Adding internal drives-Apple store: $329 vs everywhere else: $105-163 ?

I have a Mac Pro. Bought it 1 year ago. Sys Profiler tells me:
Processor: 2 x 2.66 GHz Dual-Core Intel Xeon
Memory: 2 GB 677 MHz DDR2 FB-DIMM
Disk Utility tells me my two internal hard drives are as follows:
ST3500641AS P Media
(which I think is: Seagate ST3500641AS 500GB SATA/300 7200RPM 16MB Hard Drive)
WDC WD2500JS-41SGB0 Media
(which I think is: Western Digital Caviar SE SATA Hard Drive 250 GB, 3 Gb/s, 8 MB Cache, 7200 RPM)
I want to add storage. My reason is I now use external firewire drives for photo, video files I work on day to day and I’ve noticed erratic behavior when running two or more. So I want to run from internal drives and use the externals for backup. However, when I look at what to get, I am stumped by the radical variations in prices for what seem like same or similar drives.
Here’s an example:
At the Apple store I get this:
Apple Hard Drive for Mac Pro - 500GB Serial ATA 3Gb/s
A 500GB Serial ATA 3Gb-per-second Apple Hard Drive operating at 7,200 revolutions per minute. Works with Mac Pro. Price: $329.00
Elsewhere I get this:
500GB Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 SATA II 7200RPM 16MB Buffer W/ Perpendicular Drive Technology. New w/5 Year Seagate Warranty! (SEAST3500630AS) $149.
Seagate/Barracuda 7200.10/500GB /7200/16MB/Serial ATA-300 /OEM Hard Drive $119
And this:
WD Caviar SE16 500GB Hard Drive
(Serial ATA-300, 7,200 RPM, 16MB - MPN: WD5000AAKS)
Price Range: $105.99 - $163.16 from 31 Sellers
Can anyone advise me on this? Thanks.
noodle--head

Hatter
Thanks for the recommendations. Regards the Barefeats benchmarks, I've spend some time trying to find the 10 drives test. I started trying to find this when I saw your mention of it in another post. The closest I come are these: "SHOOTOUT: Quad Xeon 3.0GHz Mac Pro versus Quad G5 2.5GHz Power Mac. Originally posted August 10th, 2006." And "SHOOTOUT: What's the Fastest Boot Drive for the Mac Pro? Originally posted August 17th, 2006." But these are a year ago. In any case, based on the latter, they say: "the overall fastest single 7200rpm drive was the MaXLine Pro 500GB. The second fastest 7200rpm drive overall was the Hitachi 7K500."
Can you shed some light on how come you'd go with the WD Caviar? At OWC, they list: 500GB Maxtor MaXLine Pro 500 SATA II 3.0Gb Hard Drive-Enterprise class, 16MB Buffer, 7200RPM. $99. (What's Enterprise?). Any reason for not going with that?

Similar Messages

  • Adding Internal Drives

    Hi,
    I'm new to Macs and hope you guy's out there can help me. I have emailed WD, and spoken to Apple support without success and spent hours looking through discussion group threads trying to find an answer to what appears to be a simple question;
    Which internal drives are compatible to the MacPro 4.1 (2009)?
    My main concern is that all the Apple stuff refers to screwing the internal drive (Apple Store variety) to the carrier and sliding it into place(cable not required). So far so good. But when I look at Western Digital web site (and others) I see that it is suggested that a cable is required connecting the drive to motherboard.
    To me as an engineer (retired) these are not compatible if the drive does not fit A) onto the supplied carriers and B) there is a cable connection!
    Please, I'd like you techie guy's help me understand what suppliers don't want to to tell me about compatibility How can I tell if the drive will fit the carrier, is the cable required, and will a cable prevent assembly?
    Is this an Apple way of shutting out the competition!

    .........Which is why I put 'certain'. Thanks for the rude reply, I understand exactly what I have read.
    What is to stop the OP taking a drive out of a MyBook? ( as I have done-I use it for storage only). We don't know what other hardware he has or what else he is going to do with it. That's why I included the link so that he could read and understand it in it's entirety which is something you don't appear to have done with my post. If I had known about any well known Seagate/Lacie issues I would have included links to those too.
    The OP mentioned WD so I pointed him in what I thought was the direction of a useful FYI. He reads, he makes his choice, he returns to clarify if necessary.
    Message was edited by: gumsie

  • I just used "Erase" via "Find my phone" to erase and rest my MBP. It's caused my MBP to be locked. I entered correct 4 digit PIN and it seemed to accept it, but it won't allow use of the internal drive. Yosemite loaded. Anyone else had same problem?

    I just used "Erase" via "Find my phone" to erase and reset my MBP. It's caused my MBP to be locked. I entered correct 4 digit PIN and it seemed to accept it, but it won't allow use of the internal drive. Yosemite loaded. Anyone else had same problem?

    Greetings Fraser Alexander,
    Erasing your Mac shouldn't harm your internal hard drive but erasing does clear Yosemite and everything else off of it.  Are you not able to restore it with your Time Machine backup?
    iCloud: Erase your device
    If you erase then find your Mac, you can restore the information on the Mac using a Time Machine backup. For more information, see the Apple Support article Recover your entire system. If you set an EFI firmware password on your Mac before it was lost, then erase it and later find it, you may need to take your Mac to an authorized repair center to unlock it before you can use it again.
    OS X Yosemite: Recover your entire system
    Take care,
    Nubz

  • 2 TB Internal Drive Apple installed ejects improperly

    This happens when I put my 2012 iMac to sleep. I'm running Lion 10.7.5, with 2 internal drives. The 2TB was installed by Apple, a Hitiachi HDS723020BLA642 firmware version MN0KB6D0. When it ejects and I get the error message I can only get it back by restarting. Disk Doctor can't see it to mount it. I have 2 Seagate external drives attached USB2, one for Time Machine. I've had the iMac since June 2012. The problem started 1-2 months ago but has gotten more frequent recently. I'm a graphic artist and decided to get the internal so I didnot have to worry about files disappearing because a drive won't mount. I figured and internal would solve that problem. It did not. Now I'm worried I may lose my work because of what's happening. Is anyone having this problem? I don't have the energy saver put the drives to sleep so it isn't that. Maybe a firmware update?

    Hitachi HDS723020BLA642:
      Capacity:          2 TB (2,000,398,934,016 bytes)
      Model:          Hitachi HDS723020BLA642                
      Revision:          MN0KB6D0
      Serial Number:                MN1270FA05U8KD
      Native Command Queuing:          Yes
      Queue Depth:          32
      Removable Media:          No
      Detachable Drive:          No
      BSD Name:          disk1
      Rotational Rate:          7200
      Medium Type:          Rotational
      Partition Map Type:          GPT (GUID Partition Table)
      S.M.A.R.T. status:          Verified
      Volumes:
    disk1s1:
      Capacity:          209.7 MB (209,715,200 bytes)
      BSD Name:          disk1s1
      Content:          EFI
    In_Progress:
      Capacity:          500.1 GB (500,100,001,792 bytes)
      Available:          123.87 GB (123,870,728,192 bytes)
      Writable:          Yes
      File System:          Journaled HFS+
      BSD Name:          disk1s2
      Mount Point:          /Volumes/In_Progress
      Content:          Apple_HFS
    Media_Catch:
      Capacity:          765 GB (765,000,003,584 bytes)
      Available:          564.39 GB (564,387,356,672 bytes)
      Writable:          Yes
      File System:          Journaled HFS+
      BSD Name:          disk1s3
      Mount Point:          /Volumes/Media_Catch
      Content:          Apple_HFS
    Archive:
      Capacity:          734.69 GB (734,686,519,296 bytes)
      Available:          734.06 GB (734,055,845,888 bytes)
      Writable:          Yes
      File System:          Journaled HFS+
      BSD Name:          disk1s4
      Mount Point:          /Volumes/Archive
      Content:          Apple_HFS

  • Hard drive run OS X 10.6.8 and an added internal drive run OS X 10.8?

    I want to run two OS X's on my computer so that I won't have to spend $1000+ to upgrade all my software.  I have OS X 10.6.8 on my Mac Pro hard drive now but would like to add an internal hard drive that runs only OS X 10.8.  Is this possible to do?  If so, how do I go about it?

    The Cheese Gratter Mac Pro (I used to own one), has room for four drive lots for 3.5" internal disk drives.  It is rather easy.
    <http://www.everymac.com/systems/apple/mac_pro/faq/mac-pro-how-to-upgrade-hard-dr ives-what-type-supported.html>
    <http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_xGaTmz2Kk>
    Once the new 3.5" internal drive is installed, you then use Disk Utility to format the drive. 
    Disk Utility
    select the drive on the left
    Select the "Partition" tab on the right
    Select "Options"
    Specify GUID (this is needed if you are going to boot from this drive)
    Click OK/Apply
    Decide if you want 1 partition, or more.  If more than 1, size and name each partition.
    Click Apply
    Now install your operating system.   I would suggest making a copy of the "Install OS X Mountain Lion" installer, as the installer will delete itself when it is finished.  If you make a copy before you install, it will delete the copy you are running, and you can use the original again if you need to re-install, or want to install Mountain Lion on other boot disks or systems you own or control (aka Family).
    If you have created more than 1 partition, you can install other operating system versions on those partitions or use them for data.
    You should have 2 more empty drive slots.  You can add more 3.5" disks.  If you have not been doing backups yet, I would suggest installing additional disks in those slots for backups.
    Once you have your 2nd (3rd, 4th, 5th, etc...) operating system installed, you can use System Preferences -> Startup Disk to specify which operating system you want to boot the next time you boot.
    OR you can boot holding the "Option" key, and the Mac will boot listing every bootable disk/partition and you can click on the partition you wish to boot from.
    Hopefully, when you boot up via the "Option" key, you will see a "Recovery" Partition for the Mountain Lion (10.8).  If you do not see a "Recovery" partition, you should start over and create 1 extra 2GB partition on the new drive that can be used for the Mountain Lion "Recovery" partition.

  • Adding Internal Drives to G5

    I need more space on my G5.
    Currently I have the original 80G Hard drive that came with it, and an added 200G internal drive. I work with video and am constantly having to delete old projects in order to make room for new ones.
    As I understand it, the G5 will only allow for 2 internal drives. One being the start up drive (which should hold all applications/Library/Ect.) and then another "scratch" drive for actual projects (i.e. video/audio capture). Am I correct?
    I am a novice still trying to understand what/what not to put where. All I know is that I work with hours of video and am in desparate need of more space. So any suggestions/advice you may have will be greatly appreciated.
    G5   Mac OS X (10.3.9)   1.6 Ghz Power PC 1.25 G Memory

    Trade up ;-(
    You are working with a G5 1.6 single cpu. No PCI-X, and PCI bus has a bug that limits disk writes to 75MB/sec with any PCI card interface (SATA, SCSI etc).
    I would forget the 80GB for work and put it aside for now, and invest in 500GB drive. Would be nice to build an external SATA RAID.
    There are some internal dual and triple drive bracket kits that run off SATA controllers as well - you ought to have ample room for one (or two).
    But I always thought that working with video it was very helpful to have dual cpu or better.
    Any investment in SATA drive would help now and later, but I would look at G5 2.3 Dual Core or something too.
    A boot drive, media drive, scratch can be a drive or drives set up in RAID. Even a FW800 and FW400 for backup, archive, capture etc.
    Some drives like Seagate 7200.10 750GB would be nice, but you need to upgrade to 10.4.6+. Also, my guess is that you would notice things run better with 2-4GB RAM. Definitely more than 1.25, probably double that.

  • Added Internal Drive as Eject option !! But why??

    Recently I added a 1TB internal drive to my PowerMac G4. The drive is operating as expected. However, I have the option to "Eject" the drive. This is my first Mac with multiple internal drives. Is this normal functionality to be able to "Eject" an internal drive? Is there a way to disable the "Eject" option on the drive.
    For those of you wonder how I connected a 1TB drive into my G4.
    I purchased from MacMall a Seagate 1TB BARRACUDA 7200.11 1TB INT SATA NCQ HD which obviously has a SATA connection. I then purchase a SATA to IDE converter from Cooldrives.com ($17). That permitted my SATA drive to connect to the internal IDE cable.
    Thanks in advance for your help.
    John
    Message was edited by: DaddyR

    Yes that is perfectly normal. All drives can be 'ejected' even internal ones. Even if you drag your boot drive to the trash (but don't let go) it will show the eject icon aswell.

  • I purchased iTunes $15 card at Dollar Store.  I recall entering the code somewhere but was not able to access iTunes . What can I do to get the card added to my Apple store account .

    I have misplaced the card or accidentally threw it away! I recall entering the code on back somewhere in my apple store app. Is there a way to find out if I did it right? If I did not do it correctly can u help me? Pleeeease!!

    Launch the App store or iTunes store...scroll all the way to the bottom...your Apple ID & any credit balance will be displayed. If not there, & you no longer have the card, don't waste your time contacting iTunes support, as there is nothing they can do for you.
    You can also login to iTunes on your computer, & any credit balance will be displayed next to your Apple ID.

  • 3G can catch wifi in apple store but not anywhere else

    So I upgraded my 3G to OS4.0 a few weeks ago and like many others have experienced, my wifi has gone DEAD right after the upgrade. No networks show up whatsoever. I have spent hours going through this forum and google, only to find out that there's no solution for it and some have even resorted to putting the phone in the freezer
    I was just about to give up on the problem thinking it's a hardware issue, but today I happen to pass an apple store. I explained my problem to one of the Apple consultants and as soon as he touched it there was the wifi!!! He didn't understand why it didn't work at my dorm (on college campus) and told me to come back and try.
    So here I am back at my dorm again with the same old problem - it can't find any wifi. This is getting really frustrating and I do hope I can find a solution for it. The fact that it worked at Apple Store shows that it's not a hardware issue, but what is it!!! It was able to find my campus network before I upgraded it, so I don't think it has anything to do with campus network having a weak signal. Arghhhh I hate apple. If anyone knows how to solve this please please let me know.

    So I tried using my macbook pro to share internet to the iphone, and the phone can detect the network! I'm guessing my campus network and several hundred other networks around me are too far to be detected? But how close must you be for it to work!? it's unbelievable that I live right in the city where there are hundreds of wifi detected on my laptop but none on my iphone

  • Adding Internal Drives to Apple Intel PCs (iMac 17")

    Is it possible to replace my internal SATA HD (160GB) with an internal IDE HD (260GB)?
    Is there even an IDE connector on the logicboard?

    No.  The iMac only supports SATA drives.

  • My apple password no longer works in the app store but works everywhere else, what is going on?

    Hello,
    For some reason, when I attempt to update the apps on my iPhone 5, the password is rejected.  I went to the apple website and reset my password.  Everything looks find on the website.  I then attempt to update the apps again from my iPhone and the password is rejected again.  I then tried to update the apps using iTunes, and the password was still rejected... What gives?  Any ideas?
    Thanks,

    See http://www.maclife.com/article/news/itunes_store_users_being_kicked_out_accounts _fatal_error
    Right now the ability to sign in to the App Store is not functioning. Apple is aware of the issue, but says cannot give a time frame as to win it will be fixed.  Has been ongoing since Wednesday afternoon

  • Adding Internal Drives in QuickSilver

    System has default drive in Bay 1 bottom (Seagate 60GB ATA).
    This is connected to primary Bus - ATA/66.
    Goal: to add two new 250GB ATA drives (Maxtor), and Mirror them.
    Ideally, I'd want to move the System disk (the 60GB Seagate) to the slower ATA/33 bus, location - where I removed the ZIP drive from.
    Okay, fine, that works.
    Then, I put the two new drives on the faster ATA/66 bus. Startup, I get the grey screen with the symbol on it - circle with a slash through it (like NO SMOKING).
    What is my problem?
    Thanks!
    933 MHz PowerPC G4, 1.5 GB SDRAM   Mac OS X (10.4.7)   Server

    Hi, Paul!
    Things to check...
    The optical drive should be jumpered as Master (it should already be so configured) with the Seagate jumpered as slave. (A Seagate configured as slave has no jumper pin present.)
    One Maxtor should have the jumper removed completely (slave). The other should have the pin inserted vertically across the leftmost two pins in the jumper block, as you face the pin end of the drive with the label/top of the drive facing upward (Master).
    Once configured properly, either do a PMU reset while the Mac is open, or do a PRAM reset before booting the first time. Once booted, launch Disk Utility and initialize/format the new drives.
    You must have Boot ROM version 4.3.3f2 on your QS2002 (see the System Profiler) to natively run the 250GB drives at full size/capacity on the built-in drive bus. If you have any other version, the drives will be limited to 128GB after formatting.
    Gary
    ps: You do realize that the optical drive bus runs with a max throughput of only 16.7MB/sec, right? Moreover, you might run into burning issues if you're planning to use the Seagate as the startup volume on that bus.
    1GHz DP G4 Quicksilver 2002, 400MHz B&W rev.2 G3, Mac SE30   Mac OS X (10.4.5)   5G iPod, Epson 2200 & R300 & LW Select 360 Printers, Epson 3200 Scanner

  • I want to buy an iphone 4s unlocked at apple store online and someone else at the hotel is going to receive the package for me, what should I do?

    I am from Brazil and I am going to USA in the end of the year. I know it takes 1-2 weeks to ship the iphone 4s, so I will buy it and send it to the hotel address . They will keep my package until I arrive.
    What do I have to do? Give an authorization or something like that?
    Thanks

    To buy from the Apple USA online store, you will need a credit card with a USA billing address - you cannot use a foreign credit card with a foreign billing address associated with it.  While you can ship to a hotel address in care of your name, you must make sure the Hotel will accept the package for you and secure it for you.  You may have other problems with that too.  if Apple cannot verify the address or anything about it makes them suspect a forwarding agent,they may refuse to ship to that address.

  • Still No Network Drives Showing in Bridge but Everywhere else?

    I am still somewhat confused because if I go to open a file in CS4 I have the option to browse my network; there is a network icon there and as soon as I click on it my network is immediately accessible. When I open up Lightroom to import pictures I have the same network icon and as soon as I click on that the network is again just there.
    However when I open up Bridge, it says building criteria and when it has finished it only shows me the drives attached to the computer I am currently using and there is no network icon to click on, so why is this the case when Photoshop can see it and so can Lightroom?
    Can anyone figure this out because it just does not make sense!

    The issue with your artwork not showing is due to the size of your artwork - I asked Apple to take a look at your artwork - please don't change anything at this time.
    We will get back to you once all is fixed or if there is something you need to change.
    Regards,
    Rob W
    libsyn

  • Will apple store look at somebody else's ipad?

    Hi Guys,
    This week my girlfriend's parents found that the screen on their ipad mini has multiple lines across it / and is off centre.  they are currently in the US the week.  I've booked it into the Sheffield Store (the warranty expires in March 2015), I have all the original payment details etc - will Apple deal with me in the absence of the owner?  Hopefully so but I'd like to clarify one way or the other before going into store!  It seems very difficult to ask Apple non-technical related questions like this. 
    Cheers,
    Rich

    Call the store and ask them. This is a user forum hosted by Apple. We really can't answer that question for you since we are all just users.

Maybe you are looking for

  • How can I combine calendars in iCal after move to iCloud

    At some point, I got duplicate calendars on my Mac and on MobileMe. Now I've moved to iCloud. How do you combine these? I know there would be many duplicates if all the events from one were added to the other. Thanks very much for your help. Jason

  • Using J2SE Version 5.0 with Oracle E-Business Suite 11i [ID 304099.1]

    Hi hussein, EBS 11i upgrade to Db 11gR2 RHEL 4.6 We are required to upgrade the J2SE to 5.0. The notes said download it from http://java.sun.com/j2se/1.5.0/download.jspBut when I click this site I only see Download Java EE SDK 5.0 Update 1 for Linux

  • Table based on one data service but filtered by a second data service

    Hi, I'm fairly new to VC and have got comfortable with a few simple scenarios. However, I'm trying to apply some fundamental logic that must be possible and I'm guessing straight forward. I have a data service that contains document type master data

  • Using External Variable - Server configuration

    Hi everyone! My question now is: For each screenflow and every JSP files I have to use the form ACTION field to send the URL. Is there a way to invoke the external component (the URL) by some "external Resource", so i can configure this field quick &

  • Link between the Cost element - PA segment

    Hi, I have an issue with a document which cannot be transferred to Accounting because the combination "cost element 611532 and PA object" is not possible. I have checked the validation rule "combination cost element - PA segment" which refers to a cu