3 times of replacement of Hard drive Cable within 2 years

Dear All,
I have been an iFan and loved Apple's products. I have been an owner of 4 iPods, 1 iPhone, 1 iPad and 1 Macbook Pro 13'' (bought at Jan 2010 from US online Apple store).
Unfortunately, it's incredible to say my Macbook Pro Hard Drive Cable required 3 times of replacements within 2 years. The first time of mal-function happen in the warranty period, so Authorized Apple Office replaced it. 6 months later, the bad "symptom" happen again with question mark folder on boot up screen and recovered after replacement of used hard drive cable. Six months later, question mark folder boot screen happen again and disappear after install a good HDD cable from another Macbook Pro.
You may imagine my disappointed to see "periodic" and costly repairs of my Macbook. It's unbeliveable for quality of an Apple product, which should have been better. One time of repair could be explained as "unlucky" or mistake on production line. 3 times within 2 years can not say as sporadic or random mistake. Obviously, there is an systemic problem with Apple HDD cables and  I can not sure it would be the last time I have spent money and time to replace a new cable. I worked in Vietnam, where it's not always easy to buy a new spare parts of Apple products.
Honestly, I never seen any of my PC laptops get any wrong on their HDD cable like my poor Macbook.
My case would be a very bad experience for an Macbook user.
Anyone can tell me how to prevent HDD cable from bad situation again?
Thank you very much in advance
Regards

Dad of Noel wrote:
Anyone can tell me how to prevent HDD cable from bad situation again?
I doubt it. However, you should submit a complaint to Apple (this is not the right place for it).
One time of repair could be explained as "unlucky" or mistake on production line. 3 times within 2 years can not say as sporadic or random mistake. Obviously, there is an systemic problem with Apple HDD cables
Actually, that's not obvious at all.
First, SATA cable issues are not specific to Apple. You can find, for instance, plenty of complaints on Toshiba forums. (Off-hand, it does seem to me that we didn't use to have so many problems with the old, parallel, ATA cables, but I can't be sure.)
Second, you could, for instance, have a small random manufacturing defect in a component which touches the cable. When the component warms up, that defect might damage the cable. This would explain the short life of the cables in your machine w/o the necessity of postulating a systemic issue. Of course, this is pure speculation, but it demonstrates the defect in your logic.
Third, the fact is that we, the consumers, demand ever more powerful products, in ever smaller sizes and comparatively lower prices. Apple, which is no different from any other major corp, is reacting by, among other measures, cutting corners on quality (as well as finding cheaper labour elsewhere). This is the reality which all of us have helped to bring about.
I know full well that this is cold comfort to you. But I'm afraid there is nothing else. For most of us, life is hard, bitter, and unfair.
If I were you, I'd make sure to keep all the documentation about the SATA cable problems, and, if it happened again, I'd complain once more to Apple, this time escalating it as far up the corporate food chain as I could.

Similar Messages

  • I would like to replace the hard drive cable for a 13" mid 2010 macbook pro.  What is the right model of the hard drive cable?

    i would like to replace the hard drive cable for a 13" mid 2010 macbook pro.  What is the right model of the hard drive cable?

    https://www.ifixit.com/Store/Parts/MacBook-Pro-13-Inch-Unibody-Model-A1278-Mid-2 009-Mid-2010-Hard-Drive-Cable/IF163-013-1
    Apple Part #: 922-9062, 821-0814-A

  • Anyone know how to find and replace a hard drive cable fo an HP Pavilion zv5160us laptop?

    I received message that my hard drive had failed.  I ordered an identical drive and replaced it.  I now get error message:
    PXE-E61:  Media test failure, check cable
    PXE-M0F:  exiting PXE ROM
    The recovery disks will not reformat the drive.  What does the cable look like.  Can it be replaced?  Where could I find one?
    Thanks for any help as I have bought new hard drive, more memory and recovery disks.  Hate to lose my investment completely.  Should have just bought a new laptop!

    Hi,
    Should be ok to put new WD HDD on your dv6 machine. All connectors are standard. Please watch the following videos to see some idea of this work:
        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CP0WYzpKYKk
       http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQx7PlIXFuE
    Regards.
    BH
    **Click the KUDOS thumb up on the left to say 'Thanks'**
    Make it easier for other people to find solutions by marking a Reply 'Accept as Solution' if it solves your problem.

  • 2009 macbook pro incorrect number of file hard links. repaired and still slow. I replaced the hard drive within the year and it's 1 tb not full. help!

    I have a 2009 macbook pro and I keep it up to date. I replaced the hard drive with a new 1 tb hard drive within the last year. It is not even close to full. The other night I was doing a time machine backup and the spinning color wheel appeared. It would not go away and the only thing I could do was restart the computer. The Grey apple screen appeared and nothing else happens. I restarted in disk utility and verified the drive. It said "incorrect number of file hard links". I repaired it successfully and check the drive as well as the startup drive. All was ok. I restarted my computer and it took forever to come on. It is now one but I can not do anything. The desktop and all appropriate dock items are there but I can not do anything. What should I do?

    It's likely that the startup drive, or some other hardware component, is failing. Back up all data immediately, then run Apple Diagnostics or the Apple Hardware Test.
    Even if the test is negative, you should make a "Genius" appointment at an Apple Store to have the machine tested more thoroughly.

  • Can I replace 500GB hard drive in 1st generation time capsule?

    I have a first gen Time Capsule with a 500GB hard drive.  It is out of warranty but before I crack the case I would like to know if there is anything special about replacing the hard drive with a new 2 TB HD.  Is there a preferred imaging software for a time capsule HD replacement?

    I have avoided buying advanced format drives ever since i saw the issue..
    But I should have also commented do a search for any drive you find and see if some other guinea pig has installed the particular drive you are looking at in a series 1.. note carefully the different series respond differently.. and actually series 1 seems to be more tolerant.. later series 2 and 3 can pose big problems when people have tried 3TB drives or advanced format drives.
    IMHO you want to buy drives that you KNOW are going to work.. I know a drive will work because it is NOT advanced format.. which is just a way for the scum bag hard drive companies to get more capacity out of less disk space. It has no advantage to end users.
    The series 4 TC uses advanced drive.. you can see it in all its glory sitting there smugly in the picture.
    http://www.anandtech.com/show/4577/airport-extreme-5th-gen-and-time-capsule-4th- gen-review-faster-wifi-/4
    BTW after you spend all this money do you realise you will still have a substandard TC. not dual band.. not even N full .. it is still I think only N draft.
    A new 2TB TC is around $300.. look at the price you are going to pay for a 2TB drive.. and do you know what could happen.. the power supply of the TC will fry.. as they are awful prone to do. If you ebay the TC you will get $100 or so back for it.
    It is a good time to buy brand new TC with bare drives so expensive.

  • My HP computer's hard drive crashed.  I have replaced the hard drive and reinstalled all of the software.  I have copied my I tunes library from my backup hard drive to the new one.  How do I restore the permissions?  This is the 3 rd time I have had to d

    My HP computer's hard drive crashed.  I have replaced the hard drive and reinstalled all of the software.  I have copied my I tunes library from my backup hard drive to the new one.  How do I restore the permissions?  This is the 3 rd time I have had to do this.  THe share screen says you are limited to 5 ??

    No backup is not good.
    You can transfer itunes purchases from an ipod.  File>Transfer Purchases

  • HT201250 I had to replace the hard drive in my old MacBook. I replaced it. Installed OSX10.6. Then using the system software I reinstalled data from my Time Machine backup. On completion it asked for my password. It is not accepted. I am locked out how I

    I had to replace the hard drive in my old MacBook. I replaced it. Installed OSX10.6. Then using the system software I reinstalled data from my Time Machine backup. On completion it asked for my password. It is not accepted. I am locked out how I overcome this?
    I was already using 10.7. But only had the disc for 10.6.

    Sorry I am new to this. Am I in the right area? I am using my iPhone to make contact. I am worried.

  • HT201250 When getting a replacement Seagate hard drive for my Imac through Apple, will they restore my system to it's current state? Or will I have to do it myself though Time Machine? Will Time machine restore all the programs as well?

    Apple has determined that certain Seagate 1TB hard drives used in 21.5-inch and 27-inch iMac systems may fail. These systems were sold between October 2009 and July 2011.
    Apple or an Apple Authorized Service Provider (AASP) will replace affected hard drives free of charge.
    Will this replacement program restore my system to its current state after the new drive is installed? If not, will I have to have all my original disks to re-install all the programs on my current computer, or will Time Machine restore them as well?

    Most of them will tell you to backup your data.
    Time Machine is nice, but unless you are interested in archival backup, Carbon Copy Cloner is a lot easier to recover from:
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-1992

  • I replaced my hard drive and used time machine to boot from but it installedthe unrepaired disk permissions of the faulty previous drive would this cause problems on my new drive?

    I replaced my hard drive on macbook pro and used time machine to boot from but it also installed the unrepaired disk permmissions of the other drive, would this cause problems to my new drive?

    Can you remember what the permissions problem was that you had before? You may need to reinstall OS X from scratch and not reinstall anything from your Time Machine backups. To be on the safe side you should reinstall all third-party applications from scratch, as well. Then only restore from your backup your document/data files.

  • I just replaced the hard drive on my macbook pro, reformatted new hard drive and copied over a backup from time machine now I have a kernel panic message (you must restart) - what do I do now?

    i just replaced the hard drive on my macbook pro, reformatted new hard drive, installed a back up from time machine and now have kernel panic ( you must restart your computer) what do I need to do?

    If you're able to boot, launch the Console application in any of the following ways:
    ☞ Enter the first few letters of its name into a Spotlight search. Select it in the results (it should be at the top.)
    ☞ In the Finder, press the key combination shift-command-U. The application is in the folder that opens.
    ☞ If you’re running Mac OS X 10.7 or later, open LaunchPad. Click Utilities, then Console in the page that opens.
    Select the most recent panic log under System Diagnostic Reports. Post the contents – the text, please, not a screenshot. For privacy’s sake, I suggest you edit out the “Anonymous UUID,” a long string of letters, numbers, and dashes in the header and body of the report, if it’s present (it may not be.) Please don't post "shutdownStall" or "hang" reports.
    If you can't boot in the usual way, try a safe boot. The instructions provided by Apple are as follows:
    Be sure your Mac is shut down.
    Press the power button.
    Immediately after you hear the startup tone, hold the Shift key. The Shift key should be held as soon as possible after the startup tone, but not before the tone.
    Release the Shift key when you see the gray Apple icon and the progress indicator (looks like a spinning gear).
    During startup, you’ll see a progress bar, and then the login screen, which appears even if you normally log in automatically. You must know your login password in order to log in. If you’ve forgotten the password, you will need to reset it before you begin.
    Safe mode is slower than normal, and some things won’t work at all.

  • I had to replace my hard drive twice in my power mac g5. Luckily, I had the foresight to install a backup drive the second time around. Has anybody had HD problems? Is it the Power Mac or I just lucked out on some bad drives.

    I had to replace my hard drive twice in my power mac g5. Luckily, I had the foresight to install a backup drive the second time around. Has anybody had HD problems? Is it the Power Mac or I just lucked out on some bad drives.

    Hi Leon,
    There are many well known G5 problems, but being hard on Hard Drives is not one of them.
    How old & what brand/model drives were they?

  • How can i get an internal hard drive cable replacement?

    how can i get an internal hard drive cable replacement?

    I believe iFixit sells them:
    http://www.ifixit.com/
    You can also go to an Apple store, they won't sell you the part, but they will replace it for a fee.

  • I just replaced the hard drive for my Mac Pro, and I am trying to restore what is on my Time Capsule, but it wont connect, and only is giving me the pinwheel of death. What do i do?

    I just replaced the hard drive for my Mac Pro, and I am trying to restore what is on my Time Capsule, but it wont connect, and only is giving me the pinwheel of death. What do i do?

    You will need to boot from some alternate boot device to accomplish this, if you did not initialize the drive before installing it.
    If you have another Mac, you may be able to use FireWire target disk mode.
    If your MacBook has a DVD reader and you have a Mac OS X Installer/Utilities DVD, such as the one that shipped with it, you can boot from that DVD, answer only the "what Language" question, and wait a quarter minute for the MenuBar to be drawn. Then examine the Utilities menu or the Installer menu and Find Disk Utility.

  • I've had trouble with my Macbook since the first month I bought it. I've replaced the hard drive 3 to 4 times. Now some programs won't work or shut off by itself. Is it possible to ask for a complete exchange of products?

    I've had trouble with my Macbook since the first month I bought it. I've replaced the hard drive 3 to 4 times. Now some programs won't work or shut off by itself. Is it possible to ask for a complete exchange of products?

    This may help you: http://store.apple.com/us/help/returns_refund
    It would appear that you can ask for an exchange but it doesn't specify any time frame... Hopefully someone more knowledgeable can add to this.
    By the way, if you've replaced the drive so many times, perhaps there's something else going on elsewhere.

  • I just replaced my hard drive and restored everything from Time machine. However, I am unable to open iphoto and the following message appears Your photo library was not found. Do you want to find your iPhoto Library?

    I just replaced my hard drive and restored everything from Time machine. However, I am unable to open iphoto and the following message appears Your photo library was not found. Do you want to find your iPhoto Library?
    Where do I find this library?
    thanks
    Shak

    Twas quite a hassle if I am honest which was eventually resolved but I don't feel qualified to help anyone through the process as it required a trip to my local apple store and a genius bar appointment.
    Personally, I would do anything like moving pictures out of folders etc. Certainly not creating a new users. i don't think that is an elegant solution
    Try the following which MAY just about rescue the situation for you but if they don't work you may have to do something more drastic.
    (1) Holding down Cmd & Alt at the same time, start iPhoto by clicking on the iPhoto icon. From the resulting menu choose Rebuild photo library by selecting all available options given to you and then pressing REBUILD!
    If that doesn't work
    (2) Fire up Utilities. Go to migration assistant. Chose 'From another Time machine back-up'. Open the 'Users' option that comes up next and from there select Pictures, then uncheck everything else like Applications etc (you don't want to do a full migration of everything) and click go.
    If that doesn't work, take a deep breath and this step is rather complicated but it worked for me. First of all close iPhoto! Then go to new Finder window.
    From the Finder window choose Pictures, then iPhoto library, press CMD and the letter i. It brings up a new window. Go to Sharing & permissions. From there select the padlock to unlock settings. and then select User account, then press the 'cog' icon next to +/- abd choose Apply to enclosed items.
    This may take a while. Once completed, re-open iPhoto.
    And that should (I stress should) cure it.
    Good luck.

Maybe you are looking for

  • How to attach Multiple attachments to single mail

    How to attach multiple pdfs to single mail  ? or how to attach one pdf & One excel & One word document to single mail ? Thanks In Advance

  • Macbook Pro retina or not ?

    hi so i want to be a graphic designer but i dont know which of those is better,i know i will use photoshop a lot, illustrator..  i dont want to spend a lot of money on a computer or shoul i get a pc ? which is better

  • SCCM report blank

    Hi Team,I have SCCM 2012 running for a while without issue on reporting. but today it became blank since morning. SQL is on seperate server, so the DBA checked the SSRS service, it's running. but restarted it anyway. Same. i checked the  site status

  • Tasks - Organizational data profile

    Hi all, I face the following problem: I use the same Organizational data  profile for Activities and Tasks (both for scenario Sales). For  activities, the profile works alright but for tasks, the profile  does not return any results. Also the rule th

  • Task & Appointment Manager recommendations?

    Some four weeks or so since buying my iPad 3G, I'd say that one of the most delightful things about it is the sheer ease of installing new 'apps'. But inevitably there's a lot of poor stuff to wade through in the App Store to find those of quality. I