Difference in TIFF and RAW import with ACR (how to fix)?

I'm experimenting with a workflow, so whilst this may seem like an odd thing to want to make work, I have a geniune reason for doing what's described below:
I have Canon CR2 RAW files from a 7D, Photoshop CS6 13.01 64bit, with ACR 7.1.0.354, running on Windows 7 64bit.
1. I import a CR2 image via ACR, with no changes to any sliders; opening it as Adobe RGB (1998); 16bit
2. I then save the image as a TIFF file, leaving "ICC Profile: Abode RGB (1998)" selected in the Color section of the file save dialog
3. If I then close all files, and reopen the CR2 and TIFF image, they (as expected) appear to be identical
4. After closing all files again, I then open the CR2 and make an exposure adjustment (e.g. -1.00)
5. Using Bridge, I select the TIFF file, right click and select Open in Camera Raw. I make the same exposure adjustment as for the CR2
6. Now, the adjusted CR2 and adjusted TIFF are different. A colour shift is noticable, and for a severe exposure change (i.e. +4.00) the shadow detail in the CR2 is a lot lighter
Here are two cropped areas from the files (with a 4 stop push), showing some branch/leaf and grass detail respectively. The TIFF has a greener colour cast for the grass, but much darker shadows:
TIFF
RAW
I appreciate that the CR2 is still a RAW file, and as such has the original Bayer pattern data, but is there any way I can make ACR adjustments to a TIFF (taken from a CR2) to behave in the same way as the original CR2?

ssprengel, Jeff, JJMack - thanks for the constructive replies
station_two - after your use of mildly aggressive language ("What seems to escape your grasp") in your first post, I had money that your subsequent response(s) would be on the lines of "I'm too busy to explain it to people like you". Thankyou for confirming my expectations (sometimes I wonder if some people engage in forum discussions for the sole purpose of trying to get themselves [and possibly others] riled)
So... back to trying to find a construcive solution: If the algorthirms for the adjustments in ACR do operate directly on the Bayer data (before demosiacing to RGB per pixel) then operating on the TIFF (or any other demosaiced RGB data) will indeed be a non-starter. Without (probably unlikely) input from an Adobe developer however, we can't know for sure.
> So RAW numbers after debayering to RGB are linear with numbers of photons within a particular color (R, G or B), while TIF numbers are assumed to be linear with human-vision sensitivity
Understood (I'm familiar with gamma, camera sensor behaviour, exposing to the right etc). Ultimately though, it should be possible to produce an RGB file that is also linear (i.e. not adjusted for human vision) to then bring back into ACR. However, if that's simply not possible with ACR, then that's also a non-starter (and wouldn't help anyway if the adjustments operate on the Bayer data directly).
I did look briefly into opening the RAW as a smart object, but sadly I didn't think that'd help. The goal I'm trying to achieve is an experimental idea to blend parts of images together from multiple exposures; but to achieve a single RAW file with that data as if it came from the camera (thus it could be brought into ACR to get the benefit of - from my point of view - the useful and intuitive adjustment sliders). Clearly that would require reverse engineering the particular RAW format for the camera being used (and each and every camera you'd want to support) - thus, it's not really practical.
I'd hoped to be able to convert (without edits) the RAW images into TIFF (or some other lossless RGB container that I can read programmatically), do the blending to produce a single TIFF, and then bring that back into ACR.
Whilst it's more convoluted, I suppose it might be possible to generate the unedited TIFF files purely for the purposes for getting data about the images, then using that to create a set of masks. Then, as Jeff suggests, perform adjustments to the RAW files in ACR, and use the masks to blend the imported (and now corrected) RAWs into one image. Not ideal, but perhaps worthy of more experimentation.

Similar Messages

  • I have my camera (Canon 5D MARK 2) set to take both JPEG Large and Raw files with each shot. I uploaded the images from the card to my Pro (Aperture 3) and while the import info said 1500 images were uploaded, I can't find the RAW images.  Aperture put ab

    I have my camera (Canon 5D Mark 2) set to take both JPEG Large and Raw files with each shot. I uploaded the images from the card to my Pro (Aperture 3) and while the import info said 1500 images were uploaded, I can't find the RAW images.  Aperture put about 700 images in an untitled project folder, but all the images are the JPEGs.  What am I missing?
    Thanks,
    upsjdris

    Have you checked your "Import" settings for "Raw&Jpeg" pairs in the "Import" panel?
    You can set Aperture to import raw, jpeg, or raw&jpeg.
    If you imported Raw&Jpeg, but have set Aperture to use the Jpeg as original, you will see the imported image as Jpeg image, not as a raw image, even if the raw has also been imported. You can switch between Raw and Jpeg originals for selected images from the Photos menu:
    Photos > Use Raw as original.
    Regards
    Léonie

  • Photo Stream only supports JPEG, PNG, TIFF and RAW files.

    I'm using Panasonic LX3 with its RAW format (a supported RAW format since sometimes with iPhoto '09 already)
    When I choose to Photo Stream my images after import with iPhoto '11, it says "Photo Stream only supports JPEG, PNG, TIFF and RAW files."
    My files are RAW formats so why can't I photo stream it?!
    Is there something I can get around or need to wait for Apple to support this?!

    You don;t have a preset set. What you are seeing is normal behavior when importing Raw files.
    What you see at first is the camera produced JPG preview imbedded in the Raw file. Aperture puts this up while it decodes the actual Raw data. This JPG has all the special settings and enhancements set on the camera and is basically the image that would be produced if you were shooting JPG.
    As a rule none of the settings on the camera (apart from the basics) are applied to the Raw file though some of the newer cameras have settings that could affect the data stored in the Raw file.
    This is a often asked question by those just getting into Raw and you can search the discussions here for other answers to this question.
    Given the capability of today's cameras, especially the high-end ones, a lot of users have decided to abandon Raw as unnecessary  if they are happy with the images the camera produces. It's all a matter of personal needs.
    regards

  • 10.4.11 autoupdate killed tiffs and raw files - REPAIRMENT HOW?

    Hi there!
    I got big problems when I was updating from os 10.4.10 to 10.4.11 - everything crashed and I had to install everything new - I decided to take a new harddisk as well, but when I copied the rest of the stuff from the old one, I had to realise that several tiffs and raw files were damaged in a way that "preview" can handle them, but no other programm (no photoshop, or capture one). Is there any possibility to get those stuff back working well?
    Thank you for all your help!!!
    Yours,
    Joerg

    Thanks for that,
    I downloaded RPP and it does indeed open the RAW files and lets me convert them into TIFFs or JPGs which I can then import into Photoshop to play with.  However I'm still confused about why I can't open them in Photoshop directly.  My other camera is a SLR saving to a SanDisk Extreme lll Compact Flash card and I can open RAW files off that on the same computer with no problem using a Photoshop RAW converter plug-in.

  • Difference Between Export and Direct Import Process.

    Hi SD Gurus,
    Can anyone help to understnad difference betwenn Export and Direct Import Process.

    Hi,
    export = out of the system or country
    import = into the system or country
    For example in SAP-ABAP
    On the EXPORT side
    DATA: ls_indx TYPE indx.
    ls_indx-aedat = sy-datum.
    ls_indx-usera = sy-uname.
    ls_indx-pgmid = 'ZNAME'.
    EXPORT tab = lt_orders
    TO DATABASE indx(v1)
    FROM ls_indx ID 'PERCENT'.
    On the IMPORT side
    DATA: ls_indx TYPE indx.
    ls_indx-aedat = sy-datum.
    ls_indx-usera = sy-uname.
    ls_indx-pgmid = 'ZNAME'.
    IMPORT tab = lt_orders
    FROM DATABASE indx(v1)
    TO ls_indx ID 'PERCENT'
    Regards,
    Raj

  • I tried updating my iphone 4s to the ios 7 but it said error with the firmware now my phone is stuck in recovery mode and i have no idea how to fix it any suggestions??

    i tried updating my iphone 4s to the ios 7 but it said error with the firmware now my phone is stuck in recovery mode and i have no idea how to fix it any suggestions??

    Try Restoring it 3 times in a row and see if that works.
    If not that error can indicate one of two things: Your iPhone was at one time jailbroken, had the iOS version rolled back, or ran an unauthorized beta and if none of those things are true it is a hardware error.

  • My external hard drives seem to be mixed up in lr4 and I don't know how to fix them

    My external hard drives seem to be mixed up in lr4 and I don't know how to fix them! Help!

    The file opened and cropped in photoshop was a camera raw file?
    In File>Save for Web pick Jpeg from the drop-down

  • When i press "Alt" imac runs the command "duplicate" or "copy". It interferes with work, how to fix it?

    Good day!
    I have this problem: when i press "Alt" my imac runs the command "duplicate" or "copy". It interferes with work, how to fix it?
    Thank you.

    Hi, thank you!
    For example when I work in Nuke, and press "option" (for navigation), after I will release the "option", selected node will be duplicated.
    The same issue, but with copying happens when I'm working in blender and hold the "option" to navigate - I see the message "copied selected objects to buffer".
    Maybe it's some additions to the finder, which I could set a long time ago? In any case, how to fix it?
    Thanks in advance!

  • Why all of a sudden am I having difficulty sending Gmail emails? I get a send error. When I run diagnostics there is a SMTP and IMAP account for Gmail and I am not sure how to fix this.

    Why all of a sudden am I having difficulty sending Gmail emails? I get a send error. When I run diagnostics there is a SMTP and IMAP account for Gmail and I am not sure how to fix this.

    Hi jodilynnf,
    When using Connection Doctor to see what is could be causing the issue, look for the red dots to let you know what is wrong. Then all you have to do is correct that information. You can double click on the section that is giving you issue and it will take you there. Most issues could be just password being entered incorrectly. Take a look at the article below to walk you through troubleshooting issues with Mail.
    OS X Mail: Troubleshooting sending and receiving email messages
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/TS3276
     Take it easy,
    -Norm G.

  • I'm trying to order a calendar off iphoto and have never had any issues, now it wont allow me to input a canadian address for ordering  help help help this is an xmas gift and i have no idea how to fix this have tried numerous things

    I'm trying to order a calendar off iphoto and have never had any issues, now it wont allow me to input a canadian address for ordering  help help help this is an xmas gift and i have no idea how to fix this have tried numerous things

    No I didn't even read through your post, to long.
    You said that "No matter what program I try to install, as soon as the installer opens it crashes". Were you talking about the install for this/these 3D programs or ANY program? As it is worded it sounded like ANY program. That tells me there is a problem with your Mac, software or hardware.
    Now you say others install programs, which is it. Programs other then the 3D ones install or no programs install?
    Could simply be your Mac is to old to run these programs and the installer knows that. You never said what model or year Mac it is.

  • I right clked on View Background I..., now I cannot see any of the pictures on Facebook and I don't know how to fix it

    I right clicked on my mouse and clicked View Background I..., now I cannot see any of the profile pictures or images on Facebook and I don't know how to fix it. Everything is normal on Google Chrome.

    See:
    * [[Images or animations do not show]]
    * http://kb.mozillazine.org/Images_or_animations_do_not_load
    *A way to see which images are blocked is to click the favicon ([[Site Identity Button]]) on the left end of the location bar.
    *A click on the "More Information" button will open the Security tab of the "Page Info" window (also accessible via "Tools > Page Info").
    *Go to the <i>Media</i> tab of the "Tools > Page Info" window.
    *Select the first image link and scroll down though the list with the Down arrow key.
    *If an image in the list is grayed and there is a check-mark in the box "<i>Block Images from...</i>" then remove that mark to unblock the images from that domain.

  • I have a canon MP610 printer and it is always offline and i don't know how to fix it. I have a mac lion.

    I have canon mp610 printer connected to my mac lion pc...It is always offline and i don't know how to fix this problem.

    Does File > Work Offline has a check mark when that happens?
    You can try to create a new Boolean pref with the name network.manage-offline-status and set the value to false.<br />
    Right-click on the about:config page to open the right-click context menu and use "New > Boolean" to create a new Boolean pref.
    Name: network.manage-offline-status
    Value: false
    See also http://kb.mozillazine.org/about%3Aconfig

  • I updated Xcode 5 to Xcode 6.0.1. It messed up my previous apps and i don't know how to fix it. Is it possible to uninstall Xcode 6 and go back to Xcode 5?

    Hello,
    I updated Xcode 5 to Xcode 6.0.1. It messed up my previous apps and i don't know how to fix it. Is it possible to uninstall Xcode 6 and go back to Xcode 5?

    I found this solution http://objcsharp.wordpress.com/2014/09/21/how-to-get-back-the-ios-7-sdk-after-up grading-to-xcode-6/

  • In Firefox can not see the Downloads window, in the jump in the boot to be seen - the download speed Downloaded much and now can not see how to fix it?

    in Firefox can not see the Downloads window, in the jump in the boot to be seen - the download speed
    Downloaded much and now can not see how to fix it?

    I hate the new downloads-in-a-tab scheme. This was an unnecessary change in my book (if it aint broke, don't "fix it").
    So in order to get it back, I performed the about:config browser.download.useToolkitUI change, but now all I get is a blank download window that pops up every time I download something.
    Is there something else that I need to do? I've checked the change and it was saved, but it didn't resolve my issue as much as it just caused me a new issue.

  • My ant video player after i updated to firefox four is now in the upper part of the screen where it opens up and i cant find out how to fix it

    my ant video player after i updated to firefox four is now in the upper part of the screen where it opens up and i cant find out how to fix it

    Create a new profile as a test to check if your current profile is causing the problems.
    See "Basic Troubleshooting: Make a new profile":
    *https://support.mozilla.com/kb/Basic+Troubleshooting#w_8-make-a-new-profile
    There may be extensions and plugins installed by default in a new profile, so check that in "Tools > Add-ons > Extensions & Plugins" in case there are still problems.
    If that new profile works then you can transfer some files from the old profile to that new profile, but be careful not to copy corrupted files.
    See:
    *http://kb.mozillazine.org/Transferring_data_to_a_new_profile_-_Firefox

Maybe you are looking for

  • How to read .mdb file from shared folder

    Hi All, In one of my local computer I have a shared folder and within the folder I have a .mdb file. Now I am trying to read that file from MII. I have tried with Get_File_List action block. I am providing the following information to Get_File_List F

  • Ical list view comes up blank

    has anybody had the following issue: opening the ical app on the phone, if it is in 'List' view, then the screen will be blank. if you switch to Day or Month view and then back to List again, then the entries display normally. i didnt have this issue

  • Error while data loading in BI

    Hi gurus, Our BI team is unable to load data from BI staging to BI Target.There is no data in BI Targets because of this Users can not test the BI reports. when they run it the header file status shows yellow instead of green. Please help. Regards, P

  • How do I get Premiere Elements to work?

    Have purchased Photoshop/Premiere Elements combo package in box. Have serial numbers for both. Premier's doesn't work. (Photoshop is fine.) Have tried to download Premiere trial and access with my serial number. Download assistant only offers Premier

  • Error No receiver could be determined in PI71

    hello Expert, i am testing a sample scenario with  proxy->xi->file application BC6, xi server PI71 configuration test is okey. i used the BC(BS_File) is as the sender and receiver but after run,  the sender name in the record in sxmb_moni is changed