Do I need faster RAID speed?

I have a clip that contains 4 layers of 4K R3D files (2 layers of masks + 1 layer of rotoscope + original layer) that are dynamically linked to After  Effects.  The  footage was shot in Redcode 36.
When I turn off GPU acceleration (so, software only), the bar goes red in  the timeline.  I activate GPU acceleration, the bar goes yellow in the  timeline.  Now, correct me if I'm wrong, but that yellow line means the  clip is now GPU accelerated and it may be possible to play it back in real  time (at some resolution...maybe 1/16?).
I play the clip.  The audio plays fine, the video doesn't play at  all, no matter what the playback resolution is set at.  It just stops  cold on the first frame.
I check Activity Monitor.  The CPU is hitting around 40% (sometimes less, sometimes more).  The RAM has a few GB free.
I'm on a 5.1 (2010) quad Mac Pro (3.2 GHz) with 32 GB RAM, and PP 5.0.3 on OSX 10.6.5.
QUESTIONS:
1  a) Is it possible that the bottle neck is the hard drive read and write speed? 
I have an external Raid drive (4 x 2TB) connected with eSata.  I tested  it with AJA System Test.  The read and write speed are 125MB (read) and 105MB (write).  Right  now, it's limited by the eSata card I have which caps everything around  125MB.  If I get something like this:  http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Newer...gy/MXPCIE6GS2/
I can get sustained rates of 220 MB (read) and 180 (write) from my external RAID drive (according to LaCie's website). 
b)  If I'm editing 4 layers of 4K files at 36 MB each, in theory, I need  sustained read and write speeds of 144MB (4 x 36MB) minimum, correct?   Am I way off base here? 
2.  Another thing that's confusing me is how the playback resolution  factors into all this.  If I set it to 1/16, what sustained read and  write speeds do I need to play back the clip (all 4 layers) in real  time? 1/16 x 144 MB = 9 MB.  Do I only need 9MB of sustained read and  write speeds to play back the clip in real time?  Is that how it works?   If so, how come I can't get it to play back in real time?
3)  Is there a software (for OSX 10.6.5) that can measure whether or not  the hard drive read and write speeds are peaking?  Apps like AJA System  Test don't measure the hard drive when in use.  I'd like to determine  if the hard drive read and write speeds are being strained/ pushed to  the max.
Any help would be appreciated.  Thanks!

I have a similar setup and use BM for I/O.
They have a great piece of software for testing drive i/os.
Tomorrow I may get on my system and get the exact figures of drive I/o that are required for what you need.
My internal array runs at around 210mbs bothways and I still get the
issue you described. So I guess if your thinking of uping your array to a similar speed
your issue may not be resolved. I did think that the yellow indicator meant it could play in RT.
I found on a Vid Tut. from Adobe TV (I couldn't find the link) I think it was "optimising your system"
It showed a yellow indicator on a timelione that could not play. They said this was due to the drives
not coping. Looking forward to a faster array when they are cheaper, I think around 300mbs should
do the job.

Similar Messages

  • Ps4 needing a minimum speed of 100 10 160 meg spee...

    Will bt be able to deliver the speed for ps4 online gaming bettween 100 to 160 meg per second minimum with virgin going to do those speeds for the same price bt infinty 2 prices and for ultra hd film download bt need to resolve this very quickly before the 29/11/2013 and virgin are going to do fttp not this fttc bt do so when will bt deliver full fiber broadband not fiber to the cabinate fiber to the premise or customers home to me to be called fiber broadband say to me from exchange to your home not the cabinate witch is not good enough to me and a load of other like minded people 

    All the news sources I can see on the net talk about needing faster upload speeds.  Standard ADSL tops out at about 1M.
    If the PS4 really needs 100M broadband to work (and I can't see any possible reason why it should) then it will be dead in the water on launch, as most people simply don't have that sort of speed and won't be able to get it.

  • I need a faster upload speed

    Hello i am wondering if i can get a faster upload speed?? faster then 5 Meg up ?? i really need it for video confranceing !!!i will pay a bit more.

    
    Are you currently on Max Turbo or Power?
    You can check your eligiblity for higher tiers by going into your MyAT&T account.
    Go here -
    https://www.att.com/olam/passthroughAction.myworld?actionType=Manage
    Once logged in, hover over the "Internet" tab. As one of the options, you should see "Change Plan." Click on that and see if there's a higher plan available.
    You may also call AT&T at 800.288.2020 and contact the sales department to discuss upgrading your plan.
     

  • Need a RAID that will work on both new and old Mac Pro

    Desperately need to expand my RAID storage, and also not quite ready to buy the new Mac Pro.   Are there any high quality 6TB+ RAID enclosures that will work on both the new and older non-firebolt Mac Pros?  I already have a sh*t load of 2TB 3.5 drives, so I only need an enclosure.  
    Even when i get the new macpro, I will use the old mac pro as a second station, so i need the RAID to work on both. 

    Why not go for a eSATA Raid and a cheap eSATA card for old Mac Pro  and get either a Thunderbolt to eSATA or USB 3.0 to eSATA adapter for your new Mac Pro? Thunderbolt to eSATA is faster, of course.
    I have a MacPower/Inxtron Hydra 4 x 2 TB eSata for example. I have a eSATA card in my Mac Pro and when I need to use it on my Retina Macbook Pro I use a USB 3.0 to eSATA adapter. Gives me about 240 MBytes/s with Raid 5.
    On the eSATAcard it's just a little bit more, like 250/260 MBytes/s.

  • Do you need a raid?

    I am getting a Mac Pro 12 Core, planning on using fcp for basic captures of small shots, maybe a minute would be the longest at 1080i pro res.
    I am hoping to use the internal 3gb/sec 1TB 7200-rpm Serial ATA drive for that (just media).
    Then Raid-5 two other internal 2tb drives for protection for system, apps & jobs, which I will be doing heavy after effects, 3d work.
    Do I even need to raid a single drive for any reason? I don't think so, but I know little about this and all of the research says you need a raid for sure for fcp.

    You can't RAID 1 drive. By definition you need two or more drives to make a RAID.
    I am hoping to use the internal 3gb/sec 1TB 7200-rpm Serial ATA drive for that (just media).
    Get a SECOND drive. Don't use the system drive. But I think you meant that.
    Then Raid-5 two other internal 2tb drives for protection for system, apps & jobs, which I will be doing heavy after effects, 3d work.
    Protection of the system? Apps? Jobs? What? No...you use a protected RAID to work on, not generally as backup. And you don't use it to back up the system and your work. Use a drive for TIME MACHINE or Super Duper (for your system drive)...but if you want a drive for backup, get a RAID 5 and work on it...or get a DROBO to back up your work.
    And you can't RAID 5 two drives. You need at least three. You gotta read up on this:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID
    Generally you have your system drive...and if you want, a drive for TIME MACHINE or other backup software. Then you have a RAID drive to store your media and work from..RAID 0 for speed (two 500GB drives show up as one 1TB drive, and the data is spread across both drives), RAID 1 for redundancy (two 500GB drives show up as one 500GB drive...the footage is mirrored on both)...or RAID 5 where you have three or more drives, and one of the drives is used as redundant backup. Typically you have 5, 8, 10 or 12 drive RAID 5 setups.
    And you MUST have a hardware card or storage box for Raid 5...if you want it to be any good. Look at www.maxxdigital.com, Caldigit.com...
    Shane

  • Restricted from purchasing services..need fast sol...

    "You are currently restricted from purchasing services or redeeming vouchers. Please contact Customer Support to review your account status."
    i contact customer service support but didnt got any useful response.
    i changed my passwords two times already and also create new account but same thing its also has been restricted from purchasing services just after 30 minutes from creating it !!!!!!!
    how to resolve this?
    please need fast solution for this as im trying to solve it from 1 week or more

    Hi, ArfanMirza, and welcome to the Community,
    Please remember this Community is not a branch of Skype Customer Service!  Please contact Skype customer service again to follow up, having handy any service ticket numbers you may have had issued to you.
    Regards,
    Elaine
    Was your question answered? Please click on the Accept as a Solution link so everyone can quickly find what works! Like a post or want to say, "Thank You" - ?? Click on the Kudos button!
    Trustworthy information: Brian Krebs: 3 Basic Rules for Online Safety and Consumer Reports: Guide to Internet Security Online Safety Tip: Change your passwords often!

  • Need apps: BEST speed dialer favorite, BEST video viewer, BEST list maker..

    Need apps: BEST speed dialer favorite (I have to turn on/off and reset hourly to get email so I can't keep favorites in my phone area), BEST video viewer (short form or longer form) AND BEST list maker that allows sync with online component (so I can keep a list on iPhone and/or online when not on iPhone).
    Thanks!

    Ah yeah I know that. I am asking users on this board what they consider the "BEST" in a specific category. The app store is not very user friendly (too many clicks), plus the categories are vague and contain a mish-mosh of stuffs. I have downloaded several apps (free and paid) for other needs—but really would like suggestions on those I have yet to download.
    BTW your response was rather lame and not very helpful.

  • Need fastly help. A friend installed MAC false, my MAC isn't starting with THW normal MAC System. How can I change that?, Need fastly help. A friend installed MAC false, my MAC isn't starting with THW normal MAC System. How can I change that?

    I need fastly help.
    I am going to cry.
    A friend installed for lexware Office Easy plus Windows 7 but not with boot-i don't know.
    I Never worked with windows and ma MAC is now just starting with windows 7.
    Please help me, how can I get MAC IOS - i don't know back??

    Welcome to the Apple Support Communities
    If I've understood you, you can't start into Mac OS X. Press X key after the startup sound, so your computer will start in OS X

  • HT5312 Hi i need fast the security questions answear how can i get it ?

    Hi i need fast the security questions answear how can i get it ?

    If you have a rescue email address (which is not the same thing as an alternate email address) set up on your account then you can try going to https://appleid.apple.com/ and click 'Manage your Apple ID' on the right-hand side of that page and log into your account. Then click on 'Password and Security' on the left-hand side of that page and on the right-hand side you might see an option to send security question reset info to your rescue email address.
    If you don't have a rescue email address (you won't be able to add one until you can answer 2 of your questions) then see if the instructions on this user tip helps you get them reset : https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-4551

  • Thunderbolt audio distortion and slow Pegasus Raid Speeds

    Having major problems with my MBP 17" and my thunderbolt set up. (MBP 17" 2.3 i7 quad core, (2) 27" thunderbolt displays, Pegasus R6 12TB Raid, Blackmagic Ultra Studio Pro 3D)
    Apple states this clearly on there website that it is possible with this exact set up.
    Issues: With all 4 devices plugged in the Raid speed goes from about 515mb/sec write to 166mb/sec write speed. 
                With one thunderbolt display, raid, and blackmagic I get around 460mb/sec.  As soon as the second display is added to the mix the speed drops off considerably. 
    After Effects and Davinci Resolve color correction software cannot get sync on the Blackmagic box. Final Cut works ok.
    The other really big problem is that when you do any kind of data transfer across the thunderbolt line, I cant get audio to play back for more than a few seconds. I get distortion and static in the line.  I have tried the thunderbolt audio from the monitors and the Blackmagic box.
    The most curious thing is that it all works on the 13" MBP.  The write speed goes to 225mb/sec with everything plugged in, however it must be enough, because the audio doesnt distort and I can get sync on my color correction monitor out of the Blackmagic box.
    I also tried a brand new 17" MBP 2.5 i7.  I still get the same problem.  It is like there is something wrong with the 17".
    I have contacted Pegasus and Blackmagic.  Pegasus said that they now know about it and are working with Apple. 
    Does anyone else have this set up and are you experiencing the same problems?  Please feel free to respond with any questions.  I wouldl love to hear from Apple regarding this matter.  Seems like a big problem.
    (other items testing)
    -Switched video card to not auto switch.  just use high performance.
    -Went to Apple, bought a brand new 17" 2.5, stock.  tested it.  same exact results.
    -Moved all the items around in the daisy chain to see if one item has to be first.  No luck.
    -Laptop monitor open and closed, same result.
    -Reinstall OS.
    -Brand new motherboard.
    -New hard drive
    -New RAM
    No luck again.

    This is not a surprise. Apple's software RAID is slow. The best option for using Apple's software RAID is to use a regular disk for your audio files and keep the backup copy on a RAID. Also, depending on how important those files are, you might also want to keep an off-site backup copy because fires, floods, and thefts do occur.

  • Current xserve raid speed rate not fast enough

    guys,
    my xserve raid having problem when i edit HD project 1920*1080, its ok when i edit, but when i view all 30 mins movie, its hang when play till 5 mins of the movie, and keep on hanging after that, why is that? is it because the setting of my xserve raid got problem? read n write speed not fast enough?
    help plzzzz

    Both the write cache ticks should be on, The allow host cache flushing should be off. The use steady streaming mode tick should be off also. (So the pattern of th ticks is: on, off, on, off)
    The stripes stting depends on the cache size of the disk. On disks with lower than 16 MB, the 8 stripes setting is right. On disks from 16MB cache you can use the 128 stripes setting (In general the 750 GB disks have 16 MB, the others have lower).

  • Do I need a Raid to edit video or can I work with Xserve internal drives

    to start with and upgrade to a RAID system later on.
    I mainly do SD video with ProRes codec, I want to to have to CPU sharing media.
    Thanks,
    AN

    It sounds to me like what you want is external shared storage - starting small and then expanding as time goes on.
    I hate to say it but I think that the Xserve is probably the most expensive and least effective way to do this. What you'll end up with is probably 4TB of storage (maybe 6TB if you do a ram disk and 2TB x3) shared over ethernet. I would instead suggest that you look into multi-TB NAS system you can share between the stations which will give you the same effective storage at a much lower cost. If you were getting the speed of fibre or the mass storage of DAS from the Xserve I could see it but you're getting the drawbacks without the benefits.
    Unfortunately SAN is not something you can piecemeal together - it needs to be planned and implemented as a whole. While the Xserve you buy today may, or may not, be useful when you make an Xsan down the road the Xserve will be a small portion of any Xsan implementation.
    Speaking as someone who used to do video you need to spend smart with today's dollars and I'm not sure the Xserve does that for you now. If you can get the same features for less money or more features/storage for the same money that is usable now - that's my vote.
    My $.02,
    =Tod

  • Idiot needs help increasing speed of motion template "blizzard".

    I need to overlay some snow over an existing shot done on exterior location with snow machines.
    I've found the "blizzard" setup in motion and, since I really don't know motion at all, I want to ask if a kind expert out there can help me simply on how to speed it up, so that the snow falls/moves faster.
    Please understand that I can't learn "Motion" in order to do this one effect and I'd appreciate it if you guys and gals would not berate me for being so lazy as to ask for your help on this one issue.
    Many thanks if you can and will help,
    Best wishes,
    An idiot,
    Harry

    This is just an FYI on forum use - Please click on the or buttons over posts as appropriate - you not only reward those who answer your questions, but point future readers to where you found your answers...
    Patrick

  • Faster video speed on imported clips

    I've been trying to import video from my Sony Digital8 camera to my MacMini. I've had a couple of problems...
    With "start a new clip with each scene break" checked, it breaks up my video into clips that are only .16 of a second long. When I don't have it checked, it imports longer sections like it should, but when I run them on my computer, the playback speed is too fast.
    Anyone know what is causing this or how to fix it?

    Hi
    Very hard to figure out what's going wrong.
    What kind of material do You start with ?
    • Hi8 movie tape
    • Video8 movie tape
    • miniDV SP movie tape
    • miniDV LP movie tape
    • Camera docked as A/D box to VCR
    Is there any setting on Your Digital8 Camera that needs to be set ?
    Did You connect to Mac via FireWire ?
    Have You tried to
    • Delete iMoivie pref file
    • Repair Permissions
    • Free space on internal boot hard disk > 25Gb
    Yours realy trying to figure it out Bengt W

  • Faster WiFi speed for G5 tower

    Hi all!!
      I revived my old G5 tower a month ago and connected to my new fibre optic connection via WiFi and it's SLOWWWW compared to my
    MacPro withch is connected through ethernet (no problem there). My question; Is there a FASTER wifi card for the G5 or what can I use
    to speed up my wifi connection?? I know I can just go 54mbps with the card that I have now but need to go at around 250mbps. Any help
    is welcomed!!!
    THANKS!!!
    Serge

    So we know more abot it...
    At the Apple Icon at top left>About this Mac.
    Then click on More Info>Hardware and report this upto *but not including the Serial#*...
    Hardware Overview:
    Machine Name: Power Mac G5 Quad
    Machine Model: PowerMac11,2
    CPU Type: PowerPC G5 (1.1)
    Number Of CPUs: 4
    CPU Speed: 2.5 GHz
    L2 Cache (per CPU): 1 MB
    Memory: 10 GB
    Bus Speed: 1.25 GHz
    Boot ROM Version: 5.2.7f1

Maybe you are looking for