Apple says "logic board needs replaced" because MBP won't turn on w/o SMC reset but I think I can fix it; can you help?

Hello,
Less than a year after purchasing a brand new, early-2011 Macbook Pro (still covered under Extended Apple Care) and, sadly, only a week or two after finally upgrading to 8GB RAM, I returned to my notebook after taking a shower and watched it suddenly shut itself down. It has not been responsive to the power button since then (although, see below.. I think I can fix it).
Genius Bar took one look at the visible moisture sensor you can see underneath where the RAM sits and declared it water-damaged. While I agree that either a short and/or corrosion is causing my MBP to malfunction, I don't believe it should void my warranty because the problem isn't that I spilled something on it.1
I hope someone can give me some insight into fixing this myself. Apple says "the Logic Board needs replaced" (a common CS response, I've noticed) the water damage voids my Extended Care + that it'll be at least $1200 and several weeks. Here's the situation:
MBP will not turn on just by pressing the power button. However, MBP consistently (every time) powers up when I do an SMC reset.
I have it in verbose mode and it begins booting. But, it will invariably turn off without warning anywhere between 30 seconds and 8-10 minutes after powering up.
MBP will not turn on just by pressing the power button. However, MBP consistently (every time) powers up when I do an SMC reset.
I have it in verbose mode and it begins booting. But, it will invariably turn off without warning anywhere between 30 seconds and 5 minutes of powering up.
Eighty percent of the time, it turns off during the pre-Xorg boot. However, I have also seen it fully boot, I log in, I'm able to peruse logfiles/etc. Safe Mode (holding shift) crashes early. Single-user mode makes no difference. PRAM/NVRAM/etc makes no difference. I can boot to the Recovery Partition but it turns off just the same (disk utility scan takes too long).
I haven't been able to really test the Internet Recovery because the hotel wireless takes too long. I did boot into Hardware Test and it passed the basic and extended tests (although it seemed to just be testing the RAM integrity.
I can boot from the optical drive with a FreeBSD 9 livecd and an Ubuntu 11.04 livecd. Of note is that the laptop shuts off consistently when FreeBSD begins the journaling services for the ZFS filesystem (every time).
Here is where this leads me to believe I'm at (I am not dogmatic here and would appreciate any corrections or insight):
It seems like there may be corrosive damage on the logic board but maybe it's isolated given the various consistencies in what's happening. It seems like whenever SATA is use, I lose power. When SATA isn't really used (the HW Test), the laptop has literally stayed on for days and days.
I want to get in there and clean up any corrosion with 91% isopropyl alcohol (9% distilled, non-conductive water).
I want to use a bootable OSX livecd with an "emergency console" so I can, basically, use boot options to step throught the boot process and see if I can isolate the problem.
Here is what I'm uncertain about and could use guidance:
Does any of this sound remotely reasonable to anyone who has been through this or am I delusional?
Any tips on identifying and cleaning any corrosion?
While I had made a bootable version of Lion via Disk Utility and a rescue disk with some third-party app, they are MIA and I don't have another Mac at the moment. Do I have any other options? Again, an install dvd is not exactly what I want -- more like a rescue dvd. I had read about some Apple Stores giving/copying bootable USB thumb drives like this to customers. But, I noticed that this is now on sale there for $80. I would use this like once and, ideally, could use my MBP to make more. $80 seems a bit much.
I should be able to step through the boot process in a way like what's possible with FreeBSD, no?
Anyone have any other specific troubleshooting tips?
I really, reallly need my MBP back as soon as possible. I'd really appreciate any wisdom and insight! Thank you,
-ryan                             
To be totally honest, about 3 weeks prior I spilled some milk from cereal on the desk and a little bit got onto the battery. However, the notebook worked fine for the following weeks. I believe that the problems have been caused by ambient humidity ... I've been staying in a hotel that steams up the entire room when I take a shower. The windows are covered in water droplets so why wouldnt the MBP be affected? As noted, these problems began after I lingered in a hot shower.

multiplryan wrote:
To be totally honest, about 3 weeks prior I spilled some milk from cereal on the desk and a little bit got onto the battery.
I don't think you have a case.
You can replace the logic board yourself if you are a DIY'er and save some money.

Similar Messages

  • Logic board needs replacing..

    So about a year ago I had my 2011 21" iMac plugged in and in sleep mode, when the power went out due to a storm. The morning after I tried to turn it on and it wouldn't start up, so I checked the Internet and it said to check if it was the power cable which I checked, and it wasnt that. I scheduled an appointment at the Apple Store and they checked the cable and confirmed that it wasn't that and said they would check the power supply, and it wasn't that either. They then told me I would need to have my Logic board replaced, which I DO NOT have money for, so I took it home. I then brought it to my girlfriends dad who fixes computers, and he just took a cable from a broken printer he had and it ran, but he said it took a little while to turn on after pressing the button repeatedly. So he brought it back to my house and after pressing the power button over and over with no luck, I left it. About an hour later I went down and it was on, and I ended up using it without any issues. It went on like that for the few times I had to turn it on after a power outage or whatevet, only noticing that it ran a bit hotter than it used to. So today my town had scheduled for a temporary power outage due to maintenance, and I powered down the the computer just in case and when i returned later to power it back up, it wouldn't turn on, so now I'm hoping it will be on when I check later but my question is, if i needed a logic board replacement, would the computer still power up eventually and operate as smoothly as it does?

    Power problems can cause havoc.
    1. make sure that the Energy Saver Preferences, "Start up automatically after a power failure" is unchecked.
    That way it will not try to startup on it owe when the power comes back on.
    2. given all the weird problems, I'm surprised that you forged on to Yosemite...?
    First thing I would do is make a new bootable backup clone on one of my external hard drives. That way I could do more testing, including wiping the OS X from the HDD and starting over.
    3. run the Extended Apple Hardware Test @ > Using Apple Hardware Test - Apple Support
    If the Hardware Test does run from the version on your HDD, run the Hardware Test on your original Snow Leopard set.

  • MBP won't turn on/charge with any charger but only after a period of charger flashing orange/green

    Hi all,
    I have a MBP bought in September 2012. Left my charger at home so I have been using my old 60W charger which is a little tatty and sometimes gave a 'Battery Not Charging' error message, but after a little fiddling would always work. To stop the inconvenience of fiddling all the time I had left it on charge for probably 24 hours, and it said the battery was charged. Last night took it off charge, left it for 10 minutes and when I went to use it the computer was switched off. When I tried to plug the charger it I just got green/orange flashing, and absolutely no life from the MBP.
    Tried a couple of other chargers (none of which are mine) and nothing seems to work. Got my exams coming up and it's majorly stressing me out that I won't have it for weeks. None of the London Apple stores have appointments until next week. Help?!

    Brenden thanks for the response, i actually went to an Apple Authorized center, no apple stores being in my vicinity, they solved the issue in less time than it takes saying it as resetting the SMC was not working.
    apparently it was a short circuit from a bad power connection, computer is back and running again, nothing to do with OS X update or a bad charger.
    thanks anyways,

  • APPLE TECH TEAM SUGGESTED TO REPLACE MY MACBOOK PRO'S LOGIC BOARD FOR 2ND TIME?All the funtionality and applications is working fine but my screen backlight is off.If i expose it to direct sunlight , i can see what is running on my MAC(out of warranty)

    APPLE TECH TEAM SUGGESTED TO REPLACE MY MACBOOK PRO'S LOGIC BOARD FOR 2ND TIME?All the funtionality and applications is working fine but my screen backlight is off.If i expose it to direct sunlight , i can see what is running on my MAC(out of warranty)

    likely display inverter board.
    did you get your inverter board replaced already?
    Did you have a question?
    If the diagnostic in shop indicates same, thats 1000X better than anyone can do online in "diagnosis" (not really genuine diagnosis of course)

  • My logic board was replaced on my Mac and now my CS4 will not open. I re-downloaded it, gave the serial number, but it still won't open.  Now what?

    My logic board was replaced on my Mac and now my CS4 will not open. I re-downloaded it, gave the serial number, but it still won't open.  It said that the licensing had expired.  But this is not the case.  Now what?

    uninstall, clean (Use the CC Cleaner Tool to solve installation problems | CC, CS3-CS6) and then properly install (do not migrate, use timemachine etc) using the installation files.
    Downloadable installation files available:
    Suites and Programs:  CC 2014 | CC | CS6 | CS5.5 | CS5 | CS4 | CS3
    Acrobat:  XI, X | 9,8 | 9 standard
    Premiere Elements:  13 | 12 | 11, 10 | 9, 8, 7 win | 8 mac | 7 mac
    Photoshop Elements:  13 |12 | 11, 10 | 9,8,7 win | 8 mac | 7 mac
    Lightroom:  5.7.1| 5 | 4 | 3
    Captivate:  8 | 7 | 6 | 5
    Contribute:  CS5 | CS4, CS3
    Download and installation help for Adobe links
    Download and installation help for Prodesigntools links are listed on most linked pages.  They are critical; especially steps 1, 2 and 3.  If you click a link that does not have those steps listed, open a second window using the Lightroom 3 link to see those 'Important Instructions'.

  • My iphone 3gs will not connect to itunes and it says that I need to do a system restore. It also says that I need to enter my password on the iphone to connect to itunes but I can not do this because the phone is in emergency phone call mode only.

    My iphone 3gs will not connect to itunes and it says that I need to do a system restore. It also says that I need to enter my password on the iphone to connect to itunes but I can not do this because the phone is in emergency phone call mode only.

    Turn your phone off and connect your cable to the computer, but not the device just yet. Start up iTunes. Now, hold down the home button on your phone and plug it in to the cable - don't let go of the button until iTunes tells you it's detected a phone in recovery mode. Now you can restore to factory settings.
    Unfortunately, the data on your phone is already gone if you're seeing the connect to iTunes logo.

  • Hello, I am getting an HP Battery Alert, Do I need to replace?. It says it may need replacement.

    I am wondering if I really do need to change my battery on my HP Pavillion dv7. my Pc is about 2 years old and just got that message when starting my PC. 
    It says HP Battery Alert
    The system has detected the storage capacity of the battery stated below to be very low. For optimal performance, this battery may need to be replaced.
    Primary (internal) Battery (601)
    Enter- Continue Startup
    For more information please visit: www.hp.com/go/techcenter/startup
    Can you help me with this.???

    Hello, I am getting an HP Battery Alert, Do I need to replace?. It says it may need replacement.[ New ]
    08-12-2011 08:48 PM
    I am wondering if I really do need to change my battery on my HP Pavillion dv7. my Pc is about 2 years old and just got that message when starting my PC. 
    It says HP Battery Alert
    The system has detected the storage capacity of the battery stated below to be very low. For optimal performance, this battery may need to be replaced.
    Primary (internal) Battery (601)
    Enter- Continue Startup
    For more information please visit: www.hp.com/go/techcenter/startup
    Can you help me with this? how can i resolve it??

  • My Mac has Snow Leopard 10.5.8. I want to install Mtn. Lion. Apple says I first need to install SL 10.6.8 and that it'll be available at Software Updates. It isn't. Now what?

    My Mac has Snow Leopard 10.5.8. I want to install Mtn. Lion. Apple says I first need to install SL 10.6.8 and that it'll be available at Software Updates. It isn't (and I've installed every software update I can pull up.) Now what?

    10.5.8 is Leopard. 10.6.x is Snow Leopard.
    Upgrading to Mountain Lion
    You can upgrade to Mountain Lion from Lion or directly from Snow Leopard. Mountain Lion can be downloaded from the Mac App Store for $19.99. To access the App Store you must have Snow Leopard 10.6.6 or later installed.
    If you need to purchase Snow Leopard you can still purchase a copy from Apple's online store's telesales agents.[1-800-MY-APPLE (1-800-692-7753) or Customer Service and Sales Support at 1-800-676-2775.] Ask for a Sales Representative.
    Third-party sources for Snow Leopard are:
    Snow Leopard from Amazon.com
    Snow Leopard from eBay
    After you install Snow Leopard you will have to download and install the Mac OS X 10.6.8 Update Combo v1.1 to update Snow Leopard to 10.6.8 and give you access to the App Store.
    If you need to purchase Lion call 1-800-692-7753 or 1-800-676-2775. Ask for a Sales Representative. They will check your Apple ID, and email you a code and instructions.  The cost is $29.99 (as it was before) plus tax.  It's a download.
    Be sure your computer meets the minimum requirements:
    Apple - OS X Mountain Lion - Read the technical specifications.
    Macs that can be upgraded to OS X Mountain Lion
    iMac (Mid 2007 or newer)
    MacBook (Late 2008 Aluminum, or Early 2009 or newer)
    MacBook Pro (Mid/Late 2007 or newer)
    MacBook Air (Late 2008 or newer)
    Mac mini (Early 2009 or newer)
    Mac Pro (Early 2008 or newer)
    Xserve (Early 2009)
    Are my applications compatible?
    See App Compatibility Table - RoaringApps - App compatibility and feature support for OS X & iOS.
    Am I eligible for the free upgrade?
    See Apple - Free OS X Mountain Lion upgrade Program.
    For a complete How-To introduction from Apple see Apple - Upgrade your Mac to OS X Mountain Lion.

  • My ipod touch needed to be updated so I did and now it won't turn on all it does is show the itunes icon and says toconnect it to itunes so I did and let it be updated and now it wont turn on and I tried resetting but nothing changed.

    My ipod touch needed to be updated so I did and now it won't turn on all it does is show the itunes icon and says toconnect it to itunes so I did and let it be updated and now it wont turn on and I tried resetting but nothing changed.

    Try:
    - iOS: Not responding or does not turn on
    - Also try DFU mode after try recovery mode
    How to put iPod touch / iPhone into DFU mode « Karthik's scribblings
    - If not successful and you can't fully turn the iOS device fully off, let the battery fully drain. After charging for an least an hour try the above again.
    - Try on another computer          
    - If still not successful that usually indicates a hardware problem and an appointment at the Genius Bar of an Apple store is in order.
    Apple Retail Store - Genius Bar       

  • I'm trying to sync a 4s so that it can be activated w ATT...my computer says that I need to have 11.1 or higher in order to do that but when I download from the itunes site nothing happens and I still can't sync phone...what am I doing wrong?

    I'm trying to sync a 4s so that it can be activated w ATT...my computer says that I need to have 11.1 or higher in order to do that but when I download from the itunes site nothing happens and I still can't sync phone...what am I doing wrong?

    The screen that says "Download Now" also shows the proposed iTunes version number (in the box below):
    Be sure it indicates 11.1.3.
    If it is, here's further troubleshooting:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1538

  • I have a problem with My Apple ID, because I have forgotten my security question and I don't have any rescue email address. Would you help me please?

    I have a problem with My Apple ID, because I have forgotten my security question and I don't have any rescue email address. Would you help me please?
    It's not possible to me calling apple support, because I'm not in usa now.

    Then find whatever number that you need for wherever you are -  in this support article - and seek help here.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5699

  • I just bought a iPhone 4s from someone on-line, everything is working correctly however i cannot connect to any wifi, it says that it is unavailable, i know that it could be the wifi chip damaged but the phone is in almost perfect condition. Help please?

    I just bought a iPhone 4s from someone on-line, everything is working correctly however i cannot connect to any wifi, it says that it is unavailable, i know that it could be the wifi chip damaged but the phone is in almost perfect condition. Help please?

    Help with what?  If the WiFi radio is broken, there's nothing any of us on this forum can do help you.  Either go to Apple and pay for an out of warranty replacement, or find a 3rd party repair shop and get the phone repaired.

  • MBP won't turn on

    My MBP won't turn on.  I've read several threads on the same issue but was confused on what could be the problem and possible solution.  I have a 2006 year model.  The computer powers up, fan turns on but does not boot up.  The screen stays dark and no apple sound at start up.  I would appreciate any instructions on how I may try to fix the problem myself.
    Thanks.

    2006 model laptop, it's what? 7 years old?
    It's had a good life and you got a good value as they typically only last about 3-4 years now.
    I wouldn't waste any time or money on it, just open it up and take the hard drive out and use a SATA to USB adapter cable to a new Mac and use Setup Assistant or Migration Assistant to transfer content over.
    Or you can opt for a Windows laptop and install MacDrive to read the HFS+ format and transfer files that way.

  • My macbook black shutdown during a thunder storm , what do i need to? it won't turn on and the charger light is not on green or on at all..have i fried it?

    my macbook black shutdown during a thunder storm , what do i need to? it won't turn on and the charger light is not on green or on at all..have i fried it?please help a.s.a.p...

    Most likely.
    You can try to boot from the Install DVD for your Mac and run AHT from there if it boots.
    If not it sounds like it is time to take it to Apple for repair.
    Allan

  • I bought mountain lion en app stores and start download, but stops and mentioned is incomplete. and when start installation mentioned error because download is incomplete and send me to download again but the button is in  "downloaded"  what can i do?

    I bought mountain lion en app stores and start download, but stops and mentioned is incomplete. and when start installation mentioned error because download is incomplete and send me to download again but the button is in  "downloaded"  what can i do?

    Welcome to the support forums.
    Please ask this question in the Mac App Store forum where they can better assist you.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Can I use Optical Audio alongside a speakerless monitor to play audio through speakers?

    I have an Apple TV 3 and so far I am relatively pleased. However.. I have no sound, this just about renders my Apple TV useless. Is it possible to use the Optical Audio cable to play sound from films, music etc. while still having the Apple TV connec

  • Anyone successful at using Oracle 9.0.1's XMLType in WebLogic 700?  Works outside of WL

    I have code working that uses Oracle's new XMLType column (CLOB implementation). It works as straight java with JDBC connection, but fails with "InvocationTargetException null " error on line : myClob = CLOB.createTemporary( conn, false, CLOB.DURATIO

  • Why can't I use the CS5 inDesign that I purchased?

    Five months ago, I bought a new iMac. It took weeks to transfer or install my old software onto this new computer (because the new iMacs no longer have disc drives and most of the original software was installed from discs). Finally I got it to the p

  • JSP page import problems

    Hi, i've got a problem with importing java classes into my jsp file. i use the following method: <%@ page import="Person" %> Person is originally a selfwritten class which lies in the subdirectory WEB-INF/classes of my webapps directory of my tomcat

  • Why does my lightbox keep opening a new window?

    I'm currently finishing off my website and all I need to do that is make four images click into their own seperate light boxes. I number of my code savy friends cannot find anything wrong with my code. The problem is that when I click on the image on