Alternate driver for LaserJet Pro MFP printer

Can anyone suggest an alternate driver for a Mac Mini (OS X v10.4.11) to print on a LaserJet PRO MFP M127fw ?
This question was solved.
View Solution.

Hi @suckerfish1, 
I understand that you are looking for drivers for the 10.4 to use with the LaserJet PRO MFP M127fw. I can help you with this.
Unfortunately 10.4, isn't a supported operating system, there are no drivers available.
Here are the Supported Mac OS X operating systems: Mac OS X v10.6 Snow Leopard, OS X v10.7 Lion, OS X v10.8 Mountain Lion.
HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127fw and Color LaserJet Pro MFP M177fw Printers Product Specifications.
You would have to upgrade to 10.6 or get another Laserjet that supports 10.4.
Have a nice day!
Thank You.
Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
Gemini02
I work on behalf of HP

Similar Messages

  • Where can I find a 10.5.8 driver for Laserjet 400 m401dne printer?

    I'm running OS 10.5.8 on a G5 desktop (tower), and I just bought a LaserJet Pro 400 M401dne and connected it to this Mac with a usb cable. The Mac will print to it using a generic postscript driver automatically chosen by the OS. There is no driver for the LaserJet 400 on the list of drivers available in the OS.
    The installer disk for the printer doesn't offer any driver installation for 10.5.8. It just says that the DVD software won't work with this version of the Mac OS.
    This printer is capable of doing duplex (double-sided) printing, which is the main reason I bought this printer, but I am not given that option in any of the dialogue boxes for the printer when I hit PRINT. Apparently the generic postscript driver doesn't recognize the duplex printing feature of the printer. As a result I cannot print on both sides of a page.
    I went to the HP website and could not find a LaserJet 400 driver for OS 10.5, nor do I see any driver for it on the Apple website. The free Gutenprint driver utility lists many LaserJet models, but not the 400.
    Does anyone know where I might find a driver for this LaserJet 400 that will enable it to do double-sided printing in OS 10.5.8?
    Tom

    You solved the problem, BDAqua! I downloaded the driver for the LaserJet 500 from the HP website, as you suggested, and I found that it runs my LaserJet 400! And now I have the double-sided printing capability that I wanted. I just now printed out some double-sided pages to prove it.
    I never even considered that a driver for a different HP printer might run this one, but it does. It offers options for printing color that this printer does not have, since the HP 400 is only a black-and-white (or grayscale) printer, and the driver thinks it is running a color printer, but I can simply ignore those.
    So the HP Color LaserJet 500 driver for OS 10.5.8 is able to run the HP LaserJet 400 monochrome printer. Whodathunk!
    Other HP LaserJet 400 owners running 10.5.8 take note!
    Thank-you very much BDAqua!
    Tom

  • LaserJet Pro MFP M127fn Printer Driver Installation Failed

    Got a brand new, fresh out of the box, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127fn. Failed to install the driver that came with it on my computer Windows 7 64-bit Home Premium. I downloaded latest driver (full version) and still failed to install. The installation stopped at 75% repeatedly.  Printer itself seems to work fine. I printed the Self Test / Configuration page.   I am connecting/wired with the router.
    I tried the installation many many times. Hope one of you have a solution for this problem. 
    Any assistance would be appreciated.

    Hi AngryDad,
    Welcome to the HP Forums!
    Sorry to hear you are having the same issues, but I am happy to help!
    Let's try the following:
    Uninstall the software. Uninstalling the Printer Software.
    Clean boot the computer. How to perform a clean boot in Windows.
    Disable any firewall programs. Turn Windows Firewall on or off.
    Disable any antivirus programs. Disable antivirus software.
    Create a new user account. Create a user account.
    Reinstall the software. HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127/128 Series Full Software and Drivers.
    If this still does not resolve the issue proceed to back up your files, and reinstall Windows 7.
    Hope this fixes your problem, and have a good day!  
    RnRMusicMan
    I work on behalf of HP
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" to say “Thanks” for helping!

  • LaserJet Pro MFP M225dw driver not available for Mac OS10.4.11

    I can print by connecting the printer to the computer with USB connector. But without the driver, the printer is seen by the computer as a generic postscript printer; and the printer's special attributes such as 2-sided printing is not made available. Is there any alternative driver that may be used for this combination, please?

    Hi @ayame ,
    I see by your post that you are looking for the drivers for 10.4.11. I would like to help.
    Unfortunately the only drivers available from HP are from 10.7 and higher.
    HP LaserJet Pro MFP M225dw Drivers.
    You have to update the Mac to use the Full HP Software drivers.
    Have a great day!
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • Driver for HP LaserJet Pro MFP m127fn for AIX unix

    Hi All,
    we are using aix7.1 OS we need to print from the server to the remote printer "HP LaserJet Pro MFP m127fn" via the network.
    we need the appropriate driver for aix to be able to configure the printer on the server.
    any suggestion or work arroud is verry help full.
    Thank u in advance.

    Hello , the supplies message usually indicates a low toner capacity.  The following information shows how to adjust the low setting and please keep in mind that once the cartridge is truely out a reduction in print qualitty will be seen on all printed pages.  The toner cartridge (s) will need to be replaced.  On the printers control panel press the wrench icon (setup)-select sustem setup-select supply settings- black cartridge- very low setting- continue.  This will override the low message and allow printing.  The long term resolution is to replace the cartridge.
    (Although I am employed by HP, I am speaking for myself and not for HP)

  • HP LaserJet Pro MFP M125nw Driver Setup Error - Please Help - I can't Use My Printer

    Hi,
    I have just bought a new HP LaserJet Pro MFP M125nw Printer. But I can not install it. I can't use it, even one page written document.
    This is the error when setup appears:
    Please help me...

    Hi @NafirKeyh ,
    I see that you are experiencing issues installing the printer on Windows 7. I would really like to be able to help you resolve this issue.
    Try these steps to see if it will resolve the issue. Disabling the Startup programs and temporarily turn off the Antivirus Software should prevent any interference during the installation.
    Fatal Error 'Error 1603. A fatal error occurred during installation' (MSI Error 1603) Displays Durin...
    How is the printer going to be connected? (USB/Ethernet/Wireless)
    If you need further assistance, just let me know.
    Have a nice day!
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • Color LaserJet Pro MFP M176n installed but not printing

    Hello Everyone,
    I have problem with my printer Color LaserJet Pro MFP M176n.
    at thebegining i try to install it buteverytime i run the installer it give me HP Installer error, so i installed the Microsoft Net Framework 3.5 and run the install and it was working perfict, i install the driver on USB cable and after it show me successfull and print test page and finish, so i click print test page and in printer and fax the printer M176n Show 1 printing job and then 0 but no print came out i try again same, i remove the cable and plug it again the printer is responding perfictly but still not printing i check the scanner and its working fine but only the printing is not, so i try to install it through network and it was sccessfully installed with IP but when i print, still the same 1 printing Job but nothing came out of the printer when it came 0 printing job.
    Please help......
    - Windows is windows XP 32bit
    - Printer name   Color LaserJet Pro MFP M176n PCLms
    Thanks
    I did try to use Scan Doctor, the printer didnt print at the first check but when it ask forenternal print test page it printed then it ask me toif it print of not and i click yes it print in enternal print so it ask me to remove and reinstall so i did 2 to 3 times and still same will  not print but when run Scan doctor it will print on enternal print .....
    Wael Hilal

    Hello @ Averus89, 
    Welcome to the HP forum. 
    I understand you have done quite a lot to resolve your M176n and its connection to the ePrint service. 
    I would like to help you with this issue. 
    If the printer is not printing the web services info sheet, or allowing you to add it to HP Connected, I
    would set a manual DNS. 
    I wont go into great detail about setting this up. From your post, I feel you know your way around the printer and your network. If I am mistaken, let me know. I will go into detail. 
    The DNS to try is:
    Primary: 209.244.0.3
    Secondary: 209.244.0.4
    Set the DNS then try printing the web services info page again. 
    Let me know if this helps. 
    Aardvark1
    I work on behalf of HP
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!

  • HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP M177fw doesn't print under user account. Windows 7 Pro x86

    Dear Sirs,
    We found a bug using HP CLJ Pro MFP M177fw on windows 7 pro 32-bit edition.
    In our company we use custom folder to keep temporary files of all user accounts. It is C:\temp. So in the environment variables window we have user variables TEMP and TMP with the C:\temp path. System variables TEMP/TMP are the same.
    After installing MFP's driver, under accounts with administrator rights we can print normally. But when we use account with user rights print doesn't work. Trying to print windows test page, we receive error message "Test page failed to print" and spooler state is clean. When we change user variables TEMP/TMP on default %USERPROFILE%\AppData\Local\Temp,  we can print testpage successfully.
    With older model HP CLJ Pro MFP M175 we have no trouble at our customized operating systems.
    Can we hope on fixing print driver with regard to this problem?
    Regards,
    Evgeniy [edited personal information by moderator]

    Hello rasitbolukcu,
    Welcome to the HP Support forums.  I understand that you are having difficulties enabling the web services for your Laserjet Pro MFP M177fw printer.
    I appreciate all the information you gave me, it makes it much easier to assist you with the troubleshooting. I have included the Getting the Latest Firmware and Product Updates document.  It will walk you through ensuring the printer has the latest firmware.  Once you have updated the printer, please try to enable the web services again. 
    Regards,
    Happytohelp01
    Please click on the Thumbs Up on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” on the post that solves your issue to help others find the solution.
    I work on behalf of HP

  • HP Laserjet PRO MFP M125nw; Wireless Driver installati​on problem in Win 8.1

    Product name : HP Laserjet PRO MFP M125nw, product nr CZ173A
    US Operating system: Dual Boot:   Win Vista home premium (32 bit) / Win 8.1 pro (32 bit)
    The printer was installed under Vista in September 2014 and was and still is wireless printing and scanning without a problem.
    Recently I tried to install the printer (wireless) under Win 8.1 and I downloaded the latest Full Feature software from HP.nl.
    During installation the software installation package could not find the printer and installation was aborted.
    I ran the printer self test / Configuration. The network Info and product info sheets were without  errors. A ping to the IP address of the printer was without a loss. The firewall indicated that HP software is accepted.
    Off course I read everything on HP about this problem I followed every advice and repeatedly gave it a try. I even installed the usb cable solution ( USB was working ok) followed by your change connection instructions, but all in vain.
    To my surprise HP was able to find my printer when I checked on http:// www.hp.com/cgi-bin/hpsupport/index.pl. However the printer was found in my local network as a HP Laserjet Pro M1132 multifunctional printer with product nr stars 3NW-01 which is not correct, however the found serie nr. of CNB7G3RC78 was correct.
    The print and scan doctor made some changes to the software and after that I was able to print wirelessly, however the Scan doctor button did not react at all and using the program was not possible further. Starting the program again gave the same result.
    Conclusion:       In Vista: HP wireless print and HP wireless Scan is working fine
                            In Win 8.1: HP wireless print is OK, HP wireless Scan cannot be installed !????
                            In Win 8.1: Windows Printer driver and Win Fax& Scan driver both wireless working ok
    Remark: Reading the display is difficult in dim lit areas. The on / off button is brightly lit and this light should be used to enlighten the display instead.
    A solution for the scanning problem would be appreciated.
    Kind regards
    JWAH

    Hi @JWAH , and welcome to the HP Forums!
    I understand you're experiencing driver issues. I'd like to help!
    I would suggest Uninstalling the Printer Software.
    Once it is uninstalled, I would suggest putting your system into clean boot mode within the Microsoft configuration.  You can do so by following this document: How to perform a clean boot in Windows.
    Once the computer is in clean boot mode, I would suggest reinstalling the HP LaserJet Pro MFP M125/126 Series Full Software and Drivers.
    Good luck and please let me know the results of your troubleshooting steps. Thank you for posting on the HP Forums!
    Please click “Accept as Solution " if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos, Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks" for helping!
    Jamieson
    I work on behalf of HP
    "Remember, I'm pulling for you, we're all in this together!" - Red Green.

  • HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127fw will not print anything except its own config

    Just purchased a HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127fw.  I cannot manage to get it to print using any type of connection to the printer.
    I can connect to the printer from my Ubuntu PC and my Android phone, but when I attempt to print, the job just hangs, never erroring, but never completing.  I have attempted printing from various applications, including a test page from the HPLIP tools, but the jobs reports "processing".
    When I attempt to print an information sheet from the printer's front panel, it asks me to confirm, but then nothing happens.
    I can connect to the printer's web server, but clicking on the print info button there does nothing.
    I have successfully connected with HP's ePrint service using the printer's reported email address, but the service reports "problem with printer".
    I don't know what else to try here.
    This question was solved.
    View Solution.

    Hi richRemer,
    I see that you are having issues printing from the computer and the Android phone.
    I will be happy to help you.
    Power cycle the computer and the router.
    I would do a power reset on the printer. With the printer still turned on, disconnect the power cable from the back of the printer. Then disconnect the power cable from the wall outlet. Wait 10 seconds and reconnect the power cable back to the wall outlet first, then the back of the printer and power it on again.
    Make sure the printer is connected directly to a wall outlet. (don't use a power hub or a surge protector)
    Print a hardware self test. Find out what the IP address is.
    Printing a Configuration Report.
    I have provided you with the Driver Support for Linux OS.
    If you are still having issues please go to Linux support page.
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • LaserJet Pro MFP M276nw software installer not detecting printer via USB or wi-fi - Windows 7

    I am trying to install a LaserJet Pro MFP M276nw on Windows 7 Home Premium x64, and I know the printer functions fine, as I have installed it on both Windows Vista Basic x32 and Windows 7 Professional x64 all on the same desktop. The operating system has been changed a couple of times, hence the multiple installs.
    I downloaded the full featured software from HP.com and went through the routine of installation as per usual, except that now the software doesn't detect the printer when it requests that I connect it via USB.  Trying to install via wi-fi doesn't work because the printer still needs to be attached via USB in order to create the proper wireless handshake.  Windows 7 detects the printer, and in-fact installed the drivers for it automatically.  However, the printer installation software suite does not respond to the printer being connected, and just hangs there, waiting for it to appear.
    I have tried multiple USB ports and it's the same issue.  I've installed the basic driver also available for download on HP.com, but that software does not appear to include an option for scanning files to the computer.  The printer itself will scan to email or to to a USB thumb drive, and even to a network folder, but not directly onto the computer.  If it wasn't a necessary function of an all-in-one printer, I wouldn't bother with the scanning feature and simply make do with the basic printer driver. 
    Anyone have some sort of idea regarding this issue?

    Hi @KP_ ,
    I see that you are having issues with setting up the printer on the one computer. I would like to help you out today.
    I would uninstall the software, turn off the Startup programs, Antivirus software and update the driver during the install by the post I have provided.
    Disconnect the USB cable.
    Uninstall the software.
    Here are the steps to run the uninstall from the computer or the CD.
    To uninstall from program files:
    Touch the Windows key and the E key to access the computer window.
    Select the C drive.
    Select program files or program files x86.
    Open the HP and printer name folder.
    Select uninstall.
    Uninstall the software from the CD:
    Touch the Windows key and the E key to access the computer window. Right click on the CD for the printer, left click open in a new window, double click on uninstall.
    I would disable all the start up programs and temporarily turn off the Antivirus Software to see if there is a program interfering in the back ground. How to use MSCONFIG . Click on the start up tab and click disable all.
    Download, save and then run the latest drivers. Don't Connect the USB cable until prompted during the install.
    HP LaserJet Full Feature Software and Driver.
    Right after connecting the USB cable, follow this document immediately. A Fatal Error Displays During Software Installation. Disregard the title. If the printer stays listed properly, don't worry about updating the driver.
    Test the printer.
    Then you will have to go back and enable the Startup programs and turn the Antivirus Software back on again.
    If you need further assistance, just let me know.
    Have a great day!
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • LaserJet Pro MFP M127fw, Can't Enable Web Printing

    I have tried using the machine to enable web printing as well as using the computer and typing in ip address.  No matter which way I go I cannot enable web printing on my laserjet pro mfp m127fw.  I am connected to the net.  Can access the internet on other devices.  So there should be no issues there.  Is something wrong with the machine or is there something I can try?  Of course we are NOW ready to start using this feature after having the machine for a while so I hope there is not something wrong with the machine.
    Thank you!
    This question was solved.
    View Solution.

    Hi @mdandy,
    Welcome to the HP Support Forums.  I see that you are getting a connection error message when trying to enable the web services for your Laserjet M127fw printer.
    Please ensure the printer is up-to-date with its firmware. If you are unsure how to check I have included the Getting the Latest Firmware and Product Updates document to assist you.
    Once you are up-to-date with the firmware, please set a manual IP address and manual DNS servers for the printer. The steps on how to set a manual IP address can be found in the Printer Does Not Maintain Wireless Connection document. For the DNS servers please use 8.8.8.8 for the Manual Preferred DNS Server and 8.8.4.4 for the Alternate DNS server. These are Google’s public DNS servers.
    Please let me know how things go.
    Regards,
    Happytohelp01
    Please click on the Thumbs Up on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” on the post that solves your issue to help others find the solution.
    I work on behalf of HP

  • MacBook Air connected to a Laserjet Pro MFP but not printing

    Hi, I am trying to print from an HP LaserJet Pro MFP M-125a which is connected to a MacBook Air via a USB cable. The software has been downloaded and the print job window is always showing as if it is in the process of printing the print job given but no printing is issued and the print job is seen as done. Can you please tell me what's wrong why the print outs are not coming out?
    This question was solved.
    View Solution.

    Hi @Lilium ,
    I see that you are having issues printing through the USB connection. I would really like to be able to help you resolve this issue.
    Did you download and install the full software solution or run the Apple Upates?
    Check the driver name that is installed for the printer. Make sure it shows just the printer's name.
    Click the Apple menu and then click System Preferences. Click Printers & Scanners, highlight the printer name on the left side and on the right side of the screen it should show the printer's name. (LaserJet Pro MFP M125a )
    If the full printer name isn't listed correctly, delete it and add the printer name back in from the list. Click the - sign to delete the driver and then click the + sign to add the driver, might have to click the drop down to select the printer's name to add it in.
    How is the printer name listed?
    If the issue persists, please try the following steps:
    Repair the Disk Permissions on the Mac:
    Close all applications.
    On the Apple menu bar, click Go, click Applications and then click Utilities.
    Double-click Disk Utility.
    Highlight your hard drive/partition on the left.
    Click Verify and then Repair Disk Permissions.
    Restart the computer..
    Reset the Printing System:
    Note: This will remove all printers in the print and Fax/Scan, any printer removed can be re-added later by clicking the plus (+) symbol.
    Click the Apple icon and then click System Preferences.
    Click Printers & Scanners.
    Right-click (or Ctrl +click) in the left white side panel, then click Reset printing system.
    Click OK to confirm the reset.
    Type the correct Name and Password.
    Click OK to reset the printing system.
    Then click the + sign to add the driver, highlight the printer. (you might have to click the drop down to select the printer's name) Then click on the Add button.
    Try printing again.
    If you need further assistance, just let me know.
    Have a great day!
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • My iPhone 6 iOS 8.2 does not print on HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476nw. It displays "No AirPrint Printers Found'.

    My iPhone 6 iOS 8.2 does not print on HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP M476nw.
    It displays "No AirPrint Printers Found."
    Same thing for iPhone 5S iOS 8.2.
    Both iPhone and printer on the same wifi network.
    I tried printing from different applications. AirPrint does not work.
    I tried turning off and back on, reset, printing from different applications, ...
    iPhone 6 prints through HP Wireless Direct printing.
    Sony laptop works via wifi.

    Hi mtotonji,
    Thank you for using the Apple Support Community. Given the nature of the issues you are describing and your current configuration, you may be better served by reaching out to one of Apple's other available resources for more direct assistance - https://getsupport.apple.com/GetproductgroupList.action
    Sincerely,
    - Brenden

  • HP Laserjet Pro MFP M12fn, printing a solid black line on every paper

    I'm running windows 7 professional. I haven't received any error messages and nothing out of the oridarny has happened. My printer/scanner/fax/copy (My HP Laserjet Pro MFP M12fn, product # CZ181A) is printing with a black line down the entire paper, but its only doing it thru the feeder and not on the glass. HELP, How can I fix this? 

    Welcome to the HP Forums angelinaOO7,
    I read your post, which indicates that you are getting a black line down the page when using the feeder. You can print fine from the glass. I can help you with this.
    I would do a hard reset to see if that will resolve the issue.
    Leave the printer on and unplug the power cable from the printer and wall outlet for 60 seconds.
    Then reconnect the power cable to the printer and wall outlet rather than a surge protector.
    This ensures the printer is receiving full power and may help this situation.
    Clean the scanning glass and platen.
    Turn the printer off.
    Disconnect the power cord from the product and the wall outlet.
    Open the scanner lid.
    Clean the following scanner areas with a soft cloth or sponge that has been moistened with nonabrasive glass cleaner.
    Main scanner glass.
    Small scanner glass to the left of the main scanner glass.
    White plastic backing.
    Dry the glass and white plastic backing with a chamois or a cellulose sponge to prevent spotting.
    Plug the power cord into the product and the wall outlet.
    Turn the printer on.
    Try to make another copy.
    If you are still having issues, then update the printer's firmware.
    HP LaserJet Pro MFP M127fn Drivers.
    Select your operating system, click next, click the link for firmware.
    If you need further assistance, let me know.
    Have a wonderful day!
    Thank You.
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

Maybe you are looking for

  • Which is the recommended way of getting a KN presentation to YouTube?

    If I am reading correctly, then I have two options to get my Keynote presentation with music onto my YouTube channel: 1. After finishing the KN presentation, I can convert it to a QuickTime movie and then send that QuickTime novie to YouTube . 2. Aft

  • WWI Installation

    Dear All, I am trying to Install WWI with EHS Management Server As per config guide a) Install EHSSTART.EXE as a service Host <Name of local PC> Name For example, EhsStart Display Name For example, EH&S Failure Recovery Executable path <WWI or Expert

  • PRINT-CONTROLS

    hi Experts, I'm having a SAPscript, in it i have a signatrue window. This window triggers a PRINT-CONTROL on some condition. there is a transaction SPAD which gives us a list of existing PRINT-CONTROL. when we view this PRINT-CONTROL i cannnot find i

  • HT3775 The document "20130326_MNTvsMexico.mov" could not be opened. A required codec isn't available.

    I go the error message...The document "20130326_MNTvsMexico.mov" could not be opened. A required codec isn't available. Can anyone help?

  • Fixing library after crash

    I started adding a significant amount of music to my library today (~50 gb), but midway through the transfer, my entire computer crashed, and I was forced to reboot. I want to add the music, but I don't want to end up with a lot of duplicates, so I w