BGP Update Messages

Can a bgp UPDATE message carry more than a single prefix ? I have read a lot of text about this ( Halabi, Doyle, RFC 1771 ) but I think the wording that this literature is never clear to me about what they are exactly saying.
below is a quote from RFC 1771
" An UPDATE message can advertise at most one route, which may be
described by several path attributes. All path attributes contained
in a given UPDATE messages apply to the destinations carried in the
Network Layer Reachability Information field of the UPDATE message. "
In the wording of this RFC, is " route " same as prefix ?
Here is what Doyle says
" The Update message, whose format is shown in Figure 2-45, is used to advertise a single feasible route to a peer, or to withdraw multiple unfeasible routes, or both. "
And here is what Odom says in the Official CCIE R&S Guide
" The central concept in an individual Update message is the set of PAs. Then, all the prefixes (NLRIs) that share the exact same set of PAs and PA values are included at the end of the Update message. If a router needs to advertise a set of NLRIs, and each NLRI has a different setting for at least one PA, then separate Update messages will be required for each NLRI "
Anyone has the time to authoritatively explain this to me ?
Herbert

Hello Herbert,
the RFC is always right. ;-)
There is one prefix (network/mask) in a single BGP Update message. There can be, however, several BGP update messages in a single TCP segment. This is why one shoud always enable path MTU discovery on a BGP speaker ( ip tcp path-mtu-discovery).
While writing this I am looking at a sniffer trace from an MPLS PE router exchanging BGP updates. So I am pretty sure, that a Cisco PE (3640 with IOS 12.3T) will do exactly, what the RFC tells you.
Hope this helps! Please rate all posts.
Regards, Martin

Similar Messages

  • BGP Notification Message

    Hi all,
    I am having some trouble finding this, but I am wanting to know if there is a debug commands to find out the BGP Notification Error Codes for OPEN and Message Header (see link below)
    http://www.inetdaemon.com/tutorials/internet/ip/routing/bgp/operation/messages/notification.shtml
    I am kind of looking for something that is a verbose as debug ip bgp updates if possible. Any help is appreciated and let me know if you need additional information.

    Hi,
    Here are all the BGP notification codes:
    http://www.iana.org/assignments/bgp-parameters/bgp-parameters.xhtml#bgp-parameters-3
    HTH

  • Update message offers to download 3.6.16 as a security and stability update for 3.6.13, but will not download on Mac OS 10.4.11

    The first time I received the update message, I clicked on "Update Firefox," it spent awhile downloading, then presented an error message stating that I didn't have "enough privileges" for the update. Since I keep getting the same update message several times a day (extremely annoying), I tried updating two more times (most of the time I just close the update message). Both times it just kept downloading and downloading, and hadn't finished by the time I shut down for the day. If I am not allowed to update, I do wish that the update messages would STOP! I have 3.6.13 and will be replacing this computer soon, so I would rather just leave things as they are and not keep getting pestered to do something that can't be done.

    Using your link, I downloaded the new version. When I dragged the Firefox icon into the applications folder, it asked if I wanted the new version to replace the existing one, and I said yes. I was then told that it couldn't be done because I had insufficient privileges for some items. Is the reason for this that I didn't trash the old version BEFORE dragging the new one into the applications folder (under the assumption that "replace" meant that the old version was trashed as the new one was installed)? If not, it appears that I am back to the same problem I've had before.
    Since I'll be replacing this computer soon, it seems too troublesome to bother with this update. I'd just like the update reminders to go away!

  • TS5376 For about 4 months now I have been getting an Apple I-Tunes update message but when I try to install it, the program stops and refuses to install it saying I need to go to tools and manually install. the support page says:1. Remove iTunes and relat

    Dear Windows support personel,
         As part of my message reads above; I keep getting an i-tunes update message and when I click on the OK to download it, I get an error message saying there was a problem and I need to go to Tools>manual download.  Well, I don't know how to do that even though I gave it my best try. I went to the support sight and it had the following message;
    1. Remove iTunes and related components from the Control Panel
    Use the Control Panel to uninstall iTunes and related software components in the following order. Then, restart your computer:
    iTunes
    Apple Software Update
    Apple Mobile Device Support
    Bonjour
    Apple Application Support (iTunes 9 or later)
    Important: Uninstalling these components in a different order, or  only uninstalling some of these components, may have unintended affects.
    If you encounter an error while uninstalling, try repairing the affected component:
    I don't know if I should do that since I'm not PC savey. Could you help me by doing the work on my pc for me? I'd be most apprieciative if you'd help me in this manner.
    Sincerely,
    Christine Bocker
    <Email Edited by Host>

    Let's first try updating using an installer file downloaded from the Apple Website:
    http://www.apple.com/itunes/download/

  • ISE 1.2 - WLC 5508 - NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently

    I'm getting this error in ISE referring to my Cisco 5508 WLC.  I'm not sure how to turn down the frequency.  Any ideas?
    NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently
    Verify NAS configuration. Verify known NAS issues.

    I opened up a TAC case with Cisco yesterday and this is the response i got from them:
    There is bug on the WLC side to reduce the number acct updates:
    CSCug14713- WLC sends acct-update twice in the same millisecond
    This is fixed in 8.x on the WLC.
    So, it looks at though we just have to deal with it until they release an 8.x version for the WLC. In the meantime, you can disable the alerts in ISE.
    Administration>Settings>Alarm Settings>Misconfigured Network Device Detected
    Edit that alarm and set it to disabled

  • ISE 1.2 - Error 12929 NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently

    We are currently running Cisco ISE 1.2, and every day under the "Misconfigured Network Devices" section on the main ISE Page, I have a huge list of different devices that are all being flagged with the following error message:
    "12929 NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently." " NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently
    Verify NAS configuration. Verify known NAS issues."
    The list of devices seems to all be Cisco switches; albeit different models, IOS versions, ect.  
    i have searched on this issue, and the closest thing to a fix I can find is that it would be fixed in a WLC update, but that was 9 months ago.    I would like to know what causes this issue, and what needs to be altered in ISE, or on the switches to resolve this.
    Thank You.

     CSCuh20269    WLC sends acc updates too frequently, indicates user roams to itself  is the defect specifically on the WLC that is fixed in one of the 7.6 releases.
    Along with the config Jatin mentioned, you may want to try pulling an Accounting report from ISE periodically and analyze the traffic/isolate the endpoints/supplicants that may be causing  a lot of activity (For ex frequent IP changes ) which results in frequent accounting updates.
    Regards,
    Gurudatt
    Escalation engineer, SAMPG | CCIE#28227
    Cisco systems

  • Cisco ISE 1.2.1 - "12929 NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently" error message

    Hello,
    Running ISE 1.2.1 Patch 1, we get following error message: "12929 NAS sends RADIUS accounting update messages too frequently" on all NAS Devices (i.e. C-4500s running SPA.03.04.00.SG.151-2.SG.bin).
    There was a previous post on this forum (RE: https://supportforums.cisco.com/discussion/11894006/ise-12-wlc-5508-nas-sends-radius-accounting-update-messages-too-frequently) that stated that the "aaa accounting update newinfo" command doesn't solve this problem even though bug CSCuh01760 "Misconfigured NAS criteria needs to be changed" is resolved in ISE 1.2.1 as per the release notes.
    Could you please advise us on that to do now? Thank you. 
    Regards.  

    For the WLC side:
    1. You are probably hitting this bug CSCug14713
    2. You can also change the "Interim Update" located under the SSID > Security AAA Servers
    For the Switch side:
    1. You might be hitting this bug:CSCuh01760
    2. Make sure that you have the following command in your config "aaa accounting update newinfo"
    Thank you for rating helpful posts!

  • TS1372 a message comes up when i plug in my iPod shuffle (version 1.0.2) and when i click to restore and update message comes up saying iPod could not be restored unknown error occurred (1430)

    a message comes up when i plug in my iPod shuffle (version 1.0.2) and when i click to restore and update message comes up saying iPod could not be restored unknown error occurred (1430)

    The linked article
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1372
    has some suggestions.  Did you try doing those things?

  • 1 new update have been added to the project would you like to close the project and apply these updates message in project 2010

    1 new update have been added to the project would you like to close the project and apply these updates message  in project 2010.
    One of the PM is getting above message and not any recent changes happened?

    Hi,
    This message appears when an update has been sent for his approval and is pending. It could happen while opening the project plan, or when clicking on something like "retreive tasks updates" from the backstage menu of MS Project Pro.
    The PM should go to his approval center and check for any approval pending.
    Hope this helps,
    Guillaume Rouyre, MBA, MVP, P-Seller |

  • Why won't Photoshop CS6 Extended update? I keep getting a failed to update message.

    Why won't Photoshop CS6 Extended update? I keep getting a failed to update message.

    Run the Creative Suite Cleaner Tool, reinstall the program, try again.
    Mylenium

  • I get the"download iPod updater"message &downloading the updater won't help

    Here's what happened:
    I plugged my iPod into my iTunes to put music on it.
    It says "Do Not Disconnect" like it alwasys does, but this time doesn't go away. It stays for 45 minutes. IN an act of desperation, I disconnect.
    I lose everything.
    "Not a big deal" I think, because I can just put the stuff on my iPod again.
    I connect the two, I get the "download iPod updater" message. I download it. Same thing.
    I uninstall and reinstall about 3 times.
    Still same thing.
    PLEASE HELP.

    im having pretty much the EXACT same problem with mine. tried the "5 r's" yadda yadda, completely useless. this is my second ipod, i had a 4G that died a few months ago, which had the same problem, but about 6 months after i bought it. my 5G is brand new, got it for xmas like most people, next day i plug it in and BAM, its been blinking that **** little red circle for days and ive tried everything. im just gonna make use of my warrenty and send it in for repairs. ill post if i figure something out before then.

  • IPad1 can not install software 4.3.2 update -message due to corrupt backup - but when I go to delete backup there is no backup in device section of itunes - in preferences

    iPad1 can not install software 4.3.2 update - message - due to corrupt backup - but when I go to delete backup there is no backup in the device section of itunes under preferences

    The problem was cured by going to <user>/Library/Application Support/MobileSync/Backup and moving the files from that folder to desktop and the ipad backed up and the software installed

  • 'Updating message list' from hotmail FROZEN - Please help!

    My mom just purchased a new mac - I've purchased Outlook for her so she can easily download her hotmail messages. I've been cruising along, downloading the 17,511 messages she has on the server (I know!!) and it stopped halfway through. In the bottom righthand
    corner of the Outlook mailbox it says' Updating message list' and then has a bar which usually is filling up as it pulls messages off the server - but now nothing is happening and it seems stuck on 0/7892 (that's the text on the right of the bar). Help! Why
    is it stuck? I've done the whole process twice and it seems to get stuck here. I even checked online to see if I could delete some troubled file, but can't seem to go back that far on the server (even though it lists all 17K messages (as a number next to the
    Inbox tab - showing it has record of them, but where are they??) Thank you so much for any help you can give me!!!

    Hi Michi,
    First, check your internet connection because the low server connectivity can make such a frozen disturbance in Outlook. Apart from it there can lots of reasons behind this disturbance:
    Antivirus Programs: In most of the cases, these antivirus scanning programs pretend emails as malwares and does not allow Outlook to receive it.
    Large Attachments: If someone sending large attachments as email then its also make Outlook froze up. So to overcome from this, stop downloading large emails.
    Corruption in Outlook Data File: Corrupt Outlook data file is one of popular reason behind the disturbance like this. Use scanpst.exe to fix the corruption issue of Outlook database and
    then again try to download emails. Hopefully it will work!!!
    Problems in Outlook are not just limited to the above given reasons, there is list of errors and causes in Outlook data file and their resolution.
    For more:
    http://support.microsoft.com/kb/2652320/en-us
    Note: Improve community discussions by marking the answers helpful.
    Thanks
    Clark Kent

  • HT201210 I had an update message on my phone and I clicked yes to update.  Now the phone has a picture of itunes and usb connection, but can't be used.

    I had an update message on my phone and I clicked yes to update.  Now the phone has a picture of itunes and usb connection, but can't be used.  itunes says I have to restore my phone, but will lose all the data.  Is there anything else I can do? I really don't want to lose all my pictures and other data.

    It's in recovery mode. There is nothing left on the phone at all. If you didn't back it up before you started, your data is gone.
    you have no choice but to restore at this point.

  • I keep getting a hp update message on my desktop

    i keep getting a hp update message on my desktop. it says a update is available. clicking on it does nothing. it only goes away when i restart the computer. windows 7 os hp officejet 6500
    This question was solved.
    View Solution.

     Hey Henry sorry your having this problem what you can do is go to your control panel, then programs and feature/add or remove programs... it depends on which one it says then look for hp updates .. Uninstall that then you should be fine.

Maybe you are looking for