Compressor NTSC/PAL workflow problems...

Hello there, before i begin i admit i have double-posted this on the FCP discussions too...
I'm writing this thread on behalf of a collegue of mine who is in a bit of a pickle and doesn't have internet/forum access... I've been on the phone to him all morning and i'm stumped...
He's just finished offline-editing a new feature film by Nicolas Roeg (walkabout, performance etc) and needs to churn out a DVD for viewing-update purposes, here is the tech info followed by the problem...
ok... so, in FCP he has the sequence and media at photoJPEG quality.
The editing timebase for the sequence is 24 fps.
The problem is that he wants to make a PAL DVD, but when he goes into Compressor, and applies the relevant settings, it always comes out as NTSC...?
I've been on the phone to him, and we've both had little test sequences open (only 10" long sequence) to talk through the work-flow, and as I'm not an advanced Compressor user, I can't find ANYTHING in preferences that sets the PAL/NTSC option.
I am under the impression that it is a FCP setting that actually maked the difference... ie, he is currently using photoJPEG, 24fps... which should (for a PAL DVD) be at 25fps, DV quality.
So how do we turn a photoJPEG 24fps sequence into a PAL 25fps file that can be squidged in Compressor to make a PAL DVD...
I hope I'm making sense... and HUGE thanks in advance for any help.
regards,
J

Perhaps do an intermediate first? The automatic settings in compressor are designed to choose which frame rate it thinks is best for you, so will make the wrong decision sometimes, in terms of your desired output. Try making a new mpeg2 setting, based on the preset for dvd, and change the frame rate to 25. It will then force it to pal 25. Or if it doesn't look great, change to a quicktime first with the same settings as your mate's sequence output, apart from the frame rate which you should force to 25. Then put this new movie back into compressor with the dvd setting.
Try it on a short clip first (a minute or so), then you won't waste time with something that isn't going to work.

Similar Messages

  • FCP-compressor-NTSC/PAL workflow problems...

    Hello there,
    I'm writing this thread on behalf of a collegue of mine who is in a bit of a pickle... I've been on the phone to him all morning and i'm stumped...
    He's just finished offline-editing a new feature film by Nicolas Roeg (walkabout, performance etc) and needs to churn out a DVD for viewing-update purposes, here is the tech info followed by the problem...
    ok... so, in FCP he has the sequence and media at photoJPEG quality.
    The editing timebase for the sequence is 24 fps.
    The problem is that he wants to make a PAL DVD, but when he goes into Compressor, and applies the relevant settings, it always comes out as NTSC...?
    I've been on the phone to him, and we've both had little test sequences open (only 10" long sequence) to talk through the work-flow, and as I'm not an advanced Compressor user, I can't find ANYTHING in preferences that sets the PAL/NTSC option.
    I am under the impression that it is a FCP setting that actually maked the difference... ie, he is currently using photoJPEG, 24fps... which should (for a PAL DVD) be at 25fps, DV quality.
    So how do we turn a photoJPEG 24fps sequence into a PAL 25fps file that can be squidged in Compressor to make a PAL DVD...
    I hope I'm making sense... and HUGE thanks in advance for any help.
    regards,
    J

    Perhaps do an intermediate first? The automatic settings in compressor are designed to choose which frame rate it thinks is best for you, so will make the wrong decision sometimes, in terms of your desired output. Try making a new mpeg2 setting, based on the preset for dvd, and change the frame rate to 25. It will then force it to pal 25. Or if it doesn't look great, change to a quicktime first with the same settings as your mate's sequence output, apart from the frame rate which you should force to 25. Then put this new movie back into compressor with the dvd setting.
    Try it on a short clip first (a minute or so), then you won't waste time with something that isn't going to work.

  • NTSC - PAL conversion problem

    I'm noticing a sort of faint horizontal line effect (like cardboard) on a lot of my conversions recently - can anybody explain what might be causing this?
    Compressor setting:
    Frame Controls: On
    Resize Filter: Best (Statistical prediction)
    Output Fields: Same as Source
    Deinterlace: Better (Motion adaptive)
    Adaptive Details - Checked
    Anti-Alias: 0
    Details Level: 0
    Rate Conversion: Better (Motion compensated)

    What is the delivery format of the finished movie?
    If it's going to DVD, 99% of PAL players will handle NTSC discs without issues.
    If it is for transfer to tape or you need to be sure of having a working DVD for the other 1% and you are doing this regularly, look at setting up a relationship with a post house that has a hardware based standards converter from Snell & Wilcox or Teranex. You will get great results in real time and a real expert operating the thing. Shop around for the best deal.
    Can you post a small clip of your "cardboard effect" somewhere?

  • NTSC - PAL colors conversion for betacam

    I need to get a video file that is NTSC (no compression 8bit) into PAL (no compression 8bit) to edit it in Final cut pro 5.1.4 and to put titles from Motion, to finally put it on a betacam tape. To be shure that the conversion (NTSC-PAL) is well done, I gave the NTSC file to a professionel conversion compagny. (I tried to do it myself with compressor and with the plug-in natress, but was not completly satisfied with the result).
    Now my problem is that the conversion company didn't compensate the modification of colors during the conversion. So now I have a file in pal (no compression 8bit) but the colors are lighter then the original file in NTSC.
    Can someone tip me on a way to modify the colors in Final cut pro of my file in PAL? I know how to use most of the filters, but I don't now much about doing it professionally. I was hoping that there could be a filter or a plugin that is made for my kind of problem, and I'm afraid of making a mistake because I never prepaired a file for a betacam tape before. Do I have to be carefull with the percentage of black or of white? Do I have to work in RGB or YUV?
    My second question is: the video PAL that was converted from NTSC has lines where there is quick movement when I look at it in Final cut pro or Quicktime. (the original NTSC file didn't have them) Should I use a filter to desinterlace it or will these lines disapear any way on the betcam tape? But I'm puting titles with Motion, so those titles don't have lines... How will they mix with the video?
    Thanks for your help
    Louie

    Hi mish,
    that is such a .. <searching correct english word> hillarious (?) idea, I give you a star for that ;-)))
    changing some flags on a ready-made dvd... wow! nice try...- but as Fred said, NTSC<<>>PAL conversions are no trivial tasks... you run into many problems, e.g. where do you get the additonal 5 frames per second you need for a transfer from PAL to NTSC? how to make the audio fit to these new pictures? and, I HAVE to do this silly joke: NTSC has a very different color concept (Never The Same Color) then PAL.. and for sure a different res...
    the name is irritating, but all mighty JES Deinterlacer is doing a fantastic job in converting video standards (ok, for a free software solution...) give that a try!

  • NTSC/PAL conversion question

    On my vacation I took a lot of video clips with my digital camera, and made them into a movie. However, some of the people I want to send a movie to are in Europe/Africa, and need to view it in PAL format. When I made the movie, I did it in NTSC, format. When I transfer to iDVD, do I need to change the format in iMovie or in iDVD? If I have to do it in iMovie, do I have to completely redo the whole thing? Or is there a way to just convert the present NTSC version to the PAL version? If so, how? (I solved by lack of hard drive space by getting a new hard drive placed in my Power Mac-now have 100GB).

    Hi dianeh,
    most many/all dvdplayers over here are able to
    read/playback NTSC dvds... no problem at all...
    second:
    export whole project as QT dv stream (1h = 13GB)...
    import that into JES Deinterlacer, for free
    http://www.xs4all.nl/~jeschot/home.html
    choose conversion NTSC>PAL
    another 13Gig per hour....
    import THAT into iDVD
    burn PAL version.......
    hope I could be helpful
    Tank you-I'll give it a try!!

  • Used to, but now can't detect a NTSC/PAL external monitor.

    This has come up in this forum as well as others in the past. Here is the syndrome:
    1. iBook (or other) is hooked up to an external NTSC/PAL monitor (in my case a Sumsung LCD TV) via the mini-VGA/S-Video out.
    2. Works perfectly for some period of time, days to years, as far as I've seen people post.
    3. Suddenly, iBook does not recognize the external NTSC monitor, and outputs crap onto the monitor.
    4. Detect display in the preferences only gives the native LCD (ibook) and a VGA external monitor.
    5. This doesn't go away, and no one has found a way to make it go away.
    Anyone figure out what the crap is going on with this? ANYONE HAVE A SOLUTION???

    Pullout the Battery of working phone - Insert it after a minute - Then Check
    Regards Eree - Follow me on Twitter - Facebook - Google+
    For More visit My Blog

  • HDV NTSC/PAL machine with HDMI output ???????????? To hire????

    I live in the UK where we have PAL...I have a big job to do that is NTSC HDV...
    What can I use to play out the tapes into my FC2.....
    I have a sony HC7 buts its PAL....I also have access to couple of bigger sony cameras that play Ntsc/Pal but dont have HDMI to access the full HDV to capture it using Pro Rez via my Blachmagic card/HDMI////....
    What is best to hire>>>>>

    Thanks for your reply....
    NO the material is in NTSC and that is what i want to keep it in for NTSC DVD release....Its just that the camera i have is PAL....
    And I need to find something with HDMI out to access the raw HDV format....
    Cheers
    ROB

  • Best (PAL) workflow to convert HDV interlaced to DV progressive?

    Question - What is the best (PAL) workflow to convert HDV interlaced to DV progressive?
    Software: Pr, En and Ae - all CS4.
    My Camera: (Sony Z1) shoots HDV 1080i.
    When capturing and editing, I keep everything HDV and interlaced.
    Premiere Pro:
    Capture HDV - mpeg 1440 x 1080 (1.3333)
    Sequence - 1440 x 1080 (1.3333) HD Anamorphic 1080 (1.333) Upper Field First - (HDV 1080i25 Preset)
    Once edit is complete, I dynamically link sequences into Encore.
    Question - Should I dynamically link to Encore or export sequence from Pro?
    If you aren't a fan of dynamically linking the sequences and believe exporting the sequences from Premiere Pro is the way to go, please advise of best export settings.  I assume during the export (from Pr) is when the converting from HDV interlaced to DV progressive takes place?
    At present, I dynamically link the sequences into Encore.  This means Encore handles the conversion to DV progressive.
    Question - What are the best (Encore) transcode settings to transcode HDV 1080i25 to DV progressive widescreen?
    I've tried numerous workflows but as yet, I've not been 100% happy with any of them.
    I'm finding it quite a challenge to take HDV 1080i and produce a good looking DVD i.e minimal artifacts and no interlaced jaggies.
    I used to downconvert to DV in-camera during the capture process, but I'm finding I'm getting much better results by editing in HDV and downconverting during post.  This is what my post is really all about i.e. finding the best workflow to do this.
    I would be very keen to hear of how others are shooting and editing in HDV to then produce best/high quality DVDs.
    Thanks for reading

    Hi DaveMD,
    Thank you so much for your Q&A post. It is so helpfull for me. I will test it right now. Unfortunatly for you, I reply your post with no answer, just a feedback..Sorry
    Nevertheless, my details are :
    Software: Pr, En and Ae - all CS4.
    My Camera: (Sony FX-1000) shoots HDV 1080i.
    Premiere Pro:
    Capture HDV - mpeg 1440 x 1080 (1.3333)
    Sequence - 1440 x 1080 (1.3333) HD Anamorphic 1080 (1.333) Upper Field First - (HDV 1080i25 Preset)
    I have exported the media in DVD MPG (.m2v) from Premiere and Build the final DVD from that .m2v into Encore.
    I have to say that I am not very happy with the final result when I convert into PAL Widescreen.
    I can see little artefacts, flikers and jaggies...
    - Do you think that this "double" DVD MPG export could lower the quality?
    - Could it be the FullHD screen (1080x1920) on which I display the final result (PAL 720x572) that interprates the video?
    Thank you for your lights !
    Appia

  • G4 with OS X 10.4.11 and DVD's in various formats (NTSC, PAL, SECAM).

    Can a G4 AGP Graphics “Sawtooth” running OS X 10.4.11 Tiger play DVD's in the various regional formats (such as NTSC, PAL, and SECAM) an unlimited number of times, or is there a limit to how often the capability to play a particular format can be switched to the capability to play a different one?

    Using an application such as VLC should optimize format playability.  It may also help with the region code issue.  The "number of times" isn't to do with the DVD format, it has to do with region codes set into the DVD by the media distributors.  You can change that 5 times and then the DVD player is locked in forever. Try VLC and it may help with both the format playback and maybe get around the region code issue (disable Apple's own automatic DVD Player activation).
    VLC media player - http://www.videolan.org/vlc/ - general media player that plays just about anything.
    Niceplayer - http://code.google.com/p/niceplayer/

  • How can we debug an SRM workflow problem?

    Q: How can we debug an SRM workflow problem?

    Hi,
    In SRM system using transaction SWI6 you can troubleshoot the workflow process.
    if you are using N step badi in the workflow process, we can debug the badi BBP_WFL_APPROV_BADI
    method GET_REMAING_APPROVERS
    if required please take a help of Abap consultant to debug...
    Thanks & Regards,
    prasad.s

  • Apple TV/FM Card NTSC - PAL switch?

    G'day,
    Long shot I know... but after opening my TAM on the weekend, and examining the TV/FM tuner card, I saw it was a Philips brand card. So I wrote to Philips Australia to see if they happened to have any laying around.
    No, they said, but - some of their TV tuner cards were "switchable" between formats... I was told.
    I've put the TAM back together again now, and would rather not open it back up for nothing...
    Can anyone out there shed light on this? Apple only have 1 reference number for the TV/FM card - they don't distinguish between regions - NTSC, PAL, or SECAM. Could this be because they just have to flick a switch on the card to tell it which zone it's in???
    I do realise that the cards also have different connectors... (NTSC has screw-on antenna connectors, whereas PAL and (I think) SECAM have just slide-on ones) But is that all the difference? and you just flick a switch somewhere for the region?
    Cheers
    cosmic

    The video input standard is selected in the Apple Video Player program, so there's no need for different verions of the TV or TV/FM card. The correct video input standard (NTSC, PAL, or SECAM) for your region is pre-set, according to the region version of the Apple OS that was installed. To change the setting, select "Preferences" within the Apple Video Player program. In addition to the video input standard, you'll find settings for movie compression and the remote control. An adapter is required to change the TV/FM card's coaxial "F" type connector to a different type. Here is the User Manual for the TV/FM card. It should provide you with answers to most questions that you might have.
    Incidentally, optional Apple input/expansion cards (like the TV/FM card) or specific components found on these cards are typically manufactured by well-known, third-party semiconductor companies, but the cards are considered "Apple" products. As such, third-party companies (like Philips) won't stock these products. For example, Motorola made many of Apple's PowerPC processor chips, but they never stocked/sold the motherboards on which these processors were soldered.

  • NTSC/PAL, FCP and Compressor problems

    I need help. I use a Sony camera (HDR CX560) bought in US with NTSC as standard. I live in Europe and would like to burn a DVD for my Blue-Ray player showing it on my PAL TV.
    The footage is 1080i, 1920x1080, 29,97 fps.
    I have tried several different ways of achieving good results, but with no luck:
    1. Editing in Final Cut Pro with original specs (1080i, 29,97). The result showing in FCP viewer is not perfect, but quite good. A little bit of stuttering and a bit blury pictures. I have tried "Send to Compressor...", selected MPEG-2 for DVD in Compressor (customized to 16:9 TV format). The process stops after a minute - a file is being created, but only the first 30 seconds of the movie is visible. I also tried Share>Export file using Compressor settings. The file created does not have acceptable quality, mostly bescause of very disturbing stripes. I also tried Share>Master file but the output is not good enough (using codec Apple ProRes422 (HQ) - same stripes.
    2. Editing in Final Cut Pro with european standard (1080i, 25i). The result in FCP viewer is good with one exception - a lot of stuttering images while panning. I tried all the output/share alternatives mentioned above, with poor result.
    I use OS X 10.8.3, Final Cut Pro X 10.0.8 and Compressor 4.0.7
    Can anyone help?

    Double post.
    Russ

  • SD Pal to NTSC Pal... using compressor?

    I'm a newbie to FCP, but have a couple of questions. I have a show that is cut in Pal with all Pal sources captured in ProRes from various tape sources. I want to convert that into NTSC to version it. I understand compressor is the tool I want to use to create the conversion, but am I best to copy the timeline and change the settings to NTSC, then export it as a quicktime through compressor? I expect to have to check for upper/lower field problems as the original material is from all over, but am not sure of the process of setting up or using compressor.
    Thanks for any help

    I tried a short timeline in FCP7 using SD and HD (720p) NTSC material and converted to PAL. I was able to use the SHARE menu and File>Send To>Compressor from within FCP and got what look like very good results quickly. I just ran all versions side by side in Quicktime windows with no noticeable difference. Not the best comparison, I know, but its all I had at the moment. Hope this helps clarify a bit.
    all the best
    Terry

  • NTSC/PAL conversion workflow

    After years of working with hardware converters (the best of which I don't have available to me anymore), I'm now always playing with various software conversion methods. I know Compressor 2 works okay but is terribly slow, the Nattress filters are good and faster and I've just started playing with JES Deinterlacer which seems useful.
    Anyways, a co-worker here with an Avid and Procoder says he can capture as NTSC (DV or whatever) and just export a PAL MPEG to make a PAL DVD without an additional conversion step. I havent' looked at his results yet, but he said it looks fine and didn't take much longer than if there had been no conversion.
    So I started wondering why you can't do this with Compressor. And actually, it seems you can. Edit in FCP in one format, then create a custom MPEG-2 preset in Compressor in the other format and work just as you would otherwise. I just did this once and it worked fine though there seems to be quite a bit of jaggies when viewed on my cinema display. I don't have a multi-standard monitor in front of me right now, though I will later and will check it there.
    So, the question is, what technically is the difference between this method and using a better (but slower) converter like Nattress or Compressor 2 Format Converter and what sort of quality difference should I expect? And does anybody know how Procoder compares using this or other workflows?
    I work at a large university and occasionally need to do these things. Normally we're originatin in DV and usually just outputting to DVD, so often there's no need for a DV to DV conversion.
    Thanks much to Graeme or anyone that has any insight into this.
    Doug

    Hi Graeme. Thanks for the response. But do you know what the difference is between those low Compressor 2 settings and just changing a basic MPEG-2 preset to PAL? Know what I mean? Is it even necessary to do the whole "Advanced Conversion" step in C2? Its so quick and easy just to change the MPEG-2 setting to PAL, but I haven't had time to test how it compares to using Advanced Conversion, either at low or high quality. With alot of what I'm doing, the source media looks terrible anyways, so I don't need a perfect conversion. Just something decent and fast preferably.
    I shamefully admit I still haven't tried yours except to demo, but I will one of these days when I have a few dollars or have a huge load of conversions to get through.
    Doug

  • NTSC & PAL Problems

    I have come across a problem. I have been editing PAL footage in FCP not knowing that my project settings were set up in NTSC. I tried to reslove this problem by creating a new project and copying & pasting the existing edited work that I had done into this new project. As expexted there is a time lag with transitions/some images are distorted also. Does anyone know how I can reslove this problem without having to re edit my composition entirley?
    This is urgent as there is a deadline.
    Thanks in advance

    create a new NTSC sequence that matches the format of the original footage
    open that new empty sequence in the timeline window
    now drag the old (PAL) sequence from the browser and +whilst holding down the command key+ drop it onto the new (NTSC) sequence
    next select all the clips now in your new sequnece (press cmd-a)
    and press cmd-opt-v to open the remove attributes window
    check the scale checkbox and click OK
    hopefully that should have fixed it

Maybe you are looking for