Export to AppleTV via Compressor, Chapter Markers Wrong

I'm exporting various projects out to AppleTV via Compressor with Chapter Markers. Works great except for the Chapter Markers, which are out of sync...significantly, by 30 seconds or so. Any ideas on what the problem might be or how to ensure Chapter Markers will transfer over to the AppleTV setting in compressor?

Matt Martin1 wrote:
I'm exporting various projects out to AppleTV via Compressor with Chapter Markers. Works great except for the Chapter Markers, which are out of sync...significantly, by 30 seconds or so. Any ideas on what the problem might be or how to ensure Chapter Markers will transfer over to the AppleTV setting in compressor?
So this is a Compressor-specific issue, right?
What I mean to say is, if you're exporting QT movies out of FCP, those do not exhibit the shift in chapter markers, correct? Just trying to determine if FCP/QT is the culprit here.
Or are you exporting directly to Compressor? Or adding the chapter markers directly in Compressor?

Similar Messages

Exporting "Selected Clips" and iDVD Chapter Markers from iMovie

I've tried exporting "selected clips" from iMovie . The iDVD Chapter Markers do not appear as a menu option on the initial iDVD menu screen when "selected clips" is checked in the iMovie Share option. The chapter markers are limited to the clips I'm exporting. The "Share" dialog box seems to indicate that Chapter Markers should export but they don't. // I'm trying to break up a movie that's too long for a DVD (but I will later share to video from iMovie). I'd prefer not to make two iMovie projects out of this. Thanks!
iMac FP 17 Mac OS X (10.4.6)
iMac FP 17 Mac OS X (10.3.6)

Hello, John,
Welcome to the discussions.
You can either do your 'share to video from iMovie' before or after creating your iDVDs. But, you will need to create a second iMovie if yours is too long for one DVD and you are wanting to make 2 DVDs from the one long movie.
To make the second one before sharing the entire movie:
Select the clips you want in the second movie, then go to 'Edit' and 'Copy'.
Then, select 'New' iMovie. When it opens, give it a name like "Part2" and then 'Paste' your selected clips. Save the movie, then go back to the first one. Delete the clips you just copied.
Close iMovie. Open your DVD project. Find the 'Media' tab, go to 'Movies' and drag and drop your first movie into iDVD. Finish the iDVD project. Save and close.
Then, create the second iDVD project for your second movie in the same way.
Do 'save as disk image' for each iDVD project. That way your project is intact for each one, and you will not lose anything when you change the iMovies. You can burn your DVDs from the disk images.
Now, go back to your second iMovie. Select the clips and copy. Close that movie and open the first one. Paste the second set of clips. Now you have your original movie back and can do your share to video from it. Delete the second movie.

Cannot export as says there are chapter markers within 1 sec. of another

I started with a clean slate (I thought) with a new sequence, whereupon I put some chapter markers only to be told (when just about to export) that there were chapter markers within 1 second of other chapter markers and so those chapter markers would be ignored. Why is it saying that when I know very well (at least I think I do) that there are minutes between chapter markers? Could there be something hidden? I have spent hours exporting only to find that most of my chapter markers didn't make it through. Can someone help me with this? Thanks a bunch!

My bet is that you actually do.
Zoom in real close and Option-M (I think) to move to the next Marker... I'll bet you hit the marker button twice really quick somewhere and have two on the timeline.
When you find the bad one... hit M again to pull up the dialog box and then just DELETE.
Good luck,
CaptM

Exporting to DVD via compressor and DVDSP - fixing poor quality dissolves

Hi,
Im having real problems with the quality of the dissolves when exporting my 59min project out of FCP, into Compressor and then into DVDSP. I exported it out to Compressor 2, used DVD best quality, 90 min, 16:9 (project is for PAL) , had the bit rate 6.5 - 7.5 etc. In the finished product the dissolves are grainy and really noticeable during the transition of 1 sec.
When we were doing test burns, using a reference movie (export/quicktime/untick make movie self contained etc) and burnt through Toast, all was fine. so I know it is not the work done in FCP its the settings or something in Compressor or something in DVDSP? Not sure.
I built and burnt the project through DVDSP and also took the build (Video TS folder) and burnt it thorugh Toast as well and got the same result! Very frustrating and now I have to deliver a sub standard product to my client for a launch tomorrow. They are burning off 50 copies for it. Very upsetting. But before they do the replication of 1000 I want to sort this out.
Is there another way to get my project out of FCP and into Compressor? For example is it possbile to export a Quicktime and full quality? I've never done this and was wondering if it is an option.
Hope you can help.
Thanks.

You can modify the encoding settings in the DVDSP Preferences menu. There's a tab at the far right labeled "Encoding".
Just to confim - when I import the QT file into DVDSP, do I then just drag it onto the timeline as you would with the M2V file? Then just drag in the AC3 audio file.
Yes.
Then do I do a 'Build' in DVDSP to get the Video TS folder? Do you normally burn then through the DVDSP or burn in Toast for example.
I normally build to my secondary internal drive first and open that folder with DVD Player, just to make sure I connected everything properly. I prefer to check my project in DVD Player rather than use the built-in simulator, primarily because I can then fast forward my tracks to make sure my jump points and buttons work.
When I'm ready to burn a disc, I burn directly from DVDSP.

FCP 7 sending to compressor chapter markers question . . .

Have set an in and out point on the timeline and then send it to compressor and burn a SD DVD, the previous chapter marker prior to the in point (have parts 1 & 2 on the timeline) is showing up in the chapter list after burning. Anyone else had this issue?
In FCP 6 and previous versions, never had this problem.
thanks in advance for any info . . .

Same problem here.

Render faults after exporting to MPEG4 via compressor

Maybe this message should be placed in Compressor. Anyway, when exporting my FCP-sequence to MPEG4, some strange things happen: Text-objects change height, they're much larger in the rendered file than in my FCP-sequence. One of the logos I've made with Motion3 disappeared in de mpeg4-rendered file, while it is really visable in FCP. When exporting in other formats is shows up properly. What might be the problem? Thanks in advance. PR

If you can successfully export to Microsoft AVI then you can use the free Windows Media Encoder from Microsoft to make better WMV files.
Cheers
Eddie

Export as 16:9 w/ chapter markers?

I have a 2 hr. project shot on HDV. loaded ftg. as DV NTSC 16:9 anamorphic. I edited and added several chap makrs in FCP 4.5. now I want to export this w/ chapter mrkrs into iDVD. I need to have 16:9 look w/ chapter mkrs in iDVD. How do I do this?

If Anamorphicizer doesn't help there are other tips here that may:
Anamorphic widescreen in iDVD 5
http://capital2.capital.edu/admin-staff/dalthoff/widescreen.html

Why won't chapter markers export?

I have tried again and again to export my chapter markers but they just won't. What am I doing wrong?
Eric

If you don't have any other markers (e.g. compression), export your movie to "include chapter markers" instead of "all markers."
Actually, if you're exporting for DVD (either Compressor, DVDSP, or iDVD), you're supposed to select DVD Studio Pro Markers, not All Markers.
If you need the techie explanation, selecting All Markers writes all marker information to a single text track in QuickTime (do a Command-J of your movie in QuickTime to observe this). Compressor & DVDSP cannot parse the chapter information from this single text track.
When selecting DVD Studio Pro Markers, you're writing three kinds of marker info - Chapter, Compression and Cut - across 2 text tracks in QuickTime. DVDSP & Compressor can correctly parse the chapter info (and, because of the presence of compression and cut markers, your encodes should come out better).
As Nathan mentions, selecting Chapter Markers works as well, but you write chapter info to single text track in QuickTime, leaving out the other marker information (which makes a real difference with troublesome footage).

Compressor does not recognize chapter markers

I have exported my FCP timeline with chapter markers to a self-contained QT file.
I have enabled the text track in the QT file. Now I want to encode the QT file to MPEG-2 with the chapter markers. But I don't see any markers in Compressor? I only see the enabled text track...
Any help greatly appreciated - I must use forced I-frames due to the accuracy of placing the chapters on the final DVD.

I just ran into this problem today myself. It's unbelievable; I get so tired of Apple programming methods!! Do they even test or use these things before they release them so things make sense to the end user?
*breathe*
Alright. Ken Stone to the rescue!
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/exporting_markers_fromfcp.html
Ok, so before I get flamed, yes, there's everything to be said about understanding how to use a program before using it. I'm just asking for a little common sense programming.

Exporting: losing chapter markers

I have a video with 6 sequences. #2-5 are the 5 sections of my video. Sequence #1 contains the other 5 in order, to give me a "full video" sequence.
When I export a single sequence, the chapter markers remain intact. But when I export Sequence #1 (which contains all 5), all chapter markers are lost.
(Exporting through Compressor to DVD Studio Pro.)
How can I export my full video without losing the chapter markers?
Thanks for any help!
PowerMac G5 Mac OS X (10.4.8)

You're correct, the green chapter markers are in each individual sequence. What threw me off though, is that even in the "master" sequence (containing the nested ones), I could right-click on the timeline and all the chapter markers were available to jump to. I don't understand why they don't export.
I did export the sequences separately. In DVDSP, creating a separate track for each one preserves the chapter markers. But if I combine them on a single track as you suggested, only the first clip/sequence has its chapter markers -- none of the others come in with the clips.
So, I now have five separate tracks, and had to recreate all the stories I'd already done, as well as re-link all my menus. What a huge amount of unnecessary work.
The FCP manual talks about nested sequences and suggests using them to combine into one master sequence. It sure doesn't mention that you lose all your chapter markers.
Is there a better way to get FCP sequences into DVDSP (with chapter markers) than creating separate tracks, as I had to? This seems like a really fragmented workflow.
Thank you very much for your insight, and for your time!
Mac OS X (10.4.8)

Unable to export chapter markers

Usually in Final Cut Pro I have no problem exporting a finished video with chapter markers. However, when I go to File >> Export >> QuickTime Movie, the fields titled "Include" and "Markers" are different. "Include" says "Auto" instead of "Video & Audio", and "Markers" says "Quarter" instead of "Chapter".
Why would it do this? I simply restarted FCP and it is back to normal. But I dont understand why it would do this.
Message was edited by: hypertext07

hypertext07 wrote:
Why would it do this? I simply restarted FCP and it is back to normal. But I dont understand why it would do this.
Ghosts in the machine.

Export Chapter Markers and time

Final Cut Pro 6.0.2
Is it possible to export a file showing the chapter markers in a sequence and the timecode for each chapter? We need to analyze the duration of each chapter. Any suggestions as to how to do this.
thank you
jac
Message was edited by: jac Colon

put an in point at marker 1 and out point in marker 2 in the FCp sequence, and see how long the duration is... repeat for 2 to 3 etc...
Jerry

DVDSP not recognizing Chapter Markers from FCP?

We added Chapter Markers in FCP6. We exported one time with DVD Studio Pro Marker and tried the other time with Chapter Markers. We took it into Compressor and made the file into MPG-2 and imported into DVD Studio Pro, though it does not seem to recognize the chapter markers once in DVD Studio Pro.
Does anyone have any advice on what I might be doing wrong?
Thanks!

Or, just try selecting your sequence in FCP's browser, then go to the file menu and export using Compressor. Choose your setting, your destination, and hit submit. Saves steps, and it will export your complete sequence including chapter markers.

Chapter Markers - where did they go???

I've searched and found a lot of posts, but no solution that works for me.
I've followed this: http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/compression_chapter_markersstone.html and it doesn't help.
I've exported every way possible from FCP, and when I bring the file (or export directly) into Compressor, I can see the markers.
When I encode in Compressor, and bring it into DVD Studio Pro, there are no Chapter Markers anywhere. I had even made sure to check the boxes regarding DVD Studio Pro and Chapter Markers.
What am I missing?
Can anyone tell me if there's a way to export the Chapter Markers from FCP and import it into DVD Studio Pro?
Any help would be appreciated...

Of course I get it working right after I posted this...
Here's the solution so others can benefit:
Exporting the QT movie with "Chapter Markers" instead of anything else. You'd think that a setting specifically for "DVD Studio Pro" would work, but it doesn't. "All Markers" won't work either. Since the word "all" doesn't mean "all," it's all very confusing.
Once in Compressor, you want to see your markers show up purple instead of green. Importing the compressed file immediately imported the chapter markers.
Recap:
1. In FCP, create markers, open them and designate them as Chapter Markers.
2. Export to Compressor or QT movie, self contained not necessary, using ONLY the "Chapter Markers" setting.
3. Encode in Compressor, and bring into DVD Studio Pro.
More details are in the other posts and links, and here's another good one:
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/exporting_markers_fromfcp.html
Silal - yes, I tried selecting the clip and using "import embedded markers," but I apparently would needed a text file with that data already prepared in order to do that. I tried searching for a way to export only a chapter marker list, but I haven't found a way to do that. It would have saved me from re-encoding everything twice if I had found a way. (I would have made one manually if I didn't have almost 90 Chapters!) ...and I knew the markers needed to be in the timeline and not in the clips, but thanks for checking.
My 2 Cents:
I don't see any reason why this can't be greatly simplified. With the numbers of other users having the same confusion as I did, Apple should address this. Imagine this: You simply create a marker in FCP, and export with an option that automatically designates them all as chapter markers, and then it just works the first time. Having an option to export a chapter marker text file for importing over previously encoded files would be nice, too.

Chapter markers to idvd NOT WORKING

I created chapter markers...
I sent movie to iDVD...
There is no sub-menu with the chapters.
I checked preferences and I have it all set up correctly (I assume).
Any ideas? I really need to get this done for my son's class.
Thanks.
Dwaine
According to this article: http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?path=iMovie/9.0/en/mov3ac6b3ff.html I should be able to export to iDVD and the chapter markers should be there...
If you’ve added chapter markers to your project, you can simply burn the project to a DVD or export it, and the chapter markers will be recognized by iDVD, iTunes, iPod, iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, Front Row, QuickTime Player, DVD Player, and most standard DVD players.
Click to select the project in the Project Library, or open the project, and then do one of the tasks listed below. The Share menu appears in a light gray bar across the top of your computer screen.
To share your movie with iDVD, choose Share > iDVD, and then burn it to a DVD.
To share your movie with iTunes, choose Share > iTunes.
To send your movie to the Media Browser, choose Share > Media Browser.When you send a project to the Media Browser, it will be available for use in iDVD the next time you open iDVD, which recognizes chapter markers.
To export your movie as a movie file, choose Share > Export Movie.Keep in mind that movies exported in the tiny format don’t include chapter markers.
To export your movie using advanced QuickTime options, choose Share > “Export using QuickTime.”

This has been fixed...
Turns out I was adding COMMENTS and not CHAPTERS!
Dwaine

Export to AppleTV via Compressor, Chapter Markers Wrong

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for