ActionTec + second router = port forwarding issue

I'm having an issue with port forwarding (or maybe routing) across a pair of routers with different subnets. I know just enough about networking to be dangerous, but I can't figure this out. Hopefully someone more knowledgeable here can assist me.
Here's how my network is currently setup:
1) Standard FIOS ActionTec MI424-WR Rev D router, using default 192.168.1.* subnet.
2) Added a second router (D-Link Wireless-N w/ Gigabit Ethernet) using the 192.168.2.* subnet.
3) A patch cable connects an ActionTec LAN port to the D-Link WAN port. 
4) Most of my computers connect to the D-Link router for faster network speeds (desktop PC, NAS, etc.)
5) Both routers are running DHCP and broadcasting different SSIDs. This is so I can have a private network for my personal data (192.168.2.*) and a guest network (192.168.1.*) that friends/family/guests can use. Basically, from the 192.168.2.* network, I can access any network resource on either subnet; the 192.168.1.* network, however, cannot (easily) access the resources on the other subnet. 
6) This setup works perfectly and has met all of my needs so far.
Now, the problem I'm running into:
I purchased a security camera to monitor my home over the internet while away. It is connected to the D-Link router and I can access the camera without issue while on the 192.168.2.* network. Everything works fine locally. However, I cannot access the camera from the internet.  For sake of ease, let's use the following example setup:
Internet IP = 74.1.2.3
Router 1 = 192.168.1.1
Router 2 = 192.168.2.1
Camera = 192.168.2.2
Camera Port = 12345
Accessing the camera locally via http://192.168.2.2:12345 works fine, but accessing it remotely via http://74.1.2.3:12345 does not. I assume a route or port forward needs to be set on Router 1 (the FIOS ActionTec)? Any help is greatly appreciated.
Thanks,
-Patrick
Solved!
Go to Solution.

For future viewers, I will throw this out there. You don't normally want two routers with two port forward rules. The best practice is to give the second router a static ip on the lan of the first router and then put the second router in the dmz of the first router, and then apply port forward uses to the dmz'd router.

Similar Messages

  • I'd like to get the best out my router (Port Forward issues)

    I'm using the WRT54G2 for the router and the wmp54G. I'm trying to get games like America's Army and Team Fortress 2 to work properly. I assigned all my pc's static Ip's using the portforward guide. I forwarded the necessary ports.
    I can't connect to my account on America's Army and I can't connect to any servers on Team Fortress 2. I've tried turning off my Anti-virus and firewall but still no luck. I'm trying to do this over the pc with the wireless connection.
    Any suggestions?
    I also have another question: when forwarding ports or using the DMZ option, what IP address do I forward to? The pc directly connected to the router or the pc that's trying to use the ports (the wireless one)?
    btw, MY ISP is Comcast
    Message Edited by xxkuronoxx on 12-09-2008 08:03 AM
    Message Edited by xxkuronoxx on 12-09-2008 08:03 AM
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    In most cases, you can use the proxy DNS server that is built into the router at 192.168.1.1  (default address), but in your case would be at 192.168.2.1
    Using the proxy DNS server is preferred.  The router keeps track of your ISP's actual Internet DNS server addresses, and forwards data to the appropriate DNS server.
    If the router's proxy DNS server does not work, then enter your true Internet DNS server address into your computer.
    Additionally, I see that you are using .101 and .102 addresses in your computers.  Your default DHCP server range is .100  thru .149 , so unless you changed it, you are using illegal fixed LAN IP addresses in your computers.  This might be the cause for your problems.  Note that all fixed LAN IP addresses must be outside your DHCP server range.

  • Quantum Gateway Port Forwarding issues

    This post can be removed.... the port forwarding worked once I set it up under "Advanced Settings -> Network Settings ->Port Forwarding" instead of "Firewall -> Port Forwarding"
    Hello,
    I am having an issue setting up port forwarding.  I have made several attempts to make port forward TCP 8096, but it continues not to work.  I had it working with no problems at my with my old router before we moved so I know it's not an issue with my computer firewall or antivirus and MediaBrowser is working fine on the local network. Is anyone else experiencing Port Forwarding issues?  Also when will DMZ be enabled on this gateway?
    Any help would be apprciated. I'm trying to setup MediaBrowser so I can schedule recordings when i'm not at home.
    Thanks!
    Armyb77
    This post can be removed

    See kayster contribution here.
    SYNOLOGY DS214 - Remote access via BT Home Hub
    There are some useful help pages here, for BT Broadband customers only, on my personal website.
    BT Broadband customers - help with broadband, WiFi, networking, e-mail and phones.

  • WRTU54G-TM Port Forward issues, DHCP server disabled but still gives out addresses

    I've seen other posts about port-forwarding issues.  I've had to hard-reset the device twice in 2 months to clear this up.
    One issue that I can't figure out at all is that the DHCP server gives out addresses when it is set to disabled.  This is a problem because it gives out the public DNS servers, which will not resolve addresses on my LAN.  Anyone else seen this?
    Anyone had success putting this router behind a better one and still getting the phone SIM to register and work? 

    Have you tried to upgrade the firmware on your Router?
    Click Download  the latest firmware for your Router and save the Firmware file on your Desktop. 
    Once you Download the firmware for your Router, Now you need to login to the Router setup page and click on the "Administration" tab and below click on "Firmware Upgrade" and then click on the Browse Button and select the firmware file and click on Upgrade. 
    Once the firmware is upgraded successfully then you need to Reset your Router and Re-configure all the settings on your Router from scratch. 

  • RV215W router port forwarding not working

    RV215W router port forwarding not working.
    Port forwarding works for a short period of time, then stops working.  Reboot router, works again for short period of time, then stops again.
    I have updated firmware to latest.  I had seen other similar bugs posted for 220 and I think 180, not sure if this router has similar bugs and waiting for fix release to firmware.
    I had recently purchased two, one deployed, will hold off on other now because of issues, and may have to move to different unit if a resolution not found this week.
    Dave Gritten
    IT Director
    Maritime Beauty
    3695 Barrington St
    Halifax NS  B3K 2Y3
    cell 902.223.9685
    phone 902.429.8510 ext231
    fax 902.422.7983
    [email protected]
    www.MaritimeBeauty.com

    It's not just single port forwarding that has bugs, the entire router has bugs and simply does not work as advertised. I have found the following bugs/aspects of this router that just does not work correctly: 1. If you have to open ports, and who doesn’t, this router will eventually stop accepting packets from WAN>LAN. You will still have Internet access but no open ports. A reboot will fix this problem. Oh, by the way, this router has no scheduled reboot option! <--That would be a workaround but a welcome one for this router. 2. Firewall Access rules do not work!! Yep, a Cisco router and basic functionality simply does not work. I called Cisco and even though the tech saw the router not working denied it was a bug! Said we have to do port mirroring, setup a workstation with WireShark and capture packets so we can debug the issues.  That would take several hours. I told him I would have appreciated if Cisco would have debugged the issues with their router BEFORE they shipped the units. Stay away from Cisco Small Business Routers. I wish I had. And if there are any Cisco die-hards out there willing to prove me wrong, just reply to this and please, prove me wrong that the RV series and specifically the RV215W is not JUNK.

  • Home Hub 3 Port Forwarding Issue - Question to BT

    Question to BT
    Hello i have recently joined BT Infinity and have hit the issue of the Port Forwarding not working. My HH3 is on the following version of software. Will this version automatically upgrade to the latest version of firmware and will this fix my port forwarding issue?
    As i work in IT (Cisco Network Eng) i need to be able to access several devices/services at home and this is a real pain for me. If you think that this could drag on as some posts have indicated could you please let me know and i will either get a draytek or throw in a cisco 1841.
    Thank you
    Dean.
    Current firmware:
    V100R001C01B031SP09_L_B
    Last updated:
    Unknown

    requiem wrote:
    Question to BT
    Hello i have recently joined BT Infinity and have hit the issue of the Port Forwarding not working. My HH3 is on the following version of software. Will this version automatically upgrade to the latest version of firmware and will this fix my port forwarding issue?.........
    Thank you
    Dean.
    Current firmware:
    V100R001C01B031SP09_L_B
    Last updated:
    Unknown
    Hi Dean
    By the look of it you've got the type B version of the HH3 with current firmware.
    From http://bt.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/13073
    The latest versions of the firmware are:
    BT Home Hub 3 – Software version 4.7.5.1.83.8.57.1.3 (Type A) or V100R001C01B031SP09_L_B
    Please Click On any Text in Blue as that automatically links to information.
    PC (NDEGR)

  • Post Moved Mac Port Forwarding Issues

    Post Moved to Other BB Queries http://community.bt.com/t5/Other-BB-Queries/Mac-Port-Forwarding-issues/td-p/550779
    If you want to say thanks for a helpful answer,please click on the Ratings star on the left-hand side If the reply answers your question then please mark as ’Mark as Accepted Solution’

    Does this help...?
    http://community.bt.com/t5/Other-BB-Queries/Port-forwarding-and-Loopback-DO-work-YMMV/m-p/538328

  • RV016 Wired 16 Port Cisco Router Port Forwarding Functions

    Thank you for your time. I have created and attached a Word Document discussing the Cisco Model RV016 16 port wired Router port forwarding functions for your review. I would appreciate your time in reviewing it with your comments and suggestions.
    Thank you very much,
    Eddie LeFiles
    850-471-1271

    Thank you for your time. I have created and attached a Word Document discussing the Cisco Model RV016 16 port wired Router port forwarding functions for your review. I would appreciate your time in reviewing it with your comments and suggestions.
    Thank you very much,
    Eddie LeFiles
    850-471-1271

  • WVC54GCA - Port forwarding issue

    I recently purchased a Linksys WVC54GCA as a 2nd camera (I already have a wired Panasonic BLC1a, which works well internally and externally) I setup the Linksys camera using a separate static IP address and port 1025. I'm sure I'm doing something stupid,  but the only way I can access them through the Internet is to enable one, and disable the other in my router port forwarding. I have to forward port 80 to port 1025 to get the Linksys to work, which of course knocks off the Panasonic . I'd appreciate any thoughts anyone may.
    I've setup through TZO , DYNDNS an Viewnetcam and all have the same issue

    That's what I thought and figured the worse thing that would happen is I would use Viewnetcam.com for Cam1, and TZO for Cam2 if I had to. 
    Cam1 (Panasonic) I have set as 192.xxx.xx.150
    Cam2 (Linksys) I have set as 192.xxx.xx.151 and Port 1025
    If I do nothing with Port forwarding in my router I can get to Cam1 through Viewnetcam. If I forward port 1025 to 1025 for Cam2 (which I thought this is what I'd have to do) Cam1 still works, Cam2 doesn't. If I forward Port 80 to 1025 for Cam2, then Cam2 works, but Cam1 doesn't. (If I go to VIewnetcam I see Cam2, and if I go to TZO I see CAM2. I don't see Cam1 at all) I setup a 3rd DNS ay DynDNS just to see if that made a difference and it works the same as the other two. 
    I keep thinking it's got to be something dumb I'm doing since the obviously both work from outside if I forward Port 80 to 1025 for Cam2, or Disable that and Cam1 comes back up) 

  • Actiontec MI424WR rev I port forwarding issue.

    Within the last month, all of my wireless security cameras as well as my Directv DVR have stopped responding to remote access. All of the cameras work fine when directly connected to an e-net cable. I have checked all the settings on the router and they have not changed. I then tried to check the ports assigned to the cameras and found that they are all reported as CLOSED by two different internet port checkers. However, these same port checkers report eveything closed on this router., but my browser, email, remote desktop all work ok. Before I tear any more hair out, can some one have pity on an old fart and tell me what I have overlooked????
    KentM
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    I had a session with a VZW tech who in turn brought an Actiontec tech on the line. What we did was to delete all of the current camera rules and reinstall them. Everything now works. ????? 
    THe one remaining issue regards the port checkers that show all the well known ports closed. We never came up with an answer to that. But they are not stopping anything from working. One other item regarding the camera ports. If the camera is not on for some reason, then the port will show that it is closed...
    CaptainSTX wrote:
    Not that I have an answer for your question but misery always loves company.
    The prior firmware update for the Actiontec knocked out the automatic update  using DynamicDNS.
    The 10/31 update fixed the problem of updating DynamicDNS  however it seems to have done something to port forwarding. 
    Prior to the last two updates of the Actiontec's firmware I used to be able to run an FTP server on a USB drive connected to a router double NATed behind the Actiontec.    I was also able to remotely access certain devices using port forwarding from the Actiontec.   Not working anymore.
    Based on your problem I think it is a firmware issue with the Actiontec and there may be nothing that can be done until the next firmware update.

  • WRT1900 Port Forward Issue

    Im hoping this can be resolved quickly. Last night I found out my NAT on xbox one is set to moderate.
    And I am having trouble following port forward quides.
    I reserved a DHCP for my xbox one in network map and seemed to switch to Open NAT not sure if this fixed the party issue I was having earlier.
    Moving on if I am to forward the ports do I go to port range forwarding and use the IP address reserved from the network map?
    Essentially is a static IP and a reserved DHCP the same thing?

    Try to disable the dlink camera then try to use the websites like: www.mydomainname.com,  www.mydomainname.com:81,  www.mydomainname.com:80, and others to see where they are getting directed.
    Second let me know the IP address of NAS, Web Server and the Camera..As well as try to disable the UpnP in the Router web UI..

  • Router Port Forwarding not working since Mavericks

    I have an iMac sat behind a BT Home Hub 3 (an ADSL router, if you're not aware), with several ports (POP3, SSH, HTTP, etc) from the outside world forwarded via the hub to my Mac. Since installing Mavericks (from Snow Leopard), NONE of these ports are now open.
    They're open on the Mac, and another machine on my home network can use them locally, but from outside the network, they're hidden. Shields Up shows them as Stealth.
    Things I've tried:
    Rebooting everything.
    Setting the Home Hub up again, forwarding all the ports again.
    Turning all the sharing off in Mavericks and then back on.
    Trying the same services on different ports.
    Trying different services.
    Turning off the Mac firewall.
    Turning off the router firewall.
    Trying the Mac on another IP address and reforwarding everything to the new one.
    Putting the Mac in the DMZ.
    I can forward ports to other devices on my network (e.g. my NAS) and they work fine, so port forwarding isn't completely broken on the router
    Here's the thing though...
    On a completely separate network, on a separate Mac (a 2012 MacBook Pro) that went from Mountain Lion to Mavericks, also behind a BT Home Hub 3, EXACTLY the same thing is happening. No ports can be forwarded to the MacBook Pro, but all the ports are open to the local network.
    Any ideas? I'm pretty sure this must be a bug in Mavericks as I can't see anything else it can be.

    It's not just single port forwarding that has bugs, the entire router has bugs and simply does not work as advertised. I have found the following bugs/aspects of this router that just does not work correctly: 1. If you have to open ports, and who doesn’t, this router will eventually stop accepting packets from WAN>LAN. You will still have Internet access but no open ports. A reboot will fix this problem. Oh, by the way, this router has no scheduled reboot option! <--That would be a workaround but a welcome one for this router. 2. Firewall Access rules do not work!! Yep, a Cisco router and basic functionality simply does not work. I called Cisco and even though the tech saw the router not working denied it was a bug! Said we have to do port mirroring, setup a workstation with WireShark and capture packets so we can debug the issues.  That would take several hours. I told him I would have appreciated if Cisco would have debugged the issues with their router BEFORE they shipped the units. Stay away from Cisco Small Business Routers. I wish I had. And if there are any Cisco die-hards out there willing to prove me wrong, just reply to this and please, prove me wrong that the RV series and specifically the RV215W is not JUNK.

  • EA2700 port forwarding issues for DVR access

    So start this off I searched these forums for answers and new here but not to the router world, I have been having issues lately I set up a DVR and need to view remotely, ports are 7000 and 8080, I setup DVR on a static IP and it can access the internet and I can ping the DVR internally than I go into router and port forward those ports on DVR's IP address disabled upnp I setup dhcp reservation on DVR's IP but when I check can you see me.org it shows those ports are closed for my external than I check port 80 and shows closed looks like all my ports are close is there some firewall in this router that would do this please help

    If the ISP modem has a built in router, it's best to bridge the modem. Having 2 routers on the same line can cause connection problems: Link>http://www.practicallynetworked.com/networking/fixing_double_nat.htm and http://cognitiveanomalies.com/cisco-nat-how-nat-works/. If the modem can't be bridged then see if the modem has a DMZ option and input the IP address the router gets from the modem and put that into the modems DMZ. 
    Glad you got it working. Enjoy. 
    loginix wrote:
    So start this off I searched these forums for answers and new here but not to the router world, I have been having issues lately I set up a DVR and need to view remotely, ports are 7000 and 8080, I setup DVR on a static IP and it can access the internet and I can ping the DVR internally than I go into router and port forward those ports on DVR's IP address disabled upnp I setup dhcp reservation on DVR's IP but when I check can you see me.org it shows those ports are closed for my external than I check port 80 and shows closed looks like all my ports are close is there some firewall in this router that would do this please help

  • Bit Torrent port forwarding issue and DNS resoluti...

    Good morning comunity!
    Something odd has happened and I was hoping for some further guidance as I'm not sure what my next steps are.
    Background
    I have uTorrent running on a a machine that accesses a private RSS feed of torrents I am watching. The client sees a new file posting and automaticlly downloads the .torrent file then proceeds to download the main file itself.
    When I had BT installed back on 23 Decemeber I set up port forwarding to this machine, using a static IP, and there were no connection issues.
    What has happened
    The previous evening as I was going to bed I checked the machine and the active torrents and all my files were sitting at 0 connections for connected seeds & peers. Meaning that uTorrent wasn't able to see anyone to conenct to. 
    My Troubleshooting
    After seeing the above I began checking my connections and set up on the router as well as the machine. uTorrent has within its preferences a port checking utility for its assinged port and that was showing no open connection. I then logged in to my HH4 and verifed my port forwarding rules: nothing had changed there.
    I removed and re-added the rules, turned off UPNP as well as turned it on with no success. And during the process of adding the rule back into the system I recieved an error stating that the port was already assigned even though at that moment there were no active assignments. So I changed port numbers and the issue went away.
    I then went to chack the private torrent site and the page would not display. Then went to Down For Everyone Or Just Me to check the site as well and it was reported as being up. I loaded my VPN connection to bypass BT's network and I was able to visit the site. Logged back out and did a trace and the trace reported to route to the site. Changed my DNS to Google's DNS setting and was able to access the site.
    Where I am now
    My torrent machine is now running via the VPN but it's not the best connection in the world as changing the DNS there did not resolve the torrent connection issue.
    Does anyone, especially you folkd familar with BT and their practices, have reccomendations as to what to try next or what the issue may be?

    A lot of torrent sites are starting to be blocked. Its possible the site in question is being blocked by BT(They have no choice in this as its being forced onto them by a court order same for most of the other big ISPs). If its being blocked you would still be able to access via a VPN so long as thats not being blocked too. In terms of what you can do about it not much other than keep using the VPN.

  • Remote Coding nd Port Forwarding Issue

    I have Verizon FIOS Westall 9100 Router.
    I am trying to set up remote coding for Port 6801 and my host IP 192.168.1.9 DHCP address.
    I set up port forwarding - all TCP and UDP  to  Port 6801 to 192.168.1.9 and it shows as active with no conflicts.
    Problem is that when my remote coding was attempted, the technician said the port is blocked. We tried for over an hour and also checked online through a port forwarding tool and it said it is blocked. I checked firewall router and it is on medium security which was recommended.
    Can someone help me through this issue and make a recommendation to solve the problem?
    Thanks in advance.

    Did you define the source and destination ports?
    that router is finicky, it only likes it if the destination is defined
    IOW it should look like this
    192.168.1.9   
               TCP ANY -> 6801
    If that ANY is a number, it likely will not work

Maybe you are looking for

  • Kde 4.2 won't login after xorg-server-1.6.1.901-1 upgrade

    I upgraded my system this afternoon, but when the upgrade completed all my window decorations were gone and plasma as down.  I restarted kde from virtual console 1 and the login screen was brought up.  Now when i go to login i get stuck in an endless

  • Serial Number does not work. Help needed!

    Hello! I am attempting to reinstall CS4 on my machine at work. Initially I experienced error 147:20 a few weeks ago, and I ran their LicenseRecovery.exe tool, and that did not clear anything up. So, then I ran the Adobe CS Cleaner Tool and uninstalle

  • Add cell border to spry menu bar

    Hello, I need help with editing a style sheet for a Spry menu bar I made in Dreamweaver CS3. All I need to do is to add a thin (1px) dark gray border to the cells on the main navigation bar. Is there a bit of code I have to change/insert in the style

  • IDVD not showing in Spotlight

    For some reason iDVD does not appear in Spotlight. All other applications show, only iDVD is missing. I have to manually open iDVD from the Application folder. I couldn't find any clues on this forum as to why this is happening. Anyone got any ideas?

  • I have a partition for OS Snow and for OS Lion

    When i try to create a bootcamp partition it gives me this message The startup disk must be formatted as a single Mac OS Extended (Journaled) volume or already partitioned by Boot Camp Assistant for installing Windows.