Free goods problems changing material

Hello,
I am using free goods inclusive without item generation (NRAB condition).
I introduced a material A having free goods, ant it works fine, but if I change the material A for B in the same position (without free goods), the NRAB condition is maintained.
Has anyone seen this bug? Is there a note with this problem? I have searched it without successful.
(I am using SAP ECC 6.0
Alberto.

I suppose it disappears once you change qty (after you changed material A to B) ?

Similar Messages

Free Goods from One Material Group to Another Material Group

Salute Masters!!
I need your valuble suggestion, please provide.
I need to configure Free Goods of Material Group to Material Group.
User want:
1) Free Goods from one Material Group to another Material Group, like F010 to F040
2) User should have option to change from one Material Group to Other Material Group, which He / She want, like F010 or F020, F030, F040 any one of them.
Suppose;
Line Item Material Belongs to One Group Quantity in Gallons Free Goods from Any Material Group Quantity in Gallons
      1            A                                              3                                    F010                                             4
      2            B                                              3                                     F020
      3            C                                              4                                     F040
Any No. of Line Item Any No. of Material
                                   from One Group      Total 10                   From Any Material Group
(Comprising of 3-4 Different Material from 1 Group, they should be able to choose/provide Free Goods from other Material Group)
3) While creating Sales Order what Quantity (Gallons/No./Ltr) to be put?
How I can configure this scenario?
Please suggest, is it possible through KEY COMBINATION?
Rgds.
Srivastav
+91 7829755109
Skype ID: sanjai.srivastav1

Hi,
if you want to give free goods from other group it can be possible only for EXCLUSIVE free good type
In exclusive free goods, a material different from the orignal material can be specified as the free goods.
Example: A customer who buys 200 crates of beer, gets 5 boxes of glasses free.
In VBN1 >> Exclusive
See column ADD FREE MATERIAL
While creating Sales Order what Quantity (Gallons/No./Ltr) to be put?
Maintain alternative units in material master >> Additional data >> Material master,BUT it is only main item
Those item u want to give free that items unit is derived from free goods condition record and it CANNOT be change in order

Free goods of different material

Hi Experts,
I have mapped free goods scenario in our system.Its working well for inclusive and exclusive free goods for same material. i.e. If I have a material M1 ordered for 100 units I will get 10 units of the same material M1 free(Exclusive) and two line items generated TAN and TANN.
Similarly for inclusive condition,We have a material A1. If one orders 100 units of A1 he has to pay for 90 units only(TAN) and the remaining 10 units (TANN) comes for free.
Now I want to set up the system in such a manner that If the customer orders a material R1 of 100 units he will get material R2 of 10 units for free.
How do we do this setting? In NA00 itself? If yes please tel me the steps involved.
Regards,
Randhir

Hi,
Please find the info below.
1.      Free goods can only be supported on a 1:1 ratio. This means that an order item can lead to a free goods item. Agreements in the following form are not supported: 'With material 1, material 2 and material 3 are free of charge' or 'If material 1 and material 2 are ordered at the same time, then material 3 is free of charge'.
2.      Free goods are not supported in combinations with material structures (for example, product selection, BOM, variants with BOM explosion).
3.      Free goods are only supported for sales orders with document category C (for example, not quotations).
4.      Free goods are not supported for deliveries without reference to a sales order.
5.      Free goods cannot be used in make-to-order production, third-party order processing and scheduling agreements.
6.      If you defined a free goods for variants in a generic article (only SAP Retail), you can only process the variants in the purchase order and goods receipt individually (as single articles). In other words, you cannot process them using the generic article matrix
(you can find complete info under the below link)
http://wiki.sdn.sap.com/wiki/display/ERPLO/FreeGoodsDetermination
Br, Sats.

How to have more than one free good for a material ?

Hi everyone,
we have this requirement from the user where he wants give more than one free good for a material.
As far as i know we can configure only one free good for a material in standard SAP.
if have any idea about how to achieve this please guide me how to configure the same in SAP.
thank you in advance

Hi
Check my two links where I have explained this.
Free goods using Sale order BOM methodology
Different business scenarios and Sales BOM techniques for header and item level stock and prices
Thank$

Free good for bom material

hai i am new to sap , can any one tell me how to post free good for bom material !!

Hi,
Being a new member, one quick advice would be to search SDN and related forums before posting a new question, since this issue has been discussed many times.
To answer your question, Free Goods does not support BOM.
Please check [here|http://help.sap.com/saphelp_46c/helpdata/en/dd/55fa34545a11d1a7020000e829fd11/frameset.htm] for detailed explanation.
Regards,
Amit

Assorted Free Goods Problems in Sales Order

Hello All,
The problem is related to Assorted Free Goods Pricing in Sales Order.I have two queries which are provided below with example:-
In the sales order I am giving 2 Line Items. -
Material A & Material B of total quantity 10PC Then 1 PC of the Material C as 3rd line item
in the sales order is populated which is maintained as an assorted free good having Manual Free Item Category for eg. ZFV5.
Similarly line items A & B combined of 10 PC = 1 PC of Material C having Manual Free Item Category for eg. ZFV5.
Again if 10 PC of Material A or B are chosen respectively = 1 PC of Material C having Manual Free Item Category for eg. ZFV5 .
_Now I want to configure the following**_ -
1) The system will include the cost of the Assorted Free Good Item within the Main Item.
2) While raising a Sales Return Order for the above mentioned Sales Order it is observed that the manual free item category ZFV5 is changed to the Return Main Item Category whereas I want the item category to be picked up is Return Free Item Category against the Manual Item category .
Now considering the above scenarios please suggest solutions to attain my requirement.
Looking forward to some valuable suggestions.
Thanks & Regards
Priyanka

Hi Priyanka
As far as what i understood from your post your requirement doesnt seem to be possible in standards
If you want the cost to be transferred to the main item then in VTFL at item level there is a check box of cumulative cost
That has to be ticked
Constraintsin free goods in R3
Free goods can only be supported on a 1:1 ratio. This means that an order item can lead to a free goods item. Agreements in the following form are not supported: u2018With material 1, material 2 and material 3 are free of chargeu2018 or u2018If material 1 and material 2 are ordered at the same time, then material 3 is free of chargeu2018.
Free goods are not supported in combinations with material structures (for example, product selection, BOM, variants with BOM explosion).
Free goods are only supported for sales orders with document category C (for example, not quotations).
Free goods are not supported for deliveries without reference to a sales order.
Free goods cannot be used in make-to-order production, third-party order processing and scheduling agreements.
If you defined a free goods for variants in a generic article (only SAP Retail), you can only process the variants in the purchase order and goods receipt individually (as single articles). In other words, you cannot process them using the generic article matrix.
Regards
Raja

Free Goods Problem and User Exit if needed in Sales Order

Hello All,
The problem is related to Free Goods in Sales Order which is given with an example -
We have maintained Free Goods ( T Code - VBN1) in inclusive scenario which is as follows -
For 210 PAC (Pack) of Material A 18 PAC Free.
Where 1 PAC = 20 BT (Bottle) and 20 PAC = 1 CV (Case Pack)
In the material master of Material A the Base Unit Of Measurement (UOM) = PAC and Sales UOM = Blank so that we can use any conversion factor maintained for the material.
The conversion factors maintained for Material A are as follows -
1 BT = 1BT
1 PAC = 20 BT
1 CV = 20 PAC
Now when we are raising sales order for 11 CV the free goods are not generated in the Sale Order.
Again if we maintain the Sales UOM in CV and raise the sales order it is showing :
10 CV as main item and 1 CV as Free which is wrong because in the conversion factor we have already maintained 1CV = 20 PAC , Whereas in the inclusive scenario it is given 11CV = 210 PAC and 210 PAC = 18 PAC is free.So in any case it is taking into account 2 more PACs.
Please suggest what need to be done in this case in respect of User Exit or Source Code in ABAP if needed.
Thanks & Regards
Priyanka Mitra

Hello Priyanka Mitra,
We are facing a problem same as you.
How did you solve this problem?
We are very glad if you teach it concretely.
Please advise your solution to us.
Thanks.

Free Goods Problem in Sales Order

Hello All,
The problem is related to Free Goods in Sales Order which is given with an example -
We have maintained Free Goods ( T Code - VBN1) in inclusive scenario which is as follows -
For 210 PAC (Pack) of Material A 18 PAC Free.
Where 1 PAC = 20 BT (Bottle) and 20 PAC = 1 CV (Case Pack)
In the material master of Material A the Base Unit Of Measurement (UOM) = PAC and Sales UOM = Blank so that we can use any conversion factor maintained for the material.
The conversion factors maintained for Material A are as follows -
1 BT = 1BT
1 PAC = 20 BT
1 CV = 20 PAC
Now when we are raising sales order for 11 CV the free goods are not generated in the Sale Order.
Again if we maintain the Sales UOM in CV and raise the sales order it is showing :
10 CV as main item and 1 CV as Free which is wrong because in the conversion factor we have already maintained 1CV = 20 PAC , Whereas in the inclusive scenario it is given 11CV = 210 PAC and 210 PAC = 18 PAC is free.So in any case it is taking into account 2 more PACs.
Please suggest what need to be done in this case in respect of SD / ABAP(if needed).
Thanks & Regards
Priyanka Mitra

Yes Priyanka
This is a very interesting and a challenging issue or question
I think because of the prorata calculation type the extra 2 units is coming
This logical error has happened to me too
Inclusive 210 units means we have defined as 192 + 18 in VBN1
But the system determines the free goods in sales order as 190 + 20 that means there are 2 units which are going free than what has been maintained as condition record
But system converts our logic into its own thro that calcultion type PRO RATA which is the main culprit here
So it requires ABAP help
This qn should be awarded points (unfortunately i am not able to do so)
Regards
Raja

Free goods determination from material determination.

Hi experts,
I have one issue for you,
My scenario is:
we issue freee goods 1:1. i configured free goods setting and maintained VBN1 (condition records for free goods). i even maintained material determination configuration settings and maintained VB11 (condition records for material determination). The problem is system proposing free goods automatically when i process sales order without material determination list, if i go through material determination list system not determining free goods nor giving any message. what is the system behaviour if we go through material sustitution list to free goods. the main item (for free goods)will be existed in the substitutiion list. plez help. any suggestion will be highly appreciated.
thanks,
sada

Hi
Please consider the two issues separately. Don't club both the issues. If you have records for both material determination and free goods.,
1. Whether the material substitution is happening perfectly (as per the records created in VB11) or not.
Next.,
2. check whether the free goods are determined for the material in the sales order line item (as per the records created in VBN1) or not.
Please check and post the result.
Sometimes the freegoods will be determined in the sales order but will not create any second line item(as sub item) because while creating the records in VBN1 if you select the option 'Free goods Inclusive without line item generation. In this case NRAB condition type will be determined instead of R100.
So, also check the conditions tab and see whether the entire quantity is priced or not.
Thanks,
Ravi

Hi, guru free goods problem

Hi Sap gurus,
I want to give scheme (Free Goods )
Buy 1family pack(in which two tooth pastes will be there & i have to get 1tooth brush as free.) with lower price
how do i configure that.
Thanks in Advance

Hi Balaji,
you can go with BOM
Create 1 seperate material code ABCD
Tooth paste ABC
Tooth brush DEF
link these two material with ABCD 2 ABC and 1DEF
then stock will move from lower level and u can maintain lowest price for ABCD
i think ur problem is solved
Reward if it is useful..
Regrds
Durga Prasad
Edited by: Durga Sana on Feb 7, 2008 6:59 AM

Free goods problem

Hi,
I require free goods in quotation. For example If i enter 10 qty in quotation. The billing should be done only for 9 qty (10-1) for inclusive case.
and for exclusive case an addition line item should be generated with 1 quantity
1 is free good quantity.
The same thing should be copied to sales order, IF i create sales order with reference of quotation.
Kindly help me if any body is having an idea.
Thanks&Regards
(YUGANDHAR.P)

Hi Yugandhar,
You can maintain the scenario in free goods determination.
Using inclusive/exclusive and with Item generation and with out item generation.
And activate Complete reference indicator in VTAA for OR<-QT
It idicates whether the system copies the source document completely.
Procedure
If you mark the field, the system copies the source document into the target document completely. The system also copies the complete reference indicator. You cannot change the indicator in the target document.
Example
You mark a quotation for complete reference and you then copy the quotation into a sales order. Later, if you try to change an order quantity or to delete an item, the system sends a message.
Reward if help ful..........

Free goods problem (exclusive)

when creating a condition in VBN1 with free goods category 2 (Exclusive) i got the following message
"This selection is not possible in the inclusive bonus quantity field"
how can i solve it ??

Try this VBN1 T code , Enter the CnTy and Press enter and enter the sales org, dist ch. Before entering any other data, click on"Exclusive" Tab on the top (gift box).
Regards
Sai

Group or package free goods problem

Dear gentlemen
We need to issue the following type of free goods: buy goods A, B and C and get D for free. We need to consider our A-B-C as a package, just like a single good. How can we enter master data for this free goods type?
Regards,
Carlos Piana
La Universal
Guayaquil, Ecuador, South America

Hi carlos
I think in free goods it is not possible . we can fulfill your requirement through bonus buy functionality.
But bonus buy works in IS -RETAIL . It doesn't work in SD .
If we have to fulfill our requirement then we have to go for enhancements
Regards
Srinath

Free goods sale with addl material

Dear All,
I have maintained records for free goods in VBN1 with other material code in AddMat GrGd but while creation of sale order VA01 additional material is not showing, it is taking same material as free. In VBN1 Min qty 5, FreeGdsQty-10, CalcRule -1, Free Goods 2(Exclusive).
While creating sale order VA01 for 10 PC, it is taking same material as free for 1 pc in 2nd line and 9 PC as not free in 1st line. Plz suggest what wrong I am doing.
regards,
sp shukla

Hi,
Goto : VBN1--Specify the condition type for free Goods..by selectiong the req Key combination.
Select the button Exclusive and Maintain the data for : Materiual, Minimum Qty,from,Unit of Measure,Addnal free goods,Calculation rulke , Free goods.
*Speecify the Value for exclusive free goods *:
Under Addinal Material Free Good (Spc the respective material that is given as free good.).
This will solve your Problem.
Anywayz Further Confirmation you need to maintain is :
Free Good Delivery Control :
Maitain Condition Technique (SproSDBF--free good cond Tech for free goods)...there.... maintain cond tables, Access Seq cond types n Pricing Procedure.
n Finally Activate Free Good Determination(assign the free good procedure to the combination of SORG ,DC, Div, DocPri Pro and Customer Pri Pro)
Thanks.
Edited by: C.Ankit on Feb 13, 2012 9:16 AM

Giving BOM material as free good in Sales Order

Hi,
I have a business requirement.
I want to give a free good in Sales Oreder which is a BOM material.This should be possible by manually changing Item category for the line item in the Sales Order just like how we can change TAN to TANN in normal circumsatnces when we add free good material for any NON BOM material.
In standard functionality,the item category determined for this BOM material is TAQ but this item category field in Sales Order is non editable because of which I can not include the BOM material as free good in my sales order.
I have already defined one z Item category for free goods for this BOM material & want to use it in Sales Order.
Can you please suggest how this can be handled ?
Or is there any other work around by which will allow me to include BOM material as free good in my Sales Order ?
Thanks in advance
Regards,
BM

Hi,
Thanks everyone for the feedback.I agree with Samir Danish.It is a standard functionality of SAP which does not allow free goods for BOM material.
However, can someone suggest work around to deal with this issue.I mean if any one has been doing any work around for this issue then please let me know.It s becoming critical for me.
Regards,
BM

Free goods problems changing material

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for