Copy or Recompress in Media Manager??

Hi,
First, thanks to everybody who help out here in the forum!
I have a question:
We have a big project in the pipeline including 4 projects of each 350GB of HDV1080i50 material on different discs. We want to copy these 4 projects using the media manager and delete unused material to move it into one editing station for final editing. We will stay in HDV native editing.
In media manager, if I choose "Copy" and "Delete unused material" the estimated final size after the copy will be around 70% of the original project.
But if I keep the same settings for "Delete unused material" BUT use "Recompress" instead of "Copy" I get a much smaller estimated project (less than 25% of the original project!) using the same format as the native project (HDV1080i50)
I want to get down is size to save discspace, but please explain:
1. What is the difference between the two settings Copy and Recompress? Why does the estimated size change?
2. Since the Recompress-option will give me a smaller file-size I would like to go for this one, but is it a bad thing to recompress the material to the format (HDV1080i50) as it allready is in??
I appreciate your input on this. Thank you very much!
Best regards from Sweden.
/chris

Hey Jerry, thanks for your reply.
I actually did 2 tests. One with the setting for Recompress and one with Copy, and they turned out to have the same file-size!!
So conclusion: the estimated size that media manager gives for the Recompress-setting for HDV is FALSE. It turned out that the Recompress-setting gave me the same size as the Copy-setting and nothing less. So: I guess I have to trust the copy-setting and go for that one without recompressing.
Thanks you for your input!!
/Chris

Similar Messages

  • Media Manager won't recompress as MOV from AVI

    I have hours and hours of AVI files that were captured on a PC before I switched over. When I import into FCP, I get a warning saying the files aren't "optimized" for FCP, and that I should recompress using Media Manager.
    I use Media Manager -- I choose recompress, and pick my destination, but it only creates more AVI files, not MOV files, and I can't figure out why?
    When I try to import these new AVI files into my project, I get the same optimization warning... what am I doing wrong? (using FCP 5.1.4)

    How about trying to convert in Quicktime rather than Media Mangler?

  • Media manager ambiguities

    Hi. I have a project in which I have large uncompressed files I obtained from MPEG Streamclip. A lot of this footage I don't need and have been trying to use media manager to delete the parts of the files I'm not using. I have tried a number of ways using the 'use existing' pull down menu but the original and modified bars don't seem to change.Any ideas?

    If you're tryng to delete media you can't use 'use existing'. FCP can't delete part of an existing file, the media manager doesn't work like that. You have to use 'copy' and then the media manager will make a new media file with just the bit you want leaving you free to delete the original, full media file.

  • FCP 7.0.3 Media Manager crashing during copy

    I want to copy the used media from a project (used media is on an internal hard drive) to an external RAID drive using Media Manager in its "copy" mode.  I do this when I have finished a project to "archive" the keeper video so I can clear up space on my scratch drive for the next import.
    Media Manager starts OK but then crashes about 20 to 30 minutes into the copy process.  Both the source and destination disk look OK in Disk Utility.  Neither are full.
    Tried with two different projects - both crash.  Projects appear to be OK and successfully exported when last accessed.
    Done this many times successfully in recent months.  Only change I can think of is recent upgrade to OS.
    Any thoughts on how to work out what is causing the problem.
    FCP 7.0.3
    OS X 10.6.8
    6 Core Intel Xeon
    24Gb RAM

    It is the darndest thing.  You know when you take your car to the mechanic and report a problem but then the problem mysteriously disappears, well, after I put up the post above, I ran Media Manager for the 5th time to get the error details when it crashes  - AND IT DID NOT CRASH!  I have just run the Media Manager copy successfully on 3 projects.  Crashed 5 times, ran successfully 3 times.  And I did not change anything.  Weird?
    Sorry to bother.
    Regards
    Peter

  • I want to use media manager to make a copy of a sequence

    I want to only copy the media in s 1 minute sequence and create a new project in media manager.  It seems to only want to do the entire project.  Goes from 350 gigs to 350 gigs.  What am I doing wrong?

    Actually Shane, I'm not sure that's always true.  I've done a bunch of media manages within the last year where things such as audio files didn't have reels associated with them and everything seemed to work ok.
    I'll do a quick test and see what happens.
    That said, you ALWAYS need to test the integrity of your media manage BEFORE deleting any files or starting on any mission criticial process. 

  • Instruction book say go to verizon wireless to get free copy of media manager so I can connect phone to computer. Can't find listing

    Instruction book say go to verizon wireless to get free copy of media manager so I can connect phone to computer. Can't find listingfor the soft ware. It has one to send it to the cloud, but I want to save & edit it on my computer.

    Try this:  http://products.verizonwireless.com/index.aspx?id=fnd_backupAssistantPlus

  • Media Manager can not copy file error 47

    In editing a program together, I converted a powerpoint presentation using keynote into a Quicktime movies using the DV settings. All well and good and I have output this to tape and DVD. Now, when I try to use Media Manager to make a trimmed down archival copy with extraneous materials removed, the program reports it cannot copy this DV movie. The error reported is 47. What's up?
    I am using a completely upgraded FCP 4.5 on a G5 with 1.5 GB RAM and hard disk space galore.

    Through my research I believe the "error 47" must relate to an imcompatible frame rate from your native sequence frame rate. I've done the tests and once I changed the frame rate of the problem clip(through conversion), I no longer had any problems.
    Where is there a list of these error codes? That would be nice.

  • Media Manager, Recompressing...

    I'm attempting to combine my spanned clips does any one know if there is a way within media manager to do this. So that I can conform to ProRess and combine clips at the same time, while still saving existing timecode.
    Thanks,
    Jeremiah

    Thanks for the reply, code c doesn't matter I was just wanting to see if there was a setting or button in the media manager, that i've overlooked, that would combine the clips, I know I can re compress into whatever I want but, it re compresses an exact copy of the clip, it won't combine clips which is what I was hoping it would, Do.
    Thanks anyways

  • Media manager won't recompress media

    I have some h264 .mp4 files that I want to recompress into motion jpeg files for offline editing on my Macbook Pro. I select the Media Manager options specified in the FCP Manual -- "Recompress using Offline RT (photo JPEG)," etc. -- but Media Manager won't recompress the files. It just copies the .mp4 project over to the project media folder that it creates.
    I think I did this in the past and it worked, but it isn't working now. I also tried recompressing to Apple Intermediate Codec, and that isn't working either. I'm using FCP 5.1.4.
    I can do the job by exporting individual files from Quicktime Pro but would much rather do it all at once with FCP. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
    Thanx,
    Ralph

    These are files from an SD card camera so have no natural reel numbe
    Well, if you use Log and Transfer then FCP will assign it one. I use L&T for P2 and for the footage from my Canon DSLR, and FCP assigns it the name of the folder that I offloaded the SD card onto. Which is why I give the folders unique names...tape names.
    Maybe FCP won't recompress properly as you aren't using an editing codec to begin with. "I have some h264 .mp4 files that I want to recompress into motion jpeg files for offline editing on my Macbook Pro." H.264 isn't designed for editing, so it might not work right. First convert to ProRes 422, then media manage smaller.
    Shane

  • Custom media manager recompress setting

    I would like to start using Media Manager to recompress projects I've worked on in the past. Is there anyway I can create a preset that can be transferred from one computer to another? Ideally I would create this setting and share it with a friend.

    No. Just send him a screen shot.

  • Media Manager in FCPX?

    Hey everyone,
    I couldn't find this addressed anywhere so if it has been already, I apologize.
    Does anyone know if there is the FCP 7 equivalent of the Media Manager option in FCPX?  I'll explain my situation...
    I work in a high school and cut highlight reels for our football players.  By the end of the season I have literally hundreds of GBs of footage on my hard drive.  In FCP 7 I would import all of the footage into my project and then cut out only the plays I needed.  I would end up with a 5 minute video.  I wanted to save the project in case the player wanted any changes down the line and I also wanted to back it up in case of a hard drive crash.  What I would do is run it through Media Manager so that the whole project would compress down and only copy the files that were actually used in the video.  I would end up with a project and copied reference files that only took up a few GBs at most.  That was easy to archive and back up.
    I'm cutting highlight reels this year using FCPX for the first time.  I've finished the first one and have been genuinely happy with the workflow of the actual edit.  Somethings have been much easier for me.  However, as I'm wrapping up the first couple, I went to recompress them using to Media Manager to archive and back up and can't find the equivalent in FCPX.  I've searched around a bit and also can't find anyone who has already addressed this issue. 
    Anyone out there having this same issue and found a solution?  It would be a huge help...

    dknight38 wrote:
    …  would end up with a project and copied reference files that only took up a few GBs at most.   …
    … for one player.-
    I fully understand what you'd like to accomplish.
    but - theoretically - with your method you save the same material again and again:
    aside close-ups, you frame more than one player in a sequence.
    with FCPX actual method, that single Event serves many Projects.
    so, you SAVE space without consolidating every Project.
    plus, the 'duplicate Project' dialog allows you to transfer a Project and only USED clips to some ext drive.... keep that version, and erase original Project & Events.

  • Question:   What about Media Manager?

    Is there any equivalent to Media Manager in FCPX?   What we had wasn't perfect, but was incredibly useful.

    So in other words, No.  There's no way to trim unused media while copyng, no way to recompress the media copied to a different codec during the xfer, no way to add handles to media copies - none of the good functionality available in FCP 7.   Media management is completely essential to any editing app, and FCPX doesn't have any.

  • Media Manager - After Effects - Quality

    Hi,
    I'm not exactly sure where to ask this, so I'm asking here.
    I'm editing a ProRes 422 sequence in Final Cut. If I 'copy' media using Media Manager, getting rid of the unused portions (while keeping 2 sec handles), will there be a loss of quality in the newly produced clips?
    Also, If I correct one portion of the image in After Effects CS5 (such as removing an object in one small part of the image) and export to ProRes, will there be a quality loss in the parts of the image that were untouched?
    Do these processes affect the untouched portions of the clips or are they identical to the original?
    Thanks for any information.
    Matt

    If I 'copy' media using Media Manager, getting rid of the unused portions (while keeping 2 sec handles), will there be a loss of quality in the newly produced clips?
    Shouldn't be. This is just a COPY but within parameters. ONLY THIS PART OF THE CLIP. No recompression. But don't take my word for it. TEST it. See for yourself.
    If I correct one portion of the image in After Effects CS5 (such as removing an object in one small part of the image) and export to ProRes, will there be a quality loss in the parts of the image that were untouched?
    Slight loss of quality in the WHOLE image, as you are recompressing. And you won't just lose it in the area you are treating, but the WHOLE clip. Because you are exporting the whole clip. But ProRes is designed to hold up to 10 recompressions before you can see it. Again, test and see for yourself.
    Shane

  • Media Manager Error Codes

    Anyone happen to know where to get a list of Final Cut Pro's Media Manager error codes?
    I've been recompressing footage to get it to work in Color (no idea what's wrong with the original footage, but this seemed to fix the problem) and every now and then one of the clips gives me an error code 20.
    If I click "retry" in the resulting dialog box, it seems to just go along on it's way without any further problems, but I'm curious as to what exactly this error code is and if it has anything to do with the problems I've been having with Color.
    Thanks!

    Thanks for your reply, I think I have figured out what 20 and 34 are in my case anyway. My Story....
    Had a hard drive die on me with my project on it, sent it off and got it recovered but when I got it back I have to put all the .mov, .jpg.. etc back onto the files. Well this caused me heaps of problems because FCP did not want to automatically reconnect my media even after copying and deleting the file extension. So I had to reconnect my media manually which was ok but big pain. Accidentally some files got reconnected on the time line to the wrong media with the .mov extension and other without files extension got reconnected to the bin. Error 34 is duplicate files with the same name, when it tried to compact the files regardless of the fact one had .mov and one did not the OS sees it as the same file and we all know you cant have the same file in a folder twice. I noticed also that 20 was the same problem but it happened when a video had unlinked audio. So I fixed it by reconnected all the files that had errors to the files that had no .mov.
    Error 14 has to do with my .jpg not sure what but they don't worry me because I can just move and connected them manually.
    I hope this helps someone.
    cheers.

  • Another media manager issue

    Has anyone used the recompress option to convert the project to H.264 or MPEG4??? What I found was that if you choose the DV codec, the OfflineRT, or any other presets in the pulldown list, it works. But if you choose custom and select a codec that is not listed in the presets such as MPEG4 and H.264, it reports a "general error". I can't seem to figure it out but I do need to send a rather large project to someone via DVD or DVDs. Any help is appreciated.

    I wouldn't do what you're trying to do.
    Are you trying to send them a completed show? Export to QuickTime then use Compressor to get to H.264 or MPEG4.
    But if you're simply sending someone else your PROJECT, as in the project file and the media it uses, then what you're doing (if it worked) will kill the media quality. Keep the codec the same as your media is now, media manage the sequence to a location then start copying the files in that location to DVD. Use Apple's Backup program for example.

Maybe you are looking for