Canvas color doesn't match QT output - help!

I noticed today that my footage is appearing darker in the canvas window than it does when viewed in QuickTime. I did the following test:
1. Export a "Quicktime Movie", not self-contained, and opened that in QuickTime. Move to a specific frame for comparison.
2. Move to the same frame in the FCE canvas.
The image in the canvas looks markedly darker - to the point that I would make color corrections on it...but looking at the QT version, it seems correction is not necessary. They're quite different.
I've uploaded a screenshot of both windows next to each other here, which makes the difference obvious:
http://idisk.mac.com/gr2020-Public/canvas-qt.png
I see the same thing when exporting and compressing with QT...I first noticed the problem when making a video for the web.
Can someone please help me figure out what's going on?

I did some more research, and I think I figured out what's going on.
I think FCE (and FCP from what I'm reading) assumes your monitor is calibrated to a gamma of 1.8, and it "darkens" the images in the canvas to make them appear as they would on a gamma 2.2 display or a video monitor (which are apparently natively close to 2.2).
However, if your screen is calibrated to gamma 2.2 (most photo editing workstations are), then FCE still "darkens" everything in the canvas (it's assuming it's gamma 1.8), and in the process totally screws things up.
When videos are exported, this adjustment doesn't occur, so the video looks as it should. It's only inside the canvas that things are artificially adjusted, and everything gets messed up.
Sigh.
Assuming this is in fact what's happening, anyone have ideas how to fix this? It's totally annoying; my screen is calibrated very specifically for my still photography work, and I'd hate to have to have a totally separate display profile just work working within FCE, and then switch back to the regular one when viewing exported videos...

Similar Messages

  • Canvas brightness doesn't match FCP output files

    After spending hundreds of hours trying to color correct in the FCP canvas only to create output files (MPEG2 for DVDs and MOV files for online stuff) which are either too dark or too light, too saturated or too bland, I finally realized that what I'm seeing in my FCP canvas window does not match - at all - the final, compressed file when I export using Compressor to an avi, an mpeg, or a Quicktime MOV file.
    I invested in a good Gretamacbeth screen calibration device (Eye-One Display 2) only to find that the problem is not my monitor or its calibration, but the software.
    I can output to a Quicktime file and play the same clip, side-by-side, with the identical clip in FCP, as viewed through the canvas, on the same monitor. Invariably the FCP canvas image is darker, has higher contrast, and shows much richer color saturation. The Quicktime movie is too bright, and too washed-out looking in the colors compared with the FCP canvas. And when I output to an mpeg2 and author a DVD using DVD Studio Pro, and then pop the completed DVD into my Mac (or TV/DVD player) and view it, it always turns out much brighter and more washed out than what my FCP canvas had led me to believe.
    To try to compensate for this, I manually brightened my monitor somewhat and re-edited my footage, trying to boost luma and chroma levels as much as I could without exceeding broadcast standard limits, only to find that now some of the resulting DVD was oversaturated and too dark. I REALLY need an accurate canvas on which to edit; it's impossible to create anything worthwhile if I have nothing else to do than to simply guess how every clip is going to look and pray that the final result isn't too far off.
    Has anyone else encountered this? It's a real problem for me. I'm using FCP 5.04 on a dual-processor G5 with 5 GB of RAM and a dual-monitor setup - an Apple 17" monitor and an Apple 23" cinematic display.
    Any input or ideas would be GREATLY appreciated. Thanks in advance for your help!
    Powermac G5   Mac OS X (10.4.3)  

    Thanks to both of you, Steve and Shane, for your quick replies.
    I always render as I go, and I disabled overlays in the canvas long ago. And I realize that calibration is a key issue, especially for web files, and that the view produced in the FCP canvas isn't a full-resolution representation of the underlying digital file.
    But when I'm editing my actors' faces and adjusting their colors to get just the right amount of pink rosiness in their cheeks, and carefully setting the right light levels in the background, and then I output my file to any format and view the resulting file on the SAME CRT on which I did my editing, suddenly their faces have lost all their color, and the background is too light and washed out, even though I'm viewing the thing on the same screen I used to edit it.
    So no matter how my monitor is calibrated, I believe that any high-quality output file that FCP creates should resemble, at least in terms of color and brightness levels, the image I edited in the canvas moments earlier, at least if viewed on the same screen. I realize that resolution will vary and one might be more blurry or whatever; that's not the problem.
    In fact, if I use FCP to create a Quicktime file and an mpeg-2 for a DVD and then view that file on any of my PC monitors and on my television via my DVD player, it looks remarkably consistent. In other words, the output file looks fairly close, in terms of chroma and luma, when viewed either on my Mac (with the Quicktime player), my PC, or even my TV (viewed as a DVD). The only thing that looks different is if I compare this file to the file I edited, as seen on the FCP canvas, where the colors look much richer and the contrast is a lot darker. Even when viewing both files on the same computer screen, one in FCP and the other in Quicktime, the FCP one looks substantially different. Have others run into a similar problem, or is it just me? I can't believe professional editors have to resort to always guessing whether what they see in the canvas will look anything like their final FCP output, at least if they're viewing it on the same monitor.
    So I guess I'm really wondering whether there's some way to independently adjust the visible chroma and luma levels in the canvas itself, to configure them properly, so that what I see when I'm editing will more closely match the files I generate when I'm done, when viewing them both on the same screen.
    Thanks again for any light (or contrast!) you can shine on this problem.

  • Canvas brightness doesn't match FCP output files/Matches TIF Still Files!!

    Hi, the first part of this problem was addressed earlier in the forum-the fact that the Canvas shows the clips as much much darker and way more saturated than when viewed on an external monitor, or when exported to DVD Studio Pro and burned on dvd.
    The second part is that when I export an image from the clip in Final Cut using Quicktime Conversion to Still Image and open up the still in Preview or Photoshop or email it to another computer IT MATCHES the much darker and more saturated canvas. How is this possible? How can I get it to match the video output files?
    Any advice asap would be really really appreciated.

    You need to understand monitoring... first, a computer's display isn't set up for use as a TV set or video monitor. They don't exhibit the same response color wise to gammas. So it makes perfect sense that viewing a still will match what you saw in the canvas. If you were to look at that still externally on a video monitor, you'd see it also matches the video it came from on that same monitor. Colors aren't shifting, the differences in the displays of that same file is what's causing your consternation.
    Always color correct for the medium you wish to exhibit in... so if TV, then correct to an external video monitor which is properly set up. If to the web, then you color correct using computer displays (also properly set up) To further the problem, the gamma responses from a PC's display don't match those of a Mac's display. The PC will see things darker in general... so that too has to be taken into account when judging color, contrast and brightness...
    Jerry

  • [help] images colors doesn't match

    Hello, when I place an image inside a new document the colors doesn't match with original.
    For sample I save in tiff format from photoshop a rich black (70% 50% 30% 100%) when I place inside illustrator I get (86,01% 84,97% 78,95% 100%).
    The color profile are syncronized and I use Europe General Purpose 2 (CMYK Coated FOGRA27 ISO12647-2:2004)

    How do you know what values the bitmap image has in Illustrator? Did you pick up the color with the Color Picker? It's possible this originally picked up the value in RGB, and that got converted.
    Does Illustrator have a CMYK separation preview such as InDesign, where you can measure the original TIFF values? If not, you can also save as PDF and examine that in Acrobat, using the Output Preview.

  • PSE 7 bright vivid colors, doesn't match prints

    I tried searching for a thread to answer this question but I could not find something that really helped specifically.
    Use PSE7 to edit my jpg's and when I'm happy with the results then go to print, my prints do not match what I created on screen.  The colors are much darker, the rich greens in my landscapes are dull with a dark tint..overall, quite disappointing.
    I use a Spyder 3 pro to calibrate my monitor and use that profile as the printing profile for PSE7.  I shoot a Canon 40d in sRGB.  My monitor and printer (Canon MP600) are set to use the profile created by the Spyder 3 Pro software.
    When I use Canon Digital Photo Pro to edit raw images, the colors on screen are consistent with what I get printed on my Canon MP600.  The main difference here is that Canon DPP allows you to select the profile for image display and for printing.
    Does PSE7 allow you to somehow select from your list of available profiles what color profile to be used for display?  Out of the color management options, I've tried to use the "Optimize for display" and "Optimize for printing" options..."no color management" and "let me choose.." still no difference in the prints vs. the screen.
    If I take a file that I printed in Canon DPP, where the colors on screen match what is printed, and then open that same file in PSE7, the colors on screen are much different...they are much brighter and vivid than what I see in Canon DPP.
    All I can do in Canon DPP is edit raw files and do the basic color editing...Obviously, PSE7 has many more features and plugins that are useful so I'd like to work in that program and print from there.
    If I do all my editing of a file in PSE7 until I'm happy, my prints still won't match what I see in PSE7.  If I take that file and open it in Canon DPP, the colors are different, but they match what came out of the printer, albeit...darker and not vivid

    Thanks..that did the trick.  I feel like a big dummy now
    I got the explanation of the printer/paper profiles for my printer on the Canon website.
    The prints are MUCH closer...the only difference I can tell now is eliminated when I use a good light to view my prints, when held up to a good light or sunlight, the prints are very true to what I see on the screen.
    thanks

  • Color profile doesn't match print output

    Why do my prints come out much darker than they appear on the monitor? I edit in Adobe 5 and print from Lightroom 3  with monitor calibration (Spyder software), and ICC profiles for my Epson paper, printed on my Epson printer. 

    There could be a few reasons why your prints don't match your monitor:
    1. The profile you're using for your printer may be a generic one and not one made specifically for your printer. Just like any two TV's, even two identical TV's can represent color differently.
    2. Your monitor may be beyond its peak. Most monitors are reliable for about three years in regards to being able to represent critical color. But, the begin to degrade from day 1, just like humans.
    3. Have you confirmed your software and computer are actually using the latest monitor profile?
    4. May be that your monitor profile was made incorrectly by accident? Try making a new one.

  • Viewsonic monitor color doesn't match MacAir

    I'm trying to set up the sRGB color space on my ViewSonic monitor to match the sRGB color space on my MacAir, but it's just not working. The brightness on the VS monitor dims when I select sRGB and the Brightness Adjust option grays out so I can select it to increase it. The colors are barely close - what looks reddish brown on my Air looks more yellow-brown on the VS.
    I'm a professional photographer. I need for these colors to be accurate. Suggestions?
    Thanks very much,
    Roxyanne Young

    Hello Roxyanne,
    The sRGB option on the monitor is a standard default color pallet for the internet. You can calibrate your monitor by going to System Preferences on your MacBook Air.
    Should you need further assistance please call us toll free (U.S.) at 1-800-688-6688. A customer service agent will gladly support you.
    Thank you,
    ViewSonic Corp.

  • Same color doesn't match across documents

    I have a document set up to cmyk preview and proof setup of working cymk us web coated (swop) v2.  In this document I'm using a pantone solid coated reflex blue c.  If I copy the object with that color to a new document the color drastically changes even though it's the same reflex blue.  Notice in the image below, the blue is much richer.  I've had three other people with illustrator/print background look at this and we've compared every setting we can think of but can't figure out why it's doing this.  Any one have an idea?  We need to match the blue on the right in the image below but for the life of us we can't.  It always comes out somewhere between the two blues shown.  Thanks.

    Why is your color mode set to "CMYK" and not "Book Color"?
    Drag the reflex blue swatch from the Pantone palette to the swatches palette and choose merge colors.
    If you ever tweak a color, which is perfectly fine for getting betting color proofs out of a color proofer, always give it a differentt name (eg: PANTONE Reflex Blue C(cmyk))

  • Photoshop color doesn't match other CS applications.

    I'm going mental. I've gone thru everything I can think of. My color settings are synchronized across all CS applications. I'm trying to see document both as a soft proof and not. Neither mode improves the color differences I'm seeing on screen. Photoshop displays color TOTALLY differently from all other CS applications: Bridge, InDesign, Illustrator & Acrobat.
    In the image below, Indesign is on the left. Photoshop is on the right. Image appears in Bridge, Acrobat and Illustrator just like InDesign. What the heck? Can anyone help? I'm going CRAZY!
    Color settings:

    i can see how those color settings can cause anyone mental stress
    why are you converting everything to Adobe RGB
    why are you using Adobe RGB as your Photoshop default working space
    are you embedding profiles in your saved documents
    what profile are you "soft proofing"
    do you know what happens to your color if you open an untagged sRGB document in Photoshop and your web browser (for example)
    the short answer is you have some ICC profile and settings issues you need to understand -- how Photoshop and color managed apps react to embedded profiles and untagged documents versus how they react in unmanaged apps
    i also suspect you have at least monitor issue going on -- what monitor are you using -- how did you 'calibrate' it
    you may want to try and slug through this
    www.gballard.net/psd/assignconvert.html#tutorial

  • Dreamweaver CSS div background color doesn't match .png menu button color on PC

    Hello,
    I created a menu with buttons the same background color (CSS) as the background color on my CSS template. However, for some reason, the colors don't look the same on mac and a pc. The background on the menu buttons that I created (.png) match the css template div background on a mac. But, when the site displays on a pc, the menu background color from the css template is darker than the .png background color, even though the color code is the exact same. On a mac, the .png background color matches the css div template color exactly. Anyone know what is going on or how to fix?
    I appreciate any assistance!

    Are both monitors calibrated?
    http://www.wikihow.com/Calibrate-Your-Monitor
    Windows renders images a tad darker.  To compensate, use Gamma Correction in Photoshop.
    http://www.photoshopsupport.com/tutorials/cb/gamma.html
    Nancy O.
    Alt-Web Design & Publishing
    Web | Graphics | Print | Media  Specialists 
    http://alt-web.com/
    http://twitter.com/altweb

  • My apple monitors color doesn't match

    I recently bought a second hand 20" (clear base) display and am using the dvi to adc adapter,
    when I got both up and running the color is different between the two.
    is there a way to control or sync the two?
    this is driving me crazy, please help.
    thanks

    resolved

  • Print color doesn't match monitor

    I have a brand new iMac, love how my photos look on screen and don't understand why the colors in prints ordered through Apple online don't match. They look fine on the screen then come back too dark or too red.

    There's a similar discussion going on here
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2326897&tstart=0
    Regards
    TD

  • Viewer and browser color doesn't match on screen

    curious about what is going on.
    Attached is a link to a screen grab.
    The left side is the viewer in apple. The center is the browser in apple. The far right is the same image uploaded into the zenfolio website.
    What am I doing wrong?
    <a href="http://s1270.photobucket.com/albums/jj603/np_kitchen/test%20images/?action=view& current=Screenshot2012-09-11at55852PM.png" target="_blank"><img src="http://i1270.photobucket.com/albums/jj603/np_kitchen/test%20images/Screenshot201 2-09-11at55852PM.png" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

    I don't know the exact answer, but when people have asked about problems like these on Adobe's own Photoshop forums, it is often related to the graphics card driver. You can try experimenting to see if it changes if you turn off OpenGL in the Photoshop preferences. If it does behave differently then, it could be a graphics driver issue. That's all I know...for more, you might ask on Adobe's forum.

  • With color management, color picker current color does not match canvas color

    What gives here with color picker in CS3?
    RGB doc
    using color management/profiles
    View>>proof color using my Epson RGB printer profile
    create box
    double click fill box in palette box to view color picker
    pick color from spectrum area
    close color picker
    want to change color of box
    double click fill box to view color picker
    NOW current color does not match color on canvas, subtle but vexing color shift. So how can I use current color to pick a new color on the canvas is always different.
    here's an in illustration of the problem:
    http://docs.google.com/Presentation?id=dfv8h494_18gwqbsjg5

    Rob, here's screenshot of Acrobats Output Preview Object Inspector. You can download my PDF here - //www.fileswap.com/dl/Q1CzzOzEqt/
    I'm not sure if CM was assigned to document when created or  afterwards. In Color Settings preferences is stated Fogra 39 (if it matters - document was meanwhile saved and opened...). Are there other options to assign workspace to exsisting document?
    Peter, this is not the case. Placed image has embeded same color profile as is working space of document in ID. I tried the same with sRGB image placed in same ID document and compared it to PS but color shift (greenish) is present - it looks exactly the same.
    Guys, I can't tell you how happy I am to have you help me with this terrible and nerve-wracking problem.

  • Itunes will no longer accept any of my credit cards.  Says security code doesn't match with any card I use.  I have inputted new card info in the apple store area and it still says the same thing in itunes.  Customer service is no help at all.

    Itunes will no longer accept any of my credit cards.  It says vcode doesn't match when it does.  Customer service is no help.  I have re-inputted the info in the account section of the apple store and in itunes--still says vcode doesn't match.

    Itunes will no longer accept any of my credit cards.  It says vcode doesn't match when it does.  Customer service is no help.  I have re-inputted the info in the account section of the apple store and in itunes--still says vcode doesn't match.

Maybe you are looking for