Faster scanning via Thunderbolt

I am a relative tech novice, and I have a question regarding Tunderbolt.
I have been looking forward to a consumer technology that will permit me to quickly scan my family's tens of thousands of photographs and negatives. Current scanners are relatively slow and not suitable for such large scale projects. I'm not sure if where the bottleneck is (USB port?). I know that there are professional services out there, but a job like this would cost way too much.
Here's my question: is Thunderbolt the technology that I've been waiting for? Will it allow my to scan photographs and negatives at a more reasonable rate? Will scanner companies incorporate Thunderbolt into their scanners? If so, when do you think that would happen?
Thanks for your help.

In my experience, the bottleneck is not USB. Fujitsu and Panasonic sell a bunch of business class page scanners that are quite speedy, especially compared to scanning a sheet of paper on a flatbed. And despite being USB based, can do 20+ pages per minute (compared to 2 minutes per page on some slower flatbed scanners.) However the speed comes at a price. These scanners start at $500 and go in to the multiple thousands of dollars for the even higher speed scanners (and that may or may not include color!)
What many people want when scanning personal photos/slides/negatives is high quality and resolution. Scanning at a higher resolution will be slower, obviously. But what I find takes a lot of time is "tweaking" the scan. (The "quality" part.) Things like adjusting the alignment of the print on the scanner, cleaning off dust from the slide, and adjusting the color balance for the various brands and models of negatives is where most of my time is spent. While you can use Photoshop to adjust things like color after the fact, cleaning up dust and aligning the print prior to scanning pay off way more than trying to correct that later in post production. These are just some of the reasons why scanning services cost so much. (Imagine the scanned images put into iPhoto, then used as your screensaver or wallpaper, and you have to look at dusty scans everyday....and you paid to have someone do that!)
I never bothered to count the amount of negatives & slides I'm scanning, (I was afraid to know, else I wouldn't start, ) but it is a few hundred negatives and a total of several hundred if you include all the prints and negatives. I'm currently using an older Nikon slide & negative scanner, which has USB2 and Firewire. But for a $400 "pro" scanner, it's still slow despite me using Firewire. At the max resolution of 2400dpi, it takes over a minute per slide. That's one minute for the scan head to move a couple of inches, not Windows "hourglassing" because of USB. So Thunderbolt for this scanner would not help.
Eventually, there may be scanners with Thunderbolt, likely to replace the SCSI based scanners. But that would just be a connectivity option or convenience, rather than to improve performance. (i.e.: "everyone has a Thunderbolt port in 5 years, just like "everyone" has a USB2 port nowdays.) But IMHO, if you want faster scanning, your needs will have to go beyond "consumer" grade scanners.

Similar Messages

  • Does FCP 7 support capture via thunderbolt?

    I am looking for a multi format converter, and wondering if FCP 7 supports capture via Thunderbolt? and if not can I get around it with a Thunderbolt to FW 800 cable?

    the real issue is getting it there faster
    you cant capture faster than real time with live video!
    Blackmagic Design Video Capture with Thunderbolt

  • TWAIN scanning via AIR?

    I know that this question was asked before, but it's been over a year...so I just wanted an update.  Can AIR access TWAIN scanning devices?
    thanks,
    Bryan

    Thanks for the fast response! Deleting library/containers/com.apple.preview and the scan with preview worked!
    Thanks also to ShlomiL, repair permissions found some errors, but there was still no scan via preview possible.
    Scanning via "Digital Pictures" or "Image capture" worked all the time, but I was used to take "Preview" for scanning. "Digital Pictures has nearly the same frame, but offers a folder selector (see also the threat of Linc Davis).
    Remains the question what the german manual will tell us with (via help: scan a picture - use a flat bed scanner - extended options: "select with Einblendmenü (fade-in menu?) the location for the scanned pictures. If you use a folder, all pictures will be stored in this folder, if you use an app, pictures will be opened by this app." ???
    Would be interesting if this would work!
    Anyway - thanks for the help

  • Is it possible to add external graphics cards via thunderbolt on a 2011 MBPro?

    I have a 2011 Macbook Pro, quad core, RAM maxed at 16gb, 250 SSD, and SSHD to replace optical drive, but wanted to know if there was a way to add an external graphics card via Thunderbolt for more screens and faster work in VIDEO editing on-the-go?!?!
    Is this possible? can anyone give me any advice that would help me.
    I DO have a 2006 Mac Pro that I've also maxed out and it's STILL a BEAST and i love using it... but wanted to see how i could increase my macbook pro too, seeing it can run mavericks and ALL my adobe CC apps too.
    Thanks so much for ANY suggestions!!

    Click on the links in the "More Like This' box:
    Ciao.

  • Malicious or not? Message popped up: Mozilla security found (something like too much, forget exact word) activity on your computer so it will do a fast scan of system file. With OK button.

    I was looking at youtube.com, which always tells me my browser is not supported and recommends I download Firefox, but that is what I was using, so I went to Firefox to check for updates. (I think I also had freecycle.org open.) Then this message popped up in a new page: Mozilla security found (something like "too much", forget exact word) activity on your computer so it will do a fast scan of system file. There was an OK button. The page address was: http://update17.stegner.ce.ms/index.php?Q7Lhl9ShbRxGJXpkM1VLSi4ZE8H4pTedoVPySgeppM3VpC+thEspcFG7qxHgn1pdsC2h5ygPGWI3t5hXqMzL9EQaZZ3J1e3CKXgCb0Qp. I did not click OK but copied the link and closed the window which closed the internet. I have never seen this before and would like to know if it is really Mozilla or possibly something malicious. Thank you.

    Good catch. That almost certainly is an invitation to download malware.
    There are a lot of infected web sites pushing "fake antivirus" software. If you have any doubts about whether your system might have become infected, you can supplement your regular security software with these two highly regarded scanners:
    Malwarebytes Anti-malware : http://www.malwarebytes.org/mbam.php
    SUPERAntiSpyware : http://www.superantispyware.com/

  • I cannot get my iMac to connect to my macbook via Thunderbolt to use my laptop as an extended desktop

    I am trying to connect my iMac 21.5" desktop to my macbook pro via Thunderbolt cable so that I can use my laptop as an extended desktop. I have tried using detect displays to get it to show up and nothing happens. I've tried doing command + F2 to make it a targeted display, but the only thing I can get to happen is my iMac will mirror my Macbook and that's not what I want. No matter what I have tried it hasn't worked. I have tried turning both computers off and I have a brand new thunderbolt cable. I've updated all the software. Is there anything else I'm missing??
    I'm running OSX Yosemite 10.10.1
    Thank you !

    We've already done all of that. And we used the same thunderbolt cable to connect two iMac's and that worked totally fine doing the Command+ F2. I don't understand why we can't get the macbook to do the same.

  • Is it possible to connect a mac book pro via thunderbolt and a dvi switchbox (multiple computers) to a thunderbolt display?

    Hi,
    I'm planning to buy a thunderbolt display.Since I have not only apple computers with a thunderbolt port I wonder if it's possible to connect my mac book pro via thunderbolt and a DVI switchbox via a "mini displayport to DVI connector" to the thunderbolt display at the same time. Thunderbolt is a bus architecture. Thus there must be an ingoing and an outgoing port on the display. The rearview of the display I've seen so far don't show this:
    If this is not possible then I must question the market chances of this product. Seems as if the product marketing guys exaggerated the launch of the thunderbolt technology.
    -ais-swiss

    ais-swiss wrote:
    How to connect windows laptop (vga) to thunderbolt display?
    AHHH??!!!!!!  Was that your original question??   I assumed you were trying to output FROM your computer (MacBook Pro w/ Thunderbolt) to the new display and then OUT to be the video source to a DVI switcher.
    MB Pro w/TB ---> TB Display ---> mDP-to-DVI adapter ---> DVI switcher
    So it seems as if it's not possible to use the thunderbolt display with the mini display port adapter to DVI you've mentioned.
    I did not understand that you were trying to use other PC's into a switcher and then THAT Video source to connect INTO the TB display.   If THAT is what you're trying to do, then NO....  You can NOT use the new TB Display to be used to display "FROM" a DVI switcher (and also can NOT be used to display from other Non-TB-Apple computers).
    I've also called apple. The statement was that one needs a computer with osx 10.6.x in order to connect the thunderbolt display. That makes it impossible to hook a windows pc or older mac to the new and shiny thunderbolt display.
    I wonder why apple doesn't state this in their technical descriptions...?
    -ais-swiss
    Actually, the state that information all over the Tech Specs on the Apple Store website.
    http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC914LL/A?mco=MTY3ODQ5OTY
    Here are two different statements from that webpage:
    So yes.... other NON-Apple PC's (or non-TB devices) do Not have the Thunderbolt technology (hardware/software) to be able to communicate with the TB display or other TB devices.

  • MacBook Pro does not sense external monitor (Panasonic HDTV in my case) via thunderbolt-HDMI connection...Is update 10.8.3 helping anyone?

    My MacBook Pro (newest model in 2013 so far) does not sense external monitor (Panasonic HDTV in my case) via thunderbolt-HDMI connection...Is update 10.8.3 helping anyone else who has this issue? I returned my multiple HDMI adapters after figuring out it had to be an Apple issue n not the adapters so I can't check it myself now.
    Thanks!

    I have late 2012 MBP 13" and connect to my Panasonic Plasma correctly.
    But using the same cable, can't connect to an LG 47LM6200, the MBP detects the TV, the screen blinks blue, but the TV shows "no sinal detected" message.

  • Have most recent macbook pro connected to thunderbolt via thunderbolt cable.  Occasionally when I close my laptop the thunderbolt display goes black and does not come back on---even in response to keyboard.  Help

    Have most recent macbook pro connected to thunderbolt via thunderbolt cable.  Occasionally when I close my laptop the thunderbolt display goes black and does not come back on---even in response to keyboard.  Help

    Hello QuinnDev,
    Thank you for posting in the Apple Support Communities.  It sounds like you are trying to use your MacBook Pro with a Thunderbolt Display in closed clamshell mode (MacBook Pro closed), but sometimes the display doesn't stay on.  I found an article that talks about closed clamshell mode.  You would have to fulfill the following requirements to use your display this way:
    Requirements for closed display mode:
    Power adapter
    External keyboard, mouse, or trackpad
    External display
    You can find all the steps and the full article here:
    Mac notebooks: How to use your computer in closed clamshell (display closed) mode with an external display
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3131
    I hope this helps!
    All the best,
    Sheila M.

  • Connect Mac Mini 2011 to iMac 2011 via Thunderbolt

    Is it possible to connect the new Mac mini 2011 to the new iMac 2011 via Thunderbolt to use the Display Target Mode of the iMac ?

    See Target Display Mode And Thunderbolt.

  • HT5219 can i connect my dv camera to my new imac via thunderbolt firewire adaptor

    can i connect my dv camera to my new imac via thunderbolt firewire adaptor

    If FW is the only connection the camera has then yes Thunderbolt Firewire adapter is correct. It's available from a number of sources including Apples own online store, in the USA the link would be:
    http://store.apple.com/us/product/MD464ZM/A/apple-thunderbolt-to-firewire-adapte r

  • Using '09 iMac as Target Display via Thunderbolt Cable Fail

    I have a peculiar situation that I hoping someone can decipher with certainty:
    I have a late 2009 iMac core i7, 27" running 10.9.1
    I just received a Mac Pro - my plan was to use the iMac as a display for the Mac Pro at least for a while. I purchased a thunderbolt cable. I have connected the mac pro via thunderbolt cable to the mini display port on the iMac.
    Unfortunately I simply cannot get CMD-F2 to work, or FN-CMD-F2 on the iMac. I have tried PRAM resets etc. The system does nothing when I hit those keys. I verified the mac pro is working via HDMI.
    I am now wondering if I have the right cable. I understood thunderbolt and mini display port to be interchangeable and backward compatible so that my situation would work.
    What am I missing? Thanks much, really would like to get this mac pro on screen without buying a new monitor!

    I found that MDP iMac MUST use a MDP cable. Which of course is not as easy to come by as the thunderbolt which I picked up. Really annoying.
    http://blog.macsales.com/10899-target-display-mode-and-thunderbolt

  • Second display via Thunderbolt "flashes" after EFI 1.7

    I have a second display (Samsung SyncMaster 245BW) connected to my 27" iMac via Thunderbolt and a miniDisplay -> DVI connector.  I just recently got the 1.7 EFI software update and noticed that the second display will flash every 2 - 3 minutes.  Anyone else seeing this?  Should I revert back to the previous EFI?

    KVM switches are either compatible with Macs or they are problematic at best.
    I had a KVM here that when I switched to another screen/keyboard, the screen would stay black, until I disconnected and reconnected the Mac video cable. It was a PITA. Threw it in the trash eventually.
    I now have a mini and a nettop Linux box, both connected to the same monitor with DVI and VGA respectively. The screens are switched with a button on the monitor. If I need a keyboard on the Linux box, I attach one, otherwise I ssh into it and use the Apple keyboard. There is a separate wireless USB mouse on the Linux box, as needed.

  • Connecting 2013 Macbook Retina 15" to Acer B286 HK monitor via Thunderbolt.

    I have a 2013 Macbook Retina 15" and would like to connect an Acer B286 HK monitor via Thunderbolt/MiniDisplayPort.
    I am using the standard Apple Thunderbolt cable, but it does not work. The monitor complains about "No signal".

    Short answer: I have this exact configuration, and yes, the newest rMBP 15" w/Nvidia card will drive the UP3214Q over HDMI at 4k and 30Hz. It will drive it as a separate desktop with the laptop open, and it will drive it as the sole display -- either way works fine.
    Longer answer: You should be aware of 2 things (that I wish I had been more aware of before purchasing the monitor)
    1) If you are used to 60Hz or higher, the 30Hz limitation over HDMI is noticable, even in day-to-day productivity work. The mouse lag is very noticable and annoying to me.
    2) Scaling/HiDPI support [the way the integrated retina display works] is virtually nonexistant at the resolution you'd want to run it at. What this means is that you either run the monitor at a lower resolution (and everything is blurry), or you run it at full resolution and everything (menu, dock, fonts, etc) is extremely small. You can use SwitchResX to enable scaling support at odd resolutions (for instance, I've successfully gotten HiDPI/scaling to run at 1920x1200 and 2048x1080, with black bars at the edges), but it's not an ideal resolution for this size monitor. I want to match the TB display resolution (2560x1440) in HiDPI mode, but I've been unable to get it working after hacking away at it for 2 days.
    I'm hoping that Apple will fix these limitations. Multiple people have reported that MST over DP1.2 works on the same hardware if you boot into Windows, so the hardware support is there -- it just needs to be enabled in the drivers by Apple. Whether they actually will or not is anyone's guess. In the meantime I (and many others) are in limbo wondering if we should return these 4k displays, or keep them and hope "proper" support comes. Since it's not a specifically advertised capability, Apple isn't under any obligation, but I think there's more than a few people hoping that Apple does right by the users and enables the full functionality that the hardware supports.

  • HT5299 can i connect my sony smart TV via thunderbolt port for better resolution.

    can i connect my sony smart TV via thunderbolt port for better resolution.

    You can connect the TV via the Thunderbolt port. However if the result is "better resolution" would depend on what resolution you have now (I'm guessing you mean with the HDMI adapter?)
    I'm myself connecting the Mini Mac with a Thunderbolt->VGA adapter to my TV and get full 1920x1080 resolution.
    Have you checked your Display settings? Make sure mirroring is off, then check what resolutions you can get on the current connection.
    Please return with some more data.

Maybe you are looking for