Combining 16:9, 24p and standard NTSC in FCE

Please forgive the newbie ignorance, but I seem to have gotten myself into a severe predicament with no practical way out. Here's the situation:
In a rush of naive enthusiasm, a desire to NOT indulge my usual tendency toward perfectionistic procrastination paralysis, encouragement by others—including experienced advisors, albeit one with Windows/Avid-only experience and the other a successful, working director/screenplay writer with a minimal understanding of technical issues—and finally, getting snowed by glowing sales brochures with hidden fine print that glossed over critical compatibility issues, I borrowed a s-load of money and launched my documentary by jumping out of a plane with the following parachute:
1) Essential outdoor footage (rushed to take advantage of good summer weather) shot at 24p in true 16:9 on a borrowed Canon XL2.
2) Equally essential indoor footage (and pretty much all remaining future footage) shot in standard NTSC (29.97i? 4:3) on my Canon GL2.
3) An aging dual 500 G4 that's been expensively brought up to minimal Final Cut Express standards through a series of hundred bucks here, several hundred bucks there steps. (I probably could've bought a new Mac for what I've spent on techno-duct tape for the old!)
4) A desperate hope that I might find some way to get 1-3 to work together before I hit a rapidly enlarging terra firma!
Lest you think I'm totally nuts, let me say in my defense that I have been experimenting with post-production procedures along the way—first with iMovie until it became obvious it wouldn't do the effects I wanted and now with FCE, which will handle the minimal fancy-schmancy stuff my doc needs. But now based on my fitfully improving understanding of the technical constraints, I believe I've been misled by "false" iMovie and FCE WYSIWYG images that implied I could meld my XL2 and GL2 footage without problem.
To be more specific, I was able to successfully capture the XL2 footage in iMovie through my GL2, or at least I thought I was. I assumed the data, being digital and all, would capture correctly regardless of camera. When I could see it squished horizontally in 4:3 on my monitor, I assumed it had transferred correctly and could then be manipulated however I wanted. After I got FCE, I seemed to be able to capture the two kinds of footage and even put them together (of course, with corresponding letter- and pillar-boxing), but am now thinking I've got a mess underneath what I see on screen.
All of which is to ask, Is there any practical way to solve my problem? My piggy bank is down to its last few pennies, and short of winning the lottery, my immediate possibility of getting more cash is nil. My quixotic goal is to turn this mess into a real (24p, 16:9) movie. (If I can get them combined, I plan to use the discrepancy in quality between the two kinds of footage as an "intentional" effect).
Three other questions: After reading another discussion thread, I got JES Deinterlacer to see if it could successfully convert my NTSC to widescreen 24p. The small clip I used was glacially slow to convert, which is frustrating but could be an acceptable workaround except that it appears the result is severely degraded (which makes sense since the file size is 10% of the original). My original thought was to crop the top and bottom of the 4:3 to fit it in with the 16:9 (instead of stretch it) and have the resulting increasing contrast in resolution be part of the inside/outside "effect." Can JES, or something else, solve my conversion problem? If so, will FCE be able to handle the result?
Second thing is one of my original XL2 tapes was lost so I took my iMovie version and put it back on tape through my GL2. Has this been degraded from the original? What is happening to the 24p, 16:9 data as it goes back and forth from camera to hard drive through iMovie and FCE.
Third is I found several threads that warn specifically against capturing from a Canon camera to a firewire hard drive. I seem to have had no problem so far, but is there something corrupt underneath that I can't see?
Hoping this long post is not too annoying (maybe my mistakes can help others avoid similar ones?) and that there's a miracle out there that'll keep me from crashing and burning in a fireball
Many thanks, Chris
G4 Dual 500   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

"There is not quality degradation for digital content upon printing to tape or copy, even from a iMovie version. DV is a already compressed digital material, edited in the compressed format, so you can go far beyond 20 generations of copy without significant degradation.
"It's not exactly the same thing with HDV (because there is a conversion by Apple Intermediate Codec at each capture/print process)."
Thanks, Michel. I guess I'm still confused about the gist of the capture process, which seems to be what led me into this mess in the first place. I understand that the raw data is digital and that it won't degrade if it's copied, which is what I thought capturing was in essence. But if DV capture is standardized, what—if it's not some kind of codec-translation filter—makes the resulting media files different depending upon which application (and camera?) is used. (I know cameras can record differently—thus my XL2/GL2 discrepancy—but do they also behave differently in the capture process?)
The other explanation I can think of for the differences in capturing between iMovie, FCE, and FCP is that Apple has simply restricted the aspect ratios and frame rates each app handles as part of the justification for differing prices. I had thought they could each accept the same raw footage but what they did with it afterwards was increasingly sophisticated and therefore costly.
Live and spend lots of money to learn!

Similar Messages

  • IDVD and standard (NTSC) television resolution...

    If I understand correctly, television has 525 horizontal scan lines (NTSC), but I cannot find any options in any video conversion apps that offer a resolution option of 525x?.
    What is the best resolution to choose when converting DVD files (which may be widescreen) to play on a standard television set with no black bars above, below or on the sides?
    Also, what DVD file format should I choose to be safe as far as everyone being able to use it? If someone has a DVD console that is 9 years old, what is the safest file format to use.
    And lastly, iDVD says it can use a dual-layer disc for up to 7.7GB of space. All my dual-layer blank DVD discs say they can hold up to 8.5GB.
    Why the huge discrepancy?
    Any help is appreciated.
    Thanx.
    Message was edited by: Michael Donahue3

    Hello Michael,
    *If I understand correctly, television has 525 horizontal scan lines (NTSC), but I cannot find any options in any video conversion apps that offer a resolution option of 525x?.*
    The reason for this is that 525 scan line standard refers to analog video. See this guide for further confusion: http://lipas.uwasa.fi/~f76998/video/conversion/
    The standard for NTSC digital video (DV) is 720x480
    *What is the best resolution to choose when converting DVD files (which may be widescreen) to play on a standard television set with no black bars above, below or on the sides?*
    The resolution should be that of the source (in this case the DVD) ... but you might run into trouble here because of widescreen issues as widescreen has the same resolution but a different pixel aspect ratio.
    *Also, what DVD file format should I choose to be safe as far as everyone being able to use it? If someone has a DVD console that is 9 years old, what is the safest file format to use.*
    The video format for a DVD is given: It is multiplexed MPEG-2 (VOB files). iDVD will output just that.
    *And lastly, iDVD says it can use a dual-layer disc for up to 7.7GB of space. All my dual-layer blank DVD discs say they can hold up to 8.5GB*
    Although most manufacturers of hard disks and Flash disks define 1 gigabyte as 1,000,000,000 bytes, the computer operating systems used by most users usually calculate a gigabyte by dividing the bytes (whether it is disk capacity, file size, or system RAM) by 1,073,741,824. This distinction is a cause of confusion, as a hard disk with a manufacturer rated capacity of 400 gigabytes may have its capacity reported by the operating system as only 372 GB, depending on the type of report.
    hope this helps
    mish

  • How to retain numerical order (Of file names) when combining files in Acrobat (9) Standard

    How to retain numerical order (Of file names) when combining files in Acrobat (9) Standard, please see the attached screenshot for a clearer explanation.
    I understand that if we prefix all files with leading zero's this will probably resolve the issue but I just wondered if anyone new the answer. The ironic situation is that version 6 has no problem.
    I have spent over an hour with techincal support who were unable to provide me with an answer

    It is not clear how you are trying to do the order. Have you tried to select a set of files and then use the arrow buttons to move them in the list? If you select the heading, that will typically reorder the files by that heading and undo everything you had done before.
    You should be able to select groups of files and move them up and down in the list. All of those options appear on your view, so what is the real question?

  • SDK support in Pro and Standard editions.

    Hi,
    I want to convert PDF file into DOCX programatically. I have written the code using Acrobat SDK and tried with Acrobat X Pro trial version, and it works fine. I just want to confirm whether Acrobat X Standard edition supports exporting PDF to DOCX via SDK? and whether my code will work in Standard edition.
    Also, want to know whether there are any differences between Pro and Standard editions in terms of SDK support.
    With regards,
    Pinakin Purandare

    Hi,
    Apologies for missing the code.
    Below is the code:
                AcroPDDoc pdDocument = new AcroPDDocClass();
                if (pdDocument != null)
                    try
                        // Open PDF file.
                        result = pdDocument.Open(location);
                        if (result)
                            // If PDF file is opened then get the docx file name.
                            string docxFileName = string.Concat(Path.GetFileNameWithoutExtension(location), ".docx");
                            docxFileName = Path.Combine(Path.GetFullPath(tempPath), docxFileName);
                            try
                                object jsObject = pdDocument.GetJSObject();
                                Type type = jsObject.GetType();
                                type.InvokeMember("saveAs", BindingFlags.InvokeMethod, null, jsObject,
                                    new object[] { docxFileName, "com.adobe.acrobat.docx" });
                            finally
                                pdDocument.Close();
                                pdDocument = null;
                    finally
                        pdDocument = null;
    I have gone through the feature list of Standard edition on Acrobat site and it mentions that it has feature of exporting it to Word. But since I was not able to find trial version of standard version, I am not able to test the code.
    I want to make the decision on buying the edition based on the export to DOCX feature programatically. Hence wanted to confirm.
    With regards,
    Pinakin Purandare

  • Incorrect combinations for personnel area and personnel subare

    Hi all,
    we are getting incorrect combinations for personnel area and personnel subarea in the Target and as well in report.
    we are using standard datasources 0PERS_AREA_TEXT and 0PERS_SAREA_TEXT, we are extracting only masterdata text from ECC, Not maintaining Attibute and Hierarchy for personnel area and personnel subarea.
    we created (Actions overview) report on top of standard DSO 0PA_DS12 extracted from data source 0HR_PA_1,
    Actually some of employees are changed on xxxx.xx.xx date from one personnel area to another personnel area with respective subarea's, but here employee personnel area are coming correctly but not for subarea.
    what i need to do now?
    can any one help out in this..
    Thanks in advance.
    Thanks,
    Sri

    Hi,
    In this context we will have two senarios.
    1. Displaying the Personal Area and Personal Sub Area from Transactional data.
    2. Displaying from Master Data.
    If you choose Scenario 1 then, Personal Area and Personal Sub Area will be shown as per ECC entry. But in second scenario, If one Personal area or Personal Sub Area changed over a period of time that will effect the historical data also.
    For Example if your Personal Sub Area changed on Apr 1, 2011.
    Scenario 1: Report will be as per ECC Data ( from Apr 1, 2011 onwards it will show new Personal Sub Area).
    Scenario 2: Report will show new Personal Sub Area of Personal Area for entire data.
    Hope this will help you.
    Regards,
    Chenna.

  • How to create stacked bar and standard bar on same graph

    Can OBIEE can both Stacked and Standard bar graph on the same analysis by using Line-Bar graph type? For example, I have four measure: Target revenue, Revenue, Billed Quantity, and Target Quantity. I would like to create an analysis that includes all these four measure. On the same graph, I would like to use Stacked subtype for Target revenue and Revenue, use standard subtype for Billed quantity and use line for Target quantity. I tried, but could not find any way to put stacked subtype and standard subtype on the same graph. Do you know if this feature is available from OBIEE?

    I tried to do this and was a bit successful. I used the paint catalog. Created a a request with 6 columns assuming units and dollars be stacked and Year ago units to be a line:
    Brand Units Dollars 0 Year_Ago_units 1
    Added a new request (Combined with similar request and selected paint subject area): Now in this request my columns are:
    Brand 0 0 Year_Ago_Dollars Year_Ago_units 2
    Assuming Year_Ago_Dollars be standard in your case.
    Created a chart view with brand and 1 on x axis and Units, Dollars, Year_Ago_Dollars on y axis and line as Year_Ago_units.
    Now able to see what I am expecting. May be you need to tweak a bit more according to your requirement.
    Let me know if this is of any help!
    Thanks.
    Edited by: Venkata on Sep 30, 2010 12:11 PM

  • Dual 17'' Displays and an NTSC Monitor for Video Editing

    I am trying to hook up two 17'' apple monitors and an NTSC television monitor for video editing, but all I have on the back of my G5 tower is one ADC plug and one DVI plug. Any advice on how to make this work would be greatly appreciated.

    If you run in anything other than the LCD's native resolution your graphics card will be resampling the image. This inevitably distorts the image as pixels must be discarded to create the display. Typically this softens the image.
    Cheers,
    Neale
    Insanity is hereditary, you get it from your children

  • Want to see combination of Purchase Order and A/P report at material level

    Hello,
    Anyone familiar with an InfoProvider that will show a combination of Purchase Order and A/P data combined?
    I'm specifically looking for a source that includes the PO information at the <b>Vendor / Material</b> level with order value and quantity at the time the PO was created AND accounts payable data at the <b>Vendor / Materia</b>l level with the invoiced amount and quantity (which may vary for the PO amounts).<b></b>
    Thank you,
    Jim

    Hi
    Have you seen all of the follwoing datasources......
    http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw04/helpdata/en/df/fbb0d62f3a794d98d23609d17e1610/frameset.htm
    Hope this helps
    Regards
    N Ganesh

  • How do you combine mutable iphoto libraries and clean up duplicates

    how do you combine multiple iphoto libraries and clean up duplicates

    If not the only answer is the paid version of iPhoto Library Manager -http://www.fatcatsoftware.com/iplm/ - and maybe duplicate annihaliator -http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/18748/duplicate-annihilator
    You must have IPLM as stated - you may also need DA depending on how thing go with the merge
    LN

  • I'm looking for some help connecting linksys IP Cameras to my home network to monitor my property when I'm travelling. I used to do this with linksys WAPS, but since I've discarded all my old linksys networking and standardized on airport, I can't get the

    I'm looking for some help connecting linksys IP Cameras to my home network to monitor my property when I'm travelling.  I used to do this with linksys WAPS, but since I've discarded all my old linksys networking and standardized on airport, I can't get these things working.  I know that I have to identify my camera through the DHCP table and set up port forwarding and there is the problem. 
    My network consists of 4  base stations set up in a roaming network - same network name and passwords.  I need to do it this way so I don't have to switch network when I move from one side of the house to the other, go to the cabana, or my shop in the barn.  The network works pretty well since I went to a roaming set up.  Good performance, yata, yata, yata.
    However, the roaming network requires the AEBS's to be set up in bridge mode, rather than sharing an ip address.  When the AEBS is set to  bridge mode, you don't see a DCHP table or have the ability to identify your IP Cam through the AEBS - and hence, no port forwarding. 
    I am able to identify and set up my Linksys IP Cam by locating the ip address on my FIOS router, even though, it's plugged into an AEBS.  I set it up, see the video, remove the ethernet cable from the IP Cam, restart - and I can't get to it from an AEBS.  In researching this, it appears, I should be setting up the AEBS to "share an IP Address", going to the DHCP table and identifying the camera's IP address and setting up port forwarding.  However, you don't see any of the DHCP or port forwarding options in Airport Network Utility when configuring in bridge mode. 
    I'm hoping I'm missing something here and that the solution isn't to set it up at the FIOS router level, but I'm beginning to think that's my only hope.  What concerns me there is that I should be able to see the IP cam on the network without port forwarding since I'm not coming from outside, and I can't even do this unless it's connected hard wire.
    I'd appreciate any insight into this that anyone might have.  I've hit the wall with what I know.
    Thanks.

    In a roaming network, your "main" router is the device that would require port mapping/forwarding to be configured in order to access the IP camera from the Internet. This router is also the one that would be provide the private IP address for the camera which you will want to be a static one.
    So as you described your network, the IP cameras should be getting an IP address or you assigned it a static one and this is the address that you would enter in the Private IP address (or equivalent depending on the router used) field when setting up port mapping.
    If you are not able to access this camera from the local network, then this should be troubleshot first.

  • I would like to know how i can create a bell graph with out using sub VIs, the data that i created consists in 500 readings with values of 0 to 100, i calculated the mean value and standard diviation. I hope some one can help me

    I would like to know how i can create a bell graph with out using sub VIs, the data that i created consists in 500 readings with values of 0 to 100, i calculated the mean value and standard diviation. I hope some one can help me

    Here's a quick example I threw together that generates a sort-of-bell-curve shaped data distribution, then performs the binning and plotting.
    -Kevin P.
    Message Edited by Kevin Price on 12-01-2006 02:42 PM
    Attachments:
    Binning example.vi ‏51 KB
    Binning example.png ‏12 KB

  • Sapscript and Standard Text - Polish Characters not printing

    Hi,
    I have created an English Sapscript and translated it to Polish via transaction SE76.
    Changing my PC Region and Language settings to Polish allowed me to enter Polish Characters into Hardcoded text in the Sapscript and Standard Text via s010.
    I have two problems:
    1) With my PC Region and Language settings set to Polish, when I create my sapscript output some of the polish characters that I have entered via SE76 and SO10 do not appear and are replaced by others e.g.
    ę is dispalyed as ê
    ć is displayed as æ
    ń is displazed as #
    2) I have a business requirement to be in England Logged with PC Region and Language set to English but to print a sapscript output in Polish. Is this possible.
    We are currently on non unicode SAP system.
    Please can anyone advise.
    Regards

    Hello,
    SAP discourages mixed code page or MDMP systems and with good reason. If there is any possibility of you upgrading to a Unicode system in the near future you should try to wait for it. Supporting multiple languages in Unicode is easy, in MDMP it can be quite tricky. And MDMP makes the move to Unicode more difficult.
    That said, your BASIS team can enable Polish and you can print in Polish while your PC is set for English. The SAPScript/Form must be in Polish or using an INCLUDE that is LANGUAGE 'PL' to let SAP know which code page to use when printing.
    Seriously, look at moving to Unicode, you need to do it eventually anyways.
    Michael

  • Choice between UPK in-application help and standard EBS help

    Hi,
    We are on a EBS 11.5.10 project, implementing UPK.
    We got UPK in-application help working; changed custom.pll, set the profile option, everything fine.
    Now we would like the users to have the choice between UPK help (default) and standard EBS help.
    Therefore we opened the In-Application Support Player Configuration, and created a new Tab:
    Type: Oracle E-Business Suite help
    Tab Text: EBS help
    URL: ?
    Whatever we put in the URL, it won’t display the standard EBS context sensitive help. We can see the ‘EBS help’ tab when selecting ‘window help’ in the application but the page is blank or shows an error message.
    Do you have any tips on how to get this working?
    Thanks,
    Abe de Beer
    EBS Financials consultant
    Oracle Belgium

    Hi,
    I have the exact same requirtment, Could you please give the step what you have done so that it would be helpfull. Also after publishing the content on the i am not seeing the "Application Option" i am seeing the smart help. do we need to configure on "Application Option" or on smart help. Where ever is see the doc it says configure oracle_gateway.html but i dont see oracle/hemi folder at all. do know if there is a set up that has to be done to get this option (UPK 11.10.1)
    Thanks

  • Customized and Standard Report

    How we can differentiate between Customize and Standard report???

    Hi Mike
    thats a tough one, the PO generation is a bit restrictive to say the least when it comes to customizing. It sounds like you have worked out how to get your own template in there to render the PO.
    On the data front, all I can think of is to customize and replace the seeded PO view with one that incorporates your extra data.
    Or, get into the page customization world and write your own extract and format concurrent program/procedure and then hook it onto the buttons where you want to launch it.
    You might have more luch, response wise from the EBS PO forum.
    Procurement : Procurement
    OAF: OA Framework
    Regards
    Tim

  • Customer Statement using SAP Script and Standard print program RFKORD10

    Using sap script and standard print program RFKORD10 I need to create a customer statement where the main window will be as follows
    Invoice #     InvoiceDate  CustomerPO  Debit Amt  Credit Amt  Total
        6        7           8               9               10               11
        6        7           8               9               10               11
                                     Totals               12             13              14
    Where company code BKORM-KUKRS
                Invoice              BSID-BELNR
                Invoice date      BSID-BLDAT
                Customer PO    VBKD-BSTKD
    For each document number selected there will be one to many records in VBRP.  For each invoice item in VBRP:
    u2022     Select BSTKD from VBKD where
    o     VBELN = VBRP-VGBEL and
    o     POSNR = VBRP-VGPOS
    u2022     If no hits then select BSTKD from VBKD where
    o     VBELN = VBRP-VGBEL
    If there is more than one PO per invoice then list them in the Customer PO field without repeating the other fields.PO shouldnu2019t come more than once per invoice.
                 Debit Amt         if BSEG-SHKZG = S then WRBTR ELSE 0
                 Credit Amt        if BSEG-SHKZG = H then WRBTR ELSE 0
                 Total                  Debit Amt u2013 Credit Amt
                  Totals                Subtotals
    It will be of great help if some one can help me with the script and the alterations required in standard print program RFKORD10
    Points will b rewarded for sure.
    Thanks.

    Hi Suganya,
    The custom form is getting displayed properly. But the requirement is to have it as an editable PDF. So the functional team is working on configuring the settings of PDF forms with customers email address.
    But for right now, i customized the standard form F140_ACC_STAT_01 and standard print program RFKORD10_PDF and did the configuration. It is getting displayed (I tested only with the transaction FBL5N - customer open line items..)
    Please let me know any further details on this.
    Poornima

Maybe you are looking for