FCP-X Compressor 3.0.5 (need chapter-markers)

Can I send a FCP-X-project to Compressor 3.0.5?
I just need to set DVD-chapter-markers in there!
Or do you have another idea how to set individual chapter-markers??

This is more evidence that Apple really is not catering to a professional audience. Their agenda for a while has been digital-only content. They focus on getting finished products to ipods, ipads, and apple TVs.
Even consumers have complained about iDVD being ignored over the years in terms of feature set. I bet the next iLife will be the one to not include it.

Similar Messages

FCP 6 doesn't seem to export chapter markers in a QT movie

Hi,
New user of Mac and FCP 6 here. I've constructed my sequence in FCP 6, adding the appropriate chapter marks (which show up fine in FCP 6). I then Export my sequence to a self-contained QT movie, making sure that in the Save dialog "Marker" is set to "All Markers". If I now render the QT movie and bring it into either Compressor or DVD Studio Pro; the chapter markers are now gone.
After trying for several hours in FCP 6 to export different ways, I never could get Compressor or DVD Studio Pro to find the markers. I eventually gave up and manually reentered them into Compressor. When Compressor was complete, I brought its m2v and ac3 files into DVD Studio Pro. Lo and behold the chapter markers were still there.
Being a novice to FCP 6, do I have a setting somewhere that is preventing me from exporting markers? Or could this be a bug due to my workflow.
Thanks for any advice.
Mike

I've been wondering about this for the last couple of days. Lately my QT exports of my FCP sequences have not been retaining their chapter markers. They are fine for DVDSP, but not for Quicktime DV or even mp4 or m4v files that would normally contain them previously. What's going on here?
Sending friends and family my videos, I want to give them the option of selecting from the list of chapters in the video. I feel like I've wasted time putting the chapters in when they don't show up for the folks who play them.

Need Chapter Markers from Quicktime.

Im trying to figure out how I can see the same chapters markers in Compressor I can see in Quicktime. I have an m4v video whihc when played in quicktime shows me chapter markers. those markers do not come up in compressor. can I import a chapter list?

Re-export the video, selecting DVD Studio Pro Markers, rather than Chapters Markers.
This is an issue new to FCP Studio 3.
Also, don't export using Quicktime Conversion to .m4v.
Export to Quicktime Movie, Self-contained and create the .m4v in Compressor. The Apple TV preset is very good.

How do I export from Compressor 4 to iDVD with chapter markers?

I get that Final Cut Pro X does not create chapter markers.
I send it to Compressor 4 to do this.
Ok, so far, so good.
How do I export this so that I can then author the DVD to include a menu page, etc?
Do I do this in iDVD? If so, what format, as I see that iDVD does not import MPEG-2.

Don't use the DVD preset in Compressor. Use an MPEG4 format or maybe even AppleTV preset.
This Apple Support Article might help a little.

Compressor H.264 not exporting Chapter Markers

I am still struggling to see chapter markers show up in DVD Studio Pro using compressor & H.264. Compressor outputs the Chapters markers when using MPEG2. My understanding is that this should be automatic.
IMac Mac OS X (10.4.7)
IMac Mac OS X (10.4.7)

BKENT:
The following information appears in DVDSP 4.1 Late Breaking News file:
Exporting H.264 Clips With Markers From Final Cut Pro
Compressor does not export chapter markers when using its H.264 for HD DVD presets. You can either create a chapter marker text file that you can import or manually add the chapter markers in DVD Studio Pro directly..
http://manuals.info.apple.com/en/DVDStudio_Pro_4.1_lbnz.pdf#search=%22h.264%20chapter%20markers%22

Export to AppleTV via Compressor, Chapter Markers Wrong

I'm exporting various projects out to AppleTV via Compressor with Chapter Markers. Works great except for the Chapter Markers, which are out of sync...significantly, by 30 seconds or so. Any ideas on what the problem might be or how to ensure Chapter Markers will transfer over to the AppleTV setting in compressor?

Matt Martin1 wrote:
I'm exporting various projects out to AppleTV via Compressor with Chapter Markers. Works great except for the Chapter Markers, which are out of sync...significantly, by 30 seconds or so. Any ideas on what the problem might be or how to ensure Chapter Markers will transfer over to the AppleTV setting in compressor?
So this is a Compressor-specific issue, right?
What I mean to say is, if you're exporting QT movies out of FCP, those do not exhibit the shift in chapter markers, correct? Just trying to determine if FCP/QT is the culprit here.
Or are you exporting directly to Compressor? Or adding the chapter markers directly in Compressor?

Chapter markers not appearing in DVDSP

I have a movie in FCP (NTSC, 4:3 SP) with several chapter markers. I exported the movie from FCP as Quicktime with "All Markers" selected. I viewed the file with QT, and the markers showed up. I compressed the movie using compressor. I imported the compressed movie into DVDSP, and the markers didn't show up.
I looked at the various related messages here, and the suggestion to use the uncompressed file to establish the markers sounded good. I imported the uncompressed file, oops, no chapter markers.
I checked my software revisions, and updated Quicktime to 7.1.1. per the Apple site. I re-created the Quicktime file using FCP and imported it, uncompressed, again into DVDSP -- no markers.
I exited everything. I started FCP, created a brand-new project, imported a small clip, set 3 markers, 1 chapter, 1 chapter+compression, 1 chaptercompressionscore. I exported the file as QT with "all Markers" selected. I viewed the file with QT, and the markers are there. I put this QT file into a new project in DVDSP -- no markers showed up at all.
We can ignore Compressor for the time being, as DVDSP doesn't see the markers even if Compressor is not used. The culprit seems to be DVDSP. Is there some DVDSP setting that needs to be set to get it to recognize markers? I've had it work ok in the past, I don't know what's changed.
thanks for any help!!!
G4 dual 1GHz Mac OS X (10.4.6) FC Studio 5.1, latest updates for everything.

I looked at the various related messages here, and the suggestion to use the uncompressed file to establish the markers sounded good.
I don't know why people post that advice. It's flat out wrong. Sorry you got bad directions.
Anyways, If you're exporting out to DVD and your QuickTime Movie will be compressed via Compressor or DVDSP's internal encoder, do not export using All Markers because that embeds the marker data in a way that DVDSP and Compressor cannot properly parse. If you're going to send to Compressor or DVDSP's internal encoder, select DVD Studio Pro Markers during export from FCP.
Selecting DVDSP Markers exports Chapter, Compression and Cut markers. Cut markers are created by FCP whenever you make a cut in the timeline. With cut markers present, every time your start a new clip - or you simply use the Add Edit command (Control-V) - it's the same as adding a compression marker, in that it greatly improve encoding forcing an I-frame in the GOP.
And, for what it's worth, there is no need to flag a marker as both a chapter and a compression marker - chapter markers are automatically compression markers. They force an I-frame in the GOP structure, just like a compression marker

Chapter markers again

the way i see it: apple cut old ropes with fcpx, and the features the crowd demands the most are re-integrated. like xml and multicam, as we saw recently.
now, apple, hear me: I NEED CHAPTER MARKERS, as i told you in feedback to fcpx already.
i can't sell a music-video to customers without chapters for each song.
i bought compressor 4.0.2, as in the apple store it sais, a new feature is that markers are now chapter markers as default. yes, exported markers from compressor, but not the imported from fcpx. money for nothing.
i tried every suggested workflow, no one works perfect. neither in garage band nor in compressor it is as easy to set markers with frame accurancy as it is in final cut. exporting xml and importing in qt or compressor did not work fine, also.
i really began to like fcpx, as it has some cool new features, but all are worthless for me as long as i can't set chapter markers. i have to use final cut studio again and hope that the next update will bring chapter markers back again.

Why can't you set the chapter markers in Compressor?
Did you see this
http://www.digitalrebellion.com/blog/posts/how_to_export_chapter_markers_from_fi nal_cut_pro_x.html
P.S. You know you can import chapter markers to Compressor from a tabbed text file list that has timecode numbers?
Message was edited by: Tom Wolsky

Forgot chapter markers...out of luck?

So i just sent my sequence through compressor and forgot to add chapter markers. I want to import the m2v into dvd studio pro and have dvdsp automatically make a chapters sub menu, but it can't do that if this file doesnt have markers. is there anyway i can add them now before importing? thanks!

Here's the possible problem. markers can only be on Iframes and audio wouldn't have Iframes. I seem to remember that there was some sort of xml utility that would extract the marker locations and bring them into dvdsp, but again, there might be a problem with markers being on illegal frames.

Export fcp 5 to compressor, bye-bye chapter markers

If I'm reading the manuals and the pro training books right, the only way to export chapter markers from FCP 5 is to a QT movie. That kinda stinks a little.
Would a workaround be to export to QT and then run compressor as stand-alone? Seems like an extra step, more time and a possiblity of introducing artifacts from all of the handling.
I also tried to export markers as text file. DVD SP can import a chapter marker text file.
My original plan was to create the chapter markers in Compressor so I would get exact i-frame placement, but what a royal pain! At least in FCP you can bang through them with keyboard shortcuts.
- Eric

How much space is left on that external drive? As to the rez of your timeline, pick the sequence, and select Command-0 (that's a zero). The dialogue box will tell you what codec you're working with.
Without knowing anything else, you will definitely experience better performance by exporting to a different drive than your media is on - that drive is being asked to both read and write at the same time, which slows it down considerably. If you can export it to a different drive, you can expect to see your export time cut perhaps in half.
However, six hours is still way too long. There's some other problem going on here, it may be the drive being too full or perhaps the rez of your sequence is really high.

FCP Chapter Markers/Compressor

I have all my chapter markers in my sequence in FCP all set and I want to export with compressor so I can use the two files and load them into DVDSP.
If I export with compressor, will it automatically recognize my chapter markers when I bring them in for a chapter index in DVDSP?
I know you can do this with Quicktime movie export, but I honestly prefer Compressor so I was wondering if it will automatically do this itself within the program.

Hi Jonesi, I would highly recommend that:
• you *DONT "send to compressor" from FCP timeline or 'EXPORT to COMPRESSOR*" from FCP timeline because it is simply too slow. Instead create a EXPORT AS QUICKTIME MOVIE with (a QT reference MOVIE (dont tick "self contained qt time movie" in the QT dialogue box". . The use the refernce movie as INPUT to compressor.app. Try it it works great! MAke a compressor DROPLET for fully automated work flow.
• _Chapter markers should be made on the TIMELINE that is used for the final EXPORT_. +Beware not to use CHAPTER markers in nested sequences.+
hth
w

FCP 7 Chapter Markers

I have a ProRes 422 clip (captured from Canon XHA1S - HDV) when I 'M' and 'M' again to place a marker and description including ticking the 'Chapter Marker' button it all works. I then export from FCP using current settings and export all markers. The produced .MOV file has the chapter markers ok( I can see them in Quicktime player) but when I workflow thro Compressor (to get my .ac3 and .mv2 files) into DVDPro the chapter markers are gone. I know I have left out a lot of detail about settings in Compressor but in effect I select the Make DVD template option with no changes but can you spot anything obvious I am missing or do you need mor info to tell .. if so when else would help you determine the cause. Many thanks in advance !
Jim

I'm still learning Final Cut too, so I hope I'm not misinforming you, but I've had that problem before and it was b/c the markers were on the clips themselves or on the audio track vs. on the timeline. When you hit "M" for marker make sure nothing is selected so the marker goes onto the timeline itself. You should see them along the top under the render bars, not within the clips or audio.
I think that might be your issue. I've had so many people on here helping me, I feel inclinded to try to help others, but not sure I'm in that category yet

FCP video chapter markers not accepted by DVD SPro

When I had FCP chapter markers in the timeline and then used compressor, they appeared in DVD Studio Pro. But in realizing that I couldn't cut out any footage in FCP without ruining all of the markers I had made following that point in the timeline it was suggested that I add chapter markers onto the video itself. The markers were no longer visible as windows in the Canvas, we got them to appear in the Viewer (view-playhead sync-open). BUT... Now, these markers attached to the video (and not the Time line) appear to not be working when I open a compressed sequence in DVD Studio Pro. How can this delemna be solved?

Ok, so if this is true (about "Chapter Markers set in FCP to work in DVD-SP, they HAVE to be set to the Timeline"), does it not seem a little silly for FCP (using latest Studio updates etc) to give people the option of utilizing "chapter" markers set to the video if they don't actually work?
By the way I'm using all of the latest FCS updates and exported using File: Export: Using compressor and then opening up DVD SP and importing assets etc.
Could there not be an easier way rather than having to wait until the VERY end of the editing process to add Chapter markers to the Timeline because otherwise they get all wacked out of sink if you cut out or add any video/audio?

Chapter Markers missing via Compressor?

Hi y'all, Using the latest FCP Studio, I used the default Compressor setting for DVD best 90 minutes, and my chapter markers did not get exported. Any idea what the problem is, or how to recapture them without re-exporting from FCP? I can't find a way to export the text of the markers. I also read that markers on clips will not export, only from the timeline, but FCP would not let me add Chapter markers to the timeline. It is being ornery.

Jefferis
You can read this tutorial about * Chapters and Compression Markers *.
FCP lets you add chapter markers in timeline; you must be doing something wrong. You can add the markers in Compressor too.
Hope that helps !
Alberto

HELP NO Chapters from FCP and Compressor-Did the FCP markers correctly too.

Hi Everyone,
Having allot of good Beans with FCP.
One problem though:
1. Export to DVDSP4 with CHAPTER markers on my timeline and when I try to import my m2v file from Compressor its greyed out for some reason so, I drag it into DVDSP4 from finder and highlight my play button on the 1st template
MENU: SET ASSET AND CREATE CHAPTER INDEX.
It usually works great while it continues on but, I dont see my chapters anywhere.
I know they are there but, someone on online here said that you dont see the chapters while in compressor (which I wish showed them in the preview windo to confirm they are there) but, have yet to see them who up in DVDSP4.
I still think this is a FCP inquiry but, trying to forums.
HELP<

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=2010186&#2010186
Has some info on Chapter Markers to help.
Are you exporting the markers when you export from FCP? Are you adding them and making sure that they are on the timeline (not the track) in FCP? (If you open the movie in QT you should see the markers on the lower left in a crop down selector if they exported properly.)

FCP-X Compressor 3.0.5 (need chapter-markers)

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for