Hard Drive Failed, MacBook Pro Rejecting Replacement

On Thursday night my MacBook Pro (2010, 13'') froze and wouldn't respond, so I powered-off using the power button. Upon restart all I got was the Apple logo and the spinner; no matter how long I left it it wouldn't boot any further than that.
Booting in safe mode wouldn't work.
Booting in verbose mode and running fsck revealed several issues with the disk including bad blocks and corrupt data in the journal.
Booting from the installation disk and repairing using Disk Utility failed, as did trying to repair using fsck.
So, I installed OS X onto an external USB drive and managed to finally get the disk to mount in read-only mode after disabling journaling. I was then able to backup my data.
As my MacBook Pro is 14 months old and I didn't purchase AppleCare, I went out and bought a Hitachi Travelstar 320gb 7200rpm replacement on Saturday and fit it without any issue following the guide in the Apple manual.
This is where more issues arose. When booting from the installation disk and being presented with the language selection screen the trackpad and keyboard are not responsive at all. When booting from the external drive whilst the new drive is installed, once I'm at the login screen the trackpad and keyboard are unresponsive. However, when booting I can press C to boot from the CD/DVD and I can hold ALT to be presented with the boot drive selection screen where both trackpad and keyboard work flawlessly. So I can rule out the trackpad and keyboard being damaged. I can also back this up further because if I reinstall the damaged hard drive and boot from either an installation CD/DVD or the USB drive the trackpad and keyboard both work as expected.
I've tried resetting the PRAM; no change.
I've tried resetting the SMC; no change.
I've tried disabling the Sudden Motion Sensor; no change.
I've tried the new hard drive in an external enclosure with a different Mac and the drive is functioning fine.
So I'm totally stumpled. Why is the MacBook Pro rejecting the new hard drive? Surely this has to be some sort of compatibility issue, or deeper-lying issue? I've trawled the internet over the weekend but to no avail.
I'm booked in to see a Genius on Wednesday night but since the device is out of warranty I'm not holding much hope. The only things in my favour are Consumer law sighting it's not fit for purpose, nor has it lasted a reasonable amount of time. The fact that Apple don't provide a list of recommended hard drives anywhere or that the manual doesn't desuade you from manually replacing the drive yourself instead giving you a step-by-step guide.
Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated.
-Mic

Try getting the same hard drive as the one you pulled out.
It shouldnt be too hard to find.
As for your problem, I think were pretty much in the same boat. The same thing happened to my computer and all im getting is a white screen when booting from the new hard drive, yet putting the same one in an enclosure works just fine.

Similar Messages

  • How to replace hard drive in macbook pro?

    How to replace hard drive in macbook pro?

    Hi S,
    If you have the newer unibody style, it's very easy. If it's one of the earlier models, it's considerably more difficult. Go to Apple Menu > About This Mac > More Info > Hardware and find your Model Identifier. Then go to ifixit.com, or powerbookmedic.com or macsales.com or youtube or others and there are illustrated, detailed directions. Good luck to you and post back if you have further questions.

  • What is the best external hard drive with MacBook Pro

    What is the best external hard drive with MacBook Pro?

    I agree with Allan, and that link is also called OWC, their hard drives are great.  Have three of their Mercury Pro Elite 2 TB quad interface drives.  They will connect eSATA, Firewire 800 & 400, USB2, so broad reange of options.  Drives seem to come Mac HFS formatted, but I always reformat and partition the drives.  Service and quarantees are top notch.
    They offer a wide range of drives/drive systems so like Allan said, spend some time seeing what the have.

  • How to view windows Xp formatted hard drive with Macbook pro without losing data

    How to view Windows Xp programed Hard drive with Macbook pro with out losing data on hardrive

    Go to the First Aid tab in Disk Utility, select the external drive partition and read the format from the lower left, at the bottom.

  • When I connect an external hard drive to macbook pro it is very slow to appear on the desktop and Finder window, sometimes 20 mins or more, even with auto backup switched off . any clues?

    when I connect an external hard drive to macbook pro it is very slow to appear on the desktop and Finder window, sometimes 20 mins or more, even with auto backup switched off . any clues?

    Hi robfromkinglake west,
    Try and isolate the issue.  Check if it's only with this drive.
    Check the drive with Disk Utility
    Using Disk Utility to verify or repair disks
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1782
    I've never seen a drive take 20 minutes to mount.
    Nubz

  • Using Carbon Copy Cloner which is quicker firewire 800 Macbook Pro to external hard drive or Macbook Pro to same via Airport Extreme?

    Using Carbon Copy Cloner which is quicker firewire 800 Macbook Pro to external hard drive or Macbook Pro to same via Airport Extreme?

    Firewire 800 is the fastest and most reliable. Also it's bootable if you hold the option key down on a wired or built in keyboard.  Not bootable via Airport obviously or if Filevault is used.
    It's only your first clone that's usually takes the longest, it's shorter when it updates as you only do the changes which you can control to keep a pure clone if you wish.
    Most commonly used backup methods

  • How to install new hard drive on Macbook Pro

    My hard drive failed and I am no longer able to boot up the Macbook. If I go and buy a new hard drive and replace it with the broken one, what will happen when I turn it on. It will be a brand new drive with nothing on it. Will it automatically start installing OS X on it or do I need anything else?
    Thanks!

    It'll display a blinking question mark and/or automatically start from Apple's servers. What needs to be done depends on the computer's model.
    If it originally shipped with 10.6.8 or earlier, insert a compatible install DVD and press the C key.
    If it originally shipped with 10.7 or newer or was upgraded to use Apple's Internet Recovery system, press the Option, Command, and R keys if needed.
    Install the OS.
    (125849)

  • Is it safe to eject external hard drive while Macbook Pro is on sleep?

    Hi guys. This is the external hard drive I use for Time Machine. When in sleep mode, the external hard drive is off, but wakes up periodically when Macbook Pro Retina does its Power Sleep features including periodic back up. So...is it ok to eject external hard drive while on sleep?
    Thanks.

    Oh. Normally I leave my external hard drive connected to Macbook Pro and rarely eject it. But once in a while, I need to get that hard drive to connect to other computer for file transfer. So the question was when I need to do this (eject hard drive) while Macbook is on sleep, do I need to wake it up and log in and eject? I thought you were saying that I should always eject before the machine goes to sleep. I think I misunderstood you.
    So, I need to wake it up, log in and eject before disconnecting it?

  • Using time Capsule to replace new hard drive on MacBook Pro?

    I am replacing the internal hard drive on my MacBook pro (early 2008).  I have a time capsule that I would like to use to restore the entire back-up on the time capsule to the new hard drive.  What is the procedure to do this?  Thanks.

    First, prep the new drive:
    Drive Preparation
    1.  Boot from your OS X Installer Disc. After the installer loads select your language and click on the Continue button.  When the menu bar appears select Disk Utility from the Utilities menu.
    2. After DU loads select your hard drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left side list. Note the SMART status of the drive in DU's status area.  If it does not say "Verified" then the drive is failing or has failed and will need replacing.  SMART info will not be reported  on external drives. Otherwise, click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
    3. Under the Volume Scheme heading set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to one. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Options button, set the partition scheme to GUID then click on the OK button. Click on the Partition button and wait until the process has completed.
    4. Select the volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
    5. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Security button, check the button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
    6. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to several hours depending upon the drive size.
    Steps 4-6 are optional but should be used on a drive that has never been formatted before, if the format type is not Mac OS Extended, if the partition scheme has been changed, or if a different operating system (not OS X) has been installed on the drive.
    Second, install Snow Leopard on the new drive.
    Third, after Snow Leopard starts for the first time you will be in the Setup Assistant. When you complete the registration you will be presented with the options for continuing or restoring from a TM backup or another Mac. Select the TM option and restore your data.

  • How to replace the hard drive in MacBook Pro 2008

    Is there an instruction manual or bulletin on replacing the hard drive in a MacBook Pro, 2008 late year model?

    ifixit.com.
    RAM, HD, other repair instructions for all macs.  Also ranks each new model for its "self-service ease".  I think the new Retina models are rated 2 out of 10.

  • I replaced hard drive in macbook pro and when turning on i get a blinking question mark

    just replaced hard drive on my '09 macbook pro and rebooted to get the blinking question mark.  what do i do? not sure i have the installation disk.  i had this happen once on an older macbook and was able to figure it out but i can't remember what i did.

    Schedule an appointment with a Genius the SSD is gone.

  • Replaced Hard Drive in MacBook Pro - now TC wants to back up whole drive

    I replaced the 120 Gig hard drive in my MacBook Pro with a 320 Gig drive and cloned the old drive back to the new one. Time Machine now wants to treat this as a different drive from the one I have backed up on my Time Capsule. How do I convince TM to backup the new drive incrementally to the old image on the TC rather than creating a whole new back up?

    The cloning software you used probably does not copy the journaling entries. Since TM relies on the event-driven journaling entries, it has no choice but to start a new full backup all over again.

  • Replace hard drive in macbook pro

    Is it possible and is it user serviceable to replace the 500 gig hard drive in my Macbook pro with a LARGER drive???

    No
    13", 15", new, old, how old etc
    It is possible to put larger drives in MBP's, if I know what you have I may be able to suggest one

  • Replacement hard drive on Macbook Pro 13in early 2011 advice needed!

    Hi!
    I am replacing the hard drive in my MacBook Pro 13in from early 2011. The choices I can afford are either the Seagate 500GB 7200 rpm or the WD Scorpio Blue 500GB 5400rpm drive. I heard that the faster spinning drive causes reduced battery life and more noise. Is this true? Which one would you all suggest I choose?
    Thanks!!

    Hi,
    I am using the same model with upgraded RAM. I am also changing my hard drive to a SSD which can't be compared to a spinning drive. The best choice would be getting a SSD, however, if you have to choose between those two you listed, I would go with Seagate. Not only because it is affordable, but also most of manufactured laptops have that brand. About the battery life and more noise, that statement is "true", but it is not noticeable. I mean, faster spinning will consume more battery than slower spinning of course, but it will not effect your battery life significantly. Because it is spinning faster, it will have faster read/write ability than 5400 rpm HDDs. Overall, it really depends on how much budget you got. A 128 GB or 256 GB SSD would be affordable with a fantastic ability to do many tasks.
    I hope it helped you.

  • Hard drive on macbook pro 13' needs to be replaced, any suggestions on which one as per today? mine was since 2009.

    Hello
    i was told my HD needs to be replaced as it is damaged (no exact explanation here from Apple but nevermind)....so is there a specific HD to avoid to be installed? i bought my mac in october 2009. Thank you for the advice.

    Thank you both, really useful info.My mac is for now 250 gb 5400rpm. I have to say this 250gb is enough for me.
    I was offered as below for replacing the hard drive.
    Would be Samsung a good option? hybrid one? for sure I take note no Western. And I would go indeed for 7200 rpm as suggested by you too.
    New hard drives starting with the most expensive:
    SSD hard drive instead of regular winchester:
    120 GB Samsung SSD meghajtó 28 000Ft +afa
    250 GB Samsung SSD meghajtó 42 000Ft +áfa
          -    winchesterek:
    320GB 5400rpm winchester  20 000Ft+áfa
    500GB 5400rpm winchester  22 000Ft+áfa
    1000GB 5400rpm winchester  27 000Ft+áfa
    Faster winchesters with 7200 rpm ( a bit quicker than 5400rpm):
    320GB 7200rpm winchester  24 000Ft+áfa
    500GB 7200rpm winchester  26 000Ft+áfa
    * Hybrid Winchester:
    It includes a 500 GB Winchester and a 8 GB SSD hard drive (hence hybrid ), combines the speed of SSD and the speed of the Winchester (it takes cca 30 sec to start the laptop instead of 90 seconds):
    500GB 7200rpm winchester +8GB SSD  34 000Ft+áfa
    Also since my date needs to be saved/recovered by data saving company, I was suggested to bring an external HD.
    Any suggestion on external HD to buy? or not to buy? then at least i will have a copy before getting new hard drive for my mac.
    Thank you

Maybe you are looking for

  • Where to get JSDK Latest Version

    I'm a beginner in Servlet, can you please tell me where to get this JSKD in order to start the webserver.

  • ORA-01882: timezone region not found  in NetBeans 7.0.1

    Please how do I solve ORA-01882: timezone region not found in Netbeans 7.0.1 ?

  • The creative cloud is not opening on my computer, what do I do

    I had to uninstall then re install the creative cloud software, after doing so It worked well, but now it is not opening at all, what do I do

  • Doubt using thr Read Tag .vi

    I,m having some difficulty trying to understand the following: The manuals I´ve read tell that to use the Read Tag.vi it´s not necessary to previously start the Tag Engine using the Engine Launch.vi. But, when I try to read the value of a discrete ta

  • Slow Wireless

    Hello Just recently become a proud owner of a MacBook, having upgraded from my aging G3 iBook. Fantastic so far, apart from the wireless connection. Have a Belkin 54g router connected through UK online with a 2mb connection. Can't seem to get above 6