[BUG] showPopupBehavior not working for af:tree elements

Question

Hi,
It's currently impossible to have a showPopupBehavior showing a different noteWindow for each elements of an af:tree. However, it works correctly with a table so I assume it's a strange tree bug. The test case is the following:
<?xml version='1.0' encoding='windows-1252'?>
<jsp:root xmlns:jsp="http://java.sun.com/JSP/Page" version="2.1" xmlns:f="http://java.sun.com/jsf/core"
          xmlns:h="http://java.sun.com/jsf/html" xmlns:af="http://xmlns.oracle.com/adf/faces/rich">
  <jsp:directive.page contentType="text/html;charset=windows-1252"/>
  <f:view>
    <af:document title="Test showPopupBehavior">
      <af:form>
        <af:panelHeader text="Test showPopupBehavior">
          <af:popup id="tooltip">
            <af:noteWindow>
              <af:outputText value="Tooltip"/>
            </af:noteWindow>
          </af:popup>
          <af:panelGroupLayout layout="vertical">
            <af:outputText id="src1" value="Outside" clientComponent="true">
              <af:showPopupBehavior alignId="src1" popupId="tooltip" triggerType="mouseOver"/>
            </af:outputText>
            <!-- tableValues is an Integer array -->
            <af:table value="#{showPopup.tableValues}" var="val">
              <af:column headerText="Value">
                <af:popup id="tableTooltip">
                  <af:noteWindow>
                    <af:outputText value="Tooltip: #{val}"/>
                  </af:noteWindow>
                </af:popup>
                <af:outputText id="src2" value="Texte avec popup: #{val}" clientComponent="true">
                  <af:showPopupBehavior alignId="src2" popupId="tableTooltip" triggerType="mouseOver"/>
                </af:outputText>
              </af:column>
            </af:table>
            <!-- treeValues is a ChildPropertyTreeModel containing node objects supporting a value attribute -->
            <af:tree value="#{showPopup.treeValues}" var="node">
              <f:facet name="nodeStamp">
                <af:group>
                    <af:popup id="treeTooltip">
                      <af:noteWindow>
                        <af:outputText value="Tooltip: #{node.value}"/>
                      </af:noteWindow>
                    </af:popup>
                    <af:outputText id="src3" value="Node with popup: #{node.value}" clientComponent="true">
                      <af:showPopupBehavior popupId="treeTooltip" alignId="src3" triggerType="mouseOver"/>
                    </af:outputText>
                </af:group>
              </f:facet>
            </af:tree>
            <f:facet name="separator">
              <af:spacer width="1" height="20"/>
            </f:facet>
          </af:panelGroupLayout>
        </af:panelHeader>
      </af:form>
    </af:document>
  </f:view>
</jsp:root>Thanks,
~ Simon

Answer 1

Simon,
the difference seem to be the difference between a component child (table) and facet (tree). I can open a popup for the tree when pacing the popup outside of the tree. Then however this doesn't show dynamic data (at least none that is available on mouse over). I see how this could be done with a clientListener but this then wont be declarative
Frank
Ps.: Hope the tootip was just the sample to illustrate the problem and not the usecase you are after, because for this you could have used the shortDescr property on the node's outputText