802.11: "Preferred networks" vs. "A specific network"

I've got a new MacBook Pro and it appears that -- at least in my opinion -- has eliminiated one of the key advantages OS X networking has over Win XP.
With my G4 PowerBook, I can create a one-to-one relationship between locations and network access points. For me this is critical, as my work location has multiple access points -- some on our corporate network and some open to the internet. For the corporate nets, I have a static IP address and need various proxy configurations to be stored, whereas for the public nets, its DHCP and no proxy info needs to be stored.
On the MacBook Pro, it appears to me that I can't force network settings to access one and only one access point per location setting. Worse, I can't even change the prioirties of access per location.
This causes unpredictable behavior when my truly preferred access point is momentarily out of range. It appears that the MBP is grabbing another access point automatically. When this happens, my network settings are incorrect, and my connection is broken.
Am I missing something obvious? 'Cause this is the exact problem I've had with XP for years -- and something that has always been a ton better on Mac.
17 in MacBook Pro   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  
various   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

Thanks for the suggestion, but the behavior described in the article is the actually the issue. Here's the problem: in my work environment, there are three VLANs with three APs, all three are always visible from my desk. According to what I'm doing, I need to shift between them a couple time per day.
Physical Location: Work
Access Points Available:
- "Internet" (closed SSID, DHCP, no proxies)
- "Corporate" (closed SSID, DHCP, proxies)
- "Development" (closed SSID, static IP, no proxies)
Location "Outside Network"
- Preferred Airport: "Intenet"
- DHCP
- no proxies
Location "Inside Network"
- Preferred Airport: "Corporate"
- DHCP
- appropriate proxy settings
Location "Development Network"
- Preferred Airport: "Development"
- static IP
- no proxies
So the "Preferred network" option would work (though less than optimum) if I could change the order based on location. It would be optimum (and better than the 10.6.4 PowerPC version) if I could change the order and add/delete netwoks according to location. Unfortunately, there seems to be only one preferred network list that is global for all locations. And that causes the unpredictability that I tried to describe.

Similar Messages

  • Location-specific preferred networks lists

    I would like to have a different list of preferred networks, depending on my location.  I think it worked this way in 10.6.
    Now, in 10.8, the networks I've listed in Location A still show up in the list for Location B.
    Do I need to reset something, or is this how it works now?
    Thanks.

    In all honesty Apple messed up on iCloud from the very start and now can't fix it.
    There might be a setting but if iCloud is like everything else Apple has done they don't give the User many setting options. Apple's way or no way.
    I personally don't use it as I found it severly lacking in function. You have just pointed out another.
    TechAddict wrote:
    All devices are synced and using iCloud Keychain.  I think that's where the networks have copied across from because when I go to remove them it says they will be deleted from the keychain for all devices. The MBP is listing every network now that my mobile devices have ever connected too.  95% of those are in different countries so it's not an 'in the area of' issue.
    Going to have a rummage to see if there are any iCloud Keychain settings anywhere.  You'd think theere would be an option that shows the networks that THIS computer has connected to (as the settings screen actually states) and an option to show (or copy across) all the networks that EVERY device you own have ever connected to.  They are disticntly different.  My MBP have NEVER connected to most of them.

  • "By default, join" drop-down doesn't have "Preferred Networks" option

    I use my laptop on two different networks. I would like it to automatically join whichever one is available. The Mac Help has instructions titled "Choosing preferred AirPort networks" with three steps. Step 1 works fine; I can open network preferences and get to the drop-down labelled "By default, join". It says I should then select the option "Preferred networks" from the drop-down. The problem I have is, there is no such option. The drop-down has only one option, labelled "A specific network".
    It works identically on a regular user account and an adminstrator account. I have authenticated.
    Tiger 10.4.8, fully updated.

    Can't find the TIL again... might have it bookmarked at work though, but that's the problem... Sorry can't remember the fix right now at all.

  • "Preferred Network" option missing from Airport tab

    My computer was just joining networks, so I switched my MPB to "By Default, Join: A specific network". Now I find that I've got to tell my computer to join the wireless network at work. Since I'd like my computer to join both my home networks without interaction from me I read the help file to figure out how to do it. The help file said to choose "Preferred Networks" from the "By Default, Join:" popup menu, but the popup menu on my computer only had one choice, "A specific network".
    Anyone know what might have happened to the other options in that popup menu?
    Thanks,
    Chris

    Replying to my own post, bad form...
    I don't know why "Preferred Networks" was missing from my "By Default, Join:" menu, but I discovered that I could get the option back by creating a new location and migrating my old settings to the new location.
    Chris

  • Leopard airport issues - Preferred Networks

    I am having an Airport / Preferred Networks issue with new Macbook (Dec 07) currently running 10.5.1.
    I have a Netgear wireless router that uses WPA for my local network. It has worked fine for around 8 months with Powerbooks & ibooks running Tiger, various PC's and an iphone.
    My macbook however will not remember the preferred networks I set up. Everytime I wake it from sleep it says 'none of your preferred networks are available' and then asks if I want to join my local network. The password is remembered correctly and it attempts to join. Roughly 70% of the time it will then give a Connection Timeout error two or three times before connecting.
    I have tried the following:
    -Deleting the network location in System preferences.
    -Deleted Airport Keychain entries and restarted laptop.
    -Reset network location using System preferences, restarting laptop again.
    -Created a new user account and still found the same issue.
    Does anyone have any other suggestions or is it a matter of waiting for 10.5.2?
    Thanks, Graham

    The issues appear to be due to improper settings of routers and/or networking issues, which appear to be more prevalent on third party routers though can also affect Apple routers if their firmware isn't up to date. It is not an operating system specific issue, even though it can often appear to show up when upgrading. The reason for this is numerous routers haven't followed specs that are industry wide.
    I suggest looking over these tips*:
    http://www.macmaps.com/WIFI1048.html
    As well as making sure when you upgrade to follow these tips:
    http://www.macmaps.com/upgradefaq.html
    to avoid the most frequently encountered problems.
    - * Links to my pages may give me compensation
    Message was edited by: a brody

  • None of your preferred networks available

    We have two MBP that were upgraded to Lion and worked well with our previous router.  Since changing over to the Time Capsule both MBPs get the "none of your preferred networks are available" popup when waking from sleep mode.  After searching for an answer I cannot find a good explanaton.  Not sure if this is just a problem with the router change or Lion since people have posted having the problem with using the same router they had before upgrading to Lion.  Any help would be appreciated.

    I just got off the phone with Apple support and the fix he walked me thru has worked.
    Go to Airport Utility and click on manual setup at the bottom of the window.  Go to wireless tab and select radio channel selection...change 5GHz to 161 and 2.4GHz to 9.  Click update.
    Open network preferences and click advanced.  Highlight and delete all items that appear in preferred networks (use the minus button).  Click ok (think apply comes up as well).
    Spotlight search for "keychain".  Click on "keychain access".  Delete the instances of your network name by highlighting and using the delete key.  Close and apply if asked.
    Turn Airport off then back on.  Click to join your network and enter password.  Turn Airport off and back on (at this point it auto connected).  Restart computer and make sure it auto connects.  Put to sleep and wake back up to make sure it connects.
    These steps worked for me...not sure if it was a time capsule specific issue, but figured these steps seemed pretty universal since I changed no time capsule setting.

  • "None of your preferred networks are available" But they are!

    This is the one problem that most bugs me with my MBP, i was hoping that 10.5.2 would fix it, but it does not.
    I use my MBP on two wireless networks. They are both airport expresses with different SSIDs.
    The first (work) is one airport express and my MBP will connect to it when ever it is in range happily. The second (home) is an airport express with another airport express extending the first. The only one in range on my laptop is the extension. Every time I wake the laptop it will tell me that "None of your preferred networks are available" and show the name of my network in the list - it has the password stored and has been told to remember the network... and yet it still refuses to connect.
    Clicking the network shows that it knows the password as it displays it. I have rest both airport expresses and made the network from scratch, I have also deleted all references to the network in keychain and airport preferences, and yet it still does it.
    There are a couple of other threads on this topic, but none of them have been resolved (That i have found) and they seem to have a slightly different problem to me, so I have posted my own question.
    Does anyone know what is wrong?
    Thanks.

    I don't have the answer, I have the problem...
    I'm also in one of the other threads about 10.5.2 messing up connection to my Apple Airport Extreme (melted marshmallow), but I also have the "None of your preferred networks are available" problem.
    My network configuration looks like this: http://tijil.org/LAN_06.jpg
    I have: Hard reset Airport, re-loaded firmware, re-done all settings, powered up and down numerous times, changed channels, etc. to no avail.
    For me the Airport Base continues to work just fine with the other two computers connected to it wirelessly, but my 3 week old MacBook with 10.5.2 will no do so automatically, and once it does, even though the signal is strong and the S/N ratio is good, the connection is usually much slower than either of the other machines, has difficulty sustaining a large upload, and frequently drops out - for the MacBook only.
    This did not happen with 10.5.0 or 10.5.1 and does not happen with the machines running 10.4.x.
    The Airport Extreme Base is set to use 802.11b/g as one of the older machines can only handle 'b'...
    I have MAC screening set up and also WAP. Network is NOT 'hidden.'
    Airport Utility on the MacBook also has difficulty finding the base even when the MacBook is actually connected to it and using it to download mail. sigh
    The problem is something that changed in 10.5.2.
    Hope Apple gets this sorted soon!
    Tom

  • No "preferred network" selection!?!?

    G4 iBook running 10.4.8, trying to reconfigure after a little screwup. when i try to configure airport, the "by default, join" shows only "a specific network" choice. there is no "preferred network" choice, which is what i want. i have tried deleting the pref file, but i cannot get this choice to reappear.
    what to do???
    i have searched the forum for similar problems, but have not found anything relating to this specific issue, although i suspect it is there.

    Hi Jerome,
    Do you mean "Automatic"? Or that it shows just one network? I have never seen "a specific network" in the choices... Only Automatic or Preferred Networks...
    Is it greyed out? If it is, you might have to turn Airport back on before you can change it. Try clicking Apply Now, then open Internet Connect to turn Airport on.
    Guylaine
    By the way, just guessing here, this never happened to me... And just saw you have 345 posts, so unless they are all questions, you are more experienced than I am!

  • No signing in preferred network automatically...

    Hi, my airport is set to join in the preferred/remembered network automatically, and also set to ask if preferred netweok is not available. However, neither occured when I turn on the laptop (PB G4 12"). I waited for a few minutes, and it neither did connect to my home network automatically, nor did ask to join available/open network. I've checked all my settings. Is there something wrong with my airport or software. I hate to make this connection, but everything was fine until I got my notebook back for replacing a new lower case from Apple. Is it possible that they somehow messed up the airport while changing the case?? Your feedback is much appreciated. (I know this might not be a big deal, but it is getting really annoying that I have to connect to my home network manually every time.)

    How do you get to the preferred networks window? I'm looking at my Network pref pane and I don't see anything about preferred networks. I do see a menu to select a specific network to connect to, and it contains the same network names as the Airport menu in the menubar.

  • WP8 Selecting Prefered Network Provider when Roami...

    Hi,
    I have a Lumia 820 and I'm about to travel to another country....
    Would there be an option to select a prefered network provider when roaming?
    I'm unable to find an this option under "network+" or "mobile network" in settings..
    The reason for asking is that my current (home) network provider offers reduced roaming & data cost packages if I select specific network providers when abroad. My old "brick" phone allowed this option,or maybe the option will appear when I start roaming.
    Thanks, Murphys001

    When you arrive at your destination, goto Settings>mobile network>Network selection. The phone will start scanning for available networks. It will then list all available networks and all you have to do is to select the one you want. Don't forget to set it back to auto when you leave. 

  • Can't connect 802.1x wireless network

    I upgraded my MacBook to Leopard, and I can't connect to the 802.1x wireless network in our campus any more (It requires PEAP). I used to log on quickly and the speed was amazing compared to my Windows Laptop. But now, every time I try to connect to the network, the Leopard does not pop any window for user name and pwd any more. I tried all kinds of configuration in the "802.1x" bar in "Network Preference/AirPort/Advanced" option, and it did not work. And even worse, when I added the network into my "Preferred" and made configuration in "802.1x" option, and tried to select the preferred "Network Name", every time I did this, Leopard would freeze and crash.... What a nightmare!!
    I wonder if anybody else has the same problem with mine. I am driven crazy after two days trial.

    If you restored to factory settings/new iPod and still have the problem that indicates a hardware problem.
    Make an appointment at the Genius Bar of an Apple store..
    Apple Retail Store - Genius Bar

  • Macbook Pro no longer auto-connects to preferred network

    The title says it.
    While my computer connects automatically to some (maybe all but one) of my preferred networks, it now does not connect, annoyingly, to the one I use the most often (let's call it NET).
    I've triple checked that it's preferred and should connect automatically, and the computer remembers the password, so that if I manually select NET, it connects no problem. But:
    a) It won't auto-connect to NET, and
    b) If I turn my computer on, when it presents the list of networks to me, I have to wait for it to reload the list, cause if I click on NET originally, it doesn't connect, and I have to refresh the list and try again.
    c) Figured that might mean that it's just taking longer to load the networks and is showing me a list before it's actually picked up on the networks, but waiting forever doesn't make it autoconnect; it just refreshes the list.
    Any ideas? This is a huge pain.

    No idea. You could try deleting the file
    /Library/Preferences/SystemConfiguration/com.apple.airport.preferences.plist
    ... and restart your Mac.
    To find that file quickly, select the above path (triple-click the line), control-click to bring up the contextual menu, and select Services > Reveal. Drag that file to the Desktop, or directly to the Trash.
    This will completely erase your AirPort network preferences, requiring that you select your Wi-Fi network and authenticate again.
    What OS X version are you using, and are you using an Apple AirPort Base Station, or a third party product?

  • OS 10.8.5 Wi-Fi doesn't find "Preferred Network"

    We installed a new modem provided by Comcast that has built in wireless. After naming and establishing the password for the network, I successfully connected via my MacBook Pro, which detected it. Once connected I accessed the "Advanced Settings" screen in the Network control panel.
    Under the first "Wi-Fi" tab I dragged the new network to the top of the list of "Preferred Networks." I also confirmed that the "Remember networks this computer has joined" check-box was selected.
    Yet each time the computer wakes from sleep or is restarted the Wi-Fi utility scans for networks and doesn't connect to any. When I click on the control bar icon for Wi-Fi the network appears -- usually at the bottom of the list -- and when I click on it the computer connects immediately.
    Obviously this defeats the point of remembering preferred networks and is a nagging time-suck at the start of each work session. Has anyone else experienced this problem and discovered a solution?
    Thanks!!
    Joseph
    Washington, DC

    Hello Joseph_DC
    If you are having issues with it not connecting after waking from sleep, the check out the article below to troubleshoot the issue further. Check in the section Symptom: The network connection drops unexpectedly and there will be a solution just for that issue and will continue with going into Keychain Access the
    iPhone: Troubleshooting No Service
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ts4429
    Regards,
    -Norm G.

  • Hi, how do i stop my macbook pro not to automatically connect to a wifi connection that is not my preferred network? i want to automatically connect my macbook to my preferred network everytime i turn on my laptop. thank you.

    hi, how do i stop my macbook pro not to automatically connect to a wifi connection that is not my preferred network? i want to automatically connect my macbook to my preferred network everytime i turn on my laptop. thank you.

    System Preferences > Network > WiFi
    To give a network the highest priority, drag the name of the network to the top of the list. This is the network your computer will attempt to join first.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/PH13797

  • Why won't my Mac automatically connect to my preferred network?

    My router at home is one of my preferred networks but it won't connect automatically.  I always have to go up to the wifi menu and connect to Home manually.  Why won't it connect automatically?

    Try to drag the network to the top in the order of networks.
    System Preferences > Network > Advanced > Wi-Fi
    To delete the network,  select it and click "-" minus button underneath.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Java.lang.NullPointerException with FTP receiver

    Hi All, I have a java.lang.NullPointerException in the Runtime Workbench for my FTP Adapter, that is a receiver. At SXMB_MONI all the messages are successful. What this could be? Thanks in advance, Daniela

  • Double Click on ALV Grid

    Hi, I have this doubt regarding ALV grid display. I am displaying a list using REUSE_ALV_GRID_DISPLAY. I need to go to a transaction when i double click on a particular line on the output list based on the content of the 1st cell of that line. (ie if

  • Colors rendering differently to original final cut timeline

    i have color corrected all the shots in a video i am working on but when it comes to rendering the footage, everything comes out differently. i have used many different options to render out. share>youtube, export via qucktime conversion, and i have

  • Upgrade from BW 2.0B to BI 7.0

    Hi, Our customer is planning to upgrade their BW system from 2.0B to BI 7.0. (HW type SPARC64, OS: Solaris 9 DB: Oracle 9i ) I am preparing Prerequisites list for the same. One of the prerequisite says, if we are planning to upgrade the BW 2.0B syste

  • BI content specifically in the HR

    Hello, Can anyone please point me to documents for BI content specifically in the HR area its actual data contents, benefits, reports, and steps to implement. Thanks, Newbie