Disk Utility formats Hard Drives as Logical Volume Group

I just replaced a hard drive which had died in my Mac Pro which has OS X 10.9.5. To format the new 3TB hard drive I went to Disk Utility. I used "Erase" in its fastest form and the drive was formatted with the Type: Logical Volume Group.
I remember this was a problem a few years ago when I first put hard drives in this computer. I think it was considered a bug in the Disk Utility in OS X 10.8 that it would automatically format drives greater than 2 TB as Logical Volume Group. The solution for me was to restart the computer with my OS X 10.6 disk and use the Disk Utility in that to reformat the drive. I never really understood why Logical Volume Group was a problem but I just obeyed what the wise ones of the Internet had to say.
So, now I am wondering if I should reformat my new Hard Drive as GUID using my OS X 10.6 optical disk again? If it was a bug in the Disk Utility of OS X 10.8 then why is it not fixed in the Disk Utility of OS X 10.9? Is there an actual problem with having disks format formatted as Logical Volume Group? Is this now just Apple's way of doing things?
Thank you.

keg55 wrote:
You could do your reformat using your 10.6 DVD. That's a decision that's up to you.
Not every bug in a previous OS gets fixed in a new OS.
I don't believe CoreStorage (Logical Volume Group) causes any sort of issues. Whenever one encrypts their Macintosh HD, the format is converted to CoreStorage. Fusion Drives are using CoreStorage and now Yosemite converts portables (laptops) to CoreStorage during the install process. As far as Yosemite is concerned, Apple seems to have gone the route of CoreStorage for portables. Even during the Setup on a portable, FileVault is offered with the default of YES being checked. So, if a customer isn't paying attention and continues with the install, they could encrypt their drive without knowing to uncheck the default checkbox.
Thank you for your reply.
I have decided to reformat my new hard drive using my 10.6 disk. I like being able to split it up into more than one volume if need be.
I understand that not every bug in a previous OS gets fixed, but this strikes me as being really a very large bug, so I think it would be good if Apple addressed it.
It is useful to know about Yosemite's behaviour. When I upgrade to Yosemite I will be a bit more prepared. In fact my MacBook Pro has FileVault on with Mavericks so Yosemite won't change anything there.

Similar Messages

Hard drive is missing. I can boot from the cd but when running the disk utility, no hard drive shows up.

Hard drive is missing. I can boot from the cd but when running the disk utility, no hard drive shows up.
This is a problem that suddenly appeared.

Please post a screenshot of Disk Utility that shows what you mean. Be careful not to include any private information.
Start a reply to this message. Click the camera icon in the toolbar of the editing window and select the image file to upload it. You can also include text in the reply.

Disk utility/external hard drive failure

I have a MacBook that I got about two years ago and a Western Digital portable external hard drive (WD Passport) that's almost as old. I keep almost all of my music files on my external hard drive and then play them through iTunes. About a month ago my external hard drive stopped working. I plug the hard drive into my computer and the blue light comes on. It even shines brighter for several seconds as (it appears) the hard drive attempts to mount. But every time I do this the blue light then becomes dimmer and the drive never mounts. When the hard drive is plugged in and I open up the Disk Utility application the drive shows up. When I try to manually mount the disk it tries and fails. When I click "Verify Disk" it tries and then an error message pops up saying "Phase 1-Read FAT, Unable to read FAT (Input/output error)". I've read that the PC disk utility application may be better at reading drives so, once I'm in a place where I have access to a PC, I'm going to give that a try. Does anyone have any other suggestions?

I am assuming that you're using the Passport in the same USB port that you always have. I ask this because some people complain about USB devices working on one port but not the other, as they claim that one port may put out more voltage then the other. If this is happening in your case it would kinda make since as when you plug in the Passport all that is required is the logic board power then it will start to spin up the disk which will pull down the power and that may be why you're getting a dimmed light on the Passport.
Just try the other USB port to verify, I know it sounds silly but it's worth a shot.

Disk Utility and Hard Drive replacement on MacBook.

I am preparing to upgrade the hard drive on my MacBook and I was reading this document http://manuals.info.apple.com/en/MacBook13inch_HardDriveDIY.pdf and a the end after installing the hard drive and preparing to install Mac OS X the directions state the following: "Leave the Disk Utility application open, and restore the backed up files from the image you created before removing the hard drive.". I think that this would be a much quicker option then having to re install every application and copy over back up user data. My question is how do I create an image of the contents of the hard drive to use once I upgrade the drive?

I'd just clone (make a complete bootable backup) the internal to a backup external drive, swap out the internal, then clone back. That way you wouldn't have to do any installations.
To backup (clone) your main drive, you can use the donationware CarbonCopy Cloner @ http://www.bombich.com/software/ccc.html , or the shareware SuperDuper @ http://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/SuperDuperDescription.html , or the freeware IBackup @ http://www.grapefruit.ch/iBackup/index.html, or the Restore function of Disk Utility included in OS X.

Canceled making a new image in Disk Utility, lost hard drive space

Hi,
I was creating a new image (12 gigs) and during the process of creating it, the bar was no longer moving (for over an hour) so i canceled the process (it got a about 1/4 of the way through). But now it seems I missing about 3 gigs of space on my hard drive. It seems when it got canceled, it didnt remove it all the way. Is there a way to fix this?
Thanks

I restarted the computer, and it did not change. I ran all the terminal commands on that website, but nothing fishy came up. After i ran the disk usage command (sudo du -cxhd 1 /) it totalled up to 51 gigs of data. I have an 80 gig HD (79.68gigs) which should leave 29 gigs available. Finder says i have 24.17 gigs available, so I am missing some. maybe this is virtual memory being used? It seems like it happened after the image though. Thanks

Disk utility says hard drive is corrupt - can't restart in recovery HD utility

I have OS X 10.9.3 mini mac. I ran my disk utility to verify disk and I get this message:The volume Macintosh HD was found corrupt and needs to be repaired. Error: This disk need to be repaired using the Recovery HD. Restart your computer holding down the command and R key...but when I try it just restarts my mac it doesn't restart in Recovery HD utility. What should I do?

Try the option key during the startup sound. If you have a recovery hd, this should show you and let you select it.
Is it a wireless keyboard you are using?
Also have a look at this for additional suggestions.
http://support.apple.com/kb/ht4718
http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4811

Disk utility copying hard drive, can I use computer for other tasks

I had backup my entire hard drive and its taking forever, can I use other apps and continue to work ?
Thanks for any help!!

Best not, as files may be moved and therefore may upset the backup.

HT201071 RAW does not work in Mavericks after disk utility repaired hard drive

This worked until I had to repair a corrupted section of the hard drive, now Nikon Camera RAW files do not work for Aperture, Photoshop or even viewing in the finder. Is there a way to download just the RAW file compatability?

The latest download I could find is Digital Camera RAW Compatibility Update 5.04. Others are linked from this Apple - Support - Search. Or consider OS X Mavericks: Reinstall OS X to get all the latest software in one step.
(If you haven't already done so, set your OS X Mavericks: App Store preferences to automatically check for updates so your Mac will advise you when future Apple updates like these become available.)

Disk Utility-Ext Hard Drive Locked and no options to unlock-only visible in Disk Utility- 500GB freeagent

Running latest OS

I never received a reply to this, so I'm marking it as 'answered' just to close it out.

How Will Yosemite Logical Volume Group Affect Two-Partition Drive?

After installing Yosemite, my Macintosh HD became a Logical Volume Group. Now, in Disk Utility, both the Drive and the Volume have the same name — Macintosh HD. I want to use one of two partitions on an extra internal drive in my Mac Pro (Mid 2010) as a bootable clone of my Yosemite startup drive, using SuperDuper!. When cloning is complete, will my spare drive become a Logical Volume Group with a renamed drive? Will that effect the other partition, which is a bootable Mavericks clone?

Thanks for the tip. I see its a common trouble. But i stuck a problem that cannot be solved with this method cause i dont have revertable logic volume.
SO i cannot install system now. There's no visible disk any more.

Disk Utility: No Mac Drive in Internal HDD. Can't format or erase.

Hey guys, I just got my new mac mini and I installed a Samsung pro 840 SSD. The thing is I messed up. I turned my mac on and everything went fine, Disk Utility showed up telling me that the drive was "unreadable". I decided to turn the thing off and start Recovery so I could install Mountain Lion onto the SSD. When igot to Recovery, disk utility told me there was an error with the drives and it had to erase them, while it was working I got the The Spinning Rainbow Beach Ball of Death so I turned my mac off. Huge mistake it seems. Now when I want to install Mountain Lion there is no available disk to install it. I started Internet Recovery and accessed Disk Utility again and the Internal Drive actually appears but with nothing installed in it. The option to erase or format are not available. I did a disk verification and repair and everything was OK. I'm going crazy over this. Please help me guys!!! I'm leaving a picture so its clearer. THANK YOU!!

Being a new Mac Mini the system is attempting to create a Fusion Drive setup out of your SSD. Do you have dual drives in the system, the built-in one in addition to the new one you installed?
This is an issue with the new Mac Mini and iMac systems (see here: http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-57584237-263/disk-utility-may-combine-custo m-drive-setups-on-some-macs/) as these systems ship with Fusion Drive setups and Disk Utility assumes this is the desired setup when you use it to "fix" the drives.
You can see that when you select "Internal Drive" the type is "Logical Volume Group." Since this group is greater than the 840GB, my guess is this is the combined space from your SSD and the built-in one.
To clear this issue, open the Terminal (from the Utilities menu in the OS X installer), and run the following command:
diskutil cs list
You will see a tree of information, with one grouping showing a UUID for the Logical Volume Group (the UUID will be a string of numbers and letters, separated by several dashes).
With this UUID, run the following command to destroy the logical volume group (you can try copying and pasting the UUID, though I"m not sure if the services in the Recovery HD partition support copy and paste--otherwise just type it in manually):
diskutil cs delete UUID
When finished, follow the instructions in the artifcle I linked to above to install OS X to an external drive (if available) and use Disk Utility there to fix and manage the drives, as opposed to the version in the Recovery HD partition.

I need to sudo cs delete an encrypted hard drive but get an error "Not a valid CoreStorage Logical Volume Group UUID"

Ok so I encrypted an internal HDD with DOE compliant encryption, and forgot the password. I am not using a typical mac bootloader so apple C when its booting will not work to delete it before its mounted. I have to do it through the terminal. The drive I want to delete is HDD2. Here is the screen capture of running diskutil cs list in terminal.
Then I disconnected everything to avoid problems, leaving my encrypted HDD only, copied the UUID, it's in this format:
diskutil cs delete XXXXXXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXXXXXXXXXX
But I am unsure which group or physical UUID I need to use, there are three associated with HDD2, logical volume group, physical volume and logical volume family. I thought before pressing enter I better ask first ... as I tried it on the physical volume first and I got the error in the title so dont want to start guessing what do to.
Thanks

Is it not good form for members to advise about using the console? Surely some members are knowledgeable enough to tell me the answer to this .... I know it's easy to bork your system up totally with the console but I'm desparate, my main drive has 1GB free!

Create PXI Format Hard Drive Disk

Hello,
Can i use a "Create PXI Format Hard Drive Disk" created from LV 8.5.1 ver for formating the PXI RT controller which is having LV RT 7.1.
Regards
Aks
(Appreciate answers by giving KUDOS)
Hit the stars.............. sky is not the limit.

Hi,
I think you can, but you'll need LV (RT) 7.1 on the host PC to install LV RT 7.1 on the PXI controller using MAX after formatting it.
(Unless you have an image created by the RT replication toolkit, but then other problems might arise...)
Daniel

L305D-S5934 Has formatted hard drive, can I load recovery disk from a different machine?

Hi,
I have an older L305D (can't remember the sub group model, but it does not have the web cam). The LCD screen went out so I bought a L305D-S5934 with a formatted hard drive. I swapped my old hard drive into the new computer, but it will not boot up. It tried to recover, but that failed. Can I make a recovery disk with my old computer to use in the new one, even though they are different sub models? The new computer has a Windows license on it. If I can't make a recovery disk with the old one that will work, can I get a copy of Vista Home and use the license on the new computer to install it or does the license only work with the recovery disks? Once I have an operating system installed, I know I can get the right drivers from this website. Any help/ideas would be appreciated! I would rather not have to buy a recovery disk through Toshiba if I can avoid it.

Satellite L305D-S5934
Can I make a recovery disk with my old computer to use in the new one, even though they are different sub models?
That won't work.
can I get a copy of Vista Home and use the license on the new computer to install it or does the license only work with the recovery disks?
The OEM key won't work with a retail version of Windows. (And with the recovery discs it's unnecessary, because that one is pre-activated.)
The recovery media from Toshiba costs less than the product key for the retail installation DVD. And you don't need to mess around adding drivers and utilities.
Order Toshiba Recovery Media
-Jerry

MacBook Pro - Mac OS v10.6.8 Formatting hard drive

Hi,
I'm desperately confused (totally technologically illiterate which doesn't help!). I've just purchased a 4tb seagate expansion external harddrive and a kaiser baas HD Media Hub that I want to be able to put movies onto (off of my mac) and watch on my TV. I have figured out how to put the movies onto the hard drive but when I turn the media hub on they are not available.
I have been advised to partition the hard drive as the hub will support a maximum of 2gb (I have since partitioned my Volume Scheme to 3 partitions).
Then I was advised:-
"Another thing is, if the hard drive is formatted for a MAC computer, media hub ca not recognize it . You need to reformat that to FAT 32.
Please follow this :
Do a backup first to avoid losing contents of the hard drive when you format it
Go to 'Disk Utility' application
Select 'Erase' tab
Click the 'Volume' dropdown and select 'MSDOS'
Click Erase"
and this is where I get confused. I can open the Disk Utility application and select 'Erase' but I have no 'Volume' dropdown. Instead I have a 'Format' dropdown which offers:
Mac OS Extended (Journaled)
Mac OS Extended
Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled)
Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive)
exFAT
When I queried this I was told that when I pressed the Erase button the 'Volume' would appear in that window, but all I get is a message telling me am I aware that Erase will erase the disk.
Obviously I'm missing something but I just can't figure it out. I'd really appreciate anyone's guidance with this.
Cheers,
Kel

If you open Disk Utility, select the Media HB, and go to the Erase tab, how is it formatted now? Look at the bottom of the Disk Utility window.
Mac OS usually works best with Mac OS Extended (Journaled), not a DOS format. The screen shot show what I see in Disk Utility.
Disk Utility - Format, Erase, or Reformat a Drive

Disk Utility formats Hard Drives as Logical Volume Group

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for