Failure to Roam.  MacPro stays on same AP

I was doing some testing on another discussion question when I found that my MacBook Pro running 10.9.5 will remain attached to the same AP (access point) no matter how strong the signal or how it changes.
The information below was gathered while moving from the house to the barn (about 125ft) and back again.
The house has an Airport Extreme 802.11ac (tower) and the barn has an Airport Express 802.11n 1st generation
The network is configured for Roaming, meaning both APs are connected via ethernet cable to a switch and both have the same configuration including "Create a wireless network"
I used Wi-Fi Explorer to monitor the signal strength.  On the way to the barn I was on the 5GHz wireless.  The barn is configured only for b/g/n compatibility so uses the 2.4GHz wireless.  Once at the barn, I had to turn off the wireless on the MacPro and turn it back on again to connect to the Barn AP.
On the way back to the house, the MacBook remained on the Barn AP even though the House AP had a much stronger 2.4GHz signal.  I had to toggle the Mac's wireless again to get it to switch APs.
It is my understanding that when roaming it is not suppose to work this way.  Rather, the Mac should have determined that it had a better signal available and switched itself.  Is this an OS question or is it particular to my MacPro?
NOTE: I have also installed Wi-Fi Notifier will sometimes pop up and tell me that my data rate has changed even though I have not moved.
-------------- Everything below was previously posted on a different discussion but it shows the steps outlined above and shows the Mac fails to switch.
Using Airport Utility 6.3.2 I get the following options for my Airport Express 1st Generation.  There is a similar option for Airport Utility 5.6.1 under the "Radio Mode" pull-down.  Using Wi-Fi Explorer ($3 on the App Store) I see that only a 2.4GHz signal is available even when standing directly next to it (vs both a 2.4 GHz and 5GHz signal from my Airport Extreme 802.11ac)
Point being that the Airport Express(n) does not appear to provide both 2.4 and 5 at the same time.
This Airport Express (n) is configured for a "roaming" network, meaning it is connected via ethernet back to the cable modem which also has the Airport Extreme (ac) connected via ethernet.
As an aside, and since I walked all the way over to the barn to check this out, my MacPro appears to still be using the Airport Extreme for its connection even though Wi-Fi Explorer shows a much weaker signal.  I am in the barn now.  The Airport Express is the top line in the graph which when at the house, disappears on occasion although it is always accessible via Airport Utility.  (The Airport Express(n) is the third in the list)
I am using Airport Utility 6.3 which shows that the Airport Extreme (ac) is the AP my Mac is running through.
My MacPro is the third Mac Address in this list 70:56:...
Interesting too, now that I am in the Barn, both Airport Utility applications do NOT have access to the Airport Express (n) even though Wi-Fi Explorer continues to show a strong signal from that system.  (BTW, I also have 4 bars of wireless in the menu bar)  (FWIW: I also quit and restarted Airport Utility)  Based on further information below, it appears that my MacPro is NOT switching to a 2.4GHz network.
As an experiment, I turned off my wireless on the MacBook and turned it back on again.  Airport Utility now shows me connected to the Airport Express(n) in the barn.
Here is Wi-Fi Explorer as I return to the house (approximately 125ft)  Note the colors have been reallocated and don't match the previous screenshots.  The list has also changed.
At this point, my menubar on the MacPro usually shows 2 bars but often rises to 4.  However, it is clear my MacPro is still connected to the Airport Express in the barn because response is horrid and Airport Utility still shows that AP is servicing my MacPro.  (I cannot show that screen shot since it is a popup that disappears when I move the cursor.)
To switch back to the Airport Extreme (ac), I have to shut the wireless on my Mac off and turn it back on again.
I assume that I am connected to the 5GHz subnet since Airport Utility shows my data rate is 450Mps.
Something I had noticed until now, it also shows that my PHY is 802.11a/n.
This brings up several questions, which I should post somewhere else since my only purpose here was to suggest that an Airport Express (n) does NOT broadcast in both wireless ranges at the same time.

my only purpose here was to suggest that an Airport Express (n) does NOT broadcast in both wireless ranges at the same time.
That being the case, we have already answered your other post, which included the same statement.....by noting  that whether or not the Express will broadcast on both the 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz bands simultaneously depends entirely on which particular version of the Express that you are talking about. You never tell us.
The A1392 will. The A1264 won't.

Similar Messages

  • My friend sold me his iPod touch 3 gen 32gb but the problem is it's disabled an it ses to connect to iTunes an when I do connect it ses first I have to enter the password on the iPod but I can't cuz the screen stays the same what should I do

    My friend sold me his iPod touch 3 gen 32gb but the problem is it's disabled an it ses to connect to iTunes an when I do connect it ses first I have to enter the password on the iPod but I can't cuz the screen stays the same what should I do

    connect it in recovery mode, then set it up as a new device.

  • A friend bought second hand macbook air mid 2011 with crossed circle on the display, we tried recovery from partition and same thing happened, after internet recovery it stays the same except now it asks for password for boot option, what happened?

    A friend bought second hand macbook air mid 2011 with crossed circle on the display and give to me to try to recover the system, I tried recovery from partition and same thing occured, after internet recovery it stays the same-crossed circle after reboot, then we tried to boot from USB with mac os 10.8 on it, it installs something,like it has being finishing installation, rebootes, and now it asks for password for boot option.We have no idea what that password could be.What happened!!!

    I forgot to write down my computer specs:
    iMac 27 Mid 2011
    2.7 GHz Intel Core i5
    4 GB 1333 MHz DDR3
    AMD Radeon HD 6770M 512 MB
    OS X 10.9.2

  • How do I set a fixed page size in Muse so that the window always stays the same size

    how do I set a fixed page size in Muse so that the window always stays the same size

    Hi Aish & thanks for responding;
    I would like the window size to stay the same for the entire site and not be
    able to scale to drag & scale it. ie 950 pixels x 500 pixels.
    Thanks,
    JB
    On 12/4/14 3:30 PM, "Aishvarya Raj Rastogi" <[email protected]>

  • What I'm trying to do is when I scroll down the page have the images that are on the page stay the same look as I scroll

    What I'm trying to do is when I scroll down the page have the images that are on the page stay the same look as I scroll

    Use the scroll motion tools and set the settings all to 0

  • Why cant apple track my stolen iphone if it connects to the internet after reset. the IMEI number stays the same so i dont understand why they just dont shut it off and call me and the police to inform me about the whereabouts of the phone

    Hi, my iphone was stolen around a month ago. After the phone popped up on find my iphone in central london the police decided to be really helpful and instead going to get it they closed my case. Since then it has been offline because the "lovely" individual who stole it obviously reset it. I was just wondering why doesnt apple track phones through the IMEI number. The number stays the same, so if the phone connects to the network they should be able to know that its my stolen iphone. I just dont understand why they dont do that. They have a huge ecosystem, and if someone signs in to my iphone with their itunes account (which they pretty much have to in order to use most of the phones features) the IMEI number gets associated with that perticular account. Would it not be possible for them to realize that its my stolen phone?
    Thanks to anyone that answers.

    Your carrier can lock the IMEI number, try contacting them. At least you'll have the satifsaction of knowing the theif can't use it anymore. My guess is Apple doesn't block IMEI numbers because they don't want someone selling a phone without record, and then reporting it stolen and causing problems that way. But that's just a guess, I feel for ya. Good luck either way, if it's a locked phone you should be able to call the carrier it's locked to and have the IMEI blocked.

  • My persona stays the same no matter what I try to do...

    I have been trying to change my persona to a Halloween persona. I do the appropriate things and press the "wear it" button but the persona stays the same and does not change. Am I doing something wrong??

    Hi,
    If a horizontal notification bar appears below the location (address) bar or tab bar you can try to '''Allow''' it.
    [https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/use-themes-change-look-of-firefox Customizing]
    If the problem persists, you can also Reset Firefox and start afresh.
    The Reset Firefox feature can fix many issues by restoring Firefox to its factory default state while saving your essential information.
    Note: ''This will cause you to lose any Extensions, Open websites, and some Preferences.''
    To Reset Firefox do the following:
    #Go to Firefox > Help > Troubleshooting Information.
    #Click the "Reset Firefox" button.
    #Firefox will close and reset. After Firefox is done, it will show a window with the information that is imported. Click Finish.
    #Firefox will open with all factory defaults applied.
    Further information can be found in the [[Reset Firefox – easily fix most problems]] article.
    Did this fix your problems? Please report back to us!

  • Top 25 Played Playlist updates on computer, but stays the same on iPhone

    Hey guys,
    I'm hoping someone else can help me. My iTunes Top 25 playlist updates just fine on my iMac, but not on any of my iPhones/iPods.
    It has stayed the same constantly for about a year now, and I'm wondering if it's a file in the iTunes library that is messing it up? (Maybe something in the actual iTunes folder in Finder)
    Thanks for any help/pointing in the correct area!

    Um, bump.

  • Each time I reopen a folder the files get rearranged alphabetically, how do I stop this so the file arrangement in the folder stays the same?

    Each time I reopen a folder in OS X 10.8.4 the files get rearranged alphabetically, how do I stop this so the file arrangement in the folder stays the same?

    I might add that all the files are aliases. There are 40 altogether and I am aware I could create 10 sub-folders so I only have 4 aliases in each subfolder which would mean I only have to rearrange 4 aliases each time but this is still not ideal. I have been using Macs since the 1980's and up to now files have always stayed where you put them unless you selected Arrange By in the Finder View Menu.

  • I have the new OS X Mavericks operating system, and when I invoke IMaps, the location given is not correct. I have attempted to correct it, but it stays the same. Whazzup with that?

    I have the new OS X Mavericks operating system, and when I invoke IMaps, the location given is not correct. I have attempted to correct it, but it stays the same. Whazzup with that?

    In addition to answering innocentius' question:
    You say that nothing happens, yet you are able to export to youtube. Please describe in detail what you are trying.
    What destinations do you see? How exactly are you trying to export?
    Also: Cmd-E will only work if you set a default destination.

  • When I Crop a video it doesn't fill the frame back up, it just outlines it in black and stays the same size

    When I Crop a video it doesn't fill the frame back up, it just outlines it in black and stays the same size

    No, I am using the crop function, and the directions say after I press done it will fill the frame, which worked a year ago. Now when using th Crop function, the black area stays black and the cropped video stays the same size. I even shared it to a Master file to see if it would process during sharing, but the black area remained black and the cropped video remained the same size. Still a bit frustrated.

  • Color and style settings won't stay the same.....

    I'm trying to get my type to stay the same color and style each time I start a new email to send to someone. I can set it each time I start a new message, but I want it to stay the same automatically when I open it up. Is that possible to do in mail?
    1.6 GHz PowerPC G5   Mac OS X (10.3.9)  

    Hi,
    I have had this problem.
    It seems that iChat is more sensitive to small breaks in the network link. Web Browsers and Mail just don't show them as they make new connections each time they download mail or change pages.
    If wireless try it wired for elimination purposes.
    Check the time any DHCP server renews the leases.
    8:49 PM Monday; February 26, 2007

  • Itunes claims it's downloading, but my balance stays the same and the song never shows up under 'purchased' Help, please!

    I have a balance of $29, and just yesterday redeemed a giftcard, so itunes appears to be working correctly, however whenever I attempt to purchase a song it still has me enter my apple ID and password, and the 'mini-player' states that it is 'purchasing' for about half a second, yet it has not purchased.....the song does not appear in my library, and my balance stays the same. I have just had my harddrive updated, so there should be no problems there, and everything else on itunes seems to be running normally. Any idea what could be going on? There are no error messages at all, it's just not purchasing anyhthing. VERY fustrating!

    Thanks for the info as well, also not looking for that answer...
    Friend has purchased several books on her iPhone and now has been lost when iOS was upgraded, this was done as phone was not functioning correctly (apps failing)...
    After successfully upgraded software, all audio books where removed.... Unable to go back to a early backup, as only appears to be backups valid from after upgarde of iOS...
    So now we are in situation of trying to get apple to allow us to reload them, which after paying for them (assume £100's worth)... Do you think friend will be very happy to find she has to fork another £100 to repurchase goods, because a BUG in your upgrade software?
    Yes you may say, its her fault for not backing up!  But I find it a little suprising you show little support for these people, most people know very little of computers and buy Mac products because we believe that they just work!!!
    I like other customer will seriously think very hard before my next Apple purchase, which has upto know included..  2 Mac Book Pros, 2 iPods , 2 IPhones, 1 Apple TV, 1 iPad.. (Currently have Mac Book Pro, iPad, and iPhone)...
    We are sold onto this idea that iCloud on the adds on TV, yet no where do I see in these adverts that doesn't work with Audiobooks? What else does it not work for? If I buy something on iTunes I EXPECT it to be backed up on your servers on iCloud, thats WHY I buy your kit as it is MEANT to work, not oh sorry its your fault go lump it! We pay a premium to use iTunes, we all might as well buy off Amazon and get it shipped to the door cheaper then iTunes?

  • Sims 3 quit unexpectantly but stayed the same resolution!

    My Sims 3 quit unexpectantly and my screen stayed the same resolution. There are black bars on the side of my screen from the resolution that I was playing in the Sims. I have tried restarting the computer and going into Sims to change the resolution to the highest settings (that match up with the resolution of my computer). The Sims 3 now works with my whole computer screen but my desktop is still obscured! Please help!

    Try the following,
    TIFFEncodeParam tep = new TIFFEncodeParam();
    // Create {X,Y}Resolution fields.
    TIFFField fieldXRes = new TIFFField(0x11A, TIFFField.TIFF_RATIONAL,
                                        1, new long[][] {{DPI_X, 1}});
    TIFFField fieldYRes = new TIFFField(0x11B, TIFFField.TIFF_RATIONAL,
                                        1, new long[][] {{DPI_Y, 1}});
    tep.setExtraFields(new TIFFField[] {fieldXRes, fieldYRes});

  • Have money in my account but when I purchase songs it still charged me for it and the balance stays the same...

    I have money in my account but when I purchase songs it still charges me for it and the balance stays the same...

    Login to your account and set payment method to none.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Bootcamp problem please help

    Hi, I've been having this problem for weeks now. I was able to intall windows 7 using bootcamp, which I did numerous times with my previous macs. Today, I wiped my harddrive, and fresh installed OSX and windows 7 everything went perfect up to the poi

  • How can i calcilate cost depreciation for assets

    Hi. can anybody tell me how can i calculate cost depreciation for an asset. i have used one function module DEPR_RECALCULATE. but it will allow only one date and it will calculate depreciation for total year . i want to pass the two date . how can i

  • Using a range to input numbers to a table

    Hi i have written this bit of code to allow numbers to be written to the table. I use "b" as the limit the numbers go to but when i want to use "a" as the start point it returns the error loss of precision. E.g. i enter a = 3 and b = 8 and in the tab

  • Why my macbook pro 15" retina late 2013 shows weird display spec in the system report.

    Hi, my  macbook pro 15" retina late 2013 displays screen resolution as 3360*2100 in the system report. As we all know that the 15" model of late 2013 macbook pro has the maxmium resolution as 2880*1800. So is there anyone has a clue?

  • Captivate 5.5 customize Certificate Widget on flash

    hello all, I have a little problem with the certificate Widget, when I try to personalize it with logo and company colors, I do all this in flash and insert it into captivate 5.5 but when I put it to work it does not add the name of the course and st