DVD for Film Festival Screening & Blu-Ray Question

Hey Everyone,
I just wanted to double check something.
I have been making DVD's with DVD Studio Pro for a short film shot on HDV -- 23.98 and they look great. I chose the "Best Quality" output, etc. etc. This project is going to be screening in a small film festival and they are going to project off of a DVD. I did a test screening in a theater classroom on a big screen and it looked fine.
I wanted to check in and see if anyone thinks there is a better output option for this. I don't have a Blu-Ray Burner at this time.
Also, I plan on getting a Blu-Ray burner in the future. I hear Lacie is the way to go? Any other suggestions, and/or links to other burners highly recommended. Also, do you need Toast to burn Blu-Ray?
Thanks for your input!
- Eric

You might be able to play a true HD file from your computer, you don't need the BD. But you must test the display output from your card to the projector in advance to know you've got what it takes to connect the two and if the projector is even capable of showing 1080. Most are not.
It is highly unlikely a festival will require BD submissions, too much hassle for them and for the participants.
bogiesan
Message was edited by: David Bogie Chq-1

Similar Messages

Optimal Quicktime Export Settings For Eventual Burning to Blu-Ray DVD

Hello. We currently have a huge backlog of FCP, FCE HD and iMovie HD projects created in 720p and 1080i formats. While we all await FCP and DVD Pro support of the 1080p Blu-Ray DVD burning, in the mean time, what are the optimal Quicktime Export settings to get best possible rendering of my existing FCP, FCE HD and iMovie HD in preparation for eventual transfer to Blu-Ray DVD for best possible viewing on my large screen LCD TV via Blu-Ray DVD player. I'd like to get to work exporting all my movies into the optimal Quicktime format in preparation for 1080p Blu-Ray.
For example, I have been creating FCE projects in a 1080i 60fps format. Once completed I typically have been exporting a "Full Quality" stand-alone movie. Is that what's optimal for the 1080p Blu-Ray DVD format, or something else? For example, what about interlacing? Should I be "de-interlacing" my outputted quicktime movies for better playback in the Blu-Ray 1080p format? What other things should I be considering.

Full quality sounds like you'll be safe. Keep in mind that WHEN DVDSP gets Blu-ray support, it will be able to do al the encoding itself. I do know that the next generation DVDs are using MPEG4 or VC1 compression instead of MPEG2 like standard DVDs are today. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H.264/MPEG-4_AVC http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VC-1 That being said, I don't believe that Compressor has a VC-1 encoder, but it definitely has H.264, so if you wanted to do the encode yourself, I guess you could pick that and be set. I would do some research on the technology behind Blu-ray and then base an encode on what you find. There's also MANY threads on here about this already, so Search is your friend and use it to get more info.
Good luck and don't forget to rate if this was helpful,
-Brian

Best way to export a 720p project to a 1080 file for film festival

I have a 4 year long project, in FCP7, with a 720/24 timeline. Most footage was shot 720, though some later was shot 1080... the film is complete, and now has been accepted into film festivals. (YAY!) Now I need to create a 1080/24 Pro Res file for a festival screener.
What is the BEST way to create that file?
Right now FCP 7 is chugging away in the background as I tried Export->QuickTime Movie and selected the desired codec, and checked recompress all frames and make movie self contained.
Is this the best way?
And, I need to FedEx this out tonight... :-)
Thanks in advance for your help...
kevin
Portland Maine

>Right now FCP 7 is chugging away in the background as I tried Export->QuickTime Movie and selected the desired codec, and checked recompress all frames and make movie self contained.
No. Don't recompress...that adds a layer of compression. Simply export a QT movie...self contained, using the sequence settings. And then use Compressor to resize it to 1080.

Examples for JAVA ME in Blu Ray

Are there any code examples for using Java in Blu-Ray DVD players?

For CS4 you must update the Roxio component http://forums.adobe.com/thread/400484?
More on Encore and Roxio http://forums.adobe.com/thread/528582?tstart=0 or direct to
http://kb.roxio.com/search.aspx?URL=/content/kb/General%20Information/000070GN&PARAMS
Also, Run as Administrator http://forums.adobe.com/thread/771202?tstart=0
tstart=0

Best settings for highest quality results, Blu-Ray vs DVD

I am shooting AVCHD 1080p 60fps with a JVC GC-PX100, using a Windows 7, i7-2600 3.40Ghz., 8Gb.RAM, 1 TB HDD with PE11 and a Pioneer Blu-Ray writer drive.
I'm looking to find the best settings for replay on a 55" HDTV. I have tested both BD and DVD without seeing very much difference between the two as far as video quality is concerned,
but I want to make sure I'm using the right settings for the best quality on both drives. Can someone please offer a step by step settings procedure for both BD and DVD, also which do you
think is the better route to take between the two?
Also, I have noticed there is a ghosting image after letters/numbers on faster moving content (like railroad cars) on my video even before transferring it, can anyone give some insight to what that might be and if there may be a solution ??
Many thanks for your anticipated help.

Rikko
Thanks for the reply.
Referring back to your post 4.
Additional info: When I published my test video for DVD I chose “Computer” on the Publish+Share drop-down list, then chose MPEG, Presets: HDTV 1080p 29.97 High Quality.
Saved and burned to DVD. I also did the same choosing AVCHD Presets: MP4 – H264 1920x1080p 30. Saved and burned to DVD
Let us clarify. When the end result is "...burned to DVD" in either case, are saying that you take your saved file to DVD-VIDEO on DVD disc or AVCHD on DVD disc, using another Premiere Elements 11 project on Windows 7 64 bit.
My post numbered 1, contained the step by step for taking your 1080p60 Timeline directly to DVD-VIDEO on DVD disc or Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc.
If you are going to introduce intermediates in your workflow (Timeline content saved to file and then burn to disc), then I would offer the following scheme
a. 1080p60 project preset (project 1)
b. 1080p60 Timeline saved to file via
Publish+Share
Computer
AVCHD
with presets = MP4 - H.264 1920 x 1080p30 (and then under the Advanced Button/Video Tab, customize the export settings for 1080p60 instead of 1080p30)
c. Import that back into Premiere Elements 1080p60 project (project 2) and burn to disc DVD-VIDEO on DVD disc, AVCHD on DVD disc, or Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc..
This is another alternative interpretation to your saved and burned to DVD.....in one project, you are doing two different exports...one to a file saved to the hard drive and after than the burn to disc (be it DVD-VIDEO on DVD disc, AVCHD format on DVD disc, or Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc). If this is the case, there is no "intermediate".
There used to be the discussion about HDV to DVD-VIDEO format on DVD disc - whether HDV file should be imported into the project as source or whether the user should downsize the HDV to DV widescreen in the camera before import into a DV Widescreen Premiere Elements project. As we getting into this type of question with your 1080p60 to DV widescreen?
Please review and consider. And, then please let me know if any of the above addresses your considerations.
Thanks.
ATR

DVD Blue Ray question /customer service F rating

I called four times to customer service on friday (45min on phone)They were unable to answer any questions except price just kept transferring to different deparments.
My question was about the panansonic blue ray player on sale today
Does it have multi channel audio outputs.....my receiver does not have hdmi but does have multi channel audio inputs for 7.1
Does the Panansonic Blue ray player BD35k have multi channel audio ouputs?

If your talking about an Optical output then yes, all blu-ray players I have ever seen have had an optical output. If you mean a digital coaxial output, the answer I believe is no, but I will check at work today as I am not 100% sure.
On the other hand, if your talking about the 5.1/7.1 analog outputs commonly found on home theater in a boxes, then the answer would be no.

Quicktime settings for future transcode to Blu-Ray & DVD in Encore

Hi, I'm asking this here because I think this is where the best knowledge on the subject is. I'm making a slideshow video in Fotomagico that I hope to author to Blu-Ray and DVD in Adobe Encore. I know that it will have to be transcoded in Encore so I'm wondering what will be the best output settings when I make the original video file in Quicktime. This has been created at 1920x1080, 60fps
Some specific options that have me confused:
Frame rate: leave at 60 or not. From my understanding, blu-ray 1080p is 23.97fps and DVD is 29.97?
Compression codec: Options include AIC, ProRes, MPEG-4, H-264, etc. I have no idea what will work best?
Or, should I send a file that doesn't need transcoding? Encore calls these elementary streams and apparently they have to match Blu-Ray/DVD spec and have no audio in the file. Is there a way to make this (I assume H-264 or MPEG-2) in Quicktime?
Thanks for any tips!!!

Hey Hoffsta,
yesterday i was looking for bluray edition and i found this can be usefull i hope:
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/blu-ray_fcpfields.html
Flo

Looking for Trayless/Slot Load Blu-Ray DVD players

Looking for a list of the Trayless/Slot Load Blu-Ray DVD players. Are there any for under $100? (or near that)

Rwillen, i agree with you. What TVLOVER said has to be one of the funniest things I have heard in a few weeks. Plus how would a Stand Alone players eye last longer then a PS3 eye? They both work in the exact same manner. And dont give me any bs about the eyes in stand alones are better design and quality then those found in the PS3. Because that is false. If anything the PS3 would use the better eye due to the more use they are subjected to. I have owned 2 PS3's since they were launched. BOTH were used for heavy gaming and the Blu-Ray from day 1. Guess what? My original FAT PS3 is still alive and kicking just fine. So over 7 years of use on that thing and not a single issue other then the bluetooth board went out. But I knew how to repair electronics ordered a new board for 30 dollars and it was as good as new.
But I have always recommended the PS3 over a blu-ray system due to its ALOT more future proof then a stand alone player is. It has the ability to do more then a stand alone player, and the price makes it worth it over a stand alone. Because while people around me were buying new Blu-Ray players due to the Blu-Ray spec changing and evolving in its early days. My PS3 with just a free software update got all the same features that people had to trash their "older" models to get. And dont forget about the encryption keys. Your at the mercy of the company to continue to make new firmware to keep the keys updated to play new movies. Not so much of a worry for the PS3 as it will still be around for a long time.

DVD drive does not play blu-ray

I am wondering if anyone can help me. I have been trying for the last several days to get my DVD drive to read blu-ray's. It is an HP DV-7 1038ca and there is a Blu-Ray symbol on the drive. When I put a BD in the drive, it cannot read it at all and says there is no disc in the drive. It plays regular movies and I have never had any problems with it.
I have taken some of the earlier suggestions to people with similar problems. I tried Matz_Run.dvd.exe and it told me I had a problem. It said I can read HD-ROM but it would not recognize the disc in the drive. I dried some Cyberlink software to detect BD and BD-3D technology (I forget what it was called) and it said that everything except "software" was functioning. I have loaded the latest HP Quickplay and that did not work. Then I saw that Mediasmart's latest version was actually the replacement. I downloaded Mediasmart from the HP website (as I did not have it before this), then I installed it and upgraded it to the latest edition directly within the software. My computer still refuses to acknowledge there is a disc in the drive when I put an HD disc in. The discs I am trying to read is a 4-part series from BBC vvideo called PLANET EARTH. I have no other BluRay discs currently at my disposal. I even tried changing the country code just in case and this did not work.
Then I tried Cyberlink PowerDVD 10 Ultra Mark II as this also seems to have BD capability, but same thing, total failure. With the Cyberlink detection program, I get the idea that it works, but perhaps it does not. Is it possible that my BD laser is malfunctioning? Is there any way to check? Or perhaps the issue is something else (other than frustrating). I am running Windows 7 Home 64-bit. I am using MS Security Essentials for protection and Spybot S&D. I cannot think of any other specs to give you at this time, so feel free to ask if I left something out.
Please help.
This question was solved.
View Solution.

Hi,
Does the drive still recognise and play DVDs and CDs? If so, I'm afraid it does look like this may be a hardware issue with the BD laser.
One further thing to try is to open the drive and carefully clean both lenses and check again, but if this doesn't help, you may want to start considering replacing the Drive.
Regards,
DP-K
****Click the White thumb to say thanks****
****Please mark Accept As Solution if it solves your problem****
****I don't work for HP****
Microsoft MVP - Windows Experience

Do I need FC/e for Film Festival Submission?

Or could I get by with iMovie, say 11, 09, or my old HD?
Will I be able to submit a sufficiently high def version using iMovie 11? Or will the degradation be too much, supposing that I edit in iMovie, then burn to DVD with iDVD.
The film will be about 7 minutes and shot with Panasonic GH1 and a Go Pro in HD. There may be slow motion and a mix of ambient sound, voice, and music.
It'll be entirely shot outdoors under somewhat nasty conditions. Meaning no lights, usually no tripod.
The reason I mention these latter points is that perhaps the quality of what I bring back (shaky, low light) might be the limiting factor and not the image degradation.
I have made many iMovies for YouTube, but would like to go bigger, so to speak, in quality of video, not necessarily length.
Would I benefit from going to Final Cut Express? Or stick with iMovie?

Yes, Banff Mtn Film Festival:
Here's what they ask (don't actually understand all the requirements, yet)
TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS
For purposes of pre-selection, judging and festival screening, all
entries should meet the following criteria:
a) Entries MUST be accompanied by one polyboxed DVD-R NTSC
(Region 1 coded), which will be used for adjudication purposes.
b) Entries must also include a tape copy of the master. In order of
preference, videotape formats must be:
HD-D5 HDTV
DVC Pro
HDCam HDTV
HDV
Digital Betacam (525)
DVCam (525)
Betacam SP NTSC
MiniDV NTSC
Digital Betacam 625 and Betacam SP PAL/SECAM will
not be accepted. Due to reproduction issues, MiniDV
format is LEAST preferred.
c) Film entries must be 35mm or 16mm with OPTICAL or
MAGNETIC sound (no double band).
d) Production attributes should conform to typical broadcast
standards and include:
• 90 seconds of leader which include black, SMPTE colour bars
and black with either 0 dbvu (analogue) or –20dbFS (digital)
audio tone reference signals.
• Please remove commercial blacks and include a production
slate prior to the program start.
• 7.5 IRE Pedestal Black (preferred for NTSC).
• Maximum 105% IRE peak whites.
• Program start commences on the time-code hour.
• Program tail of two minutes of black.
• Digital content should be submitted with 48K audio and have
peak whites that do not exceed 105% IRE.

H.264 for film festival

Hi. My film has been lucky enough to have been accepted into a film festival and the festival director would like an HD h.264 version for the screening. I have to send it so I made a 720p version because a 1080 version would be almost 8gigs and a 720 version would only be 1.5gb(he said 720 would be fine). My question is, going under the h.264 in export, I chose HDTV 720p 24fps since that seemed to be the highest quality choice under the h.264s.My main question is, do you think this is the right one to choose? His email said as long as the data rate is under 15mbps, looking at it, it's data rate is 5972kbps, so I think I'm cool, although I'm now questioning whether this is actually too low. In the end, I'd just like to know if this was the right choice to make in terms of export. Sorry for the question, I'm just a little nervous because it's all on me for whether the film shows correctly at the festival.

I have to send it so I made a 720p version because a 1080 version would be almost 8gigs and a 720 version would only be 1.5gb(he said 720 would be fine).
Do you not have a delivery method for an 8GB 1080 file?
If you do, I would send 1080 even if he says 720 is fine.
He did not specify a file size limit, correct?
His email said as long as the data rate is under 15mbps, looking at it, it's data rate is 5972kbps...
I would max out the bitrate to the level he specified.

Any chance of success using iMovie for Film Festival Submission?

Say with iMovie, say 11, 09, or my old HD?
Or do I need Final Cut, say Express?
Will I be able to submit a sufficiently high def version using iMovie 11? Or will the degradation be too much, supposing that I edit in iMovie, then burn to DVD with iDVD.
The film will be about 7 minutes and shot with Panasonic GH1 and a Go Pro in HD. There may be slow motion and a mix of ambient sound, voice, and music.
It'll be entirely shot outdoors under somewhat nasty conditions. Meaning no lights, usually no tripod.
The reason I mention these latter points is that perhaps the quality of what I bring back (shaky, low light) might be the limiting factor and not the image degradation.
I have made many iMovies for YouTube, but would like to go bigger, so to speak, in quality of video, not necessarily length.
Would I benefit from going to Final Cut Express? Or could I stick with iMovie?
Anybody out there ever use iMovie for something like Banff Mtn Film Festival?

Yes, Banff Mtn Film Festival:
Here's what they ask (don't actually understand all the requirements, yet)
TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS
For purposes of pre-selection, judging and festival screening, all
entries should meet the following criteria:
a) Entries MUST be accompanied by one polyboxed DVD-R NTSC
(Region 1 coded), which will be used for adjudication purposes.
b) Entries must also include a tape copy of the master. In order of
preference, videotape formats must be:
HD-D5 HDTV
DVC Pro
HDCam HDTV
HDV
Digital Betacam (525)
DVCam (525)
Betacam SP NTSC
MiniDV NTSC
Digital Betacam 625 and Betacam SP PAL/SECAM will
not be accepted. Due to reproduction issues, MiniDV
format is LEAST preferred.
c) Film entries must be 35mm or 16mm with OPTICAL or
MAGNETIC sound (no double band).
d) Production attributes should conform to typical broadcast
standards and include:
• 90 seconds of leader which include black, SMPTE colour bars
and black with either 0 dbvu (analogue) or –20dbFS (digital)
audio tone reference signals.
• Please remove commercial blacks and include a production
slate prior to the program start.
• 7.5 IRE Pedestal Black (preferred for NTSC).
• Maximum 105% IRE peak whites.
• Program start commences on the time-code hour.
• Program tail of two minutes of black.
• Digital content should be submitted with 48K audio and have
peak whites that do not exceed 105% IRE.

Advice for backing up media - Blu Ray? Anyone try it?

I am currently using external drives to back up lots of video and was wondering if anyone has tried using a Blu Ray burner to do this? Not sure what the data limitations of the disk are? Are there external ones? Would you recommend it or wait a bit longer?
Thanks.

Absolutely, original tapes, along with a project in which they've been properly logged and captured, are the best form of backup.
But not everyone works with DV sources, and not all of our source material is batch-re-capturable.
For instance, I work with an agency that reps touring bands, and a lot of the source material I get is on DVD video. I have to rip and extract the video (to which the clients hold the rights) and import it. At this point, whiile I could theoretically repeat this procedure and get a file almost identical, it still isn't frame accurate and would require some reworking to rebuild any project if teh media were lost.
I agree Blu-ray isn't cost-effective yet per GB, and DVD-5 requires a lot of time and patience to archive. But it's still a good, safe way to back up material like this, IMHO. To steal Shane's example, drop a DVD and a hard drive from a foot off the ground and see which still works. I do archive to hard drives to keep things accessible, but I know too well how vulnerable that storage medium is to failure.
my two cents.

Bruning to proper format for film festival

I am finally ready to submit my documetnary to the Berlin International Film Festival. Below are the specs they require.
Can I do this easily in FC Studio 2?
Would the DVD be easier then the ProRES?
My timeline is 59.94 FPS and they require 29.97. Does that automaticall happen during the DVD production?
I appreciate your help.

OK, thanks, ProRes it is.
So to convert my project, I can export right in FC Studio. Export> Quicktime movie conversion> Quicktime movie> Options> Apple ProRes422?
This is being sent to Germany so the specs have to be correct for the hard drive.
If I want to send it to other festivals, who accept only DVD, how would I export to DVD from FC Studio 2?

MacPro will burn dvds but won't burn blu-rays anymore?

I've been using Compressor (ver. 3) to burn blu-rays and dvds of my movie for several months just fine. A few days ago after opening my blu-ray project in Compressor it did the usual: tray opens and it says "Please insert blu-ray media…" I put a blank disk in (the same kind I've been using all along) and pushed the keyboard eject button to close the tray but it didn't move. I manually pushed the tray closed and I could hear it spin up several times and then it spit the disk back out. I repeated this several times with no luck. I tried different blu-ray media (didn't work). I tried burning a dvd and it DID work, so I'm thinking it's not the blu-ray drive. However I tried burning with Disk Utility and it wouldn't work. I also tried to make a blu-ray burn folder and it wouldn't work. It doesn't make sense that it can burn dvds but not blu-rays.
I'm not sure what else to do. I haven't upgraded (still on Lion). Would upgrading to Mavericks fix this? Everything's been working great so I didn't want to upgrade and mess it all up. I fear taking it to an Apple Store will cost more than purchasing a new blu-ray burner.
Any thoughts or advice? Thank you for your help!

Upgrade to Yosemite.

DVD for Film Festival Screening & Blu-Ray Question

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for