Audio-sync workflow without losing meta-data or project bloat?

So I love the FCPX keywords and metadata system and media organization but I'm running into a bit of a problem: I don't know how to use it while also using sync-sound. At least, not without duplicating lots of footage and losing metadata.
For instance, I have a interview project with 20 clips, all with baked-in audio and high quality seperate audio. Here's the only solutions I've found.
Workflow #1
Normally I just tag and organize the 20 clips and then see what I like and what I need. I then run into a problem though, the audio isn't synced, and syncing it after organizing will create compound clips which don't keep the keywords and organization (favorite, rejected, etc) of the original video file. Also, I now have two copies of the same clip. One with two audio tracks and the original.
Workflow #2
I could of course also sync-sound everything before I even start organizing and tagging and then "reject" all the original clips so I can hide them easily and only show my synced files. The problem with this is that I might spend a lot of time syncing files that I'll never end up using.
An even bigger problem with workflow #1 is that I can't make a rough cut to see what I need and don't need without having to re-do everything. Say I edit a simple timeline and I use clip 2, clip 5 and clip 8. If I then want to sync-sound them I can, but they will lose all keywords and data, and I also have to re-edit the synced clips to the timeline. Doing this for a project with 50 or a 100 or more clips basically means you have to re-do the entire edit.
Maybe I'm missing something here, but this all seems really clunky. I don't see why FCPX can't just automatically find and add any sync-sound the clips that are already edited to the timeline.
I realise that PluralEyes does something sort of similar, but it has more problems:
-It adds workflow bloat... it's a bunch of extra steps and time you have to spend outside of FCPX not editing
-You still have to manually find the audio clips that correspond to the clips on the timeline and line them up roughly
-PluralEyes will mess up your timeline and add lots of gaps that then need to be cleaned up.
-With longer audio-files it seems to not work a lot of the time, and It'll just leave your timeline a mess and without an actual solution
Does anybody know if there's a better workflow for this? Because it all seems very convoluted and non-sensical. Our computers are really fast and audiofiles are relatively small and easy to decode and analyse. I don't understand why there's just not an option to have Final Cut scan your event's audiofiles and compare them to the clips in the timeline and then just automatically sync the sound. It could even make compound clips for all I care, as long as it automatically places them in the timeline in the same place as the original clip and keeps the keywords etc in the event browser.
Not that any of these ways are any worse than what I always used to do in the old FCP or Premiere, but still. There has to be a better way!
Please tell me I'm missing something, or doing something wrong.

_Freighter_, I support your statement 100%.
I need to cut a documentary shot over 10 days for which I keyworded everything. Now I need to sync audio and I face the exact same issues as you and I don't know how to get started ...

Similar Messages

  • How to sync apps without losing app data without old pc?

    I want to sync my iPhone to a new laptop and I'm unsure if i lose saved games and app data. How do I do this and is there a solution where i can also keep data from apps that isn't listed in the purchased apps(for whatever reason)?
    If you need any more information I would be happy to fill in!
    Thank you so much in advance!!!

    Copy the entire iTunes media folder from the old computer or the backup of the old computer to the new computer.

  • My old mac died and harddisk is unmountable and no available backup. bought a new mac but how to sync iphone without losing any data on new mac

    any help is much appreciated

    If there is media content on the device that isn't in your library see Recover your iTunes library from your iPod or iOS device.
    The user tip includes a link to a backup tip which you should use to make sure that you can recover your library in the event of a problem.
    tt2

  • My computer crashed.    How do I sync with a new computer without losing unsaved data?

    My computer crashed.    How do I sync with a new computer without losing unsaved data?

    Downloading past purchases from the App Store, iBookstore, and iTunes Store
    For items you cannot get the above way use a third-party utility such as Phone to PC

  • I got a new computer and need to sync my iPhone and iPad on it, how do i do that without losing all data.

    I got a new computer and need to sync my iPhone and ipad on it, how do i do that without losing all data. I need help ASAP!

    If you still have the old computer see: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4527
    If you don't have your old computer, but you made regular backups of it, restore the most recent backup using the backup software that you used to make the backup. You will have to read the instructions for it.
    If you don't have your old computer and you did not back it up regularly see: Syncing to a "New" Computer or replacing a "crashed" Hard Drive

  • How do i sync my iPhone with a different computer without losing all data?

    How do i sync my iPhone with a different computer without losing all data?

    look here:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1202

  • I want to move from pc to mac without losing app data

    i have a new mac mini that has itunes and some music/tv shows/movies on it.  but i want to move my main itunes library from my pc to my new mac mini.  i know i can just copy my itunes folder from my pc to the mac, but i want to move my iphone data from pc to mac without losing app data (especially game data).  can I just copy my pc iphone backup data files to the mac and have them work in mac format?  or can i just plug in my iphone on the new mac, do a backup/restore and continue syncing from there?  does anyone have any advice on the best way to move iphone from pc to mac?

    I was fighting this battle the past few days myself; but actually it is REALLY easy now. See here:
    http://www.macworld.com/article/146958/2010/03/moveitunes_windowsmac.html
    Then, once iTunes was on the Mac, I did this:
    1. On the Mac rename ...\iTunes\iTunes Library.itl as ...\iTunes\iTunes Library
    2. On the Mac delete ...\iTunes\iTunes Library Genius.itdb (Apparently the PC & Mac versions are not compatible - iTunes will just rebuild it later)
    3. Launch iTunes and immediately press & hold down the Option key until a dialog opens asking you to Choose a library. Navigate to the folder/drive you've copied from the PC and open ...\iTunes\iTunes Library.
    (thanks to turingtest2 for the above steps)
    That was it. Did it yesterday evening. All playlists, libraries, everything copied fine. No problems; no broken links. Perfect.

  • Can you reset a forgotten password without losing all data on an iPod touch

    How can you reset a forgotten password without losing all data. 

    You have to restore from the computer to which it is synced.  Everything on the ipod should be on the computer so it can be put back on the ipod after restore.
    http://manuals.info.apple.com/en_US/iPod_touch_iOS4_User_Guide.pdf

  • Can I use two different devices with different apple ID for backing up data on one machine without losing any data that was backed up with one device earlier?

    Can I use two different devices with different apple ID for backing up data on one machine without losing any data that was backed up with one device earlier?

    The link is to a discussion started on 12/18 in the FiOS Internet forum.  Here's the link I get now, however it is different than the link I pulled a few hours ago.  If this system changes the link again, it may not work.
    http://forums.verizon.com/t5/FiOS-Internet/Frustration-and-just-confused-with-internet-help-please/t...
    You can also look for the topic, "frustration and just confused" in the FiOS Internet forum.
    Here's a link that is in the thread that gives more detail.
    https://secure.dslreports.com/faq/15984
    Good Luck!
    P.S.  "Copper Contributor" is my "rank."  gs0b is my user name.
    If a forum member gives an answer you like, give them the Kudos they deserve. If a member gives you the answer to your question, mark the answer as Accepted Solution so others can see the solution to the problem.

  • Can I upgrade from snow leopard to mountain lion without losing my data?

    Have finished an upgrade to snow leopard without losing any data on each of 9 MacBook Pros so far.  (Have 9 more to go) Can I do the mountain lion upgrade on them without losing data or must I back up the detritus of 4 years use by teachers who despite all pleas have never backed up their documents?  Would appreciate a swift reply as everyone wants their mbp's back in their hands on Monday morning. My thanks in advance to any gurus who care to reply as my local gurus seem to have fled the ashram for the weekend.

    Installing a new version of OS X should not lead to any data loss. Of course, it's best to have a backup if anything 'goes wrong' but simply isntalling the new OS shouldn't damage any data.
    Clinton

  • My iPod dispalys this message: "Connect to a computer. Use iTunes to restore."  When I connect to a computer, iTunes doesn't recognise it.  The iPod 5th Gen does not work at all. How do I fix my iPod without losing any data?

    My iPod dispalys this message:
    "Connect to a computer. Use iTunes to restore."  When I connect to a computer, iTunes doesn't recognise it.  The iPod 5th Gen does not work at all. How do I fix my iPod without losing any data?
    I have seen the Apple webpage suggesting the "five R's" (including restore).  Before doing anything, I want to be sure that restoring or any other action is not going to delete or risk my data. 
    I would be very grateful if anyone can suggest a fix for this problem, in a way that will not risk my data. 
    Thanks in advance!

    Did you try a hard reset with the iPod still connected to your PC?  Have you tried multiple USB ports, preferably high powered USB 2.0 ports?
    To do a hard reset, first make sure the hold switch is in the Off position, then press and hold both the Select (Center) and Menu buttons together long enough for the Apple logo to appear.
    Have you also worked through each and every single troubleshooting suggestion in this Apple support document?
    iPod not recognized in 'My Computer' and in iTunes for Windows
    B-rock

  • HT4859 I have an iPhone 5 and have just set up the iCloud for it. I also have an iPad with different content and I also want to connect it to iCloud. Will I lose everything that's on my iPad or iPhone or do they sync together without losing anything?

    I have an iPhone 5 and have just set up the iCloud for it. I also have an iPad with different content and I also want to connect it to iCloud. Will I lose everything that's on my iPad or iPhone or do they sync together without losing anything?

    The problem is that all services are bundled with your Apple ID ([email protected]):
    Your iCloud account (Mail, Contacts, Calendars, Reminders, Notes, Backups, etc.),
    also iTunes & App Store purchases (Music, Movies, TV Shows, etc.),
    and the iTunes Match services.
    (I guess that all your devices - yours and your wife's are connected to one iTunes library, right?)
    If you want that your wife gets her own iCloud account for Mail, Contacts, Calendars, etc. but gets also access to your media then you have two set up two things on her device:
    iCloud (Settings > iCloud) with her account (e.g. [email protected])
    and
    iTunes & App Stores (Settings > iTunes & App Stores) with your account (e.g. [email protected]).
    In this case she gets access to your library and could use the same iTunes Match account.
    (See also: Using one Apple ID for iCloud and a different Apple ID for Store Purchases http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4895)

  • HT3728 My Time Capsule is working fine with ethernet connection, but it is no longer working with wifi, probably because of my wrong setting; is there a way to reset wifi setting without losing backuped data? Thanks you all

    y Time Capsule is working fine with ethernet connection, but it is no longer working with wifi, probably because of my wrong setting; is there a way to reset wifi setting without losing backuped data? Thanks you all

    Giancarlo Messalli wrote:
    1) are you sure a reset holding the reset button will not delete my data?
    Absolutely sure.. There is no connection at all.. reset is only the router side of the TC.
    For the hard disk to be erased you need to access the airport utility disk page.. request erase and confirm the operation.
    2) I can access to time capsule by ethernet but I am not able to input the corret setting by myself
    Thank you again
    I am uncertain why if you have access you cannot change settings.. but that is why you reset things so any of those problems should be fixed.
    Here is the Apple info on reset.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3728
    And here is the quote from the horse's mouth so to speak.
    Factory default reset: Perform this reset if you wish to repurpose the AirPort Base Station or Time Capsule and want to remove all personal profiles and settings first. This reset resets the device to its state when you first purchased it. Data stored on internal or external hard drives connected to the device will not be erased. If you choose, you may manually erase the hard drive using AirPort Utility.

  • Migration from PC to Mac without losing application data (savegames etc.)

    Hello everyone,
    I am migrating from from my old Windows PC onto a MacBook Pro, and I'm having difficulties with iTunes and my iOS devices (iPhone 4, iPad 1). Maybe someone here can help me out, I'd be ever so grateful.
    I set up iTunes on my MBP yesterday and logged in to my account. I replaced the empty iTunes Media folder with my old one (which contains all my music, videos and applications) via an external hard drive.
    First problem: it wouldn't import these files into my new library automatically. Just showed me an empty library I think I imported the entire iTunes Media folder manually yesterday via "Add to folder". The status right now (after some experimentation) is old iTunes Media folder copied, but nothing imported (that is, I have an empty library).
    When I connected my iPhone and tried to synch, I first had to authorize the MacBook for the iPhone. So far, so good. However when I tried to synch iTunes warned me that if I synch, all data on the iPhone will be removed and replaced by the data from my new local library (which is, of couse a copy of my old library, but doesn't store application data like savegames).
    I tried to do it via "transfer purchased items from iPhone", which took forever, but yielded the same result: a warning that all data on the iPhone would be erased.
    So the question is: How do I connect my iPhone and iPad to iTunes on my new Mac without losing application data like settings and savegames? And why is this so complicated and intransparent? I should be able to just copy my media, say "authorize this Computer, then add iPhone to the registered devices" and then proceed like nothing ever changed.
    I searched the net until three in the morning yesterday, but couldn't find anything that sounded safe enough to give it a try.
    Thanks in advance and best Regards,
    Nate
    PS: I do have the backup-folders from my old PC on a USB stick - are those going to help?
    Message was edited by: Nathan1980 (Correction)
    Message was edited by: Nathan1980

    I was fighting this battle the past few days myself; but actually it is REALLY easy now. See here:
    http://www.macworld.com/article/146958/2010/03/moveitunes_windowsmac.html
    Then, once iTunes was on the Mac, I did this:
    1. On the Mac rename ...\iTunes\iTunes Library.itl as ...\iTunes\iTunes Library
    2. On the Mac delete ...\iTunes\iTunes Library Genius.itdb (Apparently the PC & Mac versions are not compatible - iTunes will just rebuild it later)
    3. Launch iTunes and immediately press & hold down the Option key until a dialog opens asking you to Choose a library. Navigate to the folder/drive you've copied from the PC and open ...\iTunes\iTunes Library.
    (thanks to turingtest2 for the above steps)
    That was it. Did it yesterday evening. All playlists, libraries, everything copied fine. No problems; no broken links. Perfect.

  • How can i transfer my whatsapp chat from iphone 3gs to google nexus 5 without losing any data?

    How can i transfer my whatsapp chat from iphone 3gs to google nexus 5 without losing any data? I want to swtich from my iphone to google nexus 5.could anyone help me for this?

    steve359 wrote:
    Please pardon the intrusion…
    Hi, FoxFifth!
    Congratulations on advancing to Level 6!
    At the Water Cooler in the Level 6 Lounge, we are preparing your welcome. Would you care to join us at the Water Cooler?
    On the Discussions Home Page (https://discussions.apple.com/welcome), down at the bottom, you will, hopefully, soon find the Lounge link available to you. It should show up for you within the next 24 hours if all goes as it should.
    Hope to see you there soon!
    Thanks! I'll check that out as soon as it becomes available.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Text Variable not showing headers in Formula

    I have text variable in my report when I use in Formula its not working.Its a replacement path and if I used in normal col its showing header correctly. Any ideas guru's Thanks in Advance! Andy

  • MBAM 2.5 Monitoring and administration website

    I am installing MBAM 2.5 integrated with SCCM 2012. Reporting services point is working on SCCM Server. When installing monitoring and administration website reporting url is not working I am providing  http://sccmserver/reportserver  I have already

  • Infinity rollout stopped at the end of my street ?...

    Hi all, This is my first post so here goes. Like most people I've been waiting for Infinity for a while now. I already know my exchange has been updated MYLOF, and that my street cabinet (CAB 15) hasnt been. My issue is that the rollout has completel

  • LTA Exemptions in Infotype 582

    Hi All, The LTA amount which need to be exempted is entered in Infotype 582 - LTA subtype. This is not taken for Income Tax taxable amount. I need some help is understanding the technical internals like - what could make this LTA exemption component

  • No sound in QT movies

    I want to import old QT movies (MPEG-1) to Final Cut Pro 3 but when imported they are without sound. What can be the problem or how can I configurate FCP to import correctly the movies ? Elsa