Burning Blu-Ray?

I'm about to order a Blu-Ray internal burner for my Mac tower.
I heard a rumour that Apple is not necessarily friendly to Blu-Ray. Maybe I've heard wrong.
What app would you recommend for creating Blu-Ray disks? What is the official Blu-Ray codec, and can I render this codec from FCP (latest version) or Compressor?
And then will DVD Studio Pro do the burning?
All ears,
Ben

FCP 7 can burn directly to Blu-ray from your HD timeline.
Compressor (3.5) can compress and burn directly to Blu-ray or save Blu-ray files to your HDD.
You can choose MPEG or H.264. While H.264 was added after the original spec, and some of the VERY early players may not play them, H.264 looks gorgeous compared to MPEG at the same bitrate.
However, both FCP 7 and compressor 3.5 are extremely limiting in the menu options you can have on your disc. They are the basic necessities and about the minimum they could get away with and still claim BD authoring. It looks like they were targeting studios dailies more than final production discs.
Alternatively you can use Adobe Encore CS3/CS4/CS5. Each version has progressive improvements to the capabilities, including pop-up menus and multi-screen menu systems.
Another alternative is Toast 10.
I really wish Apple would get their act together on Blu-ray - both for mastering AND for playing on the Mac itself. It's no good Steve jobs whining about it - get off the dime Steve and make the Mac play BDs, and get a DVDSP like program for BDs.
I already upgraded to FCP7, but would willing pay double the update cost (or more - much more) to get a GOOD Blu-ray authoring app as part of the Final Cut Suite.

Similar Messages

  • Is it possible to create DVD Templates with Motion for burning Blue Ray DVDs from Final Cut Pro X?

    Is it possible to create DVD Templates with Motion for burning Blue Ray DVDs from Final Cut Pro X?

    As far as I know, motion templates can only be used with DVD Studio Pro. FCP X only lets you add a background image to the DVD menu.

  • What do i need to burn blu-rays?

    Hello everyone. I'm new to Final Cut Pro, and Macs in general, so please bare with me. I'm a film student, and recently purchased a Canon XH-A1s and a Mac Pro with Final Cut Pro 6 to jump start my video production business.
    My only problem is that i only have the ability to produce HD video, so when it comes to distribution, DVD is really not an option. I've heard with an upgrade to Final Cut Pro 7 that you can finally burn Blu-Rays without a third party application, just wondering if that was true.
    I was planning on upgrading to Final Cut Pro 7, and purchasing an external, USB Blu-Ray read/write drive. Should everything work ok if i go down that route?
    Thanks everyone,
    -Billy
    Message was edited by: blakes2406

    The Mac does not come with a Blu-ray burner. So you would be burning a Blu-ray compatible file to a standard DVD-5 or DVD-9. Neither of which are ideal for authoring Blu-ray content.
    Do an exhaustive search online about Blu-ray authoring and disk creation. This is not something for the hobbyist video creator (and I say hobbyist in the sense that you're not creating thousands of copies for mass distribution, so no one take offense.)
    Blu-ray is expensive and requires a lot of planning and prep to do it right. But you can't burn an official Blu-ray disc on a Mac as they stand. And, Compressor doesn't burn discs, it only creates files. DVD Studio Pro would be the app that would burn the Blu-ray disc, and DVDSP has not been upgraded since long before Blu-ray came on the scene.

  • Is my hl-dt-st bddvdrw gbc-h20l capable of burning Blu Ray discs (BD-R)?

    Hello. I have a HP Pavilion Elite m9470 Desktop PC with an  hl-dt-st bddvdrw gbc-h20l drive running Windows 7 Ultimate (the pc came originally with Vista). For the first time I tried to burn a Blu Ray disc BD-R in fact. When I loaded the disc into tray, the pc started trying to read the disc, without success for endless minutes. In fact the door could not open even manually - I had to restart the system to take the disc out.
    I always thought that the specific drive was capable of not only reading but also burning Blu Rays - could someone let me know? Is it a matter of appropriate software?

    You're welcome.
    Click on support & driver links on the HP site, enter the complete model # of the PC, you will see a links for information pertaining to your PC, like: HP Pavilion Elite m9470gr Desktop PC Product Specifications
    Enjoy

  • Burning Blu-Ray: Sometimes successful / Sometimes not

    I've been burning Blu-rays for the last couple of days. After a couple of burns, I get this message:
    But, here's the deal:
    I do indeed have a disk in the burner
    I can't eject said disk (so the computer may "find it") without dismounting...
    If I do unmount the burner, FCPX starts the burn process all over... with the same above message
    A "cycle" ensues... until I restart--not just the app--but the computer.
    Then... I'm good for a couple of burns before the cycle starts again.
    Trouble shoots:
    I've tried this across TWO different burners--two different brands, one NEW out of the box. Same result.
    This has happened across TWO different projects in the same library
    Anyone have any ideas?

    Luis Sequeira1 wrote:
    But I don't know if Disk Utility or some other program can burn the image to Blu Ray.
    G'Day Luis,
    Yes it works just the same as DVD.
    Al

  • Burning Blu-ray disks.  Third party hardware needed?

    I have read from earlier posts that it is not possible to burn Blu-ray© disks from DVDSP. Can third party hardware be purchased to burn such a disk having assembled the digital assets in DVDSP? Any recommendations?
    Thanks in advance.
    G5 Quad Desktop   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

    Thanks for your responses. I see that from DVD SP Late-Breaking news that'HD DVD projects authored by DVD SP 4.0.3 fully comply with the 1.0 version of he HD DVD specification...the new HD DVD standard. The disks will play on Apple DVD Player version 4.6.5 or later.
    I haven't commited to the Blu-ray© player, just the Sony HD camcorder.
    When the time comes, I will burn to a red laser disc per the Apple recommendation. And thanks for the Roxio link which makes it clear that a PC is needed for Blu-ray©
    G5 Quad Desktop Mac OS X (10.4.8)

  • HOW LONG TO BURN BLU RAY VIA COMPRESSOR 3.5?

    Does anybody know the ballpaerk figure as to how long a 115 minute FCP 7 project exported to self contained movie and brought into Compressor 3.5 to burn a blu ray disk on an external blu ray writer will take? Is Roxio Toast any faster? Thanks much for your help.

    iamfrustrated wrote:
    This is getting more interesting by the minute. I have now set the project up as two blu ray DVD's -each around 72 minutes. When I go to 'send to compressor' from fcp 7, if I select HD DVD 90 minutes (assume that is the correct method as there is no 'blu ray' option) and then set Job Action to Blu Ray, I get the message with that nice little yellow triangle warning stating: "Cannot create Blu Ray disc as no target that is either mpeg 2 video elementary stream or H.264 stream". The fcp project in compressor is dolby digital prof. 2.0 and HD H.264 6.75 mbps.
    I'm obviously doing something wrong here(?)
    The HD DVD presets create files that are usable in DVD Studio Pro for making HD DVD's - not for authoring Blu-ray discs.
    Here's what you need to do:
    Create a new preset from "H.264 for Blu-ray".
    Leave the video format and frame rate set to automatic, but lower the bitrate down to 20 Mbps with a max of 25 Mbps.
    Then add a Dolby Digital Audio track as a second target.
    Under job action set to create blu-ray disc but save it to the hard drive rather than trying to burn directly. (I know this an annoying extra step but there's been issues reporting with burning Blu-ray/AVCHD discs over 10 minutes in length.)
    This will get it onto a single disc and 20 Mbps h.264 will still look pretty good.

  • "media not present" error when burning blu ray in PE12

    I have two systems, both ground-up builds, identical Win 7 Home Premium and Premiere Elements 12 installs.  Both systems have internal blu-ray burners.  One burner is an ASUS BW-12B1AT and the other is a Pioneer burner (don't recall the model number).
    System 1:  Intel 4770k with Gigabyte MB
    System 2: AMD 8-core with Gigabyte MB
    System 1 gives "Media not present" error in PE12 when attempting to burn to blu ray discs using Verbatim discs. System is able to burn DVDs and CDs, and playback blu ray discs.  System is also capable of burning blu rays using Nero.
    System 2 works fine - blu ray media is recognized instantly by PE12 when in the drive and burns blu rays perfectly.
    I swapped the blu ray drives and SATA cables from System 1 and System 2 with the same result - this eliminated the drive manufacturer and cables from being the problem, as both drives worked perfectly in System 2 and neither worked in System 1.  I also tried different SATA ports and power supply taps on System 1 without any success.
    Then, I noticed that on System 1, with the dialog box open and indicating the "media not present" error, if I ejected the blu ray disc and reinserted it, the burner LED would flash 18 times (approx. 1/sec) and then pulse briefly indicating a burst of activity for about 1 second, as if it was either reading the disc or writing to the SATA.  If I pressed the "rescan" button during this brief burst of LED activity, then the disc was recognized and I could proceed to burn it.    If I tried to press the rescan button at any time before this instant or after, the "media not present" error did not clear.
    To me, this is an indication that something in the handshake timing of the SW and the burner is not correct, and that timing differences in the system HW are not provided for in the SW. I see that many others have had this issue and have had to buy work-around image burners to address this. I believe your burner drivers need to be reworked to eliminate this bug.  This is evidenced by the fact that Nero works and your SW does not, and that different systems consistently exhibit this problem.
    Please let me know when you will have a SW patch to address this or if you have any idea of system settings that can be adjusted (I don't know of any myself) that would eliminate this problem.

    pastrobes
    This is not Adobe. Rather user to user. If you want to contact Adobe, your likely route is via Adobe Chat.
    If you have a feature request or bug report, then consider filing a Adobe Feature Request Bug Report Forum with Adobe
    Adobe - Feature Request/Bug Report Form
    The likelihood of an Adobe engineer seeing your thread here is essentially slim to none.
    Your results are very interesting but lots more variables to consider.
    Do you have any version of Premiere Elements other than 12? It would be interesting to learn if a prior version's burn
    dialog would present with the Media Not Preset issue for your burn to Blu-ray System 1. That is easy enough done with a tryout of
    11 or 10 or 9 from the following web site. ProDesignTools: Adobe® Developments in Focus
    On the other side of the coin, you could give the new version a look in this regard. A new version is expected at the
    end of September 2014.
    As an aside, have you updated 12 to 12.1 Update, using an opened project's Help Menu/Update. If not, I would encourage
    you to do so. It does correct an Expert workspace text styles issue plus other matters undefined by Adobe.
    ATR

  • Burning blu-ray discs

    Here at the office we're running all macs with Final Cut Studio 2. We want to be able to encode for blu-ray and also burn blu-ray discs. I know we need an external burner, but does our current software support blu-ray?

    Or Netblender's DoStudio for rather less money. PC based but we successfully run it on a Mac in Bootcamp. Just completed our first full featured Blu Ray and sent for replication.
    If you know DVD-SP well then learning curve not too bad and they have very good support and forum.
    If you just need to 'dump' hi def material to Blu Ray then FCP and/or Toast may prove to be enough for your needs

  • DVD Studio burning blu-ray

    I cant find the thread dealing with this subject although I am sure many people must have raised this issue. I would like to know if Apple finally decided in its new DVD Studio version to add the possibility of authoring in HD and burning blu-rays discs?

    As I said, what I want to know is if Apple's DVD Studio Pro will at last decided to offer the solution of burning the authoring made through this application into a Blu-Ray (rather than having to use another application much more simplified and rudimentary).
    I know Steve Jobs gambled to fully suppport HD-DVD rather than Blu-Ray and he lost this gamble since HD-DVD is no longer a standard. So I am wondering if the reason why he is dragging his feet to implement Blu-Ray capabilities is that he does not like to loose and will do everything to prevent Apple from integrating the Blu-Ray standard in its applications...

  • Trying to burn Blu-ray on Power PC G5

    Does anyone make a Blu-ray video authoring software program that does not require an Intel processor?  I'm trying to use Roxio's Toast 10 with BD/HD Plug-in but is is not working.
    I have a Dual 2 GHz PowerPC G5 running OSX 10.5.8 (Leopard) with 10 GB of Ram and Final Cut Studio 2 (Final Cut Pro 6.0.4)
    My Blu-ray burner is a LaCie d2 Firewire drive.

    My Toast 10 now works in burning Blu-ray video.  I've learned from other posts that there was a problem when I updated to QuickTime 7.7 in that certain video file types were no longer recognized. Unfortunately you just can't install an earlier version over the newer version the traditional way.
    I've learned however that there is a way to install an earlier version of QuickTime (in my case QT 7.6.4 without completely re-loading the Operating System software (Leopard for me).
    There's a Shareware program called Pacifist which takes elements from the earlier QuickTime installer and replaces the newer versions problem files. The QuickTime version # still says your current version but the elements have changed. See this link for how to do this:
    http://www.digitalrebellion.com/blog/posts/using_pacifist_to_downgrade_quicktime .html
    After rebooting, the QuickTime Player (and more importantly Final Cut Pro) supported all the video files.  Toast 10 still had a problem until I trashed the Toast plist and pref files in the User>Library>Preferences folder and then re-installed Toast 10.0.9.  Now everything works!
    I still want to buy a better Blu-ray authoring program because the menus in Toast are so basic.

  • BE NICE TO BE ABLE TO BURN BLUE-RAY DISC, I TRIED AT LEAST 3 BURNERS APPROVED BY ADOBE WEBSITE AND IT'S NOT WORKING

    BE NICE TO BE ABLE TO BURN BLUE-RAY DISC,
    I TRIED AT LEAST 3 BURNERS APPROVED BY ADOBE WEBSITE AND IT'S NOT WORKING...

    Maybe the problem is caused by a stuck CAPS LOCK key? 8/

  • I want to burn blu ray discs from FVPX, compatible mac burner.

    I want to burn blu ray discs from FCPX projects. I note I should be able to but any thought on a mac compatible burner. Why is so difficult to find one??

    I would recommend navigating to www.macsales.com, because they specialize in Macs they can point you to devices that should work with your computer. Please make sure you also have software for burning Bluray discs, i'd recommend Titanium Toast.

  • Can Leopard burn blu-ray data disc?

    Leopard defines types for Blu-ray discs in the header for the disc recording service.
    Can Leopard burn a blu-ray data disc?

    Since no Mac ships with Blu-Ray drives built-in, there's no automatic support for Blu-Ray.
    However, there are several third-party applications that support burning Blu-Ray disks, including Toast.
    Many after-market Blu-Ray vendors ship a copy of Toast with their burners (after all, what's the use of the burner if you can't write data to it? )

  • Has a stop marker any function when burning blu-ray discs with Premiere Elements 12?

    Stop marker when burning blu-ray discs with Pre 12. Does it works?

    Amiral
    No.
    This applies to Premiere Elements any version.
    Stop markers placed on the Premiere Elements Timeline destined for burn to Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc are not recognized at playback of that disc using the Blu-ray player.
    If you need Blu-ray disc with stop markers, you can export your Premiere Elements Timeline content to an appropriate file type that will be compatible with a 3rd party software which will get the job done. I have heard that a software such as DVD Architect can do that, but I have not been there and done that.
    Stop markers function at playback of DVD-VIDEO on DVD disc only. And, never place a stop marker at the end of the last item on that Timeline.
    http://help.adobe.com/en_US/premiereelements/using/WS09e4b3c48f3a79fc19b622510385d4355c-7e 19.html
    Please do not hesitate to ask if you need clarification on anything written.
    Thank you.
    ATR
    Add On...I have found that the situation is the same for stop markers and AVCHD on DVD and Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc.

  • CS4 for burning Blu-rays?

    I'm thinking about upgrading from CS3 to CS4 and was wondering if the Encore CS4 was more reliable for burning blu-rays than CS3. I have been receiving all sorts of errors that have been driving me nuts.
    I'm using a Matrox Axio LE with windows XP.

    Of course a single movie would be broken up to compress in smaller parts. It's called segmented processing. It's what Qmaster does when you set up a distributed processing network. But you need more than one computer to make it worth while, and they have to be networked on, minimum, a gigabit network, but preferably on a faster Fibre network.
    The problem that comes with job segmenting is if you use a variable bit rate, because the bit rate information isn't shared between/amongst the nodes. If you use a CBR, you're all set, but like I said, it won't matter unless you have more than one computer, and you're limited by the slowest computer in the chain, as well as the network.
    If you use less than a gigabit connection, the time it takes to transfer the information to and from the cluster controller, and then reconstitute the final video is more than the time it would take to just do it on a single computer.

Maybe you are looking for