2 sites with users best setup (Exchange 2013)

Hi,
I am looking to design an Exchange environment and am looking for some help!
The scenerio:
Site A and Site B are in the same domain but different locations, with active users who require email
Each site will have a DC and Exchange 2013, running Windows Server 2012 R2
Sites have very good\stable internet connection
From what I have read online there seems to be a lot of information but I am not sure what setup would be appropriate in my situation. The different setups I think are relevent
Option 1 - Single DAG
Site A
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
1 x Witness Server
Site B
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
The mailboxes will all be in one DAG.
Option 2 - Multiple DAG
Site A - DAG1
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
1 x Witness Server
Site B - DAG1
1 x multi-roled Exchange Server
0 x Active databases per server
6 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
Site A - DAG2
1 x multi-roled Exchange Server
0 x Active databases per server
6 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
Site B - DAG2
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
1 x Witness Server
Option 3 - Single DAG
Site A
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
Site B
2 x multi-roled Exchange Servers
3 x Active databases per server
3 x Passive database (no-lag) per server
Site C
1 x Witness Server
Now I have only mentioned Site C here because it has no servers, however it is a different location to Site A and B and so could host a witness server.
What I am strugling to find (or understand) is what actually happens to the databases in a WAN failure scenerio, in each option. What I am trying to design is a solution that allows Site A and Site B to continue having email send\receive if the WAN link
between the sites fails.
Help gratefully appreciated!
EDIT
One last question if I am going with Server 2012 R2 should the FSW also be on the same O/S? What i have read it doesn't matter but surely it would for dynamic quorum?

Hi,
Based on my knowledge, if site A and site B lose connectivity to site C, all databases will stay mounted because it doesn't lose quorum.
If WAN connectivity is lost between site A and site B, one site of the two sites will retain quorum and the other site will lose quorum. For more details about this, you can refer to the "Misconception Number 2: Microsoft
recommends that you deploy the Witness Server in a third datacenter when extending a two-member DAG
across two datacenters" section in the following blog.
http://blogs.technet.com/b/exchange/archive/2011/05/31/exchange-2010-high-availability-misconceptions-addressed.aspx
Best regards,
Belinda Ma
TechNet Community Support

Similar Messages

  • Migrate Exchange 2010 to Exchange 2013, Need to defined win 7 users logon to Exchange 2010 & Win 8.1 users logon to Exchange 2013

    Hi,
    My organization have few win 7 and windows 8.1 clients. Now I want to migrate exchange server 2010 to 2013. And I don't want to remove exchange 2010 from the organization. Because I want to connect win 7 client through exchange 2010 and windows 8.1 user
    connect to exchange 2013. Is there any way to define the win 7 users to connect to exchange 2010 and Windows 8.1 users to connect to exchange 2013?
    Md. Ramin Hossain

    The client connections are proxied to the mailbox servers that hold the mailbox.
    You would need to have 2010 MBX servers with the mailboxes for the XP users, and 2013 MBX servers holding the mailboxes for the 7 users. And of course, the appropriate CAS servers.
    Realistically, you need to migrate away from Windows XP. It is no longer supported.

  • EXMON "exchange server user monitor" for Exchange 2013?

    Hello,
    it Looks like EXMON is not supported for Exchange 2013. Is this correct or can i use it with Server 2012 R2 and Exchange 2013 (CU6++)  ?
    Is there any alternative to check high log growth rate to see which user is responsable for this?
    Thanks for Feedback.
    best,
    Martin

    Hi Martin,
    Yes, ExMon is not supported for exchange 2013.
    Except the suggestion above, here is an exclusive application for you reference, it could retrieve statistics for all or selected mailboxes in a specified database and server, it may give you some help:
    Exchange Server Mailbox Statistics Tool - v1.6.2
    The tool retrieves mailbox statistics which includes Folder Count, Total Items, Associated Items, Deleted Items, Total Items Size, Deleted Items Size, Oldest Item Date, Newest Item Date, Items Age, Mailbox Age and Quota details. It also includes an additional
    option named "Archive Statistics Planner" which will let you search mailboxes and provide statistics report with specific dates. 
    Best regards,
    Niko Cheng
    TechNet Community Support

  • No premium OWA for IE11 with new install of Exchange 2013 w/sp1

    We just installed Exchange Server 2013 with sp1 included. Everything is good except IE11 users don't get the premium OWA site. I know that this was fixed in CU3, but you can't install it because SP1 is supposed to contain all the fixes through CU3.
    Does anyone have any idea?

    There's nothing wrong with the server.
    I have LAB environment also and OWA will show as legacy client rather Exchange 2013.
    I would suggest the same I suggested before... Uninstall IE11 and install IE10
    Also the windows Update has to be UpToDate
    Cheers,
    Gulab Prasad
    Technology Consultant
    Blog:
    http://www.exchangeranger.com    Twitter:
      LinkedIn:
       Check out CodeTwo’s tools for Exchange admins
    Note: Posts are provided “AS IS” without warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied, including but not limited to the implied warranties of merchantability and/or fitness for a particular purpose.

  • Error 550 5.7.1 unable to relay with SMTP PORT 25 Exchange 2013

    Hi All,
    I know this issue has been posted for a while, but still can't resolved issue. We've new Exchange 2013 SP1 (CU4) installation, everything is working properly, the OWA, Exchange Client Connection, SMTP/POP with SSL, except with SMTP Using Port 25 Non-Encrypted
    Connection.  
    If I'm using the SMTP Port 25 without TICK "My Outgoing Server (SMTP) Requires authentication", I've got the error: "550 5.7.1 Unable to relay", but if I TICK the option above, my message will be deliver without any error, how do i get
    rid this problem, I need to UN-TICK the option above for the time being, since we've hundreds email account, I want to avoid to educate and tell the user and even remote their PC, just to configure this issue, it will drive me crazy, we're going to use the
    Exchange Client Connection in the future, If everything is smooth and ok.
    I research this problem on the Internet and of course with TECHNET, but still can't, anyone can help me on this?
    fyi, I tried so many things, delete the default the Default Front End Transport for Port 25, it also not fix my issue.
    Thx
    Irwan

    Hi
    You can paste the output of below result
    Get-receiveconnector | fl name,bindings,PermissionGroups
    I think your default receive connector should be missing out some permissions.
    Also try to see if you get any message on protocol logs and paste them too
    Remember to mark as helpful if you find my contribution useful or as an answer if it does answer your question.That will encourage me - and others - to take time out to help you Check out my latest blog posts on http://exchangequery.com Thanks Sathish
    (MVP)

  • Problem with Mavericks Mail and Exchange 2013

    Hello,
    I have just updated to Mavericks a few days ago. Now I have a strange problem.
    The setup with Exchange 2013 works fine ... so I can send&receive mails.
    The problem: I only get new mails. All (few thausand) mails stored on the Exchange account are not synced to mail?!
    Maybe anyone has an idea how to solve this ...
    Thanks,
    Marc

    Some problems with Exchange mail have been solved by disabling Autodiscovery. If that doesn't work, see below.
    Back up all data. Delete the Exchange account from the Internet Accounts preference pane and add it back. If there's still no improvement, continue.
    Quit Mail. Force quit if necessary.
    Back up all data. That means you know you can restore the Mail database, no matter what happens.
    Triple-click anywhere in the line below on this page to select it:
    ~/Library/Mail/V2/MailData
    Copy the selected text to the Clipboard by pressing the key combination command-C. In the Finder, select
    Go ▹ Go to Folder
    from the menu bar. Paste into the box that opens (command-V), then press return.
    A folder window will open. Inside it there should be files with names as follows:
    Envelope Index
    ExternalUpdates.storedata
    Move those files to the Desktop, leaving the window open. Other files in the folder may have longer names that begin as above. Move those files, if any, to the Trash.
    Log out and log back in. Relaunch Mail. It should prompt you to re-import your messages. You may get a warning that the index is damaged and that Mail has to quit. Click OK.
    Test. If Mail now works as expected, you can delete the files you moved to the Desktop. Otherwise, post your results.

  • Exchange 2010 users cannot open Exchange 2013 shared mailbox

    Title says it all.
    We're in the process of migrating 1000+ mailboxes to Exchange 2013. A number of shared mailboxes have been migrated, but those users still on 2010 cannot open them.
    Is this just how it is, or is there a way around it?

    Hi,
    I tested in my lab, if the shared mailbox is on Exchange 2010, I could open this shared mailbox successfully. Then I moved this shared mailbox to Exchange 2013, after that, I couldn’t open it anymore, I got the following error:
    Besides, I tried to open a shared mailbox on Exchange 2013 which was not moved from Exchange 2010, it is the same error message.
    Based on the test, it seems that Exchange 2010 users can’t open shared mailbox on Exchange 2013. So I recommend you move those users to Exchange 2013.
    Best regards,
    Belinda Ma
    TechNet Community Support

  • Unwanted contacts synced with Office 365 and Exchange 2013

    I have an issue with unwanted contacts on Mavericks (and formerly Mountain Lion) syncing with our hosted Exchange server on Office 365. The problem began when the Office 365 service upgraded to Exchange 2013. I do not use iCloud at all.
    The unwanted contacts are only visible when I click on “All Contacts” within Contacts.app and do not appear in any hosted or local contact group. They are synced to all our macs, but are not visible on anything else, including Outlook.app or OWA, or our iPhones and iPads. Each user with a hosted Exchange account on Office 365 has the same problem, but with a different set of unwanted contacts. Normal contacts behave as expected for each user and device.
    The format of the unwanted contacts is simple. They contain nothing but an email address (no name, phone, IM or other details) which leads me to think they are automatically generated recent or suggested contacts, although some of them are quite old. We use Mail.app exclusively on our macs.
    I can delete these unwanted contacts one at a time from any of my macs, and although they appear to be deleted on the server (resyncing another mac deletes them there too), they will reappear (resynced from Exchange) within a day or two and they have to be deleted all over again. It is a frustrating and time consuming process.
    My questions then:
    can I prevent Contacts.app from the syncing these contacts?
    or can I prevent Mail.app from presumably sending them to the server in the first place?
    or is there a command I can issue through Powershell to tell Exchange to delete and not retain these contacts?
    Any other suggestions to prevent this behaviour would be most welcome.

    I'm having this exact same issue.
    Have you seen this thread? https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5252673?start=45&tstart=0
    I'm on Exchange 2013, which I manage, and Mavericks.  I also noticed you can see a "Linked Contact" on OWA 2013.
    This is just more of the extremely poor Apple software engineering we have seen over the last few years...
    Also: http://community.office365.com/en-us/forums/153/t/187666.aspx
    Message was edited by: ibrennan

  • Is Dreamweaver the best tool for creating a review site with user ratings/reviews? CMS?

    Hello everyone,
    I am really wanting to develop an online gaming review website and have some Dreamweaver/Wordpress/CMS questions i am hoping you can all help me with, thank you in advance for your patience as i am new to site development.
    I am thinking of creating a review site which will involve me writing about 100 online gaming reviews, and then getting users to upload their comments/feedback, etc. Each of the reviews would be updated monthly with stats, performance, and other details. Each review would contain a text review, video review, and various images and screenshots. Integrating user-generated content will be a big factor.
    I am trying to de-confuse myself with all the prep work around making sure i have the right tools and technology i need to be successful. Many people tell me i should use Wordpress due to the nature of my site, or at least a combination of Wordpress and Dreamweaver - not sure how that would work exactly. I dont want to be too dependant on just Wordpress because i want to be sure my site can be customized and i grow and enable more advanted value for my site visitors. ...i would love to have a members only area at some point in the near future.
    Please see below for some questions running through my head:
    1. Do i need a seperate CMS tool? ...and which may be best considering the nature of my site?
    2. Should i use Wordpress instead? ...or a combination of Wordpress and Dreamweaver? - why should i use a combination of the two?
    3. SEO is a major factor - does that make a difference?
    4. My reviews will need to be updated monthly, so i will try to maximize the use of templates, etc. Do i need to create a dynamic site in Dreamweaver or will a CMS manage that?
    5. Which options are best to avoid as much as manual coding as possible
    Thank for you taking the time to read this, ...any tips/guideance would be appreciated.
    Thank you,
    Harps

    Short answer: You don't need Dreamweaver.  Simply install WordPress on your server and use it to build your site & add/edit content. 
    Star Ratings plug-in for WordPress
    http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/gd-star-rating/
    WordPress Theme with Review Engine
    http://www.dailywp.com/review-engine-theme/
    Nancy O.

  • Problems with cmdlets within the Exchange 2013 powershell

    Hi,
    i've following problem: I can't access all possible powershell cmdlets within the exchange powershell. For example following cmdlet is missing: "Get-Queue". Also we have trouble with some other cmdlets: Get-Mailbox only lists one of 30 mailboxes
    and if we want to modify a mailbox identified by the logonname an error shows up that the user can't be found. Only the one listed user can be modified.
    What can I do to solve this problem?
    Yours
    Achim

    Hi Achim,
    You need to be assigned appropriate permissions or roles before you can run all cmdlet. Although all parameters for this cmdlet are listed, you may not have access to some parameters if they're not included in the permissions assigned to you. For example
    to run Get-Queue cmdlet - your user account must be assigned the "Organization Management" or at least "Server Management" role.
    You can try this to view roles assigned to your account:
    Get-ManagementRoleAssignment -RoleAssignee 'yourUserAcc' -Role "organization*" | fl role
    Get-ManagementRoleAssignment -RoleAssignee 'yourUserAcc' -Role "*transport*" | fl role
    Otherwise you can view and change role assignments with EAC:
    In the EAC, navigate to Permissions > Admin Roles.
    Select the role group you want to view the members of.
    In the role group details pane, view the members in the role group details pane.
    ▲ Vote if Helpful / Mark if Answer
    MCSE: Messaging 2013 Charter / Private Cloud / Server Infrastructure
    MaximumExchange.ru

  • Issue with Get-LogonStatistics in Exchange 2013

    Hi all,
    I run into an issue with the Get-LogonStatistics cmdlet. The error says:
    Cannot find LogonStatistics objects from the root 'DB1'. Please make sure that you specified the correct search root and that you have the correct permissions to perform the search.
        + CategoryInfo          : NotSpecified: (:) [Get-LogonStatistics], MapiOperationException
        + FullyQualifiedErrorId : B3D0201A,Microsoft.Exchange.Management.MapiTasks.GetLogonStatistics
        + PSComputerName        : mb1.ex2013.test
    I run that cmdlet as a member of the OrganizationAdmin rolegroup.
    Any ideas?
    Thanks in advance!

    Hello,
    Sorry for the delaying respond. The error indicates there might be a problem with the ACLs. But the cmdlet "get-mailbox" works, so the ACLs should be fine.
    From the result for checking, the everythings is also fine.
    Is there any update?
    If you have any feedback on our support, please click
    here
    Cara Chen
    TechNet Community Support

  • Active Directory Sites and Exchange 2013 Deployment

    I've recently took over responsibility of an Exchange 2013 Organization that is deployed as follows:
    Active Directory consists of 4 Sites. AD Site A, B, C, D  Exchange 2013 Enterprise resides in 2 of the 4 AD Sites as follows:
    AD Site A - ExchangeServer 1 and ExchangeServer 2
    AD Site B - Exchange Server 3
    AD Site C - No Exchange Servers
    AD Site D - No Exchange Servers
    All 4 AD Sites are 4 different Physical locations/datacenters. All 3 Exchange 2013 servers are multi-role servers.
    The Forest in which Exchange resides in consists of an empty Root domain, a Production (child) domain and a Test (child) domain. Exchange resides in the Production (child) domain.
    Issue: AD Site A contains DC's from all 3 domains: Root Domain, Production child Domain (this is where Exchange lives) and Test child Domain. I notice that Exchange in AD Site A is using DC's from the Root Domain for it's "DefaultGlobalCatalog",
    "DefaultConfigurationDomainController" and "DefaultPreferredDomainControllers" This to me does not seem to be very efficient as any Address Book queries will have to be referred to by the Root Domain DC's to the Production child domain
    where Exchange lives. All of the AD User accounts and mailboxes are in the Production child domain.
    In a situation such as this, would it be advisable to build 2 additional AD sites specifically for Exchange? Rather than re-IP Exchange or risk the impact of moving several other (non exchange) servers to another AD site, I would add the IP address
    of the Exchange servers /32 to the new Exchange dedicated AD Sites and erect a DC in these new sites adding its IP address /32. Any thoughts on this idea? If the subnet that exchange resides on is (for example) 10.60.3.0 /16 in AD Site A, and
    I build a new AD site for Exchange and add the IP address of the Exchange server such as 10.60.3.141/32 for this new Exchange AD Site boundary, I can still leave the 10.60.3.0 /16 unaffected in AD Site A, correct?
    I'm looking for Microsoft's best practices in terms of laying out AD and domain controllers pertaining to Exchange server 2013.

    Hi Anthouyray,
    Thank you for your question.
    We could use the following command to exclude domain controller which is root domain controller:
    Set-ExchangeServer –Identity  <exchange servername> -StaticExcludeDomainControllers <root domain controller>
    Then we could restart the service of “Microsoft Exchange Active Directory Topology” to check if the issue persist.
    If there are any questions regarding this issue, please be free to let me know.
    Best Regard,
    Jim
    Please remember to mark the replies as answers if they help, and unmark the answers if they provide no help. If you have feedback for TechNet Support, contact [email protected]
    Jim Xu
    TechNet Community Support

  • Exchange 2013 EAC coexistence with Exchange 2007

    Dear All,
    I have an exchange organization comprized of single Exchange 2007 SP3 UR 15 running on Win2008 SP2 and two recently installed Exchange 2013 SP1 CU7 with CAS and Mailbox role running on Win 2012 R2.
    Imidiantly after Exchange 2013 install, I am not able to login to Exchange 2013 EAC. When I enter my credentials domain\username, the EAC page simpli dose a quick refresh and I am back where I started.
    I have tryid mutiple UTLs to access EAC page, such as:
    https://localhost/ecp?ExchClientVer=15
    https://localhost/ecp?ExchClientVer=14
    https://localhost/ecp
    Each of them show the same result, a page gets refreshet. I have tryid to move my Exchange Organization user mailbox to Exchange 2013 to see if that helps but the result.
    I also noticed that OWA dosent work for mailboxes that are on Exchange 2013, they are redirected to Exchange 2007 even thou they are on Exchange 2013.
    Any idea on this one?
    Thank you
    b.

    Hi,
    From your description, I would like to verify if you have configured Exchange 2013 namespace and virtual directories (such as OWA, ECP, OAB, Web Services, AutoDiscover)correctly. Please make sure these virtual directories are configured correctly and check
    the result.
    For more information about Exchange 2007  migration to Exchange 2013, here is a helpful blog for your reference.
    Step-by-Step Exchange 2007 to 2013 Migration
    http://blogs.technet.com/b/meamcs/archive/2013/07/25/part-2-step-by-step-exchange-2007-to-2013-migration.aspx
    Hope this can be helpful to you.
    Best regards,
    If you have feedback for TechNet Subscriber Support, contact
    [email protected]
    Amy Wang
    TechNet Community Support

  • Remote Admin message to users on Exchange 2013

    Hello,
    I am currently working with a client post Exchange 2013 migration and we have noticed that when a user configures activesync on their personal device, they are no longer notified that the IT department has the ability to remote wipe.  
    Here's a link to an sample image of a similar message that they used to receive.  
    http://www.slsmk.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/as-error1.jpg
    Is there a way to re-enable this message in Exchange 2013?  We also have a device policy that has been set up.  Could the policy be the reason that the message no longer appears?  If this is no longer available in Exchange 2013, is there some
    sort of notification that can be set up to inform the user?
    Thanks,
    Dean

    Weird, I just verified that I get the popup in my organization and we don't do anything crazy out of the ordinary for ActiveSync policies.  What CU/SP are you running in your organization?  Can you check the phone to see if the activesync account
    is already a device administrator?  Maybe that has something to do with it.

  • GSSAPI with IMAP on Exchange 2013 SP1

    We are setting up Exchange 2013 SP1 in our Exchange 2010 test environment to verify our upcoming migration. I have found out that for some reason I can't get the IMAP service in Exchange 2013 to work with Kerberos (GSSAPI) authentication with Thunderbird
    as a client. It does work fine in Exchange 2010 SP3 though.
    Exchange 2010 SP3 response in Thunderbird:
    * CAPABILITY IMAP4 IMAP4rev1 AUTH=NTLM AUTH=GSSAPI AUTH=PLAIN UIDPLUS CHILDREN IDLE NAMESPACE LITERAL+
    Exchange 2013 SP1 response in Thunderbird:
     * CAPABILITY IMAP4 IMAP4rev1 AUTH=PLAIN UIDPLUS CHILDREN IDLE NAMESPACE LITERAL+
    AUTH=GSSAPI is missing and therefore I can't blame Thunderbird from complaining about this. If I compare the output from Get-ImapSettings I can't find anything that would indicate why I shouldn't work. EnableGSSAPIAndNTLMAuth is $true on both server
    and LoginType is SecureLogin.
    On
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj619283(v=exchg.150).aspx I found out that NTLM is not supported on Exchange 2013 for POP3 and IMAP4 but Kerberos (GSSAPI) and Plain Text Authentication with SSL still is.
    Has anyone got IMAP to work with Kerberos authentication on Exchange 2013 SP1?

    Hello,
    According to your description, we are unable to see the AUTH=GSSAPI in Exchange 2013.
    My environment is Exchange 2013 CU1. I get the same result as yours. Looks Like Exchange 2013 IMAP does not support GSSAPI as authentication mechanism.
    Cara Chen
    TechNet Community Support

Maybe you are looking for

  • Get my music back

    Just put a new hard drive in my Macbook Pro but all my data was lost on the old hard drive. How do I get back all the music I bought on iTunes? I

  • Business Partner Types

    Hi Experts, Under the SAP IMG -> Cross Application component, there is a function named, Business Partner Types. Can you please explain me what is the use of this in real time. Please explain this with real time example. Thanks Edited by: Navneet Sin

  • Problem with 8.0 Firefox in GMX - Opera works in this GMX Side !

    When i go to gmx.de after Update to 8.0 i have follow Problem and GMX not opened ! I testet with Opera and it is no GMX Problem . In Past before 2 Years i have the same Problem too . Best regards martin INFO IN MONITOR IS : Bad Request Your browser s

  • Do i need to uninstall excel 2004 before installing 2011?

    I am upgranding to Lion and Microsoft Excel and Office will not run under Lion. I am upgrading to office 2011. Do I need to uninstall office 2004 prior to installing 2011. If so how do I unintall 2044. thanks

  • Strange problem with Simulator

    Hello Everyone: I was wondering if anyone was having difficulty getting the 2.1 OS to run in the simulator. After updating, I changed my apps to build a 2.1 OS Simulator executable and they run fine, but the IPhone Simulator does not start in the 2.1