Final Cut Studio Workflow Discussion

I'm trying to find out how many Final Cut users out there use the "Final Cut Studio Workflow" meaning; do you guys use Soundtrack Pro, Motion, Livetype and the other programs for your work? And how often do you use them? I think it'd be really cool to get a discussion going about who is using these programs in their editing workflow and how often and what they use it for.
Most of my work comes out of FCP but I use a lot of Adobe products such as After Effects, Photoshop and Illustrator. I DVD author with DVDSP and use Compressor when I go to DVD or web.
I find it interesting that I mostly use the FCP studio for just FCP. I hardly ever touch Livetype; I've used Soundtrack Pro twice and I've never used Motion.
The reason I post this in the Final Cut Pro user forum is because I'm interested in knowing how many 'editors' are doing this extra stuff outside of traditional editing.

I use the tools I know. I know photoshop and aftereffects (sortof) and haven't gotten a handle on motion. I use soundtrack pro occasionally to normalize, and eq, but not for much else (just remembered that I did a cool little music piece using the loops in soundtrack pro. really blew my client away). I find I can do almost everything I need to do audio wise in fcp. Subframe audio editing is a little cumbersome but doable. But... I do realize that I'll need to bite the bullet and explore motion eventually.
I've used cinematools a number of times to remove pulldown from film to tape transfers and to change the frame rate of pal qts (25fps) to 24 fps (very handly when my english animators gave me qt's with the wrong frame rate.
I started out as a film editor, when all I did was make edits on a flatbed with a rivas splicer. Those days are gone forever. Every year I find I'm doing more things than I ever did before. Maybe not always with a professional skill set, but I'm getting there.
Message was edited by: Michael Grenadier

Similar Messages

  • Final Cut Studio Workflow

    I´ve got a project where I use Final Cut Pro for editing, Soundtrack Pro for sound (Logic Pro for Scoring), Motion for rotoscoping and keying, Color for color correction, and Compressor for outputting the final movie...
    So, what is the best workflow?
    I would prefer to use roundtripping from beginning to end, but this is unfortunately not always possible. Color, for instance, isn´t always on speaking terms with Motion-clips. Should I export the clips made in Motion, so that I could do the overall coloring in Color, or should I use the 3-Way Color Corrector on that particular clip? Will exporting the Motion-clip as an independent clip reduce the quality of the clip?
    I really don´t know enough regarding formats and quality loss (I´m a hobbyist, not a pro), and would appreciate all the help I could get!

    The best workflow is one that works for you.
    I do the edit to what I want inserting temporary text/graphics/animations/whatever and then strip all that out, send the sequence to Color with considerations for transitions (in other words I build handles into the edit to account for dissolves/star wipes/fish wipes). When I'm done with Color I send it back to FCP and duplicate the ___(from Color) sequence and begin to insert all the other elements and trim the edits for transitions and what not. Why do I duplicate the sequence from Color? Simply because I don't want to cut up the original so I have something to fall back upon in case I go in a horrendously wrong direction with my project.
    This is how I'll incorporate Motion projects that use an alpha channel. If you think you need to treat your Motion projects in Color then you'll need to export self-contained files, import them into FCP and then send your sequence to Color.
    Unlike the FCP timeline which begrudgingly will accept almost any format into a sequence, Color will not tolerate mixed formats or files.
    This is what works for me, as with anything in this non-linear world, you'll find many many many other opinions of what works.
    Good luck.

  • Final Cut Studio is crashing a lot using a Mac Pro (nehalem) 2009

    Greetings,
    I have a video workstation based on a Mac Pro (2x2.26GHz Quad-Core Intel Xeon Nehalem, 6 GB RAM, 640 GB HD, 512 NVIDEA VRAM) with a Blackmagic Decklink HD Extreme 2009 and an Highpoint RocketRAID 4322 card (properly connected to a RAID 5 array).
    I'm editing, with Final Cut Studio 3, a big TV project with some TGA and loads of HD XDCAM EX 35mbs video footage.
    *What is happening wrong?*
    Final Cut Pro is crashing to many times and dont let me work with the flow that is supposed. I start to work and i do a bit of scrubbing in the timeline and suddenly the rainbow spyral starts to spin and kaput! FCP just crashes.
    I've tried to many things. Re-installing everything from the baseline, plug out the 2 PCIe cards (and not even the drivers are installed). Even so FCP still crashes with the project.
    Funny thing is... This symptom only happens with the Nehalem Mac Pro. I have another station based on a Mac Pro 2x2.66 GHz Dual Core Xeon 3 GB RAM 2006 and when i run the project... everything works fine. FCP here doesn't crash.
    This is what makes me believe that the problem must be with the new Mac Pro.
    I have the reports generated by the FCP after the crash. You can find it here:
    http://www.ideiascompernas.com/reports/
    I'm getting frustrated because i've invested big in this workstation, safe in the knowledge that it was going to be stable to complete my requirements.
    Is there anything that i or Apple can do to resolve my problem. Is it the processor? Extended Hardware Test says that everything is ok.
    I'll be waiting,
    best regards, thanks,
    Pedro

    You may want to also post here:
    Final Cut Studio forum:
    http://discussions.apple.com/category.jspa?categoryID=123
    Content creation with Final Cut Studio
    http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=1137
    I see you have the GT120, not a very nice card really but maybe it is 'enough.' I'd upgrade. To ATI Radeon 4870, once you get it stable and working.
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=10251193&tstart=0
    I see your crash is kernel panic actually.
    Exception Type: EXCBADACCESS (SIGBUS)
    Exception Codes: KERNPROTECTIONFAILURE at 0x0000000000000000
    Crashed Thread: 194
    Almost always that is memory related, are you seeing parity errors?
    Watch System Profile - Memory tab
    Replace the RAM (I'd even up it to more memory, 6 x 2GB is what I would have configured for)
    Have you tested your RAM? run Apple Hardware Test?
    Disabled ALL USB and Firewire devices?
    Is the RR4322 okay to run in slot #2 (16x) rather than in slot 3 or 4 (4x)?
    Getting RAM replaced, advanced exchange, or go out and getting some Kingston or Crucial etc for your system, and swapping, really is one good method, trial and error, to find the cultprit or rule out RAM.
    Errors like this can mean flushing your caches is a must, and possibly due to errors and crashes, clean system install, checking data (both time consuming) and being careful to recheck your drives with Disk Warrior and/or TechTool Pro 5 to insure there are not any corrupt files (not perfect either which is why restore the system from known good backup image can be a must).

  • Updating Final Cut Studio 2.01 and workflow between FCP and AE

    Hi. I am currently working in FCE 3.5 and am considering purchasing Final Cut Studio 2.01 (new and sealed) as opposed to the latest version since I am running a PowerPC G5. Am I assured of being able to download all the updates for Final Cut Pro 6 and exactly which version would be the latest and final one? Was there ever an FCP v6.5? I do mainly animation/motion graphics and work in After Effects (along w/ Flash, Carrara, Photoshop, Illustrator, etc.). I understand that the workflow between FCP (as opposed to FCE) and AE is greatly enhanced. Can someone give me an idea of what advantages this new workflow will offer in terms of what I'll be able to accomplish that I can't do now w/ FCE? Also, any other comments on how FCP (as compared to FCE) will benefit me as an animator will be greatly appreciated. Lastly, am I correct in assuming that I will be able to open my FCE 3.5 project files in FCP 6 but not visa versa? Thanks. Jack.

    Thanks for the replies everyone. I see that I will need some 3rd-party support in order to realize the benefit of a Final Cut Pro/After Effects workflow. Have another question. What are the kinds of filters that you can keyframe in FCP but not in FCE? And are there many filters in FCP that are not included w/ FCE? As I deal mainly w/ animation as opposed to footage of live video I am trying to justify the investment in Final Cut Studio 2 in terms of it being a benefit to me as an animator. I currently use FCE 3.5 (which includes versions of SoundTrack and LiveType) and After Effects CS3 plus other graphics programs. I would love to be able to work within DVD Studio Pro as iDVD is so limiting as an authoring program but am not sure how much I will benefit from switching from FCE to FCP. This is what I am trying to nail down.

  • AVCHD editing in Final Cut Studio 2 vs. HDV?  Which workflow is smoother?

    How is AVCHD editing in Final Cut Studio 2 compared to HDV?
    I am in the process of buying a new camcorder.
    Thinking about the Canon HV30, but I am considering AVCHD and the HG 10 or HF 10.
    I just heard that AVCHD is tough to edit... Is this true?
    I have a 24" iMac 2.8GHz Extreme Core 2 Duo with 4 Gb RAM, and I wonder if that would be enough horsepower to edit AVCHD. I also have a 1 terabyte Raid for storage.
    I love the idea of being able to just transfer over clips rather than Log and Capturing through an entire dv tape, but is the workflow of AVCHD more work in the long run.
    I am more concerned with workflow than even picture quality.
    I have so far only worked in SD... so any thoughts from people with hands on experience and can give a good comparison of the two workflows would be greatly appreciated.
    Thanks!

    AVCHD isnt any harder to edit then HDV. We are running the SONY EX1 which is Sold State Camera. You have to use Sony XDCam Transfer software to get it into FCP.
    Here is what we found.
    AVCHD is a lot faster to ingest (ive found 4x realtime) and because you have to use the Sony XDcam Software for transfers you end up with better Loggin metadata (mostly because its easier at the time of transfer)
    AVCHD is more expensive to run currently. With 16GB cards giving you 57 minutes of video they cost about 400 Pounds a card (im in the UK). On the plus side is you can view your footage instantly with a MacBooK Pro using the ExpressCard slot to plugin your solid state card and XDcam Viewer software.
    Backup can be done in one of to ways. Use a SONY XDCam deck and store the footage on their XDCam Cartridges (way too expensive option). or use external Hardisk (we use 2 one for storage on location and second for Backup and later on for long term Storage in our Library).
    When it comes to HDV we use the HDV-Z1 cameras and the process with the Z1 is just the same as with a consumer Level DV camera. It takes longer to ingest video because its realtime. But once in it runs fine. For backup its already done by the tape and again we store all Footage on Harddisk for long term storage once the project is done with the Tapes as backups. Oh.. and also the tapes are really cheap compared to the Solid state cards.
    I have to say i was happy with AVCHD at first because the initial setup was very expensive. BUt once setup the workflow is smoother and faster the HDV tape based system. I do find the quality to be better as well on AVCHD.
    I hope that helps

  • Help please importing mpeg files to be edited with Final Cut Studio

    Hey everyone, new to the video editing thing. I have a JVC GY-HM100U Pro HD camcorder and a MacBook Pro 5,1 with 2.53 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo Processor, 4 GB 1067 MHz DPR3, NVIDIA GeForce 9400M & NVIDIA GeForce 9600MGT running OSX 10.5.8. Have recorded footage in mpeg4 and want to now edit using Final Cut Pro 7. Have downloaded Quicktime Pro and am still getting a "the movie could not be opened when trying to import the mp4 file. The movie contains some invalid data" window when trying to open the mpeg4 file. I have also downloaded DivX, FF Player, & Handbrake if these help convert to another supported file format. Please help!

    That camera is promoted on the JVC website as being Final Cut Pro compatible.
    Have you tried to import the clips via Log & Transfer?
    You might also want to read up on the [workflow for that type of camera|http://documentation.apple.com/en/finalcutpro/professionalformatsandwork flows/#chapter=6%26section=0].
    Have downloaded Quicktime Pro....
    QuickTime Pro is installed automaticallly with Final Cut Studio. No need to buy it again.
    I have also downloaded DivX, FF Player, & Handbrake...
    That software is all pretty much useless for working with Final Cut Studio.
    MPEG Streamclip is free and much better.
    Tutorials and download links:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2059475&tstart=0
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2070861&tstart=0

  • Will Final Cut Studio 3 work with OSX Mavericks?

    Hi,
    Does anyone know if Final Cut Studio 3 will work with the New OSX Mavericks when it's released this fall?
    Thanks in advance

    If you have the snow leopard install disk, you can do a custom install and just install rosetta. 
    One person on this forum, says there are serious issues with this workflow and links to another method.
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/22029476#22029476
    I've done it a few times without any issues, and I haven't seen any definitive reports detailing the problems with this. 
    Doing a complete clean install is the much safer way to have a dependable system.  Here's a user tip on OS and FCP installation
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2861
    I'd also recommend creating a bootable clone of your startup drive before doing any os upgrades or application installations or upgrades.  That way if things go south, you can easily return to the previous working system.
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2494

  • How to get final cut studio 2 install disk to work on macbook air OS 10.8.4

    I just purchased a Macbook Air OSX Mountain Lion 10.8.4 and trying to install Final Cut Studio 2, however the install disk wont open using a superdrive.  How can I get my software loaded?
    Thank you.

    Try this forum:
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/professional_applications/final_cut_stud io
    Al

  • Can I use Final Cut Studio 2 software on a MacBook Air?

    My old MacBook Pro was stolen a couple of years ago and I replaced it with a MacBook Air OSX 10.9.5. I still have the software from Final Cut Studio 2  which I used on my MacBook Pro. I haven't got around the replacing this and was looking at the Final Cut App when it dawned on me I might be able to use the software I have. Any thoughts? I know nothing about how computers work, so a simple 'No', 'Yes' or 'Do this to make it work', would be great!

    I think the gist of what the two former responders are saying is that, if you can upgrade to software that will run natively in Yosemite, then you are seemingly much better off!
    I am not a film editor (although I play one on my computer! hahahaha) but I have been told by many FCS2 users that they need ongoing access to it because of clients who ask for editorial updates to older projects.  My understanding is that Final Cut Pro X will NOT open the FCS2 files for processing.  Hence a valid reason to be able to install and operate FCS2 on today's modern Macs.
    There are three methods to install and operate FCS2 in Mavericks; I have no confirmation yet that these work in Yosemite, or if once installed in Yosemite, FCS2 will operate properly.  Here is a recent post I prepared to provide this information:
    Apple has created a "bug" in the attempt to install FCP6 in Lion, Mt. Lion and Mavericks, which makes it look like Rosetta is needed for a PowerPC app, the installer, so as to make it difficult for the use of FCP6 in these versions of OS X!  There are three ways to install it:
    1.  Pacifist https://www.charlessoft.com/
    2.  Jeremy Johnstone's Terminal method http://www.jeremyjohnstone.com/blog/2012-03-11-installing-final-cut-pro-studio-2 -0-on-mac-os-x-10-7-lion.html
    3.  HawaiianHippie has discovered the best and safest possible solution to this problem:
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/26309669?ac_cid=tw123456#26309669
    I have now successfully done this on four computers, brand new iMacs running 10.9.4.  And I've discovered an even easier way to do this!  You don't need to edit the plist file, just move it into the Trash.  Install proceeds normally.  You can return it after you're done if you like, I don't know what (if any) possible repercussions might come from leaving it deleted.
    The file, as indicated on Jeremy Johnstone's blog, is
    /System/Library/CoreServices/Installer.app/Contents/Resources/PPCRequirements.pl ist
    (Note that when you get to Installer.app, you will have to Control+click and select "Show Package Contents")
    I have not, as yet, attempted to recreate his success.

  • Can't Install Final Cut Studio V3.0

    Hi,
    I'm currently using a mid-2009 13-inch Macbook Pro running OS X Mavericks 10.9.1. I'm trying to install a retail verison of Final Cut Studio V3.0 that has 2 installs left, but my Macbook ejects the first installation disk about a minute after I put it in.
    Does anyone know why the installation disk isn't being recognized?

    Here's a user tip on installing fcp
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2861
    In particular, there's a link to this
    http://www.secondchairvideo.com/?cat=28
    which details a method in which you create disk images of all the dvd's.  Works great.

  • Can i install Final cut studio 5 and DVD Studio Pro 4 on OSX lion

    Is any body who can help me on giving me some direction on how to install Final Cut Studio 5.1 and DVD Studio Pro 4 on my OSX Lion, if it's doable. Thanks

    The easiest way is to install Rosetta from a Mac OS X 10.6 DVD first.
    There's also a way of doing it via Terminal that's been posted here a couple of times. A search should bring that up.
    Edit: Found it... https://discussions.apple.com/message/21416133#21416133 read the second post.

  • Final cut studio 3 and my mac pro major and unnecessary issues

    just a heads up, sorry for my grammar, I have been using final cut pro since it was 3.0 on my old g4 upgraded to every version since. ive edited on final cut pro ruffly 40 hours+ per week since. now i just upgraded to final cut studio 3 about 2 weeks ago and ive been having major issues with speed and freezing and rendering and the new sharing features and motion and everything.
    lets start from the beginning.
    i have a mac pro 1,1 with dual core intel xeon 2.66 ghz
    7 gb of ram
    osx 10.5.8 (cant upgrade to snow leopard just yet due to sxs problems and heard its even slower)
    NVIDIA GeForce 7300 GT (thinking may be the culprit)
    i have 2 monitors one 22" and my main 24" running both through a dvi cable
    now the first hour i started working the computer froze up completely, mouse frozen and everything
    (never happened before) after a day of unexpected quits and constant restarts i disconnected my second monitor.
    im still having the speed problems sometimes even seeing scrambled images for icons on my os dock. i dont know what to do. ill leave something to render over night, wake up and check on it and the program quit. again. i have a deadline on a video coming very quick, and ive been searching this issue on all the discussion boards here and creative cow and haven't seen an answer yet. spoke to customer support early in the issue and tried everything they said ie: new user, different drive, yada yada yada. the only thing i havent done is reinstall osx and flush my whole computer. im definatly not prepared to do so and then still have the problem. anyway. if anyone can get through this runon of a post please please help im despreate. let me know if you need anymore info and ill be glad to provide it, and if anyone that helps lives in the ny area i would be honored to buy you a drink in return for your support.
    thanks for your time.

    HOW did you upgrade? Install FCS 3 on top of FCS 2? That is not the best way to do it. Plus some of the issues you are having seem like OS issues. The best thing to do is the "scorched Earth" approach. Fresh install of the OS and fresh install of FCS 3. Always when upgrading this is the best method. And the make sure that you can go back if things don't work is to get a NEW hard drive, install the OS and FCS3 on that, and keep the old drive. Or clone your hard drive (carbon copy cloner), then erase and install. Or at least clone your drive before you update what you have (which is not the best way).
    Too late now, I know, but file that away for the future. Now you should backup all your data, then erase and install Leopard again, then install your Apps. This will take a day, maybe a day and a half, and then you will be up and running. Better than trying to stuggle for days or weeks with a staggering OS.
    Shane

  • Final Cut Studio 2 and Canon hv20

    I'm currently working on Final Cut Studio 2 and I'm looking at buying a Canon HV20. I've looked into some threads on this one and it seems that people are having trouble with this camera on FC Studio 2. Is there anyone out there that can attest to smooth and efficient workflow with this set up? A major selling point for me is the 24p, tell me it works well, please tell me it works well.
    thank you,
    t r e y v o n

    HV20 works perfectly at 24p in FCP 6.0.2.
    Added advantage is that you can capture uncompressed (with HDMI card and fast drive/RAID) at much higher quality and resolution than HDV.
    Quality is so good, you can create great 1920 x 1080 24p green screen shots (using 4:2:2 color space from HDMI) and dvMatte Pro 3.
    The next step up to get better quality at 24p is around $5K-$6K range (I think?).
    Here's a small image of a 24p frame shot on green screen with the HV20:
    http://www.ecophones.com/embed/printplace.jpg

  • What is the "Content Creation with Final Cut Studio" ?

    Hi,
    How does this category differ from Final Cut Studio?
    Thanks for your time.

    Hi:
    Check this thread:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=4606811
    Hope that helps !
      Alberto

  • Mac Book Pro and final cut studio 2

    Hi,
    Bought a MBP last year and am looking to purchase Final Cut Studio 2 Universal. After looking through some discussions I'm still unsure how well this package will run with my setup. Yes it will be fine, or yes it will run but with some limitations, or yes it will run but I should get a different video card, etc.....? A definate yes or no would be appreciated and any limitations or known issues. I will be using a120GB external hard drive for my video footage.
    Thanks, Mick
    Sorry if this is posted in the wrong area or if these questions have been answered. I'm new to Macs and forums and wouldn't like to spend that much cash on a maybe!
    Mac Book Pro 15   Mac OS X (10.4.9)   Intel core duo 2.16 GHz 2GB ram/Radeon X1600 256Mb 80GB hard drive

    Yes, it will be fine.
    The only limitation is Color which needs an external screen with at least 1650x1050 to be kind of useful though it runs at smaller resolutions.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Standard US Address format in Smart forms

    Hi All, Can any one please tell me how can we achieve standard US Address format while displaying Address. Thanking you in advance. Ragards, Bhanu.R

  • How to localize labels in WhiteBoard component

    Hello, I would need to localize some labels in the whiteboard components. Looking at the source code, it looks like you are using a private class "com.adobe.coreUI.localization.Localization". How can I work around it to set my own resource bundle? Ch

  • Monthly Spending Limit

    I received a message that I reached my monthly spending limit.  So, I am not able to use Skype my acount and we are only a third of the way through the month.  It was suggested that I sign in with a second ID, however, I discovered that the applicati

  • Trouble printing images from pdf

    When I print a selected portion from a pdf that has an image, the image is really blurry. Any help?

  • Stock can not be create

    Hi friends I am trying to create stock using /nmb1c. I entered movament type 561, material name and quality and all required fields. When press save, system display error "display account determination entry INT GBB-BSA 7920 not possible'. How i shou