Auto tone in Lightroom 3 unusable - have to 'auto tone' the image in CS4 for correct tonal quality.

The 'Auto Tone' in Lightroom 3.2 never gives me the correct tone, that I'm looking for in my image. It'll either make the overall image too dark, or over-brighten it in unrealistic colours.
I always have to go out of Lightroom and edit/auto tone my image in Photoshop CS4, which gets it spot-on just about every time, especially with my studio shoots. In Lightroom 3 the backgound/overall image stays dull looking, while in CS4 it automatically brings out the crisp white of the background.
I also use OnOne PhotoTools 2.53 Professional Edition, where I see the Auto Tone matches CS4 exactly - Lightroom 3 however definitely uses a different algorithm, which is not useful for me at all and makes for much longer editing times.
Example 1 (image auto toned in CS4):
Example 2 (image auto toned in Lightroom 3.2):

Hi Rob
Appreciate your replies.
I'm using the 'Image -> Auto Tone' function directly within CS4 - I'm not using the ACR window through CS4.
I see that CS4 can no longer be updated with the latest ACR (6.2), although obviously Lightroom 3 can still be updated. Maybe this is where the 'different auto tone results' come in. Maybe the latest version of ACR is not as compatible to my image requirements, as the previous editon with CS4 was.
Anyhow, to recap, I use 'Auto Tone' straight in CS4, with preferable results over that in LR3. I'm not sure what an effect ACR has over the 'auto tone' functionality in both these versions.
I definitely do however want to post this question in the Adobe Technical Support section - thanks for that.
Best regards,
Franz

Similar Messages

  • When I have finished working on an image in Photoshop and I hit the save button it goes instead to the "save as" screen. This never happened in previous Photoshop versions. When I get to Lightroom, I have a grey screen the says "File could not be found."

    When I have finished working on an image in Photoshop and I hit the "save" button, it goes instead to the "save as" screen. This never happened in previous Photoshop versions. When I get to Lightroom, I have a grey screen the says "File could not be found." I then have to go to "locate" to get the image. When I select the correct image, I get a message that it is not the same file name but I am eventually able to access the image. Needless to say this is having a negative impact on workflow!

    The problem with write permissions for the OneDrive folder only shows up in Lightroom 6's export dialogue, that's why it's to irritating. Lightroom 5.7.1 is not having that problem nor does the file explorer. The problem also exists on both of my machines. I will try to check for other problems with the OneDrive troubleshooter though: Running the OneDrive troubleshooter - Windows Help   

  • Hello that is able to separate an apple icloud account My IMEI. I buy a Used iphone ios 7.1.1 5c but after restore it asks me iCloud account.I have no contact with the seller. thank you for your reply.

    Hello
    that is able to separate an apple icloud account My IMEI *******.
    I buy a Used iphone 5c ios 7.1.1  but after restore it asks me iCloud account.
    I have no contact with the seller.
    thank you for your reply
    <Edited by Host>

    The iPhone has Activation Lock and will require you to have the previous owner's Apple ID and password or you'll need to get the previous owner to remove the device from his/her iCloud account:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/PH2702
    If you can't reach the previous owner or he/she is unwilling to cooperate, then the device is unusable by you. Return the iPhone for a refund if you can.
    Regards.

  • Ps cs6 on mac. since installing yosemite, when working on an image if i want to change tool, via shortcut of wacom pen click, i now have to click on the image title bar, how can i fix this please?

    ps cs6 on mac. since installing yosemite, when working on an image if i want to change tool, via shortcut or wacom pen click, i now have to click on the image title bar, how can i fix this ?

    @Naiks, having suffered through unsuccessful synching attempts for Calendar and Contacts myself, l would suggest you try the following:
    UNINSTALL iCloud control panel from your PC. Seems silly, but do it.
    Go into Outlook, and look at the very top menu. Click FILE, then ACCOUNT SETTINGS, then click the popup box.
    You will see a list of all your email accounts. Make sure that ONE of them has a checkmark against it. If not, select the account your want as your default, and click "set as default.
    Exit out of Outlook and reboot your machine.
    Now reinstall iCloud, check CALENDAR and CONTACTS, and do as instructed when prompted.
    Reboot for good luck and now launch OUTLOOK. All that remains is to locate your iCloud Contacts and Calendar files, and make them your default.
    IMPORTANT: Don't panic if you can't find your contacts -- they're there. Click CONTACTS and you'll see you have several available contact files. Locate the one label "iCloud" in grey type. Right-click on it, select PROPERTIES, then click the Outlook Address Book tab. Check the box that says something like "Make this my default Outlook Address Book." Keep clicking "apply" and "okay" until you've exited out of the dialog box maze.
    You may have to do something similar with your Calendar files. I dd not, but if you need to, do it.
    Everything should now sync pretty seamlessly.
    I didn't have the exact same problem as you, but my dilemma was close enough. Good luck!
    Arthur P. Johnson

  • I have been working on the same numbers file for the past few weeks.  The last time I opened it was 1 week ago.  Today when I tried to open it I am unable and getting a message that the file is invalid and the index.xml file is missing.

    I have been working on the same numbers file for the past few weeks.  The last time I opened it was 1 week ago.  Today when I tried to open it I am unable and getting a message that the file is invalid and the index.xml file is missing. 

    Hi Tracie,
    I upgraded to Maverick OS X 10.9.5, numbers spreadsheet is saved. Upon re-opening, it appears to be frozen, a warning "file is invalid as index.xml file is missing". I checked, and the file is not "locked". This appears to occur only with using the new numbers app. When I open previous spreadsheets from old iWorks, no such problem occurs.
    How did you resolve your problem?
    Would appreciate any help here.
    Thanks,
    Deehay

  • I am using a MacPro running OS 10.6.8. When saving an image in PS CC I no longer have a thumbnail of the image in my folder , just a generic PS symbol thumbprint. What do I do to get my image thumbnail back?

    I am using a MacPro running OS 10.6.8. When saving an image in PS CC I no longer have a thumbnail of the image in my folder , just a generic PS symbol thumbprint. What do I do to get my image thumbnail back?
    Adobe Creative Cloud

    Photoshop CC needs at least OSX 10.7-10.9
    You may be able to install and run it on 10.6.8, but as I understand it the rules for generating thumbnails has changed with Apple and CC writes them to suit the required OSX.
    Photoshop CS6 will always give you image thumbnails but CC and CC 2014 have had thumbnails generated differently for the required OSX.
    You will have to upgrade to 10.7,10.8, or 10.9
    My file saving preferences are set like this:

  • Recently downloaded a trial version of CC and when trying to use the Adjustment Brush in ACR it brings up the message 'All the local adjustment controls are set to have no effect on the image'.  I've downloaded this as an update to CS5 on my new i Mac.  W

    Recently downloaded a trial version of CC and when trying to use the Adjustment Brush in ACR it brings up the message 'All the local adjustment controls are set to have no effect on the image'. I've downloaded this as an update to CS5 on my new i Mac. Would appreciate suggestions to remedy this. Rhonda

    I think it means "the sliders are all 0 so painting adjustments with this brush won't change anything."  In other words, move one of the sliders to a non-zero position, for example Exposure from 0 to 1.0, and then see what happens.  You can edit the brush and change it to do something other than Exposure +1.

  • HT5503 ...why cant i update the software on my phone!! i hav an iphone 3gs, the option in "general" for "software update" isnt there? can i do it through the computer instead?

    i hav an iphone 3gs, the option in "general" for "software update" isnt there? can i do it through the computer instead?

    What you are looking for is only available for iOS 5 and above.  You will need to connect your iPhone to a computer and update through iTunes as always.

  • Why have apple taken away the full screen photo for calls?

    Why have apple taken away the full screen photo for calls?

    There is plenty of discussion about this here:
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/25125511#25125511

  • I have an older phone, the Iphone 4.  For some reason, all of my calendar events are gone.  I can't see old, present or future events.  Help me please.  I need this information.

    I have an older phone, the Iphone 4.  For some reason, all of my calendar events are gone.  I can't see old, present or future events.  Help me please.  I need this information.

    Please please help me, if you know how.

  • I dont have and cant get the apple id password for my phone

    i dont have and cant get the apple id password for my phone

    till whenever i want my iphone give it back to me
    i was in Condong Catur Yogyakarta,
    my phone number +6287738546695
    i will block the imei if no progress in 1 week

  • Could not open gmail on the mail application of the mac book pro. Gmail has two account types, SMTP and Google IMAP. In both cased failure in trying to log on to SMTP and Google IMAP because I have to verify that the username and password are correct.  Ho

    Could not open gmail on the mail application of the mac book pro.
    Gmail has two account types, SMTP and Google IMAP.
    In both cases failure in trying to log on to SMTP and Google IMAP because I have to verify that the username and password are correct.
    How do I verify that? Please help. Thanks.

    Routing gmail through Mail.app:
    imap-http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=81379&topic=12814
    pop-http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=13275&topic=12810
    More up-to-date advice here:
    http://www.macworld.com/article/2033842/make-mail-and-gmail-play-nice.html#tk.nl _mwhelp
    Note that you lose privacy when using Gmail (and Yahoo):
    Gmail and Yahoo both scan users' emails. They do algorithmic analysis of your email messages, targeting ads that relate to the content of your messages.

  • Dear sir/madame,I have tried to use the inbrowser editing capability for Adobe Muse to login to my CMS. To login I have use the exact same FTP details I have used to upload my website, I even checked the page url multiple times but I keep getting the same

    Dear sir/madame,I have tried to use the inbrowser editing capability for Adobe Muse to login to my CMS. To login I have use the exact same FTP details I have used to upload my website, I even checked the page url multiple times but I keep getting the same error (the username and password are invalid for your FTP server. Please check them and try again). The hosting website (Yourhosting.nl) only has this one FTP user, which I cannot expand to more users. Can you please tell me if I am doing something wrong? The url to this page is http://e-divecollege.be/index.html or www.e-divecollege.be

    Dear sir/madame,I have tried to use the inbrowser editing capability for Adobe Muse to login to my CMS. To login I have use the exact same FTP details I have used to upload my website, I even checked the page url multiple times but I keep getting the same error (the username and password are invalid for your FTP server. Please check them and try again). The hosting website (Yourhosting.nl) only has this one FTP user, which I cannot expand to more users. Can you please tell me if I am doing something wrong? The url to this page is http://e-divecollege.be/index.html or www.e-divecollege.be

  • My videos in lightroom  3.3 do not match the image in the flimstrip

    I believe I have messed up the library catalog by going into a folder and changed images using windows explorer (outside lightroom). I messed up the library to where the thumbnail for the videos are not related to the video that plays and I don't know how to correct it. Any help would be awesome.

    Press "H".
    When using the Radial Filter, there are various options using the "Show Edit Pins" menu at the bottom of the image. Pressing the "H" keys toggles between "Never" (likely what you have) and "Auto" (which shows the pins and the elipse when the mouse is over the images, but hides them when you move the mouse off the image). There are other options as well, experiment with them to get to your preferred display state.
    These same display options are also in the Gradient tool and the Adjustment Brush.

  • Lightroom 3.4 don't show the images in the correct colour.

    After importing the files from my Camera, the pictures are shown in wrong colour.
    I have a 600D from Canon and Windows 7 Professional 32 bit. Here is a picture of Lightroom 3.4 and the Original:
    My problem is how to change the settings in Lightroom to get the right colours.
    Thanks for helping me.
    Jens

    You have to make sure that you are not comparing apples to oranges..
    In order to evaluate the colors you have to make sure that two conditions are met:
    a) your monitor needs to be calibrated, and
    b) the image needs to be viewed in the same color space.
    Color space: LR displays every image in ProPhoto RGB - and there is no provision to change that -, wheras other programs (except image editing programs) often display images either in sRGB or they are not color managed at all.
    So what makes you think that what you call the "Original" shows the right color? In which program were you viewing it? Is this program color managed? And which color space does it use? And you cannot go by the display of your camera either; they are often wrong.
    In all likelihood it is LR that displays the correct color.
    WW

Maybe you are looking for

  • How do I transfer data from one hard drive to another

    I just bought a bigger external hard drive and I want to transfer all my data from the old smaller external hard drive? How do I accomplish this? I see the all the data and can highlight the files but I can not drag them on to the new external drive.

  • Remove an add-in?

    I installed an add-in a few days ago that makes the mail viewing screen better for wide screens. I want to remove this and return to the default view. How can I do this? How do I remove this? I tried to look for the add-in in the Mail package content

  • Fireworks CS3 slow startup

    Hi folks, I installed CS3 Web Premium last week. Not had chance to play with it a lot as yet but I have come across one irritation already: When I launch Fireworks CS3 it takes between 10 and 20 seconds from the program loading on screen to being abl

  • Is there any user agent to differentiate firefox metro and desktop mode?

    My application runs with silverlight plugin.I have to provide a user friendly message in metro mode that the plugin is not supported? How will I detect if firefox is running in desktop or metro mode? Please reply.Very urgent

  • Bonjour Printer not showing up

    I replaced today my old airport basestation with the new "n" basestation. Now the USB printer attached to it is not showing up (showed up on the old basestation). What do I have to do?