Can't decide between MBA, MBP, or MBPR

I'm in my last year of college and have decided I need (want) a new MacBook. I have an older 15" MBP that only works when plugged in, a Dell Mini 9, and a 2010 iMac. Planning on selling the three and getting either a 13" MBA, 13" MBP or have considered splurging for the 15" MBPR. I've looked and looked and really don't know what would be best and be the best bang for my buck. This would be my only computer and I would want to keep it for several years at least. If I got the 13" MBP I would remove the disc drive and install a SSD to increase the speed but keep the storage of the HDD. I have a decent music collection (40+ GB), do some work with Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop occasionally, but mostly do basic stuff like word, excel, web browsing etc, travel a decent amount, and would most likely get an extra display for more serious work while at home. I know this question gets asked a lot so I appreciate any responses for help.

Ordered (7/16/2012) the 2012 15.4" Macbook Pro (NON retina)
With:
2.6GHz i7 CPU
1GB GPU
HR Antiglare Wide Screen
750GB 7200 RPM HDD (installed Crucial M4 256GB SSD with a fresh install of Mountian Lion)
I really wanted the rMBP but just could not see the real value of the Retina display when the (HR) 1680 X1050 is really ideal for me. I also have the late 2011 Macbook Air that has 1440 X 900 resolution, it's not antiglare and not glossy either. I also have a 2006 Black Macbook with 1280 X 800 and it's not antiglare and not glossy. If the rMBP offered a antiglare display I'd probably still be deciding (took 3 weeks already).
The thoughts that keep me on the fence between the 15" rMBP and 15" MBP was "I need to buy the future and not invest in the past". For sure the rMBP is the future.
Since I made the decision Im glad I did (15" MBP Antiglare WS).
my Pros/Cons list
                         rMBP          MBP
Speed                   X                X     (tie, adding SSD) (Im getting 285 Write & 502 Read)
Expansion                              X     (increase RAM and HDD or SSD)
Weight                  X                      ( rMBP about a pound lighter, not impressed)
Generation                             X     (decided long ago to NOT buy 1st generation anything, if possible)
Repairability                           X     (replace battery on MBP and other parts, but not the rMBP, yet)
Resale                  X                       (not sure here but makes since, new beats old)
Antiglare                                X     (no contest)
Cost                     X                       (my configuration was about $320 more than the retina)
Ports                                      X     (FW800, Gigabit Ethernet, DVD/CD drive, have HDMI adaper)
Value                                     X     ( rMBP display would be a waste of money for me)
BTW, my GeekBenck score is 12096

Similar Messages

I Can't Decide between a iPod Touch (5th Generation) or a iPad Mini 2

I'm looking for an apple product from Christmas. Originally the iPad Mini came to mind then I saw the Mini 2 and I also a iPod Touch. So I can't decide between a 32GB iPod Touch 5th Gen or a 32GB iPad Mini 2.
You see one of the reasons I liked the Mini was the size factor for games and music but them I said to myself that's too big for listening to music on my daily commute. So I really don't know. If it helps I already have an iPod Touch 4th Gen but it's 16GB and the charging socket only works sometimes.

I would get the Mini because the design of the 5G iPod is over two years old. It will max out iOS updates before the the Mini will.
But the desire for a smaller device may be more important.

Can't decide between the iphone or ipad as my first apple product. Is there a difference other than phone and size?

Can't decide between the iphone or ipad as my first apple product. Is there a difference other than phone and size?

A couple of differences:
iPad native apps
Interactive e-books with multi-touch and 3D support (in iBooks 2)
Layouts (kind of merges with iPad apps, Music/Settings, etc. all look different)
Wi-Fi only models, no contracts
iPads are unlocked by default (3G models)
As paul said, I would really wait for the next iteration of iPad. That's what I'm doing

I need to upgrade my OS from Snow Leopard 10.6.8. I can't decide between Lion or Mountain Lion can anyone tell me the difference between the two?

I need to upgrade my OS from Snow Leopard 10.6.8. I can't decide between Lion or Mountain Lion for my upgrade can anyone tell me the difference between the two?

Click here for information.
(125089)

Can't decide between the 1st gen and 2nd gen 32GB iPod Touch, please help.

I would like to buy a 32GB iPod Touch, the problem is that i can't decide whether i should buy a 1st gen or 2nd gen.
Obviously 2nd gen is "better" but is it worth the extra $$$?
Best Buy has the 1st gen for $310 and the 2nd gen is $400, that's $90 difference.
Any advice would be appreciated.

that's $90 difference.
Actually, it's only $80 because the 1G touch will come with the old 1.x software and it cost $10 to upgrade to 2.x software.

Can't Decide On Which MBP To Get, Can Someone Help?

So I might get a MacBook Pro tomorrow and I'm not sure whether if I should get a regular MBP or one with Retina Display @ 13". I will mainly be using it for music, will install Parallels and use FL Studio, other than that mainly use OS X. Any suggestions?

I just made the switch to the RETINA , after using a 2008 MBP I decided i wanted the new rMBP and I have to tell you that I noticed a huge difference in the way FACE TIME LOOKS on the RETINA screen it looks as though you are sitting in the room and there is no DELAY when you are moving. I was amazed at the RETINA when watching MOVIES. I put my MACBOOK PRO 2008 up against my 2013 rMBP and there is a huge difference. QUALITY that cannot be beat. Others' are saying not to go RETINA, but it's a persoal preference to each his own. Go to the APPLE STORE AND TEST ONE OUT before you order or buy. YOU WON"T BE SORRY if you test drive the retina first @ the APPLE STORE be sure you ask a genuis all the questions you can to help you decide.

I can't decide between the 20" and 24" iMac C2D

Hey all...
I am in the process of selling my Power Mac G5 Dual 1.8GHz with 2GB of RAM as I want to move to an iMac C2D. I keep flip flopping between the 20" and 24". The only upgrade I would get for either would be bumping the memory to 2GB. The price delta between the two is $500. That additional $500 buys me a larger screen, better video and better speakers. I am also leveraging my daughter's educational discount.
I don't use my Mac for business. I use it for email, web browsing and research. In addition, I am a heavy iLife user, except for Garage Band. I use iTunes and iPhoto a lot. I also import movies into iMovie and iDVD. It will be used every day after work for about 3 hours and a lot on the weekends.
My Power Mac is running fine and has served me well for the last two years. I figured I'd sell it while I can still get some decent money for it (my eBay auction ends tonight!).
I just really want an iMac. There is something to be said for using a Mac with an Apple display. My G5 was connected to a Dell 2005FPW 20" widescreen. I also have two AMD based machines running Windows/Linx connected to my new Dell 2407WFP 24" widescreen and it is almost too big! Those are used for gaming, development, virtual machines, etc.
Is the 24" overkill? I don't know. It looked beautiful last night in the Apple Store.
Thoughts. Comments? Suggestions?

Hi there. I recieved mu 24" imac on Thursday this week having sent back my 20" as soon as the 24" came out. It was the best decision i ever made. I do alot of photo retouching and editing as I am a photographer and have only just started playing with the computer. The screen makes a massive difference, not only for photo's but for all other things, it enables you to keep windows open at a good viewing size and see them all on screen at the same time.
I know its a difficult decision as had to convince my girlfriend that it was worth the extra cost, but i am so glad to have done it.
The 20" was lovely and a fantastic size, the extra 4" is a worthy investment.
I was worried it was overkill also, but after using it today fully for the first time i could not imagine having a smaller screen.
Hope this helps, using Photoshop and Aperture means i really appriciate the extra space, but when i browse the web the pages do tend to look a little lost!! ;o)
Ant

Can't decide between Macbook Pro or Air, any adivce?

Hey everyone!
Well tonight the "Service Battery" warning appeared on my mid 2009 Macbook Pro with 868 charge cycles. I am assuming I can continue using the computer, plugged in, for a few weeks without problems?
Anyway, I will be getting a new laptop soon, and am debating between:
1. the 13" Pro with 256GB flash, 2.4 GHz processor and 8GB RAM
2. the 13" Air with 256GB flash and 8GB RAM
With education pricing at my university, the two will essentially cost the same. I am attracted to the great screen on the Pro but also the great battery life and light-weight nature of the Air (Although now I hear its okay to leave the battery plugged in constantly... And since I am always near an outlet, I am not sure battery life really matters?). I will be using the computer for mostly internet browsing, word processing and FaceTime. I am also really interested in longevity of the device and am unsure which to go with. Anyone have any suggestions, opinions or recommendations?

I also forgot to include that I have heard the Pro is noticeably faster, so I guess if that is true, that is another plus!

Can't decide between a 12 inch and 15 inch Powerbook, comments welcome.

I have a new PowerMac G5, and am looking to add a laptop. I love the size of the 12 inch Powerbook, but see enough differences between it and the 15 inch that I am looking at both. I will only be using my laptop when I travel, on airplanes, in airport, and hotel rooms. I see myself mostly reading email, surfing the web, and possibly working on individual scenes in Final Cut Express, and Soundtrack. I would appreciate any comments, complaints, or suggestions from anyone who has experience with either laptop.
Bill

I owned a 12" PB G4 and recently switched over to the new hi-res 15" Powerbook. I was really torn about it, I love my 12" PB, it is great to carry around, surf the web, etc. I did not want to give up the small size, but finally switched. Here is my opinion:
The 15" Powerbook is the clear winner. In terms of performance the 15" Powerbook with a 7200 RPM drive and the 128 MB video RAM is clearly faster in perceived day to day use. The significant extra real estate (specially in current generation of 15") is just stunning. I have not yet sold my old 12" and when I occasionally pick up the 12" the screen looks cramped and small. And as far as size differential the only real issue is that I could easily and safely pick up the 12" with one hand and I really don't want to do that with the 15". And place the 15" on one leg I have to carefully balance it (where the 12" would just stay).
I believe the 15" when open requires just under one extra inch in space for traveling no the airlines. My experience is that I have been on flights where even the 12" would get crushed by the person in front, so I am not sure how significant this part is to you.
Finally and before you commit you should go look at the display of the 15". There are some issues with alternate lines being a little dimmer, which bothers some people and not others (mine has it, but it does not effect what I do). Make sure it works for you in case Apple does not have a fix for this.
Good luck.

Help deciding between 13.3 MBP 2010 2.66 GHz C2D vs 13.3 MBP 2011 2.3GHz i5

Here is the deal and I hope I can get a quick response:
* I am deciding between the MBP 13.3 2010 2.66 GHz vs MBP 2011 2.3 GHz i5.
What I need:
* Most intensive stuff would be using photoshop and or primier once in a while.
What I like about the new MBP 2011:
* i5 outperforms C2D when it comes to video encoding, filter processing, etc.
What really concerns me about MBP 2011:
* Persistent heating issue complains.
* 320M being better than HD 3000 for image processing/editing.
While performace matters, so does the longevetiy of the laptop. With so many heating issues, will MBP 2011 be a good buy, so should I stick with the tested and proven MBP 2010?
Thank you.

Hi tjk,
Thanks for your input. The price is not really that much of a factor since a refurb 2010 model is almost the same price as the new 13.3 i5 MBP. I agree that performance generates heat, but lots of discussion here has been on consistent kicking in of fans in the newer model which generally seems to be running hot even with less intensive usage. Anyone with the newer model and lion can shine some light on if the issue has been fixed with the newer updates?Thanks!

Deciding between iMac and Mac Pro

My current desktop computer (a PC) is basically dead. It is under extended warrenty but the custom build place I got it from tells me nothing is covered (because of their negligence but they won't admit that) And basically they want me to pay out of pocket for a brand new computer.
However after having a Macbook Pro for a year and loving it I decided to just change my desktop over to a Mac which I want to purchase by the end of October (or if this computer gives out before then earlier) However I just can't decide between an iMac or a Mac Pro.
The 2 big things are video editing at the moment just Final Cut Express and gaming when/if I get a chance. The iMac I'm looking at is the 3.06 GHz, with 4 GB ram, and a Geforce 8800GS video card. On the Mac Pro side it'd be more or less the Stock Mac Pro with 2.8 GHZ Quad core x2, 4 GB Ram, and I'd purchase the ATI HD 3870 video card for it.
The other difficulty is I do need a new monitor as well with the iMac a new monitor isn't an issue but with the Mac Pro it's extra and I guess I'm trying to debate if the difference between the 2 computers is really worth the cost. I'd like for the new computer to last me 3-4 years maybe a bit longer so it's just a matter of which is better for my needs. Is the Mac Pro really worth it over the iMac? I know I cant replace anything in the iMac but if it can do me for awhile I don't see why that'd be a downside
The other factor is, buying at the end of october, is it wise or should I try and get as much life out of my dead PC and try and wait for the next iMac/Mac Pro refresh?
Thank you to everyone who replies with their opinions.

The biggest advantage of the MacPro is its expandability. Yes, it is faster too, but is the speed difference worth the extra cost? Looking at what you can expand in a MacPro (unlike PCs which can be swapped out component by component until nothing but the case is original equipment) I decided that expandability was too limited to be worth the price and the speed increase wasn't either.
In the past I'd bought a Mac tower and kept it 5 years, over those five years upgrading the graphics card, swapping out the CPU, bigger drives, etc. I looked at the MacPro and concluded there wasn't much I would or could do to expand it other than a bigger hard drive or more hard drives and more memory. Maybe a better graphics card. Meanwhile, I could buy an iMac, keep it for 2 1/2 years, sell it, buy a new iMac and keep it for 2 1/2 years and wind up spending less (thanks to the high resale values of Macs).

Trying to decide between an iMac or MacBook pro

Recently bought a iPhone and iPad and loved both of them. Now I want to upgrade my windows desktop pc to apple. Just can't decide between IMac or macbookpro. I love the big screen but I also love the portability of the MacBook. At least want a 15 inch screen.

I guess it all comes down to what you want to use it for. If you need the portability and want the bigger screen you should consider purchasing a larger monitor and run off that when you're not out and about.. It's certainly a good compromise.

MBA or MBP? can't decide

I've been using a MBP 2.2 for 2 years now and want to get another mac but I can't decide. I've heard the MBA overheats a lot and no multitouch. The only thing attractive is the size.
New MBP has better battery life, don't know about the overheating issue.
any thoughts?

The MBA is lightweight, ultraportable and very sexy. That being said, it is not for everyone. The complaints that some have made regarding overheating can be due to several issues ranging from its small breathing holes positioned at the bottom and/or network issues. I have a first generation MBA (1.6 GHz early 2008), after a few months of heating and freezing, I learned most of this is due to user negligence. First of all, its form factor is so compact, and yet it is able to perform as well as any other notebook, assuming you know what things to avoid or what steps to take to ensure it can perform to the specifications.
The first thing I learned is that it is not a laptop, it is a notebook, the term laptop is the reason for most people's frustrations with the little guy. The fan vents are positioned under the machine so it needs to sit on a flat, ridgid surface. So if you want to use it on your lap avoid placing it over fabric. Use a ridgid surface, if you must use it in bed or on the couch, the simple solution is a laptop table or in my case, I use a small cutting board I purchased at walmart that fits perfectly under it.
The second thing that can cause overheating or sluggish responses is the wireless network you use. I use a Time Capsule which can be configured to use the 5MHz band and the 802.11n radio mode however, if you have more than one wireless machine in your network and one of them at least does not have the 802.11n but 802.11g (such as older macs, the iphone, etc.), your network will be downgraded to the slower radio mode. This cannot be avoided unless you have this year's new wave of airport extremes and time capsules, which have the ability to run in dual modes.
So if you take all of these things into consideration and accept the fact that this machine was built to work with the latest network technology and you can live with it sitting on a flat ridgid surface, there is no reason why you wouldn't love the machine. I have used it for over a year and do not see how I could ever part with it. This notebook is as small as I ever want to get and will be my favorite apple computer for a long time.

In the market for a MBA 13" and cant decide between 128gb vs 256gb. Help please?

I am in the market for a MBA 13" and cant decide between the 128gb vs 256gb. I will be finishing up grad school within the year and plan on purchasing an iMac to use as the main computer. I would be using the MBA for internet access, some word docs, viewing pdf files, etc. Nothing really heavy, no video/sound editing, or photography type funtions. I would however like to mess with the garage band program but am new to apple and dont have any experience with it. Itunes library is currently about 600 songs and very few pics. I was originally planning on the macbook pro 13" until I talked to a sales person at the apple store who introduced me to the idea of a MBA. I really like the price point of the 128gb vs 256gb but just want to make sure that I am being realistic with size. Help please?

I've worked part time for an Apple reseller for a very long time and sold a lot of low end computers to people who thought they were going to use the computer for just email and surfing, maybe writing the Christmas letter. It didn't take me long to realize that a lot of those customers were coming back within a year or 18 months to upgrade their computer or replace it with a more powerful one.
Based on this experience, I try very hard not to let someone walk out of the store with the low end MBA if that's the only computer in the household. It can't be upgraded. Since the 2011 MBA shipped I've seen another trend developing - it has happened in my own household, with a lot of the people I work with, and customers too. Despite having another computer, even one that in terms of specs is more powerful than the MBA, a lot of people have turned their MBA into their main computer. With that in mind, the 128GB drive really is the bare minimum and it will be costly to upgrade - not to mention voiding the warranty.

I can't seem to decide between the 13" or the 15" MacBook Pro. I had a 14.5 in Dell which crashed on me for the third and last time. It was also my primary home computer. Is the 15" necessary or should I just get the 13"?

I can't seem to decide between the 13" or the 15" MacBook Pro. I had a 14.5" I'm just used to that size. Dell which crashed on me for the third and last time. It was also my primary home computer. Is the 15" necessary or should I just get the 13"? I probably won't be doing any graphics or anything like that.

It is really a matter of your personal preference. You have to choose between the extra carrying convenience of the smaller machine and the greater "real estate" of the bigger. I use a 15", and have not found it inconvenient for carrying, even on aircraft, where it has to share backpack space with an SLR camera and assorted lenses.

Can't decide between MBA, MBP, or MBPR

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for