Airport Extreme with 6 TB Drive vs. Drobo vs. NAS?

I am looking for system design advice in preparation for a new Mac Pro set up.
Long story short- I am a semi-professional photographer.  I shoot 1 - 2 TB a year (Nikon D800 and various other bodies).  I currently have a 24" iMac (2007) and a MacBook Pro (2008) that are WELL past their prime.  I have at least 8 TB of external drives with all of my previous years of Aperture libraries connected to my iMac which is my primary machine.
My question-
I am looking to have my previous Aperture libraries accessible to all of my machines and have a central storage solution. 
I am looking opinions on placing a new Airport Extreme with a 6 TB external drive connected to it with my previous libraries (which do not change) on it and have it Time Machine backup my current photo library and system nightly.  I do not require fast access to my previous libraries or fast backups.
I have off site backups of all my libraries and I backup my current stuff monthly offsite.
My new MacPro set-up will likely have a 4-6 TB G Tech drive attached to it for fast access for video projects etc.
I want all my photos accessibl, a current onsite backup… and I want it all automated- no input at all… and I don’t want a big huge mess of RAID drives and worries of multiples drives all over the place.
What would most of you suggest?
Drobo? NAS? … any help is appreciated.
Thanx

Thank you for the replies. 
My predicament can’t be unique. I need a large chunk of connected, stable and slow storage that seldom gets used but is safe and sound… and I need a safe automatic backup of my current projects (but never am I so stressed that every nanosecond of data is replicated on the moon at the speed of light…).
I have witnessed massive Drobo failures and oddly been thankful that I had a mess of several external drives on my desk.
The other challenge is that my new system will be installed in a location that has no easy way of connecting to the wired network in my house…
Should I go with an Airport Extreme to increase the wifi speed a bit in the house and an attached Drobo 5D to the new machine?

Similar Messages

  • AirPort Extreme with USB hard drive

    Hi...I have an AirPort Extreme with a Maxtor OneTouch 250MB hard drive attached (via USB port). I have two computers which access the internet and the hard drive through the AirPort.
    The first computer is a 1.8 GHz PowerPC G5 (with 3GB of SDRAM). The second is a 2 GHz Intel Core2 Duo IMac (with 4GB of SDRAM).
    Both computers have full signal strength via AirPort and both computers have no connection/speed issues with the internet. It's when trying to copy to/from the USB disk that there are problems. The older Mac, the G5, has no problems at all. Great copy speeds in both directions, I can even work off of files on the USB disk without a problem.
    The iMac, though, has a problem writing to/from the external hard disk. It connects without a problem, but after that, things come to a standstill.
    For example, I can copy a 25MB file from the AirDisk to the G5 in about 15 seconds. If I try to copy the same file to the iMac, it takes as long as 5 minutes. I've tried every setting I can in AirPort Utility, including trying each of the channels individually, and nothing helps. I've disconnected the G5 from the network and that didn't make a difference, either.
    Other info...the AirPort firmware is updated to version 7.3.2 and both Macs are updated to System 10.5.4.
    If anybody has any advice, I will be eternally grateful.

    I have a very similar problem. I have a 2.8 GHz iMac with 2GB RAM and am using OS X v10.5.4, and an Airport Extreme (v7.3.2), both updated to latest firmware. I have a 500 GB TrekStor external HD connected to the AEBS via USB. The TrekStor HD was pre-formatted in FAT32 and is visible on my iMac's desktop and in Finder but I cannot transfer files to it or see files on it. When I drag and drop a file on the TrekStor, it sometimes seems to go well but then the file is not visible via Finder, and sometimes I get an "insufficient privileges" message. I repair permissions on the iMac's internal HD without any change. I am logged in as the admin. All assistance is much appreciated!

  • Airport Extreme with External Hard Drive on Windows 7

    I just purchased an Airport Extreme in order to connect my collection of old hard drives so I can share the files with my Windows computer and Apple TV.
    My main problem is accessing a single hard drive (exFAT, one partition -- couldn't format into FAT32) from my Windows 7 laptop. The Airport connects wirelessly to my Fios router with no problem. 
    Using the Airport Utility > Disks I can see the hard drive (although it only shows its physical name "SAMSUNG HM302JI" not the name I gave it when I formatted it, "Storage300GB"), however it doesn't show any files on the drive (and there are a few test files of all types: jpg, xlsx, a sub-folder, etc.). I can't see the drive via My Computer nor can I map the drive using the IP address (192.168.1.13). When I tried adding a USB hub (for adding the other hard drives once I get this one working) I see the same problem, just the name of the device but no folders.
    Norton 360 can see the device, but Windows cannot. I've tried turning off Norton, but that hasn't helped.
    I have searched the web and support communities high and low, and I have yet to find any help.
    Any help would be appreciated!!

    My main problem is accessing a single hard drive (exFAT, one partition -- couldn't format into FAT32) from my Windows 7 laptop. The Airport connects wirelessly to my Fios router with no problem.
    The real main problem is that the USB port on the AirPort Extreme will not support exFAT or NTFS. 
    It will support HFS+ and FAT16/32.
    Please see this Apple support document to confirm:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2426

  • Airport extreme with USB hard drive permissions problem may be parallels

    I cannot access my external hard drive because of some permission problem. I know because I can see this through the disk repair utility. I've attached my external hard drive to my airport extreme. It originally came up well and worked fine. Then it lost connection and now doesn't recognize my password. To confuse matters worse I have parallels installed. This might be where the password problem is as the mac wants to access as a guest and the parallels (windows MX) as my account name. It's all pretty complicated to explain. What I want to do now is just to forget the airport plan and reach my hard drive but it won't boot up even with airport off and a direct firewire connection. It does show up in disk repair utility but with permissions. How can I get to these permissions and drop them. What if they're windows permissions somehow? How can I get started.
    Thanks

    I have a very similar problem. I have a 2.8 GHz iMac with 2GB RAM and am using OS X v10.5.4, and an Airport Extreme (v7.3.2), both updated to latest firmware. I have a 500 GB TrekStor external HD connected to the AEBS via USB. The TrekStor HD was pre-formatted in FAT32 and is visible on my iMac's desktop and in Finder but I cannot transfer files to it or see files on it. When I drag and drop a file on the TrekStor, it sometimes seems to go well but then the file is not visible via Finder, and sometimes I get an "insufficient privileges" message. I repair permissions on the iMac's internal HD without any change. I am logged in as the admin. All assistance is much appreciated!

  • Airport Extreme with external hard drive or Timecapsule for back up

    Well the subject pretty much states the question. I'm of the mindset that an all in one, though convenient/less parts, if it fails it takes my data/wireless with it. If I have an external drive (ie. WD 1TB MyBook), I can fill it, then upgrade only the drive if I want to leaving the base station. My only issue is then wireless printing, and the lack of another USB port (don't really want to put a portable hub in my router). So would I have to get an Airport Express station too? I have no experience with putting up multiple stations, or Airport for that matter (Windows convert). So, all help/input appreciated

    Well the subject pretty much states the question. I'm of the mindset that an all in one, though convenient/less parts, if it fails it takes my data/wireless with it. If I have an external drive (ie. WD 1TB MyBook), I can fill it, then upgrade only the drive if I want to leaving the base station. My only issue is then wireless printing, and the lack of another USB port (don't really want to put a portable hub in my router). So would I have to get an Airport Express station too? I have no experience with putting up multiple stations, or Airport for that matter (Windows convert). So, all help/input appreciated

  • Which to buy?  Time capsule or Airport Extreme with USB drive(s)?

    I'm getting either a TC or an Airport Extreme with an external drive.
    Archive:
    I noticed that TC can archive to an external drive. It seems this can be handy for creating off-site backups. Can I do this with a drive on Airport Extreme (with a powered hub and another drive)? Or do I need to move the drive to a Mac and copy there? Or should I use a network backup instead in either case? I guess this is my main question: Can archive work with Airport Extreme?
    Mounting:
    Is mounting the Airport Extreme for WiFi range any easier than the TC?
    Drive failure:
    Is the TC drive likely to fail over the next couple years? And the other way, if the TC breaks, is the drive something I can use elsewhere? I'm a little concerned about having all my eggs in one basket.
    Other:
    Anything I should be aware of in making this decision?

    +Are there any constraints in the orientation of TC that the AirPort Extreme does not have?+
    No, not really as long as you give either device plenty of airspace as they both tend to run warm to very warm. I thought mounting the AirPort Extreme might improve the signal strength a bit, but it made no measurable difference for me.
    +Is the TC significantly heavier?+
    The Extreme is under 2 pounds, the TC comes in a bit over 3 pounds.
    +Is mounting on a pegboard bad for the HD?+
    I think you may be asking if you can mount it vertically. That's not a problem and the Apple store even sells wall mounts for either device.
    +Yikes. I got bad info. I read the "unsupported" constraint was dropped a couple versions ago. I thought all the comments on this were referring to the older versions of AirPort Extreme.+
    Here's the Apple document. Nothing changed with Snow Leopard and I saw a specific Snow Leopard document about this...just can't find it at the moment. I'm sure other forum regulars will confirm as well if they see this post.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2038
    +Is there a list of file servers that Time Machine is compatible with?+
    Sorry, I don't have first hand knowledge on that and my policy is to only offer advice on things that I've done myself. That question might be worth a separate post since few people will see this question buried where it is.
    Message was edited by: Bob Timmons

  • External Hard Drive on Airport Extreme with a PC

    I am trying to setup my Seagate FreeAgent external hard drive through my AirPort Extreme with my PC laptop.  The AirPort Utility recognizes the disk, and I have enabled file sharing, but I cannot see the drive on either of my PC laptops that are connected to the network.  How do I make the drive visable? 

    With an AirPort Extreme, the PCs will "see" the HFS+ formatted drive on the network as a FAT32 volume, so there is no need to reformat the drive as FAT32, but the normal limitations of FAT32, like maximum file size of 4 GB, slow transfers, etc. will still apply.

  • How do I connect airport extreme to seagate hard drive using windows

    How do I connect airport extreme to seagate hard drive using windows?

    First the AirPort Extreme Base Station (AEBS) cannot share out an external HDD attached to its USB port unless it is formatted in either HFS+ or FAT16/32. It will not work if the HDD is formatted in either NTFS or ExFAT.
    If the HDD is formatted properly, when you access the AEBS with the AirPort Utility, does the HDD show up properly on the Disks tab of the utility?
    If it does, then you would access the HDD as any other network share, using the following format: //servername/sharename. In the case of the AirPort Disk (a HDD attached to the USB port of either an Extreme or Time Capsule), the "servername" would be the Extreme's Base Station Name, and the "sharename" would be the volumename of the HDD.

  • AirPort Extreme with 3T time capsule file security question

    Right now I am using a MacMini with an external HD as a file server.  I'm thinking g of using the new AirPort Extreme with 3T time capsule to do the same tho g (while also extended my wifi reach).
    With the Mac mini I have fine control over who gets to see and do what to which folders and files.  It seems that with the AirPort Extreme thee is no notion of permissions or access control -- if you can get on the wireless you can access the files.  That is extremely insecure. 
    Is my understanding correct?  Is there no way to secure files hosted on an AirPort Extreme so only certain users can access them??
    - john

    Are there any instructions for how to format and set HFS+ user permissions on the AP Extreme's HDD?
    For the formatting part, you will need to temporarily connect the drive to your Mac, and then, use the Disk Utility (a part of the OS X operating system) to partition and format the drive. You should find this utility in the \Applications\Utilities folder. For HFS+, choose "Mac OS Extended (Journaled)" for the Format option.
    For assigning user permissions using accounts, you will need to use the AirPort Utility.
    Run the AirPort Utility
    Select the Extreme, and then, click on Edit.
    Select the Disks tab.
    Select the HDD in the Partitions window.
    Choose "With accounts" as the Secure Shared Disks option.
    Click on the "+" button to add user accounts.
    For each account desired, enter the Account Name, Password, and File Sharing Access type.
    Click Save.
    Click Update to write the new configuration information to the base station and wait for the station to restart.

  • I have a Airport Extreme with a 1TB external HD connected to it.  How can I password protect certain files?

    I have a Airport Extreme with a 1TB external HD connected to it.  I have it set up so my Macbook Pro and PC's in the house can access it.  i have some files that i would like to protect(sensitive personal info.).  Is there a way that can be done where as certain folders are password protected?  Any advice is appreciated.  Thanks!

    Would a good workaround be to use disk utility to set up a password protected sparse image, of course being connected directly to the Mac, then connect the drive to the Airport Extreme?
    Then, couldn't one use that drive and protected files as normal on the airport? It would just require one extra step of using a Mac to set things up first.
    I disconnected my Airport so cannot check it out for myself.
    Hugh

  • Airport Extreme with Gigabit Ethernet - Does it have jumbo frame support?

    Please, can I get definite answer to this question? I do not need speculations as I read some reviews already. Can we have Apple finally put complete specification of the product rather than "popular one" with attachement of protocol numbers?
    I just need simple answer possibly from Apple engineering team to the following questions:
    1. Does current Airport Extreme have support for jumbo frames (everything above 1500bytes per frame)? (if one does not know what that is them perhaps understanding acronym "MTU" can help a bit)
    2. If there is support then what is the maximum supported size of jumbo frame? (Some products do not go above 6k and I read some statistics that traffic somwhere is usually 66% at about 4k jumbo frames and above that there is not much...)
    3. If there is no support then does Apple plan on update for this (firmware or hardware) in the future?
    Please, do not tell me that someoene ran something with jumbo frame and it worked as I tried yesterday LaCie Ethernet drive with supposedly setup (I set it myself) of jumbo frame 4k and on soft reboot of the drive it worked when connected to Airp[ort Extreme, but after hard reboot the disk is not visible anymore. I will recover the disk, but I need to understand if I have chance of using jumbo frames that tremendously improve performance with large files (e.g. try movies stored for AppleTV on network drive) when using Airport Extreme with its gigabit Ethernet... or that is just Gigabit Ethernet for product marketing purposes only.
    I just need reliable answer by product specification that should be on paper at Apple, but it is not so I hope that one of guys here has access to some engineering team.
    Thank you,
    Maciek Samsel

    The spec. on the chip used by Apple support your conclusion.
    BCM5395 Features
    Complies with IEEE802.3, IEEE802.3u, IEEE802.3ab standards
    5 10/100/1000Mbps Auto-Sense RJ45 ports supporting Auto-MDI/MDIX
    All ports Support Full/Half Duplex transfer mode for 10/100Mbps and Full Duplex transfer mode for 1000Mbps
    Port-based and MAC-based VLAN
    IEEE 802.1Q-based VLAN with 4K entries
    Port-based rate control
    Port mirroring
    Compact field processor (CFP)
    512 rules
    Filtering, classifications, remarking, and priority actions.
    Priority modification on egress
    DOS Attack Prevention
    Loop detection for unmanaged configurations with Broadcom’s patented LoopDTech™ technology
    CableChecker™ with unmanaged mode support
    Double tagging
    IEEE 802.3x programmable per-port flow control and back pressure, with IEEE 802.1x support for secure user authentication
    4K entry MAC address table with automatic learning and aging
    128-KB packet buffer
    128 multicast group support
    Jumbo Frame support up to 9728 byte

  • Airport extreme with time machine

    Airport extreme with time machine bought in September 2007 can it be reformatted to use as a back up drive for other than time machine and how.  It is 1TB but can only seem to get two disk images of e

    Airport extreme with time machine
    This sounds like you have a Time Capsule, correct?
    can it be reformatted to use as a back up drive for other than time machine
    You can place other type of files and folders on the Time Capsule hard drive. No additional formatting is required for this.
    and how
    Use the Finder to click on the Time Capsule under the SHARED heading on the left side of a Finder window
    Click on the Time Capsule icon, then double click on the folder named "Data" (unless you have renamed the drive), and "Data" will mount on the desktop.
    You can drag/drop or copy/paste files to "Data" just like any other hard drive
    t is 1TB but can only seem to get two disk images of e
    The disk images contain all of your backups. Leave them alone.

  • Am replacing airport extreme with Time Machine and want to upgrade from Tiger to Snow leopard. Am told I should manually back up into T Machine before OS update but set up utility won't allow anything with OS below 10.5 and I'm 10.4.11. What to do?

    Am replacing airport extreme with Time Machine and want to upgrade from Tiger to Snow leopard. Am told I should manually back up into T Machine before OS update but set up utility won't allow anything with OS below 10.5 and I'm 10.4.11. What to do?

    I think you mean you are replacing your Airport Extreme with a Time Capsule. Time Machine is software integrated into OS X 10.5 & 10.6 used to automatically backup a system to an external HD. Time Capsule is an Airport Extreme that has a hard disk integrated into it that can be used for storage or  as a Time Machine backup drive.
    Because you are currently on Tiger 10.4.x you can backup to a external HD using SuperDuper or Carbon Copy Cloner. Having a backup is very wise before doing any major system update. After  you have created the backup and have successfully upgraded to Snow Leopard you can still use the external HD for many things. The strategy I'd recommend is to use the new Time Capsule as your Time Machine backup and then use the external HD as backup using SuperDuper or CCC. Redundant backups is wise because backups can (and do) fail too! In addition both SD and CCC are bootable clones, this is useful in that if your internal HD crashes you can boot from a cloned drive and continue working until the internal HD is replaced.
    Below are some links to some articles from MacWorld, I would recommend reading them where you find a common theme, redundant backups. Backup Plan I, Backup Plan II & Backup Plan III.
    Roger

  • How do I add an Airport Extreme with Time Capsule to an existing non-Apple network?

    How do I add an Airport Extreme with Time Capsule to an existing non-Apple network?  I have an ISP provided wireless Router that has to remain as the base station.  I am able to join my 1/2TB Airport Extreme and Airport Express to the network, but I can't access/use Time Machine.

    One option would be to connect the Time Capsule (TC) to the ISP-provided wireless router by Ethernet. You can then configure the for a roaming network. Then, depending on what your goal is for the AirPort Express, you can either: 1) Add it to roaming network, 2) Configure the TC & the Express for an "extended" network, or 3) Configure the Express to "join" the roaming network for AirPlay.

  • I am getting a "connection timeout" message when trying to access my Airport Extreme with various laptops, Play Station 3 and Wii. My Airport Extreme is about a month old; it was working fine until about a week ago. C

    I am getting a "connection timeout" message when trying to access my Airport Extreme with various laptops, Play Station 3 and Wii. My Airport Extreme is about a month old; it was working fine until about a week ago. Suddenly, the "timeout" is not allowing me to connect to my wireless network.

    It could be that there's a new source of interference.
    Use the advice in the second message of this thread to investigate the signal and noise levels that each client sees:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2347845&start=1
    By the way, you've been misled by the poor field labeling into trying to type your entire message into the subject field, instead of putting a one-line topic description there.

Maybe you are looking for