1,000 Photos Disappear, 18 months of Backups don't help

After updating to iLife '09 (8.02) from '08 and all its predecessors, all my photos since February 2008 have completely disappeared. They are completely gone.
I've:
1. Rebuilt the library from iPhoto
2. Used iPhoto Library Manager to rebuild the library
3. Used Time Machine to restore the library to various dates (pre-installation of iPhoto '09).
4. Used iPhoto '08 (version 7.1.5) to view restored files from Time Machine.
No luck at all. Two interesting items, though:
1. When viewing the library in v8.02 as the library exists today, there are 169 photos. Note that there should be about 1,500. When I use iPhoto's "Browse Backups" command to "page through" the Time Machine backup file on the library, the photo count is 169 for every single backup going back 18 months. (In other words, I believe that the TM file is either corrupted going backwards or is only a copy of today repeated backwards. Other theories welcome.)
2. When I use v7.1.5 and open a February 2009 TM backup library, then it (says it) has 24 photos vs. 169 in 8.0.2. Just as in the other case, when I page back through history into earlier times, the number of photos remains at 24.
The library file is both large, at 3.42 gig for 169/24 amateur point-and-shoot Canon Sure Shots and incredibly stable, according to iPhoto is has been at the same size back a year or more.
Needless to say, but I will anyway, I'd very much like to find those photos of the kids.
A.) Is there some other program that will look into an iPhoto library to tell or show me what's in it?
B.) Any suggestions or theories (suggestions much preferred!) on how to proceed?
All this on MacBook Pro Core Duo running 10.5.7. Permissions cleaned fairly frequently; Cocktail every couple of weeks.
Thanks.

Time Machine is a back up tool not an archiving one.
At some point these photos were lost - lets say that happened on day 1. As TM works it updates the back up until the back up disk is full. Lets say that happens at day 30.
Then at day 30, anything from Day 1 that is not still on your Mac is dumped to make room for stuff from day 31.
So, TM does not back up things for ever, just for as long as they are on your Mac + 30 days in this example.
An archiving tool would keep them for ever.
As to how this might have occurred?
One possible way is that, at some point as second Library was created, and this then was used to overwrite the older library. This would account for the existing library and the missing photos. How this might happen without human intervention, I don't know. Perhaps a misconfigured back up application at some point? But I'm just guessing.
At the risk of pressing on a sore point it demonstrates the importance of testing back ups too.
FWIW my back up procedure uses two different apps, three Hard Disks, and four locations.
Regards
TD

Similar Messages

  • Hard drive crashed, catalog is ok (other drive).  I've renamed/taged/noted 20 000 photos in that month! Do I have to start over?

    I've done so much work in that last month. Can I use my "up to date" catalog to make Lightroom "reorganize" my files?
    If not I will have to use my old catalog and my old files directory...to start over!
    Thanks!!

    Hi! Nope, Catalog is up to date. I've lost all photos since my reorganisation/renaming/tagging i've done in lightroom. My backup of those files is one month old.
    So I still have my "old" files and old catalog is also availlable so I could start over again but i'ts a lot of time/work...But can I use my new Catalog to recover?

  • 5,000 photos there, just no thumbnails...Any HELP appreciated!!

    Hello. I recently installed iphoto 09 from ilife. When I opened it, all of my photos were grey square thumbnails. I might have done something wrong in the installation, however, if I click on a grey square, the photo does come up. It is like the thumbnails got lost somewhere. Any help would be appreciated and thank you so much for your time.

    Hello Mr. Devlin I was hoping you would take my iphoto challenge on. Thank you.. I have started the process you suggested. When the dialogue box opened, (after I copied the "iphoto recovered library"file to my external hard drive) I selected the first option, which was rebuild "the small thumbnails" and when it was through there was no change, no new thumbnails to replace the greyed squares. Closed iphoto and called up the dialogue box again and selected the 2nd option, rebuild all the thumbnails. I will keep you posted if it is successful or if not. Again, thank you for your time. Melody

  • ITunes showing I have photos on my iPad and I don't-help me please!

    HI, need a bit of help.
    My iTunes shows in the summary of what data I've consumed where on my iPad Air 2 that I have got 362 photos which is using 6.07MB.
    I've recently cleared my iPad of all it's photos so why it's still saying I've got any photos on there at all I am unsure about.
    Is there anything I could do to make my iPad and iTunes see I don't have 6GB of photos!!
    Thanks
    Lauren

    Have you deleted them from the recently deleted folder too.

  • I have around 1,000 photos on my old phone and I want to put them on my new phone without using a backup or iTunes, which would be the easiest way?

    I have around 1,000 photos on my old phone and I want to put them on my new phone without using a backup or iTunes, which would be the easiest way?

    I was looking for something on the net, and i run into this post. Am not sure if you have found a soulution or not, anyways, if not here are some programs that i love and they show you every thing in your iPhone:
    iFunBox, iBackupBot and DiskAid
    am sure they will help you find what you want and then you can just copy them to your computer.
    if you use Mac, iPhoto will import everything for you.

  • Iphoto 8.1.2 crashed while deleting  photos (7,000) from my iphone and the photos disappeared from iphone and iphoto

    First i imported my photos to iphoto 8.1.2 when it finished, asked me if i want to "delete them from the camara"  i clicked yes and crashed while deleting  photos (7,000) from my iphone and the photos disappeared from iphone and iphoto

    No early version of iPhoto can open a Library from a later version.
    You can try revert the Library with iPhoto Library Manager
    http://www.fatcatsoftware.com/iplm/Help/downgrading%20a%20library%20to%20an%20ea rlier%20version%20of%20iphoto.html

  • I have 21,000  photos stored in iphoto. I have a WD 1.5TB backup external hard drive.  What is the best way to erase about half of my photos on my internal hard drive?

    I have 21,000  photos stored in iphoto. I have a WD 1.5TB backup external hard drive.  What is the best way to erase about half of my photos on my internal hard drive?

    Here's one way to do what you want:
    Make sure the drive is formatted Mac OS Extended (Journaled)
    1. Quit iPhoto
    2. Copy the iPhoto Library from your Pictures Folder to the External Disk.
    Now you have two full versions of the Library.
    3. On the Internal library, trash the Events you don't want there
    Now you have a full copy of the Library on the External and a smaller subset on the Internal
    Some Notes:
    As a general rule: when deleting photos do them in batches of about 100 at a time. iPhoto can baulk at trashing large numbers at one go.
    You can choose which Library to open: Hold down the option (or alt) key key and launch iPhoto. From the resulting menu select 'Choose Library'
    You can keep the Library on the external updated with new imports using iPhoto Library Manager

  • After iPhoto quit unexpectedly, the last 5 months of photos disappeared from my library. Please help!

    After iPhoto quit unexpectedly, the last 5 months of photos disappeared from my library. Please help! I can't find them anywhere.

    You're using iPhoto 6?
    Try these in order - from best option on down...
    1. Do you have an up-to-date back up? If so, try copy the library6.iphoto file from the back up to the iPhoto Library allowing it to overwrite the damaged file.
    2. Download <a href="http://www.fatcatsoftware.com/iplm/"><b><u>iPhoto Library Manager</b></u></a> and use its rebuild function. This will create a new library based on data in the albumdata.xml file. Not everything will be brought over - no slideshows, books or calendars, for instance - but it should get all your albums and keywords back.
    Because this process creates an entirely new library and leaves your old one untouched, it is non-destructive, and if you're not happy with the results you can simply return to your old one.
    3. If neither of these work then you'll need to create and populate a new library.
    To create and populate a new *iPhoto 6* library:
    Note this will give you a working library with the same Rolls and pictures as before, however, you will lose your albums, keywords, modified versions, books, calendars etc.
    Move the iPhoto Library to the desktop
    Launch iPhoto. It will ask if you wish to create a new Library. Say Yes.
    Go into the iPhoto Library on your desktop and find the Originals folder. From the Originals folder drag the individual Roll Folders to the iPhoto Window and it will recreate them in the new library.
    When you're sure all is well you can delete the iPhoto Library on your desktop.
    In the future, in addition to your usual back up routine, you might like to make a copy of the library6.iPhoto file whenever you have made changes to the library as protection against database corruption.

  • Merging large camera rolls in photo stream for iCloud merge/backup/share

    I've got some pretty large camera rolls on my iPhone, never having realized I wasn't "synching" them to my iPad. Well, I looked at them and saw some large ones, as well as 1.000 photos in my iPhone my photo stream.  I'd like iCloud to keep them sync he'd between the two, but can I do that? If I can, how do I take all the camera rolls and all those photos and get them into the my photo stream? There didn't seem to be a way to copy them, that I could see on my iPhone.
    is it because the my photo stream size limit is 1,000?
    and if not! how do I mass copy all those pics into the my photo stream?
    and once I synch those, had do I synch them with the same iCloud account on my MacBook? That also seems like a problem, although Id ultimately like them there, because the faces, events, etc stuff in iPhoto seems really well done, plus, I've got the largest disk by far in my MacBook compared to the RAM in my iPhone & iPad.
    any help would be really appreciated!
    Thanks!

    Hi Mike,
    Something else you may want to set up. If you have the same iCloud account set up on the Mac and you have Photo Stream turned on in iCloud, then in iPhoto, under Preferences>Photo Stream, you can turn on the option to automatically import your Photo Stream into iPhoto. That way, you have a backup of your Photo Stream that is saved in iPhoto Events every Month:
    I have mine set up to do this, and I find it to be a great backup to my regular imports. I leave my Photo Stream imports out there as they are generated in Events (June 2013 Photo Stream, July 2013 Photo Stream, etc.). I also then import my Camera Roll every month or so, and import it into an Album that I label as desired. Photo Stream, of course, only has photos, no videos, so importing your Camera Roll is critical if you take videos.
    Post back after you have set things up if you have any questions!
    Cheers,
    GB

  • Need to move 10,000 photos

    I am about to install a new SSD drive that will become my new C: drive, i am using PSE 11, (I have used various other version of PSE and have updated them through the years) and am planning to install  the program on the new SSD drive. I have about 10,000 photos in one catalog. I have them filed by year and then within each year i have them filed in folders by by month or event. Due to space limitations of the new SSD drive I need to move them to a different internal hard drive( I do have an external drive if that is easier). How do i go about doing this without losing the connections i have made in my one catalog to these 10,000 photos?
    Thanks for your help.

    john885 wrote:
    Michael,
    I have completed the backup of PSE 11 catalog into my external drive, using the backup catalog command in PSE. I have backed up my pictures though windows and the backup contains the same file structure on my external drive as is does on my existing (soon to be my former) C drive. I have just gone through a practice run (not doing the actual restore) to see how it is done. I am still thinking that since the actual pictures (only the thumbnails have been backed up with the catalog backup) have not been backed up through PSE 11 that when this process is actually completed all the pictures will go through a reconnect process.
    John,
    I see you have done:
    1 - a backup through PSE to the external drive. You can check that a folder has been created there with the name you choose for the backup. If you can see a 'catalog.buc' and a 'backup.tly' file in it, that means the backup is ok.
    2 - a Windows copy (backup) of your picture file tree on the external drive. That's another kind of backup. It does not contain a copy of the catalog (the database)
    That's very good, having two backups is a good thing!
    Your goal is to restore your picture files to the internal F: drive when you are ready, that is when the SSD is installed with the PSE software. You have the choice to also store your catalog (database) folder on the SSD or on drive F. Storing it on the SSD would not bring noticeable increase in speed, so I suppose you'll store it on the F: drive.
    You'll have to choose if you want to use ;
    - the PSE restore function (restores the files and the catalog with automatically reconnected files)
    - or the Windows folder tree copy followed by a PSE semi-automatic reconnection.
    Both solutions are roughly equivalent in time, the PSE solution is simpler, the Windows solution requires that you know how to find and copy the catalog (database) folder and that you know how to tell PSE to reconnect missing files. It's up to you to choose : if you master the second solution, that will be helpful if you need to reconnect files in other circumstances. With PSE11, reconnecting a whole folder tree is automatic and really quick if you choose the Windows solution, it is automatic in the PSE restore solution.
    If you choose the Windows solution, you'll have to locate your catalog folder and copy it. You can copy it directly to your F: drive. Let's say your new pictures folder path is  F:My Photos,  the folder copy of the catalog could be F:My Photos catalog. The folder catalog can be found with the help menu, option system info.
    I will have on my new SSD a folder from the installation of Windows 7 called My Pictures. Since i no longer want pictures to go to that folder, i am wondering if there is a way to have any new pictures automatically directed to the folder on my new F drive ?
    Are you using the photo downloader ? If so, check the preferences in the edit menu. You can define a default location for the pictures you upload from your camera card to your computer, and another one for the default location for your scans.
    Side note and just a question to Windows experts in this forum : I thought that you could move the default 'My Pictures' folder to another drive, am I wrong ?

  • Switching libraries / photos disappeared

    I could not find my exact situation in the forums, though several closely resembled it:
    1. Normally I keep all my photos on a library in my external HD.
    2. Over the summer, I downloaded several hundred directly onto my macbook HD, not having access to the external HD.
    3. This evening, I looked at the localdrive summer photos in iPhoto...then connected to my external HD and restarted iphoto holding down the 'option' button, and selected the external HD iphoto library.
    4. I planned to import the local-drive summer photos into the primary external HD library but couldn't find the local-drive iphoto library in my Finder's Picture folder.
    5. Desperate search ensues...
    6. I don't know where those summer photos were stored, exactly. I've followed several threads extensively (creating smart folders - didn't work for me, etc) but my situation is slightly different due to my having broken protocol on the following:
    a. At some point before learning the "option" key method to choose libraries, in order to trick iphoto into discovering my external drive iphoto library, I created a folder called "BackupPhotos" in my Pictures folder. Into "BackupPhotos", I placed the iPhotoLibrary folder. This confused iphoto enough to ask for the location of the iphoto library, and I directed it to my external drive.
    7. I'm concerned because in looking through my BackupPhotos > iPhotoLibrary folder, I see no evidence of any 2007 photos...I can see that its a snapshot of my iphoto library from back in 2006 when I backed it up last, but there's no indication of newer photos there. There is, however, quite a bit of stuff in there that appears non-human-readable to me.
    Your help appreciated...
    --mwbrown2007

    TD,
    I tried again. I searched using Easyfind and searched using Spotlight for library6.iphoto. Unfortunately, I only succeeded in finding a single library (not 2) -- it was my BACKUP library: basically a snapshot of my photo library from 1 year ago. There was no evidence of any of my CURRENT photos.
    But the roll of CURRENT photos that had been there for the past 2 months disappeared overnight.
    Again:
    1. I was using iphoto with a blank library on my mac. iphoto did not know that my BACKUP library existed elsewhere, because I had not pointed iphoto to it.
    2. I uploaded a set of photos from my camera -- my CURRENT photos.
    3. At this point I believe that I had 2 libraries on my Mac -- 1 with a single roll of uploaded photos, and 1 with my backup library.
    3. I connected to my EXTERNAL library, with the intent of importing my CURRENT photos. Then I realized I didn't know the location of my Current Library.
    4. When, however, I tried to reconnect to my Current Library through iPhoto, I couldn't find it in the Pictures Folder, where I would have expected it to live.
    5. If its any forensic help, I used Picasa Mac Uploader to upload some of those CURRENT photos to Picasa/Google 2 nights ago. Maybe some of the log files in the Mac Uploader reference the root directory of the CURRENT photos location.
    This is a real mystery to me. I would like to hear the truth if it seems obvious to you that I somehow overwrote my current library. Otherwise, I'd really like to find them!
    Thanks,
    Mark

  • I logged out of iCloud and lost over 2,000 photos

    I Logged out of my iCloud account and I logged back in later, but I realized I had lost of 2,000 photos. I have looked on other iCloud devices,but have found nothing. I would try to restore my iPhone to the back up from a couple months ago, but then I would loose all the photos I have taken after that. Please help!

    Logging out of iCloud would have no affect on your Camera Roll. Did you do anything other than logging out of iCloud?
    If you have a recent backup of your device, you can always reset it to Factory Settings, and then restore it using that backup.
    Can you think of anything other than logging out of iCloud that occurred?
    Cheers,
    GB

  • I have over 50,000 photos. Events no longer show up. How do I create a new iPhoto folder like in the old days with iPhoto Manager?

    I have over 50,000 photos in the current iPhoto Library. I need to download 3,000 more from trip to Spain. Can/should I make a new iPhoto Library? How do I do that?

    1) I had the same problem bedeviling me for over a month
    (with the Apple Store people unable to figure out a solution!).
    It turned out that the solution was exceedingly simple and easy:
    http://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/18554/why-isnt-iphoto-11-showing-an-eve nt-present-in-the-library
    I have no idea how it happened, but like Asbjornu, "I had managed to sort the events "manually" (View > Sort Events > Manually) which hid the newly created events in-between my rather large amount of existing events. Sorting by date (View > Sort Events > By Date + Descending) shows my new events first in the list as they should."
    I left out a huge whoop when this (simple) command solved everything.
    2) Yes, you can create another iPhoto library
    http://support.apple.com/kb/PH2505?viewlocale=en_US
    To create a new photo library:
                               Quit iPhoto.                       
                               Hold down the Option key as you open iPhoto.                       
                               In the window that appears, click Create New.                       
                               Type a name and choose a location to store the new photo library.                       
                               Click Save.
    Afterwards, iPhoto will sometimes ask which library you want to open.
    3) As far as the corrupted iPhoto is concerned,
    trash or anything else, try rebuilding iPhoto (but
    only after making a copy of your current iPhoto
    library on an external disk, naturally).
    Once the copy is made, close iPhoto, and
    wait until you won't be using iPhoto or your computer for a long time
    (like before you go to bed).  Close all other apps, or as many as possible,
    and reopen iPhoto while holding down the Option and Command keys
    at the same time.  Keep the buttons down until you get a page with a series
    of half a dozen unmarked boxes or more, mark them ALL, launch rebuild,
    and come back in the morning…

  • My iPhone was stolen last night and I'm trying to recover all my photos from that phone and get them on my mac laptop. The iCloud photo stream only imported 1,000 photos from my stolen phone. How can I retrieve all of my other photos?

    my iPhone was stolen last night and I'm trying to recover all my photos from that phone and get them on my mac laptop. The iCloud photo stream only imported 1,000 photos from my stolen phone. How can I retrieve all of my other photos?

    You have to reset the device to Factory Settings in order to restore it from an iCloud backup. You probably want to back it up as is before you do this.
    To do the reset after you have backed up the current device, go to Settings>Reset>Reset all Content & Settings. This will erase the device. If you are signed onto iCloud with Find My iPhone turned on, go to Settings>iCloud and scroll to the bottom to sign out of iCloud before you do the reset.
    Once you have reset your device, you will set it up like a new phone. When it asks if you want to restore it from an iCloud backup, select the backup you want to restore it from.
    Cheers,
    GB

  • More than 1,000 photos in Photostream, Events as well?

    I made a clean install of Lion and recuperated about 5,000 photos in a regular folder structure. Never opened iPhoto after the clean install.
    Yesterday, I upgraded iPhoto on all devices, including my MBP and opened iPhoto for the first time. I activated Photostream and now I have the advertised 1,000 photos in Photostream but overall, I find now 2,300 photos and 79 events. I did not import anything in iPhoto, did not open iTunes and have never synced iPhone and iPad over iTunes with this machine. How is that possible?
    I had my 5,000 photos still on my iPhone and iPad where I installed yesterday also iPhoto for iOS. Did Photostream recuperate all of those photos? Did it sync them back from my mobile devices?
    Anybody any ideas?

    You're talking about photo stream (up to 1000 photos for up to 30 days).  Photo stream is not a photo storage service, in fact, icloud doesn't provide a photo storage; the only other thing it does is perform backups of the Camera Roll, if you have set that up correctly.  You should be syncing photos to your computer for archiving, don't trust the pics to icloud!
    Aside from storing on your computer, there are other services that provide storage - like Dropbox.
    Read this...  import photos to your computer...
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4083

Maybe you are looking for

  • How I can set the Non-standard option of -Xmxn of jvm

    Hi there, Can any one tell me how I can set the Non-standard option of -Xmxn of jvm (setp by step).Iam using Sun's jvm(jdk1.2.2).Iam facing a error(java.lang .OutOfMemory).I want to set the maximum size of the memory allocation pool.Any help will be

  • Bootcamp and keyboard

    Hi there, I am running bootcamp and when I am starting to install Windows XP I can't actually move into the setup because the keyboard won't work. Is there anyone who found a solution? Thanks.

  • The Internet crime--I need the US authorities contact info

    The Apple moderator may erase this message. I have been experiencing extremely critical and controversial two of the Internet crime issues. The one is from May 2004 (This is not related with Apple machines and its OSs) and the other one is from Decem

  • Remote File Not Deleted

    During any "Put" operation I am usually getting a failure for some or all the files I am trying to upload. When this happens the progress bar zips through, regenerates and then progresses very slowly on the same file. The log records the error " The

  • Simple validation problem

    Hi all, I am new to Jdeveloper and using Jdeveloper 10.1.3 and ADF, created a page/screen based on a table using Jheadstart I have a simple validation to make, when a user enters a code in one of the field, the system should populate the name from a