made a decision. I definitely need drum programming ability, and I'm not sure if Pro Tools le even has a drum map? Any and all advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

servo2112 wrote:
I need something with good compositional/midi tools, but I also need powerful audio editing...non-destructive editing in the arrange window... I definitely need drum programming ability..
Taking just the key points above, Logic will definitely fit the bill better. Logic seems to be a better compositional tool, although PT can also be used for that. Both do SOME non-destructive editing in the arrange windows. Protools has no drum editor at all.
However, PT is still better at audio editing.
It would depend on how much audio editing you plan on doing vs midi/composition.
The above poster is certainly in the ballpark about the add-ons you have to buy with PT just to equal the tools that come with Logic. I would say you'll probably have to spend at least another $1000 on plugin instruments and utility tools (CD burning/mastering) above the cost of PTLE software. Assume you will need at least the Music Production Toolkit in addition to PTLE. You will also want Toast Titanium to burn CDs unless you get Logic w/Waveburner.
The 003 will definitely not sound as good as the Apogee.
I've used PTLE since 1999 and it's great for recording and editing audio, but nothing special for writing and nothing special for midi.

Similar Messages

  • My iPhone will not turn on after a yet another blue screen of death. Please help!

    As mentioned above, my phone will not turn on after a yet another blue screen of death. All of a sudden it turned off, and it wouldn't turn on for quite some time, even after I plugged it in the charger. It wasn't long after the screen turned on, but it only displayed a bright black. I decided to turn it on and off a few times. Nothing worked.
    I have also tried to call the phone from another one. It was as if the phone was simply off.

    Hello ZarinaUrum,
    The article linked below details a number of troubleshooting steps that can help restore functionality to your iPhone.
    iOS: Not responding or does not turn on
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/TS3281
    Cheers,
    Allen

  • DVD Studio Pro 4 Question Please Help

    Hello, i have one problem with DVD Studio Pro 4 version 4.0.2. Now the first time i go to save it lets me, sometimes when i go to save the secound or third time it will say error unable to save untitled. Can someone please tell me why it is unable to save sometimes,
    Thanks in advance.

    Hi,
    I am having the same problem. G5 quad 4GB of memory and plenty of disk free space. DVD Studio Pro 4.0.3. Compressor is also up-to-date.
    I can save the project once, but thereafter if I try to save the project I get the message "The document xxx.dspproj could not be saved."
    Any help would be appreciated.
    SyB

  • Logic and Pro Tools

    Hello all. I"ve got a few questions concerning Logic and Pro Tools. First, can you trigger Logic's sounds in Pro tools? ie Logic as the "slave" and Pro Tools as the "master" And can you record vocals into Logic using an MBox 2 or is there some other interface I need? If so, what would you suggest?
    Thanks in advance for your time

    You can use an Mbox2 with logic. If you already have pro tools, or plan on having it in addition to logic, thats what I would do, as both programs can use the mbox2. Although, they can't both use it at the same time. Which leads to this.
    It is possible to have pro tools running using the mbox2 while logic is running, using your computers soundcard. I have done this, but I have found no real way to synch them. I've been looking at ways of syncing Logic and Pro Tools together on the same computer, and it seems to be not really doable, although I believe people have done it. A lot of people have one computer for Logic and one for Pro Tools and sync them together with time code, which works really well.
    I'm really pretty new to logic, so I'm sure I dont have the best answers,
    Good Luck!

  • Can i use my snowball usb mic with Logic or Pro Tools???

    Can i use my snowball usb mic with Logic or Pro Tools???

    Hi there,
    Did you find out anything more in regard to this?
    I have been using Pro Tools 8 with the MBox 2 connected to my iMac operating Leopard. It worked a treat for nearly four years.
    However the hardrive has just been replaced on the iMac which now has Snowleopard.  I don't want to have to update to Lion and then fork out £500 for Pro Tools 10. 
    I would be content to get Logic Pro 9 if I can attach the MBox 2 to it.
    Your advice would be appreciated
    PXC

  • Have the makers of Logic or Pro Tools given any thought to the Df/deaf producers wishing to use these programs?

    Have the creators of Logic or Pro tools given any consideration to the Df/deaf musicians wishing to produce with these programs? They just rely on visual arrangement of sonic information that must be 'listened' to to throughout composition. There must be away of improving this inaccessibility.

    Have the creators of Logic or Pro tools given any consideration to the Df/deaf musicians wishing to produce with these programs? They just rely on visual arrangement of sonic information that must be 'listened' to to throughout composition. There must be away of improving this inaccessibility.

  • I've installed windows 7 with the help of bootcamp on my macbook pro 2011. Please help me how to install mac drivers for windows7 64 bit???

    I've installed windows 7 with the help of bootcamp on my macbook pro 2011.
    Please help me how to install mac drivers for windows7 64 bit???

    You either download drivers from within Boot Camp Assistant and save to USB FAT disk, or you insert and use 10.6.x OS X DVD when in Windows and install and run the SETUP from there.
    General Help:
    Boot Camp 4.0, OS X Lion: Frequently asked question
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4818
    http://manuals.info.apple.com/en_US/boot_camp_install-setup_10.7.pdf
    create a Windows support software (drivers) CD or USB storage media
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4407
    Installation Guide   Instructions for all features and settings.
    Boot Camp 4.0 FAQ   Get answers to commonly asked Boot Camp questions.
    Windows 7 FAQ   Answers to commonly asked Windows 7 questions.
    - support articles and tips, how to.
    http://www.apple.com/support/bootcamp/
    Macs that work with 64-bit editions of Microsoft Windows Vista and Windows 7
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1846
    Step 4: Install the Boot Camp Drivers for Windows
    After installing Windows, install Mac-specific drivers and other software for Windows using your Mac OS X installation disc.  The Mac OS X disc installs drivers to support Mac components, including AirPort,built-in iSight camera, the Apple Remote, the trackpad on a portable Mac, and thefunction keys on an Apple keyboard. 
    The Mac OS X disc also installs the Boot Camp control panel for Windows and theApple Boot Camp system tray item.
    To install the Boot Camp drivers:
    1 Eject the Windows installation disc.
    2 Insert the Mac OS X disc.  If the installer doesn’t start automatically, browse the disc using Windows Explorerand double-click the setup.exe file in the Boot Camp directory.
    3 Follow the onscreen instructions.
    If a message appears that says the software you’re installing has not passed Windows  Logo testing, click Continue Anyway.
    Windows that appear only briefly during the installation don’t require your input.
    If nothing appears to be happening, there may be a hidden window that you mustrespond to. Check the taskbar and look behind open windows.
    Important: Do not click the Cancel button in any of the installer dialogs.
    4 After your computer restarts, follow the instructions in the Found New Hardware  Wizard to update your software drivers (Windows XP only).
    5 Follow the instructions for any other wizards that appear.
    6 Check for updated Boot Camp drivers by using Apple Software Update or going to www.apple.com/support/bootcamp.
      If You Have Problems Installing the Device Drivers 
    If it appears that the Boot Camp drivers weren’t successfully installed, try repairing them.
    To repair Boot Camp drivers:
    1 Start up your computer in Windows.
    2 Insert your Mac OS X installation disc.
    3 If the installer doesn’t start automatically, browse the disc using Windows Explorerand double-click the setup.exe file in the Boot Camp directory.
    4 Click Repair and follow the onscreen instructions.
    If a message appears that says the software you’re installing has not passed Windows  Logo testing, click Continue Anyway. 
    If you need to reinstall specific drivers, you can install one driver at a time. For example,if your built-in iSight camera isn’t working, you can reinstall just the iSight driver.
    Individual drivers are in the Drivers folder on the Mac OS X installation disc.

  • HT1420 i have less than 5 authorised computers. yet cannot authorise my new iMAC27. Please help..

    i have less than 5 authorised computers. yet cannot authorise my new iMAC27. Please help..

    Hello Morfaly,
    Thanks for the question. The following article may provide a solution to your issue:
    iTunes: Missing folder or incorrect permissions may prevent authorization
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1277
    Thanks,
    Matt M.

  • I do forgot my Apple ID security question, please help me how to rescue email address or how to reset Apple ID security questions?

    I do forgot my Apple ID security question, please help me how to rescue email address or how to reset Apple ID security questions?

    From another post:
    On your browser, whether Safari, Google Chrome or otherwise, navigate tohttps://appleid.apple.com.
    Once here click Manage your Apple ID button and sign into your iCloud account. Here, on the left side select Password and Security and this will list options on the right side. You should be able to see an option to reset your security questions.
    Note other links in realtion to rescue email address:http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5312
    If you cannot see or reset your security question, or even obtaining an error, then you would have to contact Apple directly: http://support.apple.com/kb/HE57. Here you would explain the issue, transfer you to an Account Security Agent who will be able to veritfy your identity and assist you in the resetting of you security questions.

  • Hey. i just restored my iphone and now it says your apple id is disabled then i forgot everything about my email and security questions please help me enable my apple id

    hey. i just restored my iphone and now it says your apple id is disabled then i forgot everything about my email and security questions please help me enable my apple id
    i dont think there is another way to unlock my apple but i need to

    Hello there, Th3FoX98.
    The following Knowledge Base article is a great resource for what to do if you've forgotten the answers to your Apple ID security questions:
    If you forgot the answers to your Apple ID security questions
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT6170
    Thanks for reaching out to Apple Support Communities.
    Cheers,
    Pedro.

  • My iphone 5 doesn't sync with itunes on my pc. it says this computer has  previously been synced to another io6 device or iphone? please help what to do?

    My iphone 5 doesn't sync with itunes on my pc. it says this computer has  previously been synced to another io6 device or iphone? please help what to do?

    The error message you're seeing is likely the other way around -- i.e. something like "This iPhone has previously been synced with a different computer".   There's no problem syncing multiple iOS devices to the same computer.
    However, the reverse is not true for the iPhone --  you cannot connect an iPhone to another computer without it being erased, even if you manually manage music and video.  So, it sounds like you've been syncing your iPhone to a different computer?
    Also, 5.1 (not 5.0.1) is the latest iOS.

  • HT3887 my bluetooth says 'Not Available' how do i get it to work again. I have restarted the computer several times and have replaced the batteries in both the keyboard and mouse and yet it still is not working! please help

    my bluetooth says 'Not Available' how do i get it to work again. I have restarted the computer several times and have replaced the batteries in both the keyboard and mouse and yet it still is not working! please help

    I have had the same problem. It was cured by turning computer off and/or restarting it. I am not sure  if once was enough. I think shutting down must cut out whatever it is that blocks bluetooth. Good luck

  • HT2968 I can not update several of my apps that i have purchased a while back in my Apps Store on my MacPro. Because it keeps using my old @me account for iTunes and i don't remember the password or security question, Please help?

    I can not update several of my apps that i have purchased a while back in my Apps Store on my MacPro. Because it keeps using my old @me account for iTunes and i don't remember the password or security question, Please help?

    Hi AlphaCentori,
    If you are having issues accessing the Apple ID that was used to originally purchase those apps, you may find the following article helpful:
    Apple Support: Rescue email address and how to reset Apple ID security questions
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht5312
    Regards,
    - Brenden

  • I want to change my apple id password but I forgot the security questions please help me some using my icloud I'd

    I want to change my apple id password but I forgot the security questions please help me some using my icloud I'd and if confirmation is must so please phone number is mine please send a code please help me my apple

    Welcome to the Apple community.
    If you are unable to remember your password, security questions, don’t have access to your rescue address or are unable to reset your password for whatever reason, your only option is to contact AppleCare, upon speaking to an operator you should explain that your problem is related to your Apple ID, this way you will not be charged for assistance, even if you don’t have an AppleCare plan.
    The operator will take you through some steps you may have already tried, however they need to be sure they have exhausted all usual approaches before trying to reset your account, so you should try to be helpful and show patience with the procedure.
    The operator will need to verify they are speaking to the account holder and may ask you some questions that only the account holder could know, and you will need to answer them if the process is to proceed.
    Once the operator has verified your identity they will send a message through to your device which contains an alpha numeric code, which you will need to read back to them.
    Once this has been completed they will send an email to your iCloud email address after a period of 24 hours, so you should check that mail is enabled in your devices iCloud settings.
    Upon receipt of the email, use the reset link provided to reset your password, after which you should be able to make the adjustments to iCloud that you wish to do.

  • My apple id have been blocked an i do not remember the identity or security question please help what can i do?

    my apple id have been blocked an i do not remember the identity or security question please help what can i do?

    If your account is disabled you might be able to re-enable it via this page : http://appleid.apple.com, then 'reset your password'
    You might then need to log out of your account on your iPhone and iPad by tapping on your id in Settings > iTunes & App Storeand then log back in so as to 'refresh' the account on it.
    For your security questions, if you have a rescue email address (which is not the same thing as an alternate email address) on your account then the steps half-way down this page will give you a reset link on your account : http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5312
    If you don't have a rescue email address then you will need to contact Support in your country to get the questions reset.
    Contacting Apple about account security : http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5699 (you can also try this link if you can't get your account enabled via the above)
    When they've been reset (and if you don't already have a rescue email address) you can then use the steps half-way down the HT5312 link above to add a rescue email address for potential future use

Maybe you are looking for