DVD Rendering and Burning: differences between Premiere Pro and Premiere Elements

I am landscape photogapher and wish to either create slide shows in Premerie or import them to Premiere  from H264 1080 quicktime files generated by Ligthroom 3.  I do not do frame by frame video editing.  My only goal in using Premiere is to be able to render and/or burn DVD's and eventually Bluetooh compatible DVD's for play back on commercial flat panel TV's, e.g., Samsung flat panel dvd's.
Are the DVD rendering and burning capablity of Pemiere CS5 Pro and Premiere 9 Elements equivalent , i.e, are that both as likely to produce DVD's that render with natural color on commercial flat panel TV's?
My prior experience is that my Lightroom generated 1080, H264 quicktime movies  have perfectly natural color on Mac LCD and other computer monitors but see very over saturated color on commecial flat panel tv's. 
Discussions with Adobe tech support folks are contradictory on this matter.

The main differences between the authoring capabilities (the assembly of DVD/BD, navigation and Menus, plus burning) of Encore (the authoring program, that ships and installs with PrPro) and PrE 9 are:
1.) Encore is a full-featured authoring program, offering a lot more power and flexibility, but at the expense of having to do it "by hand," where PrE 9 is very limited in the navigation that can be employed, and it uses Menu Sets for that automation. Though PSD's, like the Menus in Encore, they have many special aspects, that must be considered, when doing any customization.
     A.) In Encore, one can create almost all sorts of navigation in the DVD/BD, limited almost exclusively to the limits imposed by the DVD, or BD specs.
     B.) PrE 9 will allow Autoplay, with no Menu, or will automatically create Scene Menus, per the Chapter Markers that you add - and that is ALL. There will      be no Into AV material. No Subtiltes. No supplemental Audio streams. Only linear navigation, or no navigation.
     C.) Menus for Encore are much more easily customized, where there are some major conventions in those from PrE, that MUST be addressed.
2.) Encore can Burn an Image (ISO) - no Image in PrE, and can Burn a BD to Folder, which cannot be done in PrE - only for DVD.
3.) Encore offers the capability to adjust Layer Breaks for DL discs.
4.) Encore allows one to adjust the Burn speed, and in PrE, one is stuck with the "fastest" based on the speed of the media + the burner
5.) Encore allows output to a Flash delivery with pretty much full navigation.
6.) Encore allows for changes in the Subpicture Highlight Color Sets, and PrE will only do that, with some Menu Set editing.
7.) Encore offers a SlideShow feature, but I feel that it is rudimentary and limited, and assemble mine in PrPro, then go to Encore for authoring.
8.) Encore is a separate program, though interfaces with PrPro with ADL (Adobe Dynamic Link), and is NOT available as a stand-alone any more - only with      PrPro.
There are probably more differences, and some of the above might not make any difference to you. Things can probably be summed up as: Encore = great power and flexibility, but with things being done manually, and PrE lacks the power and flexibility, but is semi-automatic, so probably easier to use on simple Projects.
Good luck, and hope this helps you make the decision,
Hunt
[Edit] Sorry that some of the formatting for the Outline did not translate well. Gotta' explore the Outline formatting in the editing screen more, 'cause it would probably have fixed things. Sorry about that.

Similar Messages

  • Difference between Mac Pro and Mac XServer

    Hi,
    I wanted to know if there is any difference between Mac Pro and the Mac XServer - at the OS level? Meaning, if I design an application on Mac Pro would it run seamlessly on XServer or do I need to care about a few things.
    Please advise.
    Thanks,
    Abhishek

    Both Mac OS X and Mac OS X Server are presently at the Tiger 10.4.10 release, with Mac OS X Server having various added pieces and features, and having a few structural and configuration differences.
    * Do both of them support the ipv6 protocol
    Yes; both Mac OS X and Mac OS X Server both offer IPv6.
    * do both of them support LDAP and PAM based authentication
    Mac OS X and Mac OS X Server have LDAP support, yes. Mac OS X Server has LDAP authentication, DNS and a variety of other servers built in. Mac OS X is configured as a client, though there is the Apache web server.
    Haven't looked for PAM for either platform.
    * Do both of them support the same level of Java ( I understand we need 1.5 or higher for Tiger / Leapord)
    Java itself is the same on both Mac OS X and Mac OS X Server, though Mac OS X Server has server-oriented pieces of Java present. And it's still write once, debug everywhere.
    No Leopard questions are permissible here at this time; Leopard details are NDA.
    * Do the compilers (gcc) have different compilation options - maybe xServer uses some better optimized flags that handle large volumes of data and network traffic.
    AFAIK, there are no differences in gcc defaults. Nor would I expect any. Handling volumes of data is left to the programmer. (I'm not even sure how a compiler author would even implement that sort of difference.)
    * Is there any difference in the behavior of the way the libraries ...
    I'd expect the exact same behavior the programmer requested would occur with both platforms.
    Now as for what I expect is the root of your question, yes, you'll likely want to test your application on both Mac OS X and Mac OS X Server software platforms. There can exist very hard to predict details such as cases where dual NICs or the aforementioned directory differences that have tossed a few applications off the rails and into the weeds; have caused applications to fail.
    You can choose to install Mac OS X Server on a Mac Pro. Probably the 10-client, because you probably aren't planning to serve piles of clients from the Mac Pro.
    An overview of Mac OS X Server is here:
    http://www.apple.com/server/macosx/specs.html
    Now as to whether or not I would expect run-time differences, no. But I've been at this way too long and have chased way to many weird bugs to make any promises here.

  • Is there a difference between Logic Pro and Logic Pro X?

    Maybe this is a stupid question, but is there a difference between Logic Pro and Logic Pro X?
    Already thx!

    Hi
    Short answer: No
    Longer answer:
    Logic Pro X is the latest release version of the DAw known as "Logic Pro". Previous versions were: Logic Pro 9, Logic Pro 8 etc.
    There was also a "Logic Express" (no longer available) which, though similar to Logic Pro, was missing a few features of Logic Pro in it's later versions)
    This might add more details:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic_Pro
    CCT
    edit
    AoS wrote similarly
    There you go then :-)

  • What is the conceptual and functional difference between peripheral target and Enterprise peripheral target?

                       Dear All,
    what is the conceptual and functional difference between peripheral target and Enterprise peripheral target?

    Does anyone get a chance to see this ?

  • Searching and Matching - Difference between 'Match Pattern' and 'Match Geometric Pattern'?

    I was wondering if someone can explain to me the difference between  'Match Pattern' and 'Match Geometric Pattern' VIs? I'm really not sure which best to use for my application. I'm trying to search/match small spherical particles in a grey video in order to track their speed (I'm doing this after subtracting two subsequent frames to get rid of background motion artifacts).
    Which should I use?
    Thank you!
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hi TKassis,
    1.You may find from this link for the difference between these two,
    Pattern Match : http://zone.ni.com/reference/en-XX/help/370281P-01/imaqvision/imaq_match_pattern_3/
    Geometric Match : http://zone.ni.com/reference/en-XX/help/370281P-01/imaqvision/imaq_match_geometric_pattern/.
    2. I always prefer match pattern because of its execution speed, and incase of geometric pattern match it took lot of time to match your result. You may find in the attached figure for same image with these two algorithm execution time.
    Sasi.
    Certified LabVIEW Associate Developer
    If you can DREAM it, You can DO it - Walt Disney

  • Difference between Reader, Pro and Preview

    I'm running Leopard 10.5.7 with Preview. I also have Acrobat Reader 9.1 and Acrobat Pro 9.2 installed. What is the difference between the 3 programs? My default when opening PDF's from Safari is Acrobat Pro. I can open PDF's just fine with Pro. But when I launch the Reader it asks me if I want to use that program as the default.
    I also like the ability to use the built-in Preview function because it seems to use less resources (ram) than Acrobat Pro.
    Can someone explain the difference of the 3 programs and what the advantages of one over the other are?
    I create PDF's all the time with In Design and know that with Reader I can't save any changes to the PDF I can only print and read from them.
    Do I even need Reader installed or is this overkill?

    I would say it depends on what (if anything) you need to do when viewing the PDF files in one of those 3 applications.
    Acrobat Pro: Provides useful tools in examining the document as well as making some basic corrections. These tools include Output Preview (color warnings, ink viewing, object inspector) and Preflight.
    Preview: Has some limitations when viewing documents. Most notably, overprinting cannot be simulated but there may be others. Some transparency blending modes are displayed quite as expected either.
    Reader: Lighter weight than Acrobat Pro, but I am not aware of any viewing limitations as compared with Acrobat Pro (and it does support simulating overprinting in viewing)

  • Difference between Soundtrack Pro and the version that came with FCE 3.5

    Would like to know what the important differences are between Soundtrack Pro 2 and v1.5 that shipped with Final Cut Express 1.5.

    I would say it depends on what (if anything) you need to do when viewing the PDF files in one of those 3 applications.
    Acrobat Pro: Provides useful tools in examining the document as well as making some basic corrections. These tools include Output Preview (color warnings, ink viewing, object inspector) and Preflight.
    Preview: Has some limitations when viewing documents. Most notably, overprinting cannot be simulated but there may be others. Some transparency blending modes are displayed quite as expected either.
    Reader: Lighter weight than Acrobat Pro, but I am not aware of any viewing limitations as compared with Acrobat Pro (and it does support simulating overprinting in viewing)

  • Question about Hz difference between MacBook Pro and iMac?

    Some will think I'm crazy for saying this, but my new MacBook is driving me nuts.
    In a nutshell, I have tinnitus as a result of an accident some years ago. I can hear an intermittent high pitch sound coming from the back left of the machine. I used to hear a similar sound from old TVs back when I first got tinnitus. After some deduction I realised that it was to do (I think) with the fequency. I sold my old TV and brought a new one that was a 100Hz. My theory was somewhat confirmed when they delivered it and it was the 50Hz version and yes, the high pitch sound was very evident! Upon receipt of the 100Hz model and I immediately noticed the difference.
    I'm guessing then that the MacBook has something inside emitting 50-60Hz - someone on this forum mentioned that too.
    Although I want the portability, I can't stand that sound all day long, so I'm thinking of taking it back and swapping it for an iMac.
    The question is, will I find the same problem? I'm not sure of the technical specifications in terms of Hz's between the two machines.
    It's too noisy in the shop to tell.
    Any advice appreciated.
    PS - did not have this issue with my 2008 MacBook pro.
    PPS - makes no difference if it's plugged in or not.

    Isolating the source of the high frequency would take a technician with the instruments to deteermine what components emit sound...actually very easy to do with the proper test instruments, but essential to tell you what is causing the offending sound.  Unless you know that it will be very hard to determine if the iMac will not do the same thing.
    Only qualitative way to find out is go to an Apple store or reseller with a good selection of hardware, work with the different hardware and see if it bothers you.  Preferably with few people around and low background noise level so the sound isn't masked.

  • Difference between Logic Pro and Logic Express?

    A buddy wants me to show him how to use Logic Express. I'm fairly up on Logic Pro, have used it for years. I'm wondering if I can get a trial version of Express to try out for an hour before embarrassing myself in front of him?
    Or if there is a huge amount of difference in the basic setup?

    There is very little difference, mostly in content (Jampacks, Waveburner, Mainstage..and a few of the high end plugins). Other than that they're functionally identical. same audio engine, you wouldn't know the difference just by looking at them.
    pancenter-

  • Difference between Elite Pro and Elite Pro L

    Hi I will soon buy the Elite Pro but I have newly seen that there is two models of this card availble the "old" one and the new L6. The pricedifference is about euro less for the L6 (at my local netdealer) but no specifications availble yet for this card.
    I have looked at soundblaster.com but only find the elite pro not L6.
    Anyone here who knows ?

    How could anybody know? There is no available info about a?"L6" card, official or unofficial. Is it in stock where you saw it advertised? have you tried to contact the store to ask for the differences?

  • Difference between macbook pro and macbook air

    .

    Basically the Pro is more powerful regarding cpu intense processes like graphics and video. The Air is a great basic machine at a good price that does all the regular jobs well but is not a "Hot Rod".
    Go to this link and click on the two categories to see the detailed differences.
    http://store.apple.com/us/mac

  • Can someone tell me the difference between adobe pro and adobe captivate 8?

    Hi i am wanting to purchase a new Adobe product but don't know which one I need!!
    I am a student and also have access to teacher discounts as well... All I want to do is turn PDF's in to a word document!!
    can you please advise if any of these will do it or
    do I need to buy the pro???
    thanks

    Adobe Acrobat or Microsoft Word.
    If you are either a student or a teacher..It worries me that you are asking this in a professional video editing software forum!!!!

  • Video quality and size difference between clip preview and project view

    Hey, Just want the video to look the same in project view as it does in clip preview. Video in project view is in widescreen mode and quality isn't as good. When i use the effects tool to fit the video to the screen the quality looks horrible.
    Clip is 1920x1080
    Thank you

    http://forums.adobe.com/message/3804341#3804341

  • Difference between Titanium Professional and Champ

    Hello,
    What are the differences between Titanium Pro and Champ versions? Anything else besides the I/O front panel? Does the panel have a headphone amplifier?

    there is a diffrence bro...
    What difference?
    in titanium
    Which Titanium? Both cards are called Titanium (one Pro and another Champ).
    In Champion, the card is specially tuned for a gamer.
    This does not mean anything unless you provide more information.
    Sorry, but you didn't indicate a single informati've difference.

  • Important differences between oracle 10g and 11g

    Hi friends, can anyone tell me (pointwise) what are the major (and minor) differences between Oracle 10g and 11g.
    Please point me to some documents if possible.
    Thanks in advance

    The name of the link says it all: "top_features."
    In short it is Oracle's list of what they have for marketing and sales reasons designated "top features."
    It is not intended to be, and is not, a complete list of features. Often the features Oracle does not
    talk about are the most important.
    Let me give you some examples. I have never seen Oracle announce DBMS_XPLAN as a new feature
    yet you should not run an explain plan without it. Neither have I ever seen Oracle announce the new
    NO_DATA_NEEDED predefined exception. I have listed literally hundreds of new features you will not
    find in Oracle's new features docs.
    I did a presentation at OpenWorld this year as part of the unconference titled "New Features in
    Database 11gR2 that Oracle will not announce." It was easy to prepare a one hour presentation with
    little fear of being proved incorrect. As I turned out only one of the features I presented was mentioned
    by Oracle.
    You can find the presentation slides here:
    http://www.morganslibrary.org/pres/oow09_ucnf.pdf

Maybe you are looking for

  • Estimate ADF web app use size - quick question

    Hi 1- Is there a good way to estimate or get a better accurate measurement of the amount of memory required/used by a running ADF app with Weblogic Server ? Eg How much memory footprint does a deployed ADF app uses (not including those apps that come

  • Premiere is ruining the quality of my videos. How do I fix the problem in my program?

    My original root video files are beautiful HD BUT when I import them into Premiere Pro CS5.5 the quality drops tremendously. I have even exported the video to see if it was only the preview screen. That video was jumpy and moving like crazy when my o

  • My iPod 5th generation charges way too fast.

    I bought my iPod Touch 5th generation about a year ago. And I updated to iOS 7 when it came out.  I am currently on iOS 7.1.1. Earlier my iPod was at 4%. I plugged it in and checked ten minutes later. It was already at 100%. The iPod drains battery a

  • What version of orion are the various OC4Js based on?

    I understand that the OC4J container is based on that of the orion application server. Does anyone know where I can find out which version of orion the OC4J containers were based on. I ask because we are wanting to develop a J2EE app on orion (as it'

  • Get Folder Contents....bug? ***

    I am creating a workflow using a combination of variables and filters to reorganize a bunch of files. I frequently use the "Get Folder Contents" action in this workflow. It works the first couple of instances I have it in the workflow and in all inst