Compressor vs Sorenson Squeeze Pro

This is most likely a rather stupid question but can somebody please tell me the difference between Compressor and Sorenson Squeeze Pro? I have been using Compressor for a couple of years with my FCP X output files but was just wondering whether Sorenson Squeeze holds any benefits and is worth the extra financial outlay?
Thanking you
Mitaka27

Take a look at this.
Sorenson Squeeze is designed to support production companies with higher volume compression needs, and those that need a more extensive selection of output formats.
Is it worth the extra money? For me, yes, but you need to form your own opinion.
I believe there is a trial here.
MtD

Similar Messages

Firefox will not play WebM video encoded by Sorenson Squeeze Pro 8

A short video encoded to WebM using Sorenson Squeeze Pro 8.0.48. Chrome and Opera play the HTML5 webm video with a problem. Firefox 10.0.1 and 11 just display a dimmed window with and "X" in the middle and will not load or play anything. Sorenson is a commercially proven product as confirmed by Chrome and Opera, so what gives with Firefox?

We have just completed our webm testing with Telestream's Episode Pro 6.2.1.1 and not surprisingly, the same results as Sorenson Squeeze Pro 8.
Chrome, Opera and Safari browsers play HTML5 webm video as expected.
Firefox rigidly enforces the server .htaccess configuration to specifically state Mime Types, then it will/does work.

Quicktime Pro VS Sorenson Squeeze which is better for uploading to YouTube?

I'm thinking of buying Quicktime Pro or Sorenson Squeeze - which is better for uploading to YouTube? Which would give my video better quality?
Also, with regard to Sorenson Squeeze: The website says these are its requirements - could someone explain what each of them means in logical terms?
Mac OS X system requires:
Power PC with G5 processor or greater or Intel processor - (I'll be using this program with a MacBook Pro - will this work?)
Mac OS X 10.4 or later - (Again, will this work with a MacBook Pro?)
512 MB of RAM
QuickTime 7.2 or later
DirectX 9.0b or later (What is this and how will I get it? Is it free?)
* Mac users must have the Flip4Mac plugin from Telestream (Is this plugin free?) ** Windows only feature * Plugin sold separately
Please be as specific as possible.
Thank you so much in advance for answering my questions! It is really helpful!

First.
You have no control over the conversion to Flash video (done during the YouTube upload) if you use QuickTime .mov format.
Second.
YouTube does allow H.264 Video for its "high quality" display so you would want a QuickTime .mov container.
Now you are even more confused than when you started.
Flip4Mac allows export from QuickTime (and apps like iMovie that use it) to Windows Media Player (.wmv) formats. They will also be converted to Flash Video by YouTube so you gain nothing by using it.
You don't need Squeeze, QuickTime Pro or the Flip4Mac upgrades. Just use iMovie 7 (part of iLife '08).

Premiere PRO CS4 " unexpectedly quit error" since loaded Sorenson squeeze 8.5 is there a bug fix

Premiere PRO CS4 " unexpectedly quit error" since loaded Sorenson squeeze 8.5 is there a bug fix

CS4 is old, and there will be no more updates, past the ones on the update site
All Adobe updates start here and select product, read to see if you need to install updates in number order, or if the updates are cumulative for the individual product http://www.adobe.com/downloads/updates/
Ask Sorenson if 8.5 is even supposed to work with CS4

Flash 8 Pro V. Sorenson Squeeze.

Hi guys,
I have searched on previous forums for exporting a 4 minute film for the web (.flv) I am a bit confused as some rcommend Sorenson and others Flash 8 Pro. Can anyone tell me what will produce the best quality output?
Like others - I have seen some superb looking results on the web, and want to achieve the same quality.
Thanks
Stephen

Flash 8 offers the On2 VP6 Codec which is there latest for compressing video, it even allows the use of alpha channels. If you have Flash 8 you can export to an .flv file out of Final Cut using the Quicktime conversion. You will see a flv option. You can also export from Quicktime itself. The only draw back to this way is that it is a single pass and although you can customize your compressions I don't think you can save them (or at least I haven't figured out how to yet) to use again with having to re-enter the set-up every time.
Sorenson Squeeze is a great compression program but if you wish to use the On2 VP6 codec you will have to buy it as a separate plug-in. Otherwise you will have to use the Spark Pro codec. Now the nice thing about Squeeze is that it does 2 pass for better looking compression and can save your custom settings.
Mostly I use the Flash 8 to make the On2 VP6 files for a quick client review if they are not here in the edit. I use Flash because it is in just about every browser in use today, this way clients don't have to download anything to be able to view the work.
To tell you the truth I have gotten some nice looking web video playing around with the On2 VP6 settings, but the best looking compressions I have done have come using the h.264 codec, it may be a bit bigger file size but sometimes it is worth the extra bandwidth.
Good Luck
Rich

Pro CS4 Media Encoder vs Sorenson Squeeze Quality?

Guys,
When outputting a video to Flash (for this discussion, let's assume Flash V8, medium size.....with the Web as the target audience), does anyone have experience using both PProCS4 Media Encoder and Sorenson Squeeze---being able to comment of the quality of each? Is CS4 Media Encoder doing as good a job (apples to apples) as Sorenson Squeeze would do? For general info, they want SD video in 4:3 ratio.
I've want to provide the best quality video I can to a client who is selling web training for a professional methodology. They are using video to provide additional visual support to their audio segments.
TIA,
jd

I purchased Squeeze after the release of CS4, the Adobe Media Encoder was fine in CS3. I noticed after installing CS4 that the end product (usually Quicktime, AVI, Mpeg-2 DVD and BluRay for me) was soft and fuzzy. I dug around various forums and found that many had this issue with the AME in CS4 and saw Sorenson Squeeze highly recommended. It should be noted that I use a Matrox RT.X2 card with my CS3 and now CS4 environment. I now export out an uncompressed i-Frame Matrox AVI and bring it into Squeeze and it works great.
I am finding the same issue in a non-Matrox project. We are doing a spot now that was shot in DVCPRO-HD. The image is gorgeous in PP, however when I use the AME, the resulting file is soft and dull.
Question to anyone who can help. In a non-Matrox project, what can I use to get it into Squeeze? With my Matrox projects, the uncompressed Matrox export bypassed the AME and gave me a clean image to bring into Squeeze. In my current non-Matrox DVCPRO-HD project I tried uncompressed AVI but it reduced my size to 720x480, and it reduced the quality. How do I get my footage out of Premiere and into Squeeze without using the AME?
Thanks,
Marty

Sorenson Squeeze Necessary?

I am purchasing Final Cut Studio 2, should I also buy Sorenson Squeeze to put videos online.
(I know that final cut has a compressor built in)
Enjoy your day!

Probably, but Sorenson's pro versions of their own codec you'll not have. (Sorenson 3 pro) and you will not have the ability to make WMF's...without Squeeze or Episode...
However... the makers of Episode are coming up with a plug in for Compressor 3 that will add these features. Don't think it's out yet though.
Jerry

Need help with compression rates with Sorenson Squeeze 6, Compressor3.5.2

Hopefully somebody can help me with this...
I am running Sorenson Squeeze 6 on a Mac to try and compress some Apple ProRes 422 videos into an MPEG-2 file. The file will be played in a DirectX application, running on a PC with Windows 7. When being played it looks to be heavily compressed, and I need help with some of the compression settings.
Let me get more into detail...
So I have received a Quicktime .mov that has been encoded with FCP using Apple ProRes 422 compression at 720x486 , 29.97 fps, 40.29 Mbit/s , and the file size is 515.7mb.
So, this is the type of file I will have to compress into an MPEG-2, that will be playing on a...
1.6 GHz Intel Atom 330 Dual Core
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M Graphics
1Gb DDR2 800 Ram
32Gb SATA Solid State Drive
Windows 7 Home
Here is what I have done so far on my Mac using Sorenson Squeeze 6 :
I have brought the original file in and created some presets.
First off, I am encoding these MPEG-2 videos using an elementary stream type so I can mux the files using MPEG Streamclip...
Here is a screenshot of the settings I am using in Sorenson :
- I have changed many of the data rate settings as low as 3000 Kbps, and as high as 15,000 Kbps, and the end result looks essentially the same
- The audio isn't a problem, so I'm not going to address that.
- I have used the crop/deinterlace filter and also not used the filter, and it makes a big difference, so obviously it needs to be deinterlaced.
From there I will get the .m2v file and the .m2a file, and then mux those with MPEG Streamclip.
So, I have done 8 different Pre-sets all with various settings playing primarily with the data rate, and the method from 2-pass vbr all the way to 1-pass cbr.
So again, my end result that is playing back on the windows 7 box (the specs that are listed above) looks to be heavily compressed and pixelation occurs.
- I have also done the exact same with Apple's Compressor, and have gotten better results muxing while compressing, however the end result still tends to be the same, however the end result is much better. I have gone through 8 or so different compression export settings, and just overall still have the same issue.
Any help would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks,
Crawford and Luke
LKC Creative, LLC.
[email protected]

You are using a custom layout so my directions don't make any sense...
For the future, you can set this up in DVD SP's Preferences:
Using the Standard window layout the things to play with would be like the screenshot below:

720 progressive output from Sorenson Squeeze and Sony Z1 HDV

Hi
I have a one off project where I need to film some shots in portrait 16:9 for output on (lots of) 720p digital screens on their sides. I plan on filming this with a Sony Z1 camera in 1080i HD mode on its side and then down-sizing in FCP and converting to progressive WMV files with Sorenson Squeeze.
I know the Z1 doesn't really do progressive filming. Would it be wise to hire a camera that does support it natively for best results? Or would Sorenson Squeeze do a good job of de-interlacing to 720p for HD LCD panels? Plus, does anyone know of a bracket-type attachment to mount cameras at 90 degrees on a tripod?
Any suggestions or tips for best results would be much appreciated, and thanks in advance for any help!
Message was edited by: doug m
Message was edited by: doug m

Tom,
I don't think that your issue is with the Z1. I think that it is with HDV footage in general (nasty format and all) but you don't want to hear that so let's work on getting you going.
1) You do need some sort of external monitor. YOu have several options, Cheapest is to buy a Matrox MXO and an Apple or Dell 24" monitor. Other options include cards from AJA or Blackmagic. If you are doing everything in HDV I would recommend something from AJA or BM that way you can capture to a more easily editable format like DVCProHD. Do a search for Kona, Blackmagic or capture cards aadn you will find a wealth of info.
2) for this footage you need to look at the original tapes on an HD tv and see if you are seeing the same thing. This will determine if it is a compressor issue.
3) How low did you set your bit rate? Max should be below 7 or some DVD players will have issues.
4) in DVDSP you should be able to bring in your QT ref file and it will encode it for you. If it won't import it makes me wonder if it is being exported properly. Are you going out of FCP by FILE>EXPORT>QUICKTIME>with current settings, and check Make Movie Self-contained?
One more thing, in this process you are not working with film, others here may be more harsh about this but you are using video so let's call it what it is.
K

Workflow for using Sorenson Squeeze Compression Suite

I am considering purchasing Sorenson Squeeze Compression Suite as I have noticed some unsatisfactory results in Compressor, even though I am generally impressed with Compressor and happy with the program and the options it gives, especially with exporting movie files for the web.
Right Now, if I want to export my timeline to MPEG2, I either export directly to Compressor, or I will export to a Quicktime movie file, not self-contained, and then import that into compressor. The latter of the two is certainly a faster method but I have noticed quite a few mixed opinions on these forums as to whether you lose quality or not with that method because video is being "recompressed"
Can anyone tell me the workflow when using Sorenson Squeeze Compression Suite? Will there be an option in FCP to export directly to Sorenson Squeeze as you do with Compressor, or will I have to export a Quicktime reference file and then import that into Squeeze? I noticed a few posts on this forum suggesting that you have to export a self-contained quicktime file for Sorenson Squeeze. How can that be good, as you would definitely be compressing the image more than once?
Also, maybe this is a quesion for the DVDSP forum, but I was wondering what codec is used by DVDSP for encoding the menus. Does it use Compressor in the background? or something else? And if I am using Sorenson Squeeze, will DVDSP use Sorenson for encoding the menus, or will there even be an option to tell DVDSP to use Sorenson for encoding the menus?
thanks for any input advice anyone can offer.

thanks for that info. that is really good to know.
the only thing is the box that says recompress all frames is shaded unless I check the box that says make movie self-contained. so, does that mean anything? does that mean that it will only recompress frams if you make the movie self-contained? and will never recompress if you just export a reference file?
thanks.

Can't import movie created in Sorenson Squeeze

I work with AVID and Windows at work... don't hold it against me. I'm a total Mac guy at home.
I have created some QuickTime movies with Sorenson Squeeze using the standard DV/DVCPro codec. People with Final Cut Pro tell me they cannot import my movies which seems strange. I think they are getting an "unsupported format" error message. Oddly enough when I export directly out of the AVID using the same DV/DVCPro codec they can import my movies. It is very frustrating because I want to use Sorenson to make all my movies (quicktime, windows media, mpeg2, etc) because it can do it all at the same time.
Any ideas? Thanks.

I have created a simple 6 minute movie in Photo Booth and have been completely unable to import the movie into iMovie. I would like to be able to add music to my movie via iMovie and I'm currently at a loss. Any help?
Not sure why MPEG Streamclip would have problems with the file but it is not uncommon for iMovie '08 to balk at the import of clips under certain conditions. For instance, what kind of tracks are included in your File? Any "Tween" tracks. As I am running an old G5 PPC model, my use of Photo Booth is very limited in terms of effect compatibility and he files I am able to create are limited to simple MPEG4/AAC and, as such do import. Can you post a copy for examination or can you check the "Properties" window and report what you find? Also, as a possible workaround, have you tried importing the file into GarageBand (which doesn't have all of iMovie '08's import limitations) and add your audio track there?

Files not supported error with Sorenson Squeeze 4

I'm trying to create flv. files for a video art site on the web. I have tried importing Sorenson 3 mov files, mpeg4 and mpeg2 files and simple QT files, thye all say "files not supported" after the compression says complete, and they won't play. What am I doing wrong? How shoudl I export my final cut pro movies so Squeeze will compress them? Secondly, there are a huge number of choices under flash, which should I be selecting?

I'm trying to create flv. files for a video art site
on the web. I have tried importing Sorenson 3 mov
files, mpeg4 and mpeg2 files and simple QT files,
thye all say "files not supported" after the
compression says complete, and they won't play. What
Huh? Who are they? You mean, Final Cut Pro? Is Quick Time Player selected in 'External Editors' under Final Cut Pro's 'System Settings'?
am I doing wrong? How shoudl I export my final cut
pro movies so Squeeze will compress them? Secondly,
You mean, Sorenson Squeeze 4?
there are a huge number of choices under flash, which
should I be selecting?
Sorry to say, but if you are familar with video compression, those settings are pretty much basic, and I don't know exactly what to explain to you.
iMac G5 2GHz Mac OS X (10.4.3) 1,536 MB RAM
iMac G5 2GHz Mac OS X (10.4.3) 1,536 MB RAM
iMac G5 2GHz Mac OS X (10.4.3) 1,536 MB RAM

Opinions Please: Sorenson Squeeze or Cleaner

What is better for general web streaming, Sorenson Squeeze or Cleaner?
Real, WMV, QT are the primary formats I use.
Thanks

Jeff, David is trying to make sure that it's clear what you're looking for. Your comments such as "Streaming and Compressing media before putting it on the web." make it less than clear what it is you think those programs accomplish.
Just to make it clear so we're all sure of what we're talking about, Squeeze and Cleaner don't providing streaming services, only compression. Either product can prepare a video for streaming (providing hinting for RTSP streaming, for instance), but you need a separate software package such as QuickTime Streaming Server to provide the actual streaming service. You may well already know this, but it's not clear from your post, so just making sure.
As to Squeeze vs. Cleaner, until recently I'd say Squeeze hands down. Cleaner hadn't been updated in close to two years and had fallen well behind in compatibility and features. Autodesk recently released a new version of Cleaner, though, which makes Cleaner once again a contender. I've generally preferred the interface of Cleaner for large batch processing (which we do); Squeeze and Apple's Compressor tend to lend themselves better to single or small numbers of files. But I haven't seen the most recent version of Squeeze, so it may have improved in that regard.
As to codec comparisons, I've not seen any good comparisons. Obviously Sorenson is the place to go if you're compressing with their codec. I've seen mixed reports about their H.264 codec, though, so I'd want to investigate further before I chose Squeeze (or Cleaner, for that matter) if H.264 was going to be my primary codec. You might look for additional opinions on Creative Cow, a set of forums for media professionals.
Ultimately, you may want to download the trial versions of each and perform your own testing. That way you would know exactly what each pacakage would deliver in your particular situation and workflow.
Just FYI, Popwire's Compression Master is another compression package worth looking at.
Message was edited by: Dave Sawyer

Exporting HDV with compressor to DVD Studio Pro

Could someone tell me what I'm doing wrong? When I export an HDV project using compressor for DVD Studio Pro and choose the 4:3 ratio, my video ends up squeezed horizontally. I would like to "chop" off the sides so that my subjects don't look unnaturally skinny. I just need a sample workflow to see what I am doing wrong. I'm rather new to DVD Studio Pro, so appologies blah, blah, blah. Thanks in advance.

Ooops, sorry
Open up Compressor
Click on the Preset You Want In General (or make a new One)
That will open Inspector, then click on the second icon from the right (geometry) The crop is there

Sorenson Squeeze 4.3 Settings

Hi,
I've been using Compressor 2 in the past to encode my FCP projects into MPEG2 for DVD.
I purchased Sorenson Squeeze recently for some Flash work but wanted to give it a try for encoding my MPEG2 instead of Compressor.
How do I get my FCP project into Sorenson?
Any advice on settings for Sorenson?
In Compressor I used 2 Pass VBR 4.5-6 bit rate. I know Sorenson only has a 1 pass VBR, but Im not sure how there bitrate settings work.
Any tips much appreciated.
Mike

Michael, to get your project into Sorenson just export out of FCP as a quicktime file (no need to make it self-contained) and drag the .mov onto the Sorenson window. Then choose a setting from the menu (or create a new one) and just drag this onto the project that appears in the main window - then 'squeeze' it.
Settings are very dependant on the length of your media. For projects under 60 minutes, I always use a CBR of 8.2 and make sure my PCM audio file is compressed to 128-192kbps ac3 (I use a droplet created in Compressor 2 for this so it's really easy). I must say that Sorenson's output is a lot nicer than the equivalent Compressor version - sometimes it's really obvious! You haven't wasted your money there.

Compressor vs Sorenson Squeeze Pro

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for