Encrypted Disk Image creation slow?

I just got a new MBP with Leopard. I have created a number of encrypted disk images in the past using Tiger and a MBP and have not had any trouble. This weekend I tried a few times to create a 50 gig encrypted disk image (128 AES) on an external drive and after going through the process of setting it up and waiting for it to be created, (and watching the progress bar as it was being created), after about 45 minutes NO progress was showing on the progress bar. I ended up having to cancel the creation a few times because I thought something was going wrong. I’m not sure if there is a problem creating the disk image, or leopard is slow, or what.
Does anyone know how long, on average, it would take to create an encrypted disk image of this size using leopard? I just want to know if there is a problem doing this on my MBP. Thanks for the help.

A regular 50 GB disk image takes 50GB of space, no matter if it is full of files or empty.
A 50 GB sparse disk image only takes up the amount of space equivalent to that of its enclosed files. So if the 50GB sparse image only has 1 GB of files inside, the image won't be much bigger than 1GB.
A sparse bundle is similar to a sparse image, but instead of a single file it is a folder package with many, many enclosed files called bands. A new file added to the sparse bundle will tend to modify only a few bands. This makes incremental backups of a sparse bundle more efficient because only the changed bands need to be backed up again. Any change to a sparse or regular disk image will mean that the entire image will need to be backed up again.
If you regularly add/remove files to a disk image, and you intend to back up that disk image with Time Machine, a sparse bundle is definitely the way to go. The other types will fill up your TM volume very quickly.

Similar Messages

  • Encrypted disk image creation very slow-

    I just got a new MBP with Leopard. I have created a number of encrypted disk images in the past using Tiger and a MBP and have not had any trouble. This weekend I tried a few times to create a 50 gig encrypted disk image (128 AES) on an external drive and after going through the process of setting it up and waiting for it to be created, (and watching the progress bar as it was being created), after about 45 minutes NO progress was showing on the progress bar. I ended up having to cancel the creation a few times because I thought something was going wrong. I’m not sure if there is a problem creating the disk image, or leopard is slow, or what.
    Does anyone know how long, on average, it would take to create an encrypted disk image of this size using leopard? I just want to know if there is a problem doing this on my MBP. Thanks for the help.

    A regular 50 GB disk image takes 50GB of space, no matter if it is full of files or empty.
    A 50 GB sparse disk image only takes up the amount of space equivalent to that of its enclosed files. So if the 50GB sparse image only has 1 GB of files inside, the image won't be much bigger than 1GB.
    A sparse bundle is similar to a sparse image, but instead of a single file it is a folder package with many, many enclosed files called bands. A new file added to the sparse bundle will tend to modify only a few bands. This makes incremental backups of a sparse bundle more efficient because only the changed bands need to be backed up again. Any change to a sparse or regular disk image will mean that the entire image will need to be backed up again.
    If you regularly add/remove files to a disk image, and you intend to back up that disk image with Time Machine, a sparse bundle is definitely the way to go. The other types will fill up your TM volume very quickly.

  • Writing to Encrypted Disk Image SLOW On Mac Pro

    I have a slew of Previous Gen (2010/2012) Mac Pro 12-Core 2.66 desktops running 10.8.5 (12F45). When making a standard 128-bit Encrypted Disk Image, the write speed to that image is extremely slow. Disk image is on the same system internal drive as the source material. Also tried on Gigabit Ethernet share. 1GB file takes 20 minutes.
    If I take the same disk image and run it on a 2012 Mac mini server 2.6 i7 running 10.8.5 (12F45), the write speed is fast; 1GB takes 1 minute. Same holds true for a MacBook Pro (non-Retina) 2.3 i7 running 10.8.5 (12F45).
    Antivirus is disabled on all machines for testing purposes. Mac mini is actually a clone of the Mac Pro's system, so everything is the same, software-wise.
    Is there something inherently wrong with these Xeon Mac Pros that they cannot write fast to encrypted disks? Any other variables I'm not thinking of?
    Thanks in advance.

    The write speed to an encrypted image is around 5.65MB/s in comparison to 92MB/s on normal disk. I feel frustrated to see the remaining time to copy 800GB of data from internal HDD to the mounted encrypted volume takes around 1 day. An encrypted disk managed by Truecrypt on any PC will work much better than it.
    iMac (Late 2013), OS X Yosemite (10.10.1)

  • Disk Utility - Create encrypted disk images super sloooow

    Trying to create encrypted disk images via Disk Utility on my iMac (i7 8GB) is super-slow in 10.8.   It worked quite fast in 10.7, but now it's super-slow and doesn't even seem to ever finish.
    I've tried re-installing 10.8 with no difference.
    Anyone else having trouble with this?  Even a small dmg (~200MB) doesn't seem to work.
    Unencrypted images seem to work OK (if not a little slow).
    I realize that the encryption process will be slower but something is definately wrong with 10.8 disk utility in this regard.  I have 1TB+ free space.  I have tried with another user account as well.
    My task was: (new disk image, read-write, 128bit encryption)
    2012-09-03 08:59:59 -0400: Initializing…
    2012-09-03 09:00:00 -0400: Creating…
    2012-09-03 09:03:28 -0400: Copying…  <<< seems to be stuck here...

    Good morning,
    Have you tried using Disk Utility from within the recovery mode? (Hold down CMD and R when booting)
    I used to have this problem but creating them this way really improved the time.
    Give it a go...
    Rob

  • Creating an Encrypted Disk Image on an External (USB) Drive

    I have an external 600 GB drive (2x 300 GB SATA 3.5" disks in a Thecus N2050 RAID0 external enclosure connected to iMac by USB2) onto which I would like to backup a large amount of data (500 GB).
    I store this external drive away from my home (in the office) and since I cannot guarantee physically locking away the drive I would like to logically lock the drive by placing all the backup data into an encrypted disk image created on that volume.
    I have tried creating an encrypted disk image on my USB volume in Disk Utility (Apple's instructions here) but I experience a number of issues not documented in the Apple article:
    1) I am not presented with a drop-down option for the size of the disk image.
    2) When I go ahead and try to creat the image I am told that the creation was impossible "file or folder does not exist".
    Is it possible to create disk images on USB volumes (I cannot create such a large disk image on my iMac HDD as I do not have sufficient space).
    thanks in advance
    Raf

    I realised that in Disk Utility you must not have any of your mounted drives highlighted in the left hand pane.

  • Creating a LARGE Encrypted Disk Image

    Hello,
    I have to encrypt a LARGE external Hard Drive for my work (a 1 Terabyte external drive, which comes to about 930 gigs to encrypt).
    I have to do one of the regular encrypted disk images, not one of those expandable ones.
    I know that encrypted disk images take a long time to create, as I’ve created smaller ones in the past and they take hours.
    Does anyone know how long it will take to create an encrypted disk image of this size?
    AND, since it will probably take quite a while, I was wondering if it is BAD for my MacBook Pro or the external drive itself to write information for this long of a period. I just want to make sure I don’t damage anything.
    Thanks for any help.

    I did a 400 GB one and it must have taken an hour to get the password prompt, a couple more for the creation, and another for formatting and mounting.
    If you have a bed and sleep daily, as I suspect you do, start an hour before bed, enter the password and it should be done by morning.
    You don't need a 900 GB image unless you have one 900 GB file which I doubt. Make one smaller one say 300, then copy it twice. The password will be the same in all 3 copies.
    If you look at activity monitor not much is going on during all this so don't think the house will burn down (or your pants - see other question posted today).

  • Unable to create an encrypted disk image in Lion

    disk utility gives the error Unable to create "Volume.dmg." (error - 60008) when creating an encrypted disk image. I am using the following steps:
        1.    Open disk utility
        2.    Select the disk (internal or external) to create the image on
        3.    Select File>New>Blank Disk Image…
        4.    Save As: 'Volume'
        5.    Name: Volume
        6.    Size: 50GB
        7.    Format: Mac OS Extended (Journaled)
        8.    Encryption: 128-bit AES encryption
        9.    Image Format: read/write disk image
        10.    Click the Create button
        11.    Password dialog appears
        12.    When I enter a password the dialog closes after entering only a few characters i.e. before I've finished typing, and the following error message displays:
    Unable to create "Volume.dmg." (error - 60008)
    I have previously, successfully, created encrypted disk images in Snow Leopard, and I don't know why I can't in Lion
    Does anyone have any ideas?

    Thanks for this Thomas.
    I've tried naming the image differently, but still received the error, I did however try different permutations for the password.
    The error seems to happen if I use a purely numerical password string and occurs on input of the 10th numerical character, if I start with numerical character but use an alpha before the 9th number I can continue and create a password, and I can create a password  if I start with an alpha and switch to numerals after the first alpha character, purely alphabetical passwords are fine too.
    It seems that Lion doesn't like purely numerical passwords greater than 9 characters, whereas Snow Leopard wasn't so fussy. Seems it's a bit of a bug.
    Thanks for your help

  • Unable to create an encrypted disk image with Disk Utility

    Hi:
    With our upgrade to Lion a few weeks ago, we're now unable to create an encrypted disk image of any type using Disk Utility any more. This problem occurs on 3 different machines, and is reproducible whether one is using an internal HD or an external FW HD. We can successfully create nonencrypted disk images.
    This is a duplicate post with all the details here: https://discussions.apple.com/message/18469359#18469359
    We haven't had any luck with a solution trying various permissions fixes as helpfully suggested by other readers in response to the error message # (-60008 error), so I'm hoping that someone else has run across a solution from the encrypted disk image perspective and that this tag line will generate some help.
    Thank you!

    Save As: 01 (on Desktop)
    Name: 01
    Size: 100 MB
    Format: Mac OS Encrypted (Journaled)
    Encryption: 256-bit AES
    Partitions: Single partition- Apple Partition Map
    Image Format: read/write disk image
    At the password window that pops up I enter: 1234567890
    This says password strength is "Weak"
    All works fine
    Then I repeated this using:
    Save As: 02 (on Desktop)
    Name: 02
    Size: 100 MB
    Format: Mac OS Encypted (Journaled)
    Encryption: 256-bit AES
    Partitions: Single partition- Apple Partition Map
    Image Format: read/write disk image
    At the password window that pops up I enter: 1234567890 and when I start to enter the next "1" I get the "Unable to create "02.dmg." (error -60008)
    OS 10.7.4
    Disk Utility Version 12.1.1 (353)

  • Encrypted disk image on external drive prevents that drive from ejecting

    I've tested this a few different ways, and it seems to be a rather consistent problem.
    I have an external USB hard drive (seagate) and on that drive I use encrypted disk images to store my data.
    (because it's a portable drive, I'm nervous I'll lose it and then someone will have access to my stuff).
    So anyway, whenever I mount the sparse bundle disk image, when it comes time to eject the drive (after ejecting the disk image of course), it hangs for a while and then the Finder says it can't eject, but that I can Force Eject the drive.  When I chose to Force Eject, it works, but I don't like having to force it every time.
    Anyone know what's up?
    Thanks,
    Brian.,

    Open Disk Utility > File > New >Blank Disk Image...
    or use the "Option-⌘-N" Key combo (with Disk Utlity open).
    Kj

  • Create encrypted disk image with OS install disk utility.

    I thought to make a full backup of Macintosh HD, and followed instructions in /kb/ht1553.  However, every time I tried to creae an encrypted disk image, it barfed with "Failed - User interaction required". I assume it needed the encryption password, but for some reason was unable to display a prompt for this. Anyone know how to fix this?  Thanks, Stephen.

    Create an encrypted sparse disk image instead of from folder, mount it, and then drag & drop your files into ii.

  • Corrupted files within encrypted disk images

    Greetings Apple Hivemind:
    I've run across a repeatable problem when using encrypted disk images from Disk Utility.  Essentially, I'll create an image using settings like are shown below:
    The disk image is then used for storing data.  In my case, this is usually data for Adobe Lightroom.
    At first, this worked very well, and I housed the disk images on my household NAS, connecting via samba (smb) to it on my Mac.  Over time, however, something odd started happening:  Files on those encrypted images began getting corrupted whenever I tried writing new data to them.
    My first incident was where Lightroom informed me that the catalog it was trying to open was corrupted.  I  tried to create a new one on the same encrypted volume, and it too was instantly flagged as corrupted.  I opened the individual image files on the volume with no problem, so I wasn't thinking that the volume was the culprit.  That is, until I tried dragging new image files to it manually.  The new files were immediately either completely unreadable, or a mish-mash of the content of random OTHER files on the volume!
    The result was that all old data seemed intact, but I could no longer write new data to the volumes without major data corruption issues.  I thought that this was isolated to one volume in particular, but it soon started happening on ALL of my encrypted volumes eventually.  Including those which were not, and never had been, housed on my NAS, but were on my local hard drives.
    I've since "evacuated" all my data from these images, since the ones created by Disk Utility appear to be useless, and am seeking an alternative.
    Is this something that anyone else has encountered when using encrypted disk images?  It seems like this is something I should really open a support ticket for, but I can't say I've ever tried it, so I don't know how successful it would be to do so.

    bbonn wrote:
    I should add that I've tried using the "Repair" and "Verify" functions of Disk Utility on the volumes, and despite the obvious issues that exist in them, the utility doesn't find (or fix) any inconsistencies.
    Are you repairing/verifying the actual disk images, or just the partition they're on?  If the partition, it won't look inside them.
    Drag one to Disk Utility's sidebar, select it, then use Verify or Repair.  Note: the usual messages may not appear on the DU window.  Click the Log icon in the toolbar or select Window > Show Log from the menubar to see them.

  • Indexing of encrypted disk images permanently disabled in 10.8?

    In the past, I've had no trouble forcing Spotlight to index my encrypted disk image, using the command in Terminal:
    sudo mdutil -i on /Volumes/Encrypted_Data
    After entering that command, my encrypted disk image was indexed and searchable using Spotlight.
    A couple weeks ago I updated from Lion to Mountain Lion. Today I noticed Spotlight wasn't showing any results from my encrypted disk image. So went back to Terminal and entered the above command. Instead of successfully activating indexing, Terminal gives me this message:
    /Volumes/Encrypted_Data:
                Indexing disabled.
    Is this procedure now impossible in Mountain Lion?
    Is there any way to enable indexing of this encrypted disk image? I can't get it to work.
    Thanks.

    I appear to have solved the problem to get Spotlight to index a disk image.  My image was an encrypted disk image.  I was able to get spotlight to work when it was new, but now Spotlight won't index it.  Here is the solution that I found:
    After double clicking and mounting disk the image, open Disk Utility, select the disk image file, then click unmount in the Toolbar.  Wait until it is unmounted, then click mount again.   Then go to terminal and try mdutil -sa .  If it is still not enabled, try to sudo mdutil -i on option.  The unmounting and remounting must be done everytime the image is opened.

  • HT1578 Labels (Mavericks) not working in encrypted disk image?

    I created an encrypted disk image with Disk Utility.
    I placed a file in the opened encrypted disk image, and labeled it with "test".
    If I open a finder window and look for files labelled "test" the file doesn't appear.
    This message is placed under the wrong OS, because it is not possible to choose Mevericks from the popup list!!!!

    Where I used the word label I did mean tag

  • Even though I have LCD font smoothing disabled, Mountain Lion still uses it in PDF views, Safari's location bar, Mail's message view, and the dialogs for mounting encrypted disk images.

    Even though I have LCD font smoothing disabled, Mountain Lion still uses it in PDF views, Safari’s location bar, Mail’s message view, and the dialogs for mounting encrypted disk images. Is there any solution to this problem? Also diabled the Smoothing in the SystemPrefs and also via Terminal. Font smoothing is still there. Very annoying, especially in PDF attachments in Apple Mail.

    Try feeding Safari a user-defined CSS file with font-smoothing tweaks (including none). The filename and its filesystem location are arbitrary. Use your favorite coding editor.
    Safari > Preferences > Advanced > Style Sheet:
    Here is an example with all elements uncommented. Pick the one that works best for your Safari viewing and comment out the others:
    Preview. Try Preview > Preferences > PDF > Smooth text and line art (uncheck)

  • Time Machine Backups of Encrypted Disk Images, Part 2

    Hi:
    If Time Machine is backing up a hard drive that contains a subset encrypted disk image as part of its contents, and this encrypted disk image is mounted (in an unencrypted state) where the enclosed data has been changed/manipulated in any fashion, what and when does Time Machine backup?
    In other words, does the data in the encrypted disk image only change when the encrypted disk image is unmounted? Or is it somehow backed up real time even when the encrypted disk image is mounted on the desktop in an unencrypted state while Time Machine is working?
    Sorry I can't explain this very well, but hopefully the gist is clear.
    Thanks!
    (OS 10.8.2)

    Time Machine doesn't back up a disk image file while it's mounted, whether encrypted or not.

Maybe you are looking for