Can we make the amp sim sound more "tubular"?

I play live instruments exclusively, and a rack-mounted mini + a MOTU 828 has replaced all the stage amps, pedals, preamps, etc. It's fantastic.
The one thing I'm not happy with is the guitar amp simulator's inability to re-create the valve amp (a.k.a. "Marshall Stack") sound.
The "American High Gain" sounds, to my ear, like a classic 1980s solid-state amp.
The "British High Gain" sounds to me like a classic 1970s... solid-state amp.
I don't want the flat-line "crunch" of solid state, I want the SCREAM of over-driven tubes!
In every other way, the signal processing capability of GarageBand is a dream. I like the stereo chorus effects, the reverb, the compressor, the gate, the EQ... It's just this one small thing I'm lacking that is the thorn in my side.
I can't afford a vintage Marshall Stack. I can probably afford a pretty good knock-off tube amp and a couple 4x12 cabinets, but I don't want to haul all that around to support one instrument.
Heck, I don't even want to mess with a RP200 or Guitar Pod. I shouldn't have to! If a $120 stomp-box can re-create an enjoyable illusion of tube distortion, the magnificent Mac mini should have no problem doing so as well.
Anybody have any luck getting a top-notch tube amp sound out of GarageBand? If so, would you care to share your settings? If not, are there good third-party patches and/or "Jam Pack" offerings which can get me there?

Golias wrote:
For cheapskates like me, are there any really great free (or reasonably cheap) amp-modeling plug-ins that anybody can recommend? I've experimented with a few now, and most of them don't sound that much better than the ones that come with GB.
Count me as a cheapskate guitarist as well! OK, while I'm not necessarily adverse to shelling out for the likes of AU versions of Amplitude, Guitar Rig, or the Line6 stuff, I'm definitely adverse to shelling out for it without being able to road-test it rather better the last demo versions of any AUs for these I've seen allow. It's a fair pile of money to drop on something that I'm not sure I love, might not be able to sell on easily, and could be "obsoleted" by an OS upgrade ....
So far, I've stuck with the stock GB amp sims, doing my best to tweak settings to my tastes. Even with my limited experimentation -- and abilities -- I think that the (relatively limted range of) amp simulation built in the GarageBand at least may be much more capable than it appears. I think the shipped presets are spread too generically thin to be very interesting of themselves. Clearly, Apple assumes that more serious guitarists will go off and purchase specialized AUs, and hasn't spent a lot of time getting serious gearheads in there to come up with more and better presets (or basic amp models). There is also a dearth of documentary info about how the models were designed to behave and how to get more out of them.
But what about all us cheapskate guitarists? Or at least those of us unwilling to part with so much cash for a 3rd-party digital amp model on what is, basically, a dare?
I really, really, really wish Apple -- or someone -- would set up a web site that facilitated a GB user community where people could upload and download user-made presets. (This would be useful not just for guitarists, but other presets as well.) Apple has always had a strong user community, and it seems to me like a forum like that would be a relatively cheap way of enhancing user experience and building user loyalty. The installed user base for GB must be enormous, so why this hasn't been done is beyond me.
Anyway, my stuck the info related to my (so far) most successful (in my mind ;)) GB amp sim tweak to my own web site: <http://www.carlaz.com/music/gb_presets.html>
Dubbed "El Sabado" it was aimed at a relatively modern Tony Iommi-ish tone -- which I won't claim it achieves but when I've posted some of my short demo clips to guitar-oriented forums, some listeners have been impressed that such a tone came out of the built-in GB amp simulators. (With some neck humbucker examples, some listeners also compared it to a Slash-like tone.) I'm sure other more knowledgeable than myself could improve on this or better it; and I tweaked it up in GB 2.x. I've only just been playing with GB '08 in recent weeks, so I haven't made any definite changes using the additional controls available in GB '08. The .pst file is downloadable, and there's a screenshot of the (GB 2.x) settings in case you can't use the .pst.
Obviously, the sound coming out of amp sims will depend on your indivdual guitar. The above one was designed around a LP-style twin-humbucker guitar. I've been working on a couple of bass amp sim tweaks, though my bass is an old Rick 4001, which starts off sounding a bit different from more common and more modern basses, so anything I can eventually post in the bass amp sim dept. might be a bit weird when used with, say, a Fender Jazz or Precision type bass ....

Similar Messages

  • How can I make the Lion iCal display more readable?

    How can I make the Lion iCal display more readable?

    I'm wondering the same thing.
    Under Lion, my calendars' color coding is next to useless because they're suddenly so muted.
    Previously I could easily pick out which events belonged to which calendar without effort. Now, all the colors are so light as to be nearly indisinguishable; I must toggle calendars off and on to highlight a calendar's events.

  • How can I make the drawings stand out more?

    Hi everyone,
    I have a design I like but I don't know how to make the drawings stand out more in the boxes?
    I feel they are a little bit lost in the squares. This design is the home page of foils
    every bit of advice would be very appreciated. Thanks a lot

    Hi SRiegel,thank you for your answer. I just put the screenshot here.
    But the website is more complete to see the overall atmosphere.

  • Can I make the Photostream notification sound as my text sound?

    I really hate the default text sound (maybe because there are a lot of iPhone users at my work and elsewhere) and everytime I hear the default text sound, I look at my iPhone only to find that it wasn't my iPhone. I do like the sound of Photostream notification. What's the name of that sound? Can I make that as my text tone? Thanks.

    Hey Grose1946,
    Thanks for the question. I understand that you are experiencing issues with sound on your iPhone 5c. The following resource may provide a solution:
    If you hear no sound or distorted sound from your iPhone, iPad, or iPod touch speaker - Apple Support
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203794
    Thanks,
    Matt M.

  • Can We Make the SL Wiki Environment More Collaborative?

    We were very excited to hear that the SL Wiki/blog system was going to allow more collaboration via Iphone/Ipod Touch. We are very disappointed with the result. I am hoping someone can shed some light on how to make this solution more workable with the Apple portable devices.
    Our expectations for a truly portable collaborative environment include:
    1. The ability to post and update content--not just comments
    2. The ability to actually watch wiki/blog .mov or .mp4 videos on the portable device. For example the videos found @ http://web2.wisd.us/groups/kwestv17/blog/
    3. The ability to dynamically subscribe to content without syncing with a computer.
    Is this completely unrealistic for this system? Are any of these possible with the SL Wiki/blog and an Ipod Touch? I know I can get the first item if I switch to Wordpress and install the app on each device. Item 2 just seems like it could be a format problem. I'd greatly appreciate suggestions for getting that to work. Item 3 is not as important as the other 2 but if someone knows of an app that will do it I'd be grateful.
    Thanks in advance for your great ideas!

    Item # 2 has been isolated (but not solved) to an issue with Iphone 3g. It has the same video playback capabilities as the 3G S but the videos I linked to in previous post play on the 3g s and ipod touch but not on the 3g phone.

  • I have a new iPhone 5C, have the sounds alerts set up. But I'm not getting sound alerts for new voicemail, only the red circle on the screen.  How can I make the sound alert work?

    I have a new iPhone 5C, have the sounds alerts set up. But I'm not getting sound alerts for new voicemail, only the red circle on the screen.  How can I make the sound alert work?

    I have had this same problem for weeks now with my 4S.  I just got a new 5S after being extremely frustrated and the same thing - no sounds.  After searching posts all over, I couldn't find a solution. I just told my friend of the issue and he asked "Do you have the Do Not Distrub on?"  I didn't even know such a function existed.  Upon looking that was exactly the issue.
    To resolve, go to Settings> Do Not Disturb> Manual.  If it is green, turn it off.  You will now get phone calls and text alerts.
    This functionality is also on your quick access utility menu (slide up menu).  I assume this is how it was enabled on my phone.
    I will post on other sites since I searched for weeks for this solution and didn't see it anywhere.  Good luck!

  • My iphone 4s has ceased to make the keyboard click sounds. I reset it and made sure that the keyboard click sound is selected in the Settings menu but still no click sound. Can anyone help?

    My iphone 4s has ceased to make the keyboard click sounds. I reset it and made sure that the keyboard click sound is selected in the Settings menu but still no click sound. Can anyone help?

    In Settings - Sounds - Silent - Vibrate, I tried toggling back and forth from "on" to "off", but still no keyboard click.

  • So in the last few days I've noticed that pressing my volume change keys actually isn't changing the volume on my macbook pro at all. When I press the volume up or down keys, it makes the recognisable pop sound but stays at the same volume while the squar

    So in the last few days I’ve noticed that pressing my volume change keys actually isn’t changing the volume on my macbook pro at all. When I press the volume up or down keys, it makes the recognisable pop sound but stays at the same volume while the squares go up or down. I mute it but my computer still makes sound. It’s the same with the volume control up the top of the screen, too. I slide it up and down and it doesn’t change the volume at all. The only way I can change the volume is with my speakers or the program I’m in (iTunes, VLC etc). I restarted and it seems to be okay then I go to change it a couple minutes later and it’s back to not working again.
    I’ve checked my settings- the “use all F1, F2, etc. keys as standard fuction keys” is not switched on, and I have tried a suggestion of moving the com.apple.systempreferences.plist file out of the library and onto the desktop and restarting and neither of those seem to make any difference whatsoever. I’ve tried to find online forums but the only suggestions I found were those two and they didn’t work.
    I’m just annoyed because I usually have the worst luck with technology but my macbook had been going strong and I got it because of the apparent lack of things that could go wrong, but of course even if there is one thing that could go wrong it will happen to me.
    Please help!

    You migh give resetting your NVRAM a try:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1379

  • Can I labled the same song to more than one albums? As you know, some songs are repeated in different albums.

    Can I labled the same song to more than one albums? As you know, some songs are repeated in different albums.

    You can make a copy of an existing song, then change the album, artwork and track number details. You cannot make the same physical file show up in two different albums.
    tt2

  • My mac book wont recognize my ipod. My Ipod will make the initial connected sound saying its charging but otherwise theres no way of finding the Ipod anywhere on the computer or Itunes.

    My mac book wont recognize my ipod. My Ipod will make the initial connected sound saying its charging but otherwise theres no way of finding the Ipod anywhere on the computer or Itunes. Please help with anyway I can get the Ipod recognized so I can download music from Itunes to my Ipod. Thanks in advance.

    Hello xerxes.nashion,
    It sounds like your iPod is not recognized by iTunes or your MacBook Pro.  I recommend following the steps in the article below for an issue like this:
    iPod not recognized in iTunes and Mac desktop
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1410
    Thank you for using Apple Support Communities.
    Best,
    Sheila M.

  • How can I make the spry accordion remember the panel open when I refresh the page or jump to a new page?

    How can I make the spry accordion remember the panel open
    when I refresh the page or jump to a new page?
    I am using the accordion feature on all my pages as a
    navigation aid. It has three panels. When you refresh the page the
    panel goes back to the default pane... Is there a way of
    controlling this so that the browser can remember the pane that is
    open (say set a variable, cookie, other?)

    Look for "Set the default open panel" on the following page:
    http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/spry/articles/accordion_overview/index.html
    Keep in mind you would need to change that bit of code on
    every page. The only way to do it more dynamically would be to
    include a custom javascript or PHP/ASP style script in order to
    change the value.

  • My husband uses adobe cs5. The clone tool isn't working and after resetting the tools adobe bridge now goes to picasa. How can we make the clone tool work and have bridge go to cs5 not picasa?

    My husband uses adobe cs5. The clone tool isn't working and after resetting the tools adobe bridge now goes to picasa. How can we make the clone tool work and have bridge go to cs5 not picasa?

    A lot more information about your hardware and software is needed.
    BOILERPLATE TEXT:
    If you give complete and detailed information about your setup and the issue at hand,
    such as your platform (Mac or Win),
    exact versions of your OS, of Photoshop (not just "CC", but something like CC2014.v.2.2) and of Bridge,
    your settings in Photoshop > Preference > Performance
    the type of file you were working on,
    machine specs, such as total installed RAM, scratch file HDs, total available HD space, video card specs, including total VRAM installed,
    what troubleshooting steps you have taken so far,
    what error message(s) you receive,
    if having issues opening raw files also the exact camera make and model that generated them,
    if you're having printing issues, indicate the exact make and model of your printer, paper size, image dimensions in pixels (so many pixels wide by so many pixels high). if going through a RIP, specify that too.
    a screen shot of your settings or of the image could be very helpful too,
    etc.,
    someone may be able to help you (not necessarily this poster, who is not a Windows user).
    Please read this FAQ for advice on how to ask your questions correctly for quicker and better answers:
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/419981?tstart=0
    Thanks!

  • I have an Airport Extreme Base Station and have recently upgraded to Mountain Lion. Now airport utility won't work with my base station so I bought a Time Capsule. For the life of me I can't make the substitution work and only see a blinking amber light.

    I have an Airport Extreme Base Station and have recently upgraded to Mountain Lion. Now airport utility won't work with my base station so I bought a Time Capsule. For the life of me I can't make the substitution work and only see a blinking amber light. Can anyone who has made this change offer some advice?

    apikoros wrote:
    The Utility transferred all of the AE's settings, so I still have to change the password, which leaves me with only 2 other questions, I think:
    1)  I assume it's just a matter of using the Utility, entering a stronger password and checking for it to be remembered in Keychain Access.  But do I have to  change the password for each individual unit-- the TC, the Extreme and both Expresses-- or will changing it just for the TC alone work for the entire network?
    Resetting the password you will need to do for each device... the utility cannot even see those old units.
    So you will have to do it for each one.. think it through.. because as you change passwords the others will lose connection.. so start from the express which are wireless extending .. change those first.. and go back up the chain.. as each one changes it will drop off the network.. until you reach extreme and change that. Then you might need to reboot the whole network to get everything talking again. If something goes wrong.. just pluck that one out of the mix and plug in ethernet.. reset and redo the setup. That is my preferred method anyway.. do everything in isolation one by one. By ethernet and then nothing goes wrong.
    2)  Who's the treasonous SOB who spilled the beans to you about the ICBM in my back yard?!?
    N.Korean hackers.
    [Edit] Whoops-- one more question:  I want to partition the TC's disk, but Disk Utility doesn't see it.  What do I need to do?
    You cannot partition a network disk. And apple provided no tools for it in the TC itself. You can pull the disk out and partition it but that voids your warranty. (although done with care who is to know).
    Look at Q3 here.
    http://pondini.org/TM/Time_Capsule.html
    Mixing TM and data on the TC is worth planning carefully. They don't necessarily sit happily together.

  • How can i make the text bigger?

    How can i make the text bigger?

    1. press "T" to bring up the text tool.
    2. click the text you want to edit
    3. highlight the text you want to change size with your cursur
    4. If it's not already up, press Command + T to bring up the text tool box and adjust the size under the character group. The value you want to change will have a "TT" next to it.
    If this doesn't help. More details will help us help you.

  • How can I make the edges of the JSC component curved?

    It is a very common practice to make the edges curved in web development. Curved edge looks attractive and professional. (for example see blog.com)
    How can I make the edges of the JSC component curved? For example, consider Textfield component, how to make the the sharp edges smooth and curved?
    Thank you very much.

    Follow the steps below implement rounded edges for tabs in a tabset component:
    1)Create 2 images: level1_selected.jp and level1_deselct.jpg to be used as the background for these tabs. Thse images can be easily craeted using windows paint software. Just ceate a rectangular image of size 200X30 and draw a rounded rectangle on it.
    2) Redefine the following styles in your application stylesheet(originally defined in css_master.css)
    .Tab1Div td.Tab1TblSelTd {
         background-color:#EDF5F8;width: 200px;height:40px;background-image:url(images/level1_selected.jpg)
    .Tab1Div td.Tab1TblSelTd {
         background-repeat:repeat-x;background-position:left bottom;border-bottom:none
    .Tab1Div td {
         background-color:#EFEBEF;width: 200px;height:40px;background-image:url(images/level1_deselect.jpg);border:none
    .Tab1Div td {
         background-repeat:repeat-x;background-position:bottom left
    a.Tab1Lnk:link, a.Tab1Lnk:visited {
         display:block;padding:8px 15px 0px;font-weight:bold;text-align:center
    Results: By doing this you'll have the selected and unselected tabs show up with rounded egdes and also the selected tab will look bigger than the unselected tas making it more prominent.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Send form data from Coldfusion to ASP

    I need to send form data from CF to ASP. I submit a CF page and validate it on my end with another CF page, which then needs to post the results to an asp page on another site. The post has to be sent via SSL and I don't need to and cannot receive an

  • NoClassDefFoundError: weblogic/t3/srvr/ListenThread

    Anyone else getting this exception upon startup of WebLogic 5.1? The WebLogic Server did not start up properly. Exception raised: java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: weblogic/t3/srvr/ListenThread java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: weblogic/t3/srvr/ListenThr

  • Book mark settings.........

    Hi all where do i set book marking for queries...? how to check whether bookmarks are working fine or not...?  Please let me know Regards swetha

  • Is part of iTunes store down? Purchased music not loading

    Been trying off and on for a couple of hours to download music off iCloud.  When I click on 'purchased' in iTunes I get the loading spinner but it never finishes. Anyone else? The store itself seems to be okay.  Just not this feature.

  • [svn] 4316: Merge to BlazeDS trunk.

    Revision: 4316 Author: [email protected] Date: 2008-12-15 15:59:05 -0800 (Mon, 15 Dec 2008) Log Message: Merge to BlazeDS trunk. Fix for missing fault events at connect time for MessageAgents with needsConfig flags set true before connecting. QA: Rel