Better than DVD Studio Pro?

I decided the DVD Studio (although great) is limiting and I'm looking for an upgrade.
Currently I'm looking at Sonic Scenarist which looks very comprehensive. But is there anything else of the same quality?
Thanks for any help
Tim

I had a bit of both having played with Flash & Director for a few years but the part that helped me the most was more to do with having used lots of authoring tools as well as having read DVD Dem a bunch of times.
If you can program projects in Creator you will at least know what you are trying to do. You have some knowledge of spec stuff, unlike if you go from DSP to Scenarist. That is a big jump and you may find yourself with a pretty much vertical learning curve at first! Dont be fooled by my learn it in a month comment either cause I'm still learning its little nuances...
Another point that has been raised is that dont get caught up in features too much. I often see it said that Scenarist is $15,000 or it costs more than DSP for fewer features. BUT the fact is that you can get Scenarist Studio for less and if you never do any angles work then why make a big deal about DSP allowing more streams (than Scen. Studio)!
Without more info its a tough one to advise on. Cause many houses who use Scenarist have paid for it in less than 2 months. If you dont have the clients who'll pay, or aren't able to create DVDs that will get your investment paid for then dont get Scenarist. If you can budget for a version that fits your needs its a great option but if not then you may have to give more info on why you find DSP limiting as there could be ways to do what you are trying to do...
-jake

Similar Messages

  • Is DVD Studio Pro faster than iDVD?

    Sorry I'm double posting this but I didn't get my question in the Subject line. Is DVDSP faster than iDVD? If so, by how much? I'm on the endless quest for more speed.

    I have a feeling you're asking about the time to compress video, in which case it will depend on the settings you've chosen. As a rough guestimate I would say that iDVD will compress as fast as the faster possibilities in DVD Studio Pro (which is using Compressor behind the scenes). Using Compressor would allow you to more carefully get the best quality for a given amount of video, instead of iDVD's one hour or two hour approach.
    Usually though you would tend to compress the video before taking it into DVD Studio Pro, and you wouldn't need to compress it again before doing a build or burning a disc.
    If you meant is DVD Studio Pro faster to create a title, it varies depending on what the disc needs to do. The important thing is that there are things you just cannot do in iDVD, and if you need to do those you could use DVD Studio Pro to do them.

  • Is DVD Studio Pro More Reliable Than iDVD?

    Is DVD Studio Pro more reliable than iDVD?
    Because my needs are simple, I thought I'd just use iDVD to burn DVDs. I created a movie in Final Cut Express, exported it as a Quicktime movie with chapter markers, and created an iDVD project around it. The iDVD project recognizes the chapter markers and it all plays just fine from within iDVD, but I haven't been able to successfully burn a DVD of the project.
    The video is a little over an hour long. When I start the burn process a box tells me that it will take something like 3 hours and 45 minutes, and the clock starts ticking down. Fine. Then somewhere around two hours later, iDVD quits and I get a message saying only that iDVD "quit unexpectedly." (As if I didn't know that.) The same thing happens when I try to save as a disc image instead of burning directly to a DVD. I've got plenty of hard disk space, have repaired permissions, etc.
    This leaves me wondering whether DVD Studio Pro might be a more robust program. This is a very simple project -- one video, 13 chapters -- so it's very disappointing that iDVD can't seem to deal with it.
    So -- is there any general consensus about how DVD Studio Pro compares to iDVD in terms of stability and reliability?

    I do not think there is a clear answer on that one. I use both and find iDVD has less issues than DVD SP (not that DVD SP has a ton of issues, but enough that eventually you will probably run into something that will throw things off and will need to know the workaround.)
    If you look at the boards you will see people that have problems with both applications. Not that either one is bad, but since boards are designed to help with issues, it is rare that you get someone saying "Wow this has been rock solid for a year" so it is always a grain of salt.
    DVD SP does give you more control over things, but by the same token it may not be the application you need. In other words since it is now part of the Final Cut Studio you would need to take a look at the Studio and see if it is something you want. The iApps overall, IMHO, do quite alot for many things and I use them often depending on what I am trying to do. Your project should work it sounds like and there may be something going on (well yes there is of course) You may want to take a quick look at these threads where people have quit issues with iDVD and see if any of the details in th workflow, computer etc are similar and if there are solutions.
    QUit iDVD Issues
    Hope this helps a bit

  • To create a PAL DVD in DVD Studio Pro...

    I simply took my NTSC Uncompressed Quicktime File, put it into Compressor, and when I converted the file to MPEG 2 I changed the Video Format to PAL in the Inspector Settings. I didn't make any changes to the AC3 settings...
    When the m2v and AC3 files were created I put them into DVD Studio Pro in a PAL Project and burned a DVD...
    I watched the DVD on my MacBook Pro computer in DVD Player and it looked great and the sound synced up and everything. I put the DVD into my Playstation 3 and tried to watch it on my NTSC TV Monitor and a message came up saying "Playstation doesn't support PAL format"...
    So it seems like everything worked correctly. Did it? I need to send this DVD to the Edinburgh International Film Festival and I want to make sure it will work.
    Thanks!
    Mike

    The Best Buy Blueray player to get is the Playstation 3. Someone here said that as a Blueray player it's terrible compared to a designated Blueray player, and he may be right, but my local high-end audio store said the Playstation 3 is actually a very good Blueray disc player. These guys are very reputable so I'm not sure what this other guy is talking about. I'm sure there are designated players that are better than the Playstation 3, but they can't be $400 either. And I personally thought the quality of my Blueray disc on my Playstation 3 was awesome, though of I've not watched the disc on a designated player for comparison. Hope this helps...
    Mike

  • Dvd studio pro: DVDs won't work on DVD player and windows computer

    Hi
    I have burnt some dvds on DVD Studio Pro I checked they were set to SD and PAL and have played them on my MAC and DVD player no problem but now I am hearing back from my client that they tried playing them on their windows computer and laptop and their DVD player and it isn't working what could be the reason for this?
    From Mike

    You can see if they have another software player available.  Usually VLC is a good option.  Windows player can be a bit all over the place depending on patches of the OS and other items.   I have encountered some strange things, including people claiming that DVDs I have authored were doing things that had nothing to do with the DVD (beyond the scope of what a DVD can do, etc.)
    When you say DVD Player, does this mean they are also trying to play it in a DVD Player (real player and not in computer?)  How did you burn the DVD?  Straight from DVD SP?  Check first play settings and other items?
    These are some of the first things I would be starting with, particularly if real DVD players (not in computers) are concerned.  It also can be something as small as dirt or scratches on the DVD itself.  Some machines can be better at compensating than others are. 

  • IDVD vs DVD Studio Pro

    Please help! I've heard talk that it's better to burn DVDs using DVD Studio Pro than iDVD? Is that true?
    I'm asking because I worked on a project that was distributed to over 200 people. Out of those 200 discs, about 30 of them were returned because they skipped, restarted or just didn't play on some DVD players.
    I've gone back to the drawing board and made the following changes using iDVD before burning more copies of my project:
    1) Purchased Taiyo Yuden 8x discs
    2) Changed the burning speed to 1x
    3) Changed burning option from Pro Quality to Best Performance
    I've also heard that the reason High or Pro Quality isn't a good choice for burned discs to play on standard DVD players is because the Mac burns the disc at too high of a bitrate. Is this true? Either way, should I worry about iDVD not producing a good quality disc vs using DVD Studio Pro?
    Help!!!!

    hey there Luis,
    i doubt that iDVD was the problem since 85% of your DVDs worked. it could be that some of the players were to old to play they type of discs burned. some older DVD players may not like any flavor of recordable DVD, some just may not like DVD+R, preferring the older DVD-R standard. i've used iDVD since iLife 03 & had 3 that wouldn't work on customers players, but that got resolved with customers getting newer players made since 2003/2004. w/out knowing your individual customers DVD players, you may not not hit 100% compatibility.
    DVD SP is a much more complicated app than iDVD, but they essentially do the same thing-allow the user to author & burn movies & photo slide shows to recordable DVD media. DVD SP allows for more interactivity & more types of content to be applied in authoring a DVD, such as a game or web site-like "Harry Potter & Sorcerer's Stone" DVD, as such it is more difficult for novices. it has a pretty steep learning curve just like Apple's other Pro Apps & is only available w/ FCS1 or FCS2, also pretty expensive.

  • LiveType Credit Roll Text Blurry Shaking in DVD Studio Pro Completed SD

    I first created text scrolling directly from inside FCP. The texts appear shaking/blurry in the exported MOV. After trying different font family/size but still getting the same bad result, I did more research. I then created the credit roll in LiveType, imported that into FCP. This time, the exported finished MOV looks great on computer. I thought this is the right fix but after I got everything done in DVD Studio Pro and burned a SD to test on my 50" screen SONY, the credit roll part is again shaking and blurry!! This really drove me nuts!! Well, other texts that I created both in FCP and LiveType appear just fine!! I am trying to export the credit roll texts part as self-contained mov then import back to FCP but really suspect this will fix the problem.
    That part of rolling credit texts were shaking in DVD Pro simulation but I thought that's only becuase it was not the final product. Any help will be greatly appreciated!
    p.s. I spent the past few hours googling and tried different methods but still had no luck...:(
    Thanks in advance!

    Ok...I just export a MOV with ONLY the credit roll encoded using QuickTime conversion, change the compression type to Uncompressed 8-Bit 4:2:2 which was supposed to retain the graphic/text quality better than normal setting. The completed credit roll still look shaking, however. It's white text on black, yeah I know not the best combo but there must be a way to get the text to not shake/blur...no?
    Please help, if anyone could.
    Many thanks...

  • M2v files from compressor will not play in QT or DVD Studio Pro

    I have 2 hours of HD footage that I am trying to put on a DVD. I tried exporting the entire thing (twice) to an mpeg2 but the resulting file would not open and froze quicktime. I then tried exporting the chapters individually. Even though I tried this twice, only the first clip worked. I then copied each chapter into a new sequence in FCP and exported each sequence to Compressor. This time, I could only open one of the 15 or so files in QT, but I could not even import that into DVD Studio Pro (it said it was an invalid file type). I have been using all the same settings, so I am not sure why chapter 1 works fine everywhere, chapter 2 works in QT but not DVD Studio Pro and the remaining chapters do not work anywhere. Anyone got any ideas as to what to do/try next?

    I know that it will take a while, but after two tries exporting the whole thing and the result not working, I broke it up into smaller, 10 minute sections hoping that the computer would be able to handle them better and if one is bad, it is easier to fix than re-doing the entire thing.
    The Compressor settings I am using: DVD Best Quality 150 minutes with all the default settings except that I put stream usage at HD DVD. I have also tried using Fastest Encode 150 minutes, also changing the stream usage.
    I exported 20 minutes with Fastest Encode and changed the file format to 'H.264 for DVD Studio Pro' and it worked, but it is a mov file that is much bigger than the mpeg2 (m2v) file.
    I started the compressor to work on the remaining hour at night and then left it until the next afternoon, but when I came back, it said there were 60+ hours remaining, but FCP was counting off the frames. I left it for another couple hours, hoping that compressor was simply estimating wrong, but when I came back, it said there were 93 hours remaining until it would be done. I canceled it and restarted the computer.

  • H.264 not readable in DVD Studio Pro

    I'm using compressor for a massive DVD Yearbook. The setting I am using is the H.264 For DVD Studio Pro. However, when importing the converted videos into DVD STudio Pro, the software gives an error saying, "This format is not readable by DVD SP." What gives? If it says H.264 for DVD Studio Pro, why will the program not read a file created specifically for it?

    The only format that DVDs read is mpeg 2. H.264 is a great compression, but not DVD compatible.
    You can take the original full quality .mov and compress to mpeg2 from that. It'll give you better quailty than compressing an already-compressed file. "Export using compressor" option in FCP is the best choice -- then choose DVD presets when compressor opens.

  • DVD Studio Pro keeps pixelating my footage

    Despite clean source and no matter what I change out the "problem" clip with, there's a 10 second duration in the movie file that gets pixelated every time at the exact spot. Everything else on the DVD is fine.
    I'm not sure how to describe this any better, so please feel free to ask questions to clarify any details.
    Here are a few technical details about the project:
    4.1GB being burnt to a 4.7GB, single layer DVD.
    One Pass VBR.
    Bit rates: 4.0 - 6.5
    DVD Studio Pro 4 on a MacBook Pro
    I've burnt several large DVDs with this same setup, without any problems. This one, I've burnt well over 6 times on various DVD-R brands.

    DV/DVCPRO NTSC (Compressor Quality: Best)
    Try uncompressed 8 bit (takes up room, but worthwhile) Also make sure your sequence settings are BEST for scaling. If you used any renders for filters etc, you may want to delete the renders via Render Manager and re-render
    I've used several variations for that 10 second duration. Everything from animated stills to untouched video. Nothing different than what's already on the DVD.
    So this section is basically the same as all the rest in the video?
    The running time is 96 minutes.
    Definately A.Pack the audio, rough calculation is that the average bitrate can be about 6 (http://dvd-hq.info/Calculator.html & http://www.videohelp.com/calc.htm) with audio a.Pack/Dolby at 192
    I just now switched the settings to Two Pass VBR.
    Won't work on existing project properly (trying to change encodes in preferences), you are better off encoding outside of DVD SP then bringing it the encoded assets in.
    Try just exporting the problem section and see if you can get a good encode for that, will save some times as oppossed to trying to encode the whole thing, take 30 seconds, 10 seconds on either side

  • Quality issues in iDVD - is DVD Studio Pro the answer?

    Hi all,
    I am having a problem producing a high quality DVD with iDVD. I know this is the DVD studio forum but I am wondering if I need to switch form iDVD to get the results I want. So, this is what I am doing in iDVD.
    I am using 13 QT (.mov) movie files that were made using the "Best" quality setting. Their size is 720 X 480. I am using the "Professional Quality" encoding in the Preference dialog and the Project settings dialog. The theme I am using is Revolution. (This is all in iDVD)
    I have burned a few DVDs (Memorex DVD+RW, 4X) and at first used the "Best Performance" encoding. It took about 20 min to burn the DVD. The results were too pixelated. Then I read about the other settings, and used the "Professional Quality". This higher setting took over 40 min to burn the DVD. Unfortunately,the results were not that much better.
    Can someone help me to figure out what is wrong? I am looking to produce the crisp quality I see when I view the QT movie files (before I incorporated them into my iDVD project).
    What I am thinking is that iDVD is not capable of producing the high crisp quality I am looking for and that DVD Studio Pro might be my answer. Or, could it be my QT movie files (thou they look great when I just play them on my computer in the QT player.
    Thanks
    PS: I posted a similar topic in the iDVD forum but no answers as of yet and I am on a strict deadline (aren't we all...lol)

    You didn't mention that you were doing screen captures. That makes a difference. Camtasia is compressing your screen captures. All DVDs use MPEG-2 compression. So you are in fact double compressing your videos (which always results is lower quality).
    To get better results see if you can get Camtasia to record uncompressed, or using the Animation codec at Best. This will result in a absolutely huge file, which is what you want. You bring that into iDVD for good results. Or bring it into Compressor and then DVD SP for better results. Or a third party MPEG-2 encoder like BitVice and then DVD SP for best results. Of course using anything other than iDVD will require a couple of weeks training.

  • DVD Studio pro vs iDVD: DVD Quality?

    Do the DVDs made by DVD studio Pro look better than those from iDVD?
    I have very good looking HD videos, made in iMovie: which look quite good as QT movies, but quality deteriorates a fair amount when iDVD makes it into a DVD. looking for better DVD product. Will I notice a difference with DVD Studio pro. kinda expensive if doesn't improve quality of final product.
    roger

    If you use the default compressor built into DVDSP it will probably be very similar to iDVD.
    If you buy Final Cut Studio to get DVDSP you will also get an application called Compressor that allows for very high quality HD to DVD compression if you customize the presets.

  • Can I avoid re-encoding of .mov files with Compressor and DVD Studio Pro?

    Hello,
    I've had some projects banned at one of the tracking sites because my iMovie 6.0.1/iDVD 7.1.1 workflow involves re-encoding of the iMovie .mov file to MPEG 2 when authored in iDVD. I did some research, and was advised that I could get around the re-encoding by using Compressor and DVD Studio Pro instead of iDVD. But, when I import the iMovie file to Compressor for authoring in DVD Studio Pro, the result is another MPEG 2 file. So, am I missing something, or is there no way for me to avoid re-encoding with Apple video production tools.
    Thanks for any assistance.

    The simple fact that you have to encode your files into an mpeg-2 stream means that you're going to experience a loss in quality.  Check the bitrate of your DV files.  The max bitrate for all of the elementary steams (audio, video) on a DVD is 9.8mbps.  So if your source has a higher bitrate than that... you're going to experience "lossiness."
    However there are some tricks that I've read about that increase the overall quality of compression... and yes they are for windows.  Check out AVIsynth and MeGUI... there is a learning curve to learning these tools though.  I never followed through with it.
    EDIT: Also forgot to mention that learning these things takes TIME.  Quality encoding takes much longer than realtime. 
    You can also check out some higher quality mpeg2 encoders like cinemacraft and HC encoder, although the former costs $$$.  The quality you get from these encoders are much better than what you have in iDVD and DVDSP/Compressor.

  • Issues With DVD Studio Pro 1.5 - MPEG2 Encoding & Building Discs

    Hi.
    I'm having problems encoding MPEG2 files in final cut express - everytime I try to encode, final cut closes.
    Also, when I go to build and format a disc in dvd studio pro, this also closes.
    I have looked at updating dvd studio pro to 1.5.2 and although I have downloaded the .bin file for the update, I don't know how to get it to run. The download is from the following link ( http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=120138 )
    If anyone could help at all, it would be much appreciated.
    Thanks!

    Of all the early versions of DVDSP, 1.5.2 was the most stable and you really ought to be using that if you are not going to upgrade further.
    V1 was notoriously flaky. I used to chant 'Apple+S' every day when I used it, just to remind me to save... I lost count of the number of hours lost when the app hung or crashed. That version of DVDSP was built on an entirely different code base to the current version. There are still folk who prefer to use V1 despite its faults, but I am not one of them... although I do still run a version of it somewhere.
    The upgrade will be straightforward enough. Double click the file you have downloaded and you should get a disc image. Open it and double click on the files inside. Keep your serial number handy, although I don't recall it being needed for a minor upgrade.
    You may find that encoding is your biggest hurdle. Back in the day of v1.5 there were very few cheap options open to you. One was to use the Quicktime MPEG encoder, which was a system file you had to install into the QT folder in the system library. Since the system library can't be altered whilst the system is running (i.e. your mac is on) this was a bit of an issue - you either used the terminal app, or booted into target disc mode and used a second mac to put the file into the right location. Sheesh. Alternatively, you used an altogether better encoder - BitVice. These days you have many different options for encoding - try simply exporting from FCE as .mov and encoding in something else entirely. You need to end up with elementary streams -ideally a .M2V and .aiff (for audio). You should also have A.Pack installed on your hard drive. Use this to encode the audio to AC3 (Dolby Digital).
    Then bring those assets in to DVDSP and author quickly. Use Apple+S frequently - like every time you make a change. Don't use the preview if you can avoid it, as it tended to crash out more often than not. Build the disc as a disc image and test it in DVDPlayer app.
    Of course, for a relatively low cost you can now use DVDSP v3 or 4 (available on eBay most days, I think!) This uses a far more stable code base, a more graphical approach to authoring and has more bells and whistles (not that you'll need them all the time, if ever). It is based on DVD Maestro (PC App) and is very similar to use. Advantages are many and varied compared to V1 but there is a consequential hit on speed IMO. That said, if your mac is anything close to modern (I author mostly on an old G4 still) then you will be fine.

  • Quality of DVD Studio Pro using Compressor vs iDVD

    Sorry to repeat the question below, which I have also posted under DVD SP...I thought that perhaps someone watching Compressor would also have input.
    I have been trying to obtain a DVD output with DVD Studio Pro where moderate speed pans don't jerk. Oddly, I get better results using iDVD. The image in iDVD isn't as sharp, but the quality of movement (pans, tilts) is smoother. My program length is only 20 minutes and I have used compressor to encode outside of DVD SP. The compressor setting was for DVD, 60 mins, best quality. Why is it that a consumer software such as iDVD yields better results in this aspect? What am I doing wrong in DVD SP that results in less than professional results. All input appreciated. Thanks in advance

    Pamela
    hy is it that a consumer software such as iDVD yields better results in this aspect? What am I doing wrong in DVD SP that results in less than professional results.
    You are messing around with Compressor settings . . . I guess!
    Hope that helps !
      Alberto

Maybe you are looking for