Confusion about Tiger vs. Leopard for upgrading

katberlin in some recent threads, is trying to upgrade to Leopard, however Limnos referred her to Tiger software. I too am thinking of upgrading and have almost the same vintage iBook G4 OSX 10.3.9. Is it not possible to upgrade to just Tiger or just Leopard? I'm confused.
My purpose is to be able to consider using Skype. And to be able to update to more recent versions of Firefox, etc. Will Tiger be far enough to buy me a few more years on my above laptop?

Will Tiger be far enough to buy me a few more years on my above laptop?
I have a G3 PowerBook 400MHz Pismo laptop running Tiger. Runs great on the Tiger versions of Firefox, etc. Go for Tiger.
Tiger install DVDs are in short supply. Tiger is no longer available at the Apple Store *but may be available for $129 by calling Apple Phone Sales @ 1-800-MY-APPLE (1-800-692-7753)*. For other sources, do a Google search for MA453Z/A (10.4.6), MA190Z/A (10.4.3) and M9639Z/A (10.4) . Also look on eBay. Be sure & buy a retail version (black with silver X) and not a model specific version (gray) (See Can I use another Mac's system restore disc on my Mac? ). Expect to pay (possibly a lot) more than the Apple list price of $129.
Also check these web stores: http://www.lacomputercompany.com/cgi-bin/rpcart/index.cgi?command=dispitem&type= sku&sku=19521 http://www.allmac.com/shop/index.php?cPath=5_10003
Possible Alternative if you are currently using Panther 10.3 – Do a Google search for Tiger 10.4 Upgrade DVD . It will upgrade your 10.3 to 10.4, but it doesn’t contain the full retail Tiger installer. Should be cheaper than the retail Tiger install DVD.
After you install the base 10.4.x, update to the final Tiger version 10.4.11. Here's the link for the 10.4.11 combo update http://support.apple.com/kb/TA24901?viewlocale=en_US
Look at this link Mac OS X v10.4 Tiger Installing Software Support Page
http://www.apple.com/support/tiger/install/
You can also download the Tiger Installation and Setup Guide
http://manuals.info.apple.com/en/TigerInstall_SetupGuide.pdf
When you upgrade the OS, do it via Archive & Install. See About the Archive and Install feature http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1710
Be sure to select Preserve Users & Settings. Also, repair permissions before and after the install.
 Cheers, Tom

Similar Messages

  • Tiger or Leopard for Logic Studio on my G4?

    (This is a repost from a reply in another topic) According to Apple's system requirements I need to upgrade to either Tiger or Leopard to get Logic Studio to run on my G4. Does anyone with a simlilar machine have advice of whether 10.4 or 10.5 will be my best bet? Also how do I do a "clean install" and will it make a difference. -Thanks

    Before doing a clean install please make sure you've back-up all your Songs,
    then test to see if they work,
    after they have work then you could then select the Hard-Drive from where you install L.P. 8 by double clicking onto it and use Spotlight which is at the Upper-Right of the H.D. you've just enter,
    and type Logic-Pro 8 in seconds the installed Files will appear highlight all the Files you want that comes up saying Logic-Pro 8
    Right-Click onto them then select Trash or Manually Drag them to the Trash.
    As to whether you want to use Leo or Tiger its up to you,
    I would love to use Leo however at this time it isn't fully supported by Digi Design Pro-Tools LE oo2R, so i'll have to wait before i jump in,
    therefore if you don't have wait the choose is yours, Logic -Pro 8 requires OSX 10.4.9. straight to Leo + Quicktime 7.3
    Good-Luck and a happy new-Year.
    Fr.BlayZay.

  • Prep. Questions for Upgrading Tiger- Snow Leopard for Iphone 4.

    Hi,
    Like everyone else, I failed to realized iphone 4 was not tiger compatible. Regardless of my carelessness, and my ill-feelings towards Apple for this strange move, I have a few questions that I keep getting mixed answers to and would like to finally clear some of them up. I sincerely hope someone can help me, I've been using my phone for about 2 weeks now with no contacts/apps/previous data, and the longer I wait, the more it's grating on my feelings.
    Background:
    I have many applications on my computer, like the adobe suite, games, ect. that I am worried about making the transfer. So far, no one seems to be able to tell me what is going to happen to them when/if I upgrade. I do not have the keys for the adobe suite anymore..... could this seriously screw me?
    2) I've purchased the simple, $50 family pack snow leopard install discs. Again, I'm planning on jumping from 10.4.11 to whatever comes pre-installed on those discs. My computers specs meet the requirements for snow leopard, so, Is there any problem with this? Sources online say I'm AOK, and only after I bought it from apple and bring it home do they tell me (as I called to ask about backing up my hd) that I can't use this, that I need the box set with Iwork and Ilife.
    My frustration rises
    I just really need someone to help clear this up for me before I accidently fatally lose everything on my computer because I was given false information.
    3) Incase I do totally bomb this, I'm attempting to make a copy of my harddrive to my external through Disc Utilities.
    Say I do upgrade successfully to Snow Leopard, but the Adobe Software is lost, would I be able to restore my computer back to this current Tiger state from my external?
    4)Is it just not possible to run Snow Leopard with my current versions of Imovie, Iphoto, ect?
    I'm trying to keep cool, but seriously, if I have to go back and buy the box set just to upgrade my Iwork(which i don't use) and Ilife set, and then on top of that, repurchase the Adobe suite because it won't make the switch, I'm going to not only be furious, but lose a lot of respect for Apple.
    Thanks for any help you can give me. Seriously.

    Sources online say I'm AOK, and only after I bought it from apple and bring it home do they tell me (as I called to ask about backing up my hd) that I can't use this, that I need the box set with Iwork and Ilife.
    The Box Set is "recommended", not essential, what you have will work.
    Say I do upgrade successfully to Snow Leopard, but the Adobe Software is lost, would I be able to restore my computer back to this current Tiger state from my external?
    First off, the only way to be 100% safe is to have a bootable Clone of what you have now.
    Get carbon copy cloner to make an exact copy of your old HD to the New one...
    http://www.bombich.com/software/ccc.html
    SuperDuper...
    http://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/
    Or the most expensive one & my favorite, Tri-Backup...
    http://www.tri-edre.com/english/tribackup.html
    Boot from the clone and make certain everything is OK before install SL on the internal, then you could in a worst case scenario clone it back to the internal, or have 2 different OSes to choose from.
    Is it just not possible to run Snow Leopard with my current versions of Imovie, Iphoto, ect?
    I use iMovie 6 HD in SL/10.6, but be sure if installing iMovie that your current version isn't named iMovie so it doesn't get erased.
    and then on top of that, repurchase the Adobe suite because it won't make the switch
    You don't mention which versions of Adobe Apps you have.
    Which apps work with Mac OS X 10.6?...
    http://snowleopard.wikidot.com/

  • Confused about the recent BT Infinity upgrades

    Hello, 
    I am a BT Infinity 2 customer. I received a mail about 20 days ago telling me that my speeds are going to be increased (up) to 76/19. 
    Now, I don't have any complaints about my current service as it is quite close to the original 38/9 but, nothing has been upgraded so far. Should I contact BT or is this just an upgrade that is going to happen sometime in the future?
    Note that the BT "speed checker" already claims that my line should be getting up to 76/19.
    Thanks in advance!
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hey John46, thank you for the update, this one seems to be working better!
    Here are my results :
    Best Effort test: 
     Download speedachieved during the test was - 37.56 Mbps
     For your connection, the acceptable range of speeds is 12 Mbps-0 Mbps.
     IP Profile for your line is - 38.72 Mbps
    Upstream test:
     Upload speed achieved during the test was - 8.17Mbps
     Additional Information:
     Upstream Rate IP profile on your line is - 10 Mbps

  • HT1657 Am confused about the rental time for movies

    I was reading the instructions for downloading a rental movie. It says you have 48 hours to complete watching a film after you started. But the
    The next line It says you can watch the film as many times as you like until the end of the rental period. That's a bit confusing for me.?

    When you rent a film you have it for potentially 30 days, but once you start watching it you then have 48 hours (24 hours in the US) before it expires - you can watch it as many times as you like during those 48 hours.

  • Confused about BTs rollout plans for north scotlan...

    It seems that exchanges further than dunfermline have been forgotten about
    like mine NSDEN
    15,733 residential premises
    1,543 non-residential premises. 
    I just want to know whats going on as theres no planned dates
    i live in the oli capital of europe you'd think we would get FTTC  pretty quick -_-

    "don't moan about it taking a bit longer to get to you" It's not just a bit though Colin its 5 years if not longer could be 10 years. I took Youview on being told by many different Bt staff i could get the same services as everyone else. Surely when the youview service was sold to me they could have explained there and then certain services were for fibre only. It just annoys me to find i can't get these services and even more so things are finally hitting the platform.. Colin really your answer is to move ? bit drastic don't you think ?.

  • Some confusion about Web Cache clustering for load balancing

    I have 4 Windows 2003 identical machines having OAS 10g installed with Web Cache (Same Passwords and Oracle Home) . I want to utilize them for load-balancing using Microsoft Network Load-balancing. I followed the Note: 259208.1 till step#10. Now we have virtual machine "IASPROD" for all other nodes {IASPROD1,IASPROD2,IASPROD3,IASPROD4 } I am able to logon to Web Cache manager from all nodes separately.
    On Node-1 I added all nodes entries in " Origin Server " having routed "Enabled " for all of them. Same I did added in Site-Definitions and gave alias hostname as "IASPROD" which is virtual server.
    Priority =1
    Site Hostname =iasprod1.domain Port = 80
    Policy = Unrestricted
    Origin Server Hostnames , port,proxy
    iasprod1.domain 7778 No
    iasprod2.domain 7778 No
    iasprod3.domain 7778 No
    iasprod4.domain 7778 No
    I have couple of questions might be very basic but as I am configuring very first time.
    1. How do I access all the machines through virtual name as stated above ? I tried but not working.
    2. This cluster setup should be repeated for all Nodes or for only node-1.
    3. If for only Node-1 than what will heppen in case of Node-1 goes down.
    4. How can I verify Load-balancing is working ?
    If you guyz can guide me than I'll be very greatful.

    One more addition Database is on AIX (9.2.0.4)

  • How to get Leopard for iPad, iPhone, or other hardware or software upgrade?

    Disclaimer: Apple does not necessarily endorse any suggestions, solutions, or third-party software products that may be mentioned in the topic below. Apple encourages you to first seek a solution at Apple Support. The following links are provided as is, with no guarantee of the effectiveness or reliability of the information. Apple does not guarantee that these links will be maintained or functional at any given time. Use the information below at your own discretion.
    If you need 10.5 (Leopard) or 10.6 (Snow Leopard) for upgrading 10.4.11 or earlier, realize the following:
    1. Mac OS X 10.5 may no longer be available on Apple's authorized reseller websites, however, Apple's online store phone number sometimes has 10.5 available for purchase. You may also find it in stores that specialize in used or refurbished Macs.
    2. Neither Mac OS X 10.5 nor Mac OS X 10.6 is available for download legally.
    3. Mac OS X 10.5 and above restrict your access to Mac OS 9, as is covered by this user tip:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2176255&tstart=0
    4. Mac OS X 10.5 has these system requirements:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3759
    Some Macs may be able to upgrade to 10.5 with unsupported system capabilities, using a third party software
    called LeopardAssist. No Mac can upgrade to 10.6 without the the requirements for 10.6 being met.
    5. Mac OS X 10.6 has these system requirements:
    http://www.apple.com/macosx/specs.html
    A more detailed coverage of if a Mac is Snow Leopard compatible is in this user tip:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2126451
    6. Make sure all your software and hardware is compatible with your desired operating system upgrade before installing.
    That means if a software says it is compatible with 10.5 or above, it is only compatible with 10.5 and 10.5.1.
    If it says it is compatible with 10.5.x and above, it is only compatible with 10.5, 10.5.1, and 10.5.2.
    If it says it is compatible with 10.5 to 10.5.4, you can't say for certain if it is compatible with 10.5.5 through 10.5.8.
    Check with the software or hardware vendor the intention of their compatibility label if uncertain.
    7. Backup your data at least twice, and shut down the computer and remove the backup medium from the computer before upgrading to
    any version of Mac OS X.
    8. Note: 10.6, and 10.5 are newer than 10.4.11. 10.4.11 is newer than 10.4.10, and both are newer than 10.4 through 10.4.9.
    This is the 1st version of this tip. It was submitted on September 29, 2010 by a brody.
    Do you want to provide feedback on this User Contributed Tip or contribute your own? If you have achieved Level 2 status, visit the User Tips Library Contributions forum for more information.

    Both app.execMenuItem("FindAgain") and app.execMenuItem("FindPrevious") work just fine in Acrobat 8 Pro (from the console), but only after manually running the Find version once.
    Think about it, all that JS does is call these functions. So calling Find from JS will basically not do anything because you can't specify to it what to search for. Even typing the string you want to search for in the "find" field doesn't work.
    If you want to find words in a file using a script you will need to use getPageNthWord.

  • Help upgrading from Tiger to Leopard

    I need to upgrade from Tiger to Leopard for Quickbooks 2009; can you point me to some resources that will walk me through the process (and point out any pitfalls)? Also is the product that outfits like Amazon or Buy.com are selling what I need to do the upgrade?
    Thanks.

    Hi ramonelkalsaw;
    The only thing I would add it that while the upgrade process does claim that it will preserve things for you I would add that creating a bootable clone before starting the upgrade process is a good thing. It gives you an easy way to get back to where you were before you started very quickly just in case something goes wrong.
    Allan

  • Upgrading - Tiger or Leopard?

    I need to upgrade my DVI TiBook, as it's going to be my primary machine for a while. I'm going to be upgrading the HDD to a 120Gb model, and (eventually) maxing out the RAM to 1Gb (2x 512 chips). My first step is going to be getting the RAM up to 768Mb.
    I'm also planning on upgrading the OS from my current 10.3.9 installation. My question is, should I bother with Leopard, or just upgrade to Tiger? I've been hearing talk of AirPort problems with Leopard on the Powerbook G4s, and that it will eat up a lot of my gig of ram. On the other hand, buying retail copies of Tiger is becoming more difficult and more expensive as the days progress. However, it feels like I can't just stick with 10.3, since each day it seems like it can do less and less.
    Thanks for your advice.

    Hi, Hank. Tiger will be a better fit on your machine than Leopard, all other things being equal — and particularly if you'll be using it for a while with only 768MB of RAM in it. Tiger will run nicely with that much RAM; Leopard would like more elbow room, though it will run. You're right, though, that Tiger discs are getting hard to find and very expensive. If I were you, I'd make a diligent effort to turn up a retail (not model-specific) Tiger installer, new or used. If you don't find one for a reasonable price after as much time and energy as you're willing to put in, buy Leopard instead — but boost your RAM all the way to 1GB right away.
    Be aware, also, that Leopard doesn't support Classic mode. If you still use any Classic applications at all, you won't be able to do so in Leopard, but will have to start up the machine in OS 9 (preferably from an external FireWire hard drive) to run those applications.
    I have the same Tibook model you have. It served me faithfully many hours every day for almost exactly five years, and I wore much of the paint off it. I was in the same quandary as yourself, continuing to run 10.3.9 as it grew longer in the tooth, trying to choose between Tiger and Leopard for most of the past year. Finally I just opted for a new MacBook Pro instead — but I kept the Tibook to run a couple of indispensable and non-upgradeable Classic apps.
    With Tiger or Leopard on it, your Tibook may serve you well for another couple of years. By then it won't have any resale value (it has little enough now), and when you retire it, you can just pull the hard drive out and keep it for use in an external enclosure with your next Mac. The $200-$300 you're planning to put into it is a small price to pay for a couple of years of extended utility.

  • Tiger or Leopard

    Right now I have not upgraded to Leopard, still running Tiger. Should I upgrade, will Logic 8 run better or worse?
    Thanks.

    One differnnce between Tiger and Leopard for audio work is shown in these images
    from http://src.infinitewave.ca.
    It would seem that Leopard (core audio in leopard) can do better Sample Rate
    Conversions from 96kHz to 44.1kHz.
    Logic itself doesn't do the conversion, it calls on CoreAudio to do the conversion.
    Of course you could use some other software that doesn't rely on the OS to do the conversion.
    Anyway, just this is a good point to upgrade to Leopard if you do ANY sample rate
    converting on the Mac OS outside of a dedicated program for it.
    this is Logic8 Core Audio in Leopard. Very good.
    this is Logic8 Core Audio with Tiger. Pretty good.
    this is Logic 7.2.3. Pretty bad (but remeber that core audio of the OS
    is doing the conversion) so this might be Panther ?

  • I have recently upgraded my iBookG4 from Tiger to Leopard 10.5.8 and find my Bluetooth USB adaptor no longer connects. The Bluetooth pane says inactive. Does Leopard require  USB 2.0. I've had the adaptor for some time so may be USB 1.0

    I have recently upgraded my iBookG4 from Tiger to Leopard 10.5.8 and find my Bluetooth USB adaptor no longer connects. The Bluetooth pane says inactive. Does Leopard require  USB 2.0. I've had the adaptor for some time so may be USB 1.0

    Bluetooth icon on menu bar shows bluetooth off. When opening bluetooth preferences it shows the devices I've connected previously,( my mobile phone), and other devices I've attempted to connect but not very successfully: my iPhone and MiniMac.  The bluetooth dongle in the USB port shows a continual blue light but does not react and the iBook does not recognise that it is there. There is absolutely no reaction when I try to pair my mobile phone, which I've done successfully before upgrading to Leopard, either by the iBook or the mobile phone.
    I assumed that Tiger was not bluetooth compatible with the iPhone or MacMini running SnowLeopard and hoped by upgrading to Leopard I could achieve some file transfers between the three devices (iBook, iPhone and MacMini)

  • Everyone keeps talking about an upgrade from Leopard to Snow Leopard for $29 but I cannot find it anywhere-any suggestions?

    Everyone keeps talking about an upgrade from Leopard to Snow Leopard for $29 but I cannot find it anywhere-any suggestions?

    Good news for current buyers ... single user SL is down to $19, 5-user family-pack is down to $29 ... I would buy the 5-user license to avoid need ing to buy it again after Apple stops selling it.

  • G5 Dual Core with ATI X1900GT - upgrade to FCS2, Tiger or Leopard?

    Hi everyone,
    I am little confused what to do. So, maybe somebody can advise me what it would be the best.
    Here is the situation:
    I am still using my G5 Dual Core 2.0 with an ATI X1900GT card, 8.5GB RAM and Decklink SP (as below states). I intend to use it till the end of this year, and then to switch to the fastest at that moment Mac Pro. Now, I have 10.4.11 and FCS-1 with almost all filters from Noise Industries. Everything works perfect.
    But I would like to upgrade to FCS-2, especially because of Motion3 new features. The questions are:
    1. Stay with Tiger and do the upgrade to FCS-2? And after that how the Motion3 will work? With similar speed? Or better, maybe worse? (I am not afraid about Final Cut - it shouldn't be any problem, but what about Motion?)
    2. Upgrade the system to Leopard, and then upgrade the FCS?
    But what about the graphic card drivers? On the Ati/AMD web site there are still (from over a year) drivers for Tiger and not for Leopard. Without the proper drivers it could be a problem to install the FCS. Few months ago, when I was changing the startup disk for WD Raptor, I did the clean system installation and tried to install FCS-1. But I forgotten about installing the ATI drivers. When I tried to install, the FCS shows the info that this computer doesn't have the graphic card which support Quartz Extreme. Of course, after installing those drivers everything works OK.
    So, how it could be with Leopard?
    3. Will the all filters (I mean filter from Noise Industries) work fine in Motion and in FCP?
    4. Will the old Motion project open correct in Motion3? I use the old project quite often.
    +For those upgrades I can use another (cloned) startup disk to avoid the "dramatic" situation.+
    I appreciate any help. Thanks in advance.
    Marek.

    Thanks for all replies.
    It looks that it is not a bad idea to stay with 10.4.11, and upgrade only the FCS.
    I will do this on my clone disk, and check if everything works fine.
    But, is it possible to install Motion3 (from FCS2 upgrade disks) and leave the Motion2 on the same disk being installed? (I suppose no, but asking just in case)
    I checked the specification of the Noise Industries - filters work fine in both system Tiger and Leopard (most of them I am using now, except of those filter which need FCP6 and Motion3), so I think I will stay with Tiger.
    Peter, do you know what capabilities exactly I can loose staying with Tiger? Do you use those filters (or some of them)?
    Marek.

  • Upgrade from tiger to leopard on a power mac G?

    can i upgrade from tiger to leopard on a power mac G5?

    Yes, however, read about the pitfalls below.
    Mac OS X 10.5 was release October 26, 2007.  Its 10.5.8 update is the newest operating system available for PowerPC Macs that meet its requirements.  It is available occasionally by calling Apple online store's phone number, even though the website does not show it.  Many want to upgrade to Leopard because of i-Devices (iPhone, iPad, iPod) bought saying iTunes 10 or later is recommended.  To check if that really is required, look at the i-Device requirements section of this tip
    If your Mac is Intel, and running 10.4.11 or earlier, and meets the hardware requirements of 10.6, a less expensive upgrade solution is to upgrade to 10.6 directly.  No need to upgrade to 10.5 unless your software won't run in 10.6.
    Software listed for Intel Mac and PowerPC Macs can run on 10.5 for the platform indicated in the link. For Leopard you need
    867 Mhz on a single processor or faster (1 Ghz and higher are faster).
    256 MB of RAM (preferably 512MB of more based on arbitrary experience).
    9 GB of hard disk space (arbitrary experience adds another 15%) free.
    Macs newer than August 28, 2009 can't run Leopard, and require a minimum of Snow Leopard.
    Dual booting Mac OS 9 and Mac OS X 10.5, check this tip:https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-1757
    Classic is not compatible with 10.5.  10.4.11 on a PowerPC Mac or earlier is needed for Classic.
    Mac OS X 10.5 is the earliest version of Mac OS X that will run iTunes 10.  This is necessary for numerous i-Devices (iPad, iPhone, and iPods).  To find out which require it, see this article
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITunes_version_history
    Should you require only iTunes 9, and are running a minimum of 10.4, backup your data at least twice, check in Apple menu -> About This Mac if you have a G3, G4, G5 (which is PowerPC), or Intel Core (which is Intel) make sure you are running 10.4.11 PowerPC or 10.4.11 Intel (depending on the aforementioned processors), and download iTunes 9.2.1.  The only reason you should upgrade to 10.5 is if some other software is required.
    Boot Camp is only available on Intel Macs with 10.5 and higher.
    Time Machine backup software first appeared in 10.5
    You have several options of installation which are explained here: https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2209
    All of which I recommend you backup your data at least twice before upgrading, and have sufficient disk space to install, and all your third party applications and drivers are known to be Leopard compatible, and after backing up your data you dismount and disconnect all but Apple keyboard and mouse and if there is an external display, that too. And just before you install repair permissions.
    If any of the above terms confuse you, ask on the Discussions board what they mean, and one of the people who knows will gladly assist you.
    You must use the installer disc that looks like *, and does not say Upgrade, Dropin, or OEM, if you choose to upgrade to Leopard.
    Message was edited by: a brody

Maybe you are looking for

  • VGA adapter with Air

    I just got the new Macbook Air and was wondering if this adapter will work with the Thunderbolt port? http://store.apple.com/dk/product/MB572Z/A?fnode=MTY1NDA3Ng&mco=MTA4NDU0NjA#over view - Mads-hk

  • Installing Oracle 10.2.0.1 and upgrade to 10.2.0.3 on WIndows 2000 using VM

    What's up with trying to install Oracle 10.2.0.1 database standard edition on a Windows 2000 OS which utilizes VMWARE? This has been the install from hell !! I just did the whole process on my Windows XP laptop in about 1 hour and the VMWARE Windows

  • Need to reinstall Windows 7 but cannot

    So about 2 years ago the hard drive randomly blew on my Aspire 5252 and since it was out of warranty at the time I didn't progress with repairing it or even acknowledge the fact it didn't come with any recovery disks. TIme has passed and I need to ge

  • Why is the giving me this error (method does not return a value) PLEASE !!

    I have this code and it is giving me this error and I don't know how to fix it can anyone out there tell me why I have included the next line of code as I have had problems in the curly brackets in the past. The error is "Client.java": Error #: 466 :

  • LibNodeManager.so could not be found

    Hi, I'm pretty new to WL so bear with me. I'm trying to start the node manager in my development environment and keep getting the following error. I'm %100 sure that the file exists in the path mentioned and every dir leading up to it has r/w permiss