Can't use only the external monitor, leaving macbook open on Lion

HW
macbook pro 15-inch, Early 2011
external samsung monitor, attached using HDMI to Thunderbolth adaptor
Previous Situation
With Snow Leopard I was able to keep the macbook screen open but turned off and use only the external monitor. This way I was able to use the front camera to make conference having everything only in the external monitor.
Current Situation
With Lion as soon as I open the macbook monitor the image splits between the two monitors and I'm not able to set the extenal one as only one.

Support today quoted Apple's engineers as saying it is "expected behaviour" under Lion for the MBP's internal display to reactivate upon opening the lid, even if you want to use only your external display. A new version of the clamshell mode-related knowledgebase article (replacing HT3131) is due shortly confirming this.
This is despite:
- the obvious temperature-related benefits that were achievable (under Snow Leopard) by opening your MBP lid whilst continuing to output solely to, say, a 27" cinema display
- potential wifi connectivity benefits of having the lid open
- the waste of energy and inefficient use of graphics processing power in needlessly running two active screens (ie if running your MBP in clamshell mode would otherwise make it too hot and/or noisy or you need it open for wifi)
- the negative longer-term impact on the battery and other components from running the MBP any hotter than it needs to be.
To have any hope of getting the previous behaviour back, we need to lobby Apple to change how Lion handles clamshell mode. Options available to them include changing Lion's expected behaviour or adding a user-selectable option within System Preferences.
If you haven't already submitted feedback, please do so below. Now the situation has been clarified as intentional, user feedback has become all the more important.
http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

Similar Messages

  • Using only the external monitor in Snow Leopard?

    Greetings,
    I primarily use an external monitor with my macbook (latest gen.) Is there an easier way turn off the laptop screen when connected to an external screen (e.g. a key combination that will turn off the laptop screen to switch to external screen-only mode)?
    My current song-and-dance involves:
    - turn on laptop (with mains power connected)
    - close lid
    - hit a key in my external keyboard
    - open lid again to facilitate ventilation
    I was hoping snow leopard would have finally addressed this pain with a simply key combo?! This is one thing that is easy in the PC world
    Thas

    If you have an external monitor, keyboard, and mouse connected, it will shut off the main screen when you close the lid. If you open the lid, it will turn the display back on.

  • Recover Vista 64-bit OS using only an external monitor

    How can I use HP System Recovery to reinstall the Vista 64-bit OS using only an external monitor?  Unfortunately the display on my HP Pavilion DV5-1000US is broken.

         Thanks for suggesting use of BIOS messages as an indicator of recovery success using an external display.  Currently all my BIOS messages go to the internal display, which is broken.  Therefore, I do not know what information those messages present.  How can  I direct the BIOS messages to the external display?
         I have located the HP Recovery Disks I made when the computer was purchased.  Thanks for reminding me about them.
    Regards,
    Clyde

  • Display only on external monitor with laptop open--possible?

    I have an external monitor (20" with resolution of 1680 x 1050) attached via DVI-D to my MacBook Pro 15". When I'm using it in this configuration, I like to only use my external monitor and not the built-in laptop display. The only way I can get this to work is to close the laptop screen and then wake up the computer using an externally attached (bluetooth, actually) keyboard.
    My question is, how can I do this and have my laptop screen open? Whenever the laptop screen is open, its built-in screen activates and I can either "mirror" the displays or have display spanning. Mirroring does not work well for me because the external monitor's native LCD resolution is 1680 x 1050 and the laptop is 14xx by something (I forget the number).
    Why do I want the screen to be open? Better airport and bluetooth reception. My external monitor is far away enough from the laptop that sometimes, the bluetooth mouse gets jittery when it tracks.
    Thanks for the help!

    How about turning the
    brightness on the MBP all the way down? Will that
    achieve what you want?
    Kryten
    Well, that means using monitor spanning. In that case, I could certainly make my external monitor the main display (thus, the one with the menu bar). The problem with monitor spanning in my situation is that it is possible windows and icons be mis-located to the laptop monitor. Because my two displays are not sitting side-by-side (they are at least 5 feet away from each other) this could get confusing.

  • How can I use only the most recent data in an average?

    I have a class which has regular listening quizzes.  If a student's average from the last three tests falls below 10 points (out of 20), then that student has to come in for extra practice.
    My Sheets are set up with the students' names running down column A.  Test 1 is column B.  A a check box for whether students handed in the pre-listening homework is in column C.  The test and homework column pattern is continued for tests 1 through 20. 
    I then have an average for all the tests for that student further over to the right.
    Next to the overall average, I would like to make a column with an average showing only the latest three test scores.  So, for example, the students have just finished test 10, the average of test 10, 9 and 8 would appear, but everything prior to that would be ignored.
    I appreciate any suggestions on a formula for how I could make that happen.
    Thank you!

    CB,
    Here's one approach. Note that I used Header Columns to make the programming easier. If you choose not to use Header Columns, you can adjust the formulas to account for the difference.
    The formula in Overall Average is: =IFERROR(AVERAGE(2:2), 0) for Alice. Fill Down.
    The formula in Last Three Scores average is: =IF(COUNT(2:2)<3, B, AVERAGE(OFFSET(D2, 0, (COUNT(2:2)-3)*2, 1, 6))) for Alice. Fill Down.
    Regards,
    Jerry

  • Can I use an additional external monitor for my mid-2010 MacBook?

    I currently run my MacBook in clamshell mode with an external monitor, keyboard, etc.  I have researched usb to VGA or DVI conversion kits but all of the sources seem outdated.  I don't need HDMI because my sound output goes through my MiniPort Display, out through speakers connected to my primary monitor.  I am aware that a usb connection will come with lag, but it isn't that big of a deal.  Thank you for your help!

    If I correctly understand you question: you have an external monitor, and you use your mac with lid closed (not a good idea at all if used for a long time, especially in warm/hot weather). Now, you want a second monitor connected via USB.
    My small piece of advice is to use your MB with lid open and thus you have two monitors, beside this, you protect your mac by a proper ventilation, which is better when lid is open.
    Other ideas are here:
    http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/35752/displaypad
    http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/22908/screenrecycler
    http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/37480/air-display
    An this is how I currently use my MB:

  • Which cable to use for 2 external monitors on MacBook Pro?

    Hy there,
    I'm currently using one external monitor on my MacBook Pro via a mini display to VGA cable from apple.
    I would like to hook up another (second external monitor) one using also VGA.
    After doing some research I've learned that I should use some sort of adaptor cable for this. I'm just wondering if there is any way of getting one of there for a decent price in europe? (decent is sub €100).
    Thanks a lot!

    Hello, Carl. 
    Thank you for visiting Apple Support Communities.
    Here is the best resource I could find that gives the best option. 
    About Mini DisplayPort to HDMI adapters
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4241
    Cheers,
    Jason H. 

  • Can i use only the fingerprint reader to log onto my phone?

    I'm wondering if I can by pass the 4 digit code completely and only use the fingerprint reader to log onto my 5S phone.

    Yes, that's how it's designed. You only need the passcode if you haven't unlocked your iPhone within the last 48 hours.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5883
    Regards.

  • 30" display and 15" PowerBook. How can I use just the 30"?

    So i just got a 30" monitor. Hooked it up to my 30" and it works great. But when i use design applications its a bummer because the top menu bar is on the small 15" monitor. Then I use mirror displays but think it such a waste of space to not use the PowerBooks sweet screen. How can I just use the 30" monitor by itself from my laptop?

    In the "Arrangement" pane of "Displays" system preference, turn off mirroring, and drag the picture of the menu bar to the picture of the monitor you want it on. If you want to use only the external display, attach the power adapter,and an external keyboard and mouse. Close the lid. The computer will sleep, but will wake, and continue to run with the lid closed, when you use the external keyboard or mouse.

  • HT6030 Why can't I get an external monitor to work on my macbook running Mavericks

    I'm trying to use an additional monitor ( Samsung) but both screens just flash on and off, I'm running Mavericks latest east version and using the mini port and VGA connector, can anyone help me here?

    Hey Starmanpaul43,
    If you haven't already, I would run through the steps in this article, which can help you troubleshoot the external monitor issue:
    Apple computers: Troubleshooting issues with video on internal or external displays
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1573
    Welcome to Apple Support Communities!
    Regards,
    Delgadoh

  • Using only an External Drive

    I bought an iomega external drive to hold my 900CD library on (160GB) so I would not use space on the internal drive. The problem is I keep ripping CD's and they keep going to the internal drive. Can anyone tell me how to use only the external drive for itunes and my ipod(30GB)?

    See this link from MacMuse, follow his instructions EXACTLY & you should be good to go. Just think, once you get the EHD up & running, no more worries about losing your music due to a computer crash. The other thing I would recommend is a secondary backup such as burning data CD's or DVD's which is what I do. I only burn about once or twice a month now, but this is just extra insurance in case the EHD takes a hike for some reason.
    MacMuse, "Computer Crashed" #4, 11:49pm Feb 7, 2005
    EDIT:
    I forgot, the one thing that was suggested to me when I put my EHD in is to regularly send backups of the .itl & .xml files which are the database files for your library, playlists, etc. to your EHD. I send copies of these 2 files to the EHD any time I add music, change playlists, etc. DO NOT MOVE the original files off your main HD, that is there "home." If you should happen to have bad luck & have a crash with these 2 files backed up, along with the iTunes music folder, you should be able to get iTunes up & running in a "jiffy".

  • Using Mac OS on multiple monitor is great, but after removing external monitor (2nd monitor) usually windows position originally on the external monitor doesn't get re-positioned to default monitor. Is there any shortcut key or utilities that can reset wi

    Using Mac OS on multiple monitor is great, but after removing external monitor (2nd monitor) usually windows position originally on the external monitor doesn't get re-positioned to default monitor. Is there any shortcut key or utilities that can reset wi

    Got the "apple firewire ntsc" choice to show up even if grayed out and "missing" under "audio/visual" menus by recreating choices in Easy Setup under "final cut pro" MENU thank GOODNESS because I was reading horror stories on here about this under another thread with someone trashing preferences, reinstalling and the works and still not getting it to show up...on my search now for an analog/digital converter up at b&h...find it odd that the s video connector wouldn't show the crt monitor when I put both displays through the 3870...I switched it back to see if it worked again when only the one dell monitor display was there and there it is again mirroring the screen display on my desktop...just can't be seen as an "external monitor" in fcp...couldn't find anything specific in the shane ross threads to this. I'm sad the program doesn't just see the s video connection though the 3870 though my computer does fine and will query up at b&h in regard to what might be affordable as far as a digital/analog converter. It's also weird in itself that when I put the two dell monitors on the one card my computer no longer could see the s video crt connection...makes no sense. Will report in later as to what I discover up at b&h as I'm sure there's a world of people out there using this sony crt monitor still even into the upgrades with computers and software so I imagine therein lies the solution. Thanks again and I'll report in as to what hardware might be suggested for me.

  • I want to remove the monitor from my 17" Macbook Pro 2008 to use as an external for my Macbook Pro 15" 2012. How can I convert lvds to Thunderbolt and power the monitor?

    I want to remove the monitor from my 17" Macbook Pro 2008 to use as an external for my Macbook Pro 15" 2012. How can I convert lvds to Thunderbolt and power the monitor?

    It's almost impossible.  The new iMacs have a Target Display Mode, but it's built to do that.  Without ripping your screen out, finding an acceptable power supply, frame, and whatever electronics to convert a Thunderbolt signal to the screen, the cost will be much larger than buying a cheaper HiDef monitor that runs with an HDMI to Thunderbolt cable to your MacBook 15.  In fact, you can sell your 17" MBP for a lot of money, unless it's broken or something, buying you a really sweet monitor.
    By the way, I found your answer by searching this forum.  I would suggest using the search function here in the futuere.

  • Can the iMac be used as an external monitor for a MacBook?

    Can the iMac be used as an external monitor for a MacBook?

    What iMac is this ?
    If it is a 2009 or 2010 27" iMac than this http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3924 could apply.
    Stefan

  • Only use the extern monitor??

    Hee,
    i have my macbook (black) connected to my HD tv with HDMI. Is it possible to use only the tv screen? so that the screen of my macbook goes to sleep?
    thnx (H)

    The only way to use the external display only is to use your MacBook with the lid closed (aka Closed ClamShell). Any other way (Mirrored or Extended) and you would be using both displays however you may turn down the brightness to lowest on your MacBook if you wish.
    Does this answer your question?
    Here's how to do Closed ClamShell: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3131

Maybe you are looking for

  • Quicktime error -50 (as many people)

    Since yesterday I can't use Compressor anymore from FCP X: I have an error -50. I already watch previous threads, I did many things (like putting QMaster to the trash). I know I can do export the media from FCPX and then go to Compressor but you're n

  • CUA - Looking for the Usual Suspects

    I was out a couple of days and when I got back our basis person told me that while I was gone they tried unsuccessfully to do some client copies and, oh, by the way, CUA is down. The clients do not have a "New User" button, but no updates occur when

  • Server with 2 nodes

    hi im thinking about making a system what i want it to do is this: have a grid of buttons when a certain button is clicked it will save the setting and go to another menue and give you more options that you can choose from after you are done selectin

  • 17in Macbook pro making funny sound.

    I have a 4 month old macbook pro and when I move it at any time sometimes it will make a funny tinking sound. It sounds like it is coming from the upper left hand side of the keyboard. If anyone has any ideas I would really appreciate it. It doesnt s

  • Will 800MHz DDR2 SODIMM RAM work OK in a 667MHz mid-2007 iMac?

    Will 800MHz DDR2 SODIMM RAM work OK in a 667MHz mid-2007 iMac?