External Hard Drive 3TB - iOmega, Western Digital... ?

Hi guys
Since my MacBook Pro is getting stuffed with huge Adobe files (I'm a graphic designer) and I'm not really into throwing stuff away since they might be useful one day, and that I can't make time to start reducing the filesize of these files, I am considering on buying a new External Hard Drive, next to my Time Capsule.
What I want to know: I have my 1TB Time Capsule and I love it for what it does, but it isn't the external hard drive I'm looking for. So what is the best solution for me, respecting the following preferences?
3 TB
wireless and FireWire or USB
not a portable disk
adapter
compatible with:MacBook Pro 15-inch, spring 2011, 2 GHz Intel Core i7
Time Capsule 1TB
Mac OS X Lion
I've already been gathering information about these devices:
Iomega® Network hard drive Home Media Cloud Edition 2 TB - Link
Western Digital 3TB My Book Studio - Link
Western Digital My Book Studio II harde schijf van 4 TB - Link
Any of these is the best solution? Or what would you advice?
Many thanks!
Bob

Just to add to the mixing pot....
Just re-read the thread and mulled over all the ideas. First off, wasn't the idea to have a means of backing up your data? The key to effective backups is redundancy; acknowledge that hardware will fail but there will always be at least one copy that missed the bullet. The 6TB monster is quite appealing from the cost per GB perspective, but I fear it will become a central and solitary repository for all your life's treasures while you try to fill it up. And if it fails, as all hardware does eventually, I'm going to get my butt chewed in the virtual sense, for having recommended it. Me? I have a slew of external drives I cycle around as I change from OS to OS, Mac to Mac and week to week. 12 at last count, plus 3 HDDs laying in their antistatic bags, waiting hopefully for me to get them their own enclosure.
When you mention working on a huge .psd on an external drive, note that you are crossing a threshold there. Mixing a device used for backups with one used as an external workspace. Just beware of the risks involved; should failure occur while you're working, your backups will die as well.
Regardless what you end up using the drive(s) for, you'll have to make a choice regarding the interface. Do you want speed or convenience. Wireless is great for ease, but are you willing to have the Mac hung up for twice or trice the time while it backs up, vs. a direct FW or eSATA link?

Similar Messages

I upgraded to Maverick and now Time Machine will not connect to the external hard drive to back up files. The external hard drive is a Western Digital "My Book Live" 2 TB. How do I solve problem?

I upgraded to Maverick and now Time Machine will not connect to the external hard drive to back up files. The external hard drive is a Western Digital "My Book Live" 2 TB. How do I solve problem?

I also had problem accessing my WD MyBookLive after upgrading to Maverick.
To resolve the problem, I used Connect To Server (Cmd K) to specify the IP address.
Then I enter a user id and password I created in the MyBookLive.
You can also verify that you have admin access to the MyBookLive using Safari or Chrome.
Just enter the MyBookLive IP address as the URL.

I have an external hard drive, from Iomega. However, I cannot copy or save any file to it. On my PC it says that is possible to read and write in it, but in my Mac, it says I can only read. can somebody help me?

I have an external hard drive, from Iomega. that I can open and see my files. However, I cannot copy or save any file to it. On my PC I have it says that is possible to read and write in it, but in my Mac, it says I can only read. can somebody help me?
Also, Im a photographer, so I like to name a lot of files at the same time (used to do in on PC and it was very usefull.) cannot find out how to do it on my Mac. Really appretiate if some one can give me a solution! Thanx

Your drive is formatted with the NTFS file system. OS X can read but not write to the NTFS file system. There are third party drivers available that claim to add the ability to OS X to write to an NTFS partition. I have not tried them and don't know if they work.
The only file system that OS X and Windows can both write to natively is the FAT32 file system.

How do you resize existing partitions on an external hard-drive without deleting their contents?

Hi, I've got an external hard drive (1 GB Western digital) Which I bought with a view to both storage and time-machine functions.
Initially, I partitioned the hard drive such that I had 750 GB for the time-machine segment, and 250 GB for the storage segment.
Now that my storage is approaching the 250 GB limit, and my time machine is only taking up 80 of the alloted 750 GB, I want to transfer some of that space across so that I'll have more room for storage.
When attempting this on disk utility, I can reduce the size of the time machine partition, but I am unable to increase the size of the storage partition.
Can someone please advise what I should do to sort this out without deleting the contents of each partition.
Regards,
Josh

Well, this is not easily answered. You can shrink existing partitions in order to add additional ones. But in order to add space from one partition to another that can only be done by first removing the lower partition first. If that partition has data, then it will be lost. Unfortunately, Disk Utility cannot manipulate partitions in place. You need a third-party utility for that, iPartition 3.4.1.
Now with that said I'll pass on a bit of advice. Do not us your Time Machine backup drive for extra storage. External storage and backups should be kept on separate drives. I suggest you get a separate drive for your storage or Time Machine backups.
If you use Disk Utility you can shrink your Time Machine partition, but the only way to put that space in another partition is to first delete the storage partition, then recreate it with a larger capacity.

External Hard drives

I didn't see any forum that was directed toward external hard drives...
Im looking to get either a Seagate 1TB external hard drive or a Western Digital 1TB hard drive. I currently have a 500 GB seagate HD but I need more space for back up. Any suggestions on which is better between Seagate and Western Digital?

Personally, of the two, I've found the Seagates to be the more reliable, Chester.
My other strong recommendation would be that you get one which is firewire capable , rather than simply USB.
But don't stick with those two brands. Have a look at http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/firewire/1394/USB/EliteAL/ and http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/firewire/owc-neptune-drives/ for example.
The OWC mercurys , in particular, are used by many of the long term Mac people here and have a very good reputation. The Neptune's make use of a good chipset in their "bridge" and are very good value for money compared to other drives of similar or lesser quality. They are at least on a par with the external offerings from some of the "name" manufacturers.
But whatever you get , get firewire. The transfer rates, even with FW400, are close to twice as fast as those you will achieve over USB when connected to an iMac G5.
Cheers
Rod

Can't access old data on external hard drive.

Hello all,
I purchased my Macbook Pro about a year ago, and never really had any problems unless I was slow on updating. Well, I recently updated, and that's when everything went to pot. My computer became really slow - constantly giving me the spinning rainbow ball - and it would do this for up to an hour. I would have to keep manually shutting down and restarting. Then, it would show a loading bar when I tried to restart, but then it would just shut off completely by itself, without ever fully loading. I tried Safe Boot, but to no avail. After that, I attempted to boot from the Mac OSX Snow Leopard disc, but that didn't work either, because it said the disc was damaged when I did a disc repair. So, I did one the other options in disc utility: Restore. However, I did this on an external hard drive (1 TB, Western Digital) that I had just purchased after the Safe Boot failure because my 250 GB was too small for me to run Time Machine on. I placed the Macintosh HD as the source and the external hard drive as a recipient, for I had read that this works effectively in transferring files before erasing the hard drive. I then erased the internal hard drive, and booted from the disc, completely reinstalling the whole system.
My computer works just as smoothly as it did before all this happened, but now there's just one problem - I cannot access anything off of the external HD. I can see the music and video files that I used to have in iTunes, and they are .m4v, .mp3 and .m4p, but iTunes and Quicktime do not recognize them. If I double click on them, it says the files are not complete (as with the Applications on the external HD). I cannot find any of my old Word Documents or pictures, just music and movie files, and Applications. When I plug my external HD into my computer, it shows up as "Macintosh HD" and a notification that it cannot be changed and that it needs to be reformatted.
Is there no hope in recovering my old pictures and Word Documents? They were all on my first 250 GB hard drive, but I erased that in attempt to make more room for Time Machine.
Thank you for your help!

raneyeb wrote:
They were all on my first 250 GB hard drive, but I erased that in attempt to make more room for Time Machine.
If you simply reformatted the drive, but didn't overwrite it with new data, there is a chance recovery software can recover your files.
You need something like DataRescue that reads the 1's and 0's of your files directly off the platters (not what anything else says) and you need another new drive to send those recovered files too when your doing it. (can't write to the same drive, it would overwrite the deleted data)
If you let TimeMachine use the drive, or you copied data onto it, or did a "Security Erase Option" then it's all gone, sorry.
Next time, once your all stable again, take a look at Carbon Copy Clone your entire boot drive (no filevault or bootcamp) to another HFS+ journaled formatted drive, it's hold option bootable and will save your bacon if a boot drive dies or if OS X gets hozed due to some unforseen software issue.
I maintain 2 clones, rotate them every few weeks, they get auto-upddated nightly.
TimeMachine I don't use, but if I did, it would be in addition to the two clones, as TM isn't bootable and is not quite reliable when you restore back from it sometimes.

External Hard Drive not showing on desktop

Hi,
I'm using a macbook pro, 15", and have been using it with my external hard drive for the past 2 months.
This afternoon, I was using the external, where i have all my music and photos stored, and it was working fine. I left the computer on sleep for about 2 hours (all programs that have stuff on the external I made sure to quit before), and when I got back the "icon" for the back up disk was slightly more "invisible" on my desktop and time machine informed me that the latest back up failed. When I tried to eject it (nothing on the disk was being used) it said it couldnt be ejected because the disk was in use.
I tried to eject again, same thing, so I restarted the computer. When I restarted the computer the external harddrive icon did not show up on my desk top. I tried pulling it out and plugging it in a few times, the disk will start up, but not load onto my desk top.
HELP!!!
the external hard drive is a Western Digital "my Passport"
Thank you!

Danja.schluter wrote:
if I repair the disk, will i lose everything on it?
Running Disk Repair will not harm your data, the idea is to repair and make it functional again.
If successful I would make a back up of that data because you may be skating on thin ice.

Recovery Disc Creation (1TB External hard-drive)

I am attempting to create a 'Recovery Disc' and I had a few questions. I tried doing a little research but I got yes and no answers. Is it possible to partition an external hard drive and make my computer think the partition is a blank USB drive to make a back-up media file? I realize this may have complications... I.E. When it tries to format the drive. Would that ruin the partition on the external HD or treat it as the drive and only format the portion that has been partitioned? It is even possible to do? The external hard drive being 1TB (Western Digital Passport) and I only need to make a ~32GB portion. I am just looking for a little insight before I go buy a new USB just to back up my laptop so HP Support Assistant stops yelling at me.

I wouldn't attempt it. Not sure it would even work, the Recovery Manager 'might' use it but it may also format the entire hdd in the process. Even if it was successful at creating the Recovery partition on it, you will still be faced with the problem of trying to get the laptop to boot from the usb hdd in the event of needing to perform a Recovery.
If you don't want to invest in a 32Gb flash drive to dedicate to this and have DVDs they can be used.Usually requires 3-5.
******Clicking the Thumbs-Up button is a way to say -Thanks!.******
**Click Accept as Solution on a Reply that solves your issue to help others**

How can I recover my files from a My Book Essential 3TB external hard drive?

The hard drive was no longer showing up on the desktop or Disk Utility even after changing cables and power supplies. So I tried another remedy and took out the hard drive of the Western Digital case and put it in a Rosewill external case. Still no luck. The only thing that shows up on the Disk Utility is what I assume is probably the external case itself but it doesn't detect the hard drive. Are the files recoverable? Will a program like DiskWarrior work? I am a little irked by the price especially if it will not work for my situation. Please help! Thank you!

The hard drive was no longer showing up on the desktop or Disk Utility even after changing cables and power supplies. So I tried another remedy and took out the hard drive of the Western Digital case and put it in a Rosewill external case. Still no luck. The only thing that shows up on the Disk Utility is what I assume is probably the external case itself but it doesn't detect the hard drive. Are the files recoverable? Will a program like DiskWarrior work? I am a little irked by the price especially if it will not work for my situation. Please help! Thank you!

Itunes with 10.3x not transferring large files to external hard drive

I have been unable to transfer any large files, basically anything over over two artists or so from old external hard drive for my old windows xp computer to my new external hard drive (both iomega and western digital have been tried) without the transfer cutting out and popping up a message to effect of itunes can not copy or add file to folder...something like that. am i missing something that i need to be doing? ive got about 33,000 items, and the thought of doing them 10-15 at a time really isn't something i want to do. But as of this point, i can't find a way to simply xfer the whole itunes library from the old external to the new one. Thanks for any help.

You can transfer purchased content ONLY! Unfortunately, you have no choice as to what gets transferred. Here are some work arounds
1. Delete off iPod Touch/iPhone/iPod then transfer
2. Transfer all content then delete from computer

Trouble with external hard drive. help.

I was formatting my hard drive to allow larger GB files with a lot of trouble so I got my other hard drive which I have previously formatted to find the program that worked. It was formatted with NTFS so I downloaded NTFS 3G and restarted my computer (iMac intel) after trying to format my portable hard drive to ntfs the software didnt work so I uninstalled it. Now my external hard drive will not read on my iMac but it will on my TV and Windows computer. When I installed the software a little error message popped up but i made no changes to the external hard drive and now it wont read on my mac.
The hard drive is a Western Digital My Book 1TB

Did you read this section of the ntfs 3g website? I don't use the program but it may have left pieces of itself on your mac causing your current problems.
You can type the following in a terminal window to see what "non-apple" drivers are still loaded on your system.
kextstat | grep -v com.apple
Post the results if you need to
2.2 Uninstalling Tuxera NTFS for Mac
Tuxera NTFS for Mac can be easily uninstalled using the Uninstall Tuxera NTFS... button in the Tuxera NTFS preference pane, which will be available in System Preferencesonce you have installed the package. See section 4 for a description of the other features in the preference pane.
If this should fail for some reason, an uninstall script exists at the following location:
/System/Library/Filesystems/fusefs_txantfs.fs/Support/uninstall-package.sh

What is the best external hard drive for backup on powerbook g4 17-inch?

i need to get a good external hard drive for backing up my files on my 2004 powerbook g4 17-inch. up till now ive been using thumbdrives, but i have way too much to backup now. i was thinking of getting the time capsule, but i don't have leopard version with time machine.
what would be an advisable backup to get without buying a new mactop yet?
please include model # if possible.
thanks in advance for anyone's input!

What I've done is buy the case and drive separately. The case I use is similar to this one: http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MEFW91UAL1K/ (looks like they don't offer this case with Firewire 800 anymore), and the hard drive is a Western Digital 3.5" Parallel ATA 320GB which Newegg carries at http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136109. The reason I like a combination like this is that the enclosure uses the Oxford 911 chipset, and Oxford chipsets have a good track record working with our macs. The Western Digital drive comes with a 3 year warranty (many pre-packaged hard drives only have a one year warranty). It is very easy to install the drive ... you plug in the power and data connectors to the hard drive, and screw the hard drive to the case.
Whatever external hard drive you get, recommend one with a Firewire connection. Our Powerbooks can boot from a Firewire connection, however, cannot boot from a USB-only connection. Also, be aware that for a USB-only connection, if the external hard drive relies on power from it there may be a problem. This is due to the Powerbook putting minimal power out on USB. There are many people who have found that they've had to either get a dual USB cable, a USB powered hub, or an external power supply for their USB-powered external hard drive. The case I mentioned above has it's own external power supply. Firewire-powered drives don't have this problem.

Sharing an external hard drive - iMac and iPad

I currently have an external hard drive connected to an iMac. I also have an iPad. How can I share the hard drive between both and have access to it from the iPad. The hard drive is a Western Digital 2TB My book.

iPads are not computers. You can't just share a hard drive like that. It is, in some specific conditions, possible to plug a hard drive or a memory stick through the camera connection kit, but then again, files need to be media files supported by the ipad, and copied a specific way (/DCIM/8CHARSNAME.EXT)

Multiple (related?) issues with external hard drive connectivity

Apologies if this has been discussed but I have been unable to find a solution or explanation after searching here and on other forums.
I recently purchased an external hard drive (1TB Iomega Select Portable, bus powered, 2.5", USB 2.0). After formatting with two HFS+ partitions the device began disconnecting unexpectedly and afterwards was often not recognisable by my mac until I rebooted. I returned the product and had it replaced by another of the same model.
The replacement external hard drive worked fine at first but hours later began showing the same symptoms. _It now connects briefly then a few seconds later disconnects._ Occasionally it seems to mount and work fine, but the problem always comes back. In the times when it is working, _Time Machine recognises the drive but only backs up at a rate of about 1KB/s!_
_I don't know if this is a problem with the external hard drive, my USB ports, or settings on my mac._ Any advise you could offer would be greatly appreciated as I've run out of troubleshooting options with my limited knowledge of computers.
_**Some tests I've done:_
1) When it's not being recognised in Finder, it's also not recognised in either Disk Utility or System Profiler
2) At one stage after repeatedly disconnecting, two other external hard drives and two thumb drives that I know work fine normally also failed to mount, but strangely two wireless mouse USB receivers worked fine. Both thumb drives were formatted as FAT32, one of the external hard drives had one HFS+ and one NTFS partition, and the other was entirely NTFS. When they weren't recognised in OS X, the two FAT32 drives and the NTFS partitions of the external hard drives were all recognised in Windows 7 via VMWare Fusion. After restarting the computer all of them now work on both Windows 7 and Mac OS X.
3) I tried the external hard drive on another computer (a PC) and it was recognised in Vista's 'Disk Management' with both partitions marked as 'healthy', but it just called it 'Disk 1' rather than showing the names I'd given each partition.
4) When I first started transferring files onto the drive I often got 'error code -36', but found a solution that seemed to fix that by deleting the '._' files from the source folder through Terminal.
5) I've tried different USB cables, both USB ports on my mac, and also connecting with and without the secondary part of the 'y' cable that was supplied with it.
Thanks very much,
Andrew
Message was edited by: andrewcarter

I have the same problem with some 2.5 drives. My iMac on 10.5.8 sees the drive fine but my older 2007 Mac Book Pro 10.6.6 would not see it and now my new Mac Book Pro had problems seeing the drive from my old Mac Book Pro in that box. I had to use migration utility over the network that took 18 hours to copy my user over. I bought a new drive box and now the drive seems to work fine. I have ejected it a couple times and all seems well. I hope it continues to function properly.

External hard drive isn't shown on desktop anymore

Hello!
I've got a problem with my external hard drive... I'm using a *G4 iMac* and an *external hard drive* by "iomega".
Today my computer crashed down and I had to relaunch it without having a chance to eject the external hard drive before.
When I get to my desktop again the hard drive wasn't there anymore. I turned the hard drive off ( it was turned on while relaunching the computer) and on again but it didn't work.
The hard drive is shown in the hard drive utility but I can't neither repair nor check it because all the buttons are "greyed out". And when I try to eject it with the utility, it says "Hard drive can't be ejected - Try to switch off all running programs". But I have no access to the hard drive to do so!
I also tried to attach the hard drive to another computer (this time I turned the hard drive off before!) but there's the same problem!
I need the data on it!
Is there any possibility to solve my problem without losing my data???
Thanks a lot in advance!!!
elbin_24

oh, already solved!
After the thousandth relaunch of the hard drive it is working now and it is shown on my desktop as it should be!!!
I'm sorry for causing this trouble here in the forum! Excuse me, please!!!!
elbin_24

External Hard Drive 3TB - iOmega, Western Digital... ?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for