Big dilemma... MacBook or iBook?

Here's the situation. I need a laptop. It will be used as a secondary computer while I am on trips. I'll do graphic and web design work, some Flash, using Adobe Creative Suite 2 and Macromedia software. None of them are Universal Binaries, therefore they will run under Rosetta on Intel Macs.
I'll do all my heavy tasks on the PowerMac, so I don't really need a "Pro" laptop. My choices are: iBook and MacBook.
Have anyone tried to work with Adobe CS2 apps on MacBook? How are they performing?

If you need the fastest performance and best battery life I'd seriously consider finding an iBook on eBay to hold you over until these apps are UB. On my MBP versus my PB G4 photoshop loads slower, but once in it tends to be on par, but it's not faster. Also battery life isn't too hot. The macbook is said to have an hour or two more battery life than a MBP, but using those apps via rosetta on battery may kill it quicker than just using a iBook. If you do the eBay thing you may wish to get a powerbook instead, though they also have less battery life, but they do have faster ram and processors.
Again I believe buying a macbook is the best choice as it will be much faster once these apps go UB. If you need a new book and want one with a G4 just do yourself a favor and don't buy it new as you'll be wasting your money away.
Nick

Similar Messages

  • Macbook vs ibook

    I am thinking of upgrading.  I am looking at refurbished laptops.  I am trying to see what the differences are between the macbooks and ibooks.
    I currently am using a very outdated imac.  I use the computer for e-mail...shopping..research on various topics...create documents and want to get a little more into graphics.
    I have been reading up as to what to buy but am still not sure of the differences between the 2 types of ;aptops.
    I am also curious. If these machines come with 10.5  what is the upgrade cost to 10.6  and where do I find info on applecare and its cost?  I think this might be a good idea. 
    ANY feedback would be appreciated.
    Thank you
    jman

    Here's a link to Eyerymac's page on the differences between iBooks and the original 2006 MacBooks http://www.everymac.com/systems/apple/macbook/faq/differences-between-macbook-ib ook-powerbook.html
    The MacBooks are much faster in start-up and all applications. With a MacBook you can start-up, open your browser and load a web page while the iBook is still starting up. The ibooks will work fine if you aren't concerned with speed.
    With iBooks you can run 10.5 only on a G4 iBook with a 900Mhz processor or better. You Can't run 10.6 on the iBooks. That requires an Intel processor which is only found on MacBooks. OS10.6 costs $29. For a 10.5 retail disk that will work on any Mac you'll have to go to eBay.
    Applecare can only be bought for a MacBook that's less than one year old. It has to be bought before the original one year warrenty expires.
    Here's a list of all iBooks http://www.everymac.com/systems/apple/ibook/index-ibook.html
    And all MacBooks http://www.everymac.com/systems/apple/macbook/index-macbook.html

  • MacBook to iBook - Networking ethernet/firewire/IP/Sharing

    MacBook to iBook - Networking ethernet/firewire/IP/Sharing - This is the problem:
    1. Firewire : I setup with firewire a MacBook to iBook IP network hub to use my MacBook over the iBook the net. Works 4 times without a problem, easy to set up, great ! Now it won't - green network status symbol in Sys>Network on booth computer. Firewire port selected on the top, as been advice already
    ( http://www.macdevcenter.com/pub/a/mac/2003/11/11/panther_internet.html )... IP Address is activ, but now it won't go on the net over my iBook with the DSL modem. Can't use the modem on my MacBook(SpeedTouch 330) Thats why ! But what is the problem now with the firewire connection ?
    2. Ethernet : Same problem as with firewire and i have this: Conect to server - "Registered User" - ask me for Password ? No Password is setup on booth computer, but it refuse to conect : "Conection Failed" Unknown user, incorrect password ! Strange stuff...
    Any help or advise would be great
    Many thanks for help in advance !
    Stefan

    To connect to another computer on your home network as a registered user, you need to enter the administrator's name and password for the computer you are trying access.

  • Macbook Pro Retina or Not? the big dilemma!

    I know this question has probably been answered here in the Apple community (and over the internet) multiple times, but I am going to ask it anyways. The response to this looks half in half i.e. half of the responses lean towards a Regular MBP whereas the other half leaning towards the Retina and that is making this decision for me quite difficult.
    I am currently a Regular 13" MBP (i7, 8g, 750 gig) mid 2012 user and I have used a late 2010 model in the past and never did I have any complains about those machines. However, with the new Retina models and SSD options I am a bit confused. I am a pretty decent user who uses work apps like Oracle (DB) Clients, Citrix, Adobe PS CS6, Full MS Office suite of products etc. I also use it for recreational things like watching movies, iTunes library (currently about 20 gigs, which is not too large) and store music, movies, videos and pics in the computer from time to time. I don't foresee having have to install any large applications in the future but that may not always be the case since I work in the IT industry and things are pretty dynamic here. I have an inclination towards the Retina MBP 13" with 256 gig SSD, however this SSD size seems a little low to me. Not that I have 200 gigs worth of apps installed but I would hate to run out of space if that situation arrived. I know I can have an external HD but I would still want to have the apps installed in the computer's storage. I have also explored the fact that I can have a Regular MBP with SSD but I am not sure if those machine can handle at true SSD speeds or will they be stuck with ATA speeds anyways which kind of defeats the purpose of having an SSD. Budget is also a consideration here since the max I can shell out would be $1700-ish.
    I know Retina display is more as a personal preference than a requirement, but do you guys think that 256 GB SSD would be enough or 512 GB SSD with a non Retina model (since budget is a concern) would be the way to go?
    I am thinking of rMBP with 256 G SSD but with that Price I can get a 15" Regular MBP with more HDD space.
    Please share your opinions.

    If budget is a concern, max out a 15" with a SSD, 16gig RAM and a few peripherals along with a couple 2TB 2.5" USB external Hard drives.
    Applications are never the concern when it comes to an internal SSD or HD,....... its the huge videos/ pdf / music / pics etc etc people want to throw into the internal HD AFTER they put every application known to mankind on their internal HD.
    Endless applications is one thing even a 128gig SSD is more than fit to handle, its all the huge files.
    Keep working working files / docs etc ON the internal, and park all low use stuff OFF onto a USB HD.
    Are you planning on doing any major photo or video editing?  You didnt indicate same,...as such other than resolution for as you mention "watching movies" is your prime use/intent for the Retina vs. non-Retina?

  • Software between the macbook and ibook

    ok
    i'm getting a refurbished ibook
    and i now know that they have two different software
    IBOOK
    - iWork ‘05 30-day trial
    - AppleWorks
    - Quicken 2005 for Macintosh
    - Nanosaur 2
    - Marble Blast Gold
    - Apple Hardware Test
    MACBOOK
    - iLife ’06
    - iWork ’06 Trial
    - Front Row
    - Photo Booth
    - Comic Life
    - OmniOutliner
    - Big Bang Board Games
    can you macpeople compare the different software for me?
    THX

    All the software on the MacBook will be universal binary based so that it will run on the Intel processor without issue. The iBook has a G4 processor. That was the latest PowerPC processor to go into a laptop, but not the latest PowerPC processor. The G5 processor apparently turned out to run too hot to put into a laptop.
    If you already have software that needs a PowerPC, that would be the best reason other than price to stick with the older technology. If you do not have old software, you should go with the newest technology, the MacBook. Especially if you already have windows software, some of which can run on the Intel MacBook.
    Not having a MacBook myself, I'd be reluctant to comment much further. However, the iMac Intel I purchased was not new, but runs like new, and I'm extremely pleased with it. My iBook G4 was purchased new two years ago before I learned the advantages of buying a refurbished Mac from Apple. Since then I steered someone else in the family into a refurb iBook, and they've been very happy with it. It was just as nice as mine was when it was new.
    By the way, I'm pretty sure that any iBook will have iLife included with it, but it won't run as fast as it will on the MacBook.
    Message was edited by: myhighway

  • External HD not detected in MacBook but iBook

    Hi All:
    I have below systems with me >
    * iBook G4 running Tiger with 1GB memory
    * Previous MacBook running Tiger with 2GB memory
    * New MacBook running Leopard with 4GB memory
    * New iMac running Leopard with 4GB memory
    I have a 100GB external HD connected to my iBook for 2 years now, via USB. And my Previous MacBook used to read and access data from the same HD too. I dunno if I have changed any setting or any software update technically forbid the access from any other Mac systems except iBook, which I bought with.
    In iBook, the external HD works perfectly. I eject it, connect it to any of my MacBook now, the light on the device is turned on but nothing moves in Finder. There's no icon, unlike in iBook where a USB HD icon appears below Macintosh HD. I tried to partition and erase everything, remain Mac OS (Journaled) format, but no luck. It's properly detected and accessible by iBook but not any others.
    Have I possible changed anything without knowing it ? Can someone share with me what to do next ? The external HD works well but I dun understand why none of other Mac systems recognise it, except the original iBook. Thank you.

    Hi:
    I am using a 100GB from Samsung. Should have mentioned earlier. It's USB-powered. I never use it with any adapter. I just plug it into iBook G4 and in less than 2 seconds time, drive pops up in Finder perfectly.
    However with MacBook running either Leopard or Tiger, the light will be on and you hear it spinning. I tried to plug in adapter last night, still no luck.
    I re-partitioned to GUID or Master Boot or Apple, either Mac Extended (Journaled) or MS-DOS, none of them works.
    Then, last night I tried to boot-camp Windows XP and to my surprise, it was detected without any problem ! Oh...... So now I think the problem is not in USB port, not in the power adapter (which I never use), not in the format, it's in Tiger or Leopard for MacBook.
    Tiger I use on iBook G4 is 10.4.11 (no problem at all)
    Tiger I use on MacBook is also 10.4.11 (not detected but light is on)
    Leopard I use on MacBook is 10.5.2 (not detected but light is on)
    I spent so much time transfer data from external HD to iBook then to iPod then to MacBook. I just dun understand. Thank you for all your posts. ^_^

  • Time Machine and New Macbook, old iBook problem.

    Hi there. I was using a G4 iBook until about 1 month ago. I had been backing it up with time machine. I then bought a new computer. Upon start up, I used time machine to move my applications and files over to the new Macbook. Everything has been dandy with the new Macbook.
    Today I tried to back up the Macbook using time machine but it appeared to freeze about halfway through. I investigated the boards for advice. Since my iBook was a Power PC and the new Macbook is an Intel computer, I understand that I needed to reformat the external hard drive. Okay, I did that. I then tried to run a backup but it again froze, after only 60 MBs of 37 GBs. When I try opening the external hard drive I notice that it still refers to my computer as my iBook rather than the Macbook. Does this explain the problem and if so, how can I rename my computer to reflect the change? I don't get it.

    To the extent that Time Machine uses a computer's "name" in naming its backup files, that could be the explanation.
    Have you renamed your MacBook to see if that helps?

  • Itunes 11 window too big for macbook pro

    My itunes window is too big for my macbook pro screen. Itunes 11.0.2, macbook 10.8.3. How can I make it fit?

    Click here and use one of the scripts to change the size of the window. This works with applications other than iTunes as well.
    (42352)

  • ITunes performance on MacBook versus iBook

    I'm thinking about upgrading my 3 1/2 year old iBook for a new MacBook and I'm wondering how much of an improvement I'll get using iTunes. I've got about 23,000 songs on an external Firewire drive and there's typical an annoying delay loading my library and then occasional spinning multicolored orbs when I'm navigating the library.
    Since using iTunes with AirTunes is one the main functions I use the laptop for, I'm wondering if the increase in processor power (1.07 to 2.4 GHz) and RAM (768 MB to 2 GB) on a MacBook will result in a significant improvement in performance.
    Also, since my iTunes library is housed in an external drive, I'm wondering to what degree the slowdowns are caused by the speed of the Firewire connection. Would connecting my external drive to a laptop with Firewire 800 capability play a significant role in improving the overall performance of iTunes?
    Yeah, I know these are subjective, largely unanswerable questions. I'm just looking for some comments based on everyone's experiences.

    I think you'll find that the new MacBook will be dramatically faster.
    I have a 10,000 song library and recently upgraded from a 1.5 Ghz 12" PowerBook. There is no longer a delay while loading the library, zero blips while browsing it, and even coverflow works perfectly. You'll be very impressed.

  • Macbook pro, ibook, or macbook?

    which is the better laptop; an ibook g4, a macbook , or the macbook pro?

    You didn't mention what you are planning to do with the laptop. If you're looking for a basic system to do word processing, email, and web surfing, the ibook is more than adequate, runs cooler, and is much less expensive. If you're wanting to do more with your system, especially things which require more processor power, then you simply can't beat the new intel systems.
    As for pro vs macbook, there are plenty of other threads on this list that can give you some tips. A quick comparison:
    MB ram max is 2GB, MBP is 3GB
    MBP has faster processor options
    Screen on MBP is larger - up to 17"
    hard drive in MB is user-upgradeable, not in MBP
    MBP graphics are faster than MB
    MBP has expressCard slot for future upgrade options
    MBP has a back-lit keyboard
    Some people really don't like the keyboard on the MB; it's a bit different than most folks are used to, though in actual use it's pretty nice.
    Try to visit a mac store or other retailer and check out the differences yourself. The differences between the MBP and MB are relatively minor; for most users, the MB is more than adequate. Kind of depends what you want to use it for.
    To Alan E: Interesting observation about the temperature of your MBP - every C2D MBP I've gotten my hands on gets uncomfortably hot during heavy processor use. Try running an app like the Prey demo available on the apple software site - it will warm your machine up. Guaranteed. I agree about the speed of the laptop, though - it's really fast.
    Oh, and madeMacx: you can disable the keyboard backlight if you find it annoying. It's nice when you actually need it, but the novelty wears off pretty quickly

  • Any info on importing kindle format books into MacBook Pro ibook app?   Thanks!

    Any info on importing Kindle format books in an iBook app on my MacBook Pro would be much appreciated.....Thanks..

    Can't be done without stripping the DRM.  That is illegal, and can't be discussed in this forum.  If you have no DRM that's one thing.   There are several services that will convert the book format.  I've found a few on Google.

  • Macbook or ibook ?

    which is the better laptop; an ibook g4, a macbook , or the macbook pro?
    ibook g3   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

    The iBook and the MacBook/Pro are three very different computers, the most obvious difference being the Intel Core [2] Duo and the G4 processors. The best laptop would of course be a MBP, with the larger screen, more processing power (over 2GHz), and dedicated video card.
    However, the best laptop for you is up to you. What would you be using it for? iBooks are best for less CPU and memory intensive processes, like internet surfing, music, maybe light photo editing or simpler games, etc. MacBooks are best for internet, photo editing, light video editing, some games, etc. If you think you'd ever get into heavy video editing or gaming, the MBP is the way to go with the dedicated video card. MacBooks are best for today's consumers, MacBook Pros are best for today's professionals, and iBooks are best for today's kids (or adults who don't need the computer for much more than internet and email).
    Like Nick A said, Intel-based Macs are the best. PPC Macs just don't compare, and they're best for kids, like I said above.
    Here are some more threads related to iBooks and MacBooks:
    http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=4353176
    http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=4449391

  • Transferring data to Macbook from iBook

    I have transferred lots of needed files from my old iBook to my new Macbook but can't get them to open. They were done on Appleworks 6.2.2. Is there any hope of opening them? I purchased Office for Mac with my new laptop.
    Macbook   Mac OS X (10.4.7)  

    ok. I enabled Appleworks 5 and 6 in the Word menu. The same thing happened as before when I tried to open a transferred document: a box popped up with options to get iWorks...I assume for a price. There was a trial for 30 days but don't I need it for more time if I am to be able to continue to open these documents as I wish?

  • Upgrading to Macbook from Ibook - software conflict?

    Hi,
    I'd like to mirror my current system and sofware across to the a new-to-me Macbook.
    How can I do it - if indeed it's possible? Ideally, I'd like to burn a disc image of my entire machine and copy that across somehow.
    thanks

    To build a little on what Michael just said. You simply can't do it. While the OS for your iBook looks pretty much the same as it does on the new MacBooks (or any new Intel based machine), it is very different under the hood. The version of OS X that you have on your iBook "speaks" PowerPC. It wouldn't have the slightest idea what to do with an Intel processor. You can move your personal documents and applications over, but you can't simply move over an entire image.

  • Need help moving cursor from MacBook to iBook G4 together...

    using my mouse. I bought a new MacBook, but still use my old iBook G4 and it works great too.
    I just can't figure out how to have the cursor go from one to another. I tried Synergy, but it became confusing when I tried to install and have now given up.
    Anyone have any solutions to this?
    Thanks.
    MacBook   Mac OS X (10.6.4)    

    I use Teleport between 3 Macs (similar to synergy)
    <http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/22339>
    In my case I use my iMac's keyboard and mouse to tell my PowerMac G5 and my MacBook what to do.
    The PowerMac G5 and MacBook Teleports are configured to share, and the iMac is setup to control the other 2. It works very well for me. At worse, when I move my MacBook out of the office and back, I sometimes have to tell the iMac to stop using Teleport and then start again to re-acquire the MacBook. Otherwise it is great.

Maybe you are looking for