Edited RAW files used to make a photo book

I am posting a question that I mistakenly posted in the wrong support community. 
I have photos in both RAW and JPEG format.  I know that when a RAW file is edited it is saved as a JPEG.  I noticed that the size of the edited RAW file is often smaller than the same JPEG photo. (Sometimes it's up to 2MB or more difference.)  Believing that a larger size photo has more detail do you recommend using one file format over the other (edited RAW v. JPEG) to create an iBook?  What is the smallest size photo recommended for a photobook?
I use iPhoto'11.
Thanks.

I know that when a RAW file is edited it is saved as a JPEG.
It's not since iPhoto 08. When you process a Raw the decisions you make are recorded in the database and a Preview is made. This preview is what's used in Media Browsers and the like - essentially any time you share a photo except via File -> Export. But the edits are never fixed or committed.
  I noticed that the size of the edited RAW file is often smaller than the same JPEG photo. (Sometimes it's up to 2MB or more difference.)
That's the difference between the camera's jpeg and the iPhoto Preview. The Preview is a medium quality version - a sort of "good for most things" version. If you export you can create much bigger files.
Believing that a larger size photo has more detail
Not necessarily so... It is less compressed, that's all.
do you recommend using one file format over the other (edited RAW v. JPEG) to create an iBook?
THere's no right answer. No matter what, you can't print the Raw so it's either going to be the camera Jpeg or one created by iPhoto from the Raw. If you don't want to process the image yourself or if you feel what you can do wuth the image is not better than the camera, it might be worth asking yourself why you're shooting Raw at all? And if you feel that what you do with the Raw is better than the camera creates, you might ask yourself why you're shooting the Jpeg at all.
What will print best is the best shot, regardless of whether the camera processed it or you did.

Similar Messages

  • Can aperture 2 on 10.4.11 still be used to make a photo book ?

    Hello Clever People !
    Can aperture 2 running on 10.4.11 still be used to make a photo book ?
    If so ... is it also possible to also upload to order via a PC running on XP ?
    Thank you in advance for your much appreciated help and expertise

    este.el.paz wrote:
    Yesterday I searched the apple discussion Unix db trying to find similar questions and found someone wanting to surf the web and do email with Unix from a few years ago and there were some recommends for "lynx" or "W3M"--the "lynx" website was unresponsive to clicking on links.  This was from a couple of years ago--are there any updates or newer browsers now available that can get around the web at current speeds?   
    Any other options to get fairly current browsers working in ppc units?  In one of the replies to my last question I got a recommend and a link to "Ten4Fox" as a re-work of Firefox and that may be my best hope, but, haven't been totally crazy about Firefox for the mac . . .  Would UNIX have something thru fink or macports that would keep a browser going into the distant future?  And, then how to get them to actually do something?  Many thanks.
    e.e.p.
    No other insights from the Unix guys?  Nothing out there in Unix-land to keep a current browser on a ppc computer?  Traditionally on this forum there has always been someone who could offer some relevant advice, no?  Not this time I suppose . . . well, if I find something I'll post back to this question.  Later dudes.
    e.e.p.

  • Importing and editing raw files using a Canon 70D

    I have a new Canon 70D.  If I upgrade to photoshop elements 12 will I be able to import raw files using this camera without using plug ins.  It would not import raw files off a 70D in elements 11 but would for my older ?Canon 60D.  Has this been corrected??

    Well if you are still seeking the link, here is it:
    Windows: http://www.adobe.com/support/downloads/detail.jsp?ftpID=5646
    Mac: http://www.adobe.com/support/downloads/detail.jsp?ftpID=5645
    You can convert a whole folder of raw images in one click. See this quick video tutorial:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bqGovpuihw
    And yes, you will be able to work upon these images in PSE12 using ACR 8.2

  • Merge to Panorama in Photoshop not using edited RAW files

    When I had LR4, I could Edit in > Merge to Panorama in PS and it would take the edited RAW files and merge them. Now in LR5 it seems to be taking the unedited RAW files and making the panorama. Is there a setting or something I'm missing in LR5?

    Yes it is that simple. Just do a google search for Lightroom and Photoshop preference file locations and you should find them. The next time you start the programs, they will rebuild them. Of course, you'll have to re-enter any custom preference settings you've used. Good luck. Of course, when you think you've located them. Just rename them and move them into another folder first. That way, if you've picked the wrong file, you can easily move it back. Once things are working, you can just delete them.
    BTW, this is a good troubleshooting tool for any mac applications that are acting wonky. Just delete that preference file, and more often than not, the problem will be fixed.

  • What steps do I take to edit raw files and save for web use, such as Instagram, Facebook, Websites, and emailing?

    What Steps do I take to edit raw files and save for web use, such as Instagram, Facebook, Websites, and emailing?

    When you open a raw file it will open in Adobe camera raw. That is where you can do most of the editing. Then it will be placed inside Photoshop where you can do more if needed.
    Now you can use the save for web dialog to export your image as a png or jpg to use on those sites.

  • How do I edit Raw files from a Canon 5D using Elements 9?

    How do I edit Raw files from a Canon 5D mark 111 using Elements 9?

    The 5D mk III is supported in PSE 10 with ACR 6.7 update.
    You could download and install the latest DNG converter and use that to convert the CR2 files to DNG files (still RAW format). Then you can edit the DNG files using PSE 9.
    Brian

  • How to edit raw files' metadata directly?

    Is it possible to edit raw files' metadata directly?  If so, how?  (I am using Bridge CS6 v5.0.2.4 x64).  In my case, raw files are from Nikon digital cameras, i.e., .NEF.
    By directly, I mean the original file is changed, rather than the sidecar .xmp file.
    This is necessary under some circumstances where it may be required to prove ownership or origin of a photo.
    Help most appreciated.
    Thank you.

    So how do you prove an image is yours?
    I did understand the ownerships problem but I also would point to the impossibility of hard proof with current technology.
    As said, I put my energy in good clients and for my images that are used on personal websites without my permission I really don't bother.
    Don't know where you live and what your country has in its law regarding copyright. I also don't know to what extend you want to go and how much money is involved with your problem.
    Never had to do it myself but I heard of several cases in the Netherlands. If you are certain it is your image and it is used without your permission and without paying you there are normal ways to seek justice.
    First call the person or company that betrayed you for info and explain, then put this in writing with the request of a reasonable fee. If no luck seek a lawyer for a first letter with warning for extra costs and fine.
    If you want (depending on the law in your country but most western countries do respect copyright) you can get it to court. Be sure to have the original raw files at hand (the whole series makes it more believable) and eventually if needed or possible seek witnesses seeing you taking the pictures.
    But it can be a long and hard road that is certainly not suitable for a small case. Then again, most of the cases have been decided in favor of the photographer, the company that first refused to pay left with the usual fee to pay including a fine (mostly the same or more as the fee) and having to pay for the costs of the court…
    Also keep in mind this is not good advertisement for you as a photographer, especially if the fine is big the word will spread around in the business. It is always problematic in this cases, hence my advise to invest in good clients...

  • IPhoto issues editing Raw files in PE4

    I've just acquired Photoshop Elements 4 and was happy at the prospect or keeping my photos in iPhoto and editing them in Elements.
    I mostly shoot in RAW format but when editing a RAW file in Elements I can't get the edit to show up in iPhoto (version 6).
    On the other hand when processing jpegs from iPhoto to Elements the edits show up fine back in iPhoto.
    Is the problem with the format change when converting RAW to Jpeg I wonder?
    I did notice that when saving the edited RAW file -and choosing Jpeg as the new format- iPhoto defaulted to the "Original" not the "Modified" folder for the save. Couldn't iPhoto determine that the file has been modified? Is that because the extension was changed?
    I also tried saving and manually selecting the MODIFIED folder but with unhappy results. The edit did show up, and in it's proper place, but when viewing in "full screen" mode the image resorted back to the unedited version after 3 or 4 seconds. I tried that a couple of times with the same results...!? I hope I didn't corrupt anything in the process!
    I realise I could just do a "save as" to my desktop and import back to iPhoto but that creates a double and also a new roll for each import...
    I haven't seen any posts about this. Has anyone had the same problem, or am I missing something elementary?
    Thanks for any feedback.
    KiwiP
    PowerMac G4 FW800   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  
    PowerMac G4 FW800   Mac OS X (10.4.7)  

    iPhoto is a consumer-level application, and RAW is a format mostly for professionals. When you import a RAW file into iPhoto it saves the RAW in the Originals folder and instantly creates a jpeg version of it in the Modified folder. This causes the problem with your editing workflow.
    Yes, changing the file extension in Elements is the same as doing a Save As - it breaks the link iPhoto has with the original. This is why you don't see your edits back in iPhoto. Any time you change the extension you will need to save as to the desktop and import the edit as a new original into iPhoto. As you've seen, you cannot save directly into the iPhoto library folder because images must be Imported for iPhoto to recognize them. If you know which files you placed in there, go ahead and drag them out (using Finder) to your desktop. Then import. (Be careful not to tamper with anything else in the library folder while you're in there.)
    My suggestion for your RAW workflow is to use Image Capture (in your Applications folder) to upload from your camera (to a folder anywhere outside of your iPhoto library folder). Edit in Elements. Last, import into iPhoto. Once inside iPhoto, the desktop copies can be deleted. You can set Image Capture to open when you connect a camera in Image Capture Preferences.
    iPhoto does create a new roll each time you import photos, but you can always reorganize your rolls. Choose Library and View > Sort Photos > by Film Rolls and you can combine, create, retitle, and redate your rolls. For example, you could keep separate rolls for files with a RAW original versus files imported as jpegs.

  • How to edit raw files in lightroom?

    when editing raw files in  lightroom the only extra option I seem to get is more control over white balance.  Am I missing something?  is there a way to open raw files in camera raw (like in photoshop elements) or can the editing options I get for all photos raw(nef) and jpg work better on raw than on jpg?  I am a little confused by it...

    Lr uses Camera Raw internally for processing raw files.
    You create renditions by editing raw images in develop mode until you are satisfied, and then exporting those renditions.
    If you mean you want access to proprietary NEF settings placed in the raw image by the camera or Nikon software... this is not possible. You can mimic some of the settings with camera profiles and presets, but Lr (like most software) does not have (complete, unfettered, unencumbered) access to proprietary image details.  Adobe uses the public Nikon SDK to get access to the encrypted WB information.

  • Do I need to convert RAW fles using Canon's Digital Photo Professional?

    I want to create a "fake" HDR photo from a single RAW file using Photomatix Pro, which can open RAW files from my Canon S95 directly. But the finished HDR is almost unusable because of too much noise. So the only way out seems to first convert RAW images into Tiff format. Unfortunately, Canon's Digital Photo Professional for Mac produced errors whenever I want to batch process raw images.
    Actually the Aperture 3 can read Canon's RAW images (.cr2) directly, and I can export 3 TIFF versions of different EVs to "cheat" the Photomatix into creating an HDR image. But I have doubts about how capable Aperture 3 is in converting Canon's proprietary RAW files as compare to Canon's own Digital Photo Professional. Could I simply use Aperture 3 exclusively for RAW conversion and forget about Digital Photo Professional?

    While Wikipedia is a valuable resource, remember that it is not peer reviewed so the level of accuracy isn't always that dependable.
    One of the reasons why Apple, Adobe, and others are always behind by several weeks to a few months when a new RAW profile comes out is that they are decoding it. Thousands upon thousands of people use Canon & Nikon RAW files every day and the large majority never use DPP or Nikon's equivalent.
    I used to use DPP before Aperture came out and even with Aperture's initial problems, it blew the doors off DPP in workflow speed and consistency.
    In my opinion, DPP only has relevance under two circumstances: 1. If you use customized Picture Styles and want to make your RAW file equivalent [somewhat irrelevant as you can create custom profiles for a camera in both Aperture & Lightroom which solve this problem - you do have to create them though by trial and error]; 2. If a new camera comes out and you must get it before it is supported by Aperture or Lightroom [Though, Adobe's DNG converter often allows you to skip over using DPP by converting your RAW files to DNG for use in Aperture or Lightroom]
    Finally, the community support as well as tech support for DPP is dreadful - pretty much doesn't exist compared to that of Aperture & Lightroom.
    Hope this helps!
    Best,
    CD

  • Can I open raw files using photoshop elements

    Can I open raw files using photoshop elements

    Yes, depending on the Camera Model and version of PSE.
    All camera makers like to make slight changes to the RAW format for their new models. Adobe then take a few months to produce a camera RAW plug-in to process the new format.
    Give you PSE version and camera model and we could be more help.
    Brian

  • Why do my recently edited RAW files lack sidecars?

    I've asked about this recently and now can describe the problem better. My previous question (Aug. 1 "Bridge Thumbnails & Preview no longer indicate edit") received answers suggesting deleting cache, which had no effect on the problem. I've now noticed that those edited RAW files lack sidecar files, although they open normally in RAW, displaying their edited state in both the image and the panels sliders.
    I'm using a MacPro 2 X 2.8 GHz Quad-core Intel Xenon, running version 10.6.8, Photoshop CS6 13.0.5
    This problem only affects recently edited RAW files (August 2013), with their thumbnails in Bridge showing the edit symbol (upper right), but  no evidence of any editing. When I open these files in RAW, the image and the panel sliders show all of my edit correctly. Although the edit is displayed,  the sidecar files are missing from the respective RAW file on my HD. Both RW2 and RAF filles are affected. When I convert these files to DNG, the thumbnails in Bridge then correctly show evidence of the edit.
    Where are those missing sidecar files?

    grprt wrote:
    …I've already "Purged Cache for Folder", twice.
    That's not what I said.  Let's try again:
    Now you have to go to each folder in Bridge and go to the Tools menu >Cache > Build and Export Cache to create the missing XMP files.
    Note that we're talking about different commands in the Tools menu, different menu items.
    Did you restart Bridge after changing the cache preferences and before selecting the command to Build and Export Cache?

  • Will edited Raw files retain the xmp edited information when converting to DNG format?

    I have a bunch of old nikon and canon Raw files that was edited in Photoshop Camera Raw.  The Raw files have corresponding xmp files.  I want to convert these edited Raw files into DNG format.  Using the Photoshop Camera Raw converter or using the free Adobe DNG Converter tool - will the edited information from the Raw files be automatically converted over to DNG? What would be the best method to convert an edited RAW  file into a DNG file, and retain all the editing (xmp files)? Thanks for help!!!

    Using either the dng converter or camera raw though PS and Bridge will convert your RAW files to dng and keep the edited info from your xmp files, which will be add into the dng format.  If you have a lot of files to convert, it might be faster to use the dng converter.  Next choice would be to select them all in Bridge, right click and select "Open in Camera Raw."

  • PSE 8 and CS4 Editing Raw Files & Version Sets

    I currently have PSE7 and CS4.  While I use Bridge for the initial download and review I like the organizer in PSE better.  PSE7 has problems interfacing with CS4.  Raw files open directly instead of opening in camera raw in CS4.  Version sets don't work either; the updated files is deleted by PSE.  My question is whether anyone knows if these issues have been addressed in PSE8.  I tried to ask Adobe but all I got is that they tried to work on these issues.

    It appears that the PSE 8 displays the same characteristics when editing RAW files. The link between CS4 and PSE Organizer shows the same problem, for editing JPEG images also. The edited version does not get saved and yet is added to the Catalog.
    Don S.

  • I have re-installed PS CS4 and Bridge onto my new Macbook Pro, but I cannot open or edit RAW files?

    I just bought a new Macbook, and I tried transferring my Photoshop CS4 and Bridge to my new one via my external Hard Drive. It's worked in the past (I did it when transferring my desktop to my laptop), but this time, I am unable to open or edit RAW files. Bridge won't even allow me the option of "Camera Raw Settings" when going under "File".
    I've tried searching for answers to my questions through these forums, and the closest I have gotten is that I need to download the updated Camera Raw plug-in, and I can't find it. Also, I need to download the update to the DNG or something like that, which I did, and that still doesn't work. I've extracted and refiled my RAWs to DNG's, and they will still not open in either Bridge, nor Photoshop. So, now I'm feeling helpless and I'm getting very frustrated at this point.
    I shoot with a Canon 7d in RAW format. I've done this for years, and my computers have opened them with CS4 since I've had it.
    I appreciate any and all help, thank you!

    "Moving", copying, transferring or migrating Adobe applications is to be avoided at all costs. 
    Always install from the original media, from scratch, then apply all updates available all over again.  The Camera Raw plug-in, for example, is buried deep inside your root level Library.
    Your best course of action is to uninstall CS4, download and run the Creative Suite Cleaner Tool and re-install CS4 as per the previous paragraph.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Another user with login problems to forums

    I didn't want to jump into either of these threads with "me too and..." http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=366881&tstart=0 http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=366684&tstart=0 but me too and... Whenever I come directly to

  • Population of Number of packages field(LIKP-ANZPK) in delivery document

    Hi, We have a requirement from our client that the number of packages field needs to be populated in the delivery document automatically. Scenario: The plant is a warehouse managed plant. The delivery document will be created and the TO will be creat

  • Conference room camera for Connect Pro??

    Trying to determine the best voice activated pan/tilt/zoom camera for conference room to use with Adobe Connect Pro. Any information is helpful . . . type of camera, quality of picture, functionality, cost, connection, etc. Thanks!

  • Plesae help on Arraylist import

    Hi all jcreator is giving me an error when i import the following package: import java.util.ArrayList; I use the above package at university on xemacs. Does jcreator have a different name for importing arraylists??? Here is my code: import java.util.

  • Importing RAW images from Canon S50 doesn't work

    I took some pictures with my Canon Powershot S50 in RAW mode but iPhoto '08 won't read them. Apple lists this camera as having a readable RAW format. What could be the problem?