Frustrating that I can clean up noise better in PE5 with a plugin than in LR..

I like to avoid flash with faces as much as I can so I tend to use high ISO fairly often with fast lenses.
One particular raw file I was having trouble with in PE5 so I added Neat Image as a plug in several months ago and to my amazement the image began to look like a 100 ISO image.
Last night I decided to see if I could replicate it in LightRoom. I worked on it for hours and could not do so using the same monitor and printer I used to create it in PE5 plus NI.
I even tried editing the image through LR to PE5 as a .tif and back again using NI while in PE5. Awful!
LR is 16 bit minimum and PE5 only works with 8 bit....is this the problem in all probability with this situation, and would CS3+LR give me a one stop solution once and for all? I don't do anything with pictures other than take them, "develop them", store them, and occasionally print one for a family member. Most of the CS products I'd never use and I've avoided putting out that much cash for items I'd rarely or never use, but the noise remover in LR is glaringly weak it appears.
As bizarre as this seems I'm finding that in some cases I'd be better off to develop in PE5 with some plug-ins and catalog with LR. I can't believe I'm typing that, but several files seem to dictate that to me.
Any comments would be appreciated, especially if it comes from developers who hint that noise problem enhancements are on the way.

".just open LR to the same popular plug ins that Adobe has allowed in other products and it would be fine"
Yeah, well, that's a bit of a problem, don't ya know. Lightroom is a "parametric image editor", meaning it doesn't edit "pixels" only parameters that WILL be applied upon export or printing. So, Photoshop "plug-in filters" simply can't be incorporated-not in the manner people seem to understand plug-ins. There aren't any "pixels" in Lightroom to operate on-just parameters...
This is an entirely new approach to image editing-well, kinda...there was an old application called Live Picture that worked in a slightly similar manner and while LP eventually got "plug-ins" to work, it required rendering, plug-in application and re-editing back in LP. Which kinda defeated the purpose.
When Lightroom gets an SDK (coming eventually) there will be an ability for third parties to write "modules" to do things in Lightroom. But that's gonna take some time. In the meantime, if ya just gotta use a 3rd party plug-in, then there's really no option besides the pixel edit in Photoshop (or Elements).

Similar Messages

  • I find it rather frustrating that you can't use things like {myArray[0]} in Bindable expressions

    I find it rather frustrating that you can't use things like
    {myArray[0]} in Bindable expressions. Are there any workarounds
    apart from manually changing the dataprovider?

    Yes, instead of an array you have to use an arraycollection
    (just wrap your array) and then you can use this with the
    getItemAt()-method.
    e.g.
    {myArrayCollection.getItemAt(0)}
    cheers
    Dietmar

  • I am having same problem with apple tv need 4.4 version and can not find solution this a brand new product out of box yesterday why would it not already have updated version. I am getting frustrated that I can not get this mirroring icon to work. I

    I am having same problem with apple tv need 4.4 version and can not find solution this a brand new product out of box yesterday why would it not already have updated version. I am getting frustrated that I can not get this mirroring icon to work. I have tried all suggestions in this thread and nothing works. I also hooked up to laptop through iTunes with micro USB nothing!!!

    The new appletv software came out 2 or 3 days ago, how would Apple get it on the device in the box in a store?
    Why don't ou update the appletv software?

  • First of all, I would have to say that getting in touch with you is a nightmare and I am not at all happy that I can't just email or live chat with someone who can help!  I am not a technical person, I just want to be able to use Photoshop Elements and ge

    First of all, I would have to say that getting in touch with you is a nightmare and I am not at all happy that I can't just email or live chat with someone who can help!  I am not a technical person, I just want to be able to use Photoshop Elements and get on with it. I bought Photoshop Elements via Amazon some months ago and it worked fine.  I then got a message that advised that the trial version would expire, which it subsequently has (I have been trawling your site for weeks and weeks trying to find an email or phone contact to get some assistance).  Relucltantly, I am now typing this - and I suspect it will not help in the slightest!  I bought the FULL not TRIAL edition of Photoshop Elements and I have contacted Amazon who confirmed this, but say I need to contact you.  Can you please let me know how I can resolve this?  Louise A Fraser

    Hi Louise, sorry to hear of your problems. This is not Adobe. We are mainly support volunteers, other users like you, trying to help one another.  You need to contact Adobe directly for activation and licencing issues. Click the link below. Use the dropdown menu for boxes (1) & (2) to scroll down the list and choose:
    1. Adobe Photoshop Elements
    2. Adobe ID, and signing-in
    3. Click on the blue button: Still need help? Contact us – then click the area marked chat 24/7, then click “start chat ”
    It’s usually possible to start a live chat, if an Adobe agent is free, and often to get the problem fixed right away. Have your serial number available. The agent can directly troubleshoot your system if you agree to activate the Adobe Connect add-on. Don’t let them pass the buck. Stay connected and ask to speak with a supervisor if necessary.
    Click here to get help now Contact Customer Care

  • I have a Sony Cybershot camera. My problem is that I can't view my panoramic photos properly with iPhoto.  Sony says to contact Mac support. Has anyone any info on this prob, please?

    Panoramic photos. I have a Sony Cybershot camera. My problem is that I can't view my panoramic photos properly with iPhoto.  Sony says to contact Mac support. Has anyone any info on this prob, please?

    Not sure what you want - you shoot the photo by doing a sweep and the camera makes a static JPEG that is long (panaromic) and you import it - on the camera and in iPhoto is is a panaromic photo
      for example
    LN

  • I using mozilla firefox so long times but it just get problem today because i can't type in english words but i can type in thai and some buttons is not english but it's other alphbets that i can't read and it's happening with yahoo and friendster and not

    I using mozilla firefox so long times but it just get problem today because i can't type in english words but i can type in thai and some buttons is not english but it's other alphbets that i can't read and it's happening with yahoo and friendster and not sure for other website
    == today ==
    == User Agent ==
    Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 2.0.50727; .NET CLR 3.0.4506.2152; .NET CLR 3.5.30729)

    Same problem with the mouse, but with the mouse I can leave the cursor in place in the text field and move to the keyboard to type. As long as the cursor is in the field it stays editable.
    The problem with the pen is it's in my hand all of the time. I just flip it up under my thumb against my palm to type. So, as soon as I move the pen, the field goes away and I can't type in it. Hoping this is making sense.
    My tablet does have the touch function too, and I just found out I can use my finger to tap in the text field, then type. I guess that'll be my solution since I prefer not to leave a mouse set up on this iMac.
    I'm thinking now that this is just a problem with the pen itself, and nothing to do with iPhoto. So glad to have this figured out! I really like iPhoto '11! So much easier for me, a simple P&S gal, than Aperture 3. I use iPhoto Library Manager too and love it!
    Thanks so much! Debbie

  • Things my WM 6.1 phone did that I can't find a way to do with the iphone

    Hi All iphoners
    I have a small list of things that I can't find a way to do with the iphone. I was hoping that someone would be able to help me with this. I know there must be a way to do these but I just have not found it yet.
    here they are:
    Play video clips from my favorite news web sites.
    search my contacts by just typing the name from anywhere in the contact list
    Play music and sounds thru by stereo bluetooth headset
    Sync my notes and tasks from outlook
    setup different tones and alarms for new e-mail, new SMS, so on
    voice announcement of who is calling if the caller is in my contacts
    Download document to the phone, word, PDF, so on
    Mark all e-mail as read with one button
    place call from calendar if phone number is in appointment
    Beam files from one phone to another
    Picture mail
    Rotate e-mail while ready e-mail. this works for web pagers but not e-mail
    thanks for all the help
    Bill

    spock4104 wrote:
    Play video clips from my favorite news web sites.
    depending on who your "favorites" are, they might have an app in the app store which includes videos
    search my contacts by just typing the name from anywhere in the contact list
    theres a search bar at the top of the contacts list. you type, it searches.
    Play music and sounds thru by stereo bluetooth headset
    sorry, can only be achieved via devices such as the Sony TMR-BT8iP (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000XRW09Y)
    setup different tones and alarms for new e-mail, new SMS, so on
    all but SMS is not customizable for now. but even with SMS, you can only choose from those available.
    voice announcement of who is calling if the caller is in my contacts
    my suggestion is to set a particular ringtone for that person. OR, you can always record yourself saying that person's name, convert it to a ringtone, and use that. (if you dont know how to create your own ringtone, a quick search on this forum should help you out).
    Download document to the phone, word, PDF, so on
    Beam files from one phone to another
    look for "Air Share" in the app store.
    Picture mail
    it can, you have to do it from the photo, not email tho.
    i dont have an answer for the ones i left out. sorry. hope these help.

  • Latest operating system that I can use on a Power Mac G5 with CPU type Power PC 970 (2.2)

    What is the latest operating system that I can use on a Power Mac G5 with CPU type Power PC 970 (2.2).  This is not an intel chip.  Thank you.

    10.5.8 without Classic, or 10.4.11 with Classic.

  • I have a newer MacBook Pro with an AMD processor.  It is my understanding that Parallels can only be used on Mac's with Intel Processors.  Is that true and if so does anyone have recommendations about how to have a windows side to my Mac

    I have a newer MacBook Pro with an AMD processor.  It is my understanding that Parallels can only be used on Mac's with Intel Processors.  Is that true and if so does anyone have recommendations about how to have a windows side to my Mac

    Then it either is a pirate clone or you are misinformed.
    Apple Computer has never used AMD processors in its products.
    However, the Graphics Processing Unit (GPU) is a Radeon unit, which is an AMD subsidiary. Parallels, VMWare, VirtualBox will all work fine with the Intel Core i7 or i5 CPU that powers the Mac, and use the AMD Radeon GPU that drives the displays.

  • How do you save a Pages '09 document so that it can be read by an older Mac with Pages '08 loaded

    I am trying out a version of iWork '09 but can see no way of saving a copy of documents in iWork'08 so that someone can read the documents who has not upgraded can read the document.

    You can read one of the many threads about Save As… no longer in Lion. It has been replaced with Duplicate then Save… which gets you to the same dialog box. This screenshot is from Save in Numbers, but it looks the same in Pages. Check the box next to Save copy as & choose iWork '08 from the drop-down menu.

  • How do I duplicate an image on the main screen so that I can edit it and compare the result with the original?

    In Elements 12 How do I duplicate an image on the main screen (as well as the photo bin) so that i can compare any editing with the original?

    In full Editor, go to Edit>Preferences>General and check "Allow Floating Documents in Full Edit Mode"
    Open the image so that you see it in the project bin
    Right click the image thumbnail in the project bin, and duplicate. It will come in as xxxcopy
    On the Arrange icon at the top, select 2-up. You should see the original and the duplicate in the work area

  • HT1386 Hi there, i have an ipod that has locked up due to children playing onit and putting a password that they can't remember. itunes won't sync with it as it does not recognise the ipod. Does anyone know how i can unlock this ipod? cheers.

    Hi, i have an ipod touch that has been locked out. Children were playing with it and now have forgotten the password. I have red screen that says to connect to itunes. itunes won't open because the message comes up saying the ipod is locked with a password. Also, this is not the computer that this ipod was last synced with. Can someone help me open this please. Cheers.

    Place the iPod in Recovery mode and then connect to your computer and restore via iTunes.

  • Clicking noise before audio regions with AU plugins

    Hi
    know this is a very old topic but this, "Clicking noise before audio regions with third party AU plugins" Does this happen to everyone with Logic or is this just for special Logic owners?

    Ronny hughes wrote:
    Ok folks just needed confirmation that it was not just me getting this.
    But can i put this to you? I'm doing some Beta testing on a set of plugins and i am having loads of problems that no one else seems to be having,
    So it is plugin specific i.e it doesn't happen on all 3rd party plugs and also now that you have confirmed it's not just my Mac.
    I would say it's not your Mac but a combination of Logic and specific plugins.
    Quick explanation...
    Logic as plugin and VI host does not flush buffers as both plugins and VI become "inactive" when Logic is stopped, this differs from most other DAWS that keep instruments and plugins idling/active. I've always thought this possibly leads to Logic's quirky behavior regarding "disk too slow" and "system overload messages", as well as plugin noise as a region is approached and dropped notes at the beginning of a project.
    As I understand it from a couple of developers I've talked with (also doing beta testing) the AU spec was at some point modified to accommodate Logic's behavior. It's now up to the plugins/VI to empty buffers when Logic is stopped. Part of the noise you're hearing is leftover plugin data being dumped as Logic approaches the region and activates the plugin.
    Again, this behavior is specific to Logic.
    Make sure the developers you're beta testing for have the latest AU developers tools/spec.
    pancenter-

  • Is CS3 better for working with RAW images than Elements 6?

    Hi all,
    I am trying to find out if it is worth buying CS3 in stead of elements 6. Surprisingly, nobody has been able to tell me what the difference exactly is.
    The best I got so far was that elements is a trimmed down version of CS3 but what more can I do with CS3?
    As I am in England, CS3 would cost me about $1100, as opposed to $650 in the US, which is a bit much if you don’t know exactly what you get for that amount.
    It says something on the adobe features section about BETTER raw processing, but not compared to what. Old version? Other software? Better than nothing?
    I will be running it under XP, and the only use will be to optimise images from a digital camera in RAW format, 90%, and a jpeg (10)%, partially for web use, partially for prints.
    The most common things are:
    Correcting exposure when pics are unevenly lit.
    Correcting color temperature.
    Removing unwanted parts of a picture e.g. somebody stepping into the picture, advertising signs or copyrighted material.
    Altering color of small parts of an image like that of a single flower in a bouquet.
    Removing blemishes in portraits.
    The photos will always stay single photos, I can not foresee any use for slide shows, animations, video or anything related.
    From what I have been able to find out so far, it seems that Elements 6 will do all this and I don’t need to spend the extra $1000, or should I?

    I have not used Photoshop Elements since version 2.0. In that version it was very similar to Photoshop as far as how the interface was designed. There were a few key elements that were missing such as the Curve adjustment. It is my understanding that there is a free download available from a third party source that will provide that capability.
    As far as Camera Raw is concerned, you only have the adjustments that are on the basic panel and the details panel. That means you don't have all of the hue/saturation/luminance adjustments, or lens correction, or the capability to create presets, or to calibrate ACR specifically for your camera. As I understand it, it is not possible to load multiple images into ACR so that you can apply changes to all of them at once. And I don't believe you have the option of working in ACR in 16-bit mode.
    With Photoshop Elements it is not possible to record actions to enable you to do batch processing of your images. What you have is a good quality basic single image photo editor.
    I cannot tell you which to purchase. I don't know what you are accustomed to, nor do I fully understand your expectations. There are trial versions of both programs that you can download and try for 30 days to see what you think. They are fully functioning programs for that trial period, which should be ample time for you to determine which program will give you the most value.

  • Has anyone found a quick, permanent solution to the missing iTunes.msi file. It's very frustrating that I can't uninstall or reinstall. I have a new iphone and I'm dead in the water:)

    Has anyone found a quick, permanent solution to the missing iTunes.msi File? I have tried many times to upgrade both itune and quicktime and get the same old error notice. Surely, by now, someone has found out how to get around this mess. Please....

    (1) Download the Windows Installer CleanUp utility installer file (msicuu2.exe) from the following Major Geeks page (use one of the links under the "DOWNLOAD LOCATIONS" thingy on the Major Geeks page):
    http://majorgeeks.com/download.php?det=4459
    (2) Doubleclick the msicuu2.exe file and follow the prompts to install the Windows Installer CleanUp utility. (If you're on a Windows Vista or Windows 7 system and you get a Code 800A0046 error message when doubleclicking the msicuu2.exe file, try instead right-clicking on the msicuu2.exe file and selecting "Run as administrator".)
    (3) In your Start menu click All Programs and then click Windows Install Clean Up. The Windows Installer CleanUp utility window appears, listing software that is currently installed on your computer.
    (4) In the list of programs that appears in CleanUp, select any iTunes entries and click "Remove", as per the following screenshot:
    (5) Quit out of CleanUp, restart the PC and try another iTunes install. Does it go through properly this time?

Maybe you are looking for

  • Update / deinstall 11.2.3a or 11.2.4 trashes Windows 8

    Hi, We are trying to roll out 11.2.4. Update of primary and sat. servers was ok. Update of Windows 2003/XP/W7 PC's ok as well. But updating Windows 8 is a nightmare. I'm running HP Elite 8300SFF PC's with W8.0 64 bit and 11.2.3a. Assigned the update

  • How to identify a particular order type(PP01) is coming to APO?

    How to identify a particular order type(PP01) is coming to APO? Can it be checked at CIF exits on APO side?

  • Interface claim error while using mobile phone  in JUSB

    hi, i am trying to read the contents of a mobile phone using the JUSB package.i get an error that says "interface not claimed before use" i hav removed the module usbserial.o and also pl2303.o too it also timeouts when i try to read the data. can any

  • New Version of Flash Player Won't Install Properly

    Cannot install new version of Adobe Flash Player. Windows 7, 32 Bit. I use Firefox. Firefox is updated. Old version was working fine. Tried to install new because old one was slow and I received prompts to update. Uninstalled old one. Now, I cannot w

  • Device Manager is blank

    Everything started when I tried to use a Huawei EC168 USB Stick to connect to the Internet. When it installs the program used to run this device into the computer, and tries to install the drivers for this purpose it installs everything but what I su