Are multiple desktops in 'Lion' totally pointless?

Having multiple desktops for different activities or jobs seems pointless if you can't open a software application from the toolbar when it is already in use on another desktop. i.e. If I need my addressbook open on my personal desktop and also on my work desktop, I can't do it. If I try the desktops flip across screen 'wham! to the desktop where the application was originally opened! No good. The only thing that comes close is to open a new 'file' on the "main" desktop and move that individual file to another desktop whilst in the Mission Control position. That says it all! It's daft... and if you close it down you cant open it again without redoing the whole mission control thing. Am I missing something here apart from my patience?

They way that I perfer to work, there are no cases where I want the OS to switch to another desktop simply because I choose to open an application that happens to already be opened on another desktop.  For me, I want the application to open in the current desktop, regardless if it is already open in another desktop.  I tend to have multiple applications open on a single desktop in windowed mode - where no single application consumes the entire screen.  For me, out-of-sight-out-of mind applies - I need to be able to see what I have to work with.
However, some of my friends at work prefer to work in a full-screen mode, where a singe application takes up the entire screen.  They are constantly switching back and forth from one application to the other, typically by pressing CMD+TAB.  I guess in this context, having the OS switch from one desktop to another based on where the application is opened would make sense.  But, to me that seems like a big waste of a desktop - only showing one application.
So, here is an example of my use-case.  I come to work and powerup my Mac.  I open  Finder and Excel so that I can start working on a report.  While I'm working on the report a friend comes over and asks me to help him with his report.  In this case, I would prefer to switch to an unused desktop and then proceed to open the applications that I need for this new task, such as  Finder and Excel (the same ones I was using for my report but now I need for my friend's report).  I already have context in those applications on Desktop1 and I don't want to lose that, hence my desire to use another desktop. So, I go to Desktop2 and click on the Finder icon in the Dock.  Instead of it opening a new instance of Finder on Desktop2, I'm jolted over to Desktop1 where Finder was already opened.  But I don't want that - I want to keep my place in Finder on Desktop1 and open a new one on Desktop2.  Sure, I can hold the CTRL key down while I press on the Finder icon in the Dock and tell it to open a new window.  However, instead of it opening a new window in Desktop2, it opens it in Desktop1 while leaving me in Desktop2 and wondering where the new Finder window is.  It seems that Safari works correctly in that it will open a new Safari window in Desktop2 if I hold the CTRL key down while I click on its icon in Dock.  However, if I forget that, I'm transported over to Desktop1 - which I don't want.
How Firefox is handled is just weird.  Lets say that I am in Desktop1 and I have Firefox opened.  Then I switch to Desktop2 and now I want Firefox open in Desktop2 too.  While in Desktop2  I can  hold the CTRL key when clicking on its icon in Dock and tell it to open a new window.  Indeed, it will open a new window - but not in Desktop2.  Instead, it opens a new window in Desktop1 and I get tranported over to Desktop1.  Again, not what I want.
Sure, you can blame the applications for this.  But to me, the OS is the coordinator of all the resource on the system, including the applications.  So, in my opinion, if it does not work consistently and and if it does not work how I expect  then it does not work well.
-Rod

Similar Messages

  • How do I turn on multiple desktops in Lion?

    How do I turn on multiple desktops in Lion?  I have a new (Aug 2011) MBP with Lion, and cannot find any way  to create one.  I have no "+" icon on mission control. I do have the high res screen, and some data appears to be off screen.  They worked fine on my previous MBP (June 2009 with Snow Leopard).

    First make sure the screen is not zoomed.  Hold CNTL and scroll down.  That will unzoom the desktop if slightly zoomed.
    Second, go back into Mission control and move your cursor up to the top right.  You'll see the pale desktop image slide out from the right side with a + symbol.  Click that.
    Regards,
    Captfred

  • Is there a way to turn off multiple desktops in lion?

    since the apps can full screen i no longer need more than one desktop space. any help in disabling this feature is much appreciated.

    since the apps can full screen i no longer need more than one desktop space. any help in disabling this feature is much appreciated.

  • Multiple desktops and mail

    The multiple desktops in Lion (replacing Spaces) - how do I keep Mail from coming up in every Desktop?  I'd like to keep all of my "communication" (Skype, Mail, Twitter, etc) in one Desktop (2 additional monitors if it matters - I dont think it does) , and have things I am working on in another...but Mail comes up regardless of the Desktop I switch to.  I want it to stay in the "communications" desktop.  Any ideas?  Possible?

    Navigate to your "Communication" desktop and Right/Control click on a running application in the Dock and select Options > Assign to This Desktop.

  • Multiple Desktop Icons in Sidebar

    Here's the setup:
    I have my user profile setup on a secondary (non-booting) HD named "Macintosh HD". I hooked up and booted off of an old laptop in FW Target mode, who's HD also was named "Macintosh HD." Well this caused all sorts of probs with my profile going missing upon disconnecting the laptop and rebooting. Opened up terminal and looked in /Volumes, there was listed "Macintosh HD" and "Macintosh HD1," the latter being the one that held my profile. So I created a temp user and logged in with that name, deleted the "Macintosh HD" volume, which was basically empty, renamed the "Macintosh HD1" to "Macintosh HD" and pointed my user to the profile. Logged out and back in as myself and all my preferences and what not were back in place.
    Here's the only problem that I haven't been able to resolve. When saving/opening files from an application, in the sidebar, there are multiple desktops, 3 to be exact. One has a generic folder icon, the other two have the desktop icon and both actually point to the true desktop.If I open up a Finder window, there is only one desktop icon, it's just a problem in the Open/Save dialog box. How can I get it back to one desktop in the sidebar?

    That works in a normal Finder window, but not in the Save/Open dialog within an application.
    However, I deleted the sidebar.plist file within the Preferences folder, restarted and all is back to normal.

  • Using multiple desktops with a 4 finger swipe on a Mac Book Pro running Lion- is there a way that I can allow Safari open on several but not all??  Looks like I can set it for one but not others.  All, one, or nothing

    Using multiple desktops with a 4 finger swipe on a Mac Book Pro running Lion- is there a way that I can allow Safari open on several but not all??  Looks like I can set it for one but not others.  All, one, or nothing

    Hey Eric,
    Thanks for taking the time. Unfortunately no that does not solve it. Same as swipe it will get me there and it will show separate programs spaced out. The issue I am having is that all my open word files are bunched up in a pile on top of each other. I can see the edges of each one but I want them to be separated from each other enough that I can visually identify what file is what.
    Again, thanks for trying, it is appreciated.

  • The multiple desktops are gone. Cntrl/right arrow no longer works

    The multiple desktops are gone. Cntrl/right arrow no longer works. Nor does dragging a window to the right.

    chiefgypsy,
    Spaces no longer exists in Mountain Lion. The replacement, Mission Control, has a different implementaion but allows similar results.
    Mac Basics: Mission Control
    About Mission Control | Macworld
    CNTRL RIGHT ARROW doesn't work: Apple Support Communities

  • Creative Cloud Connection - Using Multiple Desktops in Mac OS X Mountain Lion

    I noticed that everytime I flip through my multiple desktops or OS X full-screen apps and come back to my home desktop the Creative Cloud Connection app pops open and is visible on my desktop.  The AAM never did this before.  Is there a way to shut this off or is an update coming to make this stop?

    Thanks for the info. This concern has already been raised to the engineering team and they are working on this.
    -Harshit yadav

  • How to create multiple Spaces (desktops) in Lion

    On Lion, Spaces tend to instead be called Desktops, but I’ll continue to use the term Spaces in this article. To make more, enter Mission Control and hover your mouse over the top-right of the screen (or hold the option/alt key). You’ll see a “+” button, and you can click it to create a new Space.
    You can also hover over any Space you’ve created (or again hold the option/alt key) to see a delete button, which you can use to delete that Space. You can only delete Spaces you’ve manually created.
    This info was found in the link provided below in my searches to figure out how to get diff spaces (desktops) in Lion since i use photoshop in one space, indesign in another and lightroom in another, etc...
    http://mattgemmell.com/2011/07/27/using-spaces-on-os-x-lion/

    Ex: hope you will find an idea from the below example :
    SELECTION-SCREEN BEGIN OF BLOCK SEL1 WITH FRAME TITLE TIT1.
    PARAMETERS: CITYFR LIKE SPFLI-CITYFORM,
                CITYTO LIKE SPFLI-CITYFORM.
    SELECTION-SCREEN end OF BLOCK SEL1
    SELECTION-SCREEN BEGIN OF SCREEN 500 AS WINDOW.
    SELECTION-SCREEN INCLUDE BLOCKS SEL1.
    SELECTION-SCREEN BEGIN OF BLOCK SEL2 WITH FRAME TITLE TIT2 .
    PARAMETERS: AIRPFFR LIKE SPFLI-AIRPFROM,
                AIRPTO LIKE SPFLI-AIRPTO.
    SELECTION-SCREEN END OF BLOCK SEL2
    SELECTION-SCREEN END OF SCREEN 5000.
    INITIALIZATION.
    TIT1 = 'ITIES'.
    aT SELECTION-SCREEN.
    CASE SY-DYNNR.
    WHEN '0500'.
       MESSAGE W159(at) WITH 'SCREEN 500'.
    WHEN '1000'.
       MESSAGE W159(at) WITH 'SCREEN 1000'.
    ENDCASE.
    START-OF-SELECTION.
    TIT1 = 'CITIES FOR AIRPORTS'.
    TIT2 = 'AIRPORTS'.
    CALL SELECTION-SCREEN 500 STARTING AT 10 10.
    TIT1 = 'CITIES AGAIN'.
    CALL SELECTION-SCREEN 1000 STARTING AT 10 10.

  • Multiple desktops/different icons?

    I am a student and I use my new mbp for lots of school related things, and it would be so easy and much neater looking if I could have all school related links and icons on one desktop, and personal things on another. But I can't figure out how; no matter how I try to move them, both desktops retain the same icons. Surely there is a way to do this? I don't keep programs running if I am not actively using them so the ability to have multiple desktops seems pointless if they are identical. Thanks.
    EDIT: doesn't it run down the battery faster to leave things running anyway?

    There's no way to do this out of the box. However there are 3rd party programs that provide that functionality. One I know of is called Desktop Tidy.
    There's no reason not to leave programs running. A program that isn't doing anything wastes no CPU cycles to speak of and if the OS really needs the memory for something else, the programs running in the background doing nothing will be auto-terminated.
    I keep my email, word processor, calendar, database, browser, Reminder, notes, and several other applications running all the time.

  • How do I switch remote desktops with lion server screen sharing?

    When I sometimes use the Lion Server screen sharing feature to take over my iMac using my Macbook, I find that I'm not able to switch desktops on the remote computer, i.e. using the three finger swipe.
    Both are running the latest versions of Lion Server.
    Now there MUST be some way to do that right?
    Who knows?

    Hi John, perhaps I did not express myself clearly.
    My desktop iMac is set up with multiple desktops (desktop 1 for system stuff, desktop 2 for mail, messages, skype etc, desktop 3 for Safari and desktop 4 for text proessing, VM-Ware and other work).
    When I work on that machine I'm logged in as one user and use the three finger swipe left and right or the Cmd-1 thru Cmd-4 keys to switch between those desktops.
    I haven't founf how to do that from my a remotely connected MacBook Pro.
    Both of which are running Mountain Lion in the mean time. The iMac runs Mountain Lion Server and the MBP has ML Server installed as well, but nut implemented. Just to be able to use the remote screen...
    Hope this makes my question a bit mre clear...
    Gerard

  • Hey Mavericks, where did my multiple desktops go?!?

    In Mountain Lion I was using a second monitor connected to MBP, and would have multiple desktops open and could swipe through all of the desktops with left & right gestures. It worked great. Now I upgrade to Mavericks and I'm no longer able to do this???
    Now in Mavericks, the second display is a static display, while the MBP is the only display that's able to swipe between multiple desktops.
    Is this the way it works now, why?? Please bring back multiple desktops.
    Thanks.

    You can setup as many desktops/spaces as you like and if you are using multiple displays, they can have their own separate desktops too.There are a couple of ways to set them up, depending how you work.
    Many of Apple's apps and many third party apps have the option of Full Screen support. To use this, it is the icon in the top right of the app window of two diagonal arrows. When using that, the app automatically make its own desktop. No other app that ca share it, and nothing hides behind that app.
    This implemtation is Ok, but I tend not to use it on a large display, as I don't need one app taking up my full 24" display. I do tend to use it on my 11" MacBook Air where display real estate is much more necessary.
    Otherwise, you can create multiple desktops AND assign particular apps to those desktops, so they have their own desktop space. To initally create a new desktop, go into Mission Control, move the mouse cursor to near the top right corner and a '+' will appear (or just drag an app window there) and tap on the '+' and new desktop is created.
    You an drag app windows to desktops within Mission Control. They should launch there from then on, but I find that function buggy in Mavericks.
    If you assign an app to a desktop using the Dock, Control-click the app icon and select Options > Assign to Desktop (of your choice) then that app will always open on that desktop.
    Going between desktops is easy, go to Mission control and click on the desktop at the top, or gesture on a trackpad using a side swipe with the number of fingers asigned in System Preferences > Trackpad, or Control-Arrow keys also works, your choice.
    A

  • Multiple Desktops

    Really like the multiple Desktops.  @ 1st thought it was much like Alt-Tab or hovering across Taskbar, basically, another View/Select approach.  In 7 (& 8) would run more than one tabbed browser grouping related sites in each.  This
    does that and on a higher level.  Can EASILY be done by 'family' or even if different sign-ins are required.  Can be put to good use, keeping things nicely organized & the Desktop, et al, neat, clean & uncluttered.
     Just wanted to reiterate what a cool feature I find this to be of Windows 10. IT is so nice how related things can be grouped together making the experience slick, neat, tidy & very organised & uncluttered... not having a bunch of stuff all mixed
    up together on one Desktop.  Microsoft calls it "Virtual Desktops".  For example, I have one w/ Skype, Outlook, Calendar... another w/ all IT stuff.... another w/ Home page & whatever & another w/ sites devoted to a singer/song-write
    of particular interest to me. Anyway, you get the idea and certainly can be configured however YOU fancy.  You simply open one, put what you want in it, hit the + sign & open another, fill it and so on.  I am not sure, yet, as to how many
    one can have but, a few, @ any rate.
    10 sure is easy to use.  Makes such a nice difference not having 'Hot Corners', hidden things or stuff that pops out from edges.  Plus, now, w/ 10 and its menu, I don't have to enable the Desktop Toolbar or create a folder on the Taskbar for Applications
    and can, still, not have to change screens for anything; just be 100% on the good ole Desktop.  All w/ hardly any 'learning curve'!  And it sure is speedy!  Certainly, non-touch PC Users should not have complaints w/ Windows 10.
    Cheers,
    Drew
    Drew MS Partner / MS Beta Tester / Pres. Computer Issues Pres. Computer Issues www.drewsci.com

    Thanks for your response. I think we might be talking about the same Desktop... If you close all your folders and applications and just have the Finder - I'm talking about that Desktop. The one that's called "Desktop" in Places. The one that in System Preferences is called "Desktop and Screensaver" and lets you place a picture of your choosing in the background. I think that's what you mean when you say it's "the background that all your windows and folder sit on." That's the Desktop I mean. (It is called the Desktop, isn't it?) The point isn't having different pictures there - that was hypothetical. At the moment I have a few folders and quicktime files sitting on my Desktop. If I create multiple Spaces - no matter which Space I open, the exact same folders and quicktimes remain on the Desktop. What I was wondering - and suspect isn't possible to do - is being able to create multiple Desktops: one that will have nothing but quicktime files waiting to be opened, one that will have nothing but folders waiting to be opened, etc. I hope this is clearer.
    Message was edited by: truffaldin

  • Under Options , Applications There are multiple entries for the same item (Acrobat Document). how can I delete the duplicates?

    Under Options, Applications there are multiple entries for the same item. (Adobe Acrobat) . Three show Adobe Acrobat Reader 9.3 and the other shows (ask) or (save file) with no ability to select Acrobat Reader . Is there a way to edit this list to remove the duplicates and
    the incorrect entry? Adobe installed a very quick update today.

    They are all different. Hover your mouse pointer over each of the "Content Type" descriptions and you should see a "tooltip" to see that each has a different description.
    You need to update your plugins. It is important to keep them updated due to continuing security fixes and improvements in those plug-ins:
    * Adobe Shockwave for Director Netscape plug-in, version 11.5 (you '''<u>may</u>''' need to update)
    * Shockwave Flash 10.1 r53
    * Next Generation Java Plug-in 1.6.0_20 for Mozilla browsers
    #Check your plugin versions: http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/plugincheck/
    #*'''Note: plugin check page does not have information on all plugin versions'''
    #'''Update Shockwave for Director'''
    #*NOTE: this is not the same as Shockwave Flash; this installs the Shockwave Player.
    #*Use Firefox to download and SAVE the installer to your hard drive from the link in the article below (Desktop is a good place so you can find it).
    #*When the download is complete, exit Firefox (File > Exit)
    #*locate and double-click in the installer you just downloaded, let the install complete.
    #*Restart Firefox and check your plugins again.
    #*'''<u>Download link and more information</u>''': http://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Using+the+Shockwave+plugin+with+Firefox
    #'''Update Shockwave Flash'''
    #*Use Firefox to Download and SAVE to your hard drive from the link in article below
    #*SAVE to your Desktop so you can find it
    #*After download completes, close Firefox
    #*Click on the file you just downloaded and install
    #**Note: Vista and Win7 users may need to right-click the installer downloaded and choose "Run as Administrator"
    #**Note: Most browsers other than IE will also get updated with this one download
    #**Note: To update IE, same procedure '''<u>but use IE</u>''' to go: http://fpdownload.macromedia.com/get/flashplayer/current/install_flash_player_ax.exe
    #*After installation, restart Firefox and check your version again.
    #*'''<u>Download link and other information</u>''': https://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Managing+the+Flash+plugin#Updating_Flash
    #* Also see: http://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Installing+the+Flash+plugin
    #* Also see (if needed): http://kb2.adobe.com/cps/191/tn_19166.html#main_Uninstall
    #'''Update Java:'''
    #* Download and update instructions: https://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Using+the+Java+plugin+with+Firefox

  • Yosemite consolidating multiple desktops on dual monitors,

    I have a Mac mini (mid 2010) - 2.4 GHz - 350 GB - Yosemite 10.10.2 - with dual LG monitors. Instead of using Mission Control I prefer to have multiple desktops on each monitor. I dedicate a single app to each desktop, e.g., Safari, iTunes & iPhoto on Mon1 facing Mail, Messages & Calendar on Mon2, and swipe between apps, which I find more convenient. Six numbered desktops plus Dashboard.
    In Mavericks this arrangement was preserved on restart. However, in Yosemite, all apps on Mon2 are consolidated in a single desktop, the remaining 2 desktops - 4 & 5 - have migrated blank to Mon1, PLUS an additional blank desktop - 6 - is generated on Mon1. The single desktop on Mon2 is now 7. On subsequent restarts there become eight, then nine, then ten desktops, etc.
    I've been up and down the settings options, tried System Help, outside searches, and even mentioned the issue in passing during an unrelated Apple Tech Support call. To no avail. I had hoped that one of the updates would resolve this. It is easily but inconveniently resolved manually, but as I mentioned this was a non issue in Mavericks.
    I mentioned this problem in an earlier post, but in less detail. Has anyone else experienced or heard of this?

    I did find a workaround........ that works so far....... If I put FCPX into full screen mode.  Then my events dissapear!!!!  But if I toggle on and off the "Window/Show Events in a separate window" menu then the Events reappear and I can swipe between desktops and all the windows behave as they should.  That's a relief.  The old method doesn't work but at least this one does.  I hope this helps someone who is swiping like a mad man like I was.

Maybe you are looking for