Full length feature on FCP from mini-DV... benchmarking comparable DVD's

After over a year of post production, we just completed a full length kids’ feature film shot on a DVX-100A and edited in FCP. The title is "The Bracelet of Bordeaux", and the movie info is on IMDb and our website. This was a large scale project, with almost 300 actors, 50 crew members and 18 interior/exterior locations. There were over 60 shooting days. It was shot on mini-DV due to budgetary considerations.
The movie’s look-feel is exceptional, especially when viewed on a Mac HD screen and Sony NTSC monitor. However, when we first tested the movie in a theatre, playing a DVD through a high-end projection system, the quality was terrible. Ultimately, we achieved outstanding results by playing directly off the uncompressed FCP timeline through a Barco Hi Def projector and onto a 40-ft screen. We held a major theatrical test screening (3,000 people attended 10 shows), and the movie’s visual quality was stunningly good, receiving acclaim from audiences and critics. The results looked particularly film-like in the mid to back rows of the theatre (even numerous professional viewers thought that it was film). You can view audience comments and media reviews on IMDb.
Now we are creating a DVD to send to film festivals and prospective distributors. Of course, we will not be able to determine the projection system used at the festivals and the movie will mostly be exhibited from a DVD. I would like to know what full length feature films are out there, which were shot on mini-DV (especially the DVX100 or 100A), and edited on FCP, so I can use them to benchmark our DVD results. I have been living in the edit dungeon for over 14 months and have not kept track of movies shot in mini-DV and editing on Macs. Also, please provide any observations about the cinematic quality of these films
G5   Mac OS X (10.4.8)   FCP, DVDSP

https://eww.pavc.panasonic.co.jp/pro-av/sales_o/04reports/2004webWW/WorldWideWW/ stuffsingaporeWW/stuffsingaporeWW.html
this film was shot DV
However I can't help feel you are about to embark on a wild goose chase.
If you are going to distribute a movie on DVD for projection in multiple theatres with different equipment for screenings you will not attend I don't see what you hope to achieve.
DVD is by nature a "standard" without too much room for manoeuvre if you are supplying what must effectively be labelled a consumer market. You will have to conform your movie to a bitrate which is sympathetic to all DVD players and not for example use a DVD9 and a higher bitrate for a DVD player you own and know will work.
Cinematic quality is subjective also, which has a true film look The Sound of Music or The Matrix ? There are plenty of filters out there to give a film look and feel but to be honest the defining factor between film and video is often the quality of lighting, acting and camera work and not so much a blatant "look". It's audience acceptance of a piece in a theatre environment, which is a big help in the first place since we all associate the cinema with film (oh and adverts for the local tandoori).
Your film will look inherently different to the competition and so it should . . don't compare it!

Similar Messages

  • Unable to print full length 24" x 132" from adobe. Stops part way.

    I am trying to print an adobe document of a CAD drawing 24" by 132" with the 1050c plus.  The plotter prints about three-quarters of the way, stops printing, then rolls out the rest of the page.  I've tried all that I think of in the print settings of adobe (i.e. paper source - roll, roll size - 24 inch, under more sizes - entered size, set memory both printer and computer, quality - fast). The only thing that seems to help is the fast quality setting, where I get a bit more of my plot, but not all of it.
    If you have any suggestions of what else I can try please let me know.  Any help is much appreciated.

    Hi,
    Check for the print mode in the print options and set it as 3- print and archive .
    Regards,
    Ram

  • Apple TV and my MacBook Pro. TV shows I bought from iTunes only play for 1:50 min on Apple TV. However, the same shows play full length from my iPad. What's the cause?

    The TV series that I purchased from iTunes and have on my MacBook Pro will play on Apple TV for a short 2 minutes and then everything ends. However, the same shows play full length on Apple TV if I use my iPan. Does anyone know the cause of this?

    Hi mdr1976,
    Thanks for visiting Apple Support Communities.
    You can use iTunes Match to access your entire iTunes library on your computer and iOS devices.
    You can access your iTunes library on your Apple TV using Home Sharing, which is why it only works when your MacBook is turned on.
    See these articles for more information about Home Sharing:
    Understanding Home Sharing
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3819
    Setting up Home Sharing for Apple TV (2nd generation and 3rd generation)
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht4352
    Regards,
    Jeremy

  • HT203167 I purchased the full book from the iTunes Store after reading the sample but the full length will not download only the sample  how do I fix this?

    I purchased a full length book after reading the sample but only the sample will download  how do I fix this   as the full length book appears under purchased books?

    First try a Reset  ( No Data will be Lost )
    Press and hold the Sleep/Wake button and the Home button at the same time for at least Ten seconds... (But can take Longer)... until the Apple logo appears. Release the Buttons
    If no joy... Try a Restore...
    1: Connect the device to Your computer and open iTunes.
    2: If the device appears in iTunes, select and click Restore on the Summary pane.
    3: If the device doesn't appear in iTunes, try using the Steps in this article to force the device into Recovery Mode.
    From Here
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS3281
    Make sure you have the Latest Version of iTunes (v11) Installed on your computer
    iTunes free download from www.itunes.com/download
    Note on Recovery Mode.
    You may need to try this More than Once... Be sure to Follow ALL the Steps...
    Once you have Recovered your Device...
    Re-Sync your Content or Restore from the most Recent Backup...
    Restore from Backup  >  http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1766

  • As far as I know, the iPad cannot presently playback a full length movie from a DVD or any other source.  Are there any plans to add such a capability to the iPad in the future?

    As far as I know, the iPad cannot presently playback a full length movie from a DVD or any other source.  Are there any plans to add such a capability to the iPad in the future?

    alvwill wrote:
    Phil0124:  Sorry, I guess that I may not have communicated clearly initially.  The reason that I asked about the DVD reading capability in the first place is that I would like to be able to watch a movie "stand-alone" (like on an airplane) on my iPad without having an internet connection.  If VUDU is strickly a streaming service that wouldn't satisfy my needs after all.  After looking into the iTunes store offerings, I can see that I can either purchase a movie or rent one from them.  Either way, as I understand it, the content would then reside in a file in the iTunes folder in my computer (if rented, this would just be temporarily) and could be viewed on my computer and/or transferred to my iPad for viewing.  Considering the legal question, isn't there a copy being made and transferred into my possession.  So,what's up with that?
    Yes Vudu streams. iTunes does not. If you buy or rent a movie on your computer through the iTunes store, then you are legally entitled to transfer that movie to your digital device as long as that device is under the Same Apple ID used to download it to the computer, and is authorized to view the content. Usually this is the case if your device is synced with iTunes on the computer  This is legal and covered by the terms of use of the iTunes store.   
    If your rent a movie on your computer you can also transfer it to your iPad but it will be removed from the computer as rentals can only exist in one place at a time. When the rental period expires the movie will be automatically removed from your computer or device, wherever it is when the rental period expires.
    If you buy a movie on your iPad these can be transferred to your computer using the Transfer Purchases button on iTunes on your computer while the iPad is connected to it.   Rentals on iPads or other mobile device cannot be transferred and must be watched in the iPad or device that download them.
    All of these methods through the iTunes store download the complete movie to the device or computer, so no internet connection is required for watching at a later date.
    Rentals have a 30 day life as long as they haven't begun to be watched.  Once the movie has been started then it has a 48 hour expiry period. That is you must finish watching the rented movei within 48 hours of rental as after that it is removed from the device.  You can watch it as many times as you want in that period of time though.
    iTunes Store: Movie rental frequently asked questions (FAQ)
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1657
    How to rent a movie from the iTunes Store on your computer
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1390
    Purchased movies are yours, and never expire. If you delete the movie from your device or computer it can be re-downloaded at no extra cost provided the Movie is still available in the store.

  • FCP video out from mini-dvi to video adapter

    Is it possible to get the output of viewer / canvas from mini-dvi to video adapter for the external tv out.
    My configurations,
    Final Cut Pro 5.0
    MacBook
    Mac OS X 10.4.8
    Mini-dvi to video adapter for external output of video
    Need to find the solution.
    Please suggest your ideas to get things work.
    Expecting reply soon.

    If you use the Matrix MXO, yes. You can use the DVI out to feed a NTSC/PAL monitor. This is one of the only ways to monitor HDV.
    If you want to monitor DV (either PAL or NTSC), use firewire out to a DV/Analog converter and feed the Monitor from the converter.
    x

  • Export from FCP via QT or Compressor into DVD Studio Pro?

    Hi everyone,
    I'm editing in FCP and making a menued SD DVD. I've had success in laying out the DVD project.
    The source material is low quality and duration overall a few minutes. I'm adding a few supers to the clips.
    My question is, will I get better result exporting via compressor or via a QT export (using current settings PAL 25FPS 16:9)?
    Thanks in advance.
    Steve

    what you're doing is actually fine. But, generally, the following workflow is reccommended. It gives you more control if not better quality. Depending on your source (large or small frame size) you can adjust resizing and motion compensation and other parameters:
    export as QuickTime using "current settings." bring that resulting QT file into Compressor. Pick the DVD preset closest to the length of your project (e.g. 90 min best). From there you can select the preset in the project and adjust it.

  • Best software for fitting full length movies on to DVD?

    I have Toast 6 Titanium, which i find is a great program for all my burning needs. However, recently i've been wanting to burn a few movies i have downloaded. The problem seems to be that full length movies rarely fit on to DVD. I don't really understand it as most DVD's say they can hold around 4GB of data and the movies i download are rarely over 1GB. It's just that burning them as a DVD Movie disk seems to take up an awful lot of room.
    I heard there was software out there designed to compress it all down and squeeze the whole thing on to one disk and i was just wondering if that is true and which software applications out there are best for this?
    Many thanks,
    Steve.

    I got Toast 10 just to check out that feature. Unfortunately 'Fit To DVD' is not under the DVD-Video burning section of Toast. Fit To DVD is only available as a function for copying pre-existing DVD's, I'm trying to burn a DVD from an AVI file i've downloaded from the net. I can't believe no one out there seems to know of a program that could help me out here.

  • The green button, top left corner of a pop-up screen on MACbook, it's supposed to enlarge the pop-up to full MAC screen size, correct?  Mine does not.  Sometimes it makes the pop-up screen SMALLER.  Appreciate someone solving this for me.

    the green button, top left corner of a pop-up screen on MACbook, it's supposed to enlarge the pop-up to full MAC screen size, correct?  Mine does not.  Sometimes it makes the pop-up screen SMALLER.  Appreciate someone solving this for me.

    Are you talking about the green '+' button in the top left corner? That technically doesn't enlarge it. It switches the window from the default window size to the custom size you made. You can enlarge the window by moving your mouse to the bottom right corner of the window, and dragging until you get the size you want.
              MacBook

  • I captured from mini-dv camcorder to FCP7 using control from my computer and firewire. I cannot find the file or clips I transferred anywhere except for in Finder. How do I get the clips from Finder to FCP7. Also I did not see audio on the computer meters

    I captured from mini-dv camcorder to FCP7 using control from my computer. I only find the capture clip in Finder. How do I get the clip in Finder to FCP7.
    Also my audio in the capture was not showing up on my audio meters on my computer-is this normal. Thanks

    you will not see the audio meters from within fcp move while capturing. 
    If you only see the captured clip in the finder, not within fcp, there's something wrong.  You might try deleting your fcp preferences
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2491

  • Problem related to display column's full length as default in table control

    Hi Experts,
    I have a screen in report program. In that a table control has been designed.
    Now the issue is that when report program has been executed and the table control screen is called on a particular action then the table columns full length is not visible as default however when i checked the screen layout the default and visible length of colum header and column field is as per required.
    For example  - We have a Period field with default length as 6 and visible length as 15. Its column header is Period with both default length as 15 and visible length as 15.
    The period field has an internal table field reference and its format is NUMC.
    While column header Period is Text field created of type CHAR.
    Please suggest. Any help or inputs will be highly appreciated.
    Thanks,
    Akash

    Hi
    set cursor field 'WA_CODFOD-C_NOTE_NO' line mline.
    The value of MLINE can be from 1 and N, where N is the number of the lines shown in the table control, so if your table control can display 5 line, MLINE will be from 1 to 5.
    Now you need to create the link between the line of the table control and the line of internal table, the rule is:
    Internal Table Line = <table control>-TOP_LINE + <table control line> - 1.
    Max

  • Ios 7.1 - Barrett life further gone down to the **** and call is full screen feature remived

    Yesterday I have updated my ios to latest version 7.1 .
    Now am thinking if returning back to downgrade my os or some other models .
    It's irritating me a lot . My battery life totally gone . In standby mode fully charged mobile not even withstanding for
    3  to 4 hrs . But they are promoting IOS 7.1 as better battery life and with out any information they have removed
    The caller I'd full screen features  which they have mentioned as a improvement in 7 and older versions .
    Please some one help me out how to get rid off this . Now, my mobile is always connected to the charger and taking changer along with my mobile wher ever. I go .
    I was so excited when I was upgrading for 7.1 . But here after I will never upgrade my iPhone with out getting complete feedback abt the
    Latest release .
    I never expected this from apple . They are completely removing all the good features from iPhone .
    I am very much addicted to called if full screen , but now they have removed thise option in ios 7.1.
    Hope those bugs will be cleared in the next update and waiting for that eagerly . If not look for some other options .
    It's very difficult take my charger everywhere .

    Hello, erose3686. 
    Thank you for visiting Apple Support Communities.
    Battery life can be difficult to troubleshoot as multiple factors contribute to how long a charge can last.  Graphic intensive applications, environmental factors, display brightness and data connectivity are just a few of the items that can cause the battery life to decrease rapidly.  I would need to know a little more information about your usage patterns to give you and idea on how to maximize battery life.  However, here are some tips on how to adjust settings and charge the device that may help.
    iPhone and iPod touch: Charging the battery
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1476
    About Batteries
    About iPhone Batteries
    If you feel that you need assistance with the battery concern, you can always reach out to us via the link below.
    Contact Apple
    Cheers,
    Jason H.

  • Can you import video from Mini DV in separate clips?

    I've finally got around to rescuing all the hours of video I've got stored on Mini DV tapes. When I imported one into iMovie though, it came in as one long clip. This is not ideal. I'd hoped/expected that the many clips would come in separately, based upon breaks in the timecode.
    I guess I can work my way through the one long clip, cutting it into bits, but that's very time consuming and I may as well have imported the footage manually.
    Does anyone know how I can get footage onto my Mac from Mini DV in separate clips? Or if there's an easy way to break this hour long clip I've already imported into pieces?
    Thanks very much.

    Hi
    As AppleMan1958 writes
    Normal DV footage will be split into clips.
    But I figur. If Your miniDV tape has a functioning TimeCode (not copy from VHS)
    then iMovie 1 to HD6 - had it as an option to make a full import or as "Individual Clips"
    This choise I can not find in iMovie'11.
    May be it's still as a flag and by some chance - this got wrongly set.
    To correct this (IF) - I would delete iMovie pref file/s and re-start iMovie and try to
    make a new Import/Capture.
    To do this -
    • Close iMovie
    • Find the pref file - iMovie pref file resides in.
    Mac Hard Disk (start-up HD)/Users/"Your account"/Library/Preferences (folder)
    and is named. (one or more of these) - and put it/them on desktop
    com.apple.iMovie.plist
    com.apple.iMovie3.plist
    com.apple.iMovie7.plist
    com.apple.iMovie8.plist
    and find too - and put it on desktop
    com.apple.iApps.plist
    • Now re-start iMovie and try to do a new Import.
    Did it work ?
    Yours Bengt W

  • Can not upload video clips from mini dvd

    When I try to upload video clips from mini DVD recorded on Sony Handycam it stats the files are read only.  I have tried finalized and un-finalized clips.

    golfer709
    Thank you for the reply.
    Although what I posted in my post numbered 2 is interesting and useful information in the Premiere Elements ripping of VOBs from DVD-VIDEO, it is not answering your issue regarding a "read only" issue and did not target your specific "read only" message. Sorry about that.
    The VOBs are typically read only files on the disc.
    I have never run into a "read only" issue with regard to the Premiere Elements 10 Windows 7 64 bit Add Media/"DVD Camcorder or PC DVD Drive"/Video Importer. For that matter, not with any version of Premiere Elements with this particular feature.
    When are you getting this message.
    a. When you click on DVD Camcorder or PC DVD Drive after Get Media
    b. When you click on Get Media in the Video Importer or other
    Do you ever get a thumbnail for the VTS_01_1.VOB in the Video Importer? Is your burner drive recognized in the Source field of the Video Importer?
    If you open and explore the DVD disc, go to the VTS_01_1.VOB in the VIDEO-TS Folder, go to the VOB's properties, can you remove
    the mark next to "read only" and then have the Video Importer route work for you?
    Also, if you copy the  VTS_01_1.VOB from the opened DVD disc and paste it to the computer desktop and remove the "read only" marking, can you then import
    the VTS_01_1.VOB into Premiere Elements with its Get Media/Files and Folders?
    ATR

  • Full length movies

    Okay I am new at this iPod thing. I have held out til now so that I can watch movies on it. So I am thinking about buying this new iPod, but I am not sure it will be worth it unless I know if eventually I will be able to purchase full length movies from iTunes. It seems that they only have movie trailers on iTunes right now. Or is it easy to convert DVD's that I already own to get them to play on the iPod? Since iTunes isn't very clear on this subject... can someone help me out here? It would be greatly appreciated.

    Jennifer - it is absolutely fantastic. I've bought every ipod since they came out, and almost every bit of mac kit available - and this is, I think, the most impressive yet.
    Ripping dvds is very very simple using free software (Handbrake for the mac,though there are PC programs too), though time-wise can be a labour of love if you have a big collection. It is eminently watchable on the ipod screen, or else is perfectly good plugged into a TV.
    Lots of excellent posts in this forum tell you how to convert your DVDs.
    I love it - it's huge on the WOW factor. Buy one immediately!
    Mat

Maybe you are looking for